Water related issues in the Mekong Basin and Mekong Delta, Nguyen Tat Dac
1. WATER RELATED ISSUES IN
THE MEKONG BASIN AND
MEKONG DELTA
By Prof. Nguyen Tat Dac
Ho Chi Minh City University of
Technology (HUTECH)
2. CONTENT
1. About me
2. Brief background of the Mekong Basin
and Mekong Delta
3. Some Constraints on the development
4. Water related issues:
+ Hydro power dams
+ Water Utilisation (Flood, Salinity)
+ Climate change and MSL rise
5. Development Scenarios
3. ABOUT ME
Full Name: Nguyen Tat Dac
Working for HUTECH as Lecturer
Expertise: + Flow water and water quality
Modelling, Project Manager,
+ Three years (2000-2003) working for MRC as
Head of Working Group 1 on Basin Modeling
and Knoeledge Base, WUP ( funded by WB)
2009 -> Now: Member of State Council for Professor
Title on Water Resources
+ Develop 1D computer program (DELTA) for flow and
water quality in river network
+ Develop 1-2D computer model for simulation of flow and
salinity in case of mean sea level rise of the MK Delta
5. Background (Continued)
Upper Basin: (China-Myanmar)
+ flow contribution: 18%
+ significant hydro-power
potential
Lower Basin:
1)- Thailand (middle): flow
contribution 18%
+ Hydropower and reservoirs
+ significant irrigation development
+ land use changes/ forestry
(impact on water quality)
6. Background (Continued)
Lower Basin (continued):
2)- Laos (middle): flow contribution 35%
+ Hydropower and reservoir potential
+ land use changes/ forestry
(impact on water quality)
3) Cambodia : flow contribution 18%
+ Operation of Great Lake, flood plain
innudation
+ possible hydropower developments
+ increase of irrigation
+ fish migration
8. Background (Continued)
Lower Basin (continued):
4)- Vietnam Delta: flow
contribution 11% & 5% of
the basin area.
+ a dense canal and
embankment system
+ dry season irrigation: salinity
intrusion
+ flood season: long and deep
inundation
+ affected by tide and upstream
changes
Strongly impact by climate
change and Mean Sea
Level rise
11. CONSTRAINTS THE MK DELTA DEVELOPMENTCONSTRAINTS THE MK DELTA DEVELOPMENT
Flooding over an area of aboutFlooding over an area of about 11..4-14-1..99 million ha in the uppermillion ha in the upper
area of the Deltaarea of the Delta
Salinity intrusion over an area of aboutSalinity intrusion over an area of about 11..2-12-1..66 million ha in themillion ha in the
coastal areas with saline density of overcoastal areas with saline density of over 4g/l4g/l
Acid sulfate soils and the spread of acid water over an area ofAcid sulfate soils and the spread of acid water over an area of
aboutabout 11..00 millionmillion haha in the lowland areasin the lowland areas
Shortage of fresh water for production and domestic usesShortage of fresh water for production and domestic uses
over an area of aboutover an area of about 22..11 million ha in areasmillion ha in areas far from rivers,far from rivers,
and close to the coastlineand close to the coastline
Impacts of global climate change to the flow regime in theImpacts of global climate change to the flow regime in the
upstream areas, rainfall, and weather in the Mekong Delta andupstream areas, rainfall, and weather in the Mekong Delta and
threat from sea level rise from the seathreat from sea level rise from the sea..
Lack of food security and low incomes for farmers, lack ofLack of food security and low incomes for farmers, lack of
education of farmers, rapidly increasing populationeducation of farmers, rapidly increasing population
12. CONSTRAINTS FOR THE MK DELTA DEVELOPMENTCONSTRAINTS FOR THE MK DELTA DEVELOPMENT
Surface water pollution caused by agro-chemicals,Surface water pollution caused by agro-chemicals,
industrialization waste discharge, ships navigationindustrialization waste discharge, ships navigation
Drastic changes in land use: Saline-water mangrove forests toDrastic changes in land use: Saline-water mangrove forests to
fresh-water paddy fields, from fresh-water paddy fields tofresh-water paddy fields, from fresh-water paddy fields to
brackish-water shrimp ponds (market control)brackish-water shrimp ponds (market control)
Destruction of fertile land: Fertile land is converted toDestruction of fertile land: Fertile land is converted to
industrial zones, golf coursesindustrial zones, golf courses
Disappearance of biodiversity : traditional ones, “floatingDisappearance of biodiversity : traditional ones, “floating
paddy” (“lúa nổi”), mangrove variety (“xoài cát”) givespaddy” (“lúa nổi”), mangrove variety (“xoài cát”) gives
excellent taste crossed with a high-yield variety but worseexcellent taste crossed with a high-yield variety but worse
tastetaste
Flood and climate risk-related interventions: Creation ofFlood and climate risk-related interventions: Creation of
several canals, dike and embankment, large sluice gatesseveral canals, dike and embankment, large sluice gates
change flow pattern in main stream and overland flow,change flow pattern in main stream and overland flow,
increase water level.increase water level.
14. Tides & impacts:
Dry season: Impact the whole
MD.
80% by the East Sea;
20% by the West Sea.
Flood season:
Impact >54% of MD.
Tide from the East Sea:
Semi-diurnal tidal.
Big amplitude (2.5-4.0 m).
Tide from the West Sea:
Mixed and liked-duirnal tidal.
Small amplitude (0.8-1.2 m).
H
17. The potential for hydropower
development in the Mekong basin
The total potential hydropower in the four Lower Mekong
Basin countries is approximately 30,000 megawatts (MW).
Of this, 13,000 MW are on the Mekong’s mainstream,
and the remaining potential is in the tributaries 13,000
MW on tributaries in Lao PDR,
2,200 MW on tributaries in Cambodia and 2,000 MW on
tributaries in Viet Nam.
only 5 percent (some 1,600 MW) of the Lower Mekong’s
hydro potential have been developed, and all projects are
on the tributaries.
There is considerable hydro potential in the Upper
Mekong Basin. In Yunnan Province of the People’s
Republic of China, total hydro potential is an estimated
23,000 MW, and two projects, totalling 2,850 MW, have
already begun
20. HCM City Mar 2017
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
Jia Ba
Tuo Ba
Manwan
Xiaowan
Mengsong
Ganlanba
Jinghong
Nuozhadu
Tiemenkan
Hyang Deng
Dachaoshan
Gongguaqiao
Si Chia Gang
Wu Long Long
Liu Teng Jian
CHINA
VIET NAM
MYANMAR
INDIA
China
Dams
China
Dams
21. Hydropower dam : Lower Sesan 2
Capacity : 400MW;Height: about 40m (from river bed)
Length: 8km; Reservoir size: 33,500ha
Estimated cost: 816 million USD; start building: 2014
22.
23. POSITVE IMPACT OF HYDROPOWERS
Harnessing of a renewable natural resource
Reducing of the negative impacts that power
generation has on the global environment (for
example, reducing the use of fossil fuels will lessen air
and water pollution)
Increasing the river’s flow in the dry season, and
reducing peak flow during the flood season
Increasing the availability of electrical power will
stimulate economic development and
Improve people’s living standards
Revenues will be earned from the sale of power
24. NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF HYDROPOWER
Adverse impacts on the ecosystem (aquatic life, animals,
birds, vegetation)
Blocking of the flow of sediment
Negative impacts due to changing a river’s flow pattern
Negative social impacts (resettlement, loss of livelihood)
Loss of scenic landscapes (tourism potential)
Negative impacts on water quality due to storage of water
(eutrophication, lower temperatures for discharged water)
Negative impacts on other users of water (navigation,
fisheries)
Problems during the construction period (noise, vibration,
dust, traffic problems)
25. FLOWFLOW
Some cumulativeSome cumulative
downstreamdownstream
impacts of regulationimpacts of regulation
1) Dry season flows are1) Dry season flows are
modified to a farmodified to a far
greater extent than wetgreater extent than wet
2) The impacts on the2) The impacts on the
dry season hydrologydry season hydrology
are significant rightare significant right
down the mainstreamdown the mainstream
3) Impacts on the flood3) Impacts on the flood
season hydrology areseason hydrology are
significant until thesignificant until the
large tributaries enterlarge tributaries enter
downstream of Vientianedownstream of Vientiane
34. Flood characteristics in the upper part of Kratie
From June to November
Highest: August
-September
Mountainous, high-land
fast downstream
Most from middle basin
Kratie
35. Flood characteristics in the upper part of Kratie (continued)
Ch.Saen Vientiane Muk. Pakse Kratie
June 2490 3576 7136 8906 11031
Jul 4710 7100 14299 16981 22968
Aug 6800 12330 22118 27231 36587
Sep 5630 11297 21493 27551 38671
Oct 3840 6955 12412 16790 23931
Nov 2560 4025 6228 8330 11685
Discharge during flood season
36. Flood characteristics in the upper part of Kratie
(continued)
Probability of flood peak occurrence
Chiang Saen Pakse Kratie
Jul 4 0 0
Aug 76 51 38
Sep 20 49 61
Oct 0 0 1
Nov 0 0 0
37. Flood characteristics at Kratie
Mainly from middle part
Many peaks
Peak usually in September
Highest discharges (m3/s):
+ 1937: 64400
+ 1939: 66700
+ 1961: 62400
+ 1991: 60800
+ 1996: 64600
+ 2000: 64000
Kratie
39. Flood from Kratie to Vietnam-Cambodia border
Flood plains expanded in both
sides of the MK river
Regulation of the Great Lake (%)
Flood
season
June July Aug Sep
To G.Lake 10.1 16.2 19.0 12.1
Down. 89.9 83.8 81.0 87.9
Dry Season Oct Nov Dec Jan
From G.Lake
16.0 42.7
53.2 53.8
From Kratie 84.0 57.3 46.8 46.2
41. A dense man-made canals
Embankment & road
system
Moderate but long duration
Entire North part flooded
Flooding caused by
overland flow from border
(~80% in the main stream)
Tide influence
Characteristics of Flood in the VN Delta
42. In the main stream:
35,405 m3/s &
351.0 billion m3
On the right side:
2,541 m3/s &
14.3 billion m3
On the left side:
13,873 m3/s &
89.0 billion m3
Flow distribution of the flood 2000 to the
VN MeKong Delta
57. Changes of WL at Chiang Saen in the dry season of 2016
58. WATER ISSUES RELATED TO
TOPOGRAPHY,
HYDOMETEOROLOGY
CONDITIONS AND
DEVELOPMENTS OF THE
MEKONG BASIN
59. 59
Factors Impacted on Flood
Upstream Reservoirs make Reduction of
flood down to the Delta (normal Operation)
and Increasing (full reservoirs, big flood).
Construction of Dam at Tonle Sap may
change flow (in-out) to the Reservoir
Increase flood water level
Change of river bottom (erosion, deposition)
Change flow regime
Embankement, Road, :
CPC: Increasing flow in the main stream
VN: Increase local water level,
…..
60. HCM City Mar 2017
QL 91
QL 30
QL 54
Gates at river
mouths
Sea dykes
Sea dykes
Sea dyke GC-
VT
River dykes
HTTL Nam
HTTL
QL-PH
Topo-changes
Sluice gates along
MK, Bassac and
Cam-VN border
61. Flood control in the Long Xuyen Qudrangle
Vaøm Raêng
32,5m; -4
Coáng Soá 8; 7,5m,
66. MEAN SEA LEVEL RISE
Rate of global MSL rise (IPCC 2013 Climate
Change 2013:)
1901-2010 : 19cm- with average rate
1,7mm/year
1993-2010 : 3,2 mm/year
MSLR based on some scenaios:
By the end of 2100 (compared to1986-2005)
RCP4.5 tăng từ 36 ÷ 71cm (minimum)
RCP8.5 tăng từ 52 ÷ 98cm (maximum)
68. Sea level has risen about 20 cm over the last 50 years
Sea level rise in Vietnam
-30.0
-20.0
-10.0
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
DH(cm)
Thời gian (năm)
DHmax DHmean DHmin Linear (DHmax) Linear (DHmean) Linear (DHmin)
Source: Sea Level data at Hon Dau Station
69. Some
Evidence
on MSLR
along
coastal
areas of VN
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Bãi Cháy
-20.0
-15.0
-10.0
-5.0
0.0
5.0
10.0
1962 1966 1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Hòn Dáu
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
1966 1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Cồn Cỏ
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
1991 1995 1999 2003 2007
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Cửa Việt
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Sơn Trà
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Quy Nhơn
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
1993 1996 1999 2002 2005 2008
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Phú QUýháy
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Phú Quốc
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Rạch Giá
-20.0
-15.0
-10.0
-5.0
0.0
5.0
10.0
1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
Xu thế mực nước biển trung bình năm trạm Vũng Tàu
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006
Năm
Mựcnước(cm)
70. 70
Water level rise
Source: SIWRR (Khang ND, 2016)
Increasing of water levelceI
Station Period
Increasing WL
(mm/year)
Vũng
Tàu
1980-2015 4.85
Gành
Hào
1996-2015 16.6
2000-2015 19.6
Sông
Đốc
1996-2015 13.3
2000-2015 11
Rạch
Giá
1996-2015 2.9
2000-2015 5.3
76. Salinity in Jan&Feb 2050 at 8 river mouths of the MK Delta
(Normal and MSL rise)
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
Vàm Kênh Bình Đại AnThuận BếnTrại MỹThanh GànhHào Ông Đốc Biện Nhị RạchGiá
River mouths
MaxSalinity(g/L)
T150 T150BT T2-50BT T2_50NBD
77. Salinity at 8 river mouths in Mar & Apr 2050 of the MK Delta
(Normal and MSL rise)
10
15
20
25
30
35
VàmKênh Bình Đại An Thuận Bến Trại Mỹ Thanh Gành Hào Ông Đốc Biện Nhị Rạch Giá
River mouths
Salinitymax(g/L)
T3_50BT T3_50NBD T4_50BT T4_50NBD
78. Salinity at 8 river mouths in May & June 2050 of the MK Delta
(Normal and MSL rise)
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
VàmKênh BìnhĐại AnThuận BếnTrại Mỹ Thanh GànhHào ÔngĐốc BiệnNhị RạchGiá
River mouths
Salinitymax(g/L)
T5_50BT T5_50_NBD T6_50BT T6_50NBD
79. Max Salinity along the Vaico river in March and April 2050
(Normal and MSL rise)
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Ngã ba VàmCỏ Soài Rạp
Salinity
T3-50BT T3-50NBD T4-50BT T4-50NBD
81. Scenarios for developmentScenarios for development
1.1. Baseline conditionsBaseline conditions
2.2. Impact of climate changeImpact of climate change
3.3. Impact of catchment cover changeImpact of catchment cover change
4.4. Impact of high irrigation demand growthImpact of high irrigation demand growth
5.5. Impact of dams/reservoirsImpact of dams/reservoirs
6.6. Impact of flood control structuresImpact of flood control structures
7.7. Impact of salinity control structuresImpact of salinity control structures
8.8. Impact of navigation improvementImpact of navigation improvement
9.9. Impacts of various development orImpacts of various development or
conservation strategiesconservation strategies
10.10. etc …etc …
89. Scenarios for developmentScenarios for development
1.1. Baseline conditionsBaseline conditions
2.2. Impact of climate changeImpact of climate change
3.3. Impact of catchment cover changeImpact of catchment cover change
4.4. Impact of high irrigation demand growthImpact of high irrigation demand growth
5.5. Impact of dams/reservoirsImpact of dams/reservoirs
6.6. Impact of flood control structuresImpact of flood control structures
7.7. Impact of salinity control structuresImpact of salinity control structures
8.8. Impact of navigation improvementImpact of navigation improvement
9.9. Impacts of various development orImpacts of various development or
conservation strategiesconservation strategies
10.10. etc …etc …
90. WATER RELATED ISSUES FOR BASIN DEVELOPMENTS
(China, Thailand, Lao PDR, Cambodia)
91. SCENARIOS
Looking into 3 assumptions of changes:Looking into 3 assumptions of changes:
Climatic conditions:Climatic conditions:
System demand:System demand:
Change of water demand in and off-streamChange of water demand in and off-stream
Interventions:Interventions:
Change of irrigated areaChange of irrigated area
Change of forest coverageChange of forest coverage
New dams/reservoirs in the areaNew dams/reservoirs in the area
Embankment structure for flood controlEmbankment structure for flood control
Salinity control structuresSalinity control structures
New strategy on rice productionNew strategy on rice production
New strategy for fisheries developmentNew strategy for fisheries development
New strategy for energy productionNew strategy for energy production
Revised strategies on environment protectionRevised strategies on environment protection