2. a course of action or inaction (Heclo 1972)
a course of action adopted and pursued by a government,
party, rulers, statesman (Oxford English Dictionary)
a set of interrelated decisions … concerning the selection of
goals and the means of achieving them within a specified
situation … (Jenkins 1978)
decisions taken by those with authority and responsibility for a
given policy area (Buse et al 2005)
any course of action followed primarily because it is expedient or advantages
in a material sense
2
6. 6
Walt G and Gilson L, Reforming the health sector in developing countries: the central role of
policy analysis, Health Policy and Planning 1994; 9: 353-70
Actors
Context
Content Process
10. Source: World Health Organization. Everybody’s
Business: Strengthening health systems to improve
health outcomes—WHO’s Framework for Action.
Geneva: WHO, 2007, page 3.
11. Health Policy and Healthy Public Policy Development
Diseases or Service Response
Health System Response
12. .
.
.
.
Insurance Model
Utilization review, quality assurance function
Compliance and access orientation
No integration
Care Delivery Model
Develop standard tools: CPG, care map
Linear integration
Security (Continuum Care) Model
Community health care, optimum care site
Continuous quality improvement
Promote wellness and community health status
Multidimensional integration
12
15. Generation 2010 2020 2030
Baby Boomer
( 50 ปี ขึ้นไป)
6,462 - -
Gen X
(31 - 49 ปี)
15,742 15,742 -
Gen Y
(18 - 30 ปี)
3,750 3,750 3,750
Gen M
- 6,462 22,204
16.
17. Prevalence Hypertension: 23% male, 21% female
All samples are hypertensive, >140/90 mmHg,
Effective coverage of hypertension,
adult >15 yr. 2003
Source: National Health Exam Survey
6
12
11
19
5
5
77
64
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Male (N=7,544)
Female (N=7,580)
treated + well control Treated, not well controlled
Diagnosed, no treatment Not diagnosed
18. Prevalence DM: 6% male, 7% female
All samples have FBS, >126 mg/dl
Effective coverage of DM, adult >15yr. 2003
Source: National Health Exam Survey
9
15
24
34
2
2
66
49
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Male (N=2,045)
Female (N=2,601)
treated + well control Treated, not well controlled
Diagnosed, no treatment Not diagnosed
24. 9.4%
8.1%
5.7%
5.5%
4.5%
3.7%
2.2%
1.7%
1.3%
0.9%
0.9%
0.5%
0.3%
0.3%
0.2%
13.8%
5.8%
5.1%
5.0%
4.2%
3.9%
2.3%
1.4%
1.2%
3.6%
1.4%
0.7%
0.7%
0.4%
0.3%
0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0% 12.0% 14.0% 16.0%
Unsafe sex
Alcohol
Tobacco
Blood pressure
Not wearing helmet
Obesity
Cholesterol
Fruit & vegies
Physical inactivity
Illicit drugs
Air pollution
Water & sanitation
Malnutrition - int standard
Not wearing seatbelt
Malnutrition - Thai standard
% of total burden
2004
1999
ลำดับปัจจัยเสี่ยงที่ก่อให้เกิดภำระโรคจำกมำกไปหำน้อย ได้แก่ กำรมี
เพศสัมพันธ์ที่ไม่ปลอดภัย แอลกอฮอล์ บุหรี่ ควำมดันเลือดสูง กำรไม่
สวมหมวกและคำดเข็มขัดนิรภัย ภำวะน้ำหนักเกินและโรคอ้วน ระดับ
โคเลสเตอรอลในเลือดสูง กำรบริโภคผักและผลไม้น้อย กำรขำดกำร
ออกกำลังกำย กำรใช้สำรเสพติด มลพิษทำงอำกำศ กำรขำดน้ำสะอำด
กำรสุขำภิบำลและสุขอนำมัยที่ไม่เหมำะสม และภำวะทุพโภชนำกำร
25.
26. “Knowledge is power”
Medical process: information
process
Delocalised, distributed and
direct
Decision support, information
management, identity
technology,
imaging, visualisation, sensors,
telemedicine
The home as treatment location
The Internet Patient
27. Diagnosis, data analysis, reminders,
memory empowerment, ”second opinion”
Interactive broschures, simulations, smart
objects, ”the digital doctor”
Benefits patient participation, handle information
overload
Problems: conservative, silent knowledge,
integration with patients and organisation
28. Scanning + fast visualization
+ information fusion
Non-invasive exploration
Direct information to doctors
Shorten the treatment chain,
reduce sidetracks
Requires change in routines
29. Trends
More conditions measurable, smaller, cheaper, plentiful, more functions per chip
More intimate and biological, both non-invasive and implanted
Active ”smart” sensors/actuators, wireless communication
Pathogen sensors, automated medication
Moves the location of diagnosis and
treatment to the periphery
Information overload,
privacy, security,
training
30. Surgery supported by information
technology
Remote surgery
Direct visualisation
Augmented reality
Robotics
Economy? Stumbles on
organisation issues
31. More and more applications
Faster recovery
Faster surgery redistributes medical personell
Need of a new kind of operating theatre?
Strong link toVR and robotic surgery
32. Regenerative medicine
Rational drug design
Bionics
Genetic testing
Vaccines
Enhancing medicine
33. Rational design
Based on genomics, simulation and knowledge of
basic processes
Generics threatened, business models in
pharma threatened
Blurs the borders between palliative,
curative, preventative and enhancing
medicine
34. Neurointerfaces rapid development (~300
electrodes, permanent)
Prosthetic research underfinanced
Large gains for small groups
35. Cheap, fast genetic tests many
conditions
How many wants to test? How does
the health system respond?
Benefits: More individually adapted,
good for preventative medicine and
pharmacogenomics
Problems: Interpretation, too much
faith in genetics, diagnosis develops
faster than treatment, breaks
information monopolies
36. Reproduction as a right?
We are willing to spend enormous sums on
our children and their health
Genetic testing, preventative medicine
Perinatal medicine
37. Vaccines for treatment instead of just prevention
Immune system control
Vaccines against
Allergies
Diabetes
Autoimmune illnesses
Metabolic illnesses
Cancer
Narcotics
38. The brain/mind increasingly visible
New pharmacology + understanding of brain
leads to treatment of many mental disorders
Hybrid therapies
39. NBIC convergence
Enhancement of previous technologies
Reduced price
Increased effectiveness
Increased portability
Active and smart devices and drugs
Development gradual and enabled by
previous technologies.
41. Population Screening
Using claims/clinical data to identify patients for
disease management
Patient Risk Management
Surveying patients about disease status/burden
to identify for disease management
Team-Based Care
Using formalized teams to increase
collaboration of care
Alternative Encounters
Providing opportunities outside of the face-to-
face encounter for relationship
Cross-Consortium Coordination
Managing across sites and settings to improve
care continuity
Patient Education
Teaching patients about their disease
Outreach/Case Management
Tracking patients and their status
proactively
Decision Support At the Point of Care
Translating disease management
guidelines to patients-specific
recommendations for clinicians.
Guidelines/Protocol
Providing information to clinicians on
recommended clinical management
Performance Feedback
Measuring performance in delivering
desired care and achieving improved
outcomes
42. Lifestyle interventions
Low risk At risk
Disease
Management
DiseaseSymptomsEarly Signs
Preventive Services Case Management
Screening
Primary and Secondary
Prevention
Acute
treatment
Disease
Management
HEALTH IMPROVEMENT
DISEASE MANAGEMENT
HEALTH MANAGEMENT
POPULATION-BASED CASE-BASED
43. Primary care dominated by chronic illness care
Clinical and behavioral management increasingly
effective BUT increasingly complex
Inadequate reimbursement and greater demand
forcing primary care to increase throughput—the
hamster wheel
Unhappy primary care clinicians leaving practice;
trainees choosing other specialties
Loss of confidence in primary care by policy-makers
and funders
But, there are new models of primary care and
growing interest in changing physician payment to
encourage and reward quality
45. Coordinate with other partners - central
government + local authority + community
+ private sector,
Working in community – home ward,
Proactive, outreach services based on
community health needs,
Care coordination – horizontal and vertical
levels and case management system
46. A “continuous healing relationship” with a care team
and practice system organized to meet their needs
for:
EffectiveTreatment (clinical, behavioral, supportive),
Information and support for their self-management,
Systematic follow-up and assessment tailored to clinical
severity,
More intensive management for those not meeting targets,
and
Coordination of care across settings and professionals
47. Reviews of interventions in other
conditions show that practice changes
are similar across conditions
Integrated changes with components
directed at:
use of non-physician team members,
planned encounters,
modern self-management support,
Intensification of treatment
care management for high risk patients
electronic registries
50. Assessment of self-management goal attainment and
confidence as well as clinical status
Adherence to guidelines
Tailoring of clinical management by stepped protocol (Treat to
target)
Collaborative goal-setting and problem-solving resulting in a
shared care plan
Planning for active, sustained follow-up
Informed,
Activated
Patient
Productive
Interactions
Prepared
Practice
Team
How would I recognize a
productive interaction?
51. Informed,
Activated
Patient
They have goals and a plan to improve their health,
and the motivation, information, skills, and confidence
necessary to manage their illness well.
52. Goal
To help patients take a more active role and be
more competent managers of their health and
healthcare.
53. Goal
To help patients access effective and useful services
and resources in the surrounding community.
55. Goal
To organize practice staff, schedules and other
systems to assure that all patients receive
planned, evidence-based care.
56. Goal
To assure that clinicians and other staff have the
training, scientific information and system
support to routinely provide evidence-based
(adhere to guidelines) and patient-centered
care.
57. Goal
To assure that clinicians and other staff have
ready access to patient information on
individuals and populations to help plan,
deliver and monitor care.
58. Goal
To assure that practices within the organization
have the motivation, support and resources
needed to redesign their care systems.
59. Practices spent considerable time searching
for/developing tools
Some practices felt intimidated by taking on the whole
model – asked for a sequence
Many changes were made in ways that were not
sustainable logistically or financially (e.g., double data
entry)
CCM elements implemented as “special events” rather
than part of routine care
Many achieve process improvements but outcomes don’t
change
64. Provide reminders for providers and patients.
Identify relevant patient subpopulations for
proactive care.
Facilitate individual patient care planning.
Share information with providers and patients.
Monitor performance of team and system.
65. Barriers to CIS use
Lack of perceived value
Competing business and productivity
demands
Lack of office flow expertise
Lack of information support
Lack of leadership support
66. Functionality!
Whatever you use should be able to
deliver information that supports:
population planning
clinical summaries at the visit
individual care planning
reminders
performance feedback
67. be organized by patient; not disease, but responsive
to disease populations
contain data relevant to clinical practice
assist with internal and external performance
reporting
guide clinical care first, measurement second!
68. Everyone, including senior leadership understands
the clinical utility and supports the time involved in
upkeep.
Data forms are clear, data entry role is assigned, data
review time allotted.
Data entered and retrieved are clinically relevant, and
used for patient care first, and measurement
second.
Data can be shared with patient to improve
understanding of treatment plan.
74. 18 file and OPD
individual record
HCIS , JHCIS, HosXP,
etc.
Report for claim
New media , Social
network
Tele consultation
75. Blogs
Wikis
Facebook , twitter
Podcasts
Videocasts /Vlogs
Moblogs
MMS
Internet telephony i.e.
skype™
Tools that facilitate:
Communication
Engagement
Transparency
Trust
Tools that are:
Complementary to
traditional communication
activities
Used by organizations who
recognize the social
characteristics of effective
communication
76.
77. Asymptomatic Screenings
Lifestyle Modifications
Cessation of Addictive Behaviors
Medical Regimen Compliance
PrecautionAdoption
78. Health Information
Behavior change
Self-management
On-line
communities
Decision support
Disease
management
Healthcare tools
Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, DHHS. Expanding the Reach and Impact of
Consumer e -HealthTools. 2006.
79. Improve dietary habits
Increase physical activity levels
Reduce heavy drinking
Decrease disordered eating behaviors
Improve adherence to treatment protocols
Impact on health care utilization and costs?
Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, DHHS. Expanding
the Reach and Impact of Consumer e -HealthTools. 2006.
80. The appropriate model for obesity and
weight management is tailored information
according to design principles suggested by
Social CognitiveTheory and the Social
Marketing Model.
The health behaviors to target are self-
monitoring of diet and physical activity.
The devices areWeb-enabled “smart” cellular
telephones and wireless PDAs.
JTTufano & BT Karras. Mobile eHealth Interventions for Obesity:
ATimely Opportunity to Leverage ConvergenceTrends. Journal
of Internet Medical Research 2005;7(5):e58).
82. Embed evidence-based guidelines into
daily clinical practice.
Integrate specialist expertise and primary
care.
Use proven provider education methods.
Share guidelines and information with
patients.
83. Evidence-based medicine is an approach to
health care that promotes the collection,
interpretation, and integration of valid,
important and applicable evidence.
The best available evidence, moderated by
patient circumstances and preferences, is
applied to improve the quality of clinical
judgments.
McMaster University
84. Customize guidelines to your setting
Embed in practice: able to influence real time
decision-making
Flow sheets with prompts
Decision rules in EMR
Share with patient
Reminders in registry
Standing orders
Have data to monitor care
85. Often begins with lifestyle change or
adaptation (eliminate triggers, lose
weight, exercise more)
First choice medication
Either increase dose or add second
medication, and so on
Includes referral guideline
86. Shared care agreements
Alternating primary-specialty visits
Joint visits
Roving expert teams
On-call specialist
Via nurse case manager
87. Interactive, sequential opportunities in small
groups or individual training
Academic detailing
Problem-based learning
Modeling (joint visits)
88. Build knowledge over time
Include all clinic staff
Involve changing practice, not just acquiring
knowledge
Evans et al, Pediatrics 1997;99:157
93. Workforce Development
Up front training and Admin Support
Professional development
Integration of Complementary Medicine
Micro system optimization
94. Clinical
Doctor,
Nurse Case Manager
Support groups
Behavorist
Pharmacist, Nutrition, H. Ed.
95. Demand
* Complex
health problem
*Explosion of knowledge
and technology
*Health care reform
*Expand the scope of
nursing
Supply
*Shortage of health
care personnel, both
quantity and quality
*Malutilization especially
nurse
Unsafe both nurses and patients/clients