This presentation was first delivered at Malaysian HR Congress held at Kuala Lampur. Presentation outlines:
Succession Planning - an introduction
Succession Planning @ family run business
An approach towards Succession Planning
Steps to effective Succession Planning
Identifying and nurturing Hi-Pos
Potential and Performance mix of a Hi-Pos
Putting success into Succession Planning
How to measure its effectiveness
Conclusion
2. www.vivekmehrotra.com
What if something happens to the CEO or to a
senior executive of my organization?
Who will replace him?
Will the new incumbent have the maturity and the
desired competence to execute all responsibilities?
Are people other than him, groomed enough to fill
the void that would be created by his absence?
3. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Charlie Bell, President and COO of McDonald,
succeeded Jim Cantalupo, CEO hours after the
sudden heart attack death
Mr. Zeien, succeeded Chairman and CEO Colman
M. Mockler of Gillette Co.'s when he died of a
heart attack in his office
The Wall Street Journal Online
4. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Session Outline
Succession Planning - an introduction
Succession Planning @ family run business
An approach towards Succession Planning
Steps to effective Succession Planning
Identifying and nurturing Hi-Pos
Potential and Performance mix of a Hi-Pos
Putting success into Succession Planning
How to measure its effectiveness
Conclusion
5. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning
Is not just a process to merely find a deputy or 2IC
It is a conscious process to ensure continuity of
Business Operations
Organization’s Policies
Organization’s Culture
6. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Organic Business Growth
Mergers
Acquisition
Promotions, Demotions & Transfers
Business Re-engineering
Succession Planning
“Global aging (Over the 1998 - 2008 period), more job openings
are expected to result from replacement needs (34.7 million)
than from employment growth in the economy (20.3 million)”
(Braddock, 1999)
8. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Getting the right number of people
with the right skills, experiences, &
competencies in the right jobs
at the right time.
Workforce Planning
Nancy B. Kiyonaga, NYS Department of Civil Service
9. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession planning ensures that there
are highly qualified members for all
important positions, not just today,
but tomorrow, next year, and
five years from now.
Succession Planning
Kathryn Towe Littleton
10. www.vivekmehrotra.com
What does an organization lose if it does
not implement succession planning?
Revenue?
Market Share?
Company’s Image?
Stock Prices or Market Cap?
Human Cap?
Workplace will lose high performers
Lack of skilled workforce that understand business well
Right skill mix for the future
Right leaders to accomplish organization’s Vision & Mission
11. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning = Commercial
Success
There is a direct correlation between:
Organization’s ability to develop senior executives
& Confidence to meet future growth needs
Organization’s ability to recruit highly able executives
& having well-organized program to develop Hi-Pos’
Developmental ‘stretch’ assignments within company
& the personal involvement of the CEO
Organization’s need to hire outside leaders
& Lack of confidence to meet future growth needs
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, VOL. 13 NO. 1 2005
12. www.vivekmehrotra.com
A process that ensures…
• Right people to lead tomorrow… who live the values,
today
• Organization identify / recruit future leaders
• Employees develop new competencies & skills
• Organization alerts its rising stars to potential
leadership opportunities; well in advance
Succession Planning… what is it?
13. www.vivekmehrotra.com
A process that ensures…
• Better talent retention
• Greater employee satisfaction
• Enhanced commitment to work by the employees
• Improved image of organization
Succession Planning… what is it?
14. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning… what isn't?
Succession Planning is similar to Workforce Planning
It’s an option with management to develop leadership
Succession Planning & Leadership Development are
Two different HR processes
Stand-alone activities coordinated by HR department
Line Managers do not have much role in Succession
Planning & Leadership Development
Lack of Succession Planning may not pose a similar
threat as accounting blunders or missed targets
15. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning: the reality
Most globally recognized Indian organizations are
not properly equipped with a sound succession plan
Very few Indian companies have been able to
effectively implement a succession plan for its
important and strategic positions
(A survey by the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India)
16. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @ Family
run businesses
More than half of the top 100 companies are family
owned
De-merger of business families, with trauma and
acrimony, is fairly common in India.
Reliance Industries – Mukesh & Anil Ambani
Bajaj Auto – Rahul & Shishir Bajaj
Escorts – Rajan & Anil Nanda
Jumbo Group – Bhavika, Kiran & Komal Chhabria
Sahad P.V. - Family Values
17. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @ Family
run businesses
Family run business groups, which dealt with
Succession issues successfully
Murugappa Group
Dabur India
Thapars
GMR Group
Sahad P.V. - Family Values
18. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @
GMR group’s Succession Plan
Clearly articulated set of rules to deal with
Management succession
Ownership succession
Control and power sharing
Sucheta Dalal, CHEQUES AND BALANCES
19. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Family Constitution
Family Business Board
Laid down policies on
Consensus in decision making
Media policy
Code of conduct
Process of inducting family members into the business
Providing benefits to those who do not want to enter the
business
Succession Planning @
20. www.vivekmehrotra.com
G M Rao to step down at the age of 70
Three next generation successors to decide next chairman
Dead lock trustee
Induction of family members is on merit and are paid on par
with other professionals employed
The economic benefits of shareholding will be separate
Succession Planning @
Sucheta Dalal, CHEQUES AND BALANCES
21. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @ Family
run businesses
Ownership Vs. Management
Family owns the controlling shares, but inducts
professional managers to run their business.
Retail giant
Rob Walton - Chairman
Lee Scott - CEO
"Successful business families are those who run
businesses as capitalists and families as socialists."
N. Srinivasan
22. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @
India's largest pharmaceutical company
1952, Bhai Mohan Singh founded Ranbaxy
1967, Dr Parvinder Singh, Bhai Mohan Singh's son, a
doctorate in pharmacy from the University of Michigan
joined the company
1982, he became the company's Managing Director
1993, D.S. Brar joined as Business Development Manager,
became the President (Pharmaceuticals) and a whole time
Director
ICFAI - Center for Management Research
23. www.vivekmehrotra.com
1997, Brar revealed his retirement plans to retire in
2002.
2003, Dr Brian Tempest (President, Pharmaceutical
Division, Ranbaxy) took the reigns of Ranbaxy from
Brar as CEO and MD
2006, Malvinder Singh has taken over as CEO & MD
Succession Planning @
India's largest pharmaceutical company
24. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @ Corporates
Long Term Succession Planning
Who is completing his term this year?
Who have the skills to replace this position?
Who has necessary skills & ready for a larger or a different role?
Short Term Succession Planning
Who needs immediate replacements?
Whose professional career demands relocation?
Who would like to choose other volunteer options?
25. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Department (A)
Key Position (1)
Key Position (2)
Department (B)
Key Position (1)
Key Position (2)
Department (C)
Key Position (1)
Key Position (2)
Current / Future Competencies and expected vacancies
Assessment & Evaluation to identify Hi-Pos
Profiling of Prospective Leaders
Individual development plans/Job rotation/Simulation workshops
Independent Assignment
Assessment of individual’s competency and skill gaps
Bottom - up Succession Planning
26. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Understand
organization's
long term goals &
objectives
Determine
Critical
Positions
Assess
individual’s
competency
and identify
skill gaps
Identify
current and
future
competencies
for positions
Identify
expected
vacancies
Evaluate
potential
candidates as
successor for
key positions
Determine the
individual’s
current
performance &
future potential
Design
individual’s
development
plans
Review
individual
development
plans to ensure
needs are
addressed
27. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Steps of Succession Planning
Follow-up
• Assist with leadership transition and development
• Develop & implement coaching and mentoring programs
• Develop an evaluation plan for succession management
• Monitor progress of succession candidates
28. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @
(Talent Review and Planning)
• Review of Business Strategy
• Identification of Critical Roles
• Stock of Talent Inventory
• Identification of Potential Successor
• Assess individual’s competency and identify skill gaps
• Individual Development Plan in terms of
• Job Rotation
• Training
• Coaching
• Performance Counseling
• Follow-up on individual development plans to ensure
that all developmental needs are addressed
Express computer online
29. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning @
(Talent Review and Planning)
Lifecycle leadership development programs
• New Leaders Program
• Wipro Leaders Program
• Business Leaders Program
• Strategic Leaders Program
31. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Performance
Performance is an assessment of Hi-Po’s
• Past Business results
• Past Performance review results
Identifies mainly the areas of low performance/weakness
• Build a poor image of the employee
• Minimal level of performance from Hi-Pos’ leading to
• Wasted resources
• Low morale
• Unsatisfactory performance
• Higher degrees of employee turnover
PotentialV/s.
32. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Potential is an assessment of Hi-Po’s
Willingness to perform
Open-mindedness
Personal Accountability
Willingness to learn from successes & failures
Performance V/s. Potential
33. www.vivekmehrotra.com
“Future work potential is based on accumulated skills
and experience as evidenced by past achievement,
ability to learn new skills and willingness to tackle
bigger, more complex or higher quality assignments.”
Charan, Drotter & Noel, The Leadership Pipeline, Jossey-Bass, SF, 2001
Performance V/s. Potential
35. www.vivekmehrotra.com
How to assess pool of Hi-Pos:
Negative feedback
Change in behavior based on the feedback or …
Learning from mistakes/successes in past
Hunt for new information for self development or to
improve workgroup
Learning & Demonstration of new skills
Development of Team mates
Performance V/s. Potential
leaders@jacksonleadership.com
36. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Performance V/s. Potential
H
L H
Performance
Potential
Competent / Capable
Needs Improvement
Plan exit
Long Term employee
New employee
Misfit in the position
High Performer in current role
Able to get things done
Recognize the technical expertise
Organize the transfer of knowledge
Performance role model
Lack ability to manage
Determine career aspirations
Assist in developing leadership skills
Misses performance expectations
Unorganized working
Identify if unhappy in current role
Create development plan
Performance below expectations
Rigidity in behavior
Recruitment error
Consider exit options
Average Performer in current role
Demonstrate desire to achieve
Provide training & coaching inputs
Recognize potential; offer support
Despite competence, performing low
Awareness about perf. deficit missing
Counseling to understand culture
Help him in setting priorities
Offer challenging stretch
assignments
Offer opportunities to develop
others
Jackson leadership
37. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Putting Success into Succession Planning
Management succession is a process and not an event
• Strong commitment of senior managers
• Process is to be owned by the line management
• Simple and tailored to unique organizational needs
• Flexible and linked with strategic business plans
• Evolved from a thorough human resources review process
• Based upon objective assessment of candidates
38. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Role of CEO & Senior Executives in
Succession Planning
Culture of coaching and mentorship
Focus on the company's competitive advantage and
sustainable growth
To withdraw from the key roles for short or even
medium-term periods
To take corrective steps in case of gaps arising due to
their withdrawal
39. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Role of CEO & Senior executives in
Succession Planning
CEO is a dispensable resource
" Take a bucket and fill it with water,
Put your hand in it right up to the wrist,
Pull it out and the hole that's remaining
Is a measure of how you will be missed"
"Indispensable Man"
Bryan Hattingh
40. www.vivekmehrotra.com
How to measure the effectiveness
of the Succession Planning
The number of senior positions filled internally
The overall retention figure
The leadership talent created and provided to
the industry
41. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Succession Planning - Check list
Within x months, assessment for all key departments and
positions will be completed
Within x months, developmental plan for all Hi-Pos will be
completed
By year 20xx, increase in job rotation of Hi-Pos’ by x%
By year 20xx, increase in Hi-Pos’ leaders by x%
Over x years, increase in Hi-Pos’ retention by x%
www.exceptionalleadership.com
42. www.vivekmehrotra.com
Conclusion
Succession Planning is as critical as creating a business
strategy
Succession Planning is as important as running the
business profitably
While identifying successors appropriate weightage needs
to be given to both performance and potential
For an effective implementation of Succession Planning
involvement of CEO and line managers is a must
Measuring the effectiveness of a succession planning
program is as critical as its implementation
Washout visual – Courtesy TOI