SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 18
Discussions on  New Orleans  tourism accounts  in social media
“Facebookis a community for people to share & engage with a brand and each other, while Twitter is a constant broadcast that is great for customer service.” “Facebookis cozy night on the couch with good friends. Twitter is a great party full of interesting people to meet.” “Facebookis a mini web portal for your business that can be customized to create a great user experience whileTwitter is an excellent research and broadcast tool for resources and linking to other destinations.” “Facebookis a community that encourages you to stay and explore. Twitter is a tool that sends quick info and links you to out to other communities.”
Numbers 37,541 Total Facebook Fans (+586) 15,560 Total Twitter Followers (+652) 799 Total Twitter Lists (+44) 1,758 Total Flickr Group Photos (+44) 195 Flickr Group Members (+5) 480 NOTMC Owned Flickr Photos (+280) 606 Total YouTube Subscribers (+22) 105 Blip.fm Listeners (+2) FSC posts roughly 4-6 times every day on Facebook including at least 2 pictures In August we had 546 total posts or 17.6 posts per day on Twitter
Stats on New Orleans On Facebook, NOTMC has anywhere between 6,000 and 7,000 daily active users. In August, there were over 2,000,000 post views on Facebook and over 8,711 interactions on posts. This is according to Facebook Insights.   On Twitter – in the month of August 2011 NOTMC had a daily average of 42.5 interactions on Twitter. This is from Raven.
Highest Engagement Most recently the highest level of engagement was on a photo of Jackson Square - 118 likes and 23 comments on Facebook. Posts like this have the highest engagement levels because they resonate with people – they touch something inside them that makes them yearn to be back in New Orleans. Anyone can post travel deals and information about the city, not everyone can give you a 360 degree view of your city from the inside out.
FacebookOptions Building Fans: NOTMC Facebook Ads   ,[object Object]
Targeting: People who were 21+ in US who are current fans, people in the US who were 21+ who are not fans, people in New Orleans who were 21+ and not fans
Duration: One month
Total clicks on the ads: 6,124
Total Impressions: 10,389,812
Results: Over 50,000 Checkinson the Facebook leader board in less than one month
Total Cost: $3,750,[object Object]
Gaining Facebook Fans FSC created two Facebook Ads to drive traffic to the page, one for people currently connected to the New Orleans by New Orleans Online Facebook Page and one for anyone outside of Louisiana who was not already connected to a New Orleans page. In less just three weeks GoNOLA.com'sFacebook Page had 1,100 new FacebookFans and currently has over 5,700 fans.  $1,000 budget
Building Fans: Hotel Monteleone Facebook Contests   Tool: ShortStack Contest Name: History, Holidays & Hotel Monteleone Prize: Roundtrip airfare for two to New Orleans, two night stay in a suite at the Hotel Monteleone and more. Duration: September 7 – Present (contest ends Nov. 4, 2011) Visits to date: 6,965 Entries to date: 2,148 Total Cost: Free  The contest was built using ShortStack, a free Facebook app that allows for customized tab build out.  Using Facebook and Twitter updates, as well as including it in monthly e-newsletters and on the website, the contest has generated 2,148 entries to date and has helped the Hotel Monteleone gain 1,897 new fans and 246 interactions including Likes and Comments.  We have experienced 0unfollows and engagement continues to grow.

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Fans and Followers for Tourism

Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDaySocial Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
Dawn Crawford
 
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
FSC Interactive
 
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
Hack the Hood
 
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Birmingham Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Birmingham PresentationEmbracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Birmingham Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Birmingham Presentation
brooke.csukas
 
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
Kate Shifman
 
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Kansas City Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Kansas City PresentationEmbracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Kansas City Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Kansas City Presentation
brooke.csukas
 
Mar 14 Social Media For Non Profits
Mar 14  Social Media For Non ProfitsMar 14  Social Media For Non Profits
Mar 14 Social Media For Non Profits
Bill Brower
 
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
leishalecouvie
 
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
Kim Pittaway
 
Social Ministry
Social MinistrySocial Ministry
Social Ministry
Liz Carver
 
Social Media Integration for Non-Profits
Social Media Integration for Non-ProfitsSocial Media Integration for Non-Profits
Social Media Integration for Non-Profits
Mike Schaffer
 

Similar a Fans and Followers for Tourism (20)

Marketing with Social Media
Marketing with Social MediaMarketing with Social Media
Marketing with Social Media
 
Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDaySocial Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
Social Media for Social Good - Raleigh Social Media Day #SMDay
 
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
New Orleans CVB Tourism U March 2012
 
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
Social Media for Social Action: Case studies in campaign planning for social ...
 
How to Build Relationship and Achieve Fundraising Success in a Web 2.0 World
How to Build Relationship and Achieve Fundraising Success in a Web 2.0 WorldHow to Build Relationship and Achieve Fundraising Success in a Web 2.0 World
How to Build Relationship and Achieve Fundraising Success in a Web 2.0 World
 
Social Media for Social Change
Social Media for Social ChangeSocial Media for Social Change
Social Media for Social Change
 
NOLGA: 10 Commandments of Social Media - New Rules for Federations
NOLGA: 10 Commandments of Social Media - New Rules for FederationsNOLGA: 10 Commandments of Social Media - New Rules for Federations
NOLGA: 10 Commandments of Social Media - New Rules for Federations
 
Social Media Presentation as Seen at 2012 Convention
Social Media Presentation as Seen at 2012 ConventionSocial Media Presentation as Seen at 2012 Convention
Social Media Presentation as Seen at 2012 Convention
 
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Birmingham Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Birmingham PresentationEmbracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Birmingham Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Birmingham Presentation
 
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
Chhaya_Presentation KS 1.15.16
 
Healthcare and social media 201
Healthcare and social media 201Healthcare and social media 201
Healthcare and social media 201
 
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Kansas City Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Kansas City PresentationEmbracing Technology As A Nonprofit  Kansas City Presentation
Embracing Technology As A Nonprofit Kansas City Presentation
 
Mar 14 Social Media For Non Profits
Mar 14  Social Media For Non ProfitsMar 14  Social Media For Non Profits
Mar 14 Social Media For Non Profits
 
Using social media to promote your station final
Using social media to promote your station final Using social media to promote your station final
Using social media to promote your station final
 
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
Forman presentationforsmc (2) 2
 
No Stone Unturned: Marketing in a Complex, Twitterific World
No Stone Unturned: Marketing in a Complex, Twitterific WorldNo Stone Unturned: Marketing in a Complex, Twitterific World
No Stone Unturned: Marketing in a Complex, Twitterific World
 
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
The Future is Social: What's Your Strategy?
 
Social Ministry
Social MinistrySocial Ministry
Social Ministry
 
Social Media Integration for Non-Profits
Social Media Integration for Non-ProfitsSocial Media Integration for Non-Profits
Social Media Integration for Non-Profits
 
Sydney social media forum - ACON Health
Sydney social media forum - ACON HealthSydney social media forum - ACON Health
Sydney social media forum - ACON Health
 

Más de FSC Interactive

YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHACYouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
FSC Interactive
 
GHAC Social Media 101 Training
GHAC Social Media 101 TrainingGHAC Social Media 101 Training
GHAC Social Media 101 Training
FSC Interactive
 
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
FSC Interactive
 
Social media channels and stats
Social media channels and statsSocial media channels and stats
Social media channels and stats
FSC Interactive
 

Más de FSC Interactive (20)

FSC Case Study: New Orleans CVB | #beatouristnola
FSC Case Study: New Orleans CVB  | #beatouristnolaFSC Case Study: New Orleans CVB  | #beatouristnola
FSC Case Study: New Orleans CVB | #beatouristnola
 
FSC Case Study: Hotel Monteleone | Social Media Engages Drive Market to Boost...
FSC Case Study: Hotel Monteleone | Social Media Engages Drive Market to Boost...FSC Case Study: Hotel Monteleone | Social Media Engages Drive Market to Boost...
FSC Case Study: Hotel Monteleone | Social Media Engages Drive Market to Boost...
 
FSC Case Study: Tales of the Cocktail | Social Media Contest Gains Desired Au...
FSC Case Study: Tales of the Cocktail | Social Media Contest Gains Desired Au...FSC Case Study: Tales of the Cocktail | Social Media Contest Gains Desired Au...
FSC Case Study: Tales of the Cocktail | Social Media Contest Gains Desired Au...
 
Pay To Play: Using Social Media Ads to Reach Goals #SoMeT14US
Pay To Play: Using Social Media Ads to Reach Goals #SoMeT14USPay To Play: Using Social Media Ads to Reach Goals #SoMeT14US
Pay To Play: Using Social Media Ads to Reach Goals #SoMeT14US
 
Using Social Media to Support Your Event
Using Social Media to Support Your EventUsing Social Media to Support Your Event
Using Social Media to Support Your Event
 
FSC Interactive Facebook Case Study
FSC Interactive Facebook Case StudyFSC Interactive Facebook Case Study
FSC Interactive Facebook Case Study
 
Hoot suite 101
Hoot suite 101Hoot suite 101
Hoot suite 101
 
Social Media Marketing Basics
Social Media Marketing BasicsSocial Media Marketing Basics
Social Media Marketing Basics
 
Using Photos to Optimize Social Media
Using Photos to Optimize Social MediaUsing Photos to Optimize Social Media
Using Photos to Optimize Social Media
 
Bedt training 8 14-13
Bedt training 8 14-13Bedt training 8 14-13
Bedt training 8 14-13
 
How to Optimize PR for Online Media
How to Optimize PR for Online MediaHow to Optimize PR for Online Media
How to Optimize PR for Online Media
 
Optimizing PR Photo Opps on Social Media
Optimizing PR Photo Opps on Social MediaOptimizing PR Photo Opps on Social Media
Optimizing PR Photo Opps on Social Media
 
YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHACYouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
YouTube, Blog & LinkedIn 101 - GHAC
 
GHAC Social Media 101 Training
GHAC Social Media 101 TrainingGHAC Social Media 101 Training
GHAC Social Media 101 Training
 
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
Stirling Social Media Presentation 12-14-12
 
Facebook privacy
Facebook privacyFacebook privacy
Facebook privacy
 
NOEW 2012 presentation
NOEW 2012 presentationNOEW 2012 presentation
NOEW 2012 presentation
 
CRMA and Social Media
CRMA and Social MediaCRMA and Social Media
CRMA and Social Media
 
Twitter Glossary
Twitter GlossaryTwitter Glossary
Twitter Glossary
 
Social media channels and stats
Social media channels and statsSocial media channels and stats
Social media channels and stats
 

Último

sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
Casey Keith
 
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
2022472524
 
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
mountabuangels4u
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
Casey Keith
 

Último (20)

Discover Mathura And Vrindavan A Spritual Journey.pdf
Discover Mathura And Vrindavan A Spritual Journey.pdfDiscover Mathura And Vrindavan A Spritual Journey.pdf
Discover Mathura And Vrindavan A Spritual Journey.pdf
 
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelMathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call GirlsGenuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
 
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingOoty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
 
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call GirlsVIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Independent Call Girls in Darjeeling
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Independent Call Girls in DarjeelingWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Independent Call Girls in Darjeeling
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Independent Call Girls in Darjeeling
 
Bhubaneswar Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Bhubaneswar Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelBhubaneswar Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Bhubaneswar Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
 
Top places to visit, top tourist destinations
Top places to visit, top tourist destinationsTop places to visit, top tourist destinations
Top places to visit, top tourist destinations
 
Alipore Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
Alipore Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service AvailableAlipore Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
Alipore Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
 
Ooty Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Ooty Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelOoty Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Ooty Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
Top travel agency in panchkula - Best travel agents in panchkula
Top  travel agency in panchkula - Best travel agents in panchkulaTop  travel agency in panchkula - Best travel agents in panchkula
Top travel agency in panchkula - Best travel agents in panchkula
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
❤Personal Contact Number Mcleodganj Call Girls 8617697112💦✅.
❤Personal Contact Number Mcleodganj Call Girls 8617697112💦✅.❤Personal Contact Number Mcleodganj Call Girls 8617697112💦✅.
❤Personal Contact Number Mcleodganj Call Girls 8617697112💦✅.
 
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
IATA GEOGRAPHY AREAS in the world, HM111
 
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
Vadodara Escort💋 Call Girl (Bindu) Service #Vadodara Call Girl @Independent G...
 
Kolkata Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
Kolkata Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service AvailableKolkata Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
Kolkata Call Girls - 📞 8617697112 🔝 Top Class Call Girls Service Available
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
 

Fans and Followers for Tourism

  • 1. Discussions on New Orleans tourism accounts in social media
  • 2. “Facebookis a community for people to share & engage with a brand and each other, while Twitter is a constant broadcast that is great for customer service.” “Facebookis cozy night on the couch with good friends. Twitter is a great party full of interesting people to meet.” “Facebookis a mini web portal for your business that can be customized to create a great user experience whileTwitter is an excellent research and broadcast tool for resources and linking to other destinations.” “Facebookis a community that encourages you to stay and explore. Twitter is a tool that sends quick info and links you to out to other communities.”
  • 3. Numbers 37,541 Total Facebook Fans (+586) 15,560 Total Twitter Followers (+652) 799 Total Twitter Lists (+44) 1,758 Total Flickr Group Photos (+44) 195 Flickr Group Members (+5) 480 NOTMC Owned Flickr Photos (+280) 606 Total YouTube Subscribers (+22) 105 Blip.fm Listeners (+2) FSC posts roughly 4-6 times every day on Facebook including at least 2 pictures In August we had 546 total posts or 17.6 posts per day on Twitter
  • 4. Stats on New Orleans On Facebook, NOTMC has anywhere between 6,000 and 7,000 daily active users. In August, there were over 2,000,000 post views on Facebook and over 8,711 interactions on posts. This is according to Facebook Insights.   On Twitter – in the month of August 2011 NOTMC had a daily average of 42.5 interactions on Twitter. This is from Raven.
  • 5.
  • 6. Highest Engagement Most recently the highest level of engagement was on a photo of Jackson Square - 118 likes and 23 comments on Facebook. Posts like this have the highest engagement levels because they resonate with people – they touch something inside them that makes them yearn to be back in New Orleans. Anyone can post travel deals and information about the city, not everyone can give you a 360 degree view of your city from the inside out.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. Targeting: People who were 21+ in US who are current fans, people in the US who were 21+ who are not fans, people in New Orleans who were 21+ and not fans
  • 11. Total clicks on the ads: 6,124
  • 13. Results: Over 50,000 Checkinson the Facebook leader board in less than one month
  • 14.
  • 15. Gaining Facebook Fans FSC created two Facebook Ads to drive traffic to the page, one for people currently connected to the New Orleans by New Orleans Online Facebook Page and one for anyone outside of Louisiana who was not already connected to a New Orleans page. In less just three weeks GoNOLA.com'sFacebook Page had 1,100 new FacebookFans and currently has over 5,700 fans. $1,000 budget
  • 16. Building Fans: Hotel Monteleone Facebook Contests   Tool: ShortStack Contest Name: History, Holidays & Hotel Monteleone Prize: Roundtrip airfare for two to New Orleans, two night stay in a suite at the Hotel Monteleone and more. Duration: September 7 – Present (contest ends Nov. 4, 2011) Visits to date: 6,965 Entries to date: 2,148 Total Cost: Free The contest was built using ShortStack, a free Facebook app that allows for customized tab build out. Using Facebook and Twitter updates, as well as including it in monthly e-newsletters and on the website, the contest has generated 2,148 entries to date and has helped the Hotel Monteleone gain 1,897 new fans and 246 interactions including Likes and Comments. We have experienced 0unfollows and engagement continues to grow.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19. Tool: Wildfire Contest Name: Life, Literature & Hotel Monteleone Prize: Roundtrip airfare for two to New Orleans, two night stay in a literary suite at the Hotel Monteleone and more. Duration: February 1 – April 25, 2011 Visits: 5,403 Entries: 2,324 Total Cost: $300 The contest was built using Wildfire and lived on a customized tab on the Hotel Monteleone’sFacebook wall. Using Facebook and Twitter updates as well as including it in monthly e-newsletters and on the website the contest generated 2,324 entries and gained the Hotel Monteleone 955 new fans and 73 interactions including Likes and Comments. We experienced 0unfollows during that time.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22. Make it a conversation, respond to people and seek out targeted keywords to join the conversations
  • 24. Follow influencers and other travel profiles
  • 25. Integrate the messaging with other social platforms, but customize for Twitter language
  • 26. Be careful about scheduling or not responding
  • 27.
  • 28. McKenzie Coco FSC Interactive 1943 Sophie Wright Place New Orleans, LA 70130 t. 504.894.8011 f. 504.894.8012 www.fscinteractive.com www.facebook/fscinteractive.com @fscnola

Notas del editor

  1. Getting Fans is the easy part, but keeping them is what’s important.  Engagement can create atrophy but cutting the fat isn’t always bad.