This document summarizes Blackboard's presentation on accessibility. It discusses 3 parts of Blackboard's solution to improve accessibility: content platforms, consultation, and Blackboard Ally. Blackboard Ally automatically checks content for accessibility issues, provides alternative formats, and gives instructors feedback to improve. It also provides institutions reports on course content accessibility. Blackboard is committed to accessible platforms like Collaborate, Learn, and Moodlerooms. They provide consultation services like auditing courses and creating accessibility plans. The presentation addresses challenges for students, instructors, and institutions and emphasizes the importance of accessibility for all learners.
1. Accessibility at Blackboard
www.3playmedia.com
twitter: @3playmedia
live tweet: #a11y
Type questions in the window during the presentation
This presentation is being recorded and will be available for replay
To view live captions, please follow the link in the chat window
JoAnna Hunt
Accessibility Manager
Blackboard
Scott Ready
Director of Customer
Relations
Blackboard
Nicolaas Matthijs
Ally Product Manager
Blackboard
Lily Bond
Director of Marketing
3Play Media
lily@3playmedia.com
4. 44
Why Accessibility Matters
Visual
Impairment
(~3% of population)
Hearing
Impairment
(over 5% of population)
Cognitive
Impairment
(~25% of population)
Motor
Impairment
(~6% of population)
Approximately 1 Billion people worldwide have some form of disability
Disability Types:
*Sources: http://www.disabled-world.com/ & http://www.who.int/
5. 55
Encouraging
Inclusive
Environments
for all
With increased
attention being placed
on inclusive
environments and equal
opportunity to access to
information for
everyone, it is important
to understand the
diverse needs your
learners may have.
Revisit content and ensure it’s set up for
universal consumption
Understand how people need to interact with
different tools you are using and adjust
Rethink how learning is achieved and provide
the means to help students succeed.
6. 66
The Bigger Picture
Creating accessible environments improves everyone’s ability to consume
information - not just those with disabilities – and leads to higher quality
material, more useable experiences and personalized access.
7. 77
Proactively building programs to avoid
Accessibility Litigation
Awareness of the civil rights of
the learner
Higher expectations for
product accessibility
Lower number of students
disclosing disabilities
Mindset shifting towards
inclusion
Current Trends in Accessibility: Higher Ed
10. 1010
Blackboard is fully committed to delivering product experiences that conform to
global accessibility standards. We believe that a mature digital accessibility program
must establish a sustainable organizational culture and strong partnerships around
accessibility.
Our Commitment
BCAB
12. 1212
Taking Action: Blackboard Collaborate
• Full-screen reader support
of all key workflows.
• Global keyboard shortcuts
for common actions.
• Screen reader support for
whiteboard activities and
uploaded files, without
requiring complex
conversions.
• Live closed captioning.
13. 1313
Taking Action: Blackboard Learn
• Compatible with the latest
versions of screen readers
such as JAWS and
VoiceOver
• Common Page Structure
• Full support for captions in
uploaded media content.
• Keyboard accessible
reordering
• Ability for instructors to add
alt tags to identify images
• High contrast style settings
14. 1414
Taking Action: Moodlerooms
• Full support of screen readers,
text magnifiers and speech-to-
text solutions.
• Global keyboard shortcuts for
common actions.
• Compliance with ADA, XHTML
and JavaScript standards
• Accessible Chat Interface
• Open Source and Open sharing
- all issues openly reported,
discussed and fixed.
15. 1515
Taking Action: Web Community Manager
• Template-based pages and apps
provide consistent interactions and
user experience across pages
• Allows configuration of templates
while still remaining within the
color contrast ratio
• Provides full support for keyboard
navigation
• Text can be resized 200 percent
without loss of content or
functionality
• Contains page titles with the name
of the workspace within which the
user is working
18. 1818
Institutional Challenges
No insight into
how institution
is doing
Difficult to track
and identify
what to focus on
Lawsuits
because of legal
requirements
Manual
remediation
workflow
24. 2424
Automatic Analysis
• Automated accessibility checklist based on content
type
• Based on WCAG 2.0 AA
• Uses machine learning algorithms for a full
structural and visual analysis to learn semantics of
document
• Identifies headings, heading structure, paragraphs,
footers, tables, lists, mathematical formulas, etc.
25. 2525
Alternative Accessible Versions
High quality semantic
HTML version of the
content
HTML
Automatically inject
fixes into the original
document
Enhance original
ePub, audio, electronic
braille, etc.
Other alternative
formats
26. 2626
Instructor Feedback
• Provide feedback to instructors about
accessibility of their course content
• Provide guidance on how to fix
accessibility issues
• Aims to generate change in behavior
over time
27. 2727
Institutional Report
• Provide detailed understanding
of how institution is doing
• Helps identify where problem
areas are, what to focus on,
who to target, etc.
28. 2828
Automatically checks
for accessibility issues
and generates
alternative accessible
formats
Alternative Accessible
Versions
Guides instructors on
how to improve the
accessibility of their
course content and
alters future behavior
Instructor feedback
Provides detailed data
and insights to help
further improve course
content accessibility at
the institution
Institutional report
Summary
29. 2929
2
Ally User Group
• Receive updates about
Blackboard Ally
• Participate in UX research,
usability testing, early access, etc.
Sign up at
http://tinyurl.com/blackboard-
ally-user-group
32. 32
Registration through graduation must be
accessible to enable eLearning students
with varying abilities the opportunity to
succeed.
Most NAHE institutions are unaware of
how to do this and 60% to 80% of
undergrads choose not to disclose a
disability.
33. 3333
eLearning Accessibility Plan
The solution is designed to identify operational barriers and provide remediation
approaches within a variety of functions related to the eLearning student lifecycle. This
solution results in a comprehensive accessibility operational plan to provide a barrier-
free eLearning experience for individuals with disabilities.
Review of
academic &
student services
Goals, strategies,
metrics, and tools
for improvement
Operational
Accessibility Plan
The plan will not address physical accessibility barriers on the institution’s campus nor are the recommendations a substitute for legal counsel.
34. 3434
eLearning Accessibility Course Audit
Audit of eLearning
courses
Training on
inclusive course
creation
Analysis and
reports on barriers
in courses
The solution is designed to identify barriers within eLearning courses. This solution
results in course and institutional level reporting of barriers along with recommended
remediation approaches. Targeted course creation training is included to provide a
barrier-free eLearning experience for individuals with disabilities.
It is worthy to note that these findings and recommendations are not a substitute for legal counsel.
37. Q&A
Upcoming Webinars:
Feb 23: Best Practices for Accessible Videos
Mar 9: Campus-Wide Response to Captioning
Mar 16: Getting Faculty Involved with Accessibility
Mar 30: Quick Start to Captioning
April 13: 15 Years Since an OCR Lawsuit: NC State
You can register for our free webinars at:
www.3playmedia.com/webinars/
Panelists
JoAnna Hunt
Accessibility Manager
Blackboard
Scott Ready
Director of Customer
Relations
Blackboard
Nicolaas Matthijs
Ally Product Manager
Blackboard
Lily Bond
3Play Media
www.3playmedia.com
lily@3playmedia.com
Please type your questions into the window in your
control panel. Reference the slide # when possible. A
recording of this webinar will be available for replay.
Notas del editor
Before we dive in and talk about the products and services that Blackboard offers around accessibility, let’s take some time to better understand the Global population that’s impacted by this issue.
The World Health Organization states that there are approximately 1 Billion people in the world who have some form of disability. This population is then further broken down into the four major classifications of disability: Visual, Hearing, Motor, and Cognitive impairments.
Approximately 3% of the global population has what the World Health Organization classifies as a severe vision impairment to total blindness. But this number is probably significantly higher when you think about individuals with a range of vision challenges from low vision to color blindness.
This number increases slightly to 5% when you look at individuals with what’s considered to be a severe hearing impairment or total deafness. Again, this number is higher when you consider the range of hearing challenges that might exist in the broader population.
When you look at the population with a motor impairment, which can include anything from amputation or paralysis, to someone with Parkinson's disease which may only cause minor tremors preventing them from using a mouse, the number again increases slightly – to 6% of the global population.
By far the most significant segment is those with cognitive impairments. They make up about 25% of the global population. The range of medical conditions that fall under the umbrella of cognitive disorders can range from things like dyslexia, dyscalculia, attention deficit disorders, and autism to things like PTSD, depression, and anxiety. Even conditions like cerebral palsy, which manifests as a set of physical challenges is classified as a cognitive disorder since it’s cause is the way the brain process the commands telling the body to move.
While the percentages attached to these populations may seem small, the impact of not meeting their needs is quite large.
Accessible content provides opportunity for all users to engage and leverage content. Consider the hundreds of scenarios you could find today if you surveyed a room of people on how they consume information. It is not one size fits all anymore, from the person studying on their way home from work to someone catching up on their mobile device in a coffee shop.
There are many positives to placing an emphasis on accessible content and this mindset of including everyone when thinking about how content is designed:
Usability – allow everyone to use the content without having to fall behind due to lack of accommodations
Flexibility and Quality – provide options for consuming the content beyond what was initially delivered. Encourage widespread usage.
Portability – allow people to take information everywhere they go.
There are also negative impacts as a result of ignoring accessibility, including:
Non-Use – information is unable to be used or generally ignored due to the inaccessibility or inflexibility of delivery.
User Frustration – people become frustrated by a lack of options or inability to make the information work in their individual circumstance.
Legal risks – many organizations have been facing formal complaints around the accessibility of content.
Higher Education
With 12.9% of all students in North America having some form of disability, awareness of the civil rights of these students is increasing. The expectations around content and platform accessibility are growing as well as schools work to tackle accessibility in their courses.
This proactivity is partly driven by an increased risk of litigation and has prompted many institutions to act now.
Lastly, most students choose not to disclose their disability when they enter higher education. That's 60 to 80% of North American undergrads and 9% of graduate students. As mindsets shift towards that of inclusion, greater strides can be made to reach those students that have not disclosed.
These trends force many organizations to rethink their approach when it comes to products and content and Blackboard is good example.
At Blackboard we’ve thought out our approach to accessibility and inclusivity while keeping a few key points in mind.
For educational institutions, reaching “compliance” with accessibility expectations means they need to be doing three things:
Selecting and purchasing technology that is accessible
Building content that is inclusive to people of all abilities
Establishing policies, processes, and programs around accessibility that can help them achieve and maintain success
For many years, Blackboard’s focus has been on the accessibility of the products and platform technology that we build.
With the acquisition of Fronteer we are bringing to market Blackboard Ally – a set of tools focused on the accessibility of digital content.
Our consulting teams in all markets are researching and providing strategic consultation to help schools better understand where they are on the accessibility spectrum today (both within and outside of the LMS) and building programs and policies to improve and then maintain that success.
When it comes to our platform technology, Blackboard is fully committed to building products that meet the highest level of accessibility expectations in the market. To do this we’ve centered around the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) version 2.0 at level AA. This is the broadest, most robust set of web accessibility standards available. It’s also the only internationally recognized set of standards.
But our commitment doesn’t stop at the standards. We believe that to build the highest quality products we also need to establish partnerships with key clients and accessibility advocacy organizations to ensure that we’re aware of the changing needs of the teachers and students with disabilities and best positioned to respond to changes in all markets.
As part of our commitment, Blackboard has incorporated that focus on accessibility into our products with some great results for our users.
Blackboard Collaborate – our video conferencing and collaboration tool. Our approach has resulted in one of the most accessible products on the market today.
Blackboard Learn – our flagship LMS. Our main goal is to provide an accessible platform for students and instructors for equal access to online courses.
Moodlerooms – our open source solution. As an open source project, we have a worldwide base of Moodle support to draw from and build upon as we support and design with accessibility in mind.
Web Community Manager – reliable content management solutions. Blackboard is committed to ensuring that the Web Community Manager platform is usable and accessible to users of all abilities.
There are many long standing issues facing all levels of education when it comes to content and accessibility. At an overall level, the institutions themselves are often tasked with trying to navigate around these specific issues.
Instructors are also facing hurdles when it comes to accessible content.
Lastly but perhaps most importantly, the students themselves have a number of challenges with it comes to finding usable accessible material to complete their coursework.
Blackboard Ally aims to help make course content more accessible by taking a step further to look at the content within the systems instead of just the systems themselves.
the Learning Management System is an important player in this but we are committed to providing Ally to everyone, including non-Blackboard products and see great potential down the road for other integrations.
Blackboard Ally uses an automated accessibility checklist to analyze based on content type as well as machine learning algorithms to analyze document structure.
The checklist is based on WCAG 2.0AA standards.
Algorithms identify headings, structure elements, paragraphs, footers tables and so on to determine conversion to alternate formats.
Blackboard Ally automatically generates alternative accessible versions for course content and makes these available to all users within the course within minutes.
Blackboard Ally provides the instructor with feedback about the accessibility of their course content and guidance on how to fix accessibility issues that arise.
Blackboard Ally provides an institution wide course content accessibility report that allows for deeper insight and understanding into how the institution is performing or evolving.
Review of Benefits
Alternative Accessible Versions provide usable content to all students.
Instructor feedback can guide instructors on how to improve the accessibility of their content and also encourage continued focus and effort around accessibility for future courses.
Institutional Reports can help institutions further understand and improve course content accessibility across all courses.
If Ally is of interest to you or anyone at your institution, I’d like to encourage you to sign up to the Ally User Group.
The Ally User Group has 2 main goals. It will first of all provide recent updates and announcements about Ally.
It will also provide an opportunity to participate in some of our User Experience activities, such as UX research, usability testing, beta testing, etc. The Ally product follows a rigorous UX-led process with regular UX activities that you can participate in. This can be anything from a short questionnaire about a problem Ally is trying to solve, providing feedback on new designs, remote usability testing where you can sign up for one of the available time slots, etc. Participation in all of these activities is optional, so you can definitely the ones that are relevant or of interest to you.
So definitely sign up to the User Group. It is a great way to stay up-to-date and become involved.
Institutions generally will find themselves somewhere on this accessibility spectrum depending on the current state of their courses and programs.