SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 35
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Advisory
Skolkovo Foundation
Russia and Skolkovo’s
attractiveness as an R&D
destination
Public report
March 2013
The reader of this report understands that the work performed by PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V. (“PwC”) was
performed in accordance with the instructions of our addressee client, the Skolkovo Foundation (“Skolkovo”), and
exclusively for Skolkovo’s sole use and benefit.
The reader also acknowledges that this report was prepared at the direction of Skolkovo and may not include all
procedures deemed necessary for the reader’s purposes.
The reader additionally agrees that PwC, and its partners and employees neither owe nor accept any duty or
responsibility to it, whether in contract or in tort (including without limitation, negligence and breach of statutory duty),
and will not be liable for any loss, damage or expense of any kind whatsoever that may be caused by any use the reader
chooses to make of this report, or which may otherwise result from the reader gaining access to this report. Further, the
reader agrees that this report is not to be referred to or quoted, in whole or in part, in any prospectus, registration
statement, offering circular, public filing, loan, other agreement or document without PwC’s prior written consent.
i
Important message
Table of contents
Section Overview Page
Introduction
1 International R&D dynamics and trends 1
2 Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance 8
3 Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and
Skolkovo
12
4 Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 19
Appendices
1 Glossary 28
iii
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Given its capabilities and investment in R&D infrastructure through Skolkovo, Russia offers
favourable opportunities for international R&D investment
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
MNCs are looking to go international for additional R&D capabilities.
Nowadays, leading MNCs driven by the needs of global markets are intensively
looking for unique R&D capabilities that can generate new technologies, products and
know-how with strong commercial potential in their respective industries.
Russia is a potentially attractive R&D destination for MNCs as a country
with an extensive historical legacy in science and huge market potential.
From 2002 to 2011, at least 15 MNCs established R&D centres in Russia. Among the
main reasons why MNCs decide to establish R&D centres in Russia are the following:
1) Extensive talent pool available in Russia, ensured by:
• High level of education
• Long standing scientific and engineering culture and tradition, especially in
aerospace, nuclear science, engineering and software
• Renowned universities and research centres
• Strong track record in international educational competitions
2) Commercial opportunities driven mainly by attractive domestic market:
• B2C market: Russia is one of the largest consumer markets in Europe
• B2B market: industrial output with a 5% annual growth rate is among the
highest in the world
• B2G market: the Russian government is pursuing an ambitious modernisation
programme covering such diverse industries as healthcare, energy, aviation,
transport and utilities
However, the number of foreign corporate R&D centres in Russia is very
small in comparison with such countries as China and India, which have
attracted the majority of total outbound R&D centres over the past 10 years, at least
224 and 95 centres, respectively.
The average number of foreign R&D centres established annually in Russia per total
number of researchers in the country is the lowest among the BRIC countries: two
times lower than in Brazil, six times lower than in China, and 18 times lower than in
India, meaning that Russia’s R&D environment is relatively less penetrated by MNCs.
Meanwhile, the Russian market is also relatively untapped as the average number of
foreign R&D centres established annually in Russia per average annual GDP is also
times less then in China and India.
In particular, this is the result of the low level of integration of Russian
science into the global scientific community and a lack of entrepreneurial
culture in Russia, which is due to historical factors. Among other obstacles
preventing MNCs from establishing R&D centres in Russia is the country’s outdated
or underdeveloped R&D infrastructure, especially in the Biomedical and
Industrial Machinery industries, and administrative barriers, which partially
result from investors' unfamiliarity with Russian legislation and business practices.
Currently, the Russian government is focused on improving the country’s
R&D environment to increase its attractiveness as an R&D destination.
The Russian government is implementing a policy of economic modernisation and
support for innovation. R&D support measures include:
• Tax incentives for R&D: Russia provides a favourable tax regime for R&D activity
compared to other countries, including lower rates for major taxes and
accelerated depreciation of R&D expenditures at the federal level and/or within
SEZs and Skolkovo clusters
• Public funding of science, including grants and venture capital through special
development institutions
• Technological platforms aimed at uniting key stakeholders on a specific R&D
task: industry (large, medium and small companies), public authorities, research
institutions, civil society and the academic and financial communities; such
platforms are supported by Russian Foundation for Technology Development
providing preferential loans for R&D expenditures
• Organising innovation clusters: the cluster approach to organising R&D allows
for creating an innovation ecosystem that offers participants, including MNCs,
easy access to partners, financial sources, professional services, infrastructure
facilities, etc.
Skolkovo has successfully attracted MNCs to its R&D clusters as it
addresses the key issues such corporations face in Russia’s R&D
environment.
Skolkovo represents the Russian government’s most successful initiative for creating
R&D clusters. It has already established partnerships with several MNCs that plan to
set up R&D centres at Skolkovo.
MNCs see Skolkovo as a particularly attractive R&D location for the following reasons:
• Access to a talent pool through the country’s leading universities and research
institutes located in the greater Moscow area that specialise in Skolkovo’s
foresight industries (IT, Space and Telecom, Biomedical, Energy Efficiency,
Nuclear)
• Availability of public financial support for start-ups and access to high-
technology partners
• Cost effectiveness (tax incentives, large-scale construction of infrastructure)
• Absence of bureaucracy and red tape
iv
PwC
March 2013
International R&D dynamics and trends
1
Section 1
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Corporate R&D spending is highest in the USA and Europe while the BRIC
countries demonstrate the strongest growth
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
2
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Sources: 1) European Commission JRC; 2) PwC analysis
Corporate R&D expenditures by Top-2000 companies,
EUR bn , 2005-2010
BRIC
Asia
Europe
North
America
Others
RoW
RoW
Others
Comments
+4%
35.1%
35.1%
26.6%
2.6%
% of region
460.8
34.7%
0.4%
10.3%
5.5%
4.8%
4.5%
10.0%
21.5%
2.9%
2.2%
1.7%
0.4%
0.4%
0.1%
0.6%
2005
370.1
40.8%
10.4%
5.8%
5.8%
3.5%
8.8%
18.9%
2.8%
0.9%
0.2%
0.1%
0.2%
0.1%
0.6%
2010
1.2%
• MNCs from developed countries still take the lead in R&D
spending worldwide; in 2010 they represented 96.8% (EUR 446.1
bn) of corporate R&D spending, but their share has been gradually
decreasing since 2005, when it was 98.9%.
• However, MNCs from the BRIC countries have demonstrated
outstanding growth in corporate R&D thus increasing steadily
their share from 0.6% (EUR 2 bn) in 2005 to 2.6% (EUR 12 bn) in
2010. This rise in the BRICs’ R&D expenses has been driven by
strong overall economic growth.
• Among the BRIC countries, the most rapid growth in 2005-2010
was posted by MNCs from China (53%) and India (49%). China
holds the leading position among BRIC countries with a share of
49% in 2010. In terms of growth, Russian MNCs placed third
among their BRIC peers and in the world with a 29% CAGR in
2005-2010, while Brazilian MNCs posted an honourable fourth
place showing with 23% of annual growth from 2005 to 2010.
• Russian corporations spent on R&D EUR 193 m in 2005, while
this figure was 3.5 times higher in 2010 at around EUR 679 m.
0.6%
PwC
March 2013
Public report
MNCs are either seeking to access additional (sometimes cheaper) research
capacity (talent) or are following manufacturing to adjust development
locally. In Russia, access to research skills is currently the main driver
Internationalised
manufacturing
Internationalised
R&D
1 2
Internationalised
research
Internationalised
development and
manufacturing
1 2
• MNCs enter new markets to ensure sustainable growth
through localising their production facilities. Proximity to
customers allows for reducing the time to market.
• At the second stage, MNCs customise and tailor their goods to
local needs and regulatory requirements; thus, as a rule, they
localise development centres. Occasionally, they may also
incorporate a research centre.
• This model is typical for a huge market with relatively low
scientific potential, of which China is the best example.
Market-driven model Technology-driven model
Approach
Comments
Example
1883-
1891
1992 20051974
• Established
as two
separate firms
which merged
in 1988
• Hong Kong
business formally
established
• First
manufac-
turing
operations
established
• Opened Chinese R&D
centre focused on
power systems, robotics
& manufacturing
technologies
200719931969
• Samsung
Electronics
established in
Seoul, Korea
• Moscow
research
centre
established
• First plant established
in Kaluga, focused on
manufacturing
household appliances
(monitors, TVs, etc.)
Source: PwC analysis
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
3
1 2
or
• MNCs seek out new ideas and qualified talent to expand their own
competencies. By localising their research centres, MNCs can
benefit from the host country’s existing track record, legacy and
educational system. They can also potentially expand their research
activities through development.
• At the second stage, after acquiring a good understanding of a
specific market, and if the market is attractive, MNCs may opt to
localise their manufacturing operations.
• This model is typical for countries with strong intellectual resources
and untapped market potential, or which Russia is the best example.
PwC
March 2013
Public report
The industries most likely to offshore R&D are Telecom, Software,
Chemicals, Automobiles, Electronics, Pharma and Semiconductors
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
4
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Top industries for “exporting” R&D
centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011
1
2
3
3
5
6
18
21
21
35
36
45
50
62
63
65
69
7 6
88
98
Ø 38
Biotechnology
Gas, Water & Utilities
Oil & Gas
Construction & Materials
Electricity
Alternative Energy
HealthCare E&S
Internet
Aerospace & Defence
Industrial Machinery
Computer Hardware
General Industrials
Computer Services
E&E Equipment
Semiconductors
Pharmaceuticals
Automobiles
Chemicals
Software
Telecom1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1 2
3 4
6 75
Telecom
Primary reasons for “exporting” R&D centres by MNCs
Software
Chemicals Automobiles
Pharma SemiconductorsElectronic & Electrical
Equipment
Proximity to customers
Limited supply of technical
talent in home country
Proximity to production
facilities
Unique specialists
New markets
Legal limitations in home
country
Proximity to
manufacturers/customers
Quest for talent
Opportunity to work with
reputable research institutes
High operating costs
Lack of qualified
personnel at home
Proximity to customers
New markets: proximity
to manufacturing
facilities
Search for talent and
outstanding technologies
Proximity to suppliers
New markets: time to
market
Proximity to customers
Proximity to producers
Lack of specialised talent
Proximity to suppliers
Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) PwC analysis
6.2%
4.7%
4.4%
15.8%
16.3%
6.2%
6.5%
2.4%
2.9%
3.0%
1.9%
3.6%
0.9%
2.0%
0.14%
0.7%
1.0%
2.1%
0.2%
2.2%
68%
nn - Share of industry in total corporate R&D spending (average 2008-10)
- Space
Technologies
- ICT
- Energy
Efficiency
- Biotech
- Mix: includes
Nuclear Tech
Average share of total
R&D spending, 2008-2010
Less than 10, not active
“exporter”
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Inbound R&D is highly concentrated – the clear leaders are China, India
and the US, with Russia placing only 9-11
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
5
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
153
7
9
9
12
14
15
15
15
21
22
24
33
38
61
95
224
RoW
Brazil
Ø 45
UK
Australia
Japan
France
Russia
Canada
Ireland
Israel
Taiwan
Korea
Germany
Singapore
USA
India
China
Criteria for winning modelsTop countries for “importing” R&D centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011
2.81
2.60
1.55
2.35
0.85
4.20
2.85
1.95
3.40
1.05
1.75
3.47
2.21
1.81
All R&D,
% of
GDP
GDP,
USD
tn
 HuHuge market potential
 Low costs, including labour
 Pool of talent
 Political stability and favourable
economic environment
 Good infrastructure
 Established legislative base, especially
in IP
 Financial and non-financial incentives
 Low administrative barriers
 Developed educational and science
support system
2.25
15.2
0.31
11.3
0.88
4.47
0.23
3.09
1.39
1.55
2.37
0.18
4.38
2.23
2.25
0.92
1.20 2.23
50%
Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) Battelle; 3) PwC analysis
2011
Average
monthly
salary, USD
2009
4,240
n/a
415
1,200
65
2,230
3,703
n/a
2,633
650
5,005
2,731
4,001
5,467
3,930
565
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Some countries score well across industries due to market size, while others score
well only for a limited set of industries due to specific strengths (talent, incentives,
costs, etc.); Russia is chosen mainly for its scientific talent pool
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
6
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Japan
Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established
IP legislation, developed infrastructure
Countries
China
India
USA
Singapore
Germany
Korea
Taiwan
Ireland
Canada
France
Source: PwC analysis
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Qualified staff, English-language capabilities, IP legislation, cost effectiveness,
government support , market
Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP
legislation, highly developed infrastructure
Government support, qualified personnel, clustering, infrastructure, hub for East-
Asian market
Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP
legislation, developed infrastructure, advanced technologies
IT infrastructure, qualified personnel, tax incentives, favourable labour costs
Proximity to production facilities, strong government support, developed
infrastructure
EU membership, developed infrastructure, low taxation, the government's active
economic policy, English-speaking manpower, strong educational system and
proximity and cultural similarity to the UK and the USA
Developed ICT infrastructure, easy access to US and world markets, superior
workforce, quality of life
Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP
legislation, developed infrastructure, convenient geographical location
1- Aerospace & Defence
2- Telecommunications equipment
Huge market, proximity to manufacturing facilities, cost effectiveness, government
support
Israel
High R&D spending; highly educated population, especially with technical
background; large Jewish diaspora abroad, providing access to Western financing
resources; developed telecom infrastructure
      
Key success factors


  
   
 

 
   
 
 

 
9- Industrial Machinery
10- Chemicals
7- Semiconductors
8- Electronic & Electrical Equipment
 
   
  
- Industries with the share of more than 8% of the total number of R&D centres


   









13- Pharmaceuticals
14- Health Care Equipment
& Services
Russia
Strong Soviet legacy in physics, mathematics and aero-
space, government support, improving infrastructure    
3- Software
4- Computer Services
5- Computer Hardware
6- Internet
11- General Industrials
12- Automobiles & Parts
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Over the past 10 years, Russia has attracted approximately 15 R&D centres
– the leading sectors are ICT, Aerospace & Defence and Telecom
Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends
7
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) Company sites; 3) PwC analysis
1
1
2
2
2
3
4
Automobiles & Parts
Chemicals
Aerospace & Defence
Internet
Telecommunications
Equipment
Computer Hardware
Semiconductors
CommentsRussia’s inbound R&D centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011
 Over the past 10 years, Russia has attracted 15 R&D
centres, both Specialised Contributors and Supported
Specialisation.
 The majority of R&D centres are localised to take
advantage of Russia’s talent pool; but, there are also
centres dedicated to product customisation and are
thus market-driven.
 Currently, there are approximately 48 R&D units in
the leading sectors, including:
1. ICT: 21 centres,
2. Aerospace and Defence,
Telecommunications: 7 centres,
3. Chemicals: 6 centres.
 Among leading MNCs, Russia has hosted R&D
centres for EMC, LG, Google, EADS, Boeing, Intel,
HP, Siemens, Samsung, DuPont and Corning, among
others.
PwC
March 2013
Critical success factors in attracting R&D
investment and Russia’s performance
8
Section 2
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Our Interview Programme has shown that for MNCs the most important
country selection factors in the R&D localisation process are personnel,
stability, know-how and market
Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
6
18
19
20
29
34
37
38
40
42
45
47
50
52
53
Costs
Cooperation
Infrastructure
Legal
Acceptance
Processes
Market/
Customers
Know-how
Stability
Personnel
Image
Critical mass
Location
Culture
Regulations
Ranking of CSF by importance
Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis
Must-
have
Impor-
tant
Comments
 In our Interview Programme, we conducted interviews
with 24 MNCs from such industries as Telecom
Equipment, Aerospace and Defence, Software,
Computer Services, Computer Hardware, Internet,
Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals, Healthcare Equipment
and Services, Electricity, Alternative Energy, Oil and
Gas, General Industrials, Electronic and Electrical
Equipment, Industrial Machinery, and Automotive and
Parts, both with and without R&D centres localised in
Russia.
 Data is presented in an aggregated form: for both
research and development type centres.
 Depending on the specific industries and the R&D value
chain stage (R or D), the importance of specific factors
may differ.
 All companies interviewed across all industries
indicated that the most important factors are: talent,
technology, market and stability (political, social and
economic).
9
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Given Russia’s world-class scientific base and its statute as one of Europe’s
largest markets, the Russian government has focused on improving the
R&D environment to spur corporate capital investment in R&D
Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance
10
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
No. 1
RUSSIA’S HUGE POTENTIAL COMMENTS
World-class,
creative, bright
talent
Huge,
untapped
market
opportunities
Rapidly developing
national innovation
system
# of researchers,
2010, ‘000
• With a large number of researchers per 10,000 of
its economically active population, Russia is
comparable to developed countries and far above
developing ones.
• Historically, Russia has been strong in natural and
technical sciences, thus these disciplines account
for about 92% of the total number of researchers.
• Russia’s B2C, B2B and B2G markets are some of the
most attractive in the world.
• Russia represents one of the largest consumer markets
in Europe. The country’s industrial output, with 5%
annual growth, is among the highest in the world.
• The Russian government is carrying out an ambitious
modernisation programme covering such sectors as
healthcare, energy, aviation, transport and utilities.
Sources: 1) IMF; 2) Rosstat; 3) CIA; 4) PwC analysis
• The Russian government launched one of its most
ambitious and promising projects – the Skolkovo
Innovation Centre – aimed at developing an
innovation-driven economy in Russia and covering five
clusters: Information and Computer Technologies,
Space Technologies, and Telecommunication, Nuclear,
Energy Efficiency and Biomedical Technologies.
• Skolkovo hosts a critical mass of stakeholders and
offers a comprehensive system of incentives: tax
breaks, preferential customs regime, access to funding
and infrastructure, and simplified hiring of foreign
labour.
1 3 3
1 5 54 4 2
14
4
15
65
0
5 0
1 00
500
0
BrazilIndiaRussiaChina
1,152
USA
1,413
95
1,000
1,500
Per 10,000 of
economically active
population
82
1 4 33 1 0
44
48
1
5
0
1 0
2 0
3 0
4 0
5 01,400
1,200
200
0
GermanyRussia
13
USAIndia
1,191
China
1,341
GDP per capita,
2011, ‘000 USD
B2C market, 2010, mn of
population
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Note: a) Cover several sectors like Electricity, Energy, Alternative Energy, Healthcare Equipment, and Industrial Machinery;
b) Also relevant for specialised software in Aerospace and Pharma
In Aerospace, Internet, Nuclear Technology and Software Russia has strong
capabilities both in research and development due to the Soviet legacy in
physics, mathematics, and space technologies
Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis
Capabilities of Russia
- High - Medium - Low
11
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance
• Longstanding scientific tradition in life sciences
• Developed infrastructure for clinical tests of specific groups of illnesses
• Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors
• Attractive market size and potential
• Longstanding scientific tradition in physics and mathematics
• Strong partnership of research centres with civil/military companies in A&D
• Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors
R D
Aerospace and Defence
Telecommunications
R D Key advantages of Russia
Softwareb)
Computer Services
Computer Hardware
Internet
Semiconductors
Electronic and Eectrical
Equipment (E&EE)
Industrial Machinery
Chemicals
Automobiles and Parts
Pharmaceuticals
Healthcare Equipment and
Services
ICB sector
• Longstanding scientific tradition in mathematics proven by strong
achievements of students at international contests
• Creative educational process at leading universities that foster the ability
to solve non-standard tasks and issues
• Employee potential in software and Internet recognised by leading IT and
Internet companies
• Strong Russian market growth for Internet-related industries and in-
demand IT goods and services, e.g. growing broadband connectivity
• SME and start-up development in IT sector
• Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors
• Longstanding scientific tradition in physics and material engineering
• Market potential in these sectors due to unsatisfied demand for modern
equipment, services and goods from B2C, B2B and B2G segments
• Longstanding scientific and engineering culture in physics, mathematics,
and material engineering
• Globally renowned universities and research centres
• Developed infrastructure for working with nuclear technologies
Industrial Machinery
Electricity
Nuclear Technologiesa)
Skolkovo
cluster
- Very high
PwC
March 2013
Overview of R&D incentives globally and
availability of support in Russia and
Skolkovo
12
Section 3
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Globally, governments support R&D start-ups and projects through special
mechanisms providing services and infrastructure, and public financing and
tax incentives. While Russia does provide tax incentives and public financing
for R&D, it has not actively developed business incubators and TTOs
 Governments support R&D activity at different stages of R&D
projects, mainly through:
• tax incentives for private, innovation-driven companies;
• providing special R&D supporting mechanisms, such as
technology transfer offices, business incubators and business
accelerators;
• providing non-revocable (grants) and revocable financing
for R&D projects (mainly through special funding and
development institutions, such as public foundations, state
venture funds, development banks, etc.).
 Such support can be provided individually or as part of a
package based on R&D and R&D/industrial clusters, special
economic zones (SEZ), technoparks, technological platforms,
etc.
 Public project financing usually requires co-financing from
private sources (excluding fundamental research), i.e. own
capital, venture and private capital funds, and banks.
 Currently, the Russian government provides mainly public
financing and tax incentives for R&D projects, but lags in
providing supporting mechanisms for commercialising R&D
results.
 Existing innovation technoparks (Sarov, Idea) and innovation
centres (Dubna, Zelenograd) mainly provide infrastructure
facilities but very limited outsourcing and individual consulting
services to their residents.
 Skolkovo can be used as a platform for providing supporting
mechanisms in accordance with global best practice.
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
13
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Comments
Maturity
Incubation
(pre-seed / seed)
Acceleration
(growth)
Stage of
development Concept Technical
validation
Market
validation
Implementation
scaling-up
International
expansion
IPO or
M&A
Sales
Evolution of a
company
Transfer technology office (TTO)
1-2 years
(3-5 years for
biotech start-ups)
Up to 1 year
Business
incubator
1 2
3
4
5
Supporting
mechanisms Business accelerator
Duration Up to 2 years
6
Public
financing
R&D tax
incentives
Grants Grants, venture
capital
Venture capital,
preferential loans
Preferential
loans
Tax deductions,
preferential tax rates
Investment grants, tax
deductions, tax exemptions
Source: PwC analysis
Provided by
government
in Russia
To be
developed
in Russia
Map of government support by stages of R&D project
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Russia offers a favourable tax regime for R&D, including reduced tax rates,
accelerated depreciation of R&D expenditures and tax credits, at the
federal level as well as within SEZs and the Skolkovo clusters
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Transition economies Mature markets
Russia China India Singapore Israel Ireland USA
Reduced profits tax rate 15% 17% 5%a) 10-25% 12.5%
Profits tax holidays b) c)
Increased tax rebate for R&D expenditures 150% 150% 150%
Tax credit for R&D and investment in high-tech
Accelerated depreciation
Inclusion of some of R&D capex into revenue
expenditures
d)
Property tax reduction
Exemption from customs dues e)
  
    
Note: a) Minimal rate for a time period up to 10 years; b) Based on individual agreements; c) For designated companies; d) Only hardware for IT
companies; e) Dues are not collected
Sources: 1) Incentives for innovation 2010, PwC; 2) Russian Federation Tax Code; 3) PwC analysis
     
   
     
   
Transition economies tend to
provide higher tax rebate for R&D
expenditures
Mature markets offer tax credits more often
Tax polices are generally based on
individual countries’ conditions; however,
similar economies may have similar policies


     




 


Available in
Skolkovo
and/or SEZ
Available in
Skolkovo
and/or SEZ

14
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Russia has all major types of development institutions providing public
funding for R&D at different project stages
National development institutions in top countries/regions for inbound R&D
(with overall budget)
Administrator
of government
programme
China
Ministry of
Science and
Technology
N/A
India USA EU Russia
National
venture
capital
provider
Development
banks
Clusters/
Special
economic
zones
Council of
Scientific and
Industrial
Research
USD 150m
US Small
Business
Administration
USD 172m
The Federal
Ministry of
Economics and
Technology,
Germany
N/A
Skolkovo
Foundation
USD 200m
N/A
US Small
Business
Administration
USD 8.2bn
The European
Investment
Fund
USD 1.8 bn per
year
Not used for
innovation
development
Not used for
innovation
development
Not used for
innovation
development
The
European
Investment
Bank
EUR 1.4bn
per year
MSP-Bank
(affiliated with
VEB)
EUR 1.25bn per
year
Shenzhen
SEZ
Usually used for
manufacturing
and foreign trade
Skolkovo,
SEZ Dubna
Not used for
innovation
development
Israel
Chief
Scientist’s
Office
~USD250m
Yozma
N/A
--
N/A
Russian
Venture
Company
USD 851m
N/A N/A
Sources: 1) Development institution websites, 2) Erawatch, 3) PwC analysis
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
15
Comments
 The Russian government is
implementing a comprehensive
innovation promotion programme
and developing various
mechanisms for the financial
support for R&D, while most of
other R&D-active countries focus
on specific types of development
institutions.
 In particular, the Russian
government provides public
funding for R&D through special
government grant programmes, a
venture capital fund of funds, a
development bank (preferential
credits) and SEZs (preferential tax
regime).
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Although public funding in Russia is sufficient, access to venture capital
and loans for R&D is limited
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
16
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Loans and
credits for
R&D
Grants
Venture
capital
 Access to grant funds on terms that are
aligned with other countries’ policies
 Grant programmes cover all stages of the
R&D cycle
 Grant programme requirements are in
line with other countries’ practices and
relatively easy to meet
 R&D loans and credit instruments are
focused only on commercialisation stage
 Budgets of R&D soft loan providers are
limited with voluntary contributions from
Russian companies
 State bank-provided funding for
preferential R&D credits requires a
patent, thus significantly limiting the
range of potential borrowers
Financing
sources critical
for SMEs
Available
amount
Ease of
access
1
2
3
High High
High Low
Medium Low
Skolkovo/Russia benchmark versus other
countries
Comments on Russia
 Large number of investment funds with
capital to invest.
 RVC provides private seed capital and
risk sharing mechanisms for private
funds.
 Access to venture financing for SMEs and
start-ups is limited as a result of the lack
of innovation support structures and
mentoring systems (business angels,
professional intermediaries)
Skolkovo,
Russia
SBIR,
USA
OCS,
Israel
Russia USA Israel
Russia Europe
1. Total funds (USD bn)
2. Max. sum of grant (USD
mn)
3. Time required for
funding decision (days)
1. National VC Funds
available (USD bn)
2. VC availability a)
1. Development banks
budgets (USD bn)
3. Ease of access to loansa)
(for Europe – Germany)
87 90 70
10 1 0.8
(Average)
0.2 2.5 0.3
(2010)
1 8.2 0.1
3. Quality of proposals
(based on interviews)
2,3 4.0 4.5
Low High High
2,4 3.o
1.6 1.8
2. Number of R&D credits
provided by banks
(indicative)
Low High
Note: a) Country indicator, Global Competitive Report rating, where 1 is the lowest, 7 is the highest
Source: 1) The Global Competitiveness Report 2011-2012, 2) Development institution websites; 3) PwC Interview Programme; 4) PwC analysis
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Initiatives introduced by the Russian government are improving Russia’s
attractiveness for R&D
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Innovation commercialisation
and growth management
programme
Initiatives Description Status
Innovation projects support
programme
Presidential programme
“Innovations and Risks in
Business”
Allows managers to gain advanced knowledge and learn
necessary traits in the area of commercialising innovative
projects and managing innovative companies for the purpose of
achieving competitiveness and providing substantial business
growth
The programme is aimed at stimulating innovative activity
between students, researchers and scientists in the area of
information security and related industries
The main objective of the programme is to educate a new category
of specialists who will manage the development of a new product
as well as its introduction to the market
TACIS project
Innovation and technological
project contest ‘Technovation
Cup”
The main goal of the "Support of Export-Orientated Innovative
SMEs“ project initiated by the Russian agency and realised on its
base is to support and co-operate in the process of developing
innovation-driven and export-oriented SMEs with the ultimate
goal of expanding trade relations between EU countries and the
Russian Federation, as well as developing a “common economic
space.”
The main objective of the Cup is to help project teams to market
their product or technology in the real sector of the economy and
to turn their ideas into businesses
Sources: 1) Programs’ websites, 2) PwC analysis
Education - Moscow
State University
Was running
2006-2008,
now closed
Research Grant -
Kaspersky Lab
Type of program-
Executive agent
Running since
2008
Education –
Commission of
Executive Education
Running since
2009
Developing SMEs -
Moscow Physics
and Technology
Institute
Running
Developing SMEs -
Enterprise Europe
Network Running
17
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Russia is establishing technology platforms, primarily following the EU’s
example
Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo
18
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Energy ICT
Bio-based
economy
Production &
processes
Transport
Biofuels ARTEMISg) FABREk) Construction
Platform
Aeronautics
SmartGrids ENIACh) Food
European
Steel
Rail
TPWindc) Integral Satcom
Initiative
Global animal
health
Sustainable
min resources
Road
Photovoltaics Net!Works NanoMedicine Manufuture Waterborne
ZEPd) Networked &
Elect Media
Plants
Future textiles
& clothing
Space
SNEPTe) NESSIi) Forest-based
Water supply &
sanitation
RHCf) EUROP SusChem
EPoSSj) EuMat
Photonics21
Industrial
safety
Σ 36
Medicine and
bio-
technologies
Medicine of
future
BioTech2030
Bioenergy
ICT
Nuclear and
radiation
technologies
Electronics
and machinery
Transport
Programming
platform
Nuclear fuel
cycle
Mechatronics,
robotics
Auto and rail
roads
Super-
computer
Thermonuclear
fusion
UHF tecb) High speed rail
transport
Photonika
Radio-
technologies
Ocean
exploration
Polymer
composites
LED techa)
Power system Ecology tech Metallurgy tech
Aviation
mobility
Thermal power
High tech
systems
Solid minerals
Space Platform
Renewables
Textile and
light industry
Satellite
platform
Σ 30
Photonics
Aerospace
Power
Small
distribution
Metallurgy and
new materials
Mining and oil
& gas
processing
Mining tech
Ecology
development
Deep
processing
• Technology platforms are centralised, industry-led initiatives aimed at strengthening research and
setting strategic research agendas
• Technological platforms include as stakeholders: industry (large, medium and small companies),
public authorities, research institutions, civil society and the academic and financial communities
Sources: 1) EU Cordis; 2) Russian Federation Ministry of Economic Development; 3) PwC analysis
Note: a) Light-emitting diod; b) Ultra high frequency; c) Technology Platform; d) Zero Emission Fossil Fuel Power Plants; i) Sustainable Nuclear Energy Technology Platform; f)
Renewable Heating & Cooling; g) Advanced Research & Technology for Embedded Intelligence & Systems; h) The European Nanoelectronics Initiative Advisory Council; i)
Networked European Software and Services Initiative; j) European Technology Platform on Smart Systems Integration; k) Farm Animal Breeding and Reproduction
PwC
March 2013
Skolkovo as an innovation centre in
comparison with other development
institutions
19
Section 4
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
PwC
March 2013
Public report
R&D clusters like Skolkovo provide a platform for efficient and effective R&D
set up and facilitation of innovation
Clusters increase
productivity and
efficiency
Clusters stimulate and
enable innovation
Clusters facilitate
commercialisation and
new business
formation
Competitiveness
How R&D clusters impact on a company’s competitiveness
 Efficient access to specialised inputs, services, employees, information, institutions, training
programmes, and other “public goods”(local outsourcing)
 Ease of coordination and transactions across firms
 Rapid diffusion of best practices
 Ongoing, performance comparisons and incentives to improve against local rivals
 Proximity of rivals encourages strategic differentiation
 Greater likelihood of perceiving innovation opportunities (e.g., unmet needs, sophisticated
customers, combinations of services or technologies)
 Presence of multiple suppliers and institutions to assist in knowledge creation
 Ease of experimentation given locally available resources
 Opportunities for new companies and new lines of an established business are more apparent
 Spin-offs and start-ups are encouraged by the presence of other companies , commercial
relationships, and concentrated demand
 Commercialising new products and starting new companies is easier because of available skills,
suppliers, etc.
Sources: 1) Clusters, Innovation, and Competitiveness: New Findings and Implications for Policy, M. E. Porter, Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness
Harvard Business School, 2008; 2) PwC analysis
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
20
PwC
March 2013
Public report
This is why the majority of top R&D investors prefer to localise R&D
centres in clusters across industries
Distribution of new outbound R&D centres established worldwide by top
MNCs in 2002-2011 by type of localisation, Number of R&D centres
Top clusters by number of new foreign
R&D centres established in 2002-2011
Individual R&D
centres
Other
Energy and
Nuclear
64
78%
22%
Industrial
machinery
35
57%
43%
Automobiles
and parts
69
67%
33%
Chemicals
76
63%
R&D centres
in clusters
37%
Biomedical
Technologies
84
79%
21%
Aerospace
and
Telecom
119
63%
37%
ICT
320
87%
13%
• Essentially, clusters can be considered as
geographical concentrations of different
players which simultaneously compete and
cooperate within the same industry sector
• If they are efficiently organised, the clusters
are able to generate superior returns by
focusing innovation to create region-specific
competitive advantage
ICT
Aerospace
Telecom
Biomedical
Technologies
Energy
Efficiency
Shanghai,
China
Beijing,
China
Bangalore,
India
Singapore
Detroit, USA
(automotive)
Cluster Key foreign investors
Ruhrgebiet,
Germany
Bangalore,
India
Shanghai,
China
Biopolis, Singapore
Beijing,
China
Sourcse: 1) Glorad database; 2) PwC analysis
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
21
PwC
March 2013
Public report
In Russia, there are three main destinations for MNCs’ R&D centres;
Skolkovo is the only one that has strong federal government support and
commitment
Voronezh Centre Of
Microelectronics and
Nanotechnology
(2006)
No foreign residents
St. Petersburg SEZ (Strelna)
(2005). No foreign residents
Irkutsk
Baikal Nanotechnology
Cluster (2009)
No foreign residents
Tomsk SEZ (2005)
Kazan
“Idea” Technopark
(2004)
No foreign residents
Sarov Technopark
(2005)
Foreign rResidents:
• Intel
• CD-Adapco
• Nokia – Siemens Networks
Dubna SEZ
(2005)
No foreign residents
Zelenograd SEZ/
Technopark
(2005/1997)
Foreign residents:
• Beneq
R&D clusters in Russia Comments
Biomedical Technologies
Information and
Computer Technologies
Energy Efficiency
Technologies
Nuclear TechnologiesSpace Technologies and
Telecommunication
Specialisation
Source: 1) Skolkovo; 2) PwC analysis
 Most existing technopark initiatives and
special economic zones (SEZ) mainly focus on
domestic investors and have not yet
demonstrated the ability to successfully attract
foreign corporate R&D centres
 Moscow and St Petersburg have specialised
zones with an adjusted tax regime for residents
 Only selected foreign investors have opted to
localise their R&D centres in technoparks such
as Sarov Technopark and Zelenograd SEZ
 In the greater St Petersburg area, MNCs have
localised their R&D in the SEZ (Strelna),
driven mainly by non-tax factors (proximity to
pool of scientists, city and R&D infrastructure)
 Skolkovo has managed to attract MNCs by
providing a comprehensive value proposition
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
Other St. Petersburg area
Foreign Residents: • Corning
• Giesecke & Devrient
• LG Electronics
• Siemens
• Synopsys
• Google
• EMC
• Hewlett-Packard
• Sun
• Intel
• Alcatel-Lucent
• Motorola
Foreign partners:
22
• Cisco
• IBM
• Microsoft
• EMC
• Alstom
• Nokia
• J&J
• Siemens
• EADS
• GE
• NSN
• Ericsson
• Intel
• SAP
• Honeywell
• Sсhneider
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Skolkovo is an ambitious project supported by the federal government with
the aim of creating five industry innovation clusters in Russia
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
23
Source: Skolkovo
Skolkovo Innovation Centre structure
Clusters
Technopark
University
City
 Skolkovo has created five clusters (IT, Nuclear, Energy Efficiency, Space and Telecommunications,
Biotechnology), which specialise in developing Russian R&D projects within selected industries.
 The Skolkovo Foundation, which provides grants for R&D commercialisation activities, is the main
vehicle for project support.
 The Skolkovo Technopark is a specialised platform which provides assistance to innovation-driven
companies.
 The main services the Technopark provides for start-ups are: accounting, HR, business training and
providing offices and R&D equipment.
 Skoltech University is intended to be a specialised educational institution which will help develop
Skolkovo’s main areas and provide partner companies with well-qualified specialists.
 According to planes the University starts work in 2014. Now students have been attracted for learning in
partner institutes, Open University provides special training programmes for students.
 In 2018 15 centers of science, innovation and education are planned to launch.
 Skolkovo is aiming to become a city-laboratory, where innovations developed onsite will be introduced
and approved.
 The total building space within the Skolkovo municipality will exceed 2.4m square metres.
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Skolkovo will help Russia overcome major obstacles in the R&D environment
by providing an innovative ecosystem necessary for accelerating
commercialisation through easy access to network partners and finance
Key issues in Russia’s R&D
investment climate
Cluster mechanisms for
overcoming challenges faced
• Build strong financial infrastructure and assist
with venture capital and seed financing
• Attraction of anchor R&D investors and SMEs
• Build R&D supply infrastructure
• Technology Transfer Organisations
• Business Incubators, Accelerators
• Role model entrepreneurs teaching platform
• Entrepreneurship mentoring programme
• Social infrastructure and financial aid for mobile
workforce
• Visa support/special employment terms
• Cluster international visibility and international
collaboration
Gap between fundamental & applied
research and development / gap
between S&E and business
Low demand for technological
innovation in the economy
Poor entrepreneurial environment /
intolerance of failure by
entrepreneurs and start-ups
Difficulties with risk-tolerant
financing for SMEs
Low awareness of the country’s
attractiveness as a destination for
corporate R&D centres
Low level of workforce mobility
Clusters as an R&D ecosystem platform
FormationConception
Maturity Growth
Lack Lack of qualified managers
specialised in technological
implementations
Technology
Transfer
Commerciali
sation
Clusters &
Networks
Incubators/ TTOs/
Training centres
Strong cluster
organisation
Regulatory
Environment
Universities &
Research
institutions
Public and Private
irrevocable funding
Technologies
Venture capital
Critical mass
of researchers
employed
Industry and research
Collaboration/
Partnerships
National and international
research competitionsNational
reputation
Structured cluster
organisation
International
visibility
Shared platforms
and infrastructures
VCs are well
established
• Attracting top MNCs and R&D investors with
strong management practices to the cluster
• Networking initiatives by cluster organisation
Knowledge
Creation
Source: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
24
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Stakeholders
aiming to be
organised in
clusters
Emerging
Clusters
Developing
Clusters
Mature
clusters
World class
clusters
Most internationally known clusters are developed and have an industrial
specialisation. Skolkovo is at the embryonic stage of development, but is
expected to become an emerging cluster by the end of 2014
Degree of
cluster
development
Cluster
performance
Bubble size is proportional to the number of clusters present on the worldwide market, indicativea)
Resources
Technology
Génopole, France (●)
Medicon Valley, Denmark and Sweden (● / ●)
Oslo Teknopol, Norway (●)
Hokkaido, Japan (●)
St. Hyacinthe, Canada (●)
Biocat, Spain (●)
Bioval, Spain (● /●/ ●)
Rio, Brazil (●)
Zhangjian, China (● )
Skolkovo plan (end of 2014)
Biotech Umea, Sweden (●)
Biovalley, France, Germany and Switzerland (●)
IAR, France (● / ●)
Hamburg, Germany (●)
Food Valley, The Netherlands (●)
UAFC, Austria (●)
Ghent, Belgium (●)
Munich, Germany (● / ●)
Technion, Israel (● / ●)
• Biomed
• Agrofood
• Energy
• Maritime
• ICT
• Aerospace
• Nuclear Energy
Skolkovo, Russia (● /●/ ●/ ●/ ●)
Nancy, France (●)
Note: a) On this slide clusters are mostly represented at the highest level of maturity: This is due to the fact that these clusters have been widely studied and used as
models by PwC
Source: PwC analysis
San Diego, USA (● / ● / ●)
Cambridge, UK (●)
Toulouse, France (●)
Hyderabad, India (● / ●)
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
25
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Skolkovo plans to attract a critical mass of companies and employees in its
five clusters, which would move them to the emerging stage of development
(cont’d)
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
Skolkovo plan (end of 2014)Skolkovo “As is” (March 2013)Cluster driving forces Emerging stage criteria
• Jobs have been created
• Some visibility (reputation)
• Some funding sources have
been mobilised
• Cluster organisation has been set
up
• First strategic plan
Cultural
Supporting
Financial
Scientific
Industrial
Market
• Entrepreneurs are present
• Critical mass of entrepreneurial
activity is developing
• Lack of entrepreneurs • Entrepreneurs present
• Critical mass of entrepreneurial
activity is developing
• Cluster organisation has been set up
• Services for supporting the technology
commercialisation process are provided
through appropriate mechanisms
• Cluster organisation is in the
process of formation
• Strategic plan is developing
• Skolkovo grant programme has
been launched
• Number of investment funds are
accredited by Skolkovo
• 50% co-financing of Skolkovo
participants
• Venture capital has been mobilised
• Research assets/labs have been
inventoried
• Lack of awareness on the
importance of disclosure of
innovation
• Three shared service centres have
been launched
• First residents work in Technopark
• A number of renowned universities
and research organisations close to
Skolkovo
• Two core facility centres and 4 additional
shared service centres are to be launched
• Techopark is being developed
• Launching 5 centers of science,
innovations and education within SkTech
• Cluster strategy is in the line
with market needs
• Adoption and transfer of new
technology ensured
• Cluster strategy is developing
• Cluster strategy is in the line with
market needs
• 1000 participants
• 50 R&D centers
• Some visibility (reputation)
Sources: 1) Skolkovo KPIs to end 2014; 2) Skolkovo management; 3) PwC Interview Programme; 4) PwC analysis
26
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Skolkovo’s current partners confirm that it is an attractive destination for
R&D localisation
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions
27
“I don’t see too much bureaucracy
and decisions are made quickly.
That is very important.”
Lack of
bureaucracy and
red-tape
The right
place for a
cluster
“We hope to find good conditions for R&D
activity at Skolkovo, good price being one of
them. We needed to find a place for R&D
and Skolkovo was a natural choice for us.”
Attractive
conditions and
costs
2
3
Proactive and
supportive
actions
4
“We have not experienced any challenges yet. And at this moment
we don’t foresee any future challenges, thanks to great support
from the Skolkovo clusters and Key Partners Department.”
Positive feedback from Skolkovo’s partners
1
“The possibilities offered by Skolkovo in
terms of infrastructure, proximity to
high-technology partners and financial
advantages make Skolkovo an easy
choice for the location of our centre.”
“Skolkovo is close to Moscow and St.
Petersburg, where most of the country’s
talent pool is concentrated.””
“Our presence at Skolkovo will give
more visibility to our R&D in Russia.”
“Everything went
smoothly.”
“Skolkovo is close
to our markets.”
“When we were choosing a location for
an R&D centre we were looking at
different options including Moscow,
Kiev and other cities. Access to talent
and other resources was an important
factor for choosing Skolkovo.”
“We were attracted by the idea of the
Skolkovo innovation ecosystem with
access to talent. We also wanted to
associate our brand with Skolkovo.”
Optimal
positioning
opportunities
5
“From a government relations
point of view, it is a good idea
to establish an R&D centre in
Skolkovo.”
+
Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis
PwC
March 2013
Glossary
28
Appendix 1
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Glossary
A&D Aerospace and Defence
ASEAN Association of Southeast Asian Nations
bn billion
BRIC Brazil, Russia, India, China
BMI Business Monitor International
BB broadband
B2B Business-to-Business
B2C Business-to-Customer
B2G Business-to-Government
CAGR Compounded Annual Growth Rate
CAPEX Capital Expenditures
CSFs Critical Success Factors
CIS Commonwealth of Independent States
CT Corporate Technology
D Development
E&EE Electronic & Electrical Equipment
EIF European Investment Fund
EU European Union
EUR Euro
FDI Foreign Direct Investment
FPSES&T
Russian Foundation for Promotion
of Small Enterprise in Science and Technology
FTSE Financial Times Stock Exchange share index
GERD Gross Domestic Expenditure on R&D
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GE General Electric
HW Hardware
HQ Headquarters
HR Human Resources
HSE Higher School of Economics
ICB Industry Classification Benchmark
ICT Information and Computer Technologies
ILO International Labour Organisation
IMF International Monetary Fund
IP Intellectual Property
IPR Intellectual Property Rights
IT Information Technology
JRC Joint Research Centre
JV Joint Venture
KPIs Key Performance Indicators
kW kilowatt
MEPhI National Research Nuclear University MEPhI
m million
MNC Multinational Corporation
MISIS
National University of Science and
Technology MISIS
MSU Moscow State University
M&A Mergers & Acquisitions
NPD Network of Product Development
N/A not available
N.a. not appropriate
OECD
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development
PwC PricewaterhouseCoopers
Phystech Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology
R&D Research and Development
R²
R-square, goodness-of-fit measure in
regression analysis
R Research
RFBR Russian Foundation for Basic Research
RFTD
Russian Foundation for Technology
Development
RSFF Risk-Sharing Finance Facility
RoW Rest of the World
ROI Return on Investment
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Appendix 1 – Glossary
29
PwC
March 2013
Public report
Glossary (cont’d)
RVC Russian Venture Company
S&E Science and Engineering
S&T Science and Technology
SBIR Small Business Innovation Research
SBIRI Small Business Innovation Research Initiative
SEZ Special Economic Zones
SME Small and Medium-sized Enterprises
STTR Small Business Technology Transfer
sq.m square metre
TACIS
Technical Assistance for the Commonwealth of Independent
States
tn trillion
UNESCO
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
Organisation
TIP Technology Innovation Programme
TTO Technology Transfer Office
UK United Kingdom
US / USA United States of America
US NSF United States National Science Foundation
USD United States Dollar
VAT Value Added Tax
VC Venture Capital
WB World Bank
WEF World Economic Forum
94 FL 94 Federal Law
24/7 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
Appendix 1 – Glossary
30
© 2012 PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V. All rights reserved.
In this document "PwC" refers to PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V., which is a member firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers
International Limited, each member firm of which is a separate legal entity.
www.pwc.ru

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in Bor
Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in BorIvan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in Bor
Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in BorCUBCCE Conference
 
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...Pavel Melnikov
 
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationship
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationshipFDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationship
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationshipZoran Vaupot
 
Warsaw Seminar Roland Sommer
Warsaw Seminar Roland SommerWarsaw Seminar Roland Sommer
Warsaw Seminar Roland SommerYouth Agora
 
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies and Economic Sectors
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies  and Economic Sectors Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies  and Economic Sectors
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies and Economic Sectors Cláudio Carneiro
 
World university rankings 2014 By Dinesh Gunathilaka
World university rankings 2014 By  Dinesh GunathilakaWorld university rankings 2014 By  Dinesh Gunathilaka
World university rankings 2014 By Dinesh GunathilakaDinesh Gunathilaka
 
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan IJERA Editor
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

CASE Network Studies and Analyses 369 - Technical Assistance to CIS Countries
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 369 - Technical Assistance to CIS CountriesCASE Network Studies and Analyses 369 - Technical Assistance to CIS Countries
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 369 - Technical Assistance to CIS Countries
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 408 -
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 408 - CASE Network Studies and Analyses 408 -
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 408 -
 
Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in Bor
Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in BorIvan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in Bor
Ivan Mihajlovic - University of Belgrade Technical Faculty in Bor
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 392 - Innovation, Labour Demand and Wages i...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 392 - Innovation, Labour Demand and Wages i...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 392 - Innovation, Labour Demand and Wages i...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 392 - Innovation, Labour Demand and Wages i...
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 323 - Growth and Performance Factors in Pol...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 323 - Growth and Performance Factors in Pol...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 323 - Growth and Performance Factors in Pol...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 323 - Growth and Performance Factors in Pol...
 
Innovation dans l'UE
Innovation dans l'UEInnovation dans l'UE
Innovation dans l'UE
 
Cooperation in manufacturing through cooperation in innovation
Cooperation in manufacturing through cooperation in innovationCooperation in manufacturing through cooperation in innovation
Cooperation in manufacturing through cooperation in innovation
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 391 - Pay More, Earn Less, Work Harder - Ne...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 391 - Pay More, Earn Less, Work Harder - Ne...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 391 - Pay More, Earn Less, Work Harder - Ne...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 391 - Pay More, Earn Less, Work Harder - Ne...
 
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...
Federal endorsement and interaction with regional officials in the process of...
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 248 - Exchange Rate Regimes and the Real Se...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 248 - Exchange Rate Regimes and the Real Se...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 248 - Exchange Rate Regimes and the Real Se...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 248 - Exchange Rate Regimes and the Real Se...
 
Exploring Russia's Potential in its Non-resource Non-energy Exports to China ...
Exploring Russia's Potential in its Non-resource Non-energy Exports to China ...Exploring Russia's Potential in its Non-resource Non-energy Exports to China ...
Exploring Russia's Potential in its Non-resource Non-energy Exports to China ...
 
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationship
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationshipFDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationship
FDI in Slovenia: A love-hate relationship
 
Warsaw Seminar Roland Sommer
Warsaw Seminar Roland SommerWarsaw Seminar Roland Sommer
Warsaw Seminar Roland Sommer
 
CASE Network Report 76 - Price Convergence in the Enlarged Internal Market
CASE Network Report 76 - Price Convergence in the Enlarged Internal MarketCASE Network Report 76 - Price Convergence in the Enlarged Internal Market
CASE Network Report 76 - Price Convergence in the Enlarged Internal Market
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 307 - Business Climate in CIS Countries
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 307 - Business Climate in CIS CountriesCASE Network Studies and Analyses 307 - Business Climate in CIS Countries
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 307 - Business Climate in CIS Countries
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 420 - Distinguishing persistent from occasi...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 420 - Distinguishing persistent from occasi...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 420 - Distinguishing persistent from occasi...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 420 - Distinguishing persistent from occasi...
 
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies and Economic Sectors
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies  and Economic Sectors Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies  and Economic Sectors
Elaboration of Key Economic Strategies and Economic Sectors
 
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 370 - The Motives and Impediments to FDI in...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 370 - The Motives and Impediments to FDI in...CASE Network Studies and Analyses 370 - The Motives and Impediments to FDI in...
CASE Network Studies and Analyses 370 - The Motives and Impediments to FDI in...
 
World university rankings 2014 By Dinesh Gunathilaka
World university rankings 2014 By  Dinesh GunathilakaWorld university rankings 2014 By  Dinesh Gunathilaka
World university rankings 2014 By Dinesh Gunathilaka
 
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan
Cement Industry Overview and Market Price Forecasting In Azerbaijan
 

Similar a Public report 03 04-2013-eng

Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komanda
Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komandaCase russian venture_industry_-_3_komanda
Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komandaEVA
 
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE Platform
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE PlatformValorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE Platform
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE PlatformPanagiotis Tsarchopoulos
 
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0Mikhail Elizarov
 
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projects
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projectsNuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projects
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projectsThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
Unn tcc presentation march 25, 2014 minnesota_eng
Unn tcc presentation  march 25, 2014 minnesota_engUnn tcc presentation  march 25, 2014 minnesota_eng
Unn tcc presentation march 25, 2014 minnesota_engKendrick White
 
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications Startups
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications StartupsSk Top Space and Telecommunications Startups
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications StartupsMaxim Mikhaylov
 
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness Evgeny Kutsenko
 
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster Startups
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster StartupsSk Top Nuclear Cluster Startups
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster StartupsMaxim Mikhaylov
 
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Corpakis wide slovenia6416
Corpakis wide slovenia6416Corpakis wide slovenia6416
Corpakis wide slovenia6416Dimitri Corpakis
 
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partners
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partnersVenture report2015(eng) rmg partners
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partnersRmg partners
 

Similar a Public report 03 04-2013-eng (20)

Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komanda
Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komandaCase russian venture_industry_-_3_komanda
Case russian venture_industry_-_3_komanda
 
Russia: Diversifying Approaches in Innovation Policy
Russia: Diversifying Approaches in Innovation PolicyRussia: Diversifying Approaches in Innovation Policy
Russia: Diversifying Approaches in Innovation Policy
 
Sk Top Energy Startups
Sk Top Energy StartupsSk Top Energy Startups
Sk Top Energy Startups
 
Sk Top IT Startups
Sk Top IT StartupsSk Top IT Startups
Sk Top IT Startups
 
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE Platform
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE PlatformValorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE Platform
Valorisation of Academic R&D - The INTERVALUE Platform
 
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0
HORIZON 2020 (Октябрь 2014), Елизаров v3.0
 
Russia: Focus on Innovation
Russia: Focus on Innovation Russia: Focus on Innovation
Russia: Focus on Innovation
 
Ester master plan
Ester master planEster master plan
Ester master plan
 
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projects
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projectsNuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projects
Nuclear & radiation technologies cluster skolkovo innovation projects
 
Brochure skolkovo cluster it
Brochure skolkovo cluster itBrochure skolkovo cluster it
Brochure skolkovo cluster it
 
Unn tcc presentation march 25, 2014 minnesota_eng
Unn tcc presentation  march 25, 2014 minnesota_engUnn tcc presentation  march 25, 2014 minnesota_eng
Unn tcc presentation march 25, 2014 minnesota_eng
 
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications Startups
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications StartupsSk Top Space and Telecommunications Startups
Sk Top Space and Telecommunications Startups
 
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness
Cluster policy in Russia: similarity and uniqueness
 
Sk Top Bio Startups
Sk Top Bio StartupsSk Top Bio Startups
Sk Top Bio Startups
 
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster Startups
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster StartupsSk Top Nuclear Cluster Startups
Sk Top Nuclear Cluster Startups
 
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...
Problems and Prospects of Infrastructure and Innovative Development of Kazakh...
 
It aug2015 web-eng
It aug2015 web-engIt aug2015 web-eng
It aug2015 web-eng
 
Corpakis wide slovenia6416
Corpakis wide slovenia6416Corpakis wide slovenia6416
Corpakis wide slovenia6416
 
Kutsenko 23 12 2015 en
Kutsenko 23 12 2015 enKutsenko 23 12 2015 en
Kutsenko 23 12 2015 en
 
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partners
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partnersVenture report2015(eng) rmg partners
Venture report2015(eng) rmg partners
 

Más de The Skolkovo Foundation

микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 fin
микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 finмикрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 fin
микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 finThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИ
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИАЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИ
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками 17.11.2016 fin
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками   17.11.2016 finмикрограты для встречи с уачстниками   17.11.2016 fin
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками 17.11.2016 finThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
грантовый процесс полная 2014
грантовый процесс полная 2014грантовый процесс полная 2014
грантовый процесс полная 2014The Skolkovo Foundation
 
обновленное расписание 14102016 итог
обновленное расписание 14102016 итогобновленное расписание 14102016 итог
обновленное расписание 14102016 итогThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
форма 4 формальный отбор
форма 4 формальный отборформа 4 формальный отбор
форма 4 формальный отборThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
положение агрогенетика
положение агрогенетикаположение агрогенетика
положение агрогенетикаThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
положение агробиотех 2016
положение агробиотех 2016положение агробиотех 2016
положение агробиотех 2016The Skolkovo Foundation
 
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайтThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
приказ 184 качество жизни
приказ 184 качество жизниприказ 184 качество жизни
приказ 184 качество жизниThe Skolkovo Foundation
 
микрогранты презентация
микрогранты презентациямикрогранты презентация
микрогранты презентацияThe Skolkovo Foundation
 

Más de The Skolkovo Foundation (20)

микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 fin
микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 finмикрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 fin
микрогранты для встречи с участниками 10.02.2017 fin
 
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИ
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИАЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИ
АЛЬМАНАХ. ОМИКСНЫЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В РОССИИ
 
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками 17.11.2016 fin
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками   17.11.2016 finмикрограты для встречи с уачстниками   17.11.2016 fin
микрограты для встречи с уачстниками 17.11.2016 fin
 
грантовый процесс полная 2014
грантовый процесс полная 2014грантовый процесс полная 2014
грантовый процесс полная 2014
 
Инновации. Сколково.
Инновации. Сколково.Инновации. Сколково.
Инновации. Сколково.
 
316 pr
316 pr316 pr
316 pr
 
обновленное расписание 14102016 итог
обновленное расписание 14102016 итогобновленное расписание 14102016 итог
обновленное расписание 14102016 итог
 
297 пр жюри
297 пр жюри297 пр жюри
297 пр жюри
 
форма 4 формальный отбор
форма 4 формальный отборформа 4 формальный отбор
форма 4 формальный отбор
 
414 пр
414 пр414 пр
414 пр
 
251 пр
251 пр251 пр
251 пр
 
250 пр
250 пр250 пр
250 пр
 
249 пр
249 пр249 пр
249 пр
 
презентация сайт исп
презентация сайт исппрезентация сайт исп
презентация сайт исп
 
микрогранты сколково
микрогранты сколковомикрогранты сколково
микрогранты сколково
 
положение агрогенетика
положение агрогенетикаположение агрогенетика
положение агрогенетика
 
положение агробиотех 2016
положение агробиотех 2016положение агробиотех 2016
положение агробиотех 2016
 
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт
2016 06 30микрогранты_на сайт
 
приказ 184 качество жизни
приказ 184 качество жизниприказ 184 качество жизни
приказ 184 качество жизни
 
микрогранты презентация
микрогранты презентациямикрогранты презентация
микрогранты презентация
 

Último

Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy Verified Accounts
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Servicecallgirls2057
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...ictsugar
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfrichard876048
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfJos Voskuil
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailAriel592675
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...lizamodels9
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?Olivia Kresic
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfpollardmorgan
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Seta Wicaksana
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 

Último (20)

Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
 

Public report 03 04-2013-eng

  • 1. Advisory Skolkovo Foundation Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Public report March 2013
  • 2. The reader of this report understands that the work performed by PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V. (“PwC”) was performed in accordance with the instructions of our addressee client, the Skolkovo Foundation (“Skolkovo”), and exclusively for Skolkovo’s sole use and benefit. The reader also acknowledges that this report was prepared at the direction of Skolkovo and may not include all procedures deemed necessary for the reader’s purposes. The reader additionally agrees that PwC, and its partners and employees neither owe nor accept any duty or responsibility to it, whether in contract or in tort (including without limitation, negligence and breach of statutory duty), and will not be liable for any loss, damage or expense of any kind whatsoever that may be caused by any use the reader chooses to make of this report, or which may otherwise result from the reader gaining access to this report. Further, the reader agrees that this report is not to be referred to or quoted, in whole or in part, in any prospectus, registration statement, offering circular, public filing, loan, other agreement or document without PwC’s prior written consent. i Important message
  • 3. Table of contents Section Overview Page Introduction 1 International R&D dynamics and trends 1 2 Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance 8 3 Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 12 4 Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 19 Appendices 1 Glossary 28 iii
  • 4. PwC March 2013 Public report Given its capabilities and investment in R&D infrastructure through Skolkovo, Russia offers favourable opportunities for international R&D investment Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination MNCs are looking to go international for additional R&D capabilities. Nowadays, leading MNCs driven by the needs of global markets are intensively looking for unique R&D capabilities that can generate new technologies, products and know-how with strong commercial potential in their respective industries. Russia is a potentially attractive R&D destination for MNCs as a country with an extensive historical legacy in science and huge market potential. From 2002 to 2011, at least 15 MNCs established R&D centres in Russia. Among the main reasons why MNCs decide to establish R&D centres in Russia are the following: 1) Extensive talent pool available in Russia, ensured by: • High level of education • Long standing scientific and engineering culture and tradition, especially in aerospace, nuclear science, engineering and software • Renowned universities and research centres • Strong track record in international educational competitions 2) Commercial opportunities driven mainly by attractive domestic market: • B2C market: Russia is one of the largest consumer markets in Europe • B2B market: industrial output with a 5% annual growth rate is among the highest in the world • B2G market: the Russian government is pursuing an ambitious modernisation programme covering such diverse industries as healthcare, energy, aviation, transport and utilities However, the number of foreign corporate R&D centres in Russia is very small in comparison with such countries as China and India, which have attracted the majority of total outbound R&D centres over the past 10 years, at least 224 and 95 centres, respectively. The average number of foreign R&D centres established annually in Russia per total number of researchers in the country is the lowest among the BRIC countries: two times lower than in Brazil, six times lower than in China, and 18 times lower than in India, meaning that Russia’s R&D environment is relatively less penetrated by MNCs. Meanwhile, the Russian market is also relatively untapped as the average number of foreign R&D centres established annually in Russia per average annual GDP is also times less then in China and India. In particular, this is the result of the low level of integration of Russian science into the global scientific community and a lack of entrepreneurial culture in Russia, which is due to historical factors. Among other obstacles preventing MNCs from establishing R&D centres in Russia is the country’s outdated or underdeveloped R&D infrastructure, especially in the Biomedical and Industrial Machinery industries, and administrative barriers, which partially result from investors' unfamiliarity with Russian legislation and business practices. Currently, the Russian government is focused on improving the country’s R&D environment to increase its attractiveness as an R&D destination. The Russian government is implementing a policy of economic modernisation and support for innovation. R&D support measures include: • Tax incentives for R&D: Russia provides a favourable tax regime for R&D activity compared to other countries, including lower rates for major taxes and accelerated depreciation of R&D expenditures at the federal level and/or within SEZs and Skolkovo clusters • Public funding of science, including grants and venture capital through special development institutions • Technological platforms aimed at uniting key stakeholders on a specific R&D task: industry (large, medium and small companies), public authorities, research institutions, civil society and the academic and financial communities; such platforms are supported by Russian Foundation for Technology Development providing preferential loans for R&D expenditures • Organising innovation clusters: the cluster approach to organising R&D allows for creating an innovation ecosystem that offers participants, including MNCs, easy access to partners, financial sources, professional services, infrastructure facilities, etc. Skolkovo has successfully attracted MNCs to its R&D clusters as it addresses the key issues such corporations face in Russia’s R&D environment. Skolkovo represents the Russian government’s most successful initiative for creating R&D clusters. It has already established partnerships with several MNCs that plan to set up R&D centres at Skolkovo. MNCs see Skolkovo as a particularly attractive R&D location for the following reasons: • Access to a talent pool through the country’s leading universities and research institutes located in the greater Moscow area that specialise in Skolkovo’s foresight industries (IT, Space and Telecom, Biomedical, Energy Efficiency, Nuclear) • Availability of public financial support for start-ups and access to high- technology partners • Cost effectiveness (tax incentives, large-scale construction of infrastructure) • Absence of bureaucracy and red tape iv
  • 5. PwC March 2013 International R&D dynamics and trends 1 Section 1 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
  • 6. PwC March 2013 Public report Corporate R&D spending is highest in the USA and Europe while the BRIC countries demonstrate the strongest growth Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 2 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Sources: 1) European Commission JRC; 2) PwC analysis Corporate R&D expenditures by Top-2000 companies, EUR bn , 2005-2010 BRIC Asia Europe North America Others RoW RoW Others Comments +4% 35.1% 35.1% 26.6% 2.6% % of region 460.8 34.7% 0.4% 10.3% 5.5% 4.8% 4.5% 10.0% 21.5% 2.9% 2.2% 1.7% 0.4% 0.4% 0.1% 0.6% 2005 370.1 40.8% 10.4% 5.8% 5.8% 3.5% 8.8% 18.9% 2.8% 0.9% 0.2% 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% 0.6% 2010 1.2% • MNCs from developed countries still take the lead in R&D spending worldwide; in 2010 they represented 96.8% (EUR 446.1 bn) of corporate R&D spending, but their share has been gradually decreasing since 2005, when it was 98.9%. • However, MNCs from the BRIC countries have demonstrated outstanding growth in corporate R&D thus increasing steadily their share from 0.6% (EUR 2 bn) in 2005 to 2.6% (EUR 12 bn) in 2010. This rise in the BRICs’ R&D expenses has been driven by strong overall economic growth. • Among the BRIC countries, the most rapid growth in 2005-2010 was posted by MNCs from China (53%) and India (49%). China holds the leading position among BRIC countries with a share of 49% in 2010. In terms of growth, Russian MNCs placed third among their BRIC peers and in the world with a 29% CAGR in 2005-2010, while Brazilian MNCs posted an honourable fourth place showing with 23% of annual growth from 2005 to 2010. • Russian corporations spent on R&D EUR 193 m in 2005, while this figure was 3.5 times higher in 2010 at around EUR 679 m. 0.6%
  • 7. PwC March 2013 Public report MNCs are either seeking to access additional (sometimes cheaper) research capacity (talent) or are following manufacturing to adjust development locally. In Russia, access to research skills is currently the main driver Internationalised manufacturing Internationalised R&D 1 2 Internationalised research Internationalised development and manufacturing 1 2 • MNCs enter new markets to ensure sustainable growth through localising their production facilities. Proximity to customers allows for reducing the time to market. • At the second stage, MNCs customise and tailor their goods to local needs and regulatory requirements; thus, as a rule, they localise development centres. Occasionally, they may also incorporate a research centre. • This model is typical for a huge market with relatively low scientific potential, of which China is the best example. Market-driven model Technology-driven model Approach Comments Example 1883- 1891 1992 20051974 • Established as two separate firms which merged in 1988 • Hong Kong business formally established • First manufac- turing operations established • Opened Chinese R&D centre focused on power systems, robotics & manufacturing technologies 200719931969 • Samsung Electronics established in Seoul, Korea • Moscow research centre established • First plant established in Kaluga, focused on manufacturing household appliances (monitors, TVs, etc.) Source: PwC analysis Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 3 1 2 or • MNCs seek out new ideas and qualified talent to expand their own competencies. By localising their research centres, MNCs can benefit from the host country’s existing track record, legacy and educational system. They can also potentially expand their research activities through development. • At the second stage, after acquiring a good understanding of a specific market, and if the market is attractive, MNCs may opt to localise their manufacturing operations. • This model is typical for countries with strong intellectual resources and untapped market potential, or which Russia is the best example.
  • 8. PwC March 2013 Public report The industries most likely to offshore R&D are Telecom, Software, Chemicals, Automobiles, Electronics, Pharma and Semiconductors Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 4 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Top industries for “exporting” R&D centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011 1 2 3 3 5 6 18 21 21 35 36 45 50 62 63 65 69 7 6 88 98 Ø 38 Biotechnology Gas, Water & Utilities Oil & Gas Construction & Materials Electricity Alternative Energy HealthCare E&S Internet Aerospace & Defence Industrial Machinery Computer Hardware General Industrials Computer Services E&E Equipment Semiconductors Pharmaceuticals Automobiles Chemicals Software Telecom1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 2 3 4 6 75 Telecom Primary reasons for “exporting” R&D centres by MNCs Software Chemicals Automobiles Pharma SemiconductorsElectronic & Electrical Equipment Proximity to customers Limited supply of technical talent in home country Proximity to production facilities Unique specialists New markets Legal limitations in home country Proximity to manufacturers/customers Quest for talent Opportunity to work with reputable research institutes High operating costs Lack of qualified personnel at home Proximity to customers New markets: proximity to manufacturing facilities Search for talent and outstanding technologies Proximity to suppliers New markets: time to market Proximity to customers Proximity to producers Lack of specialised talent Proximity to suppliers Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) PwC analysis 6.2% 4.7% 4.4% 15.8% 16.3% 6.2% 6.5% 2.4% 2.9% 3.0% 1.9% 3.6% 0.9% 2.0% 0.14% 0.7% 1.0% 2.1% 0.2% 2.2% 68% nn - Share of industry in total corporate R&D spending (average 2008-10) - Space Technologies - ICT - Energy Efficiency - Biotech - Mix: includes Nuclear Tech Average share of total R&D spending, 2008-2010 Less than 10, not active “exporter”
  • 9. PwC March 2013 Public report Inbound R&D is highly concentrated – the clear leaders are China, India and the US, with Russia placing only 9-11 Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 5 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination 153 7 9 9 12 14 15 15 15 21 22 24 33 38 61 95 224 RoW Brazil Ø 45 UK Australia Japan France Russia Canada Ireland Israel Taiwan Korea Germany Singapore USA India China Criteria for winning modelsTop countries for “importing” R&D centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011 2.81 2.60 1.55 2.35 0.85 4.20 2.85 1.95 3.40 1.05 1.75 3.47 2.21 1.81 All R&D, % of GDP GDP, USD tn  HuHuge market potential  Low costs, including labour  Pool of talent  Political stability and favourable economic environment  Good infrastructure  Established legislative base, especially in IP  Financial and non-financial incentives  Low administrative barriers  Developed educational and science support system 2.25 15.2 0.31 11.3 0.88 4.47 0.23 3.09 1.39 1.55 2.37 0.18 4.38 2.23 2.25 0.92 1.20 2.23 50% Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) Battelle; 3) PwC analysis 2011 Average monthly salary, USD 2009 4,240 n/a 415 1,200 65 2,230 3,703 n/a 2,633 650 5,005 2,731 4,001 5,467 3,930 565 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
  • 10. PwC March 2013 Public report Some countries score well across industries due to market size, while others score well only for a limited set of industries due to specific strengths (talent, incentives, costs, etc.); Russia is chosen mainly for its scientific talent pool Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 6 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Japan Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP legislation, developed infrastructure Countries China India USA Singapore Germany Korea Taiwan Ireland Canada France Source: PwC analysis 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Qualified staff, English-language capabilities, IP legislation, cost effectiveness, government support , market Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP legislation, highly developed infrastructure Government support, qualified personnel, clustering, infrastructure, hub for East- Asian market Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP legislation, developed infrastructure, advanced technologies IT infrastructure, qualified personnel, tax incentives, favourable labour costs Proximity to production facilities, strong government support, developed infrastructure EU membership, developed infrastructure, low taxation, the government's active economic policy, English-speaking manpower, strong educational system and proximity and cultural similarity to the UK and the USA Developed ICT infrastructure, easy access to US and world markets, superior workforce, quality of life Highly qualified personnel, internationally renowned universities, established IP legislation, developed infrastructure, convenient geographical location 1- Aerospace & Defence 2- Telecommunications equipment Huge market, proximity to manufacturing facilities, cost effectiveness, government support Israel High R&D spending; highly educated population, especially with technical background; large Jewish diaspora abroad, providing access to Western financing resources; developed telecom infrastructure        Key success factors                          9- Industrial Machinery 10- Chemicals 7- Semiconductors 8- Electronic & Electrical Equipment          - Industries with the share of more than 8% of the total number of R&D centres                13- Pharmaceuticals 14- Health Care Equipment & Services Russia Strong Soviet legacy in physics, mathematics and aero- space, government support, improving infrastructure     3- Software 4- Computer Services 5- Computer Hardware 6- Internet 11- General Industrials 12- Automobiles & Parts
  • 11. PwC March 2013 Public report Over the past 10 years, Russia has attracted approximately 15 R&D centres – the leading sectors are ICT, Aerospace & Defence and Telecom Section 1 – International R&D dynamics and trends 7 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Sources: 1) Glorad database; 2) Company sites; 3) PwC analysis 1 1 2 2 2 3 4 Automobiles & Parts Chemicals Aerospace & Defence Internet Telecommunications Equipment Computer Hardware Semiconductors CommentsRussia’s inbound R&D centres, Number of centres, 2002-2011  Over the past 10 years, Russia has attracted 15 R&D centres, both Specialised Contributors and Supported Specialisation.  The majority of R&D centres are localised to take advantage of Russia’s talent pool; but, there are also centres dedicated to product customisation and are thus market-driven.  Currently, there are approximately 48 R&D units in the leading sectors, including: 1. ICT: 21 centres, 2. Aerospace and Defence, Telecommunications: 7 centres, 3. Chemicals: 6 centres.  Among leading MNCs, Russia has hosted R&D centres for EMC, LG, Google, EADS, Boeing, Intel, HP, Siemens, Samsung, DuPont and Corning, among others.
  • 12. PwC March 2013 Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance 8 Section 2 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
  • 13. PwC March 2013 Public report Our Interview Programme has shown that for MNCs the most important country selection factors in the R&D localisation process are personnel, stability, know-how and market Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination 6 18 19 20 29 34 37 38 40 42 45 47 50 52 53 Costs Cooperation Infrastructure Legal Acceptance Processes Market/ Customers Know-how Stability Personnel Image Critical mass Location Culture Regulations Ranking of CSF by importance Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis Must- have Impor- tant Comments  In our Interview Programme, we conducted interviews with 24 MNCs from such industries as Telecom Equipment, Aerospace and Defence, Software, Computer Services, Computer Hardware, Internet, Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals, Healthcare Equipment and Services, Electricity, Alternative Energy, Oil and Gas, General Industrials, Electronic and Electrical Equipment, Industrial Machinery, and Automotive and Parts, both with and without R&D centres localised in Russia.  Data is presented in an aggregated form: for both research and development type centres.  Depending on the specific industries and the R&D value chain stage (R or D), the importance of specific factors may differ.  All companies interviewed across all industries indicated that the most important factors are: talent, technology, market and stability (political, social and economic). 9
  • 14. PwC March 2013 Public report Given Russia’s world-class scientific base and its statute as one of Europe’s largest markets, the Russian government has focused on improving the R&D environment to spur corporate capital investment in R&D Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance 10 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination No. 1 RUSSIA’S HUGE POTENTIAL COMMENTS World-class, creative, bright talent Huge, untapped market opportunities Rapidly developing national innovation system # of researchers, 2010, ‘000 • With a large number of researchers per 10,000 of its economically active population, Russia is comparable to developed countries and far above developing ones. • Historically, Russia has been strong in natural and technical sciences, thus these disciplines account for about 92% of the total number of researchers. • Russia’s B2C, B2B and B2G markets are some of the most attractive in the world. • Russia represents one of the largest consumer markets in Europe. The country’s industrial output, with 5% annual growth, is among the highest in the world. • The Russian government is carrying out an ambitious modernisation programme covering such sectors as healthcare, energy, aviation, transport and utilities. Sources: 1) IMF; 2) Rosstat; 3) CIA; 4) PwC analysis • The Russian government launched one of its most ambitious and promising projects – the Skolkovo Innovation Centre – aimed at developing an innovation-driven economy in Russia and covering five clusters: Information and Computer Technologies, Space Technologies, and Telecommunication, Nuclear, Energy Efficiency and Biomedical Technologies. • Skolkovo hosts a critical mass of stakeholders and offers a comprehensive system of incentives: tax breaks, preferential customs regime, access to funding and infrastructure, and simplified hiring of foreign labour. 1 3 3 1 5 54 4 2 14 4 15 65 0 5 0 1 00 500 0 BrazilIndiaRussiaChina 1,152 USA 1,413 95 1,000 1,500 Per 10,000 of economically active population 82 1 4 33 1 0 44 48 1 5 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 01,400 1,200 200 0 GermanyRussia 13 USAIndia 1,191 China 1,341 GDP per capita, 2011, ‘000 USD B2C market, 2010, mn of population
  • 15. PwC March 2013 Public report Note: a) Cover several sectors like Electricity, Energy, Alternative Energy, Healthcare Equipment, and Industrial Machinery; b) Also relevant for specialised software in Aerospace and Pharma In Aerospace, Internet, Nuclear Technology and Software Russia has strong capabilities both in research and development due to the Soviet legacy in physics, mathematics, and space technologies Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis Capabilities of Russia - High - Medium - Low 11 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 2 – Critical success factors in attracting R&D investment and Russia’s performance • Longstanding scientific tradition in life sciences • Developed infrastructure for clinical tests of specific groups of illnesses • Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors • Attractive market size and potential • Longstanding scientific tradition in physics and mathematics • Strong partnership of research centres with civil/military companies in A&D • Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors R D Aerospace and Defence Telecommunications R D Key advantages of Russia Softwareb) Computer Services Computer Hardware Internet Semiconductors Electronic and Eectrical Equipment (E&EE) Industrial Machinery Chemicals Automobiles and Parts Pharmaceuticals Healthcare Equipment and Services ICB sector • Longstanding scientific tradition in mathematics proven by strong achievements of students at international contests • Creative educational process at leading universities that foster the ability to solve non-standard tasks and issues • Employee potential in software and Internet recognised by leading IT and Internet companies • Strong Russian market growth for Internet-related industries and in- demand IT goods and services, e.g. growing broadband connectivity • SME and start-up development in IT sector • Lower labour cost in the sectors versus competitors • Longstanding scientific tradition in physics and material engineering • Market potential in these sectors due to unsatisfied demand for modern equipment, services and goods from B2C, B2B and B2G segments • Longstanding scientific and engineering culture in physics, mathematics, and material engineering • Globally renowned universities and research centres • Developed infrastructure for working with nuclear technologies Industrial Machinery Electricity Nuclear Technologiesa) Skolkovo cluster - Very high
  • 16. PwC March 2013 Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 12 Section 3 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
  • 17. PwC March 2013 Public report Globally, governments support R&D start-ups and projects through special mechanisms providing services and infrastructure, and public financing and tax incentives. While Russia does provide tax incentives and public financing for R&D, it has not actively developed business incubators and TTOs  Governments support R&D activity at different stages of R&D projects, mainly through: • tax incentives for private, innovation-driven companies; • providing special R&D supporting mechanisms, such as technology transfer offices, business incubators and business accelerators; • providing non-revocable (grants) and revocable financing for R&D projects (mainly through special funding and development institutions, such as public foundations, state venture funds, development banks, etc.).  Such support can be provided individually or as part of a package based on R&D and R&D/industrial clusters, special economic zones (SEZ), technoparks, technological platforms, etc.  Public project financing usually requires co-financing from private sources (excluding fundamental research), i.e. own capital, venture and private capital funds, and banks.  Currently, the Russian government provides mainly public financing and tax incentives for R&D projects, but lags in providing supporting mechanisms for commercialising R&D results.  Existing innovation technoparks (Sarov, Idea) and innovation centres (Dubna, Zelenograd) mainly provide infrastructure facilities but very limited outsourcing and individual consulting services to their residents.  Skolkovo can be used as a platform for providing supporting mechanisms in accordance with global best practice. Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 13 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Comments Maturity Incubation (pre-seed / seed) Acceleration (growth) Stage of development Concept Technical validation Market validation Implementation scaling-up International expansion IPO or M&A Sales Evolution of a company Transfer technology office (TTO) 1-2 years (3-5 years for biotech start-ups) Up to 1 year Business incubator 1 2 3 4 5 Supporting mechanisms Business accelerator Duration Up to 2 years 6 Public financing R&D tax incentives Grants Grants, venture capital Venture capital, preferential loans Preferential loans Tax deductions, preferential tax rates Investment grants, tax deductions, tax exemptions Source: PwC analysis Provided by government in Russia To be developed in Russia Map of government support by stages of R&D project
  • 18. PwC March 2013 Public report Russia offers a favourable tax regime for R&D, including reduced tax rates, accelerated depreciation of R&D expenditures and tax credits, at the federal level as well as within SEZs and the Skolkovo clusters Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Transition economies Mature markets Russia China India Singapore Israel Ireland USA Reduced profits tax rate 15% 17% 5%a) 10-25% 12.5% Profits tax holidays b) c) Increased tax rebate for R&D expenditures 150% 150% 150% Tax credit for R&D and investment in high-tech Accelerated depreciation Inclusion of some of R&D capex into revenue expenditures d) Property tax reduction Exemption from customs dues e)         Note: a) Minimal rate for a time period up to 10 years; b) Based on individual agreements; c) For designated companies; d) Only hardware for IT companies; e) Dues are not collected Sources: 1) Incentives for innovation 2010, PwC; 2) Russian Federation Tax Code; 3) PwC analysis                     Transition economies tend to provide higher tax rebate for R&D expenditures Mature markets offer tax credits more often Tax polices are generally based on individual countries’ conditions; however, similar economies may have similar policies                 Available in Skolkovo and/or SEZ Available in Skolkovo and/or SEZ  14
  • 19. PwC March 2013 Public report Russia has all major types of development institutions providing public funding for R&D at different project stages National development institutions in top countries/regions for inbound R&D (with overall budget) Administrator of government programme China Ministry of Science and Technology N/A India USA EU Russia National venture capital provider Development banks Clusters/ Special economic zones Council of Scientific and Industrial Research USD 150m US Small Business Administration USD 172m The Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology, Germany N/A Skolkovo Foundation USD 200m N/A US Small Business Administration USD 8.2bn The European Investment Fund USD 1.8 bn per year Not used for innovation development Not used for innovation development Not used for innovation development The European Investment Bank EUR 1.4bn per year MSP-Bank (affiliated with VEB) EUR 1.25bn per year Shenzhen SEZ Usually used for manufacturing and foreign trade Skolkovo, SEZ Dubna Not used for innovation development Israel Chief Scientist’s Office ~USD250m Yozma N/A -- N/A Russian Venture Company USD 851m N/A N/A Sources: 1) Development institution websites, 2) Erawatch, 3) PwC analysis Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 15 Comments  The Russian government is implementing a comprehensive innovation promotion programme and developing various mechanisms for the financial support for R&D, while most of other R&D-active countries focus on specific types of development institutions.  In particular, the Russian government provides public funding for R&D through special government grant programmes, a venture capital fund of funds, a development bank (preferential credits) and SEZs (preferential tax regime).
  • 20. PwC March 2013 Public report Although public funding in Russia is sufficient, access to venture capital and loans for R&D is limited Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 16 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Loans and credits for R&D Grants Venture capital  Access to grant funds on terms that are aligned with other countries’ policies  Grant programmes cover all stages of the R&D cycle  Grant programme requirements are in line with other countries’ practices and relatively easy to meet  R&D loans and credit instruments are focused only on commercialisation stage  Budgets of R&D soft loan providers are limited with voluntary contributions from Russian companies  State bank-provided funding for preferential R&D credits requires a patent, thus significantly limiting the range of potential borrowers Financing sources critical for SMEs Available amount Ease of access 1 2 3 High High High Low Medium Low Skolkovo/Russia benchmark versus other countries Comments on Russia  Large number of investment funds with capital to invest.  RVC provides private seed capital and risk sharing mechanisms for private funds.  Access to venture financing for SMEs and start-ups is limited as a result of the lack of innovation support structures and mentoring systems (business angels, professional intermediaries) Skolkovo, Russia SBIR, USA OCS, Israel Russia USA Israel Russia Europe 1. Total funds (USD bn) 2. Max. sum of grant (USD mn) 3. Time required for funding decision (days) 1. National VC Funds available (USD bn) 2. VC availability a) 1. Development banks budgets (USD bn) 3. Ease of access to loansa) (for Europe – Germany) 87 90 70 10 1 0.8 (Average) 0.2 2.5 0.3 (2010) 1 8.2 0.1 3. Quality of proposals (based on interviews) 2,3 4.0 4.5 Low High High 2,4 3.o 1.6 1.8 2. Number of R&D credits provided by banks (indicative) Low High Note: a) Country indicator, Global Competitive Report rating, where 1 is the lowest, 7 is the highest Source: 1) The Global Competitiveness Report 2011-2012, 2) Development institution websites; 3) PwC Interview Programme; 4) PwC analysis
  • 21. PwC March 2013 Public report Initiatives introduced by the Russian government are improving Russia’s attractiveness for R&D Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Innovation commercialisation and growth management programme Initiatives Description Status Innovation projects support programme Presidential programme “Innovations and Risks in Business” Allows managers to gain advanced knowledge and learn necessary traits in the area of commercialising innovative projects and managing innovative companies for the purpose of achieving competitiveness and providing substantial business growth The programme is aimed at stimulating innovative activity between students, researchers and scientists in the area of information security and related industries The main objective of the programme is to educate a new category of specialists who will manage the development of a new product as well as its introduction to the market TACIS project Innovation and technological project contest ‘Technovation Cup” The main goal of the "Support of Export-Orientated Innovative SMEs“ project initiated by the Russian agency and realised on its base is to support and co-operate in the process of developing innovation-driven and export-oriented SMEs with the ultimate goal of expanding trade relations between EU countries and the Russian Federation, as well as developing a “common economic space.” The main objective of the Cup is to help project teams to market their product or technology in the real sector of the economy and to turn their ideas into businesses Sources: 1) Programs’ websites, 2) PwC analysis Education - Moscow State University Was running 2006-2008, now closed Research Grant - Kaspersky Lab Type of program- Executive agent Running since 2008 Education – Commission of Executive Education Running since 2009 Developing SMEs - Moscow Physics and Technology Institute Running Developing SMEs - Enterprise Europe Network Running 17
  • 22. PwC March 2013 Public report Russia is establishing technology platforms, primarily following the EU’s example Section 3 – Overview of R&D incentives globally and availability of support in Russia and Skolkovo 18 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Energy ICT Bio-based economy Production & processes Transport Biofuels ARTEMISg) FABREk) Construction Platform Aeronautics SmartGrids ENIACh) Food European Steel Rail TPWindc) Integral Satcom Initiative Global animal health Sustainable min resources Road Photovoltaics Net!Works NanoMedicine Manufuture Waterborne ZEPd) Networked & Elect Media Plants Future textiles & clothing Space SNEPTe) NESSIi) Forest-based Water supply & sanitation RHCf) EUROP SusChem EPoSSj) EuMat Photonics21 Industrial safety Σ 36 Medicine and bio- technologies Medicine of future BioTech2030 Bioenergy ICT Nuclear and radiation technologies Electronics and machinery Transport Programming platform Nuclear fuel cycle Mechatronics, robotics Auto and rail roads Super- computer Thermonuclear fusion UHF tecb) High speed rail transport Photonika Radio- technologies Ocean exploration Polymer composites LED techa) Power system Ecology tech Metallurgy tech Aviation mobility Thermal power High tech systems Solid minerals Space Platform Renewables Textile and light industry Satellite platform Σ 30 Photonics Aerospace Power Small distribution Metallurgy and new materials Mining and oil & gas processing Mining tech Ecology development Deep processing • Technology platforms are centralised, industry-led initiatives aimed at strengthening research and setting strategic research agendas • Technological platforms include as stakeholders: industry (large, medium and small companies), public authorities, research institutions, civil society and the academic and financial communities Sources: 1) EU Cordis; 2) Russian Federation Ministry of Economic Development; 3) PwC analysis Note: a) Light-emitting diod; b) Ultra high frequency; c) Technology Platform; d) Zero Emission Fossil Fuel Power Plants; i) Sustainable Nuclear Energy Technology Platform; f) Renewable Heating & Cooling; g) Advanced Research & Technology for Embedded Intelligence & Systems; h) The European Nanoelectronics Initiative Advisory Council; i) Networked European Software and Services Initiative; j) European Technology Platform on Smart Systems Integration; k) Farm Animal Breeding and Reproduction
  • 23. PwC March 2013 Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 19 Section 4 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
  • 24. PwC March 2013 Public report R&D clusters like Skolkovo provide a platform for efficient and effective R&D set up and facilitation of innovation Clusters increase productivity and efficiency Clusters stimulate and enable innovation Clusters facilitate commercialisation and new business formation Competitiveness How R&D clusters impact on a company’s competitiveness  Efficient access to specialised inputs, services, employees, information, institutions, training programmes, and other “public goods”(local outsourcing)  Ease of coordination and transactions across firms  Rapid diffusion of best practices  Ongoing, performance comparisons and incentives to improve against local rivals  Proximity of rivals encourages strategic differentiation  Greater likelihood of perceiving innovation opportunities (e.g., unmet needs, sophisticated customers, combinations of services or technologies)  Presence of multiple suppliers and institutions to assist in knowledge creation  Ease of experimentation given locally available resources  Opportunities for new companies and new lines of an established business are more apparent  Spin-offs and start-ups are encouraged by the presence of other companies , commercial relationships, and concentrated demand  Commercialising new products and starting new companies is easier because of available skills, suppliers, etc. Sources: 1) Clusters, Innovation, and Competitiveness: New Findings and Implications for Policy, M. E. Porter, Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness Harvard Business School, 2008; 2) PwC analysis Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 20
  • 25. PwC March 2013 Public report This is why the majority of top R&D investors prefer to localise R&D centres in clusters across industries Distribution of new outbound R&D centres established worldwide by top MNCs in 2002-2011 by type of localisation, Number of R&D centres Top clusters by number of new foreign R&D centres established in 2002-2011 Individual R&D centres Other Energy and Nuclear 64 78% 22% Industrial machinery 35 57% 43% Automobiles and parts 69 67% 33% Chemicals 76 63% R&D centres in clusters 37% Biomedical Technologies 84 79% 21% Aerospace and Telecom 119 63% 37% ICT 320 87% 13% • Essentially, clusters can be considered as geographical concentrations of different players which simultaneously compete and cooperate within the same industry sector • If they are efficiently organised, the clusters are able to generate superior returns by focusing innovation to create region-specific competitive advantage ICT Aerospace Telecom Biomedical Technologies Energy Efficiency Shanghai, China Beijing, China Bangalore, India Singapore Detroit, USA (automotive) Cluster Key foreign investors Ruhrgebiet, Germany Bangalore, India Shanghai, China Biopolis, Singapore Beijing, China Sourcse: 1) Glorad database; 2) PwC analysis Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 21
  • 26. PwC March 2013 Public report In Russia, there are three main destinations for MNCs’ R&D centres; Skolkovo is the only one that has strong federal government support and commitment Voronezh Centre Of Microelectronics and Nanotechnology (2006) No foreign residents St. Petersburg SEZ (Strelna) (2005). No foreign residents Irkutsk Baikal Nanotechnology Cluster (2009) No foreign residents Tomsk SEZ (2005) Kazan “Idea” Technopark (2004) No foreign residents Sarov Technopark (2005) Foreign rResidents: • Intel • CD-Adapco • Nokia – Siemens Networks Dubna SEZ (2005) No foreign residents Zelenograd SEZ/ Technopark (2005/1997) Foreign residents: • Beneq R&D clusters in Russia Comments Biomedical Technologies Information and Computer Technologies Energy Efficiency Technologies Nuclear TechnologiesSpace Technologies and Telecommunication Specialisation Source: 1) Skolkovo; 2) PwC analysis  Most existing technopark initiatives and special economic zones (SEZ) mainly focus on domestic investors and have not yet demonstrated the ability to successfully attract foreign corporate R&D centres  Moscow and St Petersburg have specialised zones with an adjusted tax regime for residents  Only selected foreign investors have opted to localise their R&D centres in technoparks such as Sarov Technopark and Zelenograd SEZ  In the greater St Petersburg area, MNCs have localised their R&D in the SEZ (Strelna), driven mainly by non-tax factors (proximity to pool of scientists, city and R&D infrastructure)  Skolkovo has managed to attract MNCs by providing a comprehensive value proposition Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions Other St. Petersburg area Foreign Residents: • Corning • Giesecke & Devrient • LG Electronics • Siemens • Synopsys • Google • EMC • Hewlett-Packard • Sun • Intel • Alcatel-Lucent • Motorola Foreign partners: 22 • Cisco • IBM • Microsoft • EMC • Alstom • Nokia • J&J • Siemens • EADS • GE • NSN • Ericsson • Intel • SAP • Honeywell • Sсhneider
  • 27. PwC March 2013 Public report Skolkovo is an ambitious project supported by the federal government with the aim of creating five industry innovation clusters in Russia Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 23 Source: Skolkovo Skolkovo Innovation Centre structure Clusters Technopark University City  Skolkovo has created five clusters (IT, Nuclear, Energy Efficiency, Space and Telecommunications, Biotechnology), which specialise in developing Russian R&D projects within selected industries.  The Skolkovo Foundation, which provides grants for R&D commercialisation activities, is the main vehicle for project support.  The Skolkovo Technopark is a specialised platform which provides assistance to innovation-driven companies.  The main services the Technopark provides for start-ups are: accounting, HR, business training and providing offices and R&D equipment.  Skoltech University is intended to be a specialised educational institution which will help develop Skolkovo’s main areas and provide partner companies with well-qualified specialists.  According to planes the University starts work in 2014. Now students have been attracted for learning in partner institutes, Open University provides special training programmes for students.  In 2018 15 centers of science, innovation and education are planned to launch.  Skolkovo is aiming to become a city-laboratory, where innovations developed onsite will be introduced and approved.  The total building space within the Skolkovo municipality will exceed 2.4m square metres.
  • 28. PwC March 2013 Public report Skolkovo will help Russia overcome major obstacles in the R&D environment by providing an innovative ecosystem necessary for accelerating commercialisation through easy access to network partners and finance Key issues in Russia’s R&D investment climate Cluster mechanisms for overcoming challenges faced • Build strong financial infrastructure and assist with venture capital and seed financing • Attraction of anchor R&D investors and SMEs • Build R&D supply infrastructure • Technology Transfer Organisations • Business Incubators, Accelerators • Role model entrepreneurs teaching platform • Entrepreneurship mentoring programme • Social infrastructure and financial aid for mobile workforce • Visa support/special employment terms • Cluster international visibility and international collaboration Gap between fundamental & applied research and development / gap between S&E and business Low demand for technological innovation in the economy Poor entrepreneurial environment / intolerance of failure by entrepreneurs and start-ups Difficulties with risk-tolerant financing for SMEs Low awareness of the country’s attractiveness as a destination for corporate R&D centres Low level of workforce mobility Clusters as an R&D ecosystem platform FormationConception Maturity Growth Lack Lack of qualified managers specialised in technological implementations Technology Transfer Commerciali sation Clusters & Networks Incubators/ TTOs/ Training centres Strong cluster organisation Regulatory Environment Universities & Research institutions Public and Private irrevocable funding Technologies Venture capital Critical mass of researchers employed Industry and research Collaboration/ Partnerships National and international research competitionsNational reputation Structured cluster organisation International visibility Shared platforms and infrastructures VCs are well established • Attracting top MNCs and R&D investors with strong management practices to the cluster • Networking initiatives by cluster organisation Knowledge Creation Source: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 24
  • 29. PwC March 2013 Public report Stakeholders aiming to be organised in clusters Emerging Clusters Developing Clusters Mature clusters World class clusters Most internationally known clusters are developed and have an industrial specialisation. Skolkovo is at the embryonic stage of development, but is expected to become an emerging cluster by the end of 2014 Degree of cluster development Cluster performance Bubble size is proportional to the number of clusters present on the worldwide market, indicativea) Resources Technology Génopole, France (●) Medicon Valley, Denmark and Sweden (● / ●) Oslo Teknopol, Norway (●) Hokkaido, Japan (●) St. Hyacinthe, Canada (●) Biocat, Spain (●) Bioval, Spain (● /●/ ●) Rio, Brazil (●) Zhangjian, China (● ) Skolkovo plan (end of 2014) Biotech Umea, Sweden (●) Biovalley, France, Germany and Switzerland (●) IAR, France (● / ●) Hamburg, Germany (●) Food Valley, The Netherlands (●) UAFC, Austria (●) Ghent, Belgium (●) Munich, Germany (● / ●) Technion, Israel (● / ●) • Biomed • Agrofood • Energy • Maritime • ICT • Aerospace • Nuclear Energy Skolkovo, Russia (● /●/ ●/ ●/ ●) Nancy, France (●) Note: a) On this slide clusters are mostly represented at the highest level of maturity: This is due to the fact that these clusters have been widely studied and used as models by PwC Source: PwC analysis San Diego, USA (● / ● / ●) Cambridge, UK (●) Toulouse, France (●) Hyderabad, India (● / ●) Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 25
  • 30. PwC March 2013 Public report Skolkovo plans to attract a critical mass of companies and employees in its five clusters, which would move them to the emerging stage of development (cont’d) Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions Skolkovo plan (end of 2014)Skolkovo “As is” (March 2013)Cluster driving forces Emerging stage criteria • Jobs have been created • Some visibility (reputation) • Some funding sources have been mobilised • Cluster organisation has been set up • First strategic plan Cultural Supporting Financial Scientific Industrial Market • Entrepreneurs are present • Critical mass of entrepreneurial activity is developing • Lack of entrepreneurs • Entrepreneurs present • Critical mass of entrepreneurial activity is developing • Cluster organisation has been set up • Services for supporting the technology commercialisation process are provided through appropriate mechanisms • Cluster organisation is in the process of formation • Strategic plan is developing • Skolkovo grant programme has been launched • Number of investment funds are accredited by Skolkovo • 50% co-financing of Skolkovo participants • Venture capital has been mobilised • Research assets/labs have been inventoried • Lack of awareness on the importance of disclosure of innovation • Three shared service centres have been launched • First residents work in Technopark • A number of renowned universities and research organisations close to Skolkovo • Two core facility centres and 4 additional shared service centres are to be launched • Techopark is being developed • Launching 5 centers of science, innovations and education within SkTech • Cluster strategy is in the line with market needs • Adoption and transfer of new technology ensured • Cluster strategy is developing • Cluster strategy is in the line with market needs • 1000 participants • 50 R&D centers • Some visibility (reputation) Sources: 1) Skolkovo KPIs to end 2014; 2) Skolkovo management; 3) PwC Interview Programme; 4) PwC analysis 26
  • 31. PwC March 2013 Public report Skolkovo’s current partners confirm that it is an attractive destination for R&D localisation Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Section 4 – Skolkovo as an innovation centre in comparison with other development institutions 27 “I don’t see too much bureaucracy and decisions are made quickly. That is very important.” Lack of bureaucracy and red-tape The right place for a cluster “We hope to find good conditions for R&D activity at Skolkovo, good price being one of them. We needed to find a place for R&D and Skolkovo was a natural choice for us.” Attractive conditions and costs 2 3 Proactive and supportive actions 4 “We have not experienced any challenges yet. And at this moment we don’t foresee any future challenges, thanks to great support from the Skolkovo clusters and Key Partners Department.” Positive feedback from Skolkovo’s partners 1 “The possibilities offered by Skolkovo in terms of infrastructure, proximity to high-technology partners and financial advantages make Skolkovo an easy choice for the location of our centre.” “Skolkovo is close to Moscow and St. Petersburg, where most of the country’s talent pool is concentrated.”” “Our presence at Skolkovo will give more visibility to our R&D in Russia.” “Everything went smoothly.” “Skolkovo is close to our markets.” “When we were choosing a location for an R&D centre we were looking at different options including Moscow, Kiev and other cities. Access to talent and other resources was an important factor for choosing Skolkovo.” “We were attracted by the idea of the Skolkovo innovation ecosystem with access to talent. We also wanted to associate our brand with Skolkovo.” Optimal positioning opportunities 5 “From a government relations point of view, it is a good idea to establish an R&D centre in Skolkovo.” + Sources: 1) PwC Interview Programme; 2) PwC analysis
  • 32. PwC March 2013 Glossary 28 Appendix 1 Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination
  • 33. PwC March 2013 Public report Glossary A&D Aerospace and Defence ASEAN Association of Southeast Asian Nations bn billion BRIC Brazil, Russia, India, China BMI Business Monitor International BB broadband B2B Business-to-Business B2C Business-to-Customer B2G Business-to-Government CAGR Compounded Annual Growth Rate CAPEX Capital Expenditures CSFs Critical Success Factors CIS Commonwealth of Independent States CT Corporate Technology D Development E&EE Electronic & Electrical Equipment EIF European Investment Fund EU European Union EUR Euro FDI Foreign Direct Investment FPSES&T Russian Foundation for Promotion of Small Enterprise in Science and Technology FTSE Financial Times Stock Exchange share index GERD Gross Domestic Expenditure on R&D GDP Gross Domestic Product GE General Electric HW Hardware HQ Headquarters HR Human Resources HSE Higher School of Economics ICB Industry Classification Benchmark ICT Information and Computer Technologies ILO International Labour Organisation IMF International Monetary Fund IP Intellectual Property IPR Intellectual Property Rights IT Information Technology JRC Joint Research Centre JV Joint Venture KPIs Key Performance Indicators kW kilowatt MEPhI National Research Nuclear University MEPhI m million MNC Multinational Corporation MISIS National University of Science and Technology MISIS MSU Moscow State University M&A Mergers & Acquisitions NPD Network of Product Development N/A not available N.a. not appropriate OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development PwC PricewaterhouseCoopers Phystech Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology R&D Research and Development R² R-square, goodness-of-fit measure in regression analysis R Research RFBR Russian Foundation for Basic Research RFTD Russian Foundation for Technology Development RSFF Risk-Sharing Finance Facility RoW Rest of the World ROI Return on Investment Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Appendix 1 – Glossary 29
  • 34. PwC March 2013 Public report Glossary (cont’d) RVC Russian Venture Company S&E Science and Engineering S&T Science and Technology SBIR Small Business Innovation Research SBIRI Small Business Innovation Research Initiative SEZ Special Economic Zones SME Small and Medium-sized Enterprises STTR Small Business Technology Transfer sq.m square metre TACIS Technical Assistance for the Commonwealth of Independent States tn trillion UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation TIP Technology Innovation Programme TTO Technology Transfer Office UK United Kingdom US / USA United States of America US NSF United States National Science Foundation USD United States Dollar VAT Value Added Tax VC Venture Capital WB World Bank WEF World Economic Forum 94 FL 94 Federal Law 24/7 24 hours a day, 7 days a week Skolkovo Foundation • Russia and Skolkovo’s attractiveness as an R&D destination Appendix 1 – Glossary 30
  • 35. © 2012 PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V. All rights reserved. In this document "PwC" refers to PricewaterhouseCoopers Russia B.V., which is a member firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited, each member firm of which is a separate legal entity. www.pwc.ru