SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 11
Descargar para leer sin conexión
YEAR   COMPANY       PROJECT       TITLE                                       SPONSORED BY



2009                 Dustbuster    The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster
                                   “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place




       Borne out of the ashes of a marketplace failure, Dustbuster created a new mass-
       market category as it took the Black & Decker brand from the workshop into the home.
       Dustbuster has continued to lead the category for thirty years.
In 1972, Black & Decker was getting worried. They had every reason to be. Their core power tool business had
been under assault from foreign competition since the 1960s. While their low-cost consumer power tools had
been successful since post WW2, that very success had eroded their reputation in the more profitable professional
power tool category. After decades of growth and success, people were beginning to think of Black & Decker as
the low-end manufacturer. This did not sit well with the Maryland-based company. Their foundation had been built
on innovation and quality… quality that had been recognized in 1943 with the prestigious Army-Navy E Award.
Only five percent of the thousands of manufacturers eligible were awarded this merit for outstanding production
in support of the War and Navy departments1. It was only natural for Black & Decker to draw upon their history of
creating breakthrough innovations to propel their business through trying times.




An Historic Heritage – To the Moon and Back
In 1960, the space race was well underway. NASA was very in-
terested in battery-based, “no-torque” power tools. Cords were
problematic both because they were easy to get tangled in and
because the nearest electrical outlet might well be nearly 250,000
miles away. Torque, on the other hand, was a big problem in zero
and low gravity. Thanks to Newton’s Third Law, an astronaut using a
high-torque drill in space would be launched into orbit… around the
drill bit. Since whirling dervish astronauts weren’t the goal, NASA
awarded Black & Decker a choice contract. The challenge was to
develop cordless, rechargeable, “no-torque” electric wrenches for
use in space, and drills for extracting core samples on the surface
of the moon.

Battery-operated products using dry-cell zinc batteries had
been around for decades. But their use was primarily in toys or
other small products that required very little power. Since zinc
batteries had limited capacities, the batteries would need frequent
replacement in situations with higher power requirements. In the
1960s, General Electric (GE) developed new rechargeable nickel
cadmium (NiCad) batteries with considerably more power and life.
Using these new batteries, Black & Decker introduced the world’s
first cordless rechargeable drill in 1961. A year later, they used the   The torque-reducing technology built into the Black &
same technology in a shrub trimmer. Despite these advances, the          Decker Moon Drill kept Apollo 15 astronauts grounded
                                                                         while working in the low gravity conditions of the lunar
new technology remained costly and inefficient.                          surface.

Funding from the space program fueled the breakthroughs required
to deliver the cordless Minimum Torque Reaction Space Tool, which was used in 1964 by Project Gemini astronauts
working in weightless conditions. Later, in 1971, the Black & Decker Moon Drill was used on the Apollo 15 mission
to the lunar surface.




Cordless Goes Modular
The research undertaken by GE and Black & Decker for the NASA projects greatly increased the quality and reduced
the cost of rechargeable batteries. This opened up new opportunities for battery powered consumer products. In



                  YEAR       COMPANY         PROJECT        TITLE                                                PAGE(S)



                  2009                       Dustbuster     The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster            18 of 50
                                                            “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
1969, a cordless reel lawn mower was introduced. It used much larger rechargeable batteries than the small NiCad
batteries used in hand tools.

So, when they found themselves under attack by low-cost foreign competitors, Black & Decker knew better than
to simply square off against the competition in a price war. Remembering the entrepreneurial spirit of founders
S. Duncan Black and Alonzo G. Decker, they sought instead to regain their competitive edge by developing high-
end innovations. They began by engaging in an extraordinary internal effort focused on new product research and
development. The overarching strategy was to increase sales growth by expanding beyond their strong, power-tool
base and into labor-saving devices in general. Where others might have focused on cost-cutting, Black & Decker
execs focused on creating new products that would expand their business into new markets.

One of the most interesting such projects was the development of the Mod 4 Power Handle Cordless System guided
by senior industrial designer Rod Bunyea. The name was derived from the four NiCad power cells in the handle. The
concept began as an attempt to develop a new handheld, cordless grass shear that could, with the addition of a
wheeled extension handle, also be used in a standing position. The grass shear design was configured in two parts –
the business end with the clippers, and the power end that included the batteries in a handle housing. The extension
tube for stand-up use fit between the two parts. This design inspired an entirely new concept for modular products.
With a separate power handle, additional functional assemblies beyond the grass shear head could be attached.
For example, a ¼” drill head, a shrub trimmer, a sealed-beam lantern, and a small vacuum cleaner called the Spot-
vac. All would be compact, cordless, and hand-held, and all would be interchangeable with a single, rechargeable
power source. Most importantly, the retail price of such a modular system of products would be considerably less
than the cost of five individual products. Amidst high expectations, the Mod 4 system was introduced in 1974 and
immediately hailed as an innovative new product. In May 1977, it was featured in Fortune Magazine as one of the
25 best designed products available in the US.




A Hard-Learned Reality Check
Despite all the acclaim, the Mod 4 system was a failure in the mar-
ketplace. Sales were far less than anticipated. Post-mortem market
research revealed the reasons. First and foremost, buyers did not
like to buy multi-purpose products. The Mod 4 was deliberately sold
as a set of five, simply to make the price of each seem more reason-
able. If sold individually, the cost of the batteries inside each sepa-
rate unit would make the price too high. But even though the price of
the entire system of five products was about the same as the price
for two, buyers simply preferred to buy one product at a time.

Rechargeable batteries were confounding to new users. Most
                                                                       The modular Mod 4 system was hailed as a great
people were more familiar with existing battery-operated products, innovation, yet failed in the marketplace. Lesson’s
like toys, which used disposable batteries. They simply didn’t from the Mod 4’s demise gave rise to the Dustbuster’s
understand that the new batteries in the Mod 4 were actually re- success.
chargeable. These people regarded any battery-operated product
as unreliable and requiring frequent, costly battery replacement. And those who understood the idea of recharg-
ing were tripped up by the lack of a “ritual of recharging.” They’d forget to put the power handle in the charger
after finishing a task. This meant that, when they wanted to use it again, the whole system was dead. On top of
all this, due to a business recession, Black & Decker was unable to spend enough to promote the Mod 4 system
and properly explain the concept to the general public. Black & Decker learned some important lessons from this



                  YEAR        COMPANY         PROJECT        TITLE                                       PAGE(S)



                  2009                        Dustbuster     The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster   19 of 50
                                                             “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
experience—market research should be done before investing in a new product. And when you create an innovation
that completely changes the existing user experience, consumers will need to be educated about the use of these
new technologies. At the time, it would have been difficult to imagine that the smoldering ashes of the Mod 4’s
failure would give rise to Black & Decker’s most successful new product in history.




Out of the Basement and into the Kitchen
In early 1977, a positive nugget was unearthed. It turned out
that 92% of women users surveyed in the Mod 4 aftermath were
highly satisfied with the Spot-vac. Many were wives of men who
had purchased the Mod 4 system for their basement workshops.
When hubby was out, the wives snuck down to the basement to get
the Spot-vac to use upstairs. The women reported that they found
themselves frequently using it to pick up minor spills of cereal or
debris from the kitchen floor. This was much easier than going to the
hall closet for their canister vac, lugging it to the kitchen, unwind-
ing and plugging in the cord, and then, after a two-second pick-up,
unplugging the cord, re-winding it, and lugging the canister back to     On the original Dustbuster, the Black & Decker logo
its storage place in the closet.                                         was reduced to minimum visibility in order to avoid the
                                                                         perception that this was a power tool.
Based on this preliminary research, Marketing suggested that as
many as 50,000 units of a Spot-vac type product could be sold annually. This represented about 20% of the cur-
rent hand-held vac market. Jim Martz, Black & Decker’s new product marketing manager met with Marty Schrock
from Engineering and the new design chief, Carroll Gantz. Gantz had joined Black & Decker in 1972 as the manager
of industrial design for the US Consumer Power Tool Division. Prior to that, he’d spent 17 years at Hoover. When
Gantz joined Black & Decker, he happily thought that he’d never have to design another vacuum. But when Black &
Decker decided to explore design concepts for a kitchen vac, Gantz’s years of experience would prove invaluable.

The Mod 4 research identified a number of specific complaints and problems that needed to be addressed. Low
power was the main issue. Some thought recharging time was too long. Some didn’t like the messy paper filter bag,
and some didn’t like the nozzle. Some didn’t know where to store it, or how to recharge it. Some thought it didn’t
look like a woman’s product. But, in spite of all these complaints, 92% of the women surveyed were quite satisfied!
Within a few days, a preliminary model was ready, cobbled together with modified Spot-vac components and a
wall-mounted charger base. The development team agreed that the proof-of-concept model was too reminiscent
of the Spot-vac and still looked too much like a power tool. It needed additional conceptual study to make it more
compatible with the upstairs of a home or the kitchen environment. Design chief Gantz wanted to get as many ideas
as possible before meeting with the New Products Committee. He assigned designers Rod Bunyea, Bob Somers,
and Larry House to take a day and develop concepts independently.

When the team reconvened to discuss their design concepts, a number of key elements were identified. First, since
the vac had to be constantly recharged when not in use, and since there are no electrical outlets in storage closets,
the charger base would have to be kept in plain sight at or near a standard upstairs outlet. This meant that the base
should visually suggest a home to which the vac was easily returned after use, without the necessity to plug it in.
For inspiration, the Trimline phone was studied. Designed by Henry Dreyfuss Associates in 1965, the Trimline’s
form-fitting nest for the receiver included the disconnect switch—the user needed only to hang up the phone when
finished.




                  YEAR       COMPANY         PROJECT        TITLE                                                PAGE(S)



                  2009                       Dustbuster     The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster            20 of 50
                                                            “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
Secondly, since the vac and its charger had to be stored in plain sight, it needed to be as flat and compact against
the wall as possible, so as not to be knocked off by passers-by. The answer seemed to be a flat rectangular cross-
section, rather than the decades-enduring cylindrical shape of traditional hand vacs. This would also eliminate the
problem of visual similarity to the current Mod 4 Spot-vac, and avoid the inappropriate “power tool” look.

Thirdly, with the vac stored in plain sight, no one wanted to see a dirty nozzle. It was suggested that the exposed
nozzle and the business end of the vac could be tapered into a narrow opening similar to a crevice tool. This nozzle
tip could then be hidden by the nest when stored. Finally, to visually convey the idea of a quick-and-easy solution to
small spills, it was thought that the form of the vac could suggest the familiar flat wedge shape of the side view of
a standard dustpan.

Gantz combined all of these concepts in a formal color concept sketch. In March of 1977, it was reviewed by the
New Products Committee. The concept was very well received, and the team was authorized to proceed with
refining it into a realistic appearance model. Gantz worked with the engineers to determine all the physical size
requirements for batteries, charger, dirt cup, and motor. By September, they had produced a refined appearance
model. The model was executed in colors designed to appeal to the current household market, and to avoid the then
standard Black & Decker power tool colors of orange and white.




The Dustbuster is Born
The appearance model was used in market
research to better determine consumer in-
terest in the product. Research participants
were shown how the new cordless vac might
be used in the kitchen to pick up dry spills
and other quick-cleanup tasks. People loved
it! Marketing doubled their original first-year
sales projections to 100,000 units, and
on January 12, 1978, the design team got
the final go-ahead for full development. A
multidisciplinary development team was
assembled, including key representatives
from engineering, industrial design, market-
ing, and manufacturing. The headlong race
to market was on.

Engineering’s challenge was to improve
                                                  From original concept sketch to final production: Carroll Gantz’s team had a clear
battery performance to optimize power and         vision of what the Dustbuster would need to be.
run time. Three NiCad batteries produced
150 hours, or five years worth of 15-to-20-
second bursts.

A major decision was to eliminate the throw-away dirt filter bag, and use a washable, re-usable filter bag instead.
This innovation was a very popular with housewives, who dreaded handling those dirty bags and constantly having
to buy replacements at high cost. To empty the vac, one just snapped off the dirt cup and emptied the dirt directly
into the trash. At this point, Marketing had a much larger challenge. Black & Decker had to somehow grow their
brand image from the basement to the kitchen and from male buyers to female buyers. Also, Black & Decker’s usual
hardware store distribution system was not going to cut it. Success in this new category would require massive



                  YEAR        COMPANY         PROJECT           TITLE                                                PAGE(S)



                  2009                        Dustbuster        The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster            21 of 50
                                                                “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
promotion within the trade and with consumers. It would also require a completely new distribution system to reach
department and discount stores. This new product introduction would entail a huge capital investment with high
risk. But Black & Decker had faith in the concept and their team.

One of the key strategic decisions made was to downplay the Black & Decker brand name on the product to al-
most invisibility, and to color the product in the currently popular household color of medium beige. The designers
prepared an appearance model in the new colors, modified the charger shape to provide a more complete visual
nest for the unit, and added the “Duster” name to demonstrate graphic possibilities. The name “Dustbuster” soon
emerged from a company-wide contest. Subsequent public testing insured that the name communicated the
aggressive power desired from such a product. The perception of “power” was so essential that the engineers
deliberately modified the fan system to be noisier than it had to be, in order to convey an audible sense of power. A
new Dustbuster logotype was developed and incorporated into the product. The Black & Decker logo was reduced
to minimum visibility in order to avoid the perception that this was a power tool. By July 1978, a run of prototype
models had been produced for both mechanical and focus group testing. The prototypes were 14 1/2 inches long
and weighed 1.4 pounds.




Great Expectations
In early August, focus groups were conduct-                               First Year Sales Projections (in units)
ed. Sixty percent of consumers interviewed
                                                 1,200,000
said they would “definitely” or “probably” buy
such a product. Based on this, Marketing         1,000,000
raised first-year sales estimates to 250,000.
This was equal to the entire current market        800,000

for hand-held vacs. Marketing feverishly
                                                   600,000
produced trade literature, packaging, and
displays in preparation for the August 1978        400,000
Hardware Show in Chicago. The unveiling
of the Dustbuster was an undeniable hit            200,000

as it was declared “Best New Product in
                                                           0
Show” by trade publications. When tested
                                                               Feb                          Jan                 Aug             Jan
by consumer focus groups against three                         ’77                          ’78                 ’78             ’79
of the current top-selling appliances at the
Show, the Dustbuster was preferred by            Sales projections skyrocketed, as the design was validated at every step of
35%, compared with the GE Toaster Oven           development. First year sales of one million units still beat all expectations making
                                                 the Dustbuster Black & Decker’s most successful new product launch to date
(42%), Mr. Coffee coffeemaker (17%) and
a corn popper (5%). This amazing response
caused Marketing to once again double their
first-year sales estimates to 500,000 units.

All this was good news for Marketing, but a nightmare for Manufacturing. A year ago, they had begun planning
for annual production of 100,000 units. Last month they had to more than double tooling and production plans to
250,000. And now they were being asked to double it again to 500,000! At the urging of Carroll Gantz, Black &
Decker attorneys filed for a design patent—something they had never done before. Gantz knew that that the Dust-
buster design would be copied very quickly. On December 7, 1978, a patent was filed to protect the Dustbuster’s
unique form.




                  YEAR       COMPANY         PROJECT            TITLE                                                 PAGE(S)



                  2009                       Dustbuster         The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster             22 of 50
                                                                “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
A final pre-Christmas sales test of 6,400 pre-production units was conducted in December, 1978 in Kansas City,
MO. It was a total sellout, and an additional 4000 orders were placed, for a total of 10,400 units. First year sales
projections were raised again… this time to 750,000. Sales of the Dustbuster production units formally began in
January, 1979. When all major account orders were tallied up in February, it was clear that over a million units would
be sold the first year—the highest first-year sales of any product in Black & Decker history.




Dustbuster Hits Home
Dustbuster’s impact on the marketplace was huge. It changed
the entire hand-held vac category. In fact, it pioneered an entirely
new category of cordless vacs, many times larger than the original
category of corded hand-held vacs. Dustbuster’s success was due
to a fundamental change in the household cleaning culture. Since
the 1920s, leaders like Hoover had built the market based on the
idea that housewives vacuumed their carpets and floors regularly.
The accepted wisdom was that these women valued the frequent
deep-down cleaning offered by high suction, whirling beater bars,
and brushes. Home vacuums became larger and more powerful.
By the 1960s, manufacturers were in a horsepower race to see The Dustbuster has remained a market leader since
who could generate more suction and power. What Hoover and the it first took Black & Decker from the workshop into the
                                                                      kitchen. As of the 30th anniversary of its market debut
others missed was that more and more women were entering the in 1979, total Dustbuster sales are estimated at 150
workforce. These women simply did not have the time or inclination million units.
for such traditional vacuum cleaning. They weren’t interested in pay-
ing for expensive, large equipment, and, even if they were, they wouldn’t have the room to store these behemoths.
These women were absolutely delighted to be offered an inexpensive, light-weight and convenient hand vac to pick
up surface dirt and dry spills right on the spot. The Dustbuster became the home’s electric dust pan—quick and
convenient.

The Dustbuster’s enormous success encouraged Black & Decker to diversify beyond power tools into household
products. In 1980, they established a new Household Products Division in Easton, Maryland. It was headed by
Group VP Steve Britt. Marty Schrock was appointed Engineering VP. Carroll Gantz was appointed as the division’s
industrial design manager and a new design staff was hired. A 12-volt car vac version of the Dustbuster was one of
the first products produced by the division. Within four years, the household products line had expanded to include
lighting products, Workmate portable workbenches, garden products, stepstools, and cordless kitchen tools like
electric hand mixers, whisks, and knives. A larger corded version of the Dustbuster, called “The Collector,” was
designed by Don McCloskey for use in the shop.

Within a year of Dustbuster’s introduction, the market was flooded with imitations from all over the world. Many
were different enough to avoid lawsuits, but several were so slavishly copied that parts were literally interchange-
able with the Dustbuster. To stem the tide of patent infringements, Black & Decker initiated a lawsuit against one Far
East manufacturer called C.E.P. Their product was called the “Turboduster.” Black & Decker won the suit, and C.E.P.
was forced to destroy its tooling and cease manufacturing. This discouraged other competitors significantly, but
within five years, Black & Decker had to file patent-infringement lawsuits against more than a dozen manufacturers.




                   YEAR        COMPANY          PROJECT         TITLE                                          PAGE(S)



                   2009                         Dustbuster      The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster      23 of 50
                                                                “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
Good Design is Good for Business, but Not Job Security
Late in 1983, Black & Decker announced it had acquired GE’s Housewares Operations for $300 million. The deal
was finalized in November 1984. Within the year, marketing, engineering, and design departments all relocated to
Bridgeport, CT and merged with the former GE employees under the name of Black & Decker Household Products
Group (HPG). The designer of the Dustbuster, Carroll Gantz, was promoted to Director of Industrial Design, report-
ing to Marty Schrock, VP of Engineering. Within a year, a new headquarters was established in Shelton, CT. Then, in
January 1986, Black & Decker replaced its top management executives, including those in Shelton. Management
of the Household Products Group was transferred from Black & Decker people to ex-GE people, who outnumbered
the former five to one. Within six months, both Steve Britt and Marty Schrock lost their positions, industrial design
was transferred to the Marketing function, and Carroll Gantz was let go. The original design and leadership team
who brought Black & Decker its greatest new product introduction to date were now pushed out due to “corporate
politics.”2

Despite the personal blows to the creators of the Dustbuster, sales continued to grow. By 1985, trade press re-
ported that the hand-held vac market had grown 300% between 1981 and 1984. It was now at six to seven million
units per year, 90% of which was cordless. It was the hottest category in the business, growing 157% in the last six
months of 1985 alone. Black & Decker had the lion’s share of that market. In March of 1985, Time Magazine wrote
about the Dustbuster in an article entitled, “Market Buster: the vac that roared.” 3 In just seven years, from 1978
to 1985, Black & Decker’s worldwide household product sales grew from zero to equal to that of its established
power tool business. In 1972, Black & Decker’s annual sales were $350 million. By 1987, annual sales were five
times that—$1.8 billion!




Dustbuster Lives On and On
Since its introduction, the Dustbuster has been redesigned a
number of times, generally to increase power, run-time, and/or dirt
capacity, or to expand the range of models offered around the world.

In 1982, the Dustbuster was joined by a Dustbuster Plus model,
which had five NiCad batteries, improving power and run time. The
first major redesigns were introduced in January of 1986. The
original Dustbuster performance was improved by adding batter-
ies. The external appearance was modified slightly to house the
extra batteries, and the exhaust vents were removed from the front
surface. New graphics now added the Black & Decker logotype and
decreased the Dustbuster logo size, as Black & Decker was now well
established as a name in the housewares market. As late as 1986,
more than six years after Dustbuster’s introduction, the Hoover
Company still steadfastly shunned the cordless field because, “the
questionable performance of cordless units would jeopardize its
reputation as a producer of quality products.”4
                                                                           Quick clean-ups were a new concept, so the design
By 1990, with the design patent nearing expiration, the Dustbuster team made sure to clearly illustrate the storage/
                                                                        charging scenario by displaying it on a mock wall.
design was softened in form, following the design trends of the day.
The handle was closed into a loop, increasing the space for batteries,
and the charger nest was minimized. This latter change proved to be a mistake. As Gantz’s team had concluded
years before, people didn’t want to see a dirty, unattractive nozzle stored on their walls. In 1992, this change was



                  YEAR        COMPANY         PROJECT         TITLE                                           PAGE(S)



                  2009                        Dustbuster      The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster       24 of 50
                                                              “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
remedied when the charger nest was restored to hide the nozzle tip.
                                                       The standard Dustbuster was now called the Classic Dustbuster
                                                       with an open handle, like the original; and the previous Dustbuster
                                                       Plus now was being called the Super Dustbuster. It retained the
                                                       closed loop handle for visual differentiation. By 1999, the form was
                                                       softened further, and the new generation of rechargeable batteries
                                                       was designed to allow replacement when they lost the ability to
                                                       recharge efficiently, usually after a period of five to seven years.
                                                       This model generated 7.2 Volts. In 2001, Black & Decker introduced
                                                       a mini-Dustbuster, that weighed in at 3.5 Volts. The mini had styling
                                                       that was in tune with current design trends—very organic and
                                                       playful in character.

                                                       Many unusual, off-beat Dustbuster designs have appeared over the
                                                       years, including some that looked like cows, dogs, and zebras. Most
                                                       were imaginary, but the “Cowbuster” was actually on the market. In
                                                       1995, an original model of the 1979 Dustbuster was acquired by
                                                       the Smithsonian and placed in the National Museum of American
                                                       History along with Edison’s first light bulbs and Alexander Graham
                                                       Bell’s first telephones. At this point, 100 million Dustbusters had
                                                       been sold! Dustbusters have become a part of our culture and are
The Dustbuster Dream Team in 1979: Clockwise from      often mentioned on TV and in movies. Tiny toy Dustbusters were
bottom: Frank Lamm, Larry House, Don Zurwelle, Tom
Laughons, Bob Somers, Rod Bunyea, and Carroll Gantz.
                                                       sold in toy stores. And one of the great truisms learned by children
                                                       is, “Never hold a Dustbuster and a cat at the same time.”

As of the 30th anniversary of its market debut in 1979, total Dustbuster sales are estimated at 150 million units.
That’s half again more than the total number of Volkswagen Beetles sold to date.5 This calculates out to about $6
billion in sales for Black & Decker. Now that’s using design and innovation to clean up in the market place!




                    YEAR         COMPANY           PROJECT         TITLE                                       PAGE(S)



                    2009                           Dustbuster      The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster   25 of 50
                                                                   “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
Notes:

1.	   http://www.history.navy.mil/library/online/e_award.htm#press
2.	   Gantz, Carroll. Telephone interview with Steven R. Umbach. 2 October, 2009
3.	   “Marketbuster: the vac that roared,” Time Magazine. March, 1985
4.	   Gantz, Carroll. “Dustbuster: the Story of the Origin, Design, Development, Marketing and Success of the In-
      novative Black & Decker Dustbuster.” 2004. Self-published History.
5.	   Ibid.




References/Sources

       Hoover History:
       http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=906


       Black & Decker History:
       http://www.blackanddecker.com/CustomerCenter/Company-Information.aspx
       http://www.wikinvest.com/stock/Black_&_Decker_(BDK)
       http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_&_Decker




                 YEAR       COMPANY        PROJECT        TITLE                                       PAGE(S)



                 2009                      Dustbuster     The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster   26 of 50
                                                          “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
The Catalyst Mission
                                     Design is vital to all aspects of our lives. By bringing depth, clarity and transparency to
                                     the industrial design process, these case studies reveal the profound importance of the
                                     profession. This concrete body of evidence will instill into the collective consciousness
                                     design’s power to effect positive change.
                                     It’s the goal of Catalyst to capture design’s legacy and inspire design’s future.
                                     Catalyst case studies are sponsored by IDSA and under the direction of Catalyst
                                     Executive Director, Ravi Sawhney.




2009 Catalyst Review Panel
Arvind Bhambri              Associate Professor, Dept. of Mgmt. & Organization               USC Marshall School of Business
Robert Blaich               Author & Principal Consultant                                    Blaich Associates
Tim Brown                   President & CEO                                                  IDEO
Sam Farber                  Founder                                                          Copco, OXO, WOVO
Charles Jones               VP, Global Consumer Design                                       Whirlpool
Dr. Lorraine Justice        Swire Chair Professor / Dir. of the School of Design             The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Steve Kaneko                UX Director, Entertainment & Devices Division                    Microsoft
Guy Kawasaki                Co-founder                                                       Alltop.com
Sam Lucente                 Vice President, Design                                           Hewlett-Packard
Tom Matano                  Executive Director of Industrial Design                          Academy of Art University
Imre Molnar                 Dean of Academic Affairs                                         College for Creative Studies
Elie Ofek                   Associate Professor of Business Administration                   Harvard Business School
Ravi Sawhney                Founder & CEO                                                    RKS
Patrick Whitney             Dean and Steelcase/Robert C Pew Professor                        IIT Institute of Design

Panel members are recused from reviewing nominations with which they have any affiliation.


Credits
The Dustbuster Story: How Black & Decker Moved from the Basement into the Kitchen and
Cleaned Up in the Market Place
Written by Carroll Gantz, FIDSA and Steven R. Umbach, IDSA.
Special thanks to Carroll Gantz and Black & Decker for their time and cooperation.
2009 Catalyst case studies are available as pdfs and audio recordings at www.idsacatalyst.org.

What’s Your Legacy?
Submit your legacy-worthy design at www.idsacatalyst.org.
© Industrial Designers Society of America (IDSA) 2009




                     YEAR         COMPANY            PROJECT           TITLE                                             PAGE(S)



                     2009                            Dustbuster        The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster         27 of 50
                                                                       “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims
Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims
Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims Pranav Condur
 
Prelims with answers
Prelims with answersPrelims with answers
Prelims with answersArnav Sharma
 
Hasselblad Electronic Imaging
Hasselblad Electronic ImagingHasselblad Electronic Imaging
Hasselblad Electronic ImagingChris Sandström
 

La actualidad más candente (6)

Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims
Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims
Shaastra Main Quiz 2020 [SciTech] - Prelims
 
Prelims with answers
Prelims with answersPrelims with answers
Prelims with answers
 
Polaroid
PolaroidPolaroid
Polaroid
 
ppt on inventions
ppt on inventionsppt on inventions
ppt on inventions
 
Hasselblad
HasselbladHasselblad
Hasselblad
 
Hasselblad Electronic Imaging
Hasselblad Electronic ImagingHasselblad Electronic Imaging
Hasselblad Electronic Imaging
 

Similar a Sample case study black & decker

10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)
10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)
10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)CREAX
 
Sci-Tech quiz Finals
Sci-Tech quiz Finals   Sci-Tech quiz Finals
Sci-Tech quiz Finals Saqib Javed
 
Different Types and Forms of Innovation
Different Types and Forms of InnovationDifferent Types and Forms of Innovation
Different Types and Forms of InnovationMotaz Agamawi
 
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docxCASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docxPazSilviapm
 
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docx
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docxNext slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docx
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docxcurwenmichaela
 
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023Better Builder Magazine
 
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docxCASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docxwendolynhalbert
 
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imaging
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imagingDisruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imaging
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imagingChris Sandström
 
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn J
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn JCase 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn J
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn JTawnaDelatorrejs
 
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuum
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuumUX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuum
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuumJoy Marcus
 
Kodak BSP EMBA 75
Kodak BSP EMBA 75Kodak BSP EMBA 75
Kodak BSP EMBA 75rova1976
 
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015nsitqc
 
11 shanzhai china's ip stronghold
11 shanzhai   china's ip stronghold11 shanzhai   china's ip stronghold
11 shanzhai china's ip strongholdWesley Shu
 

Similar a Sample case study black & decker (20)

Biz Tech Quiz
Biz Tech QuizBiz Tech Quiz
Biz Tech Quiz
 
The Rise and Fall of Blockbuster
The Rise and Fall of BlockbusterThe Rise and Fall of Blockbuster
The Rise and Fall of Blockbuster
 
Kodak
KodakKodak
Kodak
 
10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)
10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)
10 innovations you thought were new (by @creaxnv)
 
Rise and fall of Kodak
Rise and fall of KodakRise and fall of Kodak
Rise and fall of Kodak
 
Rush
RushRush
Rush
 
Crucible prep 2
Crucible  prep 2Crucible  prep 2
Crucible prep 2
 
Sci-Tech quiz Finals
Sci-Tech quiz Finals   Sci-Tech quiz Finals
Sci-Tech quiz Finals
 
Different Types and Forms of Innovation
Different Types and Forms of InnovationDifferent Types and Forms of Innovation
Different Types and Forms of Innovation
 
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docxCASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the Lig.docx
 
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docx
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docxNext slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docx
Next slides are the outlineDetermine each one is low or modera.docx
 
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023
Better Builder Magazine, Issue 48 / Winter 2023
 
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docxCASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docx
CASE STUDY 5Exploring Innovation in Action The Dimming of the.docx
 
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imaging
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imagingDisruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imaging
Disruptive Innovation, Kodak and digital imaging
 
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn J
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn JCase 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn J
Case 10 Eastman Kodak’s Quest for a Digital FutureOn J
 
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuum
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuumUX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuum
UX Analysis: Evolution of the electric vacuum
 
Kodak BSP EMBA 75
Kodak BSP EMBA 75Kodak BSP EMBA 75
Kodak BSP EMBA 75
 
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015
The Tech-Biz Quiz (Finals)- NSIT Quiz Fest 2015
 
11 shanzhai china's ip stronghold
11 shanzhai   china's ip stronghold11 shanzhai   china's ip stronghold
11 shanzhai china's ip stronghold
 
Dyson case study
Dyson case studyDyson case study
Dyson case study
 

Último

A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMANA DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMANIlamathiKannappan
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Roland Driesen
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayNZSG
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyEthan lee
 
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...rajveerescorts2022
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataExhibitors Data
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdfRenandantas16
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Dave Litwiller
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒anilsa9823
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageMatteo Carbone
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesDipal Arora
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communicationskarancommunications
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...lizamodels9
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...amitlee9823
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsP&CO
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureSeta Wicaksana
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 

Último (20)

A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMANA DAY IN THE LIFE OF A  SALESMAN / WOMAN
A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A SALESMAN / WOMAN
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
 
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 

Sample case study black & decker

  • 1. YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE SPONSORED BY 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place Borne out of the ashes of a marketplace failure, Dustbuster created a new mass- market category as it took the Black & Decker brand from the workshop into the home. Dustbuster has continued to lead the category for thirty years.
  • 2. In 1972, Black & Decker was getting worried. They had every reason to be. Their core power tool business had been under assault from foreign competition since the 1960s. While their low-cost consumer power tools had been successful since post WW2, that very success had eroded their reputation in the more profitable professional power tool category. After decades of growth and success, people were beginning to think of Black & Decker as the low-end manufacturer. This did not sit well with the Maryland-based company. Their foundation had been built on innovation and quality… quality that had been recognized in 1943 with the prestigious Army-Navy E Award. Only five percent of the thousands of manufacturers eligible were awarded this merit for outstanding production in support of the War and Navy departments1. It was only natural for Black & Decker to draw upon their history of creating breakthrough innovations to propel their business through trying times. An Historic Heritage – To the Moon and Back In 1960, the space race was well underway. NASA was very in- terested in battery-based, “no-torque” power tools. Cords were problematic both because they were easy to get tangled in and because the nearest electrical outlet might well be nearly 250,000 miles away. Torque, on the other hand, was a big problem in zero and low gravity. Thanks to Newton’s Third Law, an astronaut using a high-torque drill in space would be launched into orbit… around the drill bit. Since whirling dervish astronauts weren’t the goal, NASA awarded Black & Decker a choice contract. The challenge was to develop cordless, rechargeable, “no-torque” electric wrenches for use in space, and drills for extracting core samples on the surface of the moon. Battery-operated products using dry-cell zinc batteries had been around for decades. But their use was primarily in toys or other small products that required very little power. Since zinc batteries had limited capacities, the batteries would need frequent replacement in situations with higher power requirements. In the 1960s, General Electric (GE) developed new rechargeable nickel cadmium (NiCad) batteries with considerably more power and life. Using these new batteries, Black & Decker introduced the world’s first cordless rechargeable drill in 1961. A year later, they used the The torque-reducing technology built into the Black & same technology in a shrub trimmer. Despite these advances, the Decker Moon Drill kept Apollo 15 astronauts grounded while working in the low gravity conditions of the lunar new technology remained costly and inefficient. surface. Funding from the space program fueled the breakthroughs required to deliver the cordless Minimum Torque Reaction Space Tool, which was used in 1964 by Project Gemini astronauts working in weightless conditions. Later, in 1971, the Black & Decker Moon Drill was used on the Apollo 15 mission to the lunar surface. Cordless Goes Modular The research undertaken by GE and Black & Decker for the NASA projects greatly increased the quality and reduced the cost of rechargeable batteries. This opened up new opportunities for battery powered consumer products. In YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 18 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 3. 1969, a cordless reel lawn mower was introduced. It used much larger rechargeable batteries than the small NiCad batteries used in hand tools. So, when they found themselves under attack by low-cost foreign competitors, Black & Decker knew better than to simply square off against the competition in a price war. Remembering the entrepreneurial spirit of founders S. Duncan Black and Alonzo G. Decker, they sought instead to regain their competitive edge by developing high- end innovations. They began by engaging in an extraordinary internal effort focused on new product research and development. The overarching strategy was to increase sales growth by expanding beyond their strong, power-tool base and into labor-saving devices in general. Where others might have focused on cost-cutting, Black & Decker execs focused on creating new products that would expand their business into new markets. One of the most interesting such projects was the development of the Mod 4 Power Handle Cordless System guided by senior industrial designer Rod Bunyea. The name was derived from the four NiCad power cells in the handle. The concept began as an attempt to develop a new handheld, cordless grass shear that could, with the addition of a wheeled extension handle, also be used in a standing position. The grass shear design was configured in two parts – the business end with the clippers, and the power end that included the batteries in a handle housing. The extension tube for stand-up use fit between the two parts. This design inspired an entirely new concept for modular products. With a separate power handle, additional functional assemblies beyond the grass shear head could be attached. For example, a ¼” drill head, a shrub trimmer, a sealed-beam lantern, and a small vacuum cleaner called the Spot- vac. All would be compact, cordless, and hand-held, and all would be interchangeable with a single, rechargeable power source. Most importantly, the retail price of such a modular system of products would be considerably less than the cost of five individual products. Amidst high expectations, the Mod 4 system was introduced in 1974 and immediately hailed as an innovative new product. In May 1977, it was featured in Fortune Magazine as one of the 25 best designed products available in the US. A Hard-Learned Reality Check Despite all the acclaim, the Mod 4 system was a failure in the mar- ketplace. Sales were far less than anticipated. Post-mortem market research revealed the reasons. First and foremost, buyers did not like to buy multi-purpose products. The Mod 4 was deliberately sold as a set of five, simply to make the price of each seem more reason- able. If sold individually, the cost of the batteries inside each sepa- rate unit would make the price too high. But even though the price of the entire system of five products was about the same as the price for two, buyers simply preferred to buy one product at a time. Rechargeable batteries were confounding to new users. Most The modular Mod 4 system was hailed as a great people were more familiar with existing battery-operated products, innovation, yet failed in the marketplace. Lesson’s like toys, which used disposable batteries. They simply didn’t from the Mod 4’s demise gave rise to the Dustbuster’s understand that the new batteries in the Mod 4 were actually re- success. chargeable. These people regarded any battery-operated product as unreliable and requiring frequent, costly battery replacement. And those who understood the idea of recharg- ing were tripped up by the lack of a “ritual of recharging.” They’d forget to put the power handle in the charger after finishing a task. This meant that, when they wanted to use it again, the whole system was dead. On top of all this, due to a business recession, Black & Decker was unable to spend enough to promote the Mod 4 system and properly explain the concept to the general public. Black & Decker learned some important lessons from this YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 19 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 4. experience—market research should be done before investing in a new product. And when you create an innovation that completely changes the existing user experience, consumers will need to be educated about the use of these new technologies. At the time, it would have been difficult to imagine that the smoldering ashes of the Mod 4’s failure would give rise to Black & Decker’s most successful new product in history. Out of the Basement and into the Kitchen In early 1977, a positive nugget was unearthed. It turned out that 92% of women users surveyed in the Mod 4 aftermath were highly satisfied with the Spot-vac. Many were wives of men who had purchased the Mod 4 system for their basement workshops. When hubby was out, the wives snuck down to the basement to get the Spot-vac to use upstairs. The women reported that they found themselves frequently using it to pick up minor spills of cereal or debris from the kitchen floor. This was much easier than going to the hall closet for their canister vac, lugging it to the kitchen, unwind- ing and plugging in the cord, and then, after a two-second pick-up, unplugging the cord, re-winding it, and lugging the canister back to On the original Dustbuster, the Black & Decker logo its storage place in the closet. was reduced to minimum visibility in order to avoid the perception that this was a power tool. Based on this preliminary research, Marketing suggested that as many as 50,000 units of a Spot-vac type product could be sold annually. This represented about 20% of the cur- rent hand-held vac market. Jim Martz, Black & Decker’s new product marketing manager met with Marty Schrock from Engineering and the new design chief, Carroll Gantz. Gantz had joined Black & Decker in 1972 as the manager of industrial design for the US Consumer Power Tool Division. Prior to that, he’d spent 17 years at Hoover. When Gantz joined Black & Decker, he happily thought that he’d never have to design another vacuum. But when Black & Decker decided to explore design concepts for a kitchen vac, Gantz’s years of experience would prove invaluable. The Mod 4 research identified a number of specific complaints and problems that needed to be addressed. Low power was the main issue. Some thought recharging time was too long. Some didn’t like the messy paper filter bag, and some didn’t like the nozzle. Some didn’t know where to store it, or how to recharge it. Some thought it didn’t look like a woman’s product. But, in spite of all these complaints, 92% of the women surveyed were quite satisfied! Within a few days, a preliminary model was ready, cobbled together with modified Spot-vac components and a wall-mounted charger base. The development team agreed that the proof-of-concept model was too reminiscent of the Spot-vac and still looked too much like a power tool. It needed additional conceptual study to make it more compatible with the upstairs of a home or the kitchen environment. Design chief Gantz wanted to get as many ideas as possible before meeting with the New Products Committee. He assigned designers Rod Bunyea, Bob Somers, and Larry House to take a day and develop concepts independently. When the team reconvened to discuss their design concepts, a number of key elements were identified. First, since the vac had to be constantly recharged when not in use, and since there are no electrical outlets in storage closets, the charger base would have to be kept in plain sight at or near a standard upstairs outlet. This meant that the base should visually suggest a home to which the vac was easily returned after use, without the necessity to plug it in. For inspiration, the Trimline phone was studied. Designed by Henry Dreyfuss Associates in 1965, the Trimline’s form-fitting nest for the receiver included the disconnect switch—the user needed only to hang up the phone when finished. YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 20 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 5. Secondly, since the vac and its charger had to be stored in plain sight, it needed to be as flat and compact against the wall as possible, so as not to be knocked off by passers-by. The answer seemed to be a flat rectangular cross- section, rather than the decades-enduring cylindrical shape of traditional hand vacs. This would also eliminate the problem of visual similarity to the current Mod 4 Spot-vac, and avoid the inappropriate “power tool” look. Thirdly, with the vac stored in plain sight, no one wanted to see a dirty nozzle. It was suggested that the exposed nozzle and the business end of the vac could be tapered into a narrow opening similar to a crevice tool. This nozzle tip could then be hidden by the nest when stored. Finally, to visually convey the idea of a quick-and-easy solution to small spills, it was thought that the form of the vac could suggest the familiar flat wedge shape of the side view of a standard dustpan. Gantz combined all of these concepts in a formal color concept sketch. In March of 1977, it was reviewed by the New Products Committee. The concept was very well received, and the team was authorized to proceed with refining it into a realistic appearance model. Gantz worked with the engineers to determine all the physical size requirements for batteries, charger, dirt cup, and motor. By September, they had produced a refined appearance model. The model was executed in colors designed to appeal to the current household market, and to avoid the then standard Black & Decker power tool colors of orange and white. The Dustbuster is Born The appearance model was used in market research to better determine consumer in- terest in the product. Research participants were shown how the new cordless vac might be used in the kitchen to pick up dry spills and other quick-cleanup tasks. People loved it! Marketing doubled their original first-year sales projections to 100,000 units, and on January 12, 1978, the design team got the final go-ahead for full development. A multidisciplinary development team was assembled, including key representatives from engineering, industrial design, market- ing, and manufacturing. The headlong race to market was on. Engineering’s challenge was to improve From original concept sketch to final production: Carroll Gantz’s team had a clear battery performance to optimize power and vision of what the Dustbuster would need to be. run time. Three NiCad batteries produced 150 hours, or five years worth of 15-to-20- second bursts. A major decision was to eliminate the throw-away dirt filter bag, and use a washable, re-usable filter bag instead. This innovation was a very popular with housewives, who dreaded handling those dirty bags and constantly having to buy replacements at high cost. To empty the vac, one just snapped off the dirt cup and emptied the dirt directly into the trash. At this point, Marketing had a much larger challenge. Black & Decker had to somehow grow their brand image from the basement to the kitchen and from male buyers to female buyers. Also, Black & Decker’s usual hardware store distribution system was not going to cut it. Success in this new category would require massive YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 21 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 6. promotion within the trade and with consumers. It would also require a completely new distribution system to reach department and discount stores. This new product introduction would entail a huge capital investment with high risk. But Black & Decker had faith in the concept and their team. One of the key strategic decisions made was to downplay the Black & Decker brand name on the product to al- most invisibility, and to color the product in the currently popular household color of medium beige. The designers prepared an appearance model in the new colors, modified the charger shape to provide a more complete visual nest for the unit, and added the “Duster” name to demonstrate graphic possibilities. The name “Dustbuster” soon emerged from a company-wide contest. Subsequent public testing insured that the name communicated the aggressive power desired from such a product. The perception of “power” was so essential that the engineers deliberately modified the fan system to be noisier than it had to be, in order to convey an audible sense of power. A new Dustbuster logotype was developed and incorporated into the product. The Black & Decker logo was reduced to minimum visibility in order to avoid the perception that this was a power tool. By July 1978, a run of prototype models had been produced for both mechanical and focus group testing. The prototypes were 14 1/2 inches long and weighed 1.4 pounds. Great Expectations In early August, focus groups were conduct- First Year Sales Projections (in units) ed. Sixty percent of consumers interviewed 1,200,000 said they would “definitely” or “probably” buy such a product. Based on this, Marketing 1,000,000 raised first-year sales estimates to 250,000. This was equal to the entire current market 800,000 for hand-held vacs. Marketing feverishly 600,000 produced trade literature, packaging, and displays in preparation for the August 1978 400,000 Hardware Show in Chicago. The unveiling of the Dustbuster was an undeniable hit 200,000 as it was declared “Best New Product in 0 Show” by trade publications. When tested Feb Jan Aug Jan by consumer focus groups against three ’77 ’78 ’78 ’79 of the current top-selling appliances at the Show, the Dustbuster was preferred by Sales projections skyrocketed, as the design was validated at every step of 35%, compared with the GE Toaster Oven development. First year sales of one million units still beat all expectations making the Dustbuster Black & Decker’s most successful new product launch to date (42%), Mr. Coffee coffeemaker (17%) and a corn popper (5%). This amazing response caused Marketing to once again double their first-year sales estimates to 500,000 units. All this was good news for Marketing, but a nightmare for Manufacturing. A year ago, they had begun planning for annual production of 100,000 units. Last month they had to more than double tooling and production plans to 250,000. And now they were being asked to double it again to 500,000! At the urging of Carroll Gantz, Black & Decker attorneys filed for a design patent—something they had never done before. Gantz knew that that the Dust- buster design would be copied very quickly. On December 7, 1978, a patent was filed to protect the Dustbuster’s unique form. YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 22 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 7. A final pre-Christmas sales test of 6,400 pre-production units was conducted in December, 1978 in Kansas City, MO. It was a total sellout, and an additional 4000 orders were placed, for a total of 10,400 units. First year sales projections were raised again… this time to 750,000. Sales of the Dustbuster production units formally began in January, 1979. When all major account orders were tallied up in February, it was clear that over a million units would be sold the first year—the highest first-year sales of any product in Black & Decker history. Dustbuster Hits Home Dustbuster’s impact on the marketplace was huge. It changed the entire hand-held vac category. In fact, it pioneered an entirely new category of cordless vacs, many times larger than the original category of corded hand-held vacs. Dustbuster’s success was due to a fundamental change in the household cleaning culture. Since the 1920s, leaders like Hoover had built the market based on the idea that housewives vacuumed their carpets and floors regularly. The accepted wisdom was that these women valued the frequent deep-down cleaning offered by high suction, whirling beater bars, and brushes. Home vacuums became larger and more powerful. By the 1960s, manufacturers were in a horsepower race to see The Dustbuster has remained a market leader since who could generate more suction and power. What Hoover and the it first took Black & Decker from the workshop into the kitchen. As of the 30th anniversary of its market debut others missed was that more and more women were entering the in 1979, total Dustbuster sales are estimated at 150 workforce. These women simply did not have the time or inclination million units. for such traditional vacuum cleaning. They weren’t interested in pay- ing for expensive, large equipment, and, even if they were, they wouldn’t have the room to store these behemoths. These women were absolutely delighted to be offered an inexpensive, light-weight and convenient hand vac to pick up surface dirt and dry spills right on the spot. The Dustbuster became the home’s electric dust pan—quick and convenient. The Dustbuster’s enormous success encouraged Black & Decker to diversify beyond power tools into household products. In 1980, they established a new Household Products Division in Easton, Maryland. It was headed by Group VP Steve Britt. Marty Schrock was appointed Engineering VP. Carroll Gantz was appointed as the division’s industrial design manager and a new design staff was hired. A 12-volt car vac version of the Dustbuster was one of the first products produced by the division. Within four years, the household products line had expanded to include lighting products, Workmate portable workbenches, garden products, stepstools, and cordless kitchen tools like electric hand mixers, whisks, and knives. A larger corded version of the Dustbuster, called “The Collector,” was designed by Don McCloskey for use in the shop. Within a year of Dustbuster’s introduction, the market was flooded with imitations from all over the world. Many were different enough to avoid lawsuits, but several were so slavishly copied that parts were literally interchange- able with the Dustbuster. To stem the tide of patent infringements, Black & Decker initiated a lawsuit against one Far East manufacturer called C.E.P. Their product was called the “Turboduster.” Black & Decker won the suit, and C.E.P. was forced to destroy its tooling and cease manufacturing. This discouraged other competitors significantly, but within five years, Black & Decker had to file patent-infringement lawsuits against more than a dozen manufacturers. YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 23 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 8. Good Design is Good for Business, but Not Job Security Late in 1983, Black & Decker announced it had acquired GE’s Housewares Operations for $300 million. The deal was finalized in November 1984. Within the year, marketing, engineering, and design departments all relocated to Bridgeport, CT and merged with the former GE employees under the name of Black & Decker Household Products Group (HPG). The designer of the Dustbuster, Carroll Gantz, was promoted to Director of Industrial Design, report- ing to Marty Schrock, VP of Engineering. Within a year, a new headquarters was established in Shelton, CT. Then, in January 1986, Black & Decker replaced its top management executives, including those in Shelton. Management of the Household Products Group was transferred from Black & Decker people to ex-GE people, who outnumbered the former five to one. Within six months, both Steve Britt and Marty Schrock lost their positions, industrial design was transferred to the Marketing function, and Carroll Gantz was let go. The original design and leadership team who brought Black & Decker its greatest new product introduction to date were now pushed out due to “corporate politics.”2 Despite the personal blows to the creators of the Dustbuster, sales continued to grow. By 1985, trade press re- ported that the hand-held vac market had grown 300% between 1981 and 1984. It was now at six to seven million units per year, 90% of which was cordless. It was the hottest category in the business, growing 157% in the last six months of 1985 alone. Black & Decker had the lion’s share of that market. In March of 1985, Time Magazine wrote about the Dustbuster in an article entitled, “Market Buster: the vac that roared.” 3 In just seven years, from 1978 to 1985, Black & Decker’s worldwide household product sales grew from zero to equal to that of its established power tool business. In 1972, Black & Decker’s annual sales were $350 million. By 1987, annual sales were five times that—$1.8 billion! Dustbuster Lives On and On Since its introduction, the Dustbuster has been redesigned a number of times, generally to increase power, run-time, and/or dirt capacity, or to expand the range of models offered around the world. In 1982, the Dustbuster was joined by a Dustbuster Plus model, which had five NiCad batteries, improving power and run time. The first major redesigns were introduced in January of 1986. The original Dustbuster performance was improved by adding batter- ies. The external appearance was modified slightly to house the extra batteries, and the exhaust vents were removed from the front surface. New graphics now added the Black & Decker logotype and decreased the Dustbuster logo size, as Black & Decker was now well established as a name in the housewares market. As late as 1986, more than six years after Dustbuster’s introduction, the Hoover Company still steadfastly shunned the cordless field because, “the questionable performance of cordless units would jeopardize its reputation as a producer of quality products.”4 Quick clean-ups were a new concept, so the design By 1990, with the design patent nearing expiration, the Dustbuster team made sure to clearly illustrate the storage/ charging scenario by displaying it on a mock wall. design was softened in form, following the design trends of the day. The handle was closed into a loop, increasing the space for batteries, and the charger nest was minimized. This latter change proved to be a mistake. As Gantz’s team had concluded years before, people didn’t want to see a dirty, unattractive nozzle stored on their walls. In 1992, this change was YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 24 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 9. remedied when the charger nest was restored to hide the nozzle tip. The standard Dustbuster was now called the Classic Dustbuster with an open handle, like the original; and the previous Dustbuster Plus now was being called the Super Dustbuster. It retained the closed loop handle for visual differentiation. By 1999, the form was softened further, and the new generation of rechargeable batteries was designed to allow replacement when they lost the ability to recharge efficiently, usually after a period of five to seven years. This model generated 7.2 Volts. In 2001, Black & Decker introduced a mini-Dustbuster, that weighed in at 3.5 Volts. The mini had styling that was in tune with current design trends—very organic and playful in character. Many unusual, off-beat Dustbuster designs have appeared over the years, including some that looked like cows, dogs, and zebras. Most were imaginary, but the “Cowbuster” was actually on the market. In 1995, an original model of the 1979 Dustbuster was acquired by the Smithsonian and placed in the National Museum of American History along with Edison’s first light bulbs and Alexander Graham Bell’s first telephones. At this point, 100 million Dustbusters had been sold! Dustbusters have become a part of our culture and are The Dustbuster Dream Team in 1979: Clockwise from often mentioned on TV and in movies. Tiny toy Dustbusters were bottom: Frank Lamm, Larry House, Don Zurwelle, Tom Laughons, Bob Somers, Rod Bunyea, and Carroll Gantz. sold in toy stores. And one of the great truisms learned by children is, “Never hold a Dustbuster and a cat at the same time.” As of the 30th anniversary of its market debut in 1979, total Dustbuster sales are estimated at 150 million units. That’s half again more than the total number of Volkswagen Beetles sold to date.5 This calculates out to about $6 billion in sales for Black & Decker. Now that’s using design and innovation to clean up in the market place! YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 25 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 10. Notes: 1. http://www.history.navy.mil/library/online/e_award.htm#press 2. Gantz, Carroll. Telephone interview with Steven R. Umbach. 2 October, 2009 3. “Marketbuster: the vac that roared,” Time Magazine. March, 1985 4. Gantz, Carroll. “Dustbuster: the Story of the Origin, Design, Development, Marketing and Success of the In- novative Black & Decker Dustbuster.” 2004. Self-published History. 5. Ibid. References/Sources Hoover History: http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=906 Black & Decker History: http://www.blackanddecker.com/CustomerCenter/Company-Information.aspx http://www.wikinvest.com/stock/Black_&_Decker_(BDK) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_&_Decker YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 26 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place
  • 11. The Catalyst Mission Design is vital to all aspects of our lives. By bringing depth, clarity and transparency to the industrial design process, these case studies reveal the profound importance of the profession. This concrete body of evidence will instill into the collective consciousness design’s power to effect positive change. It’s the goal of Catalyst to capture design’s legacy and inspire design’s future. Catalyst case studies are sponsored by IDSA and under the direction of Catalyst Executive Director, Ravi Sawhney. 2009 Catalyst Review Panel Arvind Bhambri Associate Professor, Dept. of Mgmt. & Organization USC Marshall School of Business Robert Blaich Author & Principal Consultant Blaich Associates Tim Brown President & CEO IDEO Sam Farber Founder Copco, OXO, WOVO Charles Jones VP, Global Consumer Design Whirlpool Dr. Lorraine Justice Swire Chair Professor / Dir. of the School of Design The Hong Kong Polytechnic University Steve Kaneko UX Director, Entertainment & Devices Division Microsoft Guy Kawasaki Co-founder Alltop.com Sam Lucente Vice President, Design Hewlett-Packard Tom Matano Executive Director of Industrial Design Academy of Art University Imre Molnar Dean of Academic Affairs College for Creative Studies Elie Ofek Associate Professor of Business Administration Harvard Business School Ravi Sawhney Founder & CEO RKS Patrick Whitney Dean and Steelcase/Robert C Pew Professor IIT Institute of Design Panel members are recused from reviewing nominations with which they have any affiliation. Credits The Dustbuster Story: How Black & Decker Moved from the Basement into the Kitchen and Cleaned Up in the Market Place Written by Carroll Gantz, FIDSA and Steven R. Umbach, IDSA. Special thanks to Carroll Gantz and Black & Decker for their time and cooperation. 2009 Catalyst case studies are available as pdfs and audio recordings at www.idsacatalyst.org. What’s Your Legacy? Submit your legacy-worthy design at www.idsacatalyst.org. © Industrial Designers Society of America (IDSA) 2009 YEAR COMPANY PROJECT TITLE PAGE(S) 2009 Dustbuster The Little Vac that Roared:How Dustbuster 27 of 50 “Cleaned Up” in the Market Place