SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 4
Descargar para leer sin conexión
LT2 Typology and analysis of business plans
 and incentives for BRT and urban mobility
                  systems


         Patricia Galilea and Marco Batarce
        Department of Transport Engineering and Logistics
             Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile
Motivation
 Relationship between private operator and public body is
 not easy since:
   It has conflicting goals: achieve social goals vs max profits
      Contract is a means to establish rules of this relationship
      and it must reflect the needs of both parties and secure their
      convergence
   Asymmetry of information (principal-agent)
      Efficient regulatory schemes
   Contexts are relevant
         Thus, partnership’s success is not assured
Objectives
 How a contract can induce operators to innovate and improve service
  quality?
 Incorporate not only the Government-Operator relationship, but include the
  Operator-Driver relationship
 Steps:
    Literature review on contracts and incentive theory related to public transport
     systems
    Review BRT contracts in different contexts
    Collect data on key variables
    Model theoretically the firm’s behavior for a given type of contract
    Model empirically some cases
    Recommendation of best practices on BRT contracting
    Educational package for policy makers
LT2 Typology and analysis of business plans
 and incentives for BRT and urban mobility
                  systems


         Patricia Galilea and Marco Batarce
        Department of Transport Engineering and Logistics
             Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a LT2: Typology and analysis of business plans and incentives for BRT and u…

Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesAdversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesShantanu Basu
 
Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...
	Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...	Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...
Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...inventionjournals
 
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SME
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SMERICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SME
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SMEChris Williams-Lilley
 
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspects
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspectsTheme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspects
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspectsBRTCoE
 
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 161_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16stolleman
 
SIBRT research activities
SIBRT research activitiesSIBRT research activities
SIBRT research activitiesBRTCoE
 
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesAdversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesShantanu Basu
 
CoE Presentation at general assembly
CoE Presentation at general assemblyCoE Presentation at general assembly
CoE Presentation at general assemblyBRTCoE
 
Psu policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...
Psu   policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...Psu   policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...
Psu policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...bobprocter
 
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_study
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_studyDistribution channel reengineering_a_case_study
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_studymohamedhariry3
 
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copy
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copyPresentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copy
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copyTRPC Pte Ltd
 
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-Government
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-GovernmentPPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-Government
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-GovernmentMuhammad Farooq
 

Similar a LT2: Typology and analysis of business plans and incentives for BRT and u… (20)

e-Government: have we forgotten of the public sector context?
e-Government: have we forgotten of the public sector context?e-Government: have we forgotten of the public sector context?
e-Government: have we forgotten of the public sector context?
 
3rd party logistics
3rd party logistics3rd party logistics
3rd party logistics
 
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesAdversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
 
Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...
	Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...	Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...
Effects of Government Procurement on Prompt Tendering and Supply of Goods: A...
 
Ippc seattle usa 2012
Ippc seattle usa  2012Ippc seattle usa  2012
Ippc seattle usa 2012
 
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SME
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SMERICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SME
RICS VIP RT _ Briefing Paper (V3.1) SME
 
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspects
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspectsTheme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspects
Theme 5 Regulatory and contractual aspects
 
BRT Workshop - Regulatory and Contractual Aspects
BRT Workshop - Regulatory and Contractual AspectsBRT Workshop - Regulatory and Contractual Aspects
BRT Workshop - Regulatory and Contractual Aspects
 
Models of Public Administration
Models of Public AdministrationModels of Public Administration
Models of Public Administration
 
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 161_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16
1_PPP paper_FINAL 05 17 16
 
SIBRT research activities
SIBRT research activitiesSIBRT research activities
SIBRT research activities
 
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public servicesAdversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
Adversarial and cooperative models in contracting for public services
 
Public Private
Public                           PrivatePublic                           Private
Public Private
 
Scm integration thing
Scm integration thingScm integration thing
Scm integration thing
 
Wg hart workshop presentation
Wg hart workshop presentationWg hart workshop presentation
Wg hart workshop presentation
 
CoE Presentation at general assembly
CoE Presentation at general assemblyCoE Presentation at general assembly
CoE Presentation at general assembly
 
Psu policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...
Psu   policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...Psu   policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...
Psu policy issues on electric utility industry structure and regulation wit...
 
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_study
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_studyDistribution channel reengineering_a_case_study
Distribution channel reengineering_a_case_study
 
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copy
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copyPresentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copy
Presentation 24 june 2019 r6 - public distribution copy
 
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-Government
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-GovernmentPPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-Government
PPP Options for ESD Model of Local e-Government
 

Más de BRTCoE

BRT+ Workshop
BRT+ WorkshopBRT+ Workshop
BRT+ WorkshopBRTCoE
 
MaaS Trial in Sydney
MaaS Trial in SydneyMaaS Trial in Sydney
MaaS Trial in SydneyBRTCoE
 
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos Muñoz
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos MuñozFull cost reliability by Juan Carlos Muñoz
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos MuñozBRTCoE
 
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITL
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITLCongreso nacional chileno 2019 DITL
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITLBRTCoE
 
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...BRTCoE
 
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationBRTCoE
 
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...BRTCoE
 
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...BRTCoE
 
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...BRTCoE
 
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRTCoE
 
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pZhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pBRTCoE
 

Más de BRTCoE (20)

BRT+ Workshop
BRT+ WorkshopBRT+ Workshop
BRT+ Workshop
 
MaaS Trial in Sydney
MaaS Trial in SydneyMaaS Trial in Sydney
MaaS Trial in Sydney
 
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos Muñoz
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos MuñozFull cost reliability by Juan Carlos Muñoz
Full cost reliability by Juan Carlos Muñoz
 
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITL
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITLCongreso nacional chileno 2019 DITL
Congreso nacional chileno 2019 DITL
 
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
 
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
 
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
 
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
 
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
 
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
 
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pZhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
 

LT2: Typology and analysis of business plans and incentives for BRT and u…

  • 1. LT2 Typology and analysis of business plans and incentives for BRT and urban mobility systems Patricia Galilea and Marco Batarce Department of Transport Engineering and Logistics Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile
  • 2. Motivation  Relationship between private operator and public body is not easy since:  It has conflicting goals: achieve social goals vs max profits Contract is a means to establish rules of this relationship and it must reflect the needs of both parties and secure their convergence  Asymmetry of information (principal-agent) Efficient regulatory schemes  Contexts are relevant Thus, partnership’s success is not assured
  • 3. Objectives  How a contract can induce operators to innovate and improve service quality?  Incorporate not only the Government-Operator relationship, but include the Operator-Driver relationship  Steps:  Literature review on contracts and incentive theory related to public transport systems  Review BRT contracts in different contexts  Collect data on key variables  Model theoretically the firm’s behavior for a given type of contract  Model empirically some cases  Recommendation of best practices on BRT contracting  Educational package for policy makers
  • 4. LT2 Typology and analysis of business plans and incentives for BRT and urban mobility systems Patricia Galilea and Marco Batarce Department of Transport Engineering and Logistics Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile