SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
A 
Plan 
for 
Transfer 
of 
the 
Public 
Lands 
Excerpts 
taken 
from 
the 
1932 
Congressional 
Hearings 
on 
Granting 
Remaining 
Unreserved 
Public 
Lands 
to 
the 
States. 
“It 
is 
futile 
to 
criticize 
without 
suggesting 
a 
remedy. 
This 
nation 
today 
is 
ruled 
by 
organized 
minorities. 
That 
we 
do 
not 
like 
this 
system 
of 
government 
is 
no 
reason 
why 
we 
should 
not 
use 
it 
if 
it 
is 
our 
only 
recourse. 
Bureaus 
can 
not 
exist 
without 
appropriations. 
The 
Representatives 
from 
the 
western 
states 
are 
comparatively 
too 
few 
in 
number, 
and 
perhaps 
too 
anxious 
to 
have 
the 
Bureaus 
expend 
funds 
in 
their 
districts 
to 
offer 
much 
hope 
of 
curbing 
the 
Bureaus, 
but 
the 
eleven 
public 
land 
states 
have 
twenty-­‐two 
Senators 
and 
the 
Senate 
must 
approve 
all 
Bureau 
appropriations. 
A 
little 
group 
of 
about 
half 
this 
number 
have 
been 
the 
balance 
of 
power 
in 
the 
United 
States 
Senate 
for 
the 
last 
decade. 
If 
fifteen 
or 
twenty 
of 
the 
western 
Senators 
will 
unite 
on 
any 
fair 
policy 
for 
the 
local 
control 
of 
western 
lands 
they 
can 
insure 
its 
adoption. 
“The 
Governors 
of 
the 
western 
states 
possess 
the 
most 
powerful 
peace 
time 
weapon, 
publicity. 
If 
you 
gentlemen 
will 
unite 
on 
a 
policy 
of 
resistence 
to 
further 
Federal 
encroachment, 
and 
the 
curtailment 
of 
present 
superfluous 
activity 
by 
the 
Federal 
Government 
in 
affairs 
that 
should 
be 
handled 
by 
officials 
answerable 
to 
the 
people 
at 
the 
polls, 
and 
will 
arouse 
the 
citizens 
of 
your 
commonwealth 
your 
Senators 
will 
be 
glad 
to 
carry 
out 
the 
wishes 
of 
your 
people, 
and 
the 
control 
of 
the 
lands 
and 
resources 
of 
your 
states 
will 
be 
vested 
where 
they 
were 
intended 
to 
be, 
in 
the 
hands 
of 
those 
without 
whose 
adjacent 
residency 
they 
would 
be 
worthless. 
Lands 
and 
resources 
have 
always 
been 
obtained 
or 
retained 
by 
fighting. 
Human 
nature 
has 
not 
changed. 
If 
the 
West 
desires 
to 
control 
its 
own 
resources 
it 
must 
fight 
to 
do 
so.” 
Thomas 
Maddock, 
from 
a 
1931 
address 
to 
the 
Western 
Governors, 
added 
the 
1932 
Congressional 
Record 
in 
the 
hearings 
on 
Granting 
Remaining 
Unreserved 
Public 
Lands 
to 
the 
States. 
Born 
in 
Roanoke, 
Va. 
in 
1883, 
Thomas 
Maddock 
first 
came 
to 
Arizona 
in 
1898 
from 
Newcastle, 
Pa. 
A 
Republican 
from 
Coconino 
County, 
he 
was 
elected 
to 
the 
first 
Arizona 
Legislature 
and 
later 
served 
as 
Secretary 
and 
State 
Chairman 
of 
the 
Arizona 
Republican 
Party. 
He 
served 
as 
Arizona 
State 
Highway 
Engineer 
from 
1917-­‐1922, 
and 
was 
a 
member 
of 
the 
Colorado 
River 
Commission 
from 
1923 
to 
1928.

More Related Content

What's hot

Bundle of Compromises - Civics & Economics
Bundle of Compromises - Civics & EconomicsBundle of Compromises - Civics & Economics
Bundle of Compromises - Civics & EconomicsMatthew Caggia
 
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)Tom Richey
 
The U.S. Constitution: Framing, Principles, & Ratification
The U.S. Constitution:  Framing, Principles, & RatificationThe U.S. Constitution:  Framing, Principles, & Ratification
The U.S. Constitution: Framing, Principles, & RatificationTom Richey
 
Lesson 2 Philadelphia Convention
Lesson 2 Philadelphia ConventionLesson 2 Philadelphia Convention
Lesson 2 Philadelphia Conventionms_mcmanus
 
Review Power Point
Review  Power  PointReview  Power  Point
Review Power Pointsegrey
 
Lecture 6 (2 )
Lecture 6 (2 )Lecture 6 (2 )
Lecture 6 (2 )barkasivv
 
Constitutional Underpinnings & Ratification
Constitutional Underpinnings & RatificationConstitutional Underpinnings & Ratification
Constitutional Underpinnings & RatificationJennifer Boyer-Switala
 
Govt 2306 ch_5
Govt 2306 ch_5Govt 2306 ch_5
Govt 2306 ch_5Rick Fair
 
Chapter 11 government notes
Chapter 11 government notesChapter 11 government notes
Chapter 11 government notesHolmesGov
 
Constitutional Convention Powerpoint
Constitutional Convention PowerpointConstitutional Convention Powerpoint
Constitutional Convention Powerpointkaraking
 
The Hartford Convention
The Hartford ConventionThe Hartford Convention
The Hartford Conventioni Classroom
 
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]jtoma84
 
Federalism the division of power
Federalism  the division of powerFederalism  the division of power
Federalism the division of powermistygoetz
 
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]jtoma84
 
Constitutional convention
Constitutional conventionConstitutional convention
Constitutional conventiondnm_mccoy
 
Creating agovernment1
Creating agovernment1Creating agovernment1
Creating agovernment1historyhokie
 

What's hot (19)

Bundle of Compromises - Civics & Economics
Bundle of Compromises - Civics & EconomicsBundle of Compromises - Civics & Economics
Bundle of Compromises - Civics & Economics
 
Chapter 9
Chapter 9Chapter 9
Chapter 9
 
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)
Principles of the Constitution (USHC 1.5)
 
The U.S. Constitution: Framing, Principles, & Ratification
The U.S. Constitution:  Framing, Principles, & RatificationThe U.S. Constitution:  Framing, Principles, & Ratification
The U.S. Constitution: Framing, Principles, & Ratification
 
Lesson 2 Philadelphia Convention
Lesson 2 Philadelphia ConventionLesson 2 Philadelphia Convention
Lesson 2 Philadelphia Convention
 
Review Power Point
Review  Power  PointReview  Power  Point
Review Power Point
 
Lecture 6 (2 )
Lecture 6 (2 )Lecture 6 (2 )
Lecture 6 (2 )
 
Constitutional Underpinnings & Ratification
Constitutional Underpinnings & RatificationConstitutional Underpinnings & Ratification
Constitutional Underpinnings & Ratification
 
Govt 2306 ch_5
Govt 2306 ch_5Govt 2306 ch_5
Govt 2306 ch_5
 
Chapter 11 government notes
Chapter 11 government notesChapter 11 government notes
Chapter 11 government notes
 
Constitutional Convention Powerpoint
Constitutional Convention PowerpointConstitutional Convention Powerpoint
Constitutional Convention Powerpoint
 
The Hartford Convention
The Hartford ConventionThe Hartford Convention
The Hartford Convention
 
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]
3. shaping a new nation [1782 1788]
 
Chapter 02
Chapter 02Chapter 02
Chapter 02
 
Federalism the division of power
Federalism  the division of powerFederalism  the division of power
Federalism the division of power
 
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]
3.2 launching the new nation [1789 1816]
 
Constitutional convention
Constitutional conventionConstitutional convention
Constitutional convention
 
9.4
9.49.4
9.4
 
Creating agovernment1
Creating agovernment1Creating agovernment1
Creating agovernment1
 

Viewers also liked

Making of my contents
Making of my contentsMaking of my contents
Making of my contentsMitchElsey
 
El calentamiento global
El calentamiento globalEl calentamiento global
El calentamiento globalLuciatc
 
Estadística y tic´s 3
Estadística y tic´s 3Estadística y tic´s 3
Estadística y tic´s 3anitavqr92
 
Doing The Right Thing:
Doing The Right Thing:Doing The Right Thing:
Doing The Right Thing:BASPCAN
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Making of my contents
Making of my contentsMaking of my contents
Making of my contents
 
Test ppt
Test pptTest ppt
Test ppt
 
El calentamiento global
El calentamiento globalEl calentamiento global
El calentamiento global
 
Estadística y tic´s 3
Estadística y tic´s 3Estadística y tic´s 3
Estadística y tic´s 3
 
Desarrollo humano
Desarrollo humanoDesarrollo humano
Desarrollo humano
 
Doing The Right Thing:
Doing The Right Thing:Doing The Right Thing:
Doing The Right Thing:
 

Similar to 14 attachment-i-thomas-maddock-1931-–-from-an-address-to-the-western-governors1

Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdf
Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdfUnit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdf
Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdfGiulianyAlejandroPor
 
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to Success
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to SuccessKnowledge and Courage: The Keys to Success
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to SuccessAmerican Lands Council
 
Reconconstruction
ReconconstructionReconconstruction
Reconconstructionicteacher
 
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentation
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentationThe reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentation
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentationMaxHernndez11
 
The Basics of the Transfer of Public Landes
The Basics of the Transfer of Public LandesThe Basics of the Transfer of Public Landes
The Basics of the Transfer of Public LandesAmerican Lands Council
 
Tpl overview slides
Tpl overview slidesTpl overview slides
Tpl overview slidesalecoutreach
 
Goal 3.04 and 3.05 reconstruction
Goal 3.04 and 3.05   reconstructionGoal 3.04 and 3.05   reconstruction
Goal 3.04 and 3.05 reconstructionDave Phillips
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstructionseanwsimon
 
Reconstruction 1865 1876
Reconstruction 1865 1876Reconstruction 1865 1876
Reconstruction 1865 1876MrCurtis2
 
The Politics of Reconstruction
The Politics of ReconstructionThe Politics of Reconstruction
The Politics of ReconstructionMatthew Caggia
 

Similar to 14 attachment-i-thomas-maddock-1931-–-from-an-address-to-the-western-governors1 (20)

Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
Reconstruction
Reconstruction Reconstruction
Reconstruction
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdf
Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdfUnit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdf
Unit 3 Lesson 6 - Politics and plans for reconstruction.pdf
 
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to Success
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to SuccessKnowledge and Courage: The Keys to Success
Knowledge and Courage: The Keys to Success
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
5 section 2
5 section 25 section 2
5 section 2
 
Reconconstruction
ReconconstructionReconconstruction
Reconconstruction
 
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentation
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentationThe reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentation
The reconstruction era ch 12-1.pptx power point presentation
 
The Only Solution Big Enough
The Only Solution Big EnoughThe Only Solution Big Enough
The Only Solution Big Enough
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
The Basics of the Transfer of Public Landes
The Basics of the Transfer of Public LandesThe Basics of the Transfer of Public Landes
The Basics of the Transfer of Public Landes
 
Tpl overview slides
Tpl overview slidesTpl overview slides
Tpl overview slides
 
Goal 3.04 and 3.05 reconstruction
Goal 3.04 and 3.05   reconstructionGoal 3.04 and 3.05   reconstruction
Goal 3.04 and 3.05 reconstruction
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 
Reconstruction 1865 1876
Reconstruction 1865 1876Reconstruction 1865 1876
Reconstruction 1865 1876
 
The Politics of Reconstruction
The Politics of ReconstructionThe Politics of Reconstruction
The Politics of Reconstruction
 
1412
14121412
1412
 
Reconstruction
ReconstructionReconstruction
Reconstruction
 

More from American Lands Council

Wayne County Utah Resolution of Support
Wayne County Utah Resolution of SupportWayne County Utah Resolution of Support
Wayne County Utah Resolution of SupportAmerican Lands Council
 
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148American Lands Council
 
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015American Lands Council
 
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015American Lands Council
 
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015American Lands Council
 
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the West
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the WestPERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the West
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the WestAmerican Lands Council
 
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of Support
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of SupportSportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of Support
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of SupportAmerican Lands Council
 
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015American Lands Council
 
Mineral county, MT Resolution of Support
Mineral county, MT Resolution of SupportMineral county, MT Resolution of Support
Mineral county, MT Resolution of SupportAmerican Lands Council
 
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013American Lands Council
 
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the Transfer
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the TransferSt. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the Transfer
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the TransferAmerican Lands Council
 
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal Condition
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal ConditionLincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal Condition
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal ConditionAmerican Lands Council
 

More from American Lands Council (20)

FreeTheLands Candidate Pledge 2016
FreeTheLands Candidate Pledge 2016   FreeTheLands Candidate Pledge 2016
FreeTheLands Candidate Pledge 2016
 
Final Agency Decision
Final Agency DecisionFinal Agency Decision
Final Agency Decision
 
Wayne County Utah Resolution of Support
Wayne County Utah Resolution of SupportWayne County Utah Resolution of Support
Wayne County Utah Resolution of Support
 
ALC Booklet Small Version
ALC Booklet Small VersionALC Booklet Small Version
ALC Booklet Small Version
 
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148
Sutherland Legal Analysis of UT HB 148
 
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015
ALC Presentation by Sen. Fielder, Cortez, CO - May 18, 2015
 
Opportunity to Stand for Something
Opportunity to Stand for SomethingOpportunity to Stand for Something
Opportunity to Stand for Something
 
ALC Foundation Booklet
ALC Foundation BookletALC Foundation Booklet
ALC Foundation Booklet
 
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015
TPL Presentation: Washington State, April 2015
 
Open Office Manager Position
Open Office Manager PositionOpen Office Manager Position
Open Office Manager Position
 
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015
Oregon Transfer of public Lands Presentation March 2015
 
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the West
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the WestPERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the West
PERC Divided Lands: State vs. Federal Land Management in the West
 
Klamath County Oregon Resolution
Klamath County Oregon ResolutionKlamath County Oregon Resolution
Klamath County Oregon Resolution
 
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of Support
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of SupportSportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of Support
Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife Dixie Chapter, Resolution of Support
 
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015
Quartzsite, AZ Resolution of Support, 2015
 
Mineral county, MT Resolution of Support
Mineral county, MT Resolution of SupportMineral county, MT Resolution of Support
Mineral county, MT Resolution of Support
 
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013
Town of Eagar, AZ resolution Oct. 1, 2013
 
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the Transfer
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the TransferSt. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the Transfer
St. George, UT Chamber of Commerce Letters in Support of the Transfer
 
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal Condition
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal ConditionLincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal Condition
Lincoln County MT's Delicate Fiscal Condition
 
Presentation Request Form
Presentation Request FormPresentation Request Form
Presentation Request Form
 

14 attachment-i-thomas-maddock-1931-–-from-an-address-to-the-western-governors1

  • 1. A Plan for Transfer of the Public Lands Excerpts taken from the 1932 Congressional Hearings on Granting Remaining Unreserved Public Lands to the States. “It is futile to criticize without suggesting a remedy. This nation today is ruled by organized minorities. That we do not like this system of government is no reason why we should not use it if it is our only recourse. Bureaus can not exist without appropriations. The Representatives from the western states are comparatively too few in number, and perhaps too anxious to have the Bureaus expend funds in their districts to offer much hope of curbing the Bureaus, but the eleven public land states have twenty-­‐two Senators and the Senate must approve all Bureau appropriations. A little group of about half this number have been the balance of power in the United States Senate for the last decade. If fifteen or twenty of the western Senators will unite on any fair policy for the local control of western lands they can insure its adoption. “The Governors of the western states possess the most powerful peace time weapon, publicity. If you gentlemen will unite on a policy of resistence to further Federal encroachment, and the curtailment of present superfluous activity by the Federal Government in affairs that should be handled by officials answerable to the people at the polls, and will arouse the citizens of your commonwealth your Senators will be glad to carry out the wishes of your people, and the control of the lands and resources of your states will be vested where they were intended to be, in the hands of those without whose adjacent residency they would be worthless. Lands and resources have always been obtained or retained by fighting. Human nature has not changed. If the West desires to control its own resources it must fight to do so.” Thomas Maddock, from a 1931 address to the Western Governors, added the 1932 Congressional Record in the hearings on Granting Remaining Unreserved Public Lands to the States. Born in Roanoke, Va. in 1883, Thomas Maddock first came to Arizona in 1898 from Newcastle, Pa. A Republican from Coconino County, he was elected to the first Arizona Legislature and later served as Secretary and State Chairman of the Arizona Republican Party. He served as Arizona State Highway Engineer from 1917-­‐1922, and was a member of the Colorado River Commission from 1923 to 1928.