SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 22
Andrew Olsen


         Balanced Scorecard:
      Congressional District Office

University of Maryland University College
2


                          Table of Contents:

Executive Summary……………………………………………………………                      3-4

Introduction………………………………………………………………………. 5

Overview of a Congressional District Office………………………………….. 6-7

BSC Performance Measurement & Strategic Management System………… 7

Creating a BSC……..…………………………………………………………… 7-8

Governmental BSC………………………….………………………………….. 8-9

Brooklyn District Office BSC..…………………………………………………. 9-19

     Customer Perspective….……………………………………………….                10-12

     Financial Perspective ………………………………………………….               13-14

     Internal Perspective …………………………………………………..               14-17

     Innovation & Learning Perspective…………………………………… 17-19

District Office Strategic Mission….……………………………………………          19-20

Conclusion………………………………………………………………………                         20

References………………………………………………………………………                         21-22
3


                                    Executive Summary

       I am currently employed for Congressman Vito Fossella as a constituent liaison in

his Brooklyn District office. The fact that his district covers two boroughs that is

connected by a bridge, posses an especially challenging strategic situation. How do we

make sure that the Congressman spends enough time between the two boroughs, while

also being represented appropriately within the district, particularly when he has a prior

commitment?

       The Congressman and his staff are a service-based governmental organization. A

majority of the services we provide are Federal in nature, but we also deal with numerous

nonfederal issues because we want to give our constituents the best possible service.

Community outreach is very important and utterly necessary that we both play an active

role in the community.

       The BSC is a performance measurement and strategic management system that

translates an organization's mission and strategy into a balanced set of integrated

performance measures. It allows an organization to monitor its current and efforts to

improve processes, motivate and educate employees, and enhance its ability to learn and

improve. When creating a BSC, it is imperative that senior staffers review the

organization’s vision, mission, values, goals, strategies and annual objectives in order to

identify their strategic success factors. The key is to identify objectives that will maintain

a strategic focus the office can understand and follow.

       Government offices exist not to make a profit, but to accomplish a mission, which

is placed at the top of the BSC framework. When developing a BSC for a governmental

office the customer perspective is the most important because it captures the ability of the
4


organization to provide quality and effective delivery of services, and overall customer

satisfaction. In government, financial considerations have a constraining role, but will

rarely be the primary objective. The final two perspectives represent and assess the

government’s ability to continually complete its mission.

       The services we provide our constituents are extremely important and absolutely

essential functions of congressional offices. It is imperative that we work closely with all

these stakeholders and provide them with access to the office so we can all address their

concerns and remain aware of the issues affecting the district. When interacting with

stakeholders it is imperative to have a clear line of communication so everyone knows

where they stand. Our office should give specific attention to the financial segment of the

BSC to ensure they we are maintaining and advancing goals and will focus our internal

efforts by providing the best possible constituent services for the betterment of the

constituents and the district as a whole. Communication is important when dealing with

our stakeholders so we are aware of the issues affecting our district. Every aspect of

constituent services and all our stakeholders must be considered and prioritized when

evaluating our service system. The key to the success of any project is the relationships

that form within the office and with the stakeholders. Any BSC no matter how perfectly

developed will fail unless proper, leadership, communication, efficiency and effective

decision making is in place.

       With a hard-working staff, an effective management team and the right set of

performance measures in place, we have built a performance driven office and have seen

project initiatives that continue to bring improvement to the process. Working together

with our stakeholders, we will continue to meet our goals.
5


                                        Introduction:

       I am currently employed for Congressman Vito Fossella as a constituent liaison in

his Brooklyn District office. His district encompasses all of Staten Island (S.I.) and the

Southern section of Brooklyn and is connected by the Narrows Verrazzano Bridge (V.Z.).

The fact that his district covers two boroughs that is connected by a bridge, posses an

especially challenging strategic situation. How do we make sure that the Congressman

spends enough time between the two boroughs, while also being represented

appropriately within the district, particularly when he has a prior commitment?

       The reason this is so important because S.I. represents almost three fourths of the

district with about 441,000 residents, while the Brooklyn side of the district has roughly

175,000 residents. Since S.I. is the significantly larger part of the district and the

Congressman was born and raised there, S.I. tends to get the most attention, thus leaving

Brooklyn with the “little brother complex,” as the forgotten or overlooked section of the

district. This sentiment was brewing for several years. It was so deep-rooted that it even

went back to the prior Congresswoman. No matter how much we in his Brooklyn office

stressed how strong this opinion was and the importance that something needed to be

done, nothing ever happened. This opinion continued to gain strength until finally in the

2004 election, he lost the Brooklyn side of district for the first time in his seven-year

congressional career.

       Now there is a new fervor for Brooklyn and rightfully so, especially if he wants to

continue as the Representative of the 13 th Congressional District. However, it is my

intention to elaborate how this could have been and will continue to be avoided by

incorporating the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) strategic management system.
6


                       Overview of a Congressional District Office:

       The Congressman and his staff are a service-based governmental organization.

Constituents are not charged for the services we provide. However, they do pay for these

services, as taxpayers. Federal budgets are funded by tax dollars through yearly

appropriations and this is also true of a House member’s office budget.

       A majority of the services we provide are Federal in nature, but we also deal with

numerous nonfederal issues because we want to give our constituents the best possible

service without giving them that run around feeling. Congressional offices are an

intermediary between their constituents and whatever the specific issue the constituent

may have. Currently in the Brooklyn office, we handle all constituent issues related to

the Department of Homeland Security (D.H.S.), the Department of State (D.O.S.) and

any local issue related to the Brooklyn side of the district. We are the Congressman’s

representatives and it is our job and it should be our goal to provide the best service

possible to best meet the needs of the constituency.

       Then there is the all important community outreach. Whether it is the

Congressman or an office representative, it is very important and utterly necessary that

they both play an active role in the community. This is especially important for the office

staff, since the Member can spend most of the week in D.C. while Congress is in session.

       To perform these services the Congressman is greatly dependent on the quality of

his staff. However, the problem we face is that congressional offices are limited by law

to a specific number of staffers. According to 2 U.S.C. § 92, we may employ 18

permanent employees and 4 additional employees, such as part-time employees

(Members' Congressional Handbook: Staff, 2005). It is up to Chief of Staff to decide
7


how to allocate the office staff appropriately so to best serve the congressional district.

Depending on the needs of the district, the staff can be spread thin. All these issues will

be further elaborated on in BSC section of the paper.

               BSC Performance Measurement & Strategic Management System:

       BSC focuses on strategy and vision, not on control. It is a performance

measurement and strategic management system that translates an organization's mission

and strategy into a balanced set of integrated performance measures (Ho & McKay,

2002). These measures are grounded in an organization's strategic objectives and

competitive demands and, by requiring managers to select a limited number of critical

indicators within each of the four perspectives (Financial, Internal Business, Customer,

and Learning and Growth), helps focus this strategic vision (Kaplan & Norton, 1993).

Performance measures provide a concise yet complete picture of an organization's

progress toward its mission and goal (Ho & McKay, 2002). Through the BSC, an

organization monitors both its current and its efforts to improve processes, motivate and

educate employees, and enhance its ability to learn and improve.

                                          Creating a BSC:

       When creating a BSC, it is imperative that senior staffers review the

organization’s vision, mission, values, goals, strategies and annual objectives in order to

identify their strategic success factors (Kaplan & Norton, 1996). They have the most

comprehensive view of the organization and their support is necessary for acceptance

within the organization. Most importantly, the senior staff must establish a clear

understanding of the organization’s objectives so it can be clearly communicated to every
8


employee. The key is to identify objectives that will maintain a strategic focus the office

can understand and follow.

       The BSC can be customized, but it must have unity and purpose. Senior staff

must determine the key performance indicators and targets for the organization and

establish some initiatives in order to determine how the business will meet these targets.

The performance indicators can be influenced directly by everyone in the organization,

thereby encouraging changes in behavior and activities to achieve its strategies. These

indicators are staff development, internal efficiency, customer satisfaction, and long-term

financial performance (Oliveira, 2001). Indicators are maintained to measure an

organization’s progress toward achieving its vision; other indicators are maintained to

measure the long-term drivers of success. Basically, managers are able to monitor and

adjust the implementation of their strategy, and to make fundamental changes in the

strategy itself (Kaplan & Norton, 1996).

                                   Governmental BSC:

       Government offices exist not to make a profit, but to accomplish a mission, which

is placed at the top of the BSC framework. Strategy will always be key to achieving that

mission, which is base on their customers, not financial stakeholders. The strategic

planning process begins by determining the government's primary objectives, which are

related to its stakeholders and then the secondary objectives, which reflect the choices

that will be used to pursue the primary objectives, are then established (Chan,

2002/2003).

       When developing a BSC for a governmental office the customer perspective is the

most important because it captures the ability of the organization to provide quality and
9


effective delivery of services, and overall customer satisfaction. Recognizing that budgets

are limiting factors, governmental offices should have a greater stewardship

responsibility and focus than do private sector entities.

       In government, financial considerations have a constraining role, but will rarely

be the primary objective. Success for such organizations should be measured by how

effectively and efficiently these organizations meet the needs of their constituencies and

even their ability to control costs and manage their budget. Government offices have to

focus their limited resources on specific objectives and constituents (Chan, 2004). The

financial perspective is a resource needed to attain objectives not usually related to profit

(Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004).

       The internal business perspective can encourage the government to change and

improve the way it delivered services, especially by forming partnerships within

communities and improving productivity. While the learning and growth perspectives can

determine whether the government is maintaining employee training and skills so that it

could continually improve. Basically, these final two perspectives represent and assess

the government’s ability to continually complete its mission. These four perspectives

will be evaluated in the next few sections.

                                  Brooklyn District Office BSC:

       The different perspectives incorporated in the BSC assist the senior staff to focus

more on long-term objectives. Monitoring performance and learning from the results, in

the customer, internal process, employee learning and growth, and financial perspectives

will provide you with the direction for planning short-term objectives important for

achieving the overall strategy, as well as a check on how the organization is doing in
10


fulfilling those objectives and guide us ever closer to achievement of the mission (Lang,

2004). However, due to the nature of politics, specifically for a Congressman, long-term

objectives consist of two-year increments. For that reason, the short-term objectives may

play a more prominent role and the objectives may be more general.

                                    Customer Perspective
      Objectives               Measures              Targets                    Initiatives
Continuously              Electoral Margin   Strong Electoral Base         Quality Staff &
Improving Constituent                                                      Service Leadership
Service                   Inquiry               Acknowledge inquiry
                          acknowledgement       within the first 2-4       Equipment &
                                                days; Send out inquiry     Service Excellence
                                                within the first 7-10
                          Constituent           days.                      Convenient Methods
                          Satisfaction                                     of Contact
                                                70-90% Satisfaction of
                                                all those who contact
                                                the office
Establish partnerships    Task Forces &         Evaluate & Prioritize      Establishing Task
within the community      Committees            the Community issues       Forces &
                                                & Establish Whatever       Committees to the
                          Internships           Necessary Task Forces      Appropriate
                                                & Committees               Community Issues

                                                                           Congressional
                                                                           Programs
Improved Constituent      Community             Attend 80-100% of all      Meeting with
& Community               Support               community meetings.        various community
Outreach                                        Making sure the            groups
                          Marketing the         Congressman attends
                          Congressman           the important meetings     Constituent Surveys

                                                Numerous Programs          Congressional
                                                Sponsored by the           Programs
                                                Congressman
                                                                           Making the
                                                                           Community Aware
                                                                           of the
                                                                           Congressman’s
                                                                           Achievements that
                                                                           benefit the District
11


Customer – The services we provide our constituents are an extremely important and an

absolutely essential function of congressional offices. Often Members' reputations among

their constituency are based on their ability to help individual constituents with all sorts

of more or less personal problems with the government. Constituent services involve

casework where an office staffer acts as an intermediary between the constituents and

whatever specific issue the constituent may have. Casework is crucial because it

addresses the real needs of our constituents and helps reduce the frustration they feel

towards what can appear to be a massive, impersonal government.

       It is greatly important to be able to prioritize the importance of each issue, which

should be ranked in order of urgency to the importance of the stakeholder. We attempt to

handle whatever issue is brought to out attention because if we do not do it, someone else

will and that person may become a future threat and individuals have a tendency to

remember when they were not helped. This is why it is absolutely necessary to prioritize

the importance of all issues so as not to overextend our staff and then be able to refer

those other issues to political allies. Strategic planning plays an essential role here.

       Constituent services also include community outreach where the representative

and his staff play an active role in the district. Community boards, religious and

community groups, boards of trade and other business interests, civic and merchant

associations, schools, hospitals, to name a few, all have a direct interest in the

representative and want something from him. It is imperative that we work closely with

all these stakeholders and provide them with access to the office so we can address their

concerns and remain aware of the issues affecting the district. This is why we are having

regular meetings, briefings or just talking with stakeholders and spending a significant
12


amount of time attending receptions. It also provides us with a framework for finding

common ground between any differences and what issues they hope to solve. This is

another way we increase the representative’s exposure and our accessibility while helping

the representative to avoid the label or stigma as being “unapproachable.”

       These two roles are dependent on each other. The one cannot go without the

other. No matter how effective we are in handling constituent casework, if we are not

active in the district itself, it will not make much difference to our stakeholders and vise

versa. This is especially true to our electoral base, which are our most important

stakeholders. When interacting with stakeholders it is imperative to have a clear line of

communication so everyone knows where they stand. It is essential to be open and

honest with your stakeholders. Never make vague promises or those that they cannot

keep for a short-term gain because it will negatively affect the Congressman and his

ability to perform over the long run. Most importantly, when conducting community

outreach, it is necessary to be continuously active in the community all year long and not

just around election time. Stakeholders are not foolish individuals and will realize that

the representative is just taking advantage of them for quick pre-election exposure. All

this becomes imperative, since the Congressman is up for election every two years.
13


                                     Financial Perspective
        Objectives               Measures                 Targets                Initiatives
Deliver Maximum value       Controlling costs       Closely Evaluate all     Comparative
to the Constituency                                 purchases                Shopping
                            Maximize
                            Productivity            Increase Response        Newsletter
                                                    Time to Constituent
                                                    Inquiries.               Maximize use of
                                                                             Email & our
                                                    Utilize Interns          Website

                                                 Purchase Products
                                                 that Increase the
                                                 Efficiency of the
                                                 Office
Budget Management           Allocate Funds       Use Funds to Make           Monitored Budget
                            According to Need    the Community               Management
                            and Importance       Aware of the
                                                 Congressman’s               Quarterly Review
                            Cost to Spend Ratios Achievements that
                                                 benefit the District        Utilize Free Press
                                                                             Releases &
                                                    Communicate the          Community
                                                    status of the Budget     Meetings to Promote
                                                    to Office Manager        Congressman
Cost efficiency             Maximize cost           Purchase only Cost       Quarterly Review
                            savings                 Effective Products
                                                                             Targeted Cost
                            Value Purchasing        Strategic Purchases      Containment

                            Maximize Value at
                            least Cost

Financial – No organization can successfully operate and meet customer requirements

without financial resources. If there is not a good measure of overall cost, the financial

perspective might be omitted from the measurement system, but then heavy attention

should be given to finding other more micro-cost-related measures in the other

perspectives, especially internal business processes and technology (Thor, 2003). In this

case, even though we are constraint by a federal budget, we where able to develop some

key measures. Our office should give specific attention to the financial segment of the
14


BSC to ensure they we are maintaining and advancing goals. We will also monitor cost

efficiency and budget management on a regular basis and evaluate and communicate

them throughout the office.

        The Congressman has a Members’ Representational Allowance (M.R.A.) of about

$1.2 million dollars to run his entire office (Conrad, 2005), which pays employee

salaries, and numerous expenses, such as: official & representational, district office,

communication, and franked mail to name a few. The MRA does not role over to the

following year so there are really no incentives to be cost effective, except that of public

opinion. There are many that feel that there is not enough oversight to these allowances

given to the Congressperson. It is viewed as more government waste. In the end it is the

constituents that provide the money for these MRAs, so they do have a right to be

concerned and question how and where are their tax dollars going, especially if it goes to

an elected official. If we can show our constituency that we are cost efficient and strictly

adhere to a budget, it could go a long to improving our electoral base. In addition, as a

fiscal conservative, what better way to lead by example than to manage our budget

efficiently and show that we are good stewards of the taxpayers’ money. Our goal every

year should be to finish in the black and when the Congressman returns the remaining

MRA balance to the Treasury Department, it will make for a nice press release. This is

why it is very important to pay careful attention to the various details of the financial

side.

                                    Internal Perspective
    Objectives             Measures               Targets                         Initiatives
15


Provide Highest      Electoral Margin         Strong Electoral Base       Quality & Service
Quality Service                                                           Leadership
                     Constituent              70-90% Satisfaction of
                     Satisfaction             all those who contact       Constituent Outreach
                                              the office                  Programs
Establish            Task Forces &            Evaluate & Prioritize       Establishing Task Forces
partnerships         Committees               the Community issues        & Committees to the
within the                                    & Establish Whatever        Appropriate Community
community            Internships              Necessary Task Forces       Issues
                                              & Committees
                                                                          Congressional Programs
Improve              Backlog of work          Acknowledge inquiry         Communication & IT
productivity                                  within the 2-4 days;        proficiency &
                     Labor productivity       Send out inquiry within     management
                                              the 7-10 days.
                     Equipment                                            Strategic Review
                     downtime
Identify &           Stakeholder              Know the constituents       Strategic Review
Evaluate our         Background               & what issues are
Stakeholders                                  driving your district       Prioritize Stakeholders

Internal – Our office will be focusing our internal efforts by providing the best possible

constituent services for the betterment of the constituents and the district as a whole.

However, it is also about getting the Member reelected and in turn keeping your job. We

must determine how to optimize our office in order to enhance our constituent services.

This is the goal and it must be continuously evaluated on a regular basis in order to

determine if we are meeting the needs of our constituents. It is also used to make certain

that office attitudes do not become lax. This is something offices are susceptible to when

working for an incumbent.

       Another important process in our attempt to exceed our constituents’ expectations

is to identify and evaluate all stakeholders that may affect the Congressman and his

office. This is first accomplished by identifying all of the constituent/community groups,

business organizations/interests, other governmental offices and officials, and individual

constituents who will require our attention. All stakeholders are important, but it is
16


important to evaluate each stakeholder and prioritize their relative importance. This is

necessary because constituent services are tough work. There is an unyielding demand

on our time and only so much can be accomplished at one time. There are times you can

listen to people talk about their issues for two or three hours at a time and those are long,

hard, draining hours, which take away from other necessary and important office work.

       We need to be approachable. However, we need to have control and organization

over how we run the office and handle our stakeholders. By prioritizing stakeholders, we

can structure a plan where we can best serve our stakeholders. From there we can assess

how well we are meeting all of our stakeholders' expectations while in turn develop

strategies to better meet the needs and expectations of our stakeholders. This too is

another important aspect of strategic planning. Simply put, we need to understand what

our stakeholders expect from us and making sure that we meet those expectations and

hopefully exceed them.

       Communication is important when dealing with our stakeholders so we are aware

of the issues affecting our district. That can only occur with the free exchange of

information. We need to continually work to build social and business relationships with

our team and stakeholders as a way to lessen any communication barriers surrounding

district issues. This too will be further elaborated on in the coming sections. However,

building social and business relationships is used to understand what issues are of

importance to our stakeholders. This also allows us to discover what issues affect our

stakeholders and find common ground between any differences. Two years is not much

time to work with and it is very easy to lose your electoral base. This is why our office
17


must be as efficient and effective as possible in order to exceed our constituents’

expectations.

                               Innovation & Learning Perspective
       Objectives                 Measures            Targets                         Initiatives

Quality & State of the      Availability of           Continue to          Work Closely with IT
art IT                      computer equipment        Upgrade IT when      support staff
                            with needed software      necessary
                            & connections

                            IT Competence &
                            Awareness

                            Utilization of key IT
Employee Satisfaction       Satisfaction surveys      Consistent Quality Employee Feedback &
                                                      Coverage at all    Review
                            Employee retention        Levels
                                                                         Shared Responsibilities /
                       Office Climate                                    Leadership Role
Improved Office        Overall Employee               Embraced Office    Evaluation & Strategy
Communication Strategy Knowledge                      Strategy           Meetings

                            Office Climate
Employee competencies       Employee skills           Training / Review    Support Assistance

Learning & Growth - Every aspect of constituent services and all our stakeholders must

be considered and prioritized when evaluating our service system. In our office we cross

somewhere between the self-service approach and the personal-attention approach. Our

service-system matrix varies from low contact through mail/email to high contact, such

as face-to-face meeting. It is inevitable that we will have to meet face-to-face with

constituents on a regular basis, but due to the extreme volume of casework we try to

direct constituents to make use all information systems available. However, since we

represent the Congressman, we must remain as accessible as possible. Nevertheless,

production efficiency greatly decreases when there is higher contact with constituents.

The lower the contact, such as through mail/email, fax, and Internet, the more efficiently
18


the system is allowed to function, since the constituent is unable to significantly affect or

disrupt the system. This gives us some control in how to best serve our stakeholders by

possibly easing some of our workload while preventing our staff from being taxed. IT is

improving productivity so it is important to take advantage of new technology to increase

customer or in this case constituent satisfaction.

       Leadership is also a critical element marking successful organizations. Leadership

does not stop at the top, but should cascade throughout an organization, creating

champions and a team approach to achievement of mission. BSC success often depends

on the presence of a leader(s) who is committed to the project's success (Lang, 2004) and

responsible for determining how to measure progress toward meeting the strategy;

collecting, measuring, and reporting data related to the strategy; and recommending

targets for each year.

       As previously mentioned, we are limited to no more than 18 permanent staffers

and four temporary staffers. It is up to the Chief of Staff to decide how that staff is to be

apportioned to best serve the district and depending on the needs of the district, the staff

can be spread thin. We must be able work around our limits to best serve our

constituents. It is key to be able to optimize our office staff to enhance our constituent

services.

       The key to the success of any project is the relationships that form within the

office and with the stakeholders. Communication and information exchange are key to

these relationships. We should utilize established internal communications channels to

help employees understand the strategic planning process, inform them of progress and
19


significant milestones, and continually remind them that strategic planning is a high

priority (Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004).

        In a healthy organizational culture all employees have value and are treated as

such. Information is treated as an important factor in the organization. The sharing and

free flow of information is encouraged to everyone within the organization. Staff

communication is essential so we aware of what direction our office headed in and we

remain focused on our mission. It also enables senior staff to more effectively

communicate the contents of the business plan to employees in a manner that links their

daily duties to the achievement of strategy (Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004). When

information flows freely throughout the office employees have a sense of pride and

loyalty and allows employees to remain focused on the organization’s mission. It is

detrimental that we are all on the same page. Any BSC no matter how perfectly

developed will fail unless proper, leadership, communication, efficiency and effective

decision making is in place.

                                District Office Strategic Mission:

       After evaluating the office’s four perspectives, we are able to determine that our

mission is to provide the best service to our constituency with the goal of improving our

electoral base and getting the Congressman reelected. This involves having a constant

communication between all of our stakeholders, evaluating and prioritizing our

stakeholders, while constantly looking for ways to improve and adjust the strategy when

necessary. It is imperative that we continue to monitor our BSC strategy and remain

flexible because performance management is an ever-changing process. This is key
20


because the BSC functions as the cornerstone of an organization's current and future

success (Kaplan & Norton, 1993).

                                        Conclusion:

       In the field of politics the stakes are high and there is little room for mistakes,

especially when you must run for office every two years. We must continually look to

improve or the Congressman may not get reelected and we would risk losing our jobs.

This is why we must not react to issues, but have a strategic management system to deal

with any issue possible that could affect the future of the office. Part of that strategic

management system is to provide the best possible constituent services.

       With a hard-working staff, an effective management team and the right set of

performance measures in place, we have built a performance driven office and have seen

project initiatives that continue to bring improvement to the process. Working with staff

and management, will be instrumental in sustaining progress as we monitor and evaluate

the effectiveness of the BSC because it is not just what is measured, but how the

measurements are used that determine organizational success (Kaplan & Norton, 2001).

We will use that knowledge to update and revise our vision and performance measures as

needed and to communicate that information. Working together with our stakeholders,

we will continue to meet our goals.
21


                                       References:

Chan, Y.C. (2002/2003, December/January). “The benefits of balance.” CMA

       Management, Volume 76, Issue 9, pg. 48. Retrieved December 4, 2005 from

       MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Chan, Y.C. (2004). “Performance measurement and adoption of balanced scorecard: A

       survey of municipal governments in the USA and Canada.” The International

       Journal of Public Sector Management, Volume 17, Issue 2/3, pg. 204. Retrieved

       December 4, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Conrad, D. (2005, November 25). “Lawmaker Keeps in Touch With Voters.” Yahoo

       News. Retrieved December 5, 2005 from Yahoo Financial on the World Wide

       Web: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20051125/ap_on_go_co/dialing_for_bean

Eagle, K., Cooke, T. & Rossi, T. (2004, October). “Translating Strategy Into Results.”

       Government Finance Review, Volume 20, Issue 5, pg. 16. Retrieved December 3,

       2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Ho, S., McKay, R. (2002, March). “BALANCED SCORECARD: TWO

       PERSPECTIVES.” CPA Journal, Volume 72, Issue 3. Business Source Premier

Lang, S. (2004, June). “Balanced Scorecard and Government Entities.” The CPA Journal,

       Volume 74, Issue 6, pg. 48. Retrieved December 7, 2005 from MdUSA database

       ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/.
22


Kaplan, R. & Norton, D. (1993, September/October). “Putting the balanced scorecard to

       work.” Harvard Business Review, Volume 71, Issue 5. Retrieved December 1,

       2005 from MdUSA database Business Source Premier on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Kaplan, R. & Norton, D. (1996, September/October). “Strategic learning & the balanced

       scorecard.” Strategy & Leadership, Volume 24, Issue 5, pg. 18. Retrieved

       December 2, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Kaplan, Robert S. & Norton, David P.; (1996, September). The Balanced Scorecard:

       Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business School Press

Members' Congressional Handbook. (2005). Retrieved December 9, 2005, from the

       Committee on House Administration Homepage on the World Wide Web:

       http://cha.house.gov/services/memberhandbook.htm

Oliveira, J. (2001, May). “THE BALANCED SCORECARD: AN INTEGRATIVE

       APPROACH TO PERFORMANCE EVALUATION.” Healthcare Financial

       Management, Volume 55, Issue 5. Retrieved December 2, 2005 from MdUSA

       database Business Source Premier on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Thor, C. (2003, May/June). “How to find, select, and display performance measures in

       government.” Cost Management, Volume 17, Issue 3, pg. 31. Retrieved

       December 5, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web:

       http://www.umuc.edu/library/.

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Balanced Score Card Congressional District Office

Ygl Yearin Review 2009
Ygl Yearin Review 2009Ygl Yearin Review 2009
Ygl Yearin Review 2009guest1a4e77
 
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2Kevin Wren
 
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget Office
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget OfficeKey Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget Office
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 
Maryland Heights MO Strategic Plan
Maryland Heights MO Strategic PlanMaryland Heights MO Strategic Plan
Maryland Heights MO Strategic PlanTracy Quintana
 
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdo
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdoCy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdo
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdoDon Vincent Busto
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersCongressional Budget Office
 
Holding an effective bond election
Holding an effective bond electionHolding an effective bond election
Holding an effective bond electionRodolfo Segura
 
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentation
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentationCity Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentation
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentationCity of San Angelo Texas
 
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil Bazzani
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil BazzaniYork Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil Bazzani
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil BazzaniChuck Thompson
 
Tithing Packet Training
Tithing Packet TrainingTithing Packet Training
Tithing Packet Trainingwebmasterqol
 
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pd
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pdDistrict of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pd
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pdKimberly Sallie
 
Memo to council June 13 2016
Memo to council June 13 2016Memo to council June 13 2016
Memo to council June 13 2016Devyn Barrie
 
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17Dylan Gibson
 
Somerville FY23 Proposed Budget
Somerville FY23 Proposed BudgetSomerville FY23 Proposed Budget
Somerville FY23 Proposed BudgetChris Dwan
 
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communication
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communicationDelivering reputation enhancing strategic communication
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communicationRonnie Semley Dip. CIPR, MCIPR
 
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...iosrjce
 
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...OECDtax
 
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean Quan
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean QuanOakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean Quan
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean QuanMake Oakland Better Now!
 
strategicplan serviceagency
strategicplan serviceagencystrategicplan serviceagency
strategicplan serviceagencysplashrock_lex
 

Similar a Balanced Score Card Congressional District Office (20)

Ygl Yearin Review 2009
Ygl Yearin Review 2009Ygl Yearin Review 2009
Ygl Yearin Review 2009
 
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 2
 
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget Office
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget OfficeKey Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget Office
Key Tenets of Effective Communication at the Congressional Budget Office
 
Maryland Heights MO Strategic Plan
Maryland Heights MO Strategic PlanMaryland Heights MO Strategic Plan
Maryland Heights MO Strategic Plan
 
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdo
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdoCy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdo
Cy 2013 2016 cap dev-ela of sanjoseoccmdo
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
 
Holding an effective bond election
Holding an effective bond electionHolding an effective bond election
Holding an effective bond election
 
2015 Performance
2015 Performance2015 Performance
2015 Performance
 
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentation
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentationCity Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentation
City Council April 3, 2012 Slavin presentation
 
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil Bazzani
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil BazzaniYork Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil Bazzani
York Herald 2015 1-15, By Phil Bazzani
 
Tithing Packet Training
Tithing Packet TrainingTithing Packet Training
Tithing Packet Training
 
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pd
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pdDistrict of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pd
District of Columbia Housing Authority (DCHA) Deputy Director of Finance pd
 
Memo to council June 13 2016
Memo to council June 13 2016Memo to council June 13 2016
Memo to council June 13 2016
 
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17
City Beat Newsletter - January-February 17
 
Somerville FY23 Proposed Budget
Somerville FY23 Proposed BudgetSomerville FY23 Proposed Budget
Somerville FY23 Proposed Budget
 
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communication
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communicationDelivering reputation enhancing strategic communication
Delivering reputation enhancing strategic communication
 
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...
Budget Allocation System of Regional Government Authority (Case Study at Sela...
 
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...
Session Six: Performance Budgeting For Sub National Entities, China, Meeting ...
 
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean Quan
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean QuanOakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean Quan
Oakland Mayoral Candidate Questionnaire 2014 - Jean Quan
 
strategicplan serviceagency
strategicplan serviceagencystrategicplan serviceagency
strategicplan serviceagency
 

Más de Andrew Olsen

Asia renal care taiwan business plan
Asia renal care taiwan business planAsia renal care taiwan business plan
Asia renal care taiwan business planAndrew Olsen
 
Zipcar case analysis
Zipcar case analysisZipcar case analysis
Zipcar case analysisAndrew Olsen
 
Wireless information management, a review
Wireless information management, a reviewWireless information management, a review
Wireless information management, a reviewAndrew Olsen
 
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a review
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a reviewWireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a review
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a reviewAndrew Olsen
 
Internet marketing startegy for Nike
Internet marketing startegy for NikeInternet marketing startegy for Nike
Internet marketing startegy for NikeAndrew Olsen
 
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & OutsourcingFriedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & OutsourcingAndrew Olsen
 
Fast food vs family restaurant
Fast food vs family restaurantFast food vs family restaurant
Fast food vs family restaurantAndrew Olsen
 

Más de Andrew Olsen (7)

Asia renal care taiwan business plan
Asia renal care taiwan business planAsia renal care taiwan business plan
Asia renal care taiwan business plan
 
Zipcar case analysis
Zipcar case analysisZipcar case analysis
Zipcar case analysis
 
Wireless information management, a review
Wireless information management, a reviewWireless information management, a review
Wireless information management, a review
 
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a review
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a reviewWireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a review
Wireless advertising messaging legal analysis & public policy issues, a review
 
Internet marketing startegy for Nike
Internet marketing startegy for NikeInternet marketing startegy for Nike
Internet marketing startegy for Nike
 
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & OutsourcingFriedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
 
Fast food vs family restaurant
Fast food vs family restaurantFast food vs family restaurant
Fast food vs family restaurant
 

Balanced Score Card Congressional District Office

  • 1. Andrew Olsen Balanced Scorecard: Congressional District Office University of Maryland University College
  • 2. 2 Table of Contents: Executive Summary…………………………………………………………… 3-4 Introduction………………………………………………………………………. 5 Overview of a Congressional District Office………………………………….. 6-7 BSC Performance Measurement & Strategic Management System………… 7 Creating a BSC……..…………………………………………………………… 7-8 Governmental BSC………………………….………………………………….. 8-9 Brooklyn District Office BSC..…………………………………………………. 9-19 Customer Perspective….………………………………………………. 10-12 Financial Perspective …………………………………………………. 13-14 Internal Perspective ………………………………………………….. 14-17 Innovation & Learning Perspective…………………………………… 17-19 District Office Strategic Mission….…………………………………………… 19-20 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………… 20 References……………………………………………………………………… 21-22
  • 3. 3 Executive Summary I am currently employed for Congressman Vito Fossella as a constituent liaison in his Brooklyn District office. The fact that his district covers two boroughs that is connected by a bridge, posses an especially challenging strategic situation. How do we make sure that the Congressman spends enough time between the two boroughs, while also being represented appropriately within the district, particularly when he has a prior commitment? The Congressman and his staff are a service-based governmental organization. A majority of the services we provide are Federal in nature, but we also deal with numerous nonfederal issues because we want to give our constituents the best possible service. Community outreach is very important and utterly necessary that we both play an active role in the community. The BSC is a performance measurement and strategic management system that translates an organization's mission and strategy into a balanced set of integrated performance measures. It allows an organization to monitor its current and efforts to improve processes, motivate and educate employees, and enhance its ability to learn and improve. When creating a BSC, it is imperative that senior staffers review the organization’s vision, mission, values, goals, strategies and annual objectives in order to identify their strategic success factors. The key is to identify objectives that will maintain a strategic focus the office can understand and follow. Government offices exist not to make a profit, but to accomplish a mission, which is placed at the top of the BSC framework. When developing a BSC for a governmental office the customer perspective is the most important because it captures the ability of the
  • 4. 4 organization to provide quality and effective delivery of services, and overall customer satisfaction. In government, financial considerations have a constraining role, but will rarely be the primary objective. The final two perspectives represent and assess the government’s ability to continually complete its mission. The services we provide our constituents are extremely important and absolutely essential functions of congressional offices. It is imperative that we work closely with all these stakeholders and provide them with access to the office so we can all address their concerns and remain aware of the issues affecting the district. When interacting with stakeholders it is imperative to have a clear line of communication so everyone knows where they stand. Our office should give specific attention to the financial segment of the BSC to ensure they we are maintaining and advancing goals and will focus our internal efforts by providing the best possible constituent services for the betterment of the constituents and the district as a whole. Communication is important when dealing with our stakeholders so we are aware of the issues affecting our district. Every aspect of constituent services and all our stakeholders must be considered and prioritized when evaluating our service system. The key to the success of any project is the relationships that form within the office and with the stakeholders. Any BSC no matter how perfectly developed will fail unless proper, leadership, communication, efficiency and effective decision making is in place. With a hard-working staff, an effective management team and the right set of performance measures in place, we have built a performance driven office and have seen project initiatives that continue to bring improvement to the process. Working together with our stakeholders, we will continue to meet our goals.
  • 5. 5 Introduction: I am currently employed for Congressman Vito Fossella as a constituent liaison in his Brooklyn District office. His district encompasses all of Staten Island (S.I.) and the Southern section of Brooklyn and is connected by the Narrows Verrazzano Bridge (V.Z.). The fact that his district covers two boroughs that is connected by a bridge, posses an especially challenging strategic situation. How do we make sure that the Congressman spends enough time between the two boroughs, while also being represented appropriately within the district, particularly when he has a prior commitment? The reason this is so important because S.I. represents almost three fourths of the district with about 441,000 residents, while the Brooklyn side of the district has roughly 175,000 residents. Since S.I. is the significantly larger part of the district and the Congressman was born and raised there, S.I. tends to get the most attention, thus leaving Brooklyn with the “little brother complex,” as the forgotten or overlooked section of the district. This sentiment was brewing for several years. It was so deep-rooted that it even went back to the prior Congresswoman. No matter how much we in his Brooklyn office stressed how strong this opinion was and the importance that something needed to be done, nothing ever happened. This opinion continued to gain strength until finally in the 2004 election, he lost the Brooklyn side of district for the first time in his seven-year congressional career. Now there is a new fervor for Brooklyn and rightfully so, especially if he wants to continue as the Representative of the 13 th Congressional District. However, it is my intention to elaborate how this could have been and will continue to be avoided by incorporating the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) strategic management system.
  • 6. 6 Overview of a Congressional District Office: The Congressman and his staff are a service-based governmental organization. Constituents are not charged for the services we provide. However, they do pay for these services, as taxpayers. Federal budgets are funded by tax dollars through yearly appropriations and this is also true of a House member’s office budget. A majority of the services we provide are Federal in nature, but we also deal with numerous nonfederal issues because we want to give our constituents the best possible service without giving them that run around feeling. Congressional offices are an intermediary between their constituents and whatever the specific issue the constituent may have. Currently in the Brooklyn office, we handle all constituent issues related to the Department of Homeland Security (D.H.S.), the Department of State (D.O.S.) and any local issue related to the Brooklyn side of the district. We are the Congressman’s representatives and it is our job and it should be our goal to provide the best service possible to best meet the needs of the constituency. Then there is the all important community outreach. Whether it is the Congressman or an office representative, it is very important and utterly necessary that they both play an active role in the community. This is especially important for the office staff, since the Member can spend most of the week in D.C. while Congress is in session. To perform these services the Congressman is greatly dependent on the quality of his staff. However, the problem we face is that congressional offices are limited by law to a specific number of staffers. According to 2 U.S.C. § 92, we may employ 18 permanent employees and 4 additional employees, such as part-time employees (Members' Congressional Handbook: Staff, 2005). It is up to Chief of Staff to decide
  • 7. 7 how to allocate the office staff appropriately so to best serve the congressional district. Depending on the needs of the district, the staff can be spread thin. All these issues will be further elaborated on in BSC section of the paper. BSC Performance Measurement & Strategic Management System: BSC focuses on strategy and vision, not on control. It is a performance measurement and strategic management system that translates an organization's mission and strategy into a balanced set of integrated performance measures (Ho & McKay, 2002). These measures are grounded in an organization's strategic objectives and competitive demands and, by requiring managers to select a limited number of critical indicators within each of the four perspectives (Financial, Internal Business, Customer, and Learning and Growth), helps focus this strategic vision (Kaplan & Norton, 1993). Performance measures provide a concise yet complete picture of an organization's progress toward its mission and goal (Ho & McKay, 2002). Through the BSC, an organization monitors both its current and its efforts to improve processes, motivate and educate employees, and enhance its ability to learn and improve. Creating a BSC: When creating a BSC, it is imperative that senior staffers review the organization’s vision, mission, values, goals, strategies and annual objectives in order to identify their strategic success factors (Kaplan & Norton, 1996). They have the most comprehensive view of the organization and their support is necessary for acceptance within the organization. Most importantly, the senior staff must establish a clear understanding of the organization’s objectives so it can be clearly communicated to every
  • 8. 8 employee. The key is to identify objectives that will maintain a strategic focus the office can understand and follow. The BSC can be customized, but it must have unity and purpose. Senior staff must determine the key performance indicators and targets for the organization and establish some initiatives in order to determine how the business will meet these targets. The performance indicators can be influenced directly by everyone in the organization, thereby encouraging changes in behavior and activities to achieve its strategies. These indicators are staff development, internal efficiency, customer satisfaction, and long-term financial performance (Oliveira, 2001). Indicators are maintained to measure an organization’s progress toward achieving its vision; other indicators are maintained to measure the long-term drivers of success. Basically, managers are able to monitor and adjust the implementation of their strategy, and to make fundamental changes in the strategy itself (Kaplan & Norton, 1996). Governmental BSC: Government offices exist not to make a profit, but to accomplish a mission, which is placed at the top of the BSC framework. Strategy will always be key to achieving that mission, which is base on their customers, not financial stakeholders. The strategic planning process begins by determining the government's primary objectives, which are related to its stakeholders and then the secondary objectives, which reflect the choices that will be used to pursue the primary objectives, are then established (Chan, 2002/2003). When developing a BSC for a governmental office the customer perspective is the most important because it captures the ability of the organization to provide quality and
  • 9. 9 effective delivery of services, and overall customer satisfaction. Recognizing that budgets are limiting factors, governmental offices should have a greater stewardship responsibility and focus than do private sector entities. In government, financial considerations have a constraining role, but will rarely be the primary objective. Success for such organizations should be measured by how effectively and efficiently these organizations meet the needs of their constituencies and even their ability to control costs and manage their budget. Government offices have to focus their limited resources on specific objectives and constituents (Chan, 2004). The financial perspective is a resource needed to attain objectives not usually related to profit (Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004). The internal business perspective can encourage the government to change and improve the way it delivered services, especially by forming partnerships within communities and improving productivity. While the learning and growth perspectives can determine whether the government is maintaining employee training and skills so that it could continually improve. Basically, these final two perspectives represent and assess the government’s ability to continually complete its mission. These four perspectives will be evaluated in the next few sections. Brooklyn District Office BSC: The different perspectives incorporated in the BSC assist the senior staff to focus more on long-term objectives. Monitoring performance and learning from the results, in the customer, internal process, employee learning and growth, and financial perspectives will provide you with the direction for planning short-term objectives important for achieving the overall strategy, as well as a check on how the organization is doing in
  • 10. 10 fulfilling those objectives and guide us ever closer to achievement of the mission (Lang, 2004). However, due to the nature of politics, specifically for a Congressman, long-term objectives consist of two-year increments. For that reason, the short-term objectives may play a more prominent role and the objectives may be more general. Customer Perspective Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives Continuously Electoral Margin Strong Electoral Base Quality Staff & Improving Constituent Service Leadership Service Inquiry Acknowledge inquiry acknowledgement within the first 2-4 Equipment & days; Send out inquiry Service Excellence within the first 7-10 Constituent days. Convenient Methods Satisfaction of Contact 70-90% Satisfaction of all those who contact the office Establish partnerships Task Forces & Evaluate & Prioritize Establishing Task within the community Committees the Community issues Forces & & Establish Whatever Committees to the Internships Necessary Task Forces Appropriate & Committees Community Issues Congressional Programs Improved Constituent Community Attend 80-100% of all Meeting with & Community Support community meetings. various community Outreach Making sure the groups Marketing the Congressman attends Congressman the important meetings Constituent Surveys Numerous Programs Congressional Sponsored by the Programs Congressman Making the Community Aware of the Congressman’s Achievements that benefit the District
  • 11. 11 Customer – The services we provide our constituents are an extremely important and an absolutely essential function of congressional offices. Often Members' reputations among their constituency are based on their ability to help individual constituents with all sorts of more or less personal problems with the government. Constituent services involve casework where an office staffer acts as an intermediary between the constituents and whatever specific issue the constituent may have. Casework is crucial because it addresses the real needs of our constituents and helps reduce the frustration they feel towards what can appear to be a massive, impersonal government. It is greatly important to be able to prioritize the importance of each issue, which should be ranked in order of urgency to the importance of the stakeholder. We attempt to handle whatever issue is brought to out attention because if we do not do it, someone else will and that person may become a future threat and individuals have a tendency to remember when they were not helped. This is why it is absolutely necessary to prioritize the importance of all issues so as not to overextend our staff and then be able to refer those other issues to political allies. Strategic planning plays an essential role here. Constituent services also include community outreach where the representative and his staff play an active role in the district. Community boards, religious and community groups, boards of trade and other business interests, civic and merchant associations, schools, hospitals, to name a few, all have a direct interest in the representative and want something from him. It is imperative that we work closely with all these stakeholders and provide them with access to the office so we can address their concerns and remain aware of the issues affecting the district. This is why we are having regular meetings, briefings or just talking with stakeholders and spending a significant
  • 12. 12 amount of time attending receptions. It also provides us with a framework for finding common ground between any differences and what issues they hope to solve. This is another way we increase the representative’s exposure and our accessibility while helping the representative to avoid the label or stigma as being “unapproachable.” These two roles are dependent on each other. The one cannot go without the other. No matter how effective we are in handling constituent casework, if we are not active in the district itself, it will not make much difference to our stakeholders and vise versa. This is especially true to our electoral base, which are our most important stakeholders. When interacting with stakeholders it is imperative to have a clear line of communication so everyone knows where they stand. It is essential to be open and honest with your stakeholders. Never make vague promises or those that they cannot keep for a short-term gain because it will negatively affect the Congressman and his ability to perform over the long run. Most importantly, when conducting community outreach, it is necessary to be continuously active in the community all year long and not just around election time. Stakeholders are not foolish individuals and will realize that the representative is just taking advantage of them for quick pre-election exposure. All this becomes imperative, since the Congressman is up for election every two years.
  • 13. 13 Financial Perspective Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives Deliver Maximum value Controlling costs Closely Evaluate all Comparative to the Constituency purchases Shopping Maximize Productivity Increase Response Newsletter Time to Constituent Inquiries. Maximize use of Email & our Utilize Interns Website Purchase Products that Increase the Efficiency of the Office Budget Management Allocate Funds Use Funds to Make Monitored Budget According to Need the Community Management and Importance Aware of the Congressman’s Quarterly Review Cost to Spend Ratios Achievements that benefit the District Utilize Free Press Releases & Communicate the Community status of the Budget Meetings to Promote to Office Manager Congressman Cost efficiency Maximize cost Purchase only Cost Quarterly Review savings Effective Products Targeted Cost Value Purchasing Strategic Purchases Containment Maximize Value at least Cost Financial – No organization can successfully operate and meet customer requirements without financial resources. If there is not a good measure of overall cost, the financial perspective might be omitted from the measurement system, but then heavy attention should be given to finding other more micro-cost-related measures in the other perspectives, especially internal business processes and technology (Thor, 2003). In this case, even though we are constraint by a federal budget, we where able to develop some key measures. Our office should give specific attention to the financial segment of the
  • 14. 14 BSC to ensure they we are maintaining and advancing goals. We will also monitor cost efficiency and budget management on a regular basis and evaluate and communicate them throughout the office. The Congressman has a Members’ Representational Allowance (M.R.A.) of about $1.2 million dollars to run his entire office (Conrad, 2005), which pays employee salaries, and numerous expenses, such as: official & representational, district office, communication, and franked mail to name a few. The MRA does not role over to the following year so there are really no incentives to be cost effective, except that of public opinion. There are many that feel that there is not enough oversight to these allowances given to the Congressperson. It is viewed as more government waste. In the end it is the constituents that provide the money for these MRAs, so they do have a right to be concerned and question how and where are their tax dollars going, especially if it goes to an elected official. If we can show our constituency that we are cost efficient and strictly adhere to a budget, it could go a long to improving our electoral base. In addition, as a fiscal conservative, what better way to lead by example than to manage our budget efficiently and show that we are good stewards of the taxpayers’ money. Our goal every year should be to finish in the black and when the Congressman returns the remaining MRA balance to the Treasury Department, it will make for a nice press release. This is why it is very important to pay careful attention to the various details of the financial side. Internal Perspective Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives
  • 15. 15 Provide Highest Electoral Margin Strong Electoral Base Quality & Service Quality Service Leadership Constituent 70-90% Satisfaction of Satisfaction all those who contact Constituent Outreach the office Programs Establish Task Forces & Evaluate & Prioritize Establishing Task Forces partnerships Committees the Community issues & Committees to the within the & Establish Whatever Appropriate Community community Internships Necessary Task Forces Issues & Committees Congressional Programs Improve Backlog of work Acknowledge inquiry Communication & IT productivity within the 2-4 days; proficiency & Labor productivity Send out inquiry within management the 7-10 days. Equipment Strategic Review downtime Identify & Stakeholder Know the constituents Strategic Review Evaluate our Background & what issues are Stakeholders driving your district Prioritize Stakeholders Internal – Our office will be focusing our internal efforts by providing the best possible constituent services for the betterment of the constituents and the district as a whole. However, it is also about getting the Member reelected and in turn keeping your job. We must determine how to optimize our office in order to enhance our constituent services. This is the goal and it must be continuously evaluated on a regular basis in order to determine if we are meeting the needs of our constituents. It is also used to make certain that office attitudes do not become lax. This is something offices are susceptible to when working for an incumbent. Another important process in our attempt to exceed our constituents’ expectations is to identify and evaluate all stakeholders that may affect the Congressman and his office. This is first accomplished by identifying all of the constituent/community groups, business organizations/interests, other governmental offices and officials, and individual constituents who will require our attention. All stakeholders are important, but it is
  • 16. 16 important to evaluate each stakeholder and prioritize their relative importance. This is necessary because constituent services are tough work. There is an unyielding demand on our time and only so much can be accomplished at one time. There are times you can listen to people talk about their issues for two or three hours at a time and those are long, hard, draining hours, which take away from other necessary and important office work. We need to be approachable. However, we need to have control and organization over how we run the office and handle our stakeholders. By prioritizing stakeholders, we can structure a plan where we can best serve our stakeholders. From there we can assess how well we are meeting all of our stakeholders' expectations while in turn develop strategies to better meet the needs and expectations of our stakeholders. This too is another important aspect of strategic planning. Simply put, we need to understand what our stakeholders expect from us and making sure that we meet those expectations and hopefully exceed them. Communication is important when dealing with our stakeholders so we are aware of the issues affecting our district. That can only occur with the free exchange of information. We need to continually work to build social and business relationships with our team and stakeholders as a way to lessen any communication barriers surrounding district issues. This too will be further elaborated on in the coming sections. However, building social and business relationships is used to understand what issues are of importance to our stakeholders. This also allows us to discover what issues affect our stakeholders and find common ground between any differences. Two years is not much time to work with and it is very easy to lose your electoral base. This is why our office
  • 17. 17 must be as efficient and effective as possible in order to exceed our constituents’ expectations. Innovation & Learning Perspective Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives Quality & State of the Availability of Continue to Work Closely with IT art IT computer equipment Upgrade IT when support staff with needed software necessary & connections IT Competence & Awareness Utilization of key IT Employee Satisfaction Satisfaction surveys Consistent Quality Employee Feedback & Coverage at all Review Employee retention Levels Shared Responsibilities / Office Climate Leadership Role Improved Office Overall Employee Embraced Office Evaluation & Strategy Communication Strategy Knowledge Strategy Meetings Office Climate Employee competencies Employee skills Training / Review Support Assistance Learning & Growth - Every aspect of constituent services and all our stakeholders must be considered and prioritized when evaluating our service system. In our office we cross somewhere between the self-service approach and the personal-attention approach. Our service-system matrix varies from low contact through mail/email to high contact, such as face-to-face meeting. It is inevitable that we will have to meet face-to-face with constituents on a regular basis, but due to the extreme volume of casework we try to direct constituents to make use all information systems available. However, since we represent the Congressman, we must remain as accessible as possible. Nevertheless, production efficiency greatly decreases when there is higher contact with constituents. The lower the contact, such as through mail/email, fax, and Internet, the more efficiently
  • 18. 18 the system is allowed to function, since the constituent is unable to significantly affect or disrupt the system. This gives us some control in how to best serve our stakeholders by possibly easing some of our workload while preventing our staff from being taxed. IT is improving productivity so it is important to take advantage of new technology to increase customer or in this case constituent satisfaction. Leadership is also a critical element marking successful organizations. Leadership does not stop at the top, but should cascade throughout an organization, creating champions and a team approach to achievement of mission. BSC success often depends on the presence of a leader(s) who is committed to the project's success (Lang, 2004) and responsible for determining how to measure progress toward meeting the strategy; collecting, measuring, and reporting data related to the strategy; and recommending targets for each year. As previously mentioned, we are limited to no more than 18 permanent staffers and four temporary staffers. It is up to the Chief of Staff to decide how that staff is to be apportioned to best serve the district and depending on the needs of the district, the staff can be spread thin. We must be able work around our limits to best serve our constituents. It is key to be able to optimize our office staff to enhance our constituent services. The key to the success of any project is the relationships that form within the office and with the stakeholders. Communication and information exchange are key to these relationships. We should utilize established internal communications channels to help employees understand the strategic planning process, inform them of progress and
  • 19. 19 significant milestones, and continually remind them that strategic planning is a high priority (Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004). In a healthy organizational culture all employees have value and are treated as such. Information is treated as an important factor in the organization. The sharing and free flow of information is encouraged to everyone within the organization. Staff communication is essential so we aware of what direction our office headed in and we remain focused on our mission. It also enables senior staff to more effectively communicate the contents of the business plan to employees in a manner that links their daily duties to the achievement of strategy (Eagle, Cooke, & Rossi, 2004). When information flows freely throughout the office employees have a sense of pride and loyalty and allows employees to remain focused on the organization’s mission. It is detrimental that we are all on the same page. Any BSC no matter how perfectly developed will fail unless proper, leadership, communication, efficiency and effective decision making is in place. District Office Strategic Mission: After evaluating the office’s four perspectives, we are able to determine that our mission is to provide the best service to our constituency with the goal of improving our electoral base and getting the Congressman reelected. This involves having a constant communication between all of our stakeholders, evaluating and prioritizing our stakeholders, while constantly looking for ways to improve and adjust the strategy when necessary. It is imperative that we continue to monitor our BSC strategy and remain flexible because performance management is an ever-changing process. This is key
  • 20. 20 because the BSC functions as the cornerstone of an organization's current and future success (Kaplan & Norton, 1993). Conclusion: In the field of politics the stakes are high and there is little room for mistakes, especially when you must run for office every two years. We must continually look to improve or the Congressman may not get reelected and we would risk losing our jobs. This is why we must not react to issues, but have a strategic management system to deal with any issue possible that could affect the future of the office. Part of that strategic management system is to provide the best possible constituent services. With a hard-working staff, an effective management team and the right set of performance measures in place, we have built a performance driven office and have seen project initiatives that continue to bring improvement to the process. Working with staff and management, will be instrumental in sustaining progress as we monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of the BSC because it is not just what is measured, but how the measurements are used that determine organizational success (Kaplan & Norton, 2001). We will use that knowledge to update and revise our vision and performance measures as needed and to communicate that information. Working together with our stakeholders, we will continue to meet our goals.
  • 21. 21 References: Chan, Y.C. (2002/2003, December/January). “The benefits of balance.” CMA Management, Volume 76, Issue 9, pg. 48. Retrieved December 4, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Chan, Y.C. (2004). “Performance measurement and adoption of balanced scorecard: A survey of municipal governments in the USA and Canada.” The International Journal of Public Sector Management, Volume 17, Issue 2/3, pg. 204. Retrieved December 4, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Conrad, D. (2005, November 25). “Lawmaker Keeps in Touch With Voters.” Yahoo News. Retrieved December 5, 2005 from Yahoo Financial on the World Wide Web: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20051125/ap_on_go_co/dialing_for_bean Eagle, K., Cooke, T. & Rossi, T. (2004, October). “Translating Strategy Into Results.” Government Finance Review, Volume 20, Issue 5, pg. 16. Retrieved December 3, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Ho, S., McKay, R. (2002, March). “BALANCED SCORECARD: TWO PERSPECTIVES.” CPA Journal, Volume 72, Issue 3. Business Source Premier Lang, S. (2004, June). “Balanced Scorecard and Government Entities.” The CPA Journal, Volume 74, Issue 6, pg. 48. Retrieved December 7, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/.
  • 22. 22 Kaplan, R. & Norton, D. (1993, September/October). “Putting the balanced scorecard to work.” Harvard Business Review, Volume 71, Issue 5. Retrieved December 1, 2005 from MdUSA database Business Source Premier on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Kaplan, R. & Norton, D. (1996, September/October). “Strategic learning & the balanced scorecard.” Strategy & Leadership, Volume 24, Issue 5, pg. 18. Retrieved December 2, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Kaplan, Robert S. & Norton, David P.; (1996, September). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business School Press Members' Congressional Handbook. (2005). Retrieved December 9, 2005, from the Committee on House Administration Homepage on the World Wide Web: http://cha.house.gov/services/memberhandbook.htm Oliveira, J. (2001, May). “THE BALANCED SCORECARD: AN INTEGRATIVE APPROACH TO PERFORMANCE EVALUATION.” Healthcare Financial Management, Volume 55, Issue 5. Retrieved December 2, 2005 from MdUSA database Business Source Premier on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/. Thor, C. (2003, May/June). “How to find, select, and display performance measures in government.” Cost Management, Volume 17, Issue 3, pg. 31. Retrieved December 5, 2005 from MdUSA database ABI/Inform on the World Wide Web: http://www.umuc.edu/library/.