Enviar búsqueda
Cargar
The Ideal Muslim
•
0 recomendaciones
•
154 vistas
zakir2012
Seguir
Meditación
Denunciar
Compartir
Denunciar
Compartir
1 de 109
Descargar ahora
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Recomendados
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
mfahmy2010
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Aguas licença instalaçao fepam 398143 signed li
Aguas licença instalaçao fepam 398143 signed li
Arlei Karpinski
LN-04-2011
LN-04-2011
Sonja Veselinovi?
Manejo equipos laboratorio-conociendo equipos
Manejo equipos laboratorio-conociendo equipos
SENA
Seminars and Presentations
Seminars and Presentations
Upul Atukorala
Sanciones aduaneras
Sanciones aduaneras
Melissa Romero
CC Play - das 20. Jahrhundert zum Puzzeln
CC Play - das 20. Jahrhundert zum Puzzeln
Marcus Bösch
Recomendados
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
mfahmy2010
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Aguas licença instalaçao fepam 398143 signed li
Aguas licença instalaçao fepam 398143 signed li
Arlei Karpinski
LN-04-2011
LN-04-2011
Sonja Veselinovi?
Manejo equipos laboratorio-conociendo equipos
Manejo equipos laboratorio-conociendo equipos
SENA
Seminars and Presentations
Seminars and Presentations
Upul Atukorala
Sanciones aduaneras
Sanciones aduaneras
Melissa Romero
CC Play - das 20. Jahrhundert zum Puzzeln
CC Play - das 20. Jahrhundert zum Puzzeln
Marcus Bösch
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
Ekansh Singhal
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Ting Zhou
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Susana Correia da Silva
Aplicacion retazos
Aplicacion retazos
Julian Alzate
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Verónica Del Mar Vázquez Mirabal
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Richard Green
Wedding dress list
Wedding dress list
Ting Zhou
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
analoa14
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Sonam Dendup
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Γεωργιος Μακεδων
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
megaradioexpress
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
zakir2012
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
Sameera Arsheen
Muwatta malik
Muwatta malik
Light Upon Light
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
Benjamin G. Chapman
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
lagartiger
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
zakir2012
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
zakir2012
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
zakir2012
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
zakir2012
Más contenido relacionado
Destacado
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
Ekansh Singhal
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Ting Zhou
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Susana Correia da Silva
Aplicacion retazos
Aplicacion retazos
Julian Alzate
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Verónica Del Mar Vázquez Mirabal
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Richard Green
Wedding dress list
Wedding dress list
Ting Zhou
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
analoa14
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Sonam Dendup
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Γεωργιος Μακεδων
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
megaradioexpress
Destacado
(11)
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
ekanshsinghal-3 (1) (1)
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Bridesmaiddress20160920
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Como elaborar um CV e respetiva carta de cobertura
Aplicacion retazos
Aplicacion retazos
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Nuestra historia capítulo 10
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Evvnt investment deck gdp usd 2016-17
Wedding dress list
Wedding dress list
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
Formato 5-valoracic3b3n-de-productos
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Bhutanese culture influence learning skill
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Μέσα μετάδοσης
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
Sintesis informativa 09 de marzo 2017
Similar a The Ideal Muslim
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
MOHAMMED ARIF
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
zakir2012
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
Sameera Arsheen
Muwatta malik
Muwatta malik
Light Upon Light
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
Benjamin G. Chapman
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
lagartiger
Similar a The Ideal Muslim
(6)
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
Yusuf Ali English Quran Without Commentary
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
The Holy Quran Translation By Yusuf Ali
Muwatta malik
Muwatta malik
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
OutdoorHDTVHomebrochure_3_18 Small
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
Examen de matemáticas del tema 3 de 3º de diver de resolución gráfica de sist...
Más de zakir2012
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
zakir2012
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
zakir2012
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
zakir2012
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
zakir2012
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 1
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 1
zakir2012
Forty very easy, quick & rewarding good deeds for all of us to do everyday!
Forty very easy, quick & rewarding good deeds for all of us to do everyday!
zakir2012
Everything about durood sharief
Everything about durood sharief
zakir2012
Dua e-jameela very rewarding dua equal to many pilgremages worth checking
Dua e-jameela very rewarding dua equal to many pilgremages worth checking
zakir2012
Complete guide to ramadhan
Complete guide to ramadhan
zakir2012
Collection of durood sharief english, arabic translation and transliteration
Collection of durood sharief english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
30. durood e-malwaan english, arabic translation and transliteration
30. durood e-malwaan english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
29. durood virtues of 1000 days english, arabic translation and transliteration
29. durood virtues of 1000 days english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
27. durood salaatul sa’aadat english, arabic translation and transliteration
27. durood salaatul sa’aadat english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
26. durood didaar e-mustapha english, arabic translation and transliteration
26. durood didaar e-mustapha english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
25. durood e-radawiyya english, arabic translation and transliteration
25. durood e-radawiyya english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
24. durood e-haq english, arabic translation and transliteration
24. durood e-haq english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
23. durood e-da’im english, arabic translation and transliteration
23. durood e-da’im english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
20. durood e-awal english, arabic translation and transliteration
20. durood e-awal english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
18. durood e-shifa english, arabic translation and transliteration
18. durood e-shifa english, arabic translation and transliteration
zakir2012
Más de zakir2012
(20)
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
1. durood e-ibrahimi english, arabic translation and transliteration
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday! part 1
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
Very rewarding nafl salaahs we can pray everyday part 2
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
Selected adhkaar situations & supplications
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 5
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 1
Genuine authentic durood sharief from hadith 1
Forty very easy, quick & rewarding good deeds for all of us to do everyday!
Forty very easy, quick & rewarding good deeds for all of us to do everyday!
Everything about durood sharief
Everything about durood sharief
Dua e-jameela very rewarding dua equal to many pilgremages worth checking
Dua e-jameela very rewarding dua equal to many pilgremages worth checking
Complete guide to ramadhan
Complete guide to ramadhan
Collection of durood sharief english, arabic translation and transliteration
Collection of durood sharief english, arabic translation and transliteration
30. durood e-malwaan english, arabic translation and transliteration
30. durood e-malwaan english, arabic translation and transliteration
29. durood virtues of 1000 days english, arabic translation and transliteration
29. durood virtues of 1000 days english, arabic translation and transliteration
27. durood salaatul sa’aadat english, arabic translation and transliteration
27. durood salaatul sa’aadat english, arabic translation and transliteration
26. durood didaar e-mustapha english, arabic translation and transliteration
26. durood didaar e-mustapha english, arabic translation and transliteration
25. durood e-radawiyya english, arabic translation and transliteration
25. durood e-radawiyya english, arabic translation and transliteration
24. durood e-haq english, arabic translation and transliteration
24. durood e-haq english, arabic translation and transliteration
23. durood e-da’im english, arabic translation and transliteration
23. durood e-da’im english, arabic translation and transliteration
20. durood e-awal english, arabic translation and transliteration
20. durood e-awal english, arabic translation and transliteration
18. durood e-shifa english, arabic translation and transliteration
18. durood e-shifa english, arabic translation and transliteration
The Ideal Muslim
1.
7KH0XVOLP,GHDO
5HYLVHG QG(GLWLRQ 7KH7UXH,VODPLF3HUVRQDOLW $V'HILQHGLQWKH4XU·DQDQGWKH6XQQDK õÇ ¡ ¢ ãÐ ¢øïöôÈm¡¨Ð¼Ë ”è´ß페ÜßòÓ 'U0XKDPPDGµ$OLDO+DVKLPL 7UDQVODWHGE 1DVLUXGGLQDO.KDWWDE 5HYLVHGE ,EUDKLP0.XQQD $QG $EX$D6XODLPDQµ$EGXV6DEXU ¾¯ÈÅY[Zdº¨«Y`ºÀ°«Z˜«YyYv«Y ,QWHUQDWLRQDO,VODPLF3XEOLVKLQJ+RXVH ,,3 H
2.
3XEOLVKHU¶V1RWH
$OO 3UDLVH LV IRU $OOK ,
3.
5DEE /RUG
4.
RI WKH ZRUOGV
DQG SHDFH DQG SUDHUV EH XSRQ 0XKDPPDG 7
5.
KLVIDPLODQGFRPSDQLRQVDQGDOOWKRVHZKRIROORZLQWKHLUIRRWVWHSVXQWLOWKH/DVW'D
7KHµ,GHDO0XVOLP¶LVQRZLQLWVVHFRQGUHYLVHGHGLWLRQLQ(QJOLVK/LNHWKHµ,GHDO0XVOLPDK¶LWKDV EHHQYHUZHOOUHFHLYHGERXU(QJOLVKDQG$UDELFUHDGHUV,WVSRSXODULWLVEDVHGRQWKHIDFWWKDW'UDO +VKLP¯ KDV GHDOW ZLWK WKH YDULRXV WRSLFV LQ D FRPSOHWH DQG FRPSUHKHQVLYH ZD +H KDV EURXJKW FRQFOXVLYHUHIHUHQFHVIURPWKH4XU¶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¶V SHDFH DQG EOHVVLQJV EH XSRQ WKH 3URSKHW 7
6.
KLVIDPLODQGFRPSDQLRQV
I
7.
7KH ,GHDO 0XVOLP
LV D PDQ RI WKH KLJKHVW PRUDO FKDUDFWHU ,Q KLV UHODWLRQVKLS ZLWK +LV 5DEEKLPVHOIIDPLOSDUHQWVUHODWLYHVIULHQGVDQGWKHFRPPXQLWDWODUJH KHKDVDPRVW H[FHOOHQW H[DPSOH LQ WKH 3URSKHW RI ,VOP 7KLV LGHDO LV IXUWKHU VWUHQJWKHQHG E WKH FKDUDFWHUV RI WKH ILUVW JHQHUDWLRQV RI 0XVOLPV ZKR H[FHOOHG LQ DOO WKH YDULRXV ILHOGV RI KXPDQHQGHDYRXU+HLVUHDVVXUHGIURPWKHWHDFKLQJVRI,VOPWKDWKHDOVRFDQUHDFKWKHVH QREOHKHLJKWVEZRUNLQJWRLPSURYHKLVFKDUDFWHUGDLO 7KLV FRPSUHKHQVLYH ZRUN E 'U DO+VKLP¯ LV D YDOXDEOH FRQWULEXWLRQ IRU RXU (QJOLVK UHDGHUV+HZURWHDQRWKHUERRNRQWKH,GHDO0XVOLPDKIHPDOH0XVOLP
8.
DQGRXUUHDGHUV DUHLQYLWHGWRUHDGERWKWLWOHVIRUWKHUHDVRQWKDWWKHVHWZRERRNVFRPSOHPHQWHDFKRWKHU 0D$OOK,
9.
KHOSXVDOOLQPDNLQJWKHVHSXUHWHDFKLQJVDSDUWRIRXUOLIH 7KH2WKHU7LWOHLQWKLV6HULHVLV E 7KH,GHDO0XVOLPDK
J
10.
7UDQVODWRU¶V)RUHZRUG
3UDLVHEHWR$OOK,
11.
WKH5DEE /RUG
12.
RIWKH:RUOGVDQGPDWKHEOHVVLQJVDQGSHDFHRI$OOKEH XSRQRXUEHORYHG3URSKHW0XKDPPDGDQGKLV)DPLODQGRPSDQLRQV
,GHDO 0XVOLP WKH WUXH ,VOPLF SHUVRQDOLW DV GHILQHG E WKH 4XU¶Q DQG 6XQQDK SUHVHQWV D FRPSUHKHQVLYHRYHUYLHZRIWKHZDLQZKLFKWKH3URSKHW7
13.
DQGKLVRPSDQLRQVOLYHG7KLVSLFWXUHRI WKHSUDFWLFDODVSHFWVRIDWUXO,VOPLFOLIHVWOHVHUYHVDVDWLPHOUHPLQGHUIRUDOORIXV$WDWLPHZKHQ XQ,VOPLFDQGDQWL,VOPLFLQIOXHQFHVDUH VSUHDGLQJYLDPRGHUQWHFKQRORJWRWKHKHDUWODQGVRI,VOPDQG HYHQ WR
WKH UHPRWHVW UHJLRQV ZH QHHG WR KROG ILUP WR WKH GLVWLQFW FKDUDFWHU RI RXU IDLWK DV SUHVFULEHG E $OOK,
14.
DQGUHYHDOHGWKURXJK+LV3URSKHW7
15.
'U0XKDPPDGµ$O¯ DO+VKLP¯ SUHVHQWVDZHOOWKRXJKWRXWJXLGHWRWKH,VOPLFOLIHVWOH+HVWDUWVZLWK WKH
0XVOLP¶V UHODWLRQVKLS ZLWK KLV 5DEE ZKLFK LV WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW DVSHFW RI KLV OLIH DQG SURYLGHV WKH IRXQGDWLRQIRUDOOKLVRWKHUUHODWLRQVKLSV)URPWKHUH'U+VKLP¯ RXWOLQHVKRZWKH0XVOLPVKRXOGUHODWHWR HYHUSHUVRQLQKLVOLIHVWDUWLQJZLWKKLPVHOIDQGKLVIDPLODQGPRYLQJRQEVWDJHVWRHQFRPSDVVHYHU PHPEHU RI WKH FRPPXQLW RU VRFLHW (DFK SRLQW LV VXSSRUWHG E H[WHQVLYH TXRWDWLRQV IURP WKH 4XU¶Q DQGRUpDG¯WK ,W VKRXOG EH QRWHG WKDW ZKLOH PRVW RI ,VOPLF WHDFKLQJV z DQG FHUWDLQO WKH FHQWUDO EHOLHIV DQG SUDFWLFHV ³SLOODUV´
16.
z DUH LQFXPEHQW
XSRQ PHQ DQG ZRPHQ DOLNH VRPH DVSHFWV RI WKH IDLWK DUH HPSKDVL]HGPRUHIRURQHWKDQWKHRWKHURUPDEHDSSOLFDEOHWRMXVWRQHRIWKHWZRVH[HV$QREYLRXV H[DPSOH LV WKH GUHVVFRGH ZKHUH WKH HPSKDVLV LV SODFHG RQ ZRPHQ¶V DWWLUH DOWKRXJK LW VKRXOG QRW EH IRUJRWWHQWKDWPHQDUHLQVWUXFWHGWRGUHVVPRGHVWOWRRDQGWKDWFHUWDLQSURKLELWLRQVDSSORQOWRWKHP LHWKHZHDULQJRIJROGDQGVLON
17.
$QXPEHURIWKHVH³JHQGHUVSHFLILF´PDWWHUVDUHGLVFXVVHGKHUHEXW WKHERRNVKRXOGQRWEHYLHZHGDVH[FOXVLYHPHQDQGZRPHQDOLNHPDOHDUQPXFKIURPLW
7KHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVRI4XU¶QLFTXRWDWLRQVKDYHEHHQWDNHQIURPWKHWUDQVODWLRQEXVXIµ$O¯H[FHSW ZKHUHLQGLFDWHG7KHDUFKDLFVWOHRIXVXIµ$O¯¶VWUDQVODWLRQKDVKHUHEHHQDPHQGHGDQGPRGHUQL]HGVR WKDW³WKRX´EHFRPHV³RX´³JRHWK´EHFRPHV³JRHV´HWF 0DQ ,VOPLF FRQFHSWV DUH GLIILFXOW WR H[SUHVV LQ (QJOLVK HVSHFLDOO DV ZRUGV WKDW FDUU H[WHQVLYH FXOWXUDO EDJJDJH 7KLV LV HVSHFLDOO VR ZLWK ³UHOLJLRXV´ ZRUGV ZKLFK ZKHQ UHQGHUHG LQWR (QJOLVK PD FRQYHFRQQRWDWLRQVWKDWGRQRWH[LVWLQ$UDELF)RUWKLVUHDVRQPDQ$UDELFZRUGVKDYHEHHQUHWDLQHG ZLWKH[SODQDWLRQVHLWKHULQWKHWH[WRULQWKHJORVVDUZKLFKLVWREHIRXQGDWWKHHQGRIWKHERRN 0D$OOK,
18.
UHZDUGWKHDXWKRUIRUKLVHIIRUWVWRHGXFDWHWKH0XVOLPVDERXWWKHLUUHOLJLRQPD+H FDXVHWKLVERRNWREHDVRXUFHRIEHQHILFLDOLQVWUXFWLRQDQGPD+HJXLGHXVDQGNHHSXVRQWKH6WUDLJKW 3DWK
1DÑLUXGG¯QDO.KDÓÓE 0DUFK K
19.
,QWKHQDPHRI$OOK$OORPSDVVLRQDWH$OO0HUFLIXO
2 $OOK WR RX , RIIHU SUDLVH DQG VHHN RXU KHOS DQG JXLGDQFH , VHQG SUDHUV DQG EOHVVLQJVXSRQRXUWUXVWZRUWK0HVVHQJHUDQGDOOKLVIDPLODQGFRPSDQLRQVDQGWKRVH ZKRIROORZWKHPLQDOOJRRGGHHGV
20.
XQWLOWKH'DRI-XGJHPHQW
21.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
22.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
,QWURGXFWLRQ 0 LQWHUHVW LQ WKH WRSLF RI WKH0XVOLPSHUVRQDOLW DV,VOPPHDQWLWWREHJRHVEDFNPRUHWKDQWHQ HDUV GXULQJ ZKLFK WLPH , KDYH QRWLFHG WKDW PDQ 0XVOLPV DUH RIWHQ RYHU]HDORXV LQ VRPH PDWWHUV EXW QHJOLJHQW LQ RWKHUV )RU H[DPSOH RX PLJKW VHH D 0XVOLP ZKR LQVLVWV RQ DWWHQGLQJ HYHU SUDHU DQG VWDQGLQJ LQWKHIURQWURZEXWKHSDVQRKHHGWRWKHEDGVPHOOHPDQDWLQJIURPKLVPRXWKRUFORWKHVRUKH REHVDQGIHDUV$OOK,
23.
EXWGRHVQRWWDNHFDUHWRXSKROGWKHWLHVRINLQVKLSRUKHGHYRWHVPXFKWLPHWR ZRUVKLS DQG WKH
SXUVXLW RI NQRZOHGJH EXW LV QHJOHFWLQJ KLV FKLOGUHQ¶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µZDK DQGZKRDUHLQYROYHGLQWKHSURSDJDWLRQRIDSUDFWLFDOPHVVDJHWKDWLQPRVWFDVHV SURYLGHVDQDZDUHQHVVDQGXQGHUVWDQGLQJRI,VOPLFWHDFKLQJVDQGYDOXHVIROORZLQJWUXHJXLGDQFHHWLW VHHPV WKDW WKH RYHUZKHOPLQJ QDWXUH RI WKHLU ZRUN RU SHUKDSV FDUHOHVVQHVV RU IRUJHWIXOQHVV KDV FDXVHG VRPH,VOPLVWVWRIDOOLQWRWKHWUDSRIWKHVHHUURUVZKHWKHUNQRZLQJORURWKHUZLVH 0 LQWHUHVW LQ H[SORULQJ WKH 0XVOLP SHUVRQDOLW DV ,VOP PHDQW LW WR EH OHG PH WR FRQVXOW ,VOPLF VRXUFHVWKDWUHIHUWRPDQDQGKRZKHLVWREHJXLGHGDQGPRXOGHGVRWKDW,FRXOGSUHVHQWWRWKH0XVOLPV HVSHFLDOO WKRVH ZKR DUH SUDFWLVLQJ DQG DFWLYH D FRPSOHWH VWXG RI WKLV SHUVRQDOLW GHVFULELQJ LWV GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ IHDWXUHV DQG DWWLWXGHV ,W LV KRSHG WKDW WKLV ZRUN PD UHSUHVHQW D EHDFRQ RI JXLGDQFH WR WKRVHZKRDUHIDOOLQJVKRUW LQVRPHUHVSHFWVVRWKDWWKHPDUDLVHWKHPVHOYHVXSWRWKHOHYHOWKDWWKHLU WUXHUHOLJLRQLQWHQGHG ,ZDVVKRFNHGZKHQ,UHDOL]HGKRZJUHDWDJDSH[LVWVEHWZHHQZKDW,VOPZDQWVIRUWKH0XVOLPVDQG ZKDWWKHZDQWIRUWKHPVHOYHVz H[FHSWDIHZRIWKHPZKRDUHVLQFHUHLQWKHLUIDLWKSXUHRIKHDUWDQG VRXODQGILOOHGZLWKDPELWLRQ7KHVHDUHWKHRQHVZKRDUHSDVVLRQDWHOGHYRWHGWRWKHLUUHOLJLRQGULQNLQJ GHHSOIURPLWVSXUHVSULQJDQGIROORZLQJLWVLOOXVWULRXVJXLGDQFHPRUHFORVHOHDFKGD :KRHYHU WDNHV WKH WLPH WR VWXG WKH JXLGDQFH RI $OOK ,
24.
DQG +LV 3URSKHW
7
25.
FRQVXOWLQJ WKH SURSHU VRXUFHV
LH WKH WH[WV LQ WKH 4XU¶Q DQG pDG¯WK ZLOO EH DPD]HG DW KRZ PXFK FRPSUHKHQVLYH LQIRUPDWLRQ LV WR EH IRXQG WKHUH GHDOLQJ ZLWK ERWK PDMRU DQG PLQRU DVSHFWV RI WKH LQGLYLGXDO¶V UHODWLRQVKLSZLWKKLV5DEEKLVRZQVHOIDQGWKHSHRSOHDURXQGKLP$OORIWKLVLVJXLGDQFHDLPHGDWWKH HGLILFDWLRQRIWKH0XVOLPDQGHQDEOLQJKLPWRHQMRDQLGHDOOLIHERWKDVDQLQGLYLGXDODQGDVDPHPEHU RIWKHODUJHUVRFLHW 6R LW VHHPV WKDW WKH 0XVOLP DV LQWHQGHG E WKHVH WH[WV LV VXSSRVHG WR EH D GHFHQW VRFLDO SHUVRQ ZKRPWKLVXQLTXHFRPELQDWLRQRIKRQRXUDEOHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVGLVWLQJXLVKHV7KHVHIHDWXUHVDUHGHVFULEHG LQWKH4XU¶QDQGpDG¯WKZKLFKSUHVHQWWKHPDVDUHOLJLRXVREOLJDWLRQWREHDFWLYHOSXUVXHGEPDQLQ WKHKRSHRIUHFHLYLQJUHZDUGIURP$OOK,
26.
ÎÍÎ
27.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
6R , EHJDQ WR FRPSLOH DQG FODVVLI UHIHUHQFHV IURP WKH 4XU¶Q DQG 6XQQDK $V , JDWKHUHG PRUH PDWHULDOWKHVXEMHFWEHFDPHFOHDUHUDQG,ZDVDEOHWRLGHQWLIWKHIROORZLQJWRSLFV 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLV5DEE 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVRZQVHOI 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVSDUHQWV 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVZLIH 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVFKLOGUHQ 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVUHODWLYHV 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVQHLJKERXU 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLV0XVOLPEURWKHUVDQGIULHQGV 7KH0XVOLPDQGKLVFRPPXQLWVRFLHW 7KURXJK VWXGLQJ WKH ZHDOWK RI NQRZOHGJH FRQWDLQHG LQ WKHVH VRXUFHV , UHDOL]HG WKH JUHDWQHVV RI $OOK¶VPHUFWR+LVVODYHVLQWKDW+HKDVUHVFXHGWKHPIURPHUURUDQGVHQWWKHPWUXHJXLGDQFHYLD+LV 0HVVHQJHUV%RRNVDQG/DZVVRWKDWPDQNLQGPDEHVKRZQWKH6WUDLJKW3DWKDQGVDYHGIURPVWXPEOLQJ DQGJURSLQJEOLQGOLQWKHGDUN +XPDQ EHLQJV DUH LQ JUHDW QHHG RI WKLV JXLGDQFH DQG HGXFDWLRQ VR WKDW WKH ZLOO EH DEOH WR SUDFWLVH WKHLU KXPDQLW DQG SOD WKH UROH LQ WKLV OLIH WKDW $OOK ,
28.
LQWHQGHG WKHP WR
SOD +DG LW QRW IRU WKLV 'LYLQHJXLGDQFHPDQNLQGZRXOGKDYHEHHQOHIWZDOORZLQJLQWKHPLUHRIVHOILVKQHVVKDWUHGGRPLQDWLRQ DQGRSSUHVVLRQ 7KHHYLGHQFHIRUWKLVLVDSSDUHQWLQWKHEHKDYLRXURIWKHFKLOGZKRVWULYHVWRVKRZKLVSDUHQWVWKDWKH LVEHWWHUWKDQKLVEURWKHUDQGVHHNVWRGHQWKDWKLVEURWKHUKDVDQRIWKHVDPHGHFHQWTXDOLWLHVWRZKLFK KHKLPVHOIDVSLUHV+LVQDWXUDOLQFOLQDWLRQLVWRGHIHDWKLVEURWKHUDQGSURYHWKDWKHLVEHWWHU 7KLV QDWXUDO FKDUDFWHULVWLF LV HVVHQWLDO WR PDQ¶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
29.
LQWHQGHGIRUWKHPWKXVHQDEOLQJWKHPWRHQMRDGHFHQWDQGSOHDVDQWOLIH
30.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
$OOK ,
31.
GLG QRW UHYHDO
WKLV UHOLJLRQ RI,VOPIURPDERYHWKHVHYHQKHDYHQVMXVWIRULWWREHWKH PDWWHU RI WKHRUHWLFDO GLVFXVVLRQV RU VDFUHG ZRUGV WKURXJK WKH UHFLWDWLRQ RI ZKLFK SHRSOH PLJKW VHHN EOHVVLQJVZLWKRXWXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHLUVLJQLILFDQFH$OOK,
32.
UHYHDOHGWKLVUHOLJLRQWRJRYHUQWKHOLIHRI WKH LQGLYLGXDO WKH
IDPLO DQG WKH VRFLHW DW ODUJH WR EH D EHDFRQ WKDW ZRXOG OHDG WKH SHRSOH RXW RI GDUNQHVVLQWROLJKW ´7KHUH KDYH FRPH WR RX IURP $OOK D QHZ@ OLJKW DQG D SHUVSLFXRXV %RRN ³ ZKHUHZLWK $OOK JXLGHV DOO ZKR VHHN +LV JRRG SOHDVXUH WR ZDV RI SHDFH DQG VDIHW DQG OHDGV WKHP RXW RI GDUNQHVVE+LV:LOOXQWRWKHOLJKW JXLGHVWKHPWRD3DWKWKDWLV6WUDLJKWµ@ 4XU¶DQ
33.
,QWKHVKDGHRIWKLVJXLGDQFHOLIHEHFRPHVEHWWHUPRUHSOHDVDQWDQGHQMRDEOH7KHILUVWVWHSWRZDUGV WKLVOLIHRIJXLGDQFHDQGOLJKWLQYROYHVWKHIRUPDWLRQRIDVLQFHUH0XVOLPLQGLYLGXDOZKRZLOOSUHVHQWD YLYLGDQGEHDXWLIXOSLFWXUHRI,VOPVRWKDWZKHQSHRSOHVHHKLPWKHZLOOVHHWUXH,VOPDQGZKHQWKH GHDOZLWKKLPWKHLUIDLWKZLOOLQFUHDVH
7KLVLVZKDWWKH3URSKHW7
34.
GLGDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIKLVGDµZDKZKHQKLVILUVWVWHSRQWKHORQJURDG RI,VOPZDVWRPRXOGLQGLYLGXDOVZKRZRXOGHPERG,VOPDQGEHFRPHDVLWZHUH³4XU¶QV´ZDONLQJRQ WKHIDFHRIWKHHDUWK:KHUHYHUWKHZHQWLQWKHZRUOGWKHZHUHDXQLTXHH[DPSOHRIDXQLTXHZDRI OLIH:KHQSHRSOHVDZWKLVXQLTXHZDRIOLIHHPERGLHGLQVLQFHUH EHOLHYLQJLQGLYLGXDOVWKHHPEUDFHG WKLVUHOLJLRQDQGHQWHUHG,VOPLQFURZGV
+XPDQLW WRGD DQG WKH 0XVOLPV LQ SDUWLFXODU DUHLQJUHDWQHHGRIVXFKXQLTXHLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKRXW ZKRPKXPDQOLIHLVXQEHDUDEOHGHFHQWYDOXHVFDQQRWEHXSKHOGDQGWKHWUXH OLJKWRI,VOPFDQQRWVKLQH IRUWK :KDWGRHVVXFKDPDUYHOORXVKXPDQH[DPSOHORRNOLNH7KLVLVWKHTXHVWLRQWKDWZLOOEHDQVZHUHGLQ WKHIROORZLQJSDJHV ,DVN$OOK,
35.
WRDFFHSWWKLVZRUNIRU+LVVDNHDQGWREHQHILWRWKHUVWKURXJKLWDQGPDNHLWDKHOSIRU PHRQ´WKH'DZKHUHRQQHLWKHUZHDOWKQRUVRQVZLOODYDLOEXWRQOKHZLOOSURVSHU@WKDWEULQJVWR $OOKDVRXQGKHDUWµ@ 4XU¶Q
36.
0XKDPPDG¶$O¯ DO+VKLP¯
5LDGK -XPG DObNKLUDK $+ 0D( ÎÍÐ
37.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
KDSWHU 7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5DEE 7KHEHOLHYHULVDOHUW ,VOP UHTXLUHV RI WKH 0XVOLP ILUVW DQG IRUHPRVW WKDW KH EH D WUXH DQG VLQFHUH EHOLHYHU LQ $OOK ,
38.
µ7KH([DOWHG¶FORVHOFRQQHFWHG WR+LPFRQVWDQWOUHPHPEHULQJ+LPDQGSXWWLQJKLVWUXVWLQ+LPZKLOH PDNLQJWKHHIIRUWWRKHOSKLPVHOI7KH0XVOLPVKRXOGIHHOLQWKHGHSWKVRIKLVVRXOWKDWKHLVLQFRQVWDQW QHHGRIWKHKHOSDQGVXSSRUWRI$OOK,
39.
QRPDWWHUKRZPXFKKHPDWKLQNKH FDQGRIRUKLPVHOI
7KH WUXH DQG VLQFHUH 0XVOLP LV DOHUW DQG RSHQPLQGHG WR WKH PDJQLILFHQFH RI $OOK¶V FUHDWLRQ +H NQRZVWKDWLWLV$OPLJKW$OOK,
40.
:KRLVLQFRQWURORIWKHDIIDLUVRIWKHXQLYHUVHDQGRIPDQNLQG+H UHFRJQL]HV WKH VLJQV
RI +LV XQOLPLWHG SRZHU LQ HYHU DVSHFW RI FUHDWLRQ DQG VR KLV IDLWK LQ $OOK ,
41.
LQFUHDVHVKHUHPHPEHUV+LPFRQVWDQWODQGSXWVKLVWUXVWLQ+LP %HKROG,QWKHFUHDWLRQRIWKHKHDYHQVDQGWKHHDUWKDQGWKHDOWHUQDWLRQRI1LJKWDQG'D³ WKHUH DUH LQGHHG
6LJQV IRU PHQ RI XQGHUVWDQGLQJ ³ PHQ ZKR FHOHEUDWH WKH SUDLVHV RI $OOK VWDQGLQJ VLWWLQJDQGOLQJGRZQRQWKHLUVLGHVDQGFRQWHPSODWHWKHZRQGHUVRI@FUHDWLRQLQWKHKHDYHQVDQG WKHHDUWKZLWKWKHWKRXJKW@¶2XU5DEE 1RWIRUQDXJKWKDYHRXFUHDWHGDOO@WKLV*ORUWRRX*LYH XVVDOYDWLRQIURPWKH3HQDOWRIWKH)LUH·@ 4XU¶Q
42.
2EHGLHQWWRWKHFRPPDQGVRIKLV5DEE ,WFRPHVDVQRVXUSULVHWKHQWKDWWKHVLQFHUH0XVOLPLVKXPEOREHGLHQWWR$OOK,
43.
LQDOOPDWWHUV +H QHYHU WUDQVJUHVVHV
WKH OLPLWV DQG KH IROORZV $OOK¶V FRPPDQGV DQG JXLGDQFH HYHQ ZKHQ WKH DUH FRQWUDUWRKLVRZQGHVLUHV7KHWHVWRIWKH0XVOLP¶VIDLWKOLHVLQWKLVIROORZLQJRIWKHFRPPDQGVRI$OOK ,
44.
DQG+LV0HVVHQJHU7
45.
LQDOOPDWWHUVJUHDWDQGVPDOOZLWKQRKHVLWDWLRQRUUHVHUYDWLRQ ´1RQHRIRXWUXO@EHOLHYHVXQWLOKLVLQFOLQDWLRQLVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKZKDW,KDYHEURXJKWµ
%XW QR E WKH 5DEE WKH FDQ KDYH QR UHDO@ )DLWK XQWLO WKH PDNH RX MXGJH LQ DOO GLVSXWHV EHWZHHQWKHPDQGILQGLQWKHLUVRXOVQRUHVLVWDQFHDJDLQVWRXUGHFLVLRQVEXWDFFHSWWKHPZLWK WKHIXOOHVWFRQYLFWLRQ@ 4XU¶Q
46.
,W LV WKH
PDWWHU RI DEVROXWH VXEPLVVLRQ DQG FRPSOHWH REHGLHQFH WR $OOK ,
47.
DQG +LV 0HVVHQJHU :LWKRXWERWKRIWKHVHWKHUHLVQRIDLWKDQGQR,VOP7KHUHIRUHWKHVLQFHUH0XVOLPGRHVQRWGHYLDWHIURP WKHJXLGDQFHRI$OOK,
48.
RULJQRUHWKHFRPPDQGVRI+LV0HVVHQJHUZKHWKHUWKHVHFRQFHUQKLPDVDQ
$O1DZDZL¶V)RUWpDG¯WKpDG¯WK1RS
49.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
LQGLYLGXDORUWKRVHRYHUZKRPKHKDVDXWKRULWDQGIRUZKRPKHLVUHVSRQVLEOHLHWKHPHPEHUVRI KLVIDPLO
50.
+HKDVDVHQVHRIUHVSRQVLELOLWIRUWKRVHXQGHUKLVDXWKRULW ,I
DQ PHPEHURIWKH0XVOLP¶VIDPLOLVQHJOHFWIXORUIDLOLQJLQKLVRUKHUGXWLHVWRZDUGV$OOK,
51.
DQG+LV0HVVHQJHUWKHQKHLVUHVSRQVLEOH ´(DFKRIRXLVDVKHSKHUGDQGHDFKRIRXLVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUKLVIORFNLHWKRVHRYHUZKRPRX KDYHDXWKRULW
52.
µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
53.
7KH VHQVH RI
UHVSRQVLELOLW WKDW WKH VLQFHUH 0XVOLP IHHOV ZKHQ D PHPEHU RI KLV IDPLO LV IDLOLQJ LQ VRPH LPSRUWDQW UHJDUG GLVWXUEV KLP JUHDWO +H FDQQRW EHDU LW VR KHZLOOKDVWHQWRGHDOZLWKLWVFDXVHV GHVSLWHWKHFRQVHTXHQFHV7KHRQORQHZKRFDQLJQRUHVXFKDUHVSRQVLELOLWDQGNHHSTXLHWDERXWLWLVWKH PDQZKRVHIDLWKLVZHDNDQGZKRVHPDQKRRGLVODFNLQJ ÎÍÒ
54.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
+HDFFHSWVWKHZLOODQGGHFUHHRI$OOK,
55.
,
7KH VLQFHUH 0XVOLP LV DOZDV FRQWHQW WR DFFHSW WKH ZLOO DQG GHFUHH RI $OOK ,
56.
UHPHPEHULQJ WKH DG¯WK ´+RZ DPD]LQJ
LV WKH DIIDLU RI WKH 0XVOLP +LV DIIDLUV DUH DOO JRRG ,I KH H[SHULHQFHV HDVH KH LV JUDWHIXO DQG WKDW LV JRRG IRU KLP ,I KH H[SHULHQFHV KDUGVKLS KHIDFHVLWZLWKSDWLHQFHDQGSHUVHYHUDQFHDQG WKDWLVDOVRJRRGIRUKLPµ %XNKU¯
57.
7KHVLQFHUH0XVOLPLVFRQYLQFHGWKDWEHOLHILQWKHZLOODQGGHFUHHRI$OOK,
58.
LVRQHRIWKHSLOODUVRI IDLWK :KDWHYHU EHIDOOV
KLP LQ OLIH FDQQRW KDYH EHHQ DYRLGHG EHFDXVH $OOK ,
59.
KDV GHFUHHG LW
+LV DFFHSWDQFH RI WKH GLYLQH ZLOO DQG GHFUHH ZLOO HDUQ KLP D JUHDW UHZDUG IURP $OOK ,
60.
:KR ZLOO FRXQW KLPDVRQHRIWKHVXFFHVVIXOREHGLHQWEHOLHYHUV
7KLVLVZKWKHDG¯WK VDVWKDWWKH0XVOLP¶VDIIDLUVDUHDOOJRRG,IKHJRHVWKURXJKDWLPHRIHDVHKH ZLOOJLYHPXFKWKDQNVWRKLVJHQHURXV5DEE IRU+LVERXQWDQGLIKHJRHVWKURXJKDWLPHRIKDUGVKLSKH ZLOOEHDULWZLWKSDWLHQFHDQGIRUWLWXGHIROORZLQJWKHFRPPDQGVRIKLV5DEE DQGDFFHSWLQJ+LVZLOODQG GHFUHH:KDWHYHUWKHFDVHLWLVWUXOJRRGIRUKLP 7KHRQHZKRWXUQVWR$OOK,
61.
LQUHSHQWDQFH
, 7KH0XVOLPPDILQGKLPVHOIEHFRPLQJQHJOHFWIXODQGVOLSSLQJIURPWKH6WUDLJKW3DWKVRWKDWKHPD FRPPLWDVLQZKLFKGRHVQRWEHILWKLPDVDKXPEOHDQGYLJLODQWEHOLHYHUEXWKHZLOOVRRQUHPHPEHUKLV 5DEEWXUQDZDIURPKLVHUURUDQGVHHNIRUJLYHQHVVIRUKLVIDLOLQJV 7KRVH ZKR IHDU $OOK ZKHQ D WKRXJKW RI HYLO IURP 6DWDQ DVVDXOWV WKHP EULQJ $OOK WR UHPHPEUDQFHZKHQOR7KHVHHDULJKW@@ 4XU¶Q
62.
7KHKHDUWILOOHG ZLWKORYHDQGIHDURI$OOK,
63.
ZLOOQRWEHRYHUFRPHEQHJOLJHQFH,WLVWKRVHZKR LJQRUH$OOK¶VFRPPDQGVDQGJXLGDQFHZKRZLOOEHOHGDVWUD7KHKHDUWRIWKHVLQFHUH0XVOLPLVHYHU HDJHUWRUHSHQWDQGVHHNIRUJLYHQHVVDQGUHMRLFHVLQREHGLHQFHJXLGDQFHDQGWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
64.
+LVPDLQFRQFHUQLVWKHSOHDVXUHRIKLV5DEE
7KH VLQFHUH 0XVOLP VHHNV WR HDUQ WKH SOHDVXUH RI $OOK ,
65.
LQ HYHUWKLQJ WKDW
KH GRHV +H LV QRW FRQFHUQHGZLWKVHHNLQJWKHDSSURYDORIRWKHUVDQGLQGHHGKHPDLQFXUWKHZUDWKDQGKDWUHGRISHRSOHLQ WKHFRXUVHRIKLVHIIRUWVWRZLQGLYLQHIDYRXUDVWKH3URSKHW7
66.
µ%OHVVLQJVDQG3HDFHEHXSRQKLP¶VDLG
67.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP ´:KRHYHUVHHNVWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
68.
DWWKHULVNRIGLVSOHDVLQJWKHSHRSOH$OOK,
69.
ZLOOWDNHFDUH RIKLPDQGSURWHFW KLPIURPWKHP%XWZKRHYHUVHHNVWKHSOHDVXUHRIWKHSHRSOHDWWKHULVNRIDQJHULQJ $OOK,
70.
$OOK,
71.
ZLOODEDQGRQKLPWRWKHFDUHRIWKHSHRSOHµ
RQVHTXHQWOKHPHDVXUHVDOOKLVGHHGVDJDLQVWKLVGHVLUHWRDWWDLQWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
72.
DQGZLOO UHWDLQ RU GLVFDUG
DQ SUDFWLFH DFFRUGLQJO 7KXV WKH 0XVOLP ZLOO KDYH DSSURSULDWH VWDQGDUGV DQG WKH 6WUDLJKW 3DWK ZLOO EH FOHDUO VLJQSRVWHG IRU KLP +H ZLOO DYRLG IDOOLQJ LQWR ULGLFXORXV FRQWUDGLFWLRQV ZKHUHEKHREHV$OOK,
73.
LQRQHPDWWHUDQGGLVREHV+LPLQDQRWKHURUKHUHJDUGVVRPHWKLQJDVDOO RQHHDUDQGDUP WKHQH[W7KHUHLVQRURRPIRUFRQWUDGLFWLRQVDVORQJDVWKHVWDQGDUGVDUHFRUUHFWDQG WKHSULQFLSOHVDUHVRXQG
2QH RIWHQ QRWLFHV SHRSOH ZKR SUD GHYRWHGO LQ WKH PRVTXH WKHQ ZKHQ RQH VHHV WKHP LQ WKH PDUNHWSODFHWKHDUHGHDOLQJZLWKULE XVXURULQWHUHVW
74.
RULIRQHVHHVWKHPLQWKHKRPHWKHVWUHHWWKH VFKRRORUWKHQHLJKERXUKRRGLWLVDSSDUHQWWKDWWKHDUHQRWDSSOLQJWKHODZVRI$OOK,
75.
WRWKHLURZQ VHOYHVWKHLUZLYHVWKHLUFKLOGUHQRUDQRIWKRVHXQGHUWKHLUFDUH7KHVHSHRSOHDUHDIIOLFWHGEDVHYHUH PLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHUHDOLWRI,VOPWKLVKROLVWLFUHOLJLRQWKDWLQDOODIIDLUVGLUHFWVWKH0XVOLPWRZDUGV DJUHDWHUSXUSRVHQDPHOWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
76.
PD +HEHJORULILHG7KLVJUHDWHUSXUSRVHOHDGVWKH 0XVOLP WR
PHDVXUH DOO KLV GHHGV DJDLQVW WKH VWDQGDUGV ODLG GRZQ E $OOK ,
77.
6R WKHVH SHRSOH
ZRXOG DSSHDUWREH³VHPL0XVOLPV´WKHDUH0XVOLPVLQQDPHRQO7KLVVSOLWSHUVRQDOLWLVRQHRIWKHJUHDWHVW GDQJHUVWKDW0XVOLPVDUHFXUUHQWOIDFLQJ +HUHJXODUOSHUIRUPVWKHGXWLHVDQGJRRGGHHGVUHTXLUHGE,VO P 7KHVLQFHUH0XVOLPSHUIRUPVDOOREOLJDWRUGHHGVDQGDGKHUHVWRWKHSLOODUVRI,VOPFRPSOHWHODQG GHYRWHGO+HGRHVQRWVODFNHQGRLWKDOIKHDUWHGORUVHHNH[FXVHVQRWWRGRLW6RKHHVWDEOLVKHVSUDHU SHUIRUPLQJ HDFK RI WKH ILYH GDLO SUDHUV RQ WLPH IRU SUDHU LV WKH SLOODU RI WKH IDLWK z ZKRHYHU HVWDEOLVKHVSUDHUHVWDEOLVKHVIDLWKDQGZKRHYHUQHJOHFWVSUDHUGHVWURVWKHIDLWK 3UDHULVWKHEHVWRIGHHGVDVLVPDGHFOHDULQWKH DG¯WKQDUUDWHGE,EQ0DVµÔGW
78.
µ0D$OOKEH SOHDVHGZLWKKLP¶LQZKLFKKHVDLG ´, DVNHG WKH
0HVVHQJHU RI $OOK 7
79.
¶:KDW GHHG LV
PRVW ORYHG E $OOK ,
80.
· +H VDLG
¶7R RIIHU HDFK SUDHUDVVRRQDVLWLVGXH·,DVNHGKLP¶7KHQZKDW·+HVDLG¶7UHDWLQJRQH·VSDUHQWVZLWKKRQRXUDQG UHVSHFW·,DVNHGKLP¶7KHQZKDW·+HVDLG¶-LKGIRUWKHVDNHRI$OK,
81.
·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
82.
3UDHU LV VR
LPSRUWDQW EHFDXVH LW LV D GLUHFW OLQN EHWZHHQ WKH VHUYDQW DQG KLV 5DEE LQ ZKLFK KH GLVWDQFHVKLPVHOIIURPWKHFRQFHUQVRIGDLOOLIHDQGIRFXVHVKLPVHOIHQWLUHORQKLV5DEEDVNLQJ+LPIRU KHOSJXLGDQFHDQGSHUVHYHUDQFHWRFRQWLQXHDORQJWKH6WUDLJKW3DWK6RLWLVKDUGOVXUSULVLQJWKDWSUDHU LVFRQVLGHUHGWREHWKHEHVWRIGHHGVEHFDXVHLWLVWKHVRXUFHIURPZKLFKWKHEHOLHYHUPDUHSOHQLVKKLV WDTZ DQGWKHVSULQJLQZKRVHSXUHZDWHUKHPDFOHDQVHKLPVHOIRIKLVVLQV 5HSRUWHGEDO7LUPLGK¯DO4DŸµ¯ DQG,EQµ$VNLU,WVLVQG LVDVDQ 6HH,¶µXOÔPDOG¯Q ÎÍÔ
83.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
$EÔ +XUDUDKW
84.
VDLG ´,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
85.
VD¶:KDWZRXOGRXWKLQNLIWKHUHZHUHDULYHUUXQQLQJEWKHGRRU RI DQ RI
RX DQG KH EDWKHG LQ LW ILYH WLPHV HYHU GD ZRXOG DQ WUDFH RI GLUW EH OHIW RQ KLP· 7KH SHRSOHVDLG¶7KHUHZRXOGEHQRWUDFHRIGLUWRQKLP·+HVDLG¶7KLVLVOLNHWKHILYHGDLOSUDHUVWKURXJK ZKLFK$OOK,
86.
HUDVHVVLQ·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
87.
-ELUW
88.
VDLG ´7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
89.
VDLG¶7KHILYHGDLOSUDHUVDUHOLNHDGHHSULYHUIORZLQJEWKHGRRURIDQ RIRXLQZKLFKKHEDWKHVILYHWLPHVHDFKGD·µ 0XVOLP
90.
,EQ0DVµÔGW
91.
VDLG ´$PDQNLVVHGDZRPDQWKHQKHFDPHWRWKH3URSKHW7
92.
DQGWROGKLPZKDWKHKDGGRQH7KHQ$OOK ,
93.
UHYHDOHG WKH bDK
¶$QG HVWDEOLVK UHJXODU SUDHUV DW WKH WZR HQGV RI WKH GD DQG DW WKH DSSURDFKHVRIWKHQLJKWIRUWKRVHWKLQJVWKDWDUHJRRGUHPRYHWKRVHWKDWDUHHYLO·@ 4XU¶Q
94.
7KHPDQVDLGµ'RHVLWDSSOWRPH¶7KH3URSKHW7
95.
VDLG ¶,WDSSOLHVWRDOORIP8PPDK·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
96.
$EÔ +XUDUDKW
97.
VDLG ´7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI
$OOK 7
98.
VDLG¶7KHILYHGDLOSUDHUVIURP)ULGDWR)ULGDDUHDQH[SLDWLRQIRUWKH VLQVFRPPLWWHGLQWKHWLPHEHWZHHQSUDHUVVRORQJDVQRPDMRUVLQVNDE·LU
99.
DUHFRPPLWWHG·µ 0XVOLP
100.
µ8WKPQLEQµ$IIQW
101.
VDLG ´,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
102.
VDLQJ¶7KHUHLVQR0XVOLPZKRZKHQWKHWLPHVIRUSUDHUFRPHV SHUIRUPV ZXŸÔ· SURSHUO
FRQFHQWUDWHV RQ KLV SUDHU DQG ERZV FRUUHFWO EXW WKH SUDHU ZLOO EH DQ H[SLDWLRQIRUWKHVLQVFRPPLWWHGSULRUWRLWVRORQJDVQRPDMRUVLQKDVEHHQFRPPLWWHG7KLVLVWKHFDVH XQWLOWKHHQGRIWLPH·µ 0XVOLP
103.
7KH DG¯WKV DQG
UHSRUWV WKDW H[WRO WKH YLUWXHV RI SUDHU DQG GHVFULEH LWV LPSRUWDQFH DQG EHQHILWV DUH PDQ,WLVQRWSRVVLEOHWRTXRWHDOORIWKHPKHUH 7KH GHYRXW 0XVOLP WULHV WR SUD LQ WKH ILUVW MDPµDK FRQJUHJDWLRQ
104.
LQ WKH PRVTXH
ZKHQHYHU KH FDQ EHFDXVH WKH 3URSKHW 7
105.
WROG XV WKDW
´SUDHU RIIHUHG LQ MDP¶DK LV WZHQWVHYHQ WLPHV EHWWHU WKDQSUDHURIIHUHGLQGLYLGXDOOµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
106.
7KH3URSKHW7
107.
VDLGWKDWWKH0XVOLP ´,IKHSHUIRUPVZXŸÔ· SURSHUOWKHQJRHVRXWZLWKWKHVROHLQWHQWLRQRIJRLQJWRSUDLQWKHPRVTXHWKHQ IRU HDFK
VWHS KH WDNHV KLV VWDWXV LQ 3DUDGLVH ZLOO EH UDLVHG E RQH GHJUHH DQG RQH RI KLV VLQV ZLOO EH IRUJLYHQ :KHQ KH SUDV DVORQJDVKHUHPDLQVLQKLVSODFHRISUDHUDQGKLVZXŸÔ· GRHVQRWEHFRPH LQYDOLGDWHGWKHDQJHOVZLOOFRQWLQXHWRSUDIRUKLP¶2$OOK,
108.
EOHVVKLP2$OOK,
109.
KDYHPHUFRQ )RUWKLVUHDVRQµ$EGXOODKLEQµ8PDUW
110.
XVHGWRWDNHVKRUWVWULGHVZKHQKHZHQWWRWKHPRVTXHLQRUGHUWRLQFUHDVHWKHQXPEHURIVWHSVKH WRRNVRWKDWKLVUHZDUGZRXOGEHLQFUHDVHGDFFRUGLQJO
111.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP KLP·+HLVUHJDUGHGDVEHLQJLQDVWDWHRISUDHUVRORQJDVKHLVZDLWLQJIRUWKHSUDHUµ %XNKU¯
DQG 0XVOLP
112.
7KH3URSKHW7
113.
VSRNHRIWKHSURPLVHRI3DUDGLVHIRUWKHRQHZKRLVNHHQWRSUDLQFRQJUHJDWLRQLQ WKHPRVTXHPRUQLQJDQGHYHQLQJ ´$OOK ZLOO SUHSDUH
D SODFH LQ 3DUDGLVH IRU WKH RQH ZKR JRHV WR WKH PRVTXH LQ WKH PRUQLQJ RU LQ WKH HYHQLQJHDFKWLPHKHJRHVWRWKHPRVTXHµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
114.
RQVHTXHQWO WKH 6DEDK
RPSDQLRQV RI WKH 3URSKHW
115.
PD $OOK EH
SOHDVHG ZLWK WKHP ZHUH DOZDVHDJHUWRDWWHQGSUDHUVLQFRQJUHJDWLRQ5HIHUULQJWRWKLVµ$EGXOODKLEQ0DVµÔGW
116.
VDLG ´:KRHYHUDVSLUHVWRPHHW$OOK,
117.
DVD0XVOLPOHWKLPXSKROGWKHKDELWRIDWWHQGLQJSUDHUVZKHQHYHU WKHFDOOWRSUDHULVJLYHQ$OOK,
118.
KDVVKRZQRXU3URSKHW7
119.
WKHZDRIJXLGDQFHDQGWKHVHSUDHUV LQWKHPRVTXH
120.
DUHSDUWRIWKDWZD,IRXSUDLQRXUKRPHVOLNHWKLVPDQZKRVWDHGLQKLVKRPHWKHQ RX KDYH DEDQGRQHG
WKH 6XQQDK RI RXU 3URSKHW DQG LI RX KDYH DEDQGRQHG WKH 6XQQDK RI RXU 3URSKHWWKHQRXKDYHJRQHDVWUD7KHUHZDVDWLPHZKHQWKHRQOWSHRISHUVRQZKRZRXOGVWDDW KRPHDWWKHWLPHRISUDHUZDVWKHRQHZKRZDVNQRZQWREHDKSRFULWH$WWKDWWLPHDPDQZRXOGEH EURXJKWVXSSRUWHG EWZRRWKHUVXQWLOKHVWRRGLQWKHURZRIZRUVKLSSHUVµ 0XVOLP
121.
7KH3URSKHW7
122.
ZDVVRFRQFHUQHGWKDWSHRSOHVKRXOGDWWHQGWKHFRQJUHJDWLRQDOSUDHUVLQWKHPRVTXH WKDWKHZDQWHGWREXUQGRZQWKHKRXVHVRIWKRVHZKRIDLOHGWR MRLQWKHFRQJUHJDWLRQ ´% WKH
2QH LQ :KRVH KDQG LV P VRXO , ZDQWHG WR JLYH RUGHUV WKDW ZRRG VKRXOG EH JDWKHUHG DQG EURXJKWWRPHWKHQ,ZRXOGKDYHRUGHUHGWKHFDOOWRSUDHUWREHJLYHQDQGZRXOGKDYHDSSRLQWHGD PDQ WR OHDG WKH SUDHU WKHQ,ZRXOGKDYHJRQHWRWKHRQHVZKRZHUHDEVHQWIURPWKHFRQJUHJDWLRQ DQGEXUQWWKHLUKRXVHVGRZQDURXQGWKHPµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
123.
,WFRPHVDVQRVXUSULVHWKHQWROHDUQRI6Dµ¯GLEQDO0XVDDEZKRLQWKLUWHDUVQHYHUVDZWKHEDFN RIDQRWKHUPDQLQWKHPRVTXHEHFDXVHKHZDVDOZDVLQWKHILUVWURZEHIRUHWKH DGKQ FDOOWRSUDHU
124.
7KHUHDUHPDQVXFKH[DPSOHVLQWKHKLVWRURI,VOP
'LVWDQFHZDVQRREMHFWIRUWKH6DEDKZKRZRXOGDWWHQGWKHPRVTXHZKHQHYHUWKHKHDUGWKHFDOOWR SUDHUQRPDWWHUKRZIDUWKHLUKRPHVZHUHIURPWKHPRVTXH7KHFRQJUHJDWLRQDOSUDHUZDVVRGHDUWR WKHPWKDWWKHZRXOGHYHQUHMRLFHLQWKHGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQWKHLUKRPHVDQGWKHPRVTXHEHFDXVHHDFKVWHS WKHWRRNWRUHDFKLWZRXOGEHUHFRUGHGDPRQJWKHJRRGGHHGVIRUZKLFKWKHZRXOGEHUHZDUGHG 8EDLEQ.DµEW
125.
VDLG ´7KHUHZDVDPDQRIWKH$QÑUZKRVHKRXVHZDVIDUWKHUIURPWKHPRVTXHWKDQDQRQHHOVH,NQHZEXW KHQHYHUPLVVHGDSUDHU6RPHRQHDVNHGKLP¶:KGRRXQRWEXDGRQNHWRULGHZKHQLWLVGDUNRULW LVYHUKRW·+HVDLG¶,ZRXOGQRWOLNHPKRXVHWREHQH[WWRWKHPRVTXHEHFDXVH,ZDQWPZDONLQJWR WKH PRVTXH WKHQ
EDFN KRPH WR P IDPLO WR EH UHFRUGHG DPRQJ P JRRG GHHGV· 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OOK7
126.
VDLG¶$OOK,
127.
KDVJLYHQDOORIWKDWWRRXDVDUHZDUG·µ 0XVOLP
128.
7KLVLVUHIHUULQJWRSKVLFDOZHDNQHVVRUVLFNQHVVZKLFKGLGQRWSUHYHQWDSHUVRQIURPDWWHQGLQJWKHSUDHULQWKHPRVTXH$XWKRU
129.
ÎÍÖ
130.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
7KH3URSKHW7
131.
DGYLVHGWKRVH6DEDK ZKRVHKRPHVZHUHIDUIURPWKHPRVTXHVQRWWRPRYHWR KRXVHV WKDW
ZHUH QHDUHU +H UHDVVXUHG WKHP WKDW WKHLU HIIRUWV WR UHDFK WKH PRVTXH ZRXOG EH UHFRUGHG DPRQJWKHLUJRRGGHHGVDQGWKDWWKHLUPDQVWHSVZRXOGQRWJRWRZDVWH-ELUW
132.
VDLG ´6RPHDUHDVDURXQGWKHPRVTXHEHFDPHYDFDQWVR%DQÔ 6DODPDKZDQWHGWRPRYHWKHUH:KHQWKH 3URSKHW7
133.
KHDUGDERXWLWKHWROGWKHP¶,KDYHKHDUGWKDWRXZDQWWRPRYHQHDUWKHPRVTXH·7KH VDLG ¶HV 20HVVHQJHURI$OOKWKDWLVZKDWZHZDQWHGWRGR·+HVDLG¶2%DQÔ
6DODPDKVWDZKHUH RXDUHVRWKDWRXUHIIRUWVWRUHDFKWKHPRVTXHZLOOEHUHFRUGHGDPRQJRXUJRRGGHHGV·7KHVDLG ¶:HZRXOGQRWOLNHWRKDYHPRYHG·µ 0XVOLP
134.
$EÔ 0ÔV W
135.
VDLG ´7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
136.
VDLG¶7KHRQHZKRZLOOUHFHLYHWKHJUHDWHVWUHZDUGIRUKLVSUDHULVWKHRQH ZKRKDVFRPHWKHIDUWKHVWGLVWDQFHDQGWKHRQHZKRZDLWVWRSUDZLWKWKHLPP ZLOOUHFHLYHDJUHDWHU UHZDUGWKDQWKHRQHZKRSUDVWKHQJRHVWRVOHHS·µ %XNKU¯
DQG0XVOLP
137.
%HOLHYHUV DUH SDUWLFXODUO
HQFRXUDJHG LQ VHYHUDO DG¯WKV WR DWWHQG WKH FRQJUHJDWLRQDO SUDHUV LQ WKH PRUQLQJDQGLQWKHHYHQLQJ7KH3URSKHW7
138.
H[SODLQHGWKDWWKHUHLVDJUHDWUHZDUGIRUWKRVHZKRDWWHQG WKHPRVTXHIRUWKHVHWZRSUDHUV IDMU DQGµLVK¶
139.
,WZLOOVXIILFHKHUHWRTXRWHMXVWWZRRIWKHVHUHSRUWV
140.
µ8WKPQLEQµ$IIQW
141.
VDLG³,KHDUGWKH3URSKHW7
142.
VD ¶:KRHYHUSUDV¶LVK· LQFRQJUHJDWLRQLW LVDVLIKHVWDHGXSKDOIWKHQLJKWLQSUDHUDQGZKRHYHUSUDHGIDMU
LQ FRQJUHJDWLRQLWLVDVLIKHVSHQW WKHHQWLUHQLJKWLQSUDHU·µ0XVOLP
143.
$EÔ +XUDUDKW
144.
VDLG³7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
145.
VDLG ´1RSUDHULVDJUHDWHUEXUGHQRQWKH PXQILTÔQ KSRFULWHV
146.
WKDQIDMU DQG¶LVK·,IWKHNQHZKRZPXFKEOHVVLQJDQGUHZDUG
147.
WKHUHLVLQWKHP WKHZRXOGFRPHHYHQLIWKHKDGWRFUDZO·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
148.
7KH GHYRXW 0XVOLP
ZKR LV NHHQ WR VXFFHHG LQ WKH +HUHDIWHU ZLOO QRW KHVLWDWH WR SHUIRUP DV PDQ QILO VXSHUHURJDWRU
149.
GHHGV DV KH
FDQ QLJKW DQG GD EHFDXVH SHUIRUPLQJ PDQ QILO GHHGV EULQJV WKH VHUYDQW FORVHUWRKLV5DEEDQGLQFOXGHVKLPDPRQJWKRVHZKRUHFHLYH+LVGLYLQHKHOSDVLVUHIHUUHGWRLQWKH DG¯WK TXGV¯ VDFUHG
150.
´0VODYHFRQWLQXHVWRGUDZQHDUWR0HZLWKVXSHUHURJDWRUZRUNVVRWKDW,ZLOOORYH KLP:KHQ,ORYHKLP, DPKLVKHDULQJZLWKZKLFKKHKHDUVKLVVHHLQJZLWKZKLFKKHVHHVKLVKDQGZLWKZKLFKKHVWULNHVDQGKLVIRRW ZLWKZKLFKKHZDONV:HUHKHWRDVNVRPHWKLQJ
151.
RI0H,ZRXOGVXUHOJLYHLWWRKLPDQGZHUHKHWRDVN0H IRUUHIXJH ,ZRXOGVXUHOJUDQWKLPLWµ %XNKU¯
152.
%HFDXVHRI$OOK¶VORYHIRU+LVVODYHWKHSHUVRQZLOOEHORYHGEWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIKHDYHQDQGHDUWK DVLVGHVFULEHGLQDUHSRUWQDUUDWHGE$EÔ +XUDUDKW
153.
LQZKLFKWKH3URSKHW7
154.
VDLG ´:KHQ $OOK ,
155.
ORYHV RQH RI
+LV VHUYDQWV KH FDOOV -LEU¯O X
156.
¶0D 3HDFH EH
XSRQ KLP· DQG WHOOVKLP¶, ORYHVRDQGVRVRORYHKLP·7KHQ-LEU¯OX
157.
ZLOOORYHKLPDQGZLOOSURFODLPWRWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIKHDYHQ ¶$OOK,
158.
ORYHVVRDQGVRVRORYHKLP·6RWKHLQKDELWDQWVRI KHDYHQZLOOORYHKLPWRRDQGKHZLOOEHZHOO
%XNKU¯ UHSRUWHGDVLPLODUDFFRXQWIURP$QDV
159.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP DFFHSWHGEWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIWKHHDUWK,I$OOK,
160.
KDWHVRQHRI+LVVHUYDQWV+HFDOOV-LEU¯OX
161.
DQG WHOOVKLP¶,KDWHVRDQGVRVRKDWHKLP·7KHQ-LEU¯OX
162.
ZLOOKDWHKLPDQGZLOOSURFODLPWRWKHLQKDELWDQWV RIKHDYHQ¶$OOK,
163.
KDWHVVRDQGVRVRKDWHKLP·7KHQWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIKHDYHQZLOOKDWHKLPDQGKH ZLOODOVREHGHWHVWHGEWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIWKHHDUWKµ 0XVOLP
164.
7KH3URSKHW7
165.
XVHGWRVWDXSDWQLJKWLQSUDHUVWDQGLQJXQWLOKLVIHHWZHUHVZROOHQµb¶LVKDK µ0D$OOKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU¶DVNHGKLP ´:KDUHRXGRLQJWKLV20HVVHQJHURI$OOKZKHQ$OOK ,
166.
KDVIRUJLYHQDOORXUVLQVSDVWDQGIXWXUHµ+HUHSOLHG´6KRXOG,QRWEHDJUDWHIXOVODYHµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
167.
7KHWUXH0XVOLPWULHVWRSHUIRUPDOOKLVSUDHUVSHUIHFWO,WLVQRWPHUHOWKHPDWWHURIJRLQJWKURXJK WKHPRWLRQVZKHQWKHKHDUWLVHPSWDQGWKHPLQGLVZDQGHULQJ
:KHQKHKDVFRPSOHWHGKLVSUDHUWKH0XVOLPGRHVQRWUXVKVWUDLJKWEDFNLQWRWKHKXVWOHDQGEXVWOHRI GDLO OLIH ,QVWHDG KH VHHNV IRUJLYHQHVV IURP $OOK ,
168.
DQG SUDLVHV DQG
JORULILHV +LP LQ WKH PDQQHU SUHVFULEHG LQ WKH 6XQQDK 7KHQ KH WXUQV WR $OPLJKW $OOK ,
169.
LQ KXPEOH VXSSOLFDWLRQ
DVNLQJ +LP WR JXLGH KLP DQG WR JUDQW KLP WKH JRRGQHVV RI WKLV ZRUOG DQG WKH QH[W 7KXV SUDHU SODV LWV UROH LQ WKH SXULILFDWLRQ RI WKH KHDUW DQG VRXO )RU WKHVH UHDVRQV WKH 3URSKHW 7
170.
XVHG WR VD
´7KH VRXUFH RI P GHHSHVWVDWLVIDFWLRQLVSUDHUµ 7KRVHZKRSUDVLQFHUHODQGKXPEODUHXQGHUWKHFDUHDQGSURWHFWLRQ RI$OOK,
171.
VRWKHGRQRW IHDUZKHQHYLODSSURDFKHVQHLWKHUGRWKHEHFRPHPLVHUOZKHQVRPHWKLQJJRRGEHIDOOVWKHP 7UXOPDQZDVFUHDWHGYHULPSDWLHQWz IUHWIXOZKHQHYLOWRXFKHVKLPDQGQLJJDUGOZKHQJRRG UHDFKHVKLPz 1RWVRWKRVHGHYRWHGWR3UDHU@
4XU¶Q
172.
7KHWUXH0XVOLPDOVRSDV]DNKLIKHKDVHQRXJKZHDOWK+HFDOFXODWHVWKHDPRXQWGXHSUHFLVHODQG KRQHVWODQGSDVLWLQDPDQQHUWKDWLVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVRI,VOP(YHQLIKHKDVWR SDWKRXVDQGVRUPLOOLRQVLQ]DNKKHZRXOGQHYHUWKLQNRIDQH[FXVHQRWWRGRVR
7KLV LV EHFDXVH ]DNK LV D FOHDUOGHILQHG ILQDQFLDO REOLJDWLRQ WKDW LV DOVR DQ DFW RI ZRUVKLS 7KH VLQFHUH0XVOLPFDQQRWDIIRUGWRIDLOLQWKLVGXWZKLFKLVSUHVFULEHGEWKH6KDU¯µDK 7KH0XVOLPZKR KHVLWDWHVWRSDLWLVODFNLQJLQKLVUHOLJLRQDQGKDVDPLVHUODQGWZLVWHGDWWLWXGH,WVXIILFHVWRQRWHWKDWLW LVSHUPLWWHGWRILJKWWKHRQHZKRZLWKKROGVSDPHQWRI ]DNKHYHQWRWKHSRLQWRINLOOLQJKLPXQWLORU XQOHVV KH IXOILOV KLV REOLJDWLRQ 7KH ZRUGV RI $EÔ %DNU W
173.
FRQFHUQLQJ WKH DSRVWDWHV
HFKR GRZQ WKH FHQWXULHV WR XV UHPLQGLQJ XV RI WKH FRQQHFWLRQ WKDW ,VOP PDNHV EHWZHHQ ³UHOLJLRXV´ DQG ³ZRUOGO´ DIIDLUV³,ZLOOILJKWZKRHYHUVHSDUDWHVÑDOK IURP]DNK´7KLVGHFODUDWLRQRI$EÔ %DNUW
174.
LQGLFDWHVWKDW KH KDG D
VRXQG XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH QDWXUH RI WKLV FRPSUHKHQVLYH KROLVWLF UHOLJLRQ DQG RI WKH FORVH FRQQHFWLRQEHWZHHQÑDOKDQG]DNKDVKHKDGVHHQWKHbW RIWKH4XU¶QUHYHDOHGRQHDIWHUWKHRWKHU DQGHPSKDVL]LQJWKHFRQQHFWLRQEHWZHHQÑDOKDQG]DNK WKRVHZKRHVWDEOLVKUHJXODUSUDHUDQGUHJXODUFKDULW@ 4XU¶Q
175.
5HSRUWHGE$PDGDQGDO1LV¶¯ZLWKDDVDQLVQG $SRVWDWHVIROORZLQJWKHGHDWKRIWKH3URSKHW7
176.
QXPHURXV$UDELDQWULEHVZKRKDGHPEUDFHG,VOPUHQRXQFHGWKHIDLWKDQGUHEHOOHG,Q SDUWLFXODUWKHUHIXVHGWRSD]DNKDOWKRXJKLWZDVRQHRIWKHFHQWUDOGXWLHVRIWKHUHOLJLRQWKHKDGVZRUQWRIROORZ$EÔ %DNUW
177.
DV NKDO¯IDKZDVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUEULQJLQJWKHPEDFNLQWR,VOPDQGUHVWRULQJRUGHUDQGVWDELOLWWRWKH,VOPLFVWDWH7UDQVODWRU@
ÎÎÎ
178.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
$QGEHVWHDGIDVWLQSUDHUSUDFWLVHUHJXODUFKDULW@ 4XU¶Q
179.
WKRVHZKR@HVWDEOLVKUHJXODUSUDHUVDQGUHJXODUFKDULW @ 4XU¶Q
180.
7KHWUXH0XVOLPIDVWVLQ5DPDŸQZLWKWKHVLQFHUHLQWHQWLRQRIHDUQLQJUHZDUGDQGZLWKKLVKHDUWIXOO RIIDLWK ´:KRHYHUIDVWV5DPDŸQRXWRIIDLWKDQGKRSHRIUHZDUGDOOKLVSUHYLRXVVLQVZLOOEHIRUJLYHQµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
181.
+H NQRZV WKDW
WKH REOLJDWLRQ WR IDVW LQFOXGHV JXDUGLQJ KLV WRQJXH KLV VLJKW DQG DOO RI KLV RWKHU IDFXOWLHVVRDVWRDYRLGFRPPLWWLQJDQHUURUZKLFKPDLQYDOLGDWHKLVIDVWRUFDQFHORXWKLVUHZDUG ´:KHQ DQ RI RX LV IDVWLQJ KH VKRXOG QRW XWWHU IRXO ZRUGV RU UDLVH KLV YRLFH LQ DQJHU ,I WKHQ DQRQH SURYRNHVRUILJKWVKLPKHVKRXOGVD¶,DPREVHUYLQJDIDVW·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
182.
´:KRHYHUGRHVQRWJLYHXSIDOVHVSHHFKDQGHYLODFWLRQV$OOKKDVQRQHHGRIKLVJLYLQJXSKLVIRRGDQG GULQNµ%XNKU¯
183.
7KHIDVWLQJ0XVOLPLVFRQVWDQWODZDUHWKDWWKLVLVDPRQWKXQOLNHDQRWKHULWLVWKHPRQWKRIIDVWLQJ IRUWKHVDNHRI$OOK,
184.
DQGWKHUHZDUGRI$OOK,
185.
WKH$OO%RXQWLIXODQG$OO0XQLILFHQWLVJUHDWHVW DQGYDVWHVWWKDQDQRQHFRXOGHYHULPDJLQH ´7KH UHZDUG IRU
HYHU JRRG GHHG RI WKH VRQV RI bGDP ZLOO EH PXOWLSOLHG DQZKHUH EHWZHHQ WHQ DQG VHYHQKXQGUHGWLPHV$OOKVDLG¶([FHSWIRUIDVWLQJEHFDXVHLWLVIRU0HDQG,0VHOIZLOOJLYHUHFRPSHQVH IRULW+HJLYHVXSKLVIRRGDQGKLVSDVVLRQIRU0H·)RUWKHRQHZKRIDVWVWKHUHDUHWZRWLPHVRIUHMRLFLQJ RQH ZKHQ KH EUHDNV KLV IDVW DQG RQH ZKHQ KH PHHWV KLV 5DEE 9HULO WKH VPHOO WKDW FRPHV IURP WKH PRXWKRIRQHZKR LVIDVWLQJLVPRUHSOHDVLQJWR$OOK,
186.
WKDQWKHVFHQWRIPXVNµ 0XVOLP
187.
6RWKHVPDUW0XVOLPWDNHVFDUHWRPDNHWKHPRVWRIWKLVEOHVVHGPRQWK+HILOOVLWVGDVZLWKIDVWLQJ SUDHU UHDGLQJ 4XU¶Q
FKDULW DQG RWKHU JRRG ZRUNV DQG ILOOV LWV QLJKWV ZLWK SUDHUV WDKDMMXG DQG GXµ¶V ´:KRHYHUVSHQGVWKHQLJKWLQSUDHUGXULQJ5DPDŸQRXWRIIDLWKDQGKRSHRIUHZDUGDOOKLVSUHYLRXVVLQV ZLOOEHIRUJLYHQµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
188.
7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI
$OOK 7
189.
XVHG WR VWULYH
WR GR PRUH JRRG GHHGV GXULQJ WKLV PRQWK WKDQ DW RWKHU WLPHVDQGHVSHFLDOOGXULQJWKHODVWWHQGDVRILWµb¶LVKDKVDLG ´7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
190.
XVHGWRVWULYHGXULQJ5DPDŸQDQGHVSHFLDOOWKHODVWWHQGDVRILWPRUH WKDQKHXVHGWRDWRWKHUWLPHVµ 0XVOLP
191.
µb¶LVKDKDOVRVDLG ´:KHQWKHODVWWHQGDVRI5DPDŸQEHJDQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
192.
ZRXOGVWDXSIRUWKHZKROH QLJKWZDNHKLVIDPLOXSVWULYHH[WUDKDUGDQGDEVWDLQIURPPDULWDOUHODWLRQVµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
193.
7KH3URSKHW7
194.
RUGHUHG0XVOLPVWRVHHNODODWDOTDGU DQGHQFRXUDJHGWKHPWRVSHQGWKLVQLJKWLQ SUDHU ´6HHNODODWDOTDGU GXULQJWKHODVWWHQGDVRI5DPDŸQµ
%XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
195.
196.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
´6HHNODODWDOTDGULQWKHRGGQXPEHUHGQLJKWVRIWKHODVWWHQGDVRI5DPDŸQµ %XNKU¯
197.
´:KRHYHUVSHQGVWKHQLJKWRIODODWDOTDGU LQSUDHUDQGZRUVKLSRXWRIIDLWKDQGKRSHRIUHZDUGDOOKLV SUHYLRXVVLQVZLOOEHIRUJLYHQµ %XNKU¯
DQG0XVOLP
198.
6RWKLVEOHVVHGPRQWKLVDWLPHWKDWLVSXUHOIRUZRUVKLS7KHVHULRXVPLQGHG0XVOLPKDVQRWLPHWR VSHQGRQFKDWWLQJDQGLGOHSXUVXLWVWKURXJKRXWWKHQLJKW+HVKRXOGQRWEHDPRQJWKRVHZKRZKLOHDZD WKH QLJKW XQWLO
GDZQ DSSURDFKHV ZKHUHXSRQ WKH KDYH VRPHWKLQJ WR HDW DQG IDOO LQWR D GHHS VOHHS DQG HYHQPLVVWKHIDMU SUDHU 7KH0XVOLPZKRWUXOXQGHUVWDQGVKLVUHOLJLRQGRHVQRWVWDXSODWHDIWHUKHFRPHVKRPHIURPSUDLQJ WDUZ¯KEHFDXVHKHNQRZVWKDWLQDIHZVKRUWKRXUV¶WLPHKHZLOOKDYHWRJHWXSDJDLQWRSUDTLPDO ODO DQGHDWVDÔU SUHGDZQPHDO
199.
EHIRUHKHJRHVRXWWRWKHPRVTXHWRSUDIDMU
7KH3URSKHW7
200.
FRPPDQGHG0XVOLPVWRHDWVDÔUEHFDXVHWKHUHLVPXFKJRRGQHVVLQLW+HVDLG ´(DWVDÔUIRULQVDÔUWKHUHLVEOHVVLQJµ %XNKU¯
DQG0XVOLP
201.
7KLVLVEHFDXVHJHWWLQJXSIRUVDÔU UHPLQGVRQHWRSUDTLPDOODODQGPRWLYDWHVRQHWRJRRXWWR WKHPRVTXHWRSUDIDMU LQFRQJUHJDWLRQLQDGGLWLRQWRWKHIDFWWKDWLWKHOSVSHRSOHWR
IDVWDQGWKDWLWLVWKH 6XQQDKRIWKH3URSKHW7
202.
WKDWKHDOVRWDXJKWWRKLV6DEDK=DGLEQ7KELWW
203.
VDLG ´:HDWHVDÔU ZLWKWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
204.
WKHQZHJRWXSWRSUDµ6RPHRQHDVNHG´+RZPXFK WLPH ZDV WKHUH
EHWZHHQ WKH WZRµ +H VDLG ´)LIW bW LH WKH WLPH LW ZRXOG WDNH WR UHFLWH ILIW bW
205.
µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
206.
7KH GHYRXW 0XVOLP
GRHV QRW QHJOHFW QILO IDVWV DW WLPHV RWKHU WKDQ 5DPDŸQ VXFK DV WKH GD RI µ$UDIKDQGWKHQLQWKDQGWHQWKGDVRI0XDUUDP)DVWLQJRQWKHVHGDVLVDPRQJWKHJRRGGHHGVZKLFK FDQZLSHRXWRQH¶VVLQVDVWKH3URSKHW7
207.
H[SODLQHG$EÔ 4XWGDKW
208.
VDLG ´7KH3URSKHW7
209.
ZDVDVNHGDERXWIDVWLQJRQWKHGDRI¶$UDIKDQGKHVDLG¶,WLVDQH[SLDWLRQIRUWKH VLQVRIWKHSUHYLRXVHDUDQGWKHFXUUHQWHDU·µ 0XVOLP
210.
,EQµ$EEVW
211.
VDLG ´7KH3URSKHW7
212.
IDVWHGRQWKHGDRI¶$VKÔU·WKHWHQWKGDRI0XDUUDP
213.
DQGFRPPDQGHGRWKHUVWR IDVWRQWKLVGDWRRµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
214.
$EÔ 4XWGDKW
215.
VDLG ´7KH3URSKHW7
216.
ZDVDVNHGDERXWIDVWLQJRQWKHGDRI¶$VKÔU·DQGKHVDLG¶,WLVDQH[SLDWLRQIRUWKH VLQVRIWKHSUHYLRXVHDU·µ 0XVOLP
217.
,EQµ$EEVW
218.
VDLG ´7KH3URSKHW7
219.
VDLG¶,I,DPVWLOODOLYHQH[WHDU,ZLOOIDVWRQWKHQLQWKGDRI0XDUUDP
220.
·µ 0XVOLP
221.
)DVWLQJ IRU VL[
GDV RI 6KDZZO WKH ,VOPLF PRQWK LPPHGLDWHO IROORZLQJ 5DPDŸQ
222.
LV VLPLODUO HQFRXUDJHGDVWKH3URSKHW7
223.
VDLG
ÎÎÐ
224.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
´:KRHYHU IDVWHG 5DPDŸQ WKHQ IROORZHG LW ZLWK VL[ GDV RI 6KDZZO LW ZLOO EH DV LI KH IDVWHG IRU D OLIHWLPHµ 0XVOLP
225.
,WLVDOVRUHFRPPHQGHGWRIDVWIRUWKUHHGDVRIHDFKPRQWKFRQFHUQLQJZKLFK$EÔ +XUDUDKW
226.
VDLG ´0GHDUHVWIULHQGLHWKH3URSKHW7
227.
@DGYLVHGPHWRGRWKUHHWKLQJVWRIDVWIRUWKUHHGDVRIHDFK PRQWKWRSUDWZRUDN¶DKVRIŸX SUDHUDQGQHYHUWRVOHHSXQWLO,SUDZLWUµ %XNKU¯
DQG0XVOLP
228.
$EÔO'DUG¶W
229.
VDLG ´0EHORYHGIULHQG7
230.
DGYLVHGPHWRGRWKUHHWKLQJVWKDW,ZLOOQHYHUJLYHXSDVORQJDV,OLYHWRIDVWWKUHH GDVRIHDFKPRQWKWRSUDŸX DQGQRWWRVOHHSXQWLO,KDYHSUDHGZLWUµ 0XVOLP
231.
µ$EGXOODKLEQµ$PULEQ DOµbÑ W
232.
VDLG ´7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
233.
VDLG¶)DVWLQJIRUWKUHHGDVHDFKPRQWKLVOLNHIDVWLQJIRUDQHQWLUHOLIHWLPH·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
234.
6RPHUHSRUWVGHVFULEHWKHVHGDVDVEHLQJWKHWKLUWHHQWKIRXUWHHQWKDQGILIWHHQWKRIWKHPRQWKZKLFK DUH FDOOHGDODPDOE¯Ÿ WKHZKLWHGDV
235.
RWKHUUHSRUWVVWDWHWKDWWKH3URSKHW7
236.
XVHGWRIDVWRQWKUHH XQVSHFLILHGGDVRIHDFKPRQWK 0XµGKDKDOµ$GDZLDKW
237.
VDLG ´, DVNHG ¶b·LVKDK
¶'LG WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OOK 7
238.
XVHG WR IDVW
WKUHH GDV LQ HDFK PRQWK· 6KH VDLG ¶HV·,DVNHGKHU¶,QZKLFKSDUWRIWKHPRQWKGLGKHXVHGWRIDVW·6KHVDLG¶+HGLGQRWPLQGLQZKLFK SDUWRIWKHPRQWKKHZRXOGIDVW·µ 0XVOLP
239.
7KHFRQVFLHQWLRXV0XVOLPLQWHQGVWRJRRQpDMMWRWKH+RXVHRI$OOK,
240.
ZKHQKHLVDEOHWR GRVR %HIRUHKHVHWVRXWRQKLVMRXUQHWRWKH+RO3ODFHVKHVWXGLHVWKHUXOHVRIpDMMLQJUHDWGHWDLOH[DPLQLQJ DOOLWVPDMRUDQGPLQRUDVSHFWVVRWKDWZKHQKHSHUIRUPVWKHULWHVRIpDMMKLVpDMMZLOOEHFRPSOHWHDQG FRUUHFW+HIXOOXQGHUVWDQGVWKHZLVGRPEHKLQGWKLVJUHDWUHOLJLRXVGXWDQGIHHOVKLVVRXOILOOHGZLWKWKH IDLWKDQGMRRI,VOP$IWHUFRPSOHWLQJpDMMVXFFHVVIXOOKHZLOOUHWXUQWRKLVIDPLODQGKLVFRXQWUDV IUHHRIVLQDVWKHGDKHZDVERUQDQGILOOHGZLWKWKHDZDUHQHVVRIWKHJUHDWQHVVRIWKLVUHOLJLRQWKDWKDV JDWKHUHG WKH
QDWLRQV RI WKH HDUWK DURXQG WKH +RXVH RI $OOK ,
241.
LQ D JUHDW
LQWHUQDWLRQDO FRQIHUHQFH WKH OLNH RI ZKLFK WKH ZRUOG ZLWQHVVHV DW QR RWKHU WLPH ZKHUH GHVSLWH WKH GLIIHUHQFHV LQ VNLQ FRORXU QDWLRQDOLW DQG ODQJXDJH WKH SLOJULPV DUH XQLWHG LQ WKHLU UHVSRQVH WR WKH FDOO RI $OOK ,
242.
DQG LQ WKHLU JORULILFDWLRQDQGZRUVKLSRI+LPWKH2QH$OPLJKW*RG +HLVDWUXHVODYHRI$OOK,
243.
,
7KH0XVOLPILUPOEHOLHYHVWKDWKLVVROHSXUSRVHLQOLIHLVWRZRUVKLSKLV5DEE ,KDYHRQOFUHDWHGMLQQVDQGPHQWKDWWKHPDZRUVKLS0H@ 4XU¶Q
244.
245.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
:RUVKLSSLQJ$OOK,
246.
PDEHDFFRPSOLVKHGWKURXJKHYHUGHHGRIPDQWKDWLVDLPHGDWEXLOGLQJ DFLYLOL]DWLRQHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHDXWKRULWRI$OOK,
247.
RQHDUWKDQGOLYLQJDFFRUGLQJWR+LVFRPPDQGPHQWV 7KH DZDUHQHVV WKDW
KH LV D VODYH RI $OOK ,
248.
LV GHHSO URRWHG
LQ WKH KHDUW RI WKH 0XVOLP DQG LV WKH VWDUWLQJSRLQWIRUDOOKLVGHHGVWKURXJKZKLFKKHVHHNVWRHDUQWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
249.
6RHYHUGHHGD 0XVOLPGRHVPDEHDVPXFKDQDFWRIZRUVKLSDVWKHULWXDOVRIKLVUHOLJLRQVRORQJDVKLVLQWHQWLRQLVWR GRWKHVHGHHGVIRUWKHVDNHRI$OOK,
250.
7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWDFWRIZRUVKLSWKDW0XVOLPVFDQSHUIRUPLVWRVWULYHWRHVWDEOLVKWKHUXOHRI$OOK,
251.
RQ HDUWK DQG
WR IROORZ WKH ZD RI OLIH WKDW +H KDV SUHVFULEHG VR WKDW ,VOP ZLOO JRYHUQ WKH OLIH RI WKH LQGLYLGXDOWKHIDPLOWKHFRPPXQLWDQGWKHQDWLRQ 7KHVLQFHUH0XVOLPZLOOIHHOWKDWKLVZRUVKLSLVODFNLQJLIKHGRHVQRWVWULYHWRDFKLHYHWKHSXUSRVHIRU ZKLFK$OOK,
252.
FUHDWHGMLQQ DQGPHQQDPHOSURPRWLQJWKHVXSUHPDFRIWKHDXWKRULWRI$OOK,
253.
RQ HDUWKZKLFKLVWKHRQOZDLQZKLFKPDQNLQGFDQWUXOZRUVKLS$OOK,
254.
,KDYHRQOFUHDWHGMLQQVDQGPHQWKDWWKHPDVHUYH0H@ 4XU¶Q
255.
7KLVLVWKH RQOZDLQZKLFKWKHWUXHPHDQLQJRI³ODLOKDLOO $OOK0XKDPPDGUDVÔO$OOK´PDEH LPSOHPHQWHGLQWKLVOLIH
:LWKWKLVFOHDUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHUHDOLWRIZRUVKLSLQ,VOPWKH0XVOLPFDQQRWEXWEHDPDQZLWKD PLVVLRQLQWKLVOLIHDPLVVLRQDLPHGDWHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHUXOHRI$OOK,
256.
DORQHLQDOODVSHFWVRIOLIH+LV ,VOP FDQQRW EH
FRPSOHWH XQOHVV KH VKRXOGHUV WKH UHVSRQVLELOLW IRU IXOILOOLQJ WKLV PLVVLRQ DQG GHYRWHV FRQFHUWHGVLQFHUHHIIRUWVWRWKDWHQG,WLVWKLVPLVVLRQWKDWJLYHVWKH0XVOLPDWUXHVHQVHRIEHORQJLQJWR ,VOPDQGWKDWLVWKHRQOWKLQJWKDWZLOOPDNHKLPMRLQWKHUDQNVRIWKHEHOLHYLQJVWULYLQJ0XVOLPVDQG JLYHPHDQLQJWRKLVOLIHDVEHILWVKLVUROHDVDNKDO¯IDK RQWKLVHDUWKRQHZKRP$OOK,
257.
KDVSUHIHUUHG RYHUPRVW RI+LVFUHDWLRQ :HKDYHKRQRXUHGWKHVRQVRIbGDPSURYLGHGWKHPZLWKWUDQVSRUWRQODQGDQGVHDJLYHQWKHP IRUVXVWHQDQFHWKLQJVJRRGDQGSXUHDQGFRQIHUUHGRQWKHPVSHFLDOIDYRXUVDERYHDJUHDWSDUWRI 2XUUHDWLRQ@ 4XU¶Q
258.
1R ZRQGHU WKDW
WKH VLQFHUH 0XVOLP MRIXOO HPEUDFHV WKLV PLVVLRQ DQG HDJHUO GHYRWHV DOO KLV UHVRXUFHVz KLVWLPHKLVHQHUJDQGKLVZHDOWKz WRIXOILOOLQJLW,WLVWKHGLVWLQJXLVKLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFRI KLVOLIHIRULWHQWLWOHVKLPWRGUDZFORVHUWR$OOK,
259.
:LWKRXWLWKLVOLIHKDVQRPHDQLQJDQGWKHUHLVQR JXDUDQWHHRIHDUQLQJWKHSOHDVXUHRI$OOK,
260.
H[FHSWEGHYRWLQJRQJRLQJHIIRUWVWRDFFRPSOLVKLQJWKLV PLVVLRQ 6WULYLQJ WR
HVWDEOLVK WKH UXOH RI $OOK ,
261.
RQ HDUWK LV
WKH JUHDWHVW IRUP RI ZRUVKLS WKDW WKH 0XVOLP FDQ XQGHUWDNH IRU LW EULQJV KLP FORVHU WR $OOK ,
262.
DQG DIIRUGV KLP
WKH PHDQV RI HDUQLQJ +LV SOHDVXUH 6R WKH 0XVOLP FRQWLQXDOO VWULYHV WR PDNH WKLV JRDO D UHDOLW +H JLYHV DOOHJLDQFH WR QR RWKHU FDXVHFDUULHVQREDQQHUH[FHSWWKDWRI,VOPDQGDGKHUHVRQOWRWKHSULQFLSOHVRIWKLVUHOLJLRQ +HRIWHQUHDGV4XU¶Q ,QRUGHUWRUHDFKVXFKDKLJKOHYHOWKH0XVOLPPXVWDOZDVSODFHKLPVHOILQWKHVKDGHRIWKH*ORULRXV 4XU¶QUHMRLFLQJLQLWVUHIUHVKLQJJXLGDQFHDQGDOORZLQJLWWRSRLQWKLPLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIULJKWHRXVQHVV ÎÎÒ
263.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
+H UHDGV 4XU¶Q RIWHQ ZLWK DQ DWWLWXGH RI KXPLOLW DQG VHHNLQJ WR XQGHUVWDQG LWV PHDQLQJ +H VHWV DVLGHUHJXODUWLPHVIRUUHDGLQJZKLFKKHQHYHUPLVVHVWKHVHDUHWLPHVZKLFKKHGHYRWHVVROHOWRUHDGLQJ WKH ZRUGV RI KLV 5DEE +H OHWV WKH WUXH PHDQLQJ RI WKH 4XU¶Q IORZ WKURXJK KLV VRXO FOHDQVLQJ DQG SXULILQJLWDQGLQFUHDVLQJKLVZLVGRPIDLWKDQGVHQVHRIVHFXULW )RUZLWKRXWGRXEWLQWKHUHPHPEUDQFHRI$OOKGRKHDUWVILQGVDWLVIDFWLRQ@ 4XU¶Q
264.
7KH0XVOLP UHPHPEHUVWKHEHDXWLIXOLPDJHRIWKHRQHZKRUHDGV4XU¶QDVSRUWUDHGVRYLYLGODQG HORTXHQWOEWKH3URSKHW7
265.
VRWKDWKHILOOVKLVGDVDQGQLJKWVZLWKUHFLWDWLRQRIWKH+RO%RRNDQG UHMRLFHVLQLWVEOHVVHGPHDQLQJV7KH3URSKHW7
266.
VDLG ´7KH OLNHQHVV RI
WKH EHOLHYHU ZKR UHDGV WKH 4XU·Q LV OLNH D FLWURQ ZKRVH VPHOO LV SOHDVDQW DQGZKRVH WDVWHLVSOHDVDQWWKHOLNHQHVVRIDEHOLHYHUZKRGRHVQRWUHDGWKH4XU·QLVOLNHDGDWHZKLFKKDVQR VPHOOEXWLWVWDVWHLVVZHHWWKHOLNHQHVVRIWKHKSRFULWHZKRUHDGVWKH4XU·QLVOLNHDIUDJUDQWIORZHU ZKLFKKDVDSOHDVDQWVFHQWEXWLWVWDVWHLVELWWHUDQGWKHOLNHQHVVRIWKHKSRFULWHZKRGRHVQRWUHDG WKH 4XU·Q LV OLNH D FRORFQWK ELWWHUDSSOH
267.
ZKLFK KDV QR
VPHOO DQG LWV WDVWH LV ELWWHUµ %XNKU¯ DQG 0XVOLP
268.
7KH3URSKHW7
269.
VDLG ´5HDGWKH4XU·QIRULWZLOOFRPHIRUZDUGRQWKH'DRI5HVXUUHFWLRQWRLQWHUFHGHIRULWVUHDGHUVµ 0XVOLP
270.
$QGKH7
271.
VDLG ´2QH ZKR UHDGV
WKH 4XU·Q IOXHQWO LV ZLWK WKH KRQRXUDEOH SLRXV VFULEHV DQG RQH ZKR UHDGV WKH 4XU·Q DQG VWUXJJOHV WR UHDG LW HYHQ WKRXJK LW LV GLIILFXOW IRU KLP ZLOO UHFHLYH D GRXEOH UHZDUGµ %XNKU¯ DQG 0XVOLP
272.
DQDQ0XVOLPWKHQLJQRUHWKH4XU¶QDQGIDLOWRUHDGLWDQGUHIOHFWXSRQLWVPHDQLQJV
,Q FRQFOXVLRQ WKHUHIRUH WKH WUXH 0XVOLP¶V UHVSRQVLELOLW WRZDUGV KLV 5DEE LV WR KDYH GHHS VLQFHUH IDLWKWRGRFRQVWDQWJRRGZRUNDQGFRQWLQXDOOWRVHHN+LVSOHDVXUHWREHDWUXHVHUYDQWWR+LPDQGWR IXOILOWKHSXUSRVHRIKLVH[LVWHQFHDV$OOK,
273.
KDVGHILQHGLW ,KDYHRQOFUHDWHGMLQQV DQGPHQWKDWWKHPDVHUYH0H@ 4XU¶Q
274.
LHWKHDQJHOVZKRUHFRUGWKHGHHGVRIPDQ7KHPHDQLQJLVWKDWRQHZKRLVZHOOYHUVHGLQ4XU¶QZLOOHQMRVXFKDKLJKVWDWXVLQWKH +HUHDIWHUWKDWKHZLOOEHLQWKHH[DOWHGFRPSDQRIWKHVHSLRXVVFULEHV7UDQVODWRU@
275.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
ÎÎÔ
276.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
KDSWHU7ZR 7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV2ZQ6HOI ,QWURGXFWLRQ ,VOP ZDQWV WKH 0XVOLP WR VWDQG RXW DPRQJ SHRSOH UHDGLO GLVWLQJXLVKHG E KLV DSSHDUDQFH GUHVV GHFHQWEHKDYLRXUDQGJRRGGHHGVVRWKDWKHZLOOEHDJRRGH[DPSOHDQGZRUWKRIWKHJUHDWPHVVDJHWKDW KHEULQJVWRSHRSOH $FFRUGLQJ WR D DG¯WK QDUUDWHG E WKH JUHDW 6DE¯ ,EQ DO pDQ]DOLDK WKH 3URSKHW 7
277.
WROG KLV RPSDQLRQVZKHQWKHZHUHWUDYHOOLQJWRPHHWVRPHEURWKHUVLQIDLWK ´RXDUHJRLQJWRYLVLWRXUEURWKHUVVRUHSDLURXUVDGGOHVDQGPDNHVXUHWKDWRXDUHGUHVVHGZHOOVR WKDWRXZLOOVWDQGRXWDPRQJSHRSOHOLNHDQDGRUQPHQWIRU$OOK,
278.
GRHVQRWORYHXJOLQHVVµ
7KH 3URSKHW 7
279.
FRQVLGHUHG DQ XQNHPSW
DQG FDUHOHVV DSSHDUDQFH DQG VFUXII FORWKHV DQG IXUQLVKLQJVWREHIRUPVRIXJOLQHVVZKLFKLVKDWHGDQGIRUELGGHQE,VOP 7KHWUXH0XVOLPGRHVQRWQHJOHFWKLPVHOIQRPDWWHUKRZEXVKHLVZLWKKLV,VOPLFUHVSRQVLELOLWLHV EHFDXVH WKH RXWZDUG DSSHDUDQFH RI D PDQ FDQQRW EH VHSDUDWHG IURP KLV LQQHU QDWXUH $ UHILQHG DQG SOHDVDQW DSSHDUDQFH EHILWV D QREOH DQG GHFHQW HVVHQFH WKLV LV KRZ WKH 0XVOLP ZKR LV WR FDOO RWKHUV WR $OOK,
280.
VKRXOGEH
7KH VPDUW 0XVOLP LV RQH ZKR VWULNHV D EDODQFH EHWZHHQ WKH QHHGV RI KLV ERG PLQG DQG VRXO +H JLYHVHDFKWKHDWWHQWLRQLWGHVHUYHVDQGGRHVQRWH[DJJHUDWHLQRQHDVSHFWWRWKHGHWULPHQWRIWKHRWKHUV ,QVHHNLQJWRVWULNHWKHULJKWEDODQFHKHLVIROORZLQJWKHZLVHJXLGDQFHRIWKH3URSKHW7
281.
µ$EGXOODKLEQµ$PULEQDOµbÑ W
282.
UHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW7
283.
NQHZDERXWKLVH[DJJHUDWLRQLQ ZRUVKLSEHFDXVHKHWROGKLPµ$EGXOODK
284.
´+DYH , QRW
KHDUG WKDW RX IDVW DOO GD DQG VWD XS DOO QLJKW LQ SUDHUµ +H VDLG ´7KDW LV WUXH 2 0HVVHQJHURI$OOKµ7KH3URSKHW7
285.
WROGKLP´'RQRWGRWKDW)DVWDQGEUHDNRXUIDVWVOHHSDQGJHW XS)RURXUERGKDVDULJKWRYHURXRXUHHVKDYHDULJKWRYHURXRXUZLIHKDVDULJKWRYHURX DQGRXUYLVLWRUVKDYHDULJKWRYHURXµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
286.
+RZFDQWKH0XVOLPDFKLHYHWKLVEDODQFHEHWZHHQKLVERGPLQGDQGVRXO
5HSRUWHGE$EÔ 'ZÔGDO+NLPLQDO0XVWDGUDN,WVLVQG LVDVDQ
287.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
+LV%RG 0RGHUDWLRQLQIRRGDQGGULQN 7KH 0XVOLP WDNHV JRRG FDUH RI KLV ERG DFWLYHO SURPRWLQJ LWV JRRG KHDOWK DQG VWUHQJWK 6R KH LV PRGHUDWHLQKLVLQWDNHRIIRRGDQGGULQNDYRLGLQJJUHHGDQGFRQVXPLQJRQOZKDWKHQHHGVWRPDLQWDLQ KLVZHOOEHLQJDQGHQHUJ7KLVLVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHJXLGDQFHRI$OOK,
288.
LQWKH4XU¶Q (DWDQGGULQNEXWZDVWHQRWEH[FHVVIRU$OOKORYHVQRWWKHZDVWHUV@ 4XU¶Q
289.
6LPLODUOWKH3URSKHW7
290.
DOVRDGYLVHGPRGHUDWLRQLQIRRGDQGGULQN ´7KHUHLVQRZRUVHYHVVHOIRUWKHVRQRIbGDPWRILOOWKDQKLVRZQVWRPDFKEXWLIKHPXVWILOOLWWKHQOHWKLP DOORZRQHWKLUGIRUIRRGRQHWKLUGIRUGULQNDQGRQHWKLUGIRUDLUµ
µ8PDUW
291.
VDLG ´%HZDUHRIILOOLQJRXUVWRPDFKVZLWKIRRGDQGGULQNIRULWLVKDUPIXOWRWKHERGDQGFDXVHVVLFNQHVVDQG OD]LQHVV LQ SHUIRUPLQJ
SUDHUV %H PRGHUDWH LQ ERWK IRRG DQG GULQN IRU WKDW LV KHDOWKLHU IRU RXU ERGLHV DQG IXUWKHVW UHPRYHG IURP H[WUDYDJDQFH $OOK ,
292.
ZLOO KDWH WKH
IDW PDQ RQH ZKR UHYHOV LQ D OLIH RI OX[XU
293.
DQGDPDQZLOOQRWEHFRQGHPQHGXQWLOKHIDYRXUVKLVGHVLUHVRYHUKLVUHOLJLRQµ
7KH 0XVOLP DYRLGV GUXJV DQG VWLPXODQWV HVSHFLDOO WKRVH ZKLFK DUH FOHDUO NQRZQ WR EH DUP+H VOHHSVHDUODQGZDNHVHDUODQGGRHVQRWWDNHPHGLFLQHH[FHSWIRULOOQHVV%HVLGHVWKLVHYHUWKLQJLQKLV ZDRIOLIHLVDLPHGDWSURPRWLQJKLVQDWXUDOKHDOWKDQGHQHUJ 7KH VPDUW 0XVOLP NQRZV WKDW D VWURQJ EHOLHYHU LV PRUH ORYHGE$OOK,
294.
WKDQDZHDNRQHDVWKH 3URSKHW7
295.
VDLGVRKHWULHVWRVWUHQJWKHQKLVERGWKURXJKDKHDOWKOLIHVWOH +HH[HUFLVHVUHJXODUO
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¯WKQDUUDWHGE$PDGDO7LUPLGK¯HWDODQGDXWKHQWLFDWHGDV ÑD¯ EDOpNLP DO.DQ] ÎÎÖ
296.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
,IKHLVWRUHDSWKHEHQHILWVRIH[HUFLVHKHSODQVWRH[HUFLVHUHJXODUODQGGRHVQRWJLYHXS$OORI WKLVLVGRQHLQDQRUJDQL]HGDQGVVWHPDWLFIDVKLRQEXWLQPRGHUDWLRQDVWKLVLVWKHKDOOPDUNRIWKHWUXH 0XVOLPLQHYHUSODFHDQGDJH +LVERGDQGFORWKHVDUHFOHDQ 7KH 0XVOLP ZKRP ,VOP ZDQWV WR VWDQG RXW DPRQJ SHRSOH LV YHU FOHDQ +H KDV KLJK VWDQGDUGV RI SHUVRQDO KJLHQH EDWKLQJ IUHTXHQWO LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH JXLGDQFH RI WKH 3URSKHW 7
297.
ZKR HQFRXUDJHGSHRSOHWRZDVKWKHPVHOYHVFRPSOHWHODQGZHDUSHUIXPH HVSHFLDOORQ)ULGDV ´+DYH D
EDWK RQ )ULGDV DQG ZDVKRXUKHDGVHYHQLIRXDUHQRWLQDVWDWHRIMDQEDKLPSXULWHJ IROORZLQJVH[XDOUHODWLRQV
298.
DQGZHDUSHUIXPHµ %XNKU¯
299.
7KH 3URSKHW 7
300.
SODFHG VXFK D
JUHDW HPSKDVLV RQ FOHDQOLQHVV DQG EDWKLQJ WKDW VRPH RI WKH IRXU ,PPVFRQVLGHUHGSHUIRUPLQJJKXVO EHIRUH)ULGDSUDHUWREHREOLJDWRUZMLE
301.
$EÔ +XUDUDKW
302.
VDLG ´7KH 3URSKHW 7
303.
VDLG ¶,W LV
WKH GXW RI HYHU 0XVOLP WR WDNH D EDWK DW OHDVW
304.
RQFHHYHUVHYHQGDV DQGWRZDVKKLVKHDGDQGERG·µ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
305.
7KHWUXH0XVOLPNHHSVKLVFORWKHVDQGVRFNVFOHDQFKHFNLQJWKHPIURP WLPHWRWLPHWREHVXUHWKDW WKH KDYH
QR XQSOHDVDQW VPHOO +H DOVR ZHDUV SHUIXPH WR KHOS NHHS KLPVHOI FOHDQ ,W LV UHSRUWHG WKDW µ8PDUW
306.
XVHGWRVD³:KRHYHUVSHQGVDWKLUGRIKLVZHDOWKRQSHUIXPHLVQRWEHLQJH[WUDYDJDQW´
7KHVPDUW0XVOLPWDNHVFDUHRIKLVPRXWKIRUQRRQHVKRXOGHYHUKDYHWRVPHOODQXQSOHDVDQWRGRXU FRPLQJ IURP LW +H GRHV WKLV E FOHDQLQJ KLV WHHWK HYHU GD ZLWK D VLZN WRRWKEUXVK WRRWKSDVWH DQG PRXWKZDVKHV+HDOVRYLVLWVWKHGHQWLVWUHJXODUOWRFKHFNKLVPRXWKDWOHDVWRQFHDHDUDQGYLVLWVRWKHU VSHFLDOLVWV VXFK DV RWRODUQJRORJLVWV RU ³HDU QRVH DQG WKURDW´ GRFWRUV
307.
DV QHFHVVDU VR
WKDW KLV PRXWK ZLOOVWDFOHDQDQGKLVEUHDWKIUHVK µb¶LVKDKQDUUDWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW7
308.
´QHYHUZRNHIURPVOHHSLQJDWDQWLPHRIGDRUQLJKWZLWKRXW FOHDQLQJKLVWHHWKZLWKDVLZN EHIRUHSHUIRUPLQJZXŸÔ·µ
7KH3URSKHW¶VFRQFHUQIRURUDOKJLHQHZDVVRJUHDWWKDWKHVDLG ´,ILWZHUHQRWIRUWKHIDFWWKDW,GLGQRWZDQWWRRYHUEXUGHQP8PPDK,ZRXOGKDYHRUGHUHGWKHPWR XVHWKHVLZN EHIRUHHYHUSUDHUµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
309.
µb¶LVKDK ZDV DVNHG
ZKDW WKH 3URSKHW 7
310.
XVHG WR GR
ILUVW ZKHQ KH FDPH KRPH 6KH VDLG ³8VH VLZN´0XVOLP
311.
5HJUHWWDEOVRPH0XVOLPVQHJOHFWWKHVHWHDFKLQJVWKDWDUHDWWKHKHDUWRI,VOPDQGGRQRWSDKHHG WR WKH FOHDQOLQHVV
RI WKHLU PRXWKV ERGLHV DQG FORWKHV 6R RX PD VHH WKHP JRLQJ WR WKH PRVTXH RU WR RWKHU UHOLJLRXV PHHWLQJV DQG VWXG FLUFOHV DQQRLQJ WKHLU EURWKHUV ZLWK WKHLU XQSOHDVDQW VPHOO DQG :HDULQJSHUIXPHLQSXEOLFLVIRUPHQRQOZRPHQDUHQRWSHUPLWWHGWRGRVR7UDQVODWRU@ $DVDQDG¯WKQDUUDWHGE$PDGDQG$EÔ 'ZÔG
312.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
RIIHQGLQJWKHDQJHOVZKRVXUURXQGWKHVHEOHVVHGJDWKHULQJV:KDWLVUHDOOVWUDQJHLVWKHIDFWWKDWWKH WKHPVHOYHVOLVWHQWRDQGUHSHDWWKHVDLQJRIWKH3URSKHW7
313.
WKDWZKRHYHUHDWVRQLRQVJDUOLFRUOHHNV VKRXOGQRWJRWRWKHPRVTXHEHFDXVHKLVEUHDWKPDGLVWXUEWKHDQJHOVDQGWKHSHRSOH ´:KRHYHUHDWVRQLRQVJDUOLFRUOHHNVVKRXOGQRWDSSURDFKRXUPRVTXHEHFDXVHZKDWHYHURIIHQGVWKH VRQVRIbGDPPDRIIHQGWKHDQJHOVµ 0XVOLP
314.
7KH3URSKHW7
315.
EDQQHGWKRVHZKRKDGHDWHQWKHVHSXQJHQWYHJHWDEOHVIURPFRPLQJDQZKHUHQHDU WKH PRVTXH OHVW
WKH SHRSOH DQG WKH DQJHOV EH RIIHQGHG E WKHLU EDG EUHDWK EXW WKHVH VPHOOV SDOH LQWR LQVLJQLILFDQFHEHVLGHWKHVWHQFKRIGLUWFORWKHVILOWKVRFNVXQZDVKHGERGLHVDQGXQFOHDQPRXWKVWKDW HPDQDWHIURPVRPHFDUHOHVVDQGXQNHPSWLQGLYLGXDOVZKRRIIHQGRWKHUVLQDQJDWKHULQJ ,PP$PDGDQG,PPDO1LV¶¯ QDUUDWHWKDW-ELUW
316.
VDLG ´7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI
$OOK 7
317.
FDPH WR YLVLW
XV DQG VDZ D PDQ ZKR ZDV ZHDULQJ GLUW FORWKHV +H VDLG ¶RXOGWKLVSHUVRQQRWILQGDQWKLQJZLWKZKLFKWRZDVKKLVFORWKHV·´ 7KH3URSKHW7
318.
GLGQRWOLNHD0XVOLPWRDSSHDUEHIRUHSHRSOHZHDULQJGLUWFORWKHVLIKHKDGWKH PHDQVWRFOHDQWKHP+HHQFRXUDJHG0XVOLPVDOZDVWRGUHVVLQFOHDQFORWKHVDQGWRSUHVHQWDQHDWDQG DWWUDFWLYHDSSHDUDQFH+HXVHGWRVD ´7KHUHLVQRWKLQJZURQJZLWKNHHSLQJWZRJDUPHQWVIRU)ULGDDSDUWIURPRQH·VZRUNFORWKHVµ
,VOPIUHTXHQWOHQFRXUDJHVLWVIROORZHUVWREHFOHDQDOZDVWRSHUIXPHWKHLUFORWKHVDQGWRHQVXUHWKDW WKHLUERGLHVDOZDVVPHOOIUHVKDQGFOHDQ7KLVLVZKDWWKH3URSKHW7
319.
XVHGWRGRDFFRUGLQJWRWKHUHSRUW WKDW,PP0XVOLPTXRWHVIURP$QDVLEQ0OLNZKRVDLG³,KDYHQHYHUVPHOWDQDPEHUJULVRUPXVNWKDW KDGDEHWWHUVFHQWWKDQWKHVFHQWRIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
320.
´
0DQUHSRUWVGHVFULEHWKHFOHDQOLQHVVRIWKH3URSKHW¶VFORWKHVDQGERGDQGGHVFULEHWKHVZHHWVPHOO RIKLVVZHDW)RUH[DPSOHLIKHVKRRNKDQGVZLWKDPDQKLVEHDXWLIXOVFHQWZRXOGUHPDLQRQWKDWPDQ¶V KDQGIRUWKHUHVWRIWKHGDDQGLIKHODLGKLVKDQGRQWKHKHDGRIDFKLOGWKDWFKLOGZRXOGVWDQGRXWIURP RWKHUVEYLUWXHRIKLVVZHHWVPHOO ,PP %XNKU¯ PHQWLRQV LQ DO7U¯NK DONDE¯U UHSRUWLQJ IURP -ELU WKDW WKH 3URSKHW 7
321.
QHYHU SDVVHG WKURXJK D
SODFH EXW D SHUVRQ ZKR IROORZHG KLP ZRXOG NQRZ WKDW KH KDG EHHQ WKHUH IURP KLV OLQJHULQJVFHQW 2QFHWKH3URSKHW7
322.
VOHSWLQWKHKRXVHRI$QDV+HVZHDWHGDQG8PP$QDVFDPHWRFROOHFWWKH VZHDWLQDERWWOH7KH3URSKHW7
323.
DVNHGKHUDERXWZKDWVKHZDVGRLQJDQGVKHWROGKLP ´7KLVLVRXU VZHDWZHDGGLWWRRXUSHUIXPHDQGLWLVWKHEHVWRISHUIXPHVµ 0XVOLP
324.
+RZ XUJHQW LV
WKH0XVOLPV¶QHHGWRIROORZWKHJXLGDQFHRIWKLVJUHDW0HVVHQJHULQKLVFRPPDQGWR WDNHFDUHRIRQH¶VKDLUDQGNHHSLWQHDWLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHWHDFKLQJVRI,VOP7KLVLVUHSRUWHGLQWKH DG¯WKWKDW$EÔ 'ZÔGTXRWHVIURP$EÔ +XUDUDKW
325.
ZKRVDLG ´7KH3URSKHW7
326.
VDLG¶:KRHYHUKDVKDLUOHWKLPORRNDIWHULWSURSHUO·µ
5HSRUWHGE$EÔ 'ZÔG,EQ0MDK,WVLVQ G LVÑD¯ ÎÏÎ
327.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
/RRNLQJ DIWHU RQH¶V KDLU DFFRUGLQJ WR ,VOPLF WHDFKLQJ LQYROYHV NHHSLQJ LW FOHDQ FRPELQJ LW SHUIXPLQJLWDQGVWOLQJLWQLFHO 7KH3URSKHW7
328.
GLGQRWOLNHSHRSOHWROHDYHWKHLUKDLUXQFRPEHGDQGXQNHPSWVRWKDWWKHORRNHG OLNHZLOGPRQVWHUV+HGHVFULEHGVXFKDQXJODSSHDUDQFHDVEHLQJOLNHWKH6KDÓQ,QDO0XZDÓÓ,PP 0OLNUHSRUWVDDG¯WKZLWKDPXUVDOLVQG IURPµ$Ó¶LEQDVVUZKRVDLG ´7KH 0HVVHQJHU
RI $OOK 7
329.
ZDV LQ WKH
PRVTXH ZKHQ D PDQZLWKXQNHPSWKDLUDQGDQXQWLGEHDUG FDPHLQ7KH3URSKHW7
330.
SRLQWHGWRKLPDVLILQGLFDWLQJWKDWWRKLPWKDWKHVKRXOGWLGXSKLVKDLUDQG EHDUG7KHPDQZHQWDQGGLGVRWKHQUHWXUQHG7KH3URSKHW7
331.
VDLG¶,VWKLVQRWEHWWHUWKDQWKDWDQ RQHRIRXVKRXOGFRPHZLWKXQNHPSWKDLUORRNLQJOLNHWKH6KDÓQµ
7KH 3URSKHW¶V OLNHQLQJ D PDQ ZLWK XQWLG KDLU WR WKH 6KDÓQ FOHDUO VKRZV KRZ FRQFHUQHG ,VOP LV ZLWKDQHDWDQGSOHDVDQWDSSHDUDQFHDQGKRZRSSRVHGLWLVWRVFUXIILQHVVDQGXJOLQHVV 7KH3URSKHW7
332.
DOZDVWRRNQRWHRISHRSOH¶VDSSHDUDQFHDQGKHQHYHUVDZDVFUXIILOGUHVVHGPDQ ZLWKXQWLGKDLUEXWKHFULWLFL]HGKLPIRUKLVVHOIQHJOHFW,PP$PDGDQGDO1LV¶¯ UHSRUWWKDW-ELUW
333.
VDLG³7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
334.
FDPHWRYLVLWXVDQGKHVDZDQXQNHPSWPDQZKRVHKDLUZDVJRLQJ LQDOOGLUHFWLRQVVRKHVDLGµRXOGKHQRWILQGDQWKLQJZLWKZKLFKWRFDOPKLVKHDG¶´ *RRGDSSHDUDQFH
7KHWUXH0XVOLPWDNHVJRRGFDUHRIKLVFORWKHVVRRXZLOOVHHKLPSUHVHQWLQJDSOHDVDQWDSSHDUDQFH ZLWKRXW EHLQJ H[WUDYDJDQW +H LV SOHDVDQW WR ORRN DW DQG WR PHHW DQG GRHV QRW DQQR SHRSOH ZLWK KLV FDUHOHVV GLVKHYHOOHG DSSHDUDQFH +H DOZDV FKHFNV KLPVHOI EHIRUH KH JRHV RXW WR PHHW SHRSOH DQG KH PDNHVKLPVHOIORRNJRRGLQPRGHUDWLRQIRUWKH3URSKHW7
335.
XVHGWRPDNHKLPVHOIORRNJRRGLQIURQWRI KLVRPSDQLRQVDVZHOODVLQIURQWRIKLVIDPLO ,QKLVFRPPHQWDURQWKHbDK 6D:KRKDVIRUELGGHQWKHEHDXWLIXOJLIWV@RI$OOKZKLFK+HKDVSURGXFHGIRU+LV VHUYDQWVDQG WKHWKLQJVFOHDQDQGSXUHZKLFK+HKDVSURYLGHG@IRUVXVWHQDQFH@ 4XU¶Q
336.
$O4XUÓXE¯ VDLG³0DNÔOUHSRUWHGIURPµb¶LVKDKµ$JURXSRIWKHRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHW7
337.
ZDVZDLWLQJDWWKHGRRUIRUKLPVRKHSUHSDUHGWRJRRXW WRPHHWWKHP7KHUHZDVDYHVVHORIZDWHULQWKH KRXVHDQGKHSHHUHGLQWRLWVPRRWKLQJKLVEHDUGDQGKLVKDLUµb¶LVKDKVDLG
338.
,DVNHGKLP³20HVVHQJHU RI$OOKHYHQRXGRWKLV´+HVDLG ´HVZKHQDPDQJRHVRXWWRPHHWKLVEURWKHUVOHWKLPSUHSDUH KLPVHOISURSHUOIRU$OOK,
339.
LVEHDXWLIXODQGORYHVEHDXWµ·µ
7KH0XVOLPGRHVDOORIWKLVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKH,VOPLFLGHDORIPRGHUDWLRQDYRLGLQJWKHH[WUHPHV RIHLWKHUH[DJJHUDWLRQRUQHJOLJHQFH 7KRVH ZKR ZKHQ WKH VSHQG DUH QRW H[WUDYDJDQW DQG QRW QLJJDUGO EXW KROG D MXVW EDODQFH@ EHWZHHQWKRVHH[WUHPHV@@ 4XU¶Q
340.
341.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
,VOP ZDQWV LWV IROORZHUV DQG HVSHFLDOO LWV DGYRFDWHV Gµ¯V
342.
WR VWDQG RXW
LQ JDWKHULQJV LQ DQ DWWUDFWLYH IDVKLRQ QRW WR DSSHDU XQVLJKWO RU XQEHDUDEOH 1HJOHFWLQJ RQH¶V DSSHDUDQFH WR WKH H[WHQW RI EHLQJ RIIHQVLYH WR RQH¶V FRPSDQLRQV LQ WKH QDPH RI DVFHWLFLVP DQG KXPLOLW LV QRW SDUW RI ,VOP 7KH 3URSKHW 7
343.
ZKR ZDV WKH
HSLWRPH RI DVFHWLFLVP DQG KXPLOLW XVHG WR GUHVV LQ GHFHQW FORWKHV DQG SUHVHQWDSOHDVDQWDSSHDUDQFHWRKLVIDPLODQGKLVFRPSDQLRQV+HUHJDUGHGGUHVVLQJZHOODQGORRNLQJ JRRGDVDGHPRQVWUDWLRQRIWKHEOHVVLQJVRI$OOK,
344.
´$OOK,
345.
ORYHVWRVHHWKHVLJQVRI+LVJLIWVRQ+LVVODYHµ
,EQ6DµGUHSRUWVLQDO†DEDTWWKDW-XQGDELEQ0DN¯WKW
346.
VDLG ´:KHQHYHUDGHOHJDWLRQFDPHWRPHHWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
347.
KHZRXOGZHDUKLVEHVWFORWKHVDQG RUGHUKLVOHDGLQJRPSDQLRQVWRGROLNHZLVH,VDZWKH3URSKHW7
348.
RQWKHGDWKDWWKHGHOHJDWLRQRI .LQGDKFDPHWRPHHWKLPKHZDVZHDULQJDHPHQL JDUPHQWDQG$EÔ %DNUDQG¶8PDUZHUHGUHVVHG VLPLODUOµ
,EQDO0XEUDNDO†DEDUQ¯DOpNLPDO%DKDT¯ DQGRWKHUVUHSRUWWKDWµ8PDUW
349.
VDLG ´,VDZWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OOK7
350.
DVNIRUDQHZJDUPHQW+HSXWLWRQDQGZKHQLWUHDFKHGKLVNQHHVKH VDLG ¶3UDLVH EH
WR $OOK :KR KDV JLYHQ PH FORWKHV ZLWK ZKLFK WR FRYHU PVHOI DQG PDNH PVHOI ORRN EHDXWLIXOLQWKLVOLIH·µ µ$EGXO5DPQLEQµ$ZIW
351.
XVHGWRGUHVVLQDFORDNRUJDUPHQWWKDWZDVZRUWKIRXURUILYHKXQGUHG GLUKDPV 7DEDTW ,EQ
6DµG
352.
DQG ,EQµ$EEVERXJKWDJDUPHQWZRUWKRQHWKRXVDQG GLUKDPV
DQG ZRUHLW†DEDTW,EQ6DµG
353.
6RORQJDVWKLVWDNLQJFDUHRIRQH¶VRXWZDUGDSSHDUDQFHGRHVQRWJRWRH[WUHPHVWKHQLWLVSDUWRIWKH EHDXWWKDW$OOK,
354.
KDVDOORZHGIRU+LVVODYHVDQGHQFRXUDJHGWKHPWRDGRSW 2FKLOGUHQRIbGDP:HDURXUEHDXWLIXODSSDUHODWHYHUWLPHDQGSODFHRISUDHUHDWDQGGULQN EXWZDVWHQRWEH[FHVVIRU$OOKORYHVQRWWKHZDVWHUV6DZKRKDVIRUELGGHQWKHEHDXWLIXOJLIWV@ RI $OOK ZKLFK
+H KDV SURGXFHG IRU +LV VHUYDQWV DQG WKH WKLQJV FOHDQ DQG SXUH ZKLFK +H KDV SURYLGHG@IRUVXVWHQDQFH6D7KHDUHLQWKHOLIHRIWKLVZRUOGIRUWKRVHZKREHOLHYHDQG@SXUHO IRU WKHP RQ WKH 'D RI -XGJHPHQW 7KXV GR :H H[SODLQ WKH 6LJQV LQ GHWDLO IRU WKRVH ZKR XQGHUVWDQG@ 4XU¶Q
355.
0XVOLPUHSRUWVIURP,EQ0DVµÔGW
356.
WKDWWKH3URSKHW7
357.
VDLG ´1R RQH ZKR
KDV HYHQ DQ DWRP·VZHLJKW RI SULGH LQ KLV KHDUW ZLOO HQWHU 3DUDGLVHµ $ PDQ DVNHG KLP ´:KDW LI KH OLNHV KLV FORWKHV DQG VKRHV WRORRNJRRGµ0HDQLQJLVWKLVFRXQWHGDVSULGH
358.
7KH3URSKHW 7
359.
VDLG ´$OOK ,
360.
LV EHDXWLIXO DQGORYHVEHDXW3ULGHPHDQVGHQLQJWKHWUXWKDQGORRNLQJGRZQRQ RWKHUSHRSOHµ
7KLVLVWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJDGRSWHGEWKH6DEDK DQGWKRVHZKRIROORZHGWKHPVLQFHUHO7KHUHIRUH ,PP$EÔ pDQ¯IDKW
361.
DOZDVWRRNFDUHWRGUHVVZHOODQGWRHQVXUHWKDWKHVPHOOHGFOHDQDQGIUHVKDQG
$ pDVDQDG¯WK QDUUDWHGEDO7LUPLGK¯ DQGDOpDN¯P ÎÏÐ
362.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
XUJHGRWKHUVWRGROLNHZLVH2QHGDKHPHWDPDQZKRXVHGWRDWWHQGKLVFLUFOHZKRZDVGUHVVHGLQ VFUXII FORWKHV +H WRRN KLP WR RQH VLGH DQG RIIHUHG KLP RQH WKRXVDQG GLUKDPV ZLWK ZKLFK WR VPDUWHQ KLPVHOIXS7KHPDQWROGKLP³,KDYHPRQH,GRQRWQHHGWKLV´$EÔ pDQ¯IDKDGPRQLVKHGKLP³+DYH RXQRWKHDUGWKHDG¯WKµ$OOK,
363.
ORYHVWRVHHWKHVLJQVRI+LVJLIWVRQ+LVVHUYDQW¶6RRXKDYHWR FKDQJHRXUVHOIDQGQRWDSSHDURIIHQVLYHWRRXUIULHQG´
1DWXUDOOWKRVHZKRFDOOSHRSOHWR$OOK,
364.
VKRXOGEHEHWWHUDQGVPDUWHULQDSSHDUDQFHWKDQRWKHUV VRWKDWWKHZLOOEHEHWWHUDEOHWRDWWUDFWSHRSOHDQGPDNHWKHLUPHVVDJHUHDFKWKHLUKHDUWV,QGHHGWKH XQOLNHRWKHUVDUHUHTXLUHGWREHOLNHWKLVHYHQLIWKHGRQRWJRRXWDQGPHHWSHRSOHEHFDXVHWKRVHZKR SURFODLPWKHZRUGRI$OOK,
365.
VKRXOGWDNHFDUHRIWKHLUDSSHDUDQFHDQGSDDWWHQWLRQWRWKHFOHDQOLQHVV RI WKHLU ERGLHV
FORWKHV QDLOV DQG KDLU 7KH VKRXOG GR WKLV HYHQ LI WKH DUH LQ D VWDWH RI LVRODWLRQ RU UHWUHDWLQUHVSRQVHWRWKHFDOORIWKHQDWXUDOXQDIIHFWHGLQFOLQDWLRQRIPDQILÓUDK
366.
ZKLFKWKH3URSKHW7
367.
WROGXVDERXWDQGRXWOLQHGLWVUHTXLUHPHQWV ´)LYH WKLQJV DUH
SDUW RI WKHILÓUDKFLUFXPFLVLRQUHPRYLQJWKHSXELFKDLUSOXFNLQJKDLUIURPWKHDUPSLWV FXWWLQJWKHQDLOVDQGWULPPLQJWKHPRXVWDFKHµ %XNKU¯ DQG0XVOLP
368.
7DNLQJFDUHRIRQHVHOILQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKLVILÓUDK LVVRPHWKLQJHQFRXUDJHGE,VOPDQGVXSSRUWHG EHYHUSHUVRQRIFRPPRQVHQVHDQGJRRGWDVWH
1HYHUWKHOHVV SDLQJ DWWHQWLRQ WR RQH¶V DSSHDUDQFH VKRXOG QRW PDNH D 0XVOLP IDOO LQWR WKH WUDS RI RYHUH[DJJHUDWLQJ KLV JURRPLQJ WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW KH ORVHV VLJKW RI WKH VHQVH RI EDODQFH SUHVFULEHG E ,VOPLFWHDFKLQJ7KH0XVOLPDOZDVDLPVDWPRGHUDWLRQLQDOOWKLQJVDQGLVRQWKHDOHUWWRSUHYHQWDQ RQHDVSHFWRIKLVOLIHIURPWDNLQJRYHUDWWKHH[SHQVHRIDQRWKHU 7KH0XVOLPQHYHUIRUJHWVWKDW,VOPZKLFKHQFRXUDJHVKLPWRWDNHFDUHRIKLVDSSHDUDQFHDQGWRZHDU KLVEHDXWLIXODSSDUHODWHYHUWLPHDQGSODFHRISUDHULVDOVRWKHUHOLJLRQWKDWZDUQVKLPDJDLQVWJRLQJWR H[WUHPHVLQWKDWDQGWHOOVKLPWRDYRLGEHFRPLQJHQVODYHGEKLVDSSHDUDQFHDVWKH DG¯WKVDV ´:UHWFKHG LV WKH VODYH RI WKH G¯QU GLUKDP DQG IDQF FORWKHV RI YHOYHW DQG VLON ,I KH LV JLYHQ KH LV SOHDVHGDQGLIKHLVQRWJLYHQKHLVGLVSOHDVHGµ%XNKU¯
369.
1R GRXEW WKRVH
ZKR FDOO SHRSOH WR $OOK ,
370.
DUH VDYHG IURP
WKLV HUURU EHFDXVH WKH VXUURXQG WKHPVHOYHVZLWKWKHSURWHFWLRQRI,VOPDQGDGRSWWKHSULQFLSOHVRIPRGHUDWLRQWKDWLWKDVEURXJKW
371.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
+LV0LQG .QRZOHGJHLVDQREOLJDWLRQDQGDQKRQRXUIRUWKH0XVOLP 7KH0XVOLPEHOLHYHVWKDWH[HUFLVLQJKLVPLQGDQGVHHNLQJNQRZOHGJHDQGGLVFRYHULQJWKHVLJQVRI$OOK ,
372.
LQWKHXQLYHUVHLVDQREOLJDWLRQEHFDXVHRIWKHVDLQJRIWKH3URSKHW7
373.
´6HHNLQJNQRZOHGJHLVDGXWRQHYHU0XVOLPµ%XNKU¯
374.
7KHUHIRUHWKH0XVOLPPXVWFRQWLQXHWRSXUVXHNQRZOHGJHDVORQJDVWKHEUHDWKRIOLIHUHPDLQVLQKLV ERG 7KH IDFW
WKDW $OOK ,
375.
KDV UDLVHG WKH
VWDWXV RI WKRVH ZKR KDYH NQRZOHGJH DQG GHVFULEHG WKHP DORQH DV WUXO IHDULQJ +LP VKRXOG EH HQRXJK WR HQFRXUDJH WKH 0XVOLP WR DSSO KLPVHOI WR VHHNLQJ NQRZOHGJH)RU+HVDLG 7KRVHWUXOIHDU$OOKDPRQJ+LV6ODYHVZKRKDYHNQRZOHGJH@ 4XU¶Q
376.
1R RQH WUXO
IHDUV $OOK ,
377.
H[FHSW WKRVH ZKRVH
PLQGV DUH HQOLJKWHQHG HQRXJK WR VHH WKH JUHDWQHVV DQGSRZHURI$OOK,
378.
PDQLIHVWHGLQWKHFUHDWLRQRIWKHXQLYHUVHDQGDOOOLYLQJWKLQJVDQGWKHVHDUHWKH SHRSOHRINQRZOHGJH6R+HKDVSUHIHUUHGWKHPRYHUWKRVHZKRKDYHQRNQRZOHGJH
6D ¶$UH WKRVH HTXDO WKRVH ZKR NQRZ DQG WKRVH ZKR GR QRW NQRZ ,W LV WKRVH ZKR DUH HQGXHGZLWKXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKDWUHFHLYHDGPRQLWLRQ·@ 4XU¶Q
379.
6DIZQ LEQ µ$VVO
DO0XUG¯ FDPH WR WKH 3URSKHW 7
380.
LQ WKH PRVTXH
DQG VDLG ³2 0HVVHQJHU RI $OOK,KDYHFRPHVHHNLQJNQRZOHGJH´7KH3URSKHW7
381.
WROGKLP³:HOFRPH2VHHNHURINQRZOHGJH 7UXOWKHDQJHOVVXUURXQGWKHVHHNHURINQRZOHGJHZLWKWKHLUZLQJVJDWKHULQJDURXQGKLPLQUDQNVRQH DERYHWKHRWKHUXQWLOWKHUHDFKWKHILUVWKHDYHQRXWRIORYHIRUWKDWZKLFKKHVHHNV´
7KHWH[WVWKDWH[WROWKHYLUWXHRINQRZOHGJHDQGH[KRUWLWVSXUVXLWDUHPDQWKHUHIRUHWKHWUXH0XVOLP LVHLWKHUDVFKRODURUDVHHNHURINQRZOHGJHDQGFDQQRWEHDQWKLQJHOVH RQWLQXRXVOVHHNLQJNQRZOHGJHXQWLOGHDWK 7UXHNQRZOHGJHGRHVQRWPHDQREWDLQLQJDGHJUHHRUGLSORPDWKDWZLOOOHWRQHHDUQDQLQFRPHDQG JXDUDQWHHDJRRGVWDQGDUGRIOLYLQJDIWHUZKLFKRQHWXUQVDZDIURPOHDUQLQJDQGGRHVQRWH[SORUHWKH WUHDVXUHRINQRZOHGJHDQIXUWKHUWUXHOHDUQLQJPHDQVWKDWRQHFRQWLQXHVWRUHDGDQGVWXGLQFUHDVLQJ RQH¶VOHDUQLQJGDEGDLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHZRUGVRIWKH4XU¶Q %XWVD¶2P5DEE $GYDQFHPHLQNQRZOHGJH· @ 4XU¶Q
382.
5HSRUWHGE$PDGDO†DEDUQ¯,EQpLEEQDOpNLPZLWKDÑD¯ LVQG
ÎÏÒ
383.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
2XUULJKWHRXVSUHGHFHVVRUVQHYHUVWRSSHGVHHNLQJWRLQFUHDVHWKHLUNQRZOHGJHQRPDWWHUKRZKLJK D OHYHO RI OHDUQLQJWKHKDGDFKLHYHGDQGWKHZRXOGFRQWLQXHWKHLUSXUVXLWXQWLOWKHHQGRIWKHLUOLYHV 7KHEHOLHYHGWKDWNQRZOHGJHZDVDOLYLQJWKLQJWKDWZRXOGWKULYHLILWZHUHDFWLYHOSXUVXHGEXWZRXOG ZLWKHUDQGSHULVKLILWZHUHLJQRUHGDQGDEDQGRQHG0DQVDLQJVDUHDWWULEXWHGWRWKHPWKDWHORTXHQWO H[SUHVVWKHLUUHVSHFWIRUOHDUQLQJDQGWKHLUNHHQQHVVWRDFTXLUHNQRZOHGJH([DPSOHVRIWKHLUVDLQJVDUH JLYHQEHORZ ,PP ,EQ µ$EG DO%DUU UHSRUWHG WKDW ,EQ $E¯ *KDVVQ VDLG ³6R ORQJ DV RX DUH VHHNLQJ NQRZOHGJH RXDUHNQRZOHGJHDEOHEXWDVVRRQDVRXDEDQGRQWKLVSXUVXLWRXEHFRPHLJQRUDQW´ ,PP0OLNW
384.
VDLG³1RRQHZKRKDVNQRZOHGJHVKRXOGVWRSVHHNLQJNQRZOHGJH´
,PPµ$EGXOODKLEQDO0XEUDNZDVDVNHG³+RZORQJZLOORXVHHNNQRZOHGJH´+HVDLG³8QWLO, GLHIRUSUREDEO,KDYHQRWHWOHDUQWWKHWKLQJVWKDWZLOOEHQHILWPHPRVW´ ,PP$EÔ µ$PULEQDOµ$O¶ZDVDVNHG³)RUKRZORQJGRHVLWEHILWDPDQWRVHHNNQRZOHGJH´+H VDLG³)RUDVORQJDVKHKDVOLIHLQKLP´ ,PP 6XIQ LEQ µ8DQDK JDYH DQ H[FHOOHQW DQVZHU ZKHQ KH ZDV DVNHG ³:KR LV PRVW LQ QHHG RI VHHNLQJ NQRZOHGJH´ +H VDLG ³7KRVH ZKR KDYH WKH PRVW NQRZOHGJH´ +H ZDV DVNHG ³:K´ DQG KH UHSOLHG³%HFDXVHLIWKHPDNHDPLVWDNHLWLVZRUVH´ 6XFK ZDV ,PP )DNKU DO'¯Q DO5]¯ G $+
385.
WKH JUHDW PXIDVVLU
4XU¶QLF H[HJHWH
386.
DQG SURPLQHQWVFKRODULQSKLORVRSKµLOPDONDOP
387.
DQGRWKHUGLVFLSOLQHVZKRDXWKRUHGPDQZRUNV$OOK ,
388.
JDYH KLP VXFK
IDPH LQ NQRZOHGJH WKDW SHRSOH ZRXOG FRPH IURP DOO RYHU WR VHH KLP ZKHQHYHU KH YLVLWHGDFLW:KHQKHFDPHWRWKHFLWRI0HUYLQ7XUNPHQLVWDQ
389.
IORFNVRIVFKRODUVDQGVWXGHQWVFDPH WR KDYH WKH
SULYLOHJH RI OLVWHQLQJ WR DQG OHDUQLQJ IURP KLP $PRQJ WKH VHHNHUV RI NQRZOHGJH ZKR DWWHQGHGKLVFLUFOHZDVDRXQJPDQOHVVWKDQWZHQWHDUVROGZKRZDVYHUZHOOYHUVHGLQOLWHUDWXUH DQGJHQHDORJ:KHQ,PP)DNKUDO'¯QUHDOL]HGWKDWWKLVVWXGHQWZDVDQH[SHUWLQJHQHDORJDILHOGLQ ZKLFKKHNQHZYHUOLWWOHKHDVNHGKLVVWXGHQWWRWHDFKKLP+HGLGQRWILQGLWXQDFFHSWDEOHWREHFRPH WKHVWXGHQWRIKLVVWXGHQWDQGKHHYHQPDGHKLPVLWLQWKHWHDFKHU¶VSODFHZKLOHKHKLPVHOIVDWDWKLVIHHW 6XFKDQDFWZDVFKDUDFWHULVWLFRI,PP)DNKUDO'¯QDO5]¯DQGLWGLGQRWGHWUDFWIURPKLVKLJKVWDWXVDV KHZDVWKH,PPRIKLVDJH 7KLVUHPDUNDEOHVWRUZDVWROGEWKHOLWHUDUKLVWRULDQTÔWDO+DPZ¯ LQKLVERRN0XµMDPDOXGDE¶ 'LFWLRQDU RI OLWHUDU DXWKRUV
390.
ZKHUH KH JLYHV
D ELRJUDSK RI µ$]¯] DO'¯Q ,VPµ¯O LEQ DOpDVDQ DO 0DUZD]¯ DO1DVVEDK DOpXVDQL ZKRP TÔW PHW DQG VSHQW PXFK WLPH ZLWK VR ZDV DEOH WR ZULWH D FRPSUHKHQVLYHELRJUDSKRIKLP,QWKLVELRJUDSKKHVDV ³µ$]¯]DO'¯QWROGPHµ,PP)DNKUDO'¯QDO5]¯ ZHQWWR0HUY+HKDGVXFKDJUHDWUHSXWDWLRQDQG ZDVKHOGLQVXFKDZHWKDWQRERGGDUHGWRDUJXHZLWKKLPWKHZRXOGEDUHOEUHDWKHLQKLVSUHVHQFH, ZHQWWRPHHWKLPDQG,RIWHQZHQWWRVWXGZLWKKLP2QHGDKHVDLGWRPH³,ZRXOGOLNHRXWRZULWH PHDERRNJLYLQJWKHJHQHDORJRIDO†OLEL¯Q WKHGHVFHQGDQWVRI$EÔ †OLE
391.
VRWKDW,PDVWXGLWIRU ,GRQRWZDQWWRUHPDLQLJQRUDQWRILW´,DVNHGKLP³'RRXZDQWLWSUHVHQWHGDVDIDPLOWUHHRUZULWWHQ GRZQ DV D
QDUUDWLYH´ +H VDLG ³$ IDPLO WUHH FDQQRW EH OHDUQW E KHDUW , ZDQW VRPHWKLQJ WKDW , FDQ PHPRUL]H´6R,ZHQWDZDDQGZURWHWKHERRNZKLFK,FDOOHGDO)DNKU¯:KHQ,EURXJKWLWWRKLPKH WRRNLWWKHQJRWXSIURPKLVPDWWUHVVVDWRQWKHPDWDQGWROGPHWRVLWLQWKHSODFHKHKDGMXVWYDFDWHG, WKRXJKW WKLV ZDV WRR PXFK DQG WROG KLP ³, DP RXU VHUYDQW´ , UHSULPDQGHG PH VHYHUHO VDLQJ ³6LW
392.
7KH,GHDO0XVOLP
ZKHUH,WHOORX´$OOK,
393.
NQRZV,IHOWWKDW,KDGQRFKRLFHEXWWRVLWZKHUHKHWROGPH7KHQKH EHJDQ WR UHDG
WKH ERRN WR PH ZKLOH KH ZDV VLWWLQJ DW P IHHW DVNLQJ PH DERXW DQWKLQJ KH GLG QRW XQGHUVWDQGXQWLOKHILQLVKHGWKHERRN:KHQKHKDGILQLVKHGKHVDLG³1RZVLWZKHUHYHURXZLVKIRULQ WKLVILHOGRINQRZOHGJHRXDUHPWHDFKHUDQG,DPRXUVWXGHQWDQGLWLVQRWULJKWIRUWKHVWXGHQWWRVLW DQZKHUHEXWDWWKHIHHWRIKLVWHDFKHU6R,JRWXSDQGKHVDWLQKLVULJKWIXOSODFHDQG,EHJDQWRUHDGWR KLPVLWWLQJZKHUHKHKDGVDWSUHYLRXVO¶´ $IWHUTXRWLQJWKLVLQFLGHQWTÔWVDLG³,QGHHGWKLVLVJRRGPDQQHUVHVSHFLDOOIRUDPDQZKRHQMRV VXFKDKLJKVWDWXV´ +RZ JUHDW ZDV WKH ORYH DQG UHVSHFW WKHVH VFKRODUV JDYH WR NQRZOHGJH +RZ KLJKOWKHUHJDUGHGLW DQGKRZJUHDWLVWKHQHHGIRUWKHODWHUJHQHUDWLRQWROHDUQIURPWKHDWWLWXGHRIWKHLUIRUHEHDUV :KDW0XVOLPQHHGVWRNQRZ 7KHILUVWWKLQJWKDWWKH0XVOLP QHHGVWRNQRZLVKRZWRUHDGWKH4XU¶QSURSHUOZLWK WDMZ¯G
394.
DQGWR XQGHUVWDQGLWVPHDQLQJ7KHQKHVKRXOGOHDUQVRPHWKLQJRIWKHVFLHQFHVRIDG¯WKWKHV¯UDKRIWKH3URSKHW 7
395.
DQGWKHKLVWRURIWKH6DDEDK DQG7ELµ¯QZKRDUHSURPLQHQWILJXUHVLQ,VOP+HVKRXOGDFTXLUH DVPXFKNQRZOHGJHRIILTK DVKHQHHGVWRHQVXUHWKDWKLVZRUVKLSDQGGDLOGHDOLQJVDUHFRUUHFWDQGKH VKRXOG
HQVXUH WKDW KH KDV D VRXQG JUDVS RI WKH EDVLF SULQFLSOHV RI KLV UHOLJLRQ 7KLV LV WKH GXW RI WKH 0XVOLP ZKR LV QRW D VSHFLDOLVW LQ WKH VFLHQFHV RI 6KDU¯µDK ,I KH LV D VSHFLDOLVW LQ D EUDQFK RI6KDU¯µDK WKHQKHGRHVZKDWHYHUWUXH0XVOLPVKRXOGGRZKLFKLVWRGRKLVEHVWWROHDUQKLVVSHFLDOLWWKRURXJKO DQGEHVXFFHVVIXOLQLW,WJRHVZLWKRXWVDLQJWKDWHYHU0XVOLP DOVRQHHGVWROHDUQ$UDELFSURSHUO 7KH0XVOLPVKRXOGEHSURILFLHQWLQKLVVSHFLDOLW %HVLGHVWKLVWKH0XVOLPWXUQVWRKLVRZQVSHFLDOLWDQGJLYHVLWDOORIKLVHQHUJDQGSDVDJUHDWGHDO RIDWWHQWLRQWRLW+HDSSURDFKHVLWOLNHD0XVOLPZKREHOLHYHVWKDWLWLVDUHOLJLRXVREOLJDWLRQWRZRUNLQ KLV ILHOG RI VSHFLDOL]DWLRQ ZKHWKHU LW LV LQ 6KDU¯µDK RU LQ DQRWKHU DUHD RI UHOLJLRXV NQRZOHGJH RU LQ DQRWKHU ILHOG VXFK DV PDWKHPDWLFV SKVLFV FKHPLVWU HQJLQHHULQJ DVWURQRP PHGLFLQH LQGXVWU FRPPHUFHHWF7KHUHIRUHKHVKRXOGEHFRPHSURILFLHQWLQZKDWHYHUILHOGKHKDVVSHFLDOL]HGLQDQGVKRXOG VSDUHQRHIIRUWWRUHDGZKDWHYHUKDVEHHQZULWWHQDERXWLWERWKLQKLVRZQODQJXDJHDQGLQRWKHUVLIKHLV DEOHWR+HVKRXOGNHHSDEUHDVWRIGHYHORSPHQWVLQKLVILHOGWKURXJKFRQWLQXDOUHDGLQJDQGVWXGRIDOOLWV DVSHFWV 7KLV LV EHFDXVH LQ WKHVH WLPHV WKH VPDUW 0XVOLP LV WKH RQH ZKR DFKLHYHV JUHDW DFDGHPLF VXFFHVVZKLFKZLOOUDLVHKLVVWDWXVLQWKHHHVRIRWKHUSHRSOH7KLVLQWXUQZLOOHQKDQFHKLV GDµZDKVR ORQJDVKHSUHVHQWVLWVLQFHUHODQGHDUQHVWODQGLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHVSLULWRI,VOPDQGLWVWHDFKLQJV DERXWNQRZOHGJH ,VOPKDVPDGHNQRZOHGJHDGXWZKHUHEWKHRQHZKRVHHNVLWGUDZVFORVHUWR$OOK,
396.
DQGDGRSWV LW DV D
PHDQV RI HDUQLQJ +LV SOHDVXUH 6R ZH VHH WKDW WKH VFKRODUV RI WKH HDUO JHQHUDWLRQ XVHG WR HPSKDVL]HWKHVHVXEOLPHSULQFLSOHVLQWKHLULQWURGXFWLRQVWRWKHLUERRNVEHFDXVHWKURXJKWKHNQRZOHGJH WKDW WKH VSHQW WKHLU OLYHV VSUHDGLQJ WKH ZHUH VHHNLQJ WR HDUQ WKH SOHDVXUH RI $OOK ,
397.
DQG WKH
ÎÏÔ
398.
7KH0XVOLPDQG+LV5HODWLYHV
SUHVHQWHGWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHLUVWXGSXUHOIRU+LVVDNH 7KH0XVOLPH[SRVHVKLPVHOIWRLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWRWKHUILHOGV 7KHVPDUW0XVOLPGRHVQRWUHVWULFWKLPVHOIWRKLVRZQILHOGEXWLVRSHQWROHDUQLQJDERXWRWKHUDUHDV WRR 6R KH UHDGV ERRNV DQG DFDGHPLF OLWHUDU DQG FXOWXUDO MRXUQDOV DERXW YDULRXV XVHIXO EUDQFKHV RI NQRZOHGJH HVSHFLDOO WKRVH WKDW DUH UHODWHG WR KLV RZQ ILHOG ,Q WKLV ZD KH JDLQV D OLWWOH NQRZOHGJH DERXWPDQWKLQJVZKLFKHQULFKHVKLVPLQGDQGEURDGHQVKLVKRUL]RQV 7KH0XVOLPLVSURILFLHQWLQDIRUHLJQODQJXDJH +H GRHV QRW IRUJHW WR SD DWWHQWLRQ WR IRUHLJQ ODQJXDJHV EHFDXVH WKHVH GDV OHDUQLQJ D IRUHLJQ ODQJXDJHLVRQHRIWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWWDVNVUHTXLUHGRIWKHDFWLYH0XVOLPZKRXQGHUVWDQGVWKHGHPDQGV RIFRQWHPSRUDU,VOPLFOLIH +LVUHOLJLRQJLYHVWKHDWWHQWLYH0XVOLPDJUHDWLQFHQWLYHWROHDUQIRUHLJQODQJXDJHV)LIWHHQFHQWXULHV DJR WKH 3URSKHW 7
399.
HQFRXUDJHG WKHVWXGRIIRUHLJQODQJXDJHVVRWKDWWKH0XVOLPVZRXOGDOZDVEH DEOHWRFRPPXQLFDWH ZLWKYDULRXVQDWLRQVDQGUDFHVDQGFRQYHWRWKHPWKHPHVVDJHRIWUXWKWKDW$OOK ,
Descargar ahora