1. 02 2005
$ 9 .7 5
A P U B L I C AT I O N O F T H E M C G R A W - H I L L C O M PA N I E S
w w w. a rc h it e ct u ra l re c o rd . c o m
Scottish Parliament:
Enric Miralles’s
Bittersweet Achievement
James Cutler
Interview With the Architect
PLUS
Interiors Section and Luxury Retail
TLFeBOOK
2. CEILING SYSTEMS
[ Between us, ideas become reality.™]
image matters.
Every institution of higher learning has a signature space that tells the world who they are. Presenting
an aesthetic, innovative and sophisticated sense of a school has never been easier with Armstrong
ceilings. Whether it’s the natural elegance of WoodWorks, the creative exuberance of MetalWorks™ or
™
™
the unexpected playfulness of Infusions accent canopies, you can make a statement with high visual
impact. See for yourself how Armstrong ceilings can help take higher education to new heights.
1-877-ARMSTRONG armstrong.com/ceilings
TLFeBOOK
3. the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania
CIRCLE 1 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
9. crank
it up Continental terminal
at Cleveland Hopkins
International Airport.
Architect: The Smith
Group. Glass fabricated
by Oldcastle Glass®.
Way up! Because with Oldcastle Glass’® sound-resistant glazing it will stay
nice and quiet inside. That’s due to our sound dampening interlayers that
result in a 50% reduction in perceived noise levels. That’s great news for
architects and designers faced with shielding a building’s interior from
increasing exterior noise. Think—airport terminals, building
facades in hectic cities or any building adjacent bustling highways.
And sound-resistant glazing is merely the beginning of the most
comprehensive collection of architectural glass products According to the
U.S. Department of
available anywhere. Call 1-866-653-2278 for more information Transportation, noise
levels have risen at an
or to speak with an architectural glass specialist, or visit us unprecedented rate
at the new www.oldcastleglass.com and do more with glass. over the past 30 years.
Our sound-resistant
interlayers can reduce
those levels up to 50%.
Where glass becomes architecture TM
CIRCLE 4 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
14. CIRCLE 7 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
15. 02.2005
On the Cover: Scottish Parliament, by EMBT and RMJM. Photograph by Duccio Malagamba
Right: 21st Century Museum, by Kazuyo Sejima + Ryue Nishizawa/SANAA. Photograph by Hiro Sakaguchi
News Building Types Study 842
33 2005 AIA Honor Awards 123 Introduction: Retail by Sara Hart
38 Rebuilding after the tsunami 124 Prada, California by Joseph Giovannini*
Office for Metropolitan Architecture OMA-AMO
Departments 132 Barneys New York, Japan by Raul A. Barreneche*
17 Editorial: Tsunami Jeffrey Hutchison & Associates
19 Letters* 136 Fornarina, Nevada by Suzanne Stephens*
45 Dates & Events* Giorgio Borruso Design
51 Archrecord2: For the emerging architect by Randi Greenberg* For additional retail projects, go to Building Types
55 Corrspondent’s File: Beijing 798 by Liane Lefaivre Study at architecturalrecord.com.
59 Critique: D.C.’s Museum of the American Indian by Michael Sorkin
63 Books: Rooting Modernism in the soil of local identity Architectural Technology
69 Snapshot: Puppet Theater by Beth Broome 143 The Art and Science of Peace and Quiet by Sara Hart*
235 Record House of the Month by Deborah Snoonian, P.E.* Pursuing noise control, architects and engineers search high and low.
152 Tech Briefs by John Pastier*
Features
72 Jim Cutler Interview by Robert Ivy, FAIA Interiors
An architect discusses his ideas, influences, and working style. 187 Introduction
188 Family Room, J. Paul Getty Museum by Allison Milionis
Projects Predock_Frane Architects
80 Rheinisches Landesmuseum, Germany by Philip Jodidio* 194 RenSt Loft by Linda Hallam
Architektengruppe Stuttgart Herbert Lewis Kruse Blunck Architecture
A renovation brings cohesion to Bonn’s fragmented, aging museum. 198 Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh by Jennifer Lucchino
88 21st Century Museum, Japan by Naomi R. Pollock, AIA* EDGE studio
Kazuyo Sejima + Ryue Nishizawa/SANAA
205 Belgium Design Show Interiors Products by Josephine Minutillo
A cluster of abstract white boxes rise from a massive glass circle.
98 Scottish Parliament, Scotland by David Cohn*
Enric Miralles Benedetta Tagliabue/EMBT and RMJM
Products
With a big price, big delays, and big ambition, the Parliament arrives. 209 Acoustics
112 Art Center College of Design, California by Joseph Giovannini* 213 Product Briefs
Daly Genik 220 Product Literature
Aircraft-testing wind tunnel gets a second life as educational facility.
116 Hangil Book House, South Korea by Clifford A. Pearson* 224 Reader Service* 224 AIA/CES Self-Report Form*
SHoP Architects + Architecture Himma
North of Seoul, the Heyri Art Valley spawns a bookshop.
* You can find these stories at www.architecturalrecord.com, including expanded coverage of Projects, Building Types Studies, and Web-only special features.
The AIA/ARCHITECTURAL RECORD
Continuing-Education Opportunity is “The Art and Science of Peace and Quiet” (page 143).
02.05 Architectural Record 13
TLFeBOOK
18. Karakul, part of the Second Nature Collection from Invision. For samples visit www.invisioncarpet.com or call 800.241.4586.
CIRCLE 9 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
20. Italian works of Art around the World.
There are many works of art by Italians that are not found in museums. Since the dawn of civilization,
Italians have created and exported some of their most lasting works of art in Natural Stone: statues,
mosaics, floors, balustrades, columns, countertops, stairs and facades found in buildings around the
world. PIETRA NATURALE is recognized as the highest quality of Italian Craftsmanship and stone pro-
cessing technology. Look for our PIETRA NATURALE trademark as your assurance of an Italian work
of art in Natural Stone – the perfect encounter between man and nature.
www.pietranaturale.com
CIRCLE 10 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
21. Letters
Modern traditions Balancing this “refined, respect- Measured words A garden gone to seed
DEPARTMENTS
The December issue of RECORD is ful urban solution” with pages of I thought that your coverage of the It is possible to cavil in some fashion
quite a bonanza. The projects individualistic zoots and zaps affirms newly reopened Museum of Modern about any good architectural effort,
shown, from the Aga Khan Awards the full range of architecture’s current Art and its architect, Yoshio Taniguchi, and there is much to admire in the
to a global survey of young firms power. Of course we need the new, was superb [January 2005, page latest iteration of the Museum of
to detailed technological reports but to advance the built environment 95]. While I might have disagree- Modern Art [January 2005, page
from the universities, illustrate the we have to appreciate architecture’s ments with some of the points made, 95]. It is its interior restraint and
breadth of professional activity. origins and understand how to relate I found the article very balanced deference to the art which is par-
Enjoying this strong presenta- its past accomplishments to contem- and thoughtful. As both Suzanne ticularly admirable in this age of
tion of the new and spectacular, I porary need. In cities, we build upon Stephens and Robert Ivy are well architectural muscle flexing.
particularly appreciated your com- a great legacy, and to ignore it dimin- acquainted with the institution, their However, even here there seems
ments on Taniguchi’s work at MoMA ishes our contribution to the whole. comments went well beyond formal to be one significant problem.
[Editorial, page 17]. Isn’t it interest- So let future cities enjoy analysis, giving your readers—myself I, personally, will never forgive
ing that he could use Modernism streets filled with all manner of included—a more nuanced and the virtual total destruction of one
to engage in such a sophisticated “faceted, spiral crystalline exten- more informative take on the build- of the most beautiful gardens any-
dialogue with existing buildings and sions” and tectonic shifts, but let ing, the collection, and the institution where. In place of a Zen-like oasis
traditions? Since Modernism is sup- these new creations not obscure than has been printed elsewhere. from urban cacophony, of great
posed to be the enemy of context the crucial architectural dialogue Terence Riley visual variation and beauty in the
and the urban environment, it is between generations. The Philip Johnson Chief Curator, intimate interplay of water, sculp-
edifying to see how a skilled artist Hugh Hardy, FAIA Architecture and Design ture, and trees, we now have one
uses its vocabulary to reveal rather H3 Hardy Collaboration Architecture The Museum of Modern Art more urban plaza, one that is over-
than reject the city. New York City New York City hung by two hulking hoods that
Let our new series of
recessed architectural
Give your light new direction. products light the way.
Their compact design
blends into virtually any
installation. Each faceplate
is machined from solid
copper-free aluminum,
brass, or stainless steel billet
to provide decades of
performance under tough,
outdoor conditions. Two
housing styles allow for
installation in new
construction or retrofit
projects.
Featuring precision-milled,
louver designs available in
round or rectangular
patterns, with 0 or 30
degree cutoff angles to
direct light precisely where
you need it. Even the
lamp adjusts behind the
faceplate to optimize its
distribution to your
requirements. Choose
from round, square or
rectangular faceplates in
more than 200 finishes.
559.438.5800 • www.bklighting.com
CIRCLE 11 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
22. Letters Corrections
In the review of Jazz at Lincoln
January’s criticism of the Museum
of Modern Art [page 95] inadver-
Center [January 2005, page 146], tently omitted the fourth-floor plan.
the photo of David Rockwell’s The cost for Millennium Park’s
look like architectural versions of a Thanks for the memories Ertegun Jazz Hall of Fame was Jay Pritzker Pavilion in Chicago
nun’s habit and add, with their I was delighted to see Ulrich miscredited—it should be credited [January 2005, page 136] was
shadows, to a gloom that overlies Franzen’s home celebrating 50 to Michael Moran/Rockwell Group. misquoted in the article’s sidebar—
and enervates the character of the years of Record Houses [January The news article on Louis Kahn’s it should have been cited as
garden. The meager efforts at a 2005, page 255]. It brought back Yale Center For British Art winning $60.3 million. A project by the
change of level do nothing to con- many memories. the AIA 25 Year Award [January Vanguard firm Plasma Studio
tain or define the original precincts My first summer job was with 2005, page 26] incorrectly stated [December 2004, page 175]
of the garden, which gave it much Rick. Sixteen years later, Ezra Stoller that James Williamson, AIA, and was mislabled: The images are of
of its intimacy. photographed my house and it Louis Pounders, FAIA, were on the Hotel Puerta America in Madrid,
The visually flimsy lid over the became a Record House of 1972. 1978 jury that handed out the not of UrbaNite in London.
first floor of the south wall is the I was still Rick’s associate at the building’s AIA Honor Award. In Photographs of the University
icing on the cake. Instead of letting time. Then Barbara Anderson, AIA fact, the two nominated the project Health Network/The Toronto
the three-step “waterfall” of the cur- (my partner in more ways than one), on behalf of the Committee on Hospital New Clinical Services
tain wall come gracefully to ground and I started our own practice. Design for the 25 Year Award in Building in November 2004’s
uninterrupted, this irrelevancy inter- Our house was also a very 2004, not the original award in Business Week/Architectural
feres with and complicates a good Minimalist solution (I called it the 1978. Gladnick Wright Salameda Record Awards coverage
and simple gesture that otherwise back-of-the-truck-and-local-lumber- was the civil engineer for [page 142] were miscredited.
would have been in keeping with the yard aesthetic). Most important, it has Swarthmore College’s Unified The photographer was Ben
restraint of the interior. wonderful spaces, light, and views to Science Center [December 2004, Rahn/A-Frame Studio.
Perhaps it is the generally its surrounding unusual “Adirondack” page 198], not the landscape
high quality of the rest that makes landscape in Rye, New York. architect. Two photographs of
these things more offensive than Allan Anderson, AIA Brandeis University’s Shapiro
they might otherwise have been. Anderson LaRocca Anderson Campus Center [December 2004,
Allen Trousdale, AIA Haynes Architects page 178] should have been
via e-mail Rye, N.Y. credited to John Edward Linden. Write to rivy@mcgraw-hill.com.
50 Years of
Innovation!
…Light-Years Ahead! TM
The leader in daylighting.
The most highly insulating fenestration…
LEED TM credit Contribution in 6 separate
catergories.
Now… with Super-Insulating Nanogel ®.
Fletcher Priest Architects; Chris Gascoigue/View Photo
800-258-9777 (N. America)
See more at kalwall.com
For monumental, translucent clearspan skyroof
systems, consider our affiliated company…
And for tensioned fabric structures…
SPAN SYSTEMS, INC.
CIRCLE 12 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
24. B u i l d i t t h e way
M o t h e r N a t u r e i n t e n d e d.
Marble. Granite. Limestone. Travertine. Slate. firms are the most highly skilled stone quarriers, fabricators,
Sandstone. No manmade material can match the enduring and installers in the world. And MIA’s Dimension Stone
beauty, permanence, versatility, and value of natural stone. Design Manual is the most authoritative technical reference
And no one knows more about natural stone than on natural stone selection, application, and installation.
the members of the Marble Institute of America (MIA). So whether you’re designing hotels or homes,
MIA sets the industry’s standards for excellence in the kitchens or cathedrals, MIA can help you build it better
fabrication and installation of natural stone. MIA member with nature’s own, natural stone.
Get MIA’s Dimension Stone Design Manual for just $99 (architects-only price).
Call MIA at (440) 250-9222 or go to www.marble-institute.com.
Setting the Standards in the Natural Stone Industry
CIRCLE 14 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
27. Record News
Seura’s plan includes a simple garden at ground
level (left and below), and a sophisticated and
naturally lit shopping area underground (bottom).
Long-awaited redesign
unveiled for Paris’s Les Halles
The French firm Seura, headed by architect “soulless” and “concrete surroundings” that existed
David Mangin, has been selected to redesign on the site. Problems with Les Halles have included
the much-maligned Les Halles quarter in Paris. difficult pedestrian access and circulation patterns;
Seura defeated three other notable firms—AJN the absence of natural light in underground spaces;
(Architectures Jean Nouvel), MVRDV (Winy Maas), and a sense of disconnection between street level
and OMA (Rem Koolhaas)—in the final stage of spaces, the underground complex, and the park.
an international competition that was launched “At the moment, Les Halles is a quarter that
in March 2003. Seura's design will see the com- is avoided, especially at night,” says Mangin, who
plete redevelopment of the area of pedestrianized wants it to become a more attractive place for
streets, a park, an underground shopping and leisure, like the Tuileries or the nearby Pompidou
leisure complex, and an underground transport hub. Center. “We have to learn some lessons,” says
The $267 million plan includes a 72-foot- Mangin, “which means not finding ourselves in
wide avenue cutting through the rectangular the same situation in 30 years. In terms of form,
Les Halles site, dividing a wide grassy area on materials, and usage, the project must last.”
one side and seating areas and pathways on Mangin further proposes “to open up the station
the other. The path will connect the domed Bourse and to light it naturally, in such a way as to allow
du Commerce (commodities exchange) and a the hundreds of thousands of daily users to find
redesigned Forum des Halles, a sunken shopping, their way, to know where they are, and to find a
cinema, and theater complex. A 26-foot-high flat requisite minimum of hospitality.”
glass canopy, measuring 476 feet by 476 feet, will Seura’s scheme, many have noted, was
cover the underground shopping levels and sub- the most conservative of the finalists’ designs.
way interchange. (A separate competition is to be Nouvel’s entry included several acres of woodland
I M A G E S : C O U R T E SY S E U R A A R C H I T E CT E S
launched for the design of this canopy.) and elevated parks. Winy Maas placed a 115-foot-
Seura’s redevelopment plan calls for bulldoz- high hall at the heart of his project, with colored
ing the existing glass, steel, and concrete buildings, glass decks allowing natural light to filter into
built by Claude Vasconi and Georges Penreach in underground spaces. Koolhaas’s project included
the 1970s on the site of the old Les Halles flower, tapering towers of multicolored glass that pro-
meat, and vegetable market. In the late 1960s, jected up through the ground. Still, Paul Chemetov,
the market was relocated to a Parisian suburb, and architect of the Forum des Halles shopping center
the 19th-century glass-and-cast-iron pavilions extension, calls the winning plan, which involves
were demolished. In 2001, Paris Mayor Bertrand the least disruption to the urban fabric, “not the
Delanoë announced his wish to find a project least conservative, but the least destructive.” The
that “improves the living conditions of thousands provisional start date for construction is 2006, and
of inhabitants [of Les Halles]” and replaces the completion is set for 2012. Robert Such
TLFeBOOK
29. CIRCLE 16 ON READER SERVICE CARD OR GO
TO ARCHRECORD.CONSTRUCTION.COM/PRODUCTS/
TLFeBOOK
30. Record News
In Philadelphia, a hidden gem will soon assume the spotlight
The City of Philadelphia’s grand cultural thorough- Opponents include a team of three Barnes stu-
fare, the Benjamin Franklin Parkway, is now poised dents and their lawyer, who attempted to stop
to become a globally significant concentration of the move based on what they interpreted as a
cultural treasures. On December 13, a suburban violation of Dr. Barnes’s wishes. Other critics of
Philadelphia court judge ruled in favor of the subur- the charter change include several arts writers,
ban-based Barnes Foundation’s two-year effort to who argue that the ruling will negatively impact
change its charter (not founder Dr. Albert Barnes’s the future of donor bequests. They also accuse
will) and relocate its cash-strapped institution from the city and its leadership of attempting to make
its 79-year, Paul Cret–designed the parkway into a tourist trap.
home in Merion, Pennsylvania, to In response to the ruling, on
a new facility on the parkway. December 14 Philadelphia Mayor
The relocation involves John Street announced that the
moving the institution’s famed city will raze a juvenile detention
multibillion-dollar collection center—the parkway’s eye-
of Impressionist and Post- sore—and give the site to the
Impressionist paintings and Barnes. The site is flanked by
artworks (half the collection has Paul Cret’s Rodin Museum and
not been publicly viewed in over the Free Library of Philadelphia,
50 years). The move is backed by which Moshe Safdie is renovat-
support from 30 donors, primarily ing and expanding. Other new
the Philadelphia-based Annenberg parkway neighbors include
Foundation, Lenfest Foundation, Barnes Foundation interior. Richard Gluckman’s renovation
and Pew Charitable Trusts, totaling and expansion of the Philadelphia
P H OTO G R A P H Y : C O U R T E SY T H E B A R N E S FO U N DAT I O N ( TO P ) ; R O B E R T A . M . S T E R N A R C H I T E CT S ( B OT TO M )
an estimated $150 million. Museum of Art’s new operations, library, and
Museum officials say the move will help the gallery complex and Tadao Ando’s planned
Barnes better realize the purpose Dr. Barnes Calder Museum. Director Kimberly Camp says
envisioned: to advance education through art the Barnes’s new building will maintain the lay-
appreciation, and to provide nondiscriminatory out of its present home, including the spatial
access to art and education. (Among other relationships and the institution’s signature
restrictions, Merion officials limited the Barnes’s arrangement of artwork. An architect has not yet
annual attendance to 62,000.) Many see the been selected, nor has a plan been developed.
move as an opportunity to transform the city. Joseph Dennis Kelly II
Stern’s Philadelphia tower finally moving forward
Four years after its original public announcement, giant. Once completed, in 2007, the center will
Robert Stern’s two-building office complex for rise 975 feet, looming above Philadelphia’s cur-
downtown Philadelphia—dubbed Pennsylvania rent tallest building by more than 30 feet and
Plaza—is finally beginning construction. The proj- forging a new icon onto the city’s skyline.
ect was able to move forward thanks to a $30 Stern’s design team has created an unem-
million state grant approved last month. bellished geometric form with a rectangular glass
Up first is the 57-story, $465 million glass box at its top, which Stern describes as a “clear
tower known as the Comcast Center, headquar- obelisk legible on all four sides.” Other highlights
ters for the Philadelphia telecommunications include a mammoth structural core, extending
from the interior and seemingly rising out of its
skin, and a 110-foot-high winter garden at its
base. Green elements include 13-foot floor-to-
ceiling heights channeling daylight through the
interior, and improved quality of air and air-flow
systems. Construction of the second building, an
18-story office structure, will commence at a later
date. Stern’s office is also designing a residential
The city’s skyline will have a new height champion. tower on the city’s Rittenhouse Square. J.D.K.
TLFeBOOK