SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 70
#Ev-Ent-Anglement 2 
To (Re)Perform a Theory of Feminist 
Digital Praxis: 
Cutting Through the Noise of the Digital Self 
Visible Evidence 
Dehhi, India International Center 
December, 2014
A Performative Précis 
Performing the same Précis 
to another 
audience 
in Utrecht, 
Summer, 2014.
To Cut 
A “causal procedure and act of decision” 
Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska 
Life After New Media (MIT Press: 2012)
To Paste 
A “causal procedure and act of decision” 
Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska 
Life After New Media (MIT Press: 2012)
To Cut 
“Cuts are part of 
the phenomena they help produce.” 
Karen Barad 
Meeting the Universe Halfway (date)
Loop!
Loop … Cut! … Repeat 
“Can the loop be a new narrative form 
appropriated for the computer age?” 
“It is relevant to recall that the loop gave birth 
not only to cinema but also to computer 
programing.” 
Lev Manovich, The Language of New Media (MIT: 2001)
Assemblage
Alex Juhasz, “Digital AIDS Documentary: 
Webs, Rooms, Viruses & Quilts,” 
Blackwell Anthology of Documentary, 
Juhasz and Alisa Lebow, eds.
little parts of me
just for the man
fragments of myself
A Cut+Paste from a student at the 
Utrecht #Ev-ent-anglement
Your Script: Ev-Ent-anglement 2 
Go to http://ev-ent-anglement.com and watch the ev-ent-anglement unfold. 
As I talk, or sometime within a week after, please #cut/paste+bleed into the #ev-ent-anglement from the 
archive of yourself. 
• Please try to #cut/paste+bleed at minimum twice 
• Please try to paste+bleed to something already cut before you 
Everything you paste needs this hashtag to be seen: #eventanglement 
• On Twitter: #eventanglement 
• On Instagram: #eventanglement 
Find or make images, links, words, video or gifs that express your responses, connections, ideas, and questions. 
You can write at any length in the comment box provided. 
You might be distracted. But the “talk” and site isn’t going anywhere … http://ev-ent-anglement.com
2. Once again with feeling: 
from a student at the Utrecht Ev-ent-anglement
From Eve-ent-anglement 1, Utrecht
From Alanna Thain@Utrecht
From Ingrid Ryberg@Utrecht
From “All Shades of Grey,” 
Minou Norouzi@Urecht
From Ingrid Ryberg
From Utrecht
3. The Em-Body as #Ev-Ent-Anglement 
The photographic act, both as “technique” and 
“ethical imperative,” serves as “an active practice of 
cutting through the flow of mediation.” 
“Time is indivisible, continuous and unknowable, at 
least to the intellect. In order to ‘know’ it, we must 
… cut.” 
Kember and Zylinska, Life after New Media
Sense-Making from Utrecht with Love
The audience in Utrecht, August 2014
Her again 
(she’s found and pasted a photo of herself 
reading French Feminisms)
#Cut/Paste+Bleed 
Please refer to your script. 
I humbly request that you join the #ev-ent-anglement 
at least twice during or refer this “talk.” 
I hope we might “do media studies” in a form that is 
not only analysis but is “simultaneously critical and 
creative.” (K & Z, xvii)
From Yumke@Utrecht 
August 27, 2014 at 8:12 am 
When I was thinking about what to “paste” here, I 
wanted to contribute something in a way we all can. And I 
thought of a article written about the artist Carol 
Rossetti: http://m.mic.com/articles/92651/18- 
empowering-illustrations-to-remind-everyone-who-s-really- 
in-charge-of-women-s-bodies 
She makes empowering drawings for all kind of women, I 
really enjoyed them and felt empowered by some of 
them! 
Reply
From KJ@Internet 
August 29, 2014 at 3:52 pm 
This reminds me of Bill Shannon’s creative 
dance movement at the nexus of art & 
disability; my 6 year-old son also has the same 
pediatric hip disease (Legg-Calve-Perthes) and 
we have been relearning what it means to 
move freely in the world, always subject to 
limitations of the body. 
Reply
KJ continues 
I have recently made a rather large cut 
to myself 
or rather a surgeon made it for me 
out of great necessity 
(It was a kind of a “do or die” situation) 
This edit to my physical body invites interpretations, 
many times by strangers 
People whom I don’t know 
and who don’t know me. 
I don’t mean to be mysterious 
but 
it’s complicated. 
Online I am a composite of many identities 
gendered this way or that 
and strangely 
I find myself entangled in fragments of former selves 
which are constantly colliding 
shattering the illusion of the seamless narratives 
about gender identity 
about cancer 
often required for the comfort of others. 
#eventanglement
The Last Cut is not the Deepest 
From Sarah Kember@Internet
“Then Along Came STS/And…” by Nina 
Wakeford, pasted by Sarah Kember
From Joanna Zylinska@Internet
Editing 
“straddles the line between art and craft” 
Valerie Orpen, Film Editing: The Art of the Expressive
The first advertising silent film 
Lumiere Brothers (1896): Washing Up
Every stop is linked to another go
“Film Editing: The Art of the Expressive” 
Where the cut allows for “pruning, curtailing, 
rejecting, removing” the join permits “adding 
and accreting.” (Valerie Orpen, Film Editing)
hypermediacy 
“the collage of effect of media forms and styles” 
(Kember & Zylinska, 8)
Spatial Montage: 
“Feminism”@YouTube
A tweet with a fragmented 
screen@Utrecht
Two more tweets@Utrecht
Spatial Montage 
“Editing at its most Eisensteinian enlivens dead 
things through the clash of the cut.” 
Alex Juhasz
A Tweet with a video about AIDS 
nostalgia and death@Utrecht
The Cut-Up Method of Brion Gysin 
“Cut ups are for everyone. Anybody can make 
cut ups. It is experimental in the sense of being 
something to do.” 
William S. Burroughs
“All writing is in fact cut-ups” 
Burroughs
Man with a Movie Camera 
Women with her Editing Scissors
The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty 
(Esfir Shub, 1927)
Cutting
Ab-jecting 
“Repelling, rejecting; repelling itself, rejecting 
itself. Ab-jecting.” 
Julia Kristeva, 1980
+Metaphoric Glue 
“forces, intensities, and energies not 
substances,” effecting the “complex, random 
processes not predictable states.” 
Diana Coole and Samantha Frost: “Introduction” 
New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency and Politics
Cyborg Bleed-Through 
“What kind of politics could embrace partial, 
contradictory, permanently unclosed 
constructions of personal and collective selves 
and still be faithful, effective—and, ironically, 
socialist-feminist?” 
Donna Haraway, “A Cyborg Manifesto”
“An argument for pleasure in the confusion of boundaries and 
for responsibility in their construction,” Donna Haraway
We cut/paste+bleed binaries 
Art/Craft 
Long take/Montage 
On/Off screen 
Invisible/Visible 
Dull matter/Vibrant life 
Loop/Line 
Hierarchy/Flat 
Politics/Feelings 
Past/Present 
Present/Future 
Cut up/Happening 
Time/Space 
Virality/Duration 
Critique/Create
Intra-action 
“There is no ‘between’ as such, human and non-human 
organisms and machines emerge only 
through their mutual co-constitution.” 
Karen Barad
photos
tweets
Blog posts
videos
essays
purchases
Thumbs up
“Composting the Net” 
Shu Lea Cheang, 2012
The dump of the Internet
From KJ, looped or lopped 
August 27, 2014 at 8:19 pm 
• I have recently made a rather large cut 
to myself 
or rather a surgeon made it for me 
out of great necessity 
• (It was a kind of a “do or die” situation) 
• This edit to my physical body invites interpretations, 
many times by strangers 
People whom I don’t know 
and who don’t know me. 
• I don’t mean to be mysterious 
but 
it’s complicated. 
• Online I am a composite of many identities 
gendered this way or that 
and strangely 
I find myself entangled in fragments of former selves 
which are constantly colliding 
shattering the illusion of the seamless narratives 
about gender identity 
about cancer 
often required for the comfort of others. 
#eventanglement
From noortje@Utrecht (I think) 
August 27, 2014 at 8:44 am 
Digital distracted fragmentation/ 
watermelon nostalgia/ 
cutting pasting bleeding/ 
Abjects/ 
drowning in liquidity/ 
littering the archive of the world/ 
screaming to be reused/ 
stitching, curating ourselves/ 
Again/ 
It’s never to late to be what you have been/
From Pato Hebert@Internet 
August 27, 2014 at 6:47 am 
• Thanks for #Cutting/Pasting+Bleeding open a space with 
and for so many of us Alex. I’m wondering how our 
incisionsutures relate to to revisiting as a way to 
reassemble anew. I’m thinking about what it meant to post 
on FB from the International AIDS Conference last month, 
trying to hold the spin of real bodies in mobilizing motion in 
relationship to the stasis of health bureaucracies, the 
connective tissue of fellowship and the en-couragment of 
folks far in body but close in struggle and heart. Cleaving, 
clotting, accompanying… 
• https://www.facebook.com/pato.hebert/media_set?set=a. 
1439918602960409.1073741854.100008268480364&type= 
1
From Instagram
From domi olivieri@Utrecht 
August 27, 2014 at 7:59 am 
Right now I hear and see you talking of cutting, 
editing, pasting, and while getting distracted, 
this comes to mind: in “Cinema Interval” Trinh 
Minh-ha writes, “I would say that creating 
rhythm is a way of working with intervals – 
silences, pauses, pacing – and working with 
intervals means working with relationships in 
the wider sense of the term” (Trinh 1999a, 38).
From TL Cowan@Internet 
• August 28, 2014 at 1:38 pm 
After my first week of teaching 
• /Cut To/ 
“Race, Gender, Cultural Politics: Reading bell hooks” — a First Year Seminar teaching Teaching to 
Transgress, Writing Beyond Race and other hooks’ articles as well as some contemporary culture 
maker/theorists, Marci Blackman’s novel, Tradition, and Janet Mock’s memoir, Redefining Realness, and 
Shola Lynch’s film “Free Angela Davis and All Political Prisoners” – three of hooks’ interlocutors at a 
recent public discussion at Eugene Lang College (The New School) where I teach (see the video here: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJk0hNROvzs). #context 
• /Cut To/ 
“Transgender Cultural Studies” an upper-year seminar that also fulfills the requirement for “Intro to 
Feminist Theory” in our always precarious Gender Studies Minor. There are students who have already 
done so much thinking about this topic and others who are just beginning & I worry about the 
knowledge gap – how does a teacher make sure that everyone is learning? 
• /Cut To/ 
I am a white cisgender lady (I like ‘lady’ better than ‘woman’ these days) teaching these courses that so 
far exceed my experiential knowledges, but I’m teaching them because I believe in curriculum 
transformation and that it is possible to teach and learn across difference. But I am nervous that I am 
going to fuck it up.
From Petra Kuppers@Internet
“Sound/text ridingthe meridian hyper/text riding the meridian 
text/text ridingthemeridan sound/text” 
http://www.heelstone.com/meridian/theory2.html

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
Kelly Castle
 
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
Love Kiss
 

Destacado (12)

Physical Education
Physical EducationPhysical Education
Physical Education
 
An overview of technological advancements and
An overview of technological advancements andAn overview of technological advancements and
An overview of technological advancements and
 
Take your admisson in UG and PG course
Take your admisson in UG and PG courseTake your admisson in UG and PG course
Take your admisson in UG and PG course
 
Conflicto armado
Conflicto armadoConflicto armado
Conflicto armado
 
Conference and Registration details- ISIDD 2016
Conference and Registration details- ISIDD 2016Conference and Registration details- ISIDD 2016
Conference and Registration details- ISIDD 2016
 
Case reports
Case reportsCase reports
Case reports
 
Computer and Information Technology
Computer and Information TechnologyComputer and Information Technology
Computer and Information Technology
 
HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
HIPAA: Week 1 Discussion 2
 
A novel approach for georeferenced data analysis using hard clustering algorithm
A novel approach for georeferenced data analysis using hard clustering algorithmA novel approach for georeferenced data analysis using hard clustering algorithm
A novel approach for georeferenced data analysis using hard clustering algorithm
 
Issues and challenges with renewable energy in oman
Issues and challenges with renewable energy in omanIssues and challenges with renewable energy in oman
Issues and challenges with renewable energy in oman
 
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
A photomultiplier high voltage power supply irtcorporating a ceramic transfor...
 
Evidence based practice
Evidence based practiceEvidence based practice
Evidence based practice
 

Similar a Ev ent-anglement with photos india

digital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
digital+dilemmas+PDF.compresseddigital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
digital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
Rhonda Nicholl
 
AbjectCatalogue2f
AbjectCatalogue2fAbjectCatalogue2f
AbjectCatalogue2f
Yusra Ali
 

Similar a Ev ent-anglement with photos india (19)

Ev ent-anglement montreal
Ev ent-anglement montrealEv ent-anglement montreal
Ev ent-anglement montreal
 
Cuny talk
Cuny talkCuny talk
Cuny talk
 
Ev-ent-anglement 3: dublin
Ev-ent-anglement 3: dublinEv-ent-anglement 3: dublin
Ev-ent-anglement 3: dublin
 
Whose Life Is It Anyway Essay
Whose Life Is It Anyway EssayWhose Life Is It Anyway Essay
Whose Life Is It Anyway Essay
 
digital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
digital+dilemmas+PDF.compresseddigital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
digital+dilemmas+PDF.compressed
 
Digital uto vs dysto
Digital uto vs dystoDigital uto vs dysto
Digital uto vs dysto
 
Digital utopia vs dystopia
Digital utopia vs dystopiaDigital utopia vs dystopia
Digital utopia vs dystopia
 
To be or not to be human in our digital world
To be or not to be human in our digital worldTo be or not to be human in our digital world
To be or not to be human in our digital world
 
Essay On Emotional Intelligence
Essay On Emotional IntelligenceEssay On Emotional Intelligence
Essay On Emotional Intelligence
 
Lake of lotus (2) the meaning of near-death experiences (2)-the energy thread...
Lake of lotus (2) the meaning of near-death experiences (2)-the energy thread...Lake of lotus (2) the meaning of near-death experiences (2)-the energy thread...
Lake of lotus (2) the meaning of near-death experiences (2)-the energy thread...
 
DISSERTATION
DISSERTATIONDISSERTATION
DISSERTATION
 
“Scream the Place Down” : The power of research poetry in aged care
“Scream the Place Down” : The power of research poetry in aged care “Scream the Place Down” : The power of research poetry in aged care
“Scream the Place Down” : The power of research poetry in aged care
 
AbjectCatalogue2f
AbjectCatalogue2fAbjectCatalogue2f
AbjectCatalogue2f
 
50 Great Essays
50 Great Essays50 Great Essays
50 Great Essays
 
Sc2218 Lecture 1 (2008a)
Sc2218 Lecture 1 (2008a)Sc2218 Lecture 1 (2008a)
Sc2218 Lecture 1 (2008a)
 
ghosts in a ghosts place
ghosts in a ghosts placeghosts in a ghosts place
ghosts in a ghosts place
 
Essay On Class. Our classroom essay. Our Classroom Website. 2019-02-18
Essay On Class.  Our classroom essay. Our Classroom Website. 2019-02-18Essay On Class.  Our classroom essay. Our Classroom Website. 2019-02-18
Essay On Class. Our classroom essay. Our Classroom Website. 2019-02-18
 
Breaking The Chains on Lancet
Breaking The Chains on LancetBreaking The Chains on Lancet
Breaking The Chains on Lancet
 
defense2
defense2defense2
defense2
 

Último

Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Chris Hunter
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
kauryashika82
 

Último (20)

Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docx
psychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docxpsychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docx
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docx
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
 
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxUnit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
 
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
 
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
 

Ev ent-anglement with photos india

  • 1. #Ev-Ent-Anglement 2 To (Re)Perform a Theory of Feminist Digital Praxis: Cutting Through the Noise of the Digital Self Visible Evidence Dehhi, India International Center December, 2014
  • 2. A Performative Précis Performing the same Précis to another audience in Utrecht, Summer, 2014.
  • 3. To Cut A “causal procedure and act of decision” Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska Life After New Media (MIT Press: 2012)
  • 4. To Paste A “causal procedure and act of decision” Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska Life After New Media (MIT Press: 2012)
  • 5. To Cut “Cuts are part of the phenomena they help produce.” Karen Barad Meeting the Universe Halfway (date)
  • 7. Loop … Cut! … Repeat “Can the loop be a new narrative form appropriated for the computer age?” “It is relevant to recall that the loop gave birth not only to cinema but also to computer programing.” Lev Manovich, The Language of New Media (MIT: 2001)
  • 9. Alex Juhasz, “Digital AIDS Documentary: Webs, Rooms, Viruses & Quilts,” Blackwell Anthology of Documentary, Juhasz and Alisa Lebow, eds.
  • 13. A Cut+Paste from a student at the Utrecht #Ev-ent-anglement
  • 14. Your Script: Ev-Ent-anglement 2 Go to http://ev-ent-anglement.com and watch the ev-ent-anglement unfold. As I talk, or sometime within a week after, please #cut/paste+bleed into the #ev-ent-anglement from the archive of yourself. • Please try to #cut/paste+bleed at minimum twice • Please try to paste+bleed to something already cut before you Everything you paste needs this hashtag to be seen: #eventanglement • On Twitter: #eventanglement • On Instagram: #eventanglement Find or make images, links, words, video or gifs that express your responses, connections, ideas, and questions. You can write at any length in the comment box provided. You might be distracted. But the “talk” and site isn’t going anywhere … http://ev-ent-anglement.com
  • 15. 2. Once again with feeling: from a student at the Utrecht Ev-ent-anglement
  • 19. From “All Shades of Grey,” Minou Norouzi@Urecht
  • 22. 3. The Em-Body as #Ev-Ent-Anglement The photographic act, both as “technique” and “ethical imperative,” serves as “an active practice of cutting through the flow of mediation.” “Time is indivisible, continuous and unknowable, at least to the intellect. In order to ‘know’ it, we must … cut.” Kember and Zylinska, Life after New Media
  • 24. The audience in Utrecht, August 2014
  • 25. Her again (she’s found and pasted a photo of herself reading French Feminisms)
  • 26. #Cut/Paste+Bleed Please refer to your script. I humbly request that you join the #ev-ent-anglement at least twice during or refer this “talk.” I hope we might “do media studies” in a form that is not only analysis but is “simultaneously critical and creative.” (K & Z, xvii)
  • 27. From Yumke@Utrecht August 27, 2014 at 8:12 am When I was thinking about what to “paste” here, I wanted to contribute something in a way we all can. And I thought of a article written about the artist Carol Rossetti: http://m.mic.com/articles/92651/18- empowering-illustrations-to-remind-everyone-who-s-really- in-charge-of-women-s-bodies She makes empowering drawings for all kind of women, I really enjoyed them and felt empowered by some of them! Reply
  • 28. From KJ@Internet August 29, 2014 at 3:52 pm This reminds me of Bill Shannon’s creative dance movement at the nexus of art & disability; my 6 year-old son also has the same pediatric hip disease (Legg-Calve-Perthes) and we have been relearning what it means to move freely in the world, always subject to limitations of the body. Reply
  • 29. KJ continues I have recently made a rather large cut to myself or rather a surgeon made it for me out of great necessity (It was a kind of a “do or die” situation) This edit to my physical body invites interpretations, many times by strangers People whom I don’t know and who don’t know me. I don’t mean to be mysterious but it’s complicated. Online I am a composite of many identities gendered this way or that and strangely I find myself entangled in fragments of former selves which are constantly colliding shattering the illusion of the seamless narratives about gender identity about cancer often required for the comfort of others. #eventanglement
  • 30. The Last Cut is not the Deepest From Sarah Kember@Internet
  • 31. “Then Along Came STS/And…” by Nina Wakeford, pasted by Sarah Kember
  • 33. Editing “straddles the line between art and craft” Valerie Orpen, Film Editing: The Art of the Expressive
  • 34. The first advertising silent film Lumiere Brothers (1896): Washing Up
  • 35. Every stop is linked to another go
  • 36. “Film Editing: The Art of the Expressive” Where the cut allows for “pruning, curtailing, rejecting, removing” the join permits “adding and accreting.” (Valerie Orpen, Film Editing)
  • 37. hypermediacy “the collage of effect of media forms and styles” (Kember & Zylinska, 8)
  • 39. A tweet with a fragmented screen@Utrecht
  • 41. Spatial Montage “Editing at its most Eisensteinian enlivens dead things through the clash of the cut.” Alex Juhasz
  • 42. A Tweet with a video about AIDS nostalgia and death@Utrecht
  • 43. The Cut-Up Method of Brion Gysin “Cut ups are for everyone. Anybody can make cut ups. It is experimental in the sense of being something to do.” William S. Burroughs
  • 44. “All writing is in fact cut-ups” Burroughs
  • 45. Man with a Movie Camera Women with her Editing Scissors
  • 46. The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty (Esfir Shub, 1927)
  • 48. Ab-jecting “Repelling, rejecting; repelling itself, rejecting itself. Ab-jecting.” Julia Kristeva, 1980
  • 49. +Metaphoric Glue “forces, intensities, and energies not substances,” effecting the “complex, random processes not predictable states.” Diana Coole and Samantha Frost: “Introduction” New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency and Politics
  • 50. Cyborg Bleed-Through “What kind of politics could embrace partial, contradictory, permanently unclosed constructions of personal and collective selves and still be faithful, effective—and, ironically, socialist-feminist?” Donna Haraway, “A Cyborg Manifesto”
  • 51. “An argument for pleasure in the confusion of boundaries and for responsibility in their construction,” Donna Haraway
  • 52. We cut/paste+bleed binaries Art/Craft Long take/Montage On/Off screen Invisible/Visible Dull matter/Vibrant life Loop/Line Hierarchy/Flat Politics/Feelings Past/Present Present/Future Cut up/Happening Time/Space Virality/Duration Critique/Create
  • 53. Intra-action “There is no ‘between’ as such, human and non-human organisms and machines emerge only through their mutual co-constitution.” Karen Barad
  • 61. “Composting the Net” Shu Lea Cheang, 2012
  • 62. The dump of the Internet
  • 63. From KJ, looped or lopped August 27, 2014 at 8:19 pm • I have recently made a rather large cut to myself or rather a surgeon made it for me out of great necessity • (It was a kind of a “do or die” situation) • This edit to my physical body invites interpretations, many times by strangers People whom I don’t know and who don’t know me. • I don’t mean to be mysterious but it’s complicated. • Online I am a composite of many identities gendered this way or that and strangely I find myself entangled in fragments of former selves which are constantly colliding shattering the illusion of the seamless narratives about gender identity about cancer often required for the comfort of others. #eventanglement
  • 64. From noortje@Utrecht (I think) August 27, 2014 at 8:44 am Digital distracted fragmentation/ watermelon nostalgia/ cutting pasting bleeding/ Abjects/ drowning in liquidity/ littering the archive of the world/ screaming to be reused/ stitching, curating ourselves/ Again/ It’s never to late to be what you have been/
  • 65. From Pato Hebert@Internet August 27, 2014 at 6:47 am • Thanks for #Cutting/Pasting+Bleeding open a space with and for so many of us Alex. I’m wondering how our incisionsutures relate to to revisiting as a way to reassemble anew. I’m thinking about what it meant to post on FB from the International AIDS Conference last month, trying to hold the spin of real bodies in mobilizing motion in relationship to the stasis of health bureaucracies, the connective tissue of fellowship and the en-couragment of folks far in body but close in struggle and heart. Cleaving, clotting, accompanying… • https://www.facebook.com/pato.hebert/media_set?set=a. 1439918602960409.1073741854.100008268480364&type= 1
  • 67. From domi olivieri@Utrecht August 27, 2014 at 7:59 am Right now I hear and see you talking of cutting, editing, pasting, and while getting distracted, this comes to mind: in “Cinema Interval” Trinh Minh-ha writes, “I would say that creating rhythm is a way of working with intervals – silences, pauses, pacing – and working with intervals means working with relationships in the wider sense of the term” (Trinh 1999a, 38).
  • 68. From TL Cowan@Internet • August 28, 2014 at 1:38 pm After my first week of teaching • /Cut To/ “Race, Gender, Cultural Politics: Reading bell hooks” — a First Year Seminar teaching Teaching to Transgress, Writing Beyond Race and other hooks’ articles as well as some contemporary culture maker/theorists, Marci Blackman’s novel, Tradition, and Janet Mock’s memoir, Redefining Realness, and Shola Lynch’s film “Free Angela Davis and All Political Prisoners” – three of hooks’ interlocutors at a recent public discussion at Eugene Lang College (The New School) where I teach (see the video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJk0hNROvzs). #context • /Cut To/ “Transgender Cultural Studies” an upper-year seminar that also fulfills the requirement for “Intro to Feminist Theory” in our always precarious Gender Studies Minor. There are students who have already done so much thinking about this topic and others who are just beginning & I worry about the knowledge gap – how does a teacher make sure that everyone is learning? • /Cut To/ I am a white cisgender lady (I like ‘lady’ better than ‘woman’ these days) teaching these courses that so far exceed my experiential knowledges, but I’m teaching them because I believe in curriculum transformation and that it is possible to teach and learn across difference. But I am nervous that I am going to fuck it up.
  • 70. “Sound/text ridingthe meridian hyper/text riding the meridian text/text ridingthemeridan sound/text” http://www.heelstone.com/meridian/theory2.html

Notas del editor

  1. A Performative Précis Cut! That’s a wrap! Hey, that’s a strange way to start something, isn’t it?
  2. For, a cut marks a hard stop; an end to something that was rolling along just fine without it; a precarious if probably also false point of finitude judiciously pulled from the flow by some sort of performer, presenter, author or director. To cut is celebrated doubly by Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska as both a “causal procedure” and an “act of decision.” Cut! I need to add something here: for, for every cut there is a paste. So let me try again: Paste!
  3. Every cut is a beginning. One moment ends, another launches, hanging there just on the other side of the brink, gently commencing its steady unroll.
  4. “Cuts are part of the phenomena they help produce,” suggests Karen Barad. Cut! That’s a wrap! Hey, that’s a strange way to start something, isn’t it? Alrighty then: Loop!
  5. [PLAY VIDEO] If you use a cut and stitch to the same beginning, well, there’s your loop.
  6. “Can the loop be a new narrative form appropriated for the computer age?” asks Lev Manovich, who answers: “It is relevant to recall that the loop gave birth not only to cinema but also to computer programing.” Cut! So, I’ll just let this repeat
  7. {PLAY} while linking something else to it, and see: an assemblage we’ve got! Let a little bit of this touch a little bit of that, linking fragments that might never have been meant to be in proximity-- until I chose and moved them that is--and attached them, inelegantly together with a simple set of digital tools, all the while exposing the ugly seams so you’d see my hand, my love bleeding out to you with every careful cut and stitch. Together, sharing the page or better yet the stage. Or the quilt.
  8. I wrote this at an earlier time, about quilting, cutting and Digital AIDS Documentary. And it’s about to be in a book, one that will be duly celebrated here in India I hear tell…   On these pages, I can stitch together multiple, competing and connecting interpretations, representations, and technologies of the AIDS quilt: a paper-bound linear tactic that allows discrete moments and their memories to infect each other. If “AIDS is a crisis of connections,” digital media serves to link, defying forces of nature that might otherwise keep ideas, bodies, memories, or images untouched, disconnected or maybe uninfected. But why say anything here and now when I said it already before, there, and then and you can buy it, or rip it, and read it later? That raises two of the questions I’ll be persuing here and now (if you’re in the room) and always later if you read this Power Point online: what to do well with so many records of what we’ve already done, and why we persist at being live, in-person, together in space and time when we’ve done so much of ourself already on the Internet  …   Cut!   Hey, that really hurts! Could you help me feel a bit better? Better yet, could you help me to learn to self-suture? Both cut and link all those fragments of me back to myself, fragments that litter the stage, which is here and now but also always the Internet; me, ever so easy to find, and increasingly harder to lose.
  9. Little parts of me and sometimes you
  10. that I made just for the man!
  11. I swear it didn’t hurt when I shot them or when I was shot. But it still feels painful, having fragments of myself there to be used in the service of God only knows what
  12. In response, I want to try to cut myself back together with others, and you, in a feminist ethic that links deeper, farther, and truer, to previous knowledge and current context, to communities, ideas and analyses that matter. That links me to you in a feminist entanglement that links you to me, if you’re ready and willing to seep in that is. Your script is forthcoming. …
  13. It’s here Cut! That’s a wrap! But I’m not sure that was clear. So let me start again … Loop!
  14. 2. Once again with feeling And loop it is. That’s exactly how I started my talk this August at the Noise European Summer School in Women’s Studies from Multicultural and Interdisciplinary Perspectives, Utrecht University. And then I gave them a script, and for the next hour (and for another week on the Internet)
  15. they pasted and cut ideas,
  16. links, images, videos, tweets, and comments onto my site,
  17. and I responded, reviewed, and concluded as well.
  18. All told, there was something like 50-100 unique additions to the site made in its first iteration. I received poems, new photos and old, tweets with videos, writing with links. I’ll be showing some of these to you here, but they’re all there on the #ev-ent-anglement, waiting for your thoughts and links. This is the second ev-ent-anglement, a loop, to which I invite you to paste.
  19. I invite you to peruse what was before, and is also now and here, or later; as you wish, as you engage.
  20. I also share with you a much-addended script: it might help you to act.
  21. 3. The #Em-Body as #Ev-Ent-Anglement In their book, Life After New Media: Mediation as a Vital Process, Sarah Kember and Joanna Zylinska present a complicated command: to cut well. They suggest that the photographic act, both as “technique” and “ethical imperative” serves as “an active practice of cutting through the flow of mediation.” By making a temporal intervention with a camera—which can be an ethical choice that marks a difference between this and that, me and you, human and thing, now and then—
  22. we begin to know ourselves and our world:
  23. They write: “Time is indivisible, continuous and unknowable, at least to the intellect. In order to ‘know’ it, we must … cut.”
  24. I want us here, today, in Delhi and live across the Internet (and always also before or later and not exactly dead but not in this live time either), to build on and from their requirement and query, as well as in connection to what people in Utrecht and elsewhere thought earlier, so as to answer: “what does it mean to cut well”?
  25. I suggest that a distinctly feminist media ethic would allow us to cut through and also link onto such a technological cut—and thus to assemble—our chosen, gathered, shared, specific, local, and political fragments, actions, objects, and outcomes that we make and feel together:
  26. that we embody and archive here, in a room, and on the Internet.
  27. I ask you to #cut/paste+bleed onto this event and into the Internet—as did KJ and many others did before you – Read his thoughts, and paste your own feelings, knowledge, commitments, and questions as feminist scholars of your own definition, with your own interests, commitments, histories and theories of feminism
  28. READ
  29. When you cut and paste you will be archiving some of what we are and know here in Delhi, but also as we connect to other theres and many thens too, re-assembling records of this moment intentionally and through technology with carefully pruned, already-made digital fragments of past ourselves, communities, and commitments
  30. Together we are intentionally building and saving a feminist record of our shared now, and our linked then, as well as whatever future plans and schemes—
  31. rooted in knowledge and analysis of our past—that we can add to the mix.
  32. In Life After New Media, Kember and Zylinska ask: “Can we think of a way of ‘doing media studies’ that is not just a form of ‘media analysis’ and that is simultaneously critical and creative?” And, I propose that to try to do so, we will cut and paste well and together; we will collectively make a further feminist #ev-ent-anglement of this talk. I get to our proposed method (#cut/paste+bleed) by way of montage theory and practice, because in ways that will be important to us “editing straddles the line between art and a craft.”
  33. PLAY. When the film director yells “Cut!” the action (or performance) and the camera’s mechanisms stop. One shot is formed from all this activity and its termination. When next, the director yells “Action!” the camera begins to roll again, pulling the same piece of celluloid through its mechanisms, allowing light to expose the frames of celluloid that will record whatever performance also commences newly in front of its lens. The first stop is linked to another go. Where the cut allows for “pruning, curtailing, rejecting, removing” the join permits “adding and accreting.” Of course, for some, the art of cinema is in the shot, true for both those enamored of cinema verite, the long-take or the indexical. But for just as many others, the magic and power of cinema is in the edit, which is to say the cut and the paste. For those who celebrate the cut, cinema’s expressivity is linked to a two-part act that concludes with the paste.
  34. PLAY: The first stop is linked to another go. Where the cut allows for “pruning, curtailing, rejecting, removing” the join permits “adding and accreting.” Of course, for some, the art of cinema is in the shot, true for both those enamored of cinema verite, the long-take or the indexical. But for just as many others, the magic and power of cinema is in the edit, which is to say the cut and the paste.
  35. For those who celebrate the cut, cinema’s expressivity is linked to a two-part act that concludes with the paste.
  36. Many theorists outside of editing find power in similar projects of spatio-temporal realignment. Kember and Zylinska name this “hypermediacy … the collage of effect of media forms and styles.”
  37. This is what most webpages look like, and a great deal of contemporary editing, as well.
  38. Flat planes where many forms of media are either loosely, or sharply, but always visibly assembled together outside a logic of space/time coherence
  39. , or that of cause and effect.
  40. We sometimes call this “MTV editing,” or “spatial montage.” I put it like this about my own queer video aesthetic: “Editing at its most Eisensteinian enlivens dead things through the clash of the cut.”
  41. Of course, cutting, pasting, and showing the stitch is just plain easy to do, while also being expressively effective.
  42. William S. Borroughs wrote: “Cut ups are for everyone. Anybody can make cut ups. It is experimental in the sense of being something to do.”
  43. PLAY: Importantly for our project here, cutting or editing is both historically women’s work, craft, and arguably feminist work; “like doing the washing up,” as much as it is like creating art
  44. PLAY: Dziga Vertov’s Man With a Movie Camera also draws out cutting and editing in gendered terms. The man, the cameraman, Vertov’s real-life brother, Mikhail Kaufman, projects exuberantly into the world, empowered by his phallic camera that allows him to see and own the world newly. But soon after (or actually in the middle of) his adventure, we meet someone else: the editing-woman (after already having been introduced to several other kinds of seamstresses and the loops that support their craft). In the film’s central scene, we meet Vertov’s real world wife, Yelizaveta Svilova, who sits quietly in a dark room attending to what remains after the man’s cocky adventures (climbing towering smokestacks, wedging himself below hurtling trains), and almost effortlessly it seems, does with it whatever she will or wants. His shots’ indexical traces tremble beneath the simple, graceful snips of her scissors and the sticky pastes of her editing console.
  45. PLAY: Man with the Movie Camera could as easily be called Woman with her Editing Scissors. In her hand, the indexical hold of the shot is obliterated by the expressive clutch of the cut. “Authenticity of original footage is not truthful … The meaning of the shot is produced in context,” kvell Reisz and Millar. They refer here to Esfir Shub, inventor of the compilation film; Esfir Shub, Soviet constructivist genius sister to the other editing masters, who allowed us to understand that it is the quiet, docile, hidden editor (and the archival researcher who finds the ready-made material she uses) who can so powerfully take control of meaning in the cinema.
  46. Of course the contemporary act of self-cutting, like editing, can be understood in similarly gendered terms [PP41]: a violent act of power-seeking performed in yet another of those private places allocated to women in patriarchy. Interestingly, this kind of cutting does not bring with it an associated paste. What this cut brings with it, what it wants, its dyadic, is a bleed.
  47. While all human bodies (and those of other animals) bleed, a particular kind of bleeding will help focus the bleed’s role in our feminist project of #ev-ent-anglement 2—one where our directives are to #cut/paste+bleed —because the menses are one of many in-between bodily acts that are uniquely and distinctly female. Julia Kristeva asks us to consider bodily acts, like menstruation, at the border between clean and dirty, live and dead, inside and out: “Repelling, rejecting; repelling itself, rejecting itself.  Ab-jecting.”
  48. The seeping and connecting quality of all blood allows it to be a metaphoric glue that marks the many pulls of our present entanglement—from in to out and on to off, from me to you to us, from digital matter to living body. Sarah Ahmed calls this “affect: what sticks, or what sustains or preserves the connection between ideas, values, and objects.” Of course all people—men, those in-between or indeterminate, and females who don’t menstruate—can bleed with us too!
  49. Cyborgs all, we make quick use of technology, body, affect and and place to flow through the distinctive binaries of our time and this project:
  50. Let’s cut/paste and bleed through binaries! The bleed is how we perform what Barad calls “intra-action” where “there is no ‘between’ as such, human and non-human organisms and machines emerge only through their mutual co-constitution.”
  51. Today, and always later online, for every cut, we have a paste that we glue with figurative blood to together make our #ev-ent-anglement 2 from what is in this room at this time, what was in another place and time, and also what sits on the Internet spaces where we also reside and connect. There is no in-between.
  52. And, where do we get these things that we might cut/paste + bleed, you might ask? The Internet’s full of ‘em! Full of us. Brimming with fragments we’ve cut of ourselves ripe for new intra-actions:
  53. photos
  54. tweets
  55. blog posts
  56. videos
  57. essays
  58. purchases
  59. thumbs up
  60. If the Internet is an unorchestrated archive of fragments of all our selves, we might want to take on the empowering feminist role of editor and curate ourselves, together, into a collection that matters.
  61. Our object is ourself and ourselves. Our Bodies/Our Selves Redux. Lopped. Looped. Lined. Linked. Re-Aligned. Show the Seams. Justice to our fragments!
  62. Which is to say that we can engage in a process of cutting, pasting, and bleeding ourselves together—READ
  63. as we are and have been, as we have made ourselves online and off, in community, history, and action with others—READ
  64. as our way to cut well, because we are feminist scholars and activists, and this is our shared project
  65. Our #ev-ent-anglement with each other and technology allows us to cut/paste+bleed digital fragments of ourselves, and what matters most to us, including the words and images of others,
  66. And our histories and art and feelings … and books,
  67. into purposeful, co-produced montage-collages: READ
  68. that can not be contained, isolated or easily commodified. I invite you to join or at least bleed to us. Thank you.