2. Truth Campaign (p. 342)
Started in the late 1990s to prevent teen
smoking
Analysts claim Truth has been a success
because the creators take time to
understand & engage with the target
audience
In other words, the campaign honors the
rebellious disposition of teenagers,
something previous campaigns failed to
account for
Quote on p. 343 – “We’re not here to blow
sunshine…We’re not here to preach. We’re
here to make sure everyone gets
unfiltered...facts about...”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAhAz7JU0dg
3. Four Fundamental Principles
Know your
audience
Take action
when words
aren’t
enough
Establish
goals and
measure
success
Encourage
social support
for healthy
behaviors
4. Planning A Health Campaign
1. Defining the situation and potential benefits
2. Analyzing and segmenting the audience
3. Establishing campaign goals and objectives
4. Selecting channels of communication
5. Designing campaign messages
6. Piloting and implementing the campaign
7. Evaluating and maintaining the campaign
5. Background on Health Campaigns
Early campaigns designed with confidence that
humans want nothing so much as their health and
longevity
If behavior is unhealthy, stop doing it
Go to great lengths to pursue health-enhancing
outcomes
Thus, persuasion was not needed, only reliable
information
Motivation assumed to already be there
If so, persuasion is a mute point
Modifying behaviors is not this simple
7. Step 1 (p. 347)
Benefits What are the benefits your efforts will achieve?
What is research saying?
Are there some who would not benefit?
Current
situation
Assess the current situation – How many people currently
participate in recommended behavior?
Tap into various sources for information
Diverse
motivations
Health concerns not only motivation
Why perform a behavior?
Different audiences have different reasons
8. Step 2 (p. 348)
Audience analysis is
key
Data collection
Gather various
information via
different methods to
know your audience
Don’t rule out existing
data with what is
already tangible to
learn about your
audience’s beliefs,
values, and habits
Interviews
Questionnaires
Focus groups
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMwx
WHaZUro (Classic Egg Smashing PSA)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SfUW
m33EM8 (Milk Ad – Palm Oil)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l7ljxDjw
DjU (Texting & Driving)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QT8Bh
Zp4cs (Teen Pregnancy)
9. Step 2 Approaches
Look at all your data and find the best target group
Once you have target, fill in the blank about this target;
feelings, attitudes, perceived benefits, media habits;
imagine target as a person
Audiences carry with them some general characteristics that
will help you to understand target better
Young audiences: look at developmental stages and see
where your population falls; some predictive behaviors and
thought patterns
Personal fable: Adolescents think they are unlike others
and others do not understand them
10. Sensation Seeking Behaviors
Activation model for information exposure
Persuasive messages will be most effective
when they stimulate an optimal amount of
arousal in the reader/viewer; “optimal” not
the same for all
Sensation-seekers: people who enjoy new and
intense experiences; More impulsive
“The little prick” advertisement for HIV
testing
More young adults/adolescents
Risk (or perhaps danger) appeals to them
Sometimes hard to target this audience without
offending others
11. Informing The Audience
Underinformed audiences
Many audiences who are underinformed may also
unfortunately not receive campaign information
Need greater concerted efforts to reach them
Dissemination is critical
Use of mass media more associated with being
informed; social capital
Benefits possible when members of community build
positive social connections and mutual sense of trust
12. Step 3
What do you want to achieve with campaign?
Be clear
e.g., For people to understand the risks of smoking,
depression, texting & driving, etc.
What do you want people to start/stop/continue
doing?
How will you measure success and determine
accountability?
13. How To Motivate Individuals To Attend To Health Messages
Use Novel Messages, Settings, And Media;
Consider Discrepant And Unexpected Messages, Settings, And Media;
Instruct The Audience To Pay Attention To The Message;
Construct Messages In A Denotatively Specific Manner; Choose Spatially
Immediate Demonstratives;
Use Temporally Immediate Speech;
Avoid Qualifiers; Use Probabilities Associated With Specific Outcomes Of
Certain Behaviors
14. Step 4 (p. 359)
Channel: means of
communicating information
directly or indirectly
What does your audience
most likely use and trust?
Channel characteristics
Reach
Number of people exposed
Specificity
How accurately message can be
targeted to specific group
Impact
How persuasive is the message?
Narrowcasting
Tailored to reach
specific people
Doctor visit
Tailored messages
People ask for or need
specific things; might
complete a survey for
information
List of specific foods
for lowering
cholesterol
15. Diffusion of Innovations (p. 361)
New information is filtered, passed
along through the community
It seeks to explain how information is
shared in social communities
Diffusion – Process of communication
Innovation – Idea perceived as new by
individual(s)
Time: How much time is required to
expect changes in behaviors?
Individual will seek information from
various sources
Rate of Adoption – How quickly will
people adopt the innovation?
Consideration of advantages, ease of
use, compatibility (with goals)
16. Elaboration Likelihood Model
When we are highly involved with the message, we are more likely
to think critically about the information being presented
Central & Peripheral Routes
We remember high-involvement messages longer than others
and are more likely to act upon them
People who use high-involvement channels are usually better
informed about health than those using low-involvement
channels
Motivation Involvement
18. ELM & Motivation
Motivation Involvement
Route to
Take?
“There are stable individual differences
in intrinsic motivation to engage in
cognitive endevours” (Petty, Cacioppo,
Kao, & Rodriguez, 1986, p. 1032).
19. Designing The Message
Choose a Voice for Your Campaign
Imagine target audience as one
“person”
What is his/her personality and mood?
Friendly or authoritarian?
Logical or emotional?
Will audience respond to this person?
Look for voice that audience will trust
20. Designing The Message
Does message rely on logic or
emotion? Often, if not always, it will
be blend both of these…
Does message promote positive
rewards or negative rewards?
Is the theme confidence, self esteem,
fear, etc. ?
Is message novel or shocking?
Novel – new; shocking – intense or
improper
21. Designing The Message
Evaluation
Conduct pretest and posttest
Study behavior changes
Look at what doesn’t happen
ie: drug use
Maintenance
People more likely to continue
behavior when benefits are fully
understood
23. Health Belief Model
The level of their personal
susceptibility
Are the adverse effects
considerable?
Are the benefits worthwhile?
Are the costs justifiable?
Have they experienced a
compelling warning or alluring
incentive?
The HBM contains
several constructs that
are hypothesized to
predict why people
engage in prevention,
screening, and/or
controlling health
conditions.
24. TRA/TPB
People make decisions based
on:
How strongly they believe
behavior will lead to positive
outcome
The perceived social
implications of behavior
Know beliefs, add salient
beliefs, change current belief
evaluation/strength
Change normative belief (e.g.
perceived expectations of an
attitudes), change motivation
to comply
Attitudes toward a specific
action
What will happen if I
engage in this
behavior?
Is this outcome
desirable or
undesirable
Subjective norms regarding
that action
Normative beliefs:
others expectations
Motivation to comply:
do I want to do what
they tell me? How
much? Why?
26. TTM Theory (p. 370)
Transtheoretical Model
Says people change in 5 stages
1. Precontemplation- not aware of problem
2. Contemplation- thinking about problem
3. Preparation- deciding to take action
4. Action- making a change
5. Maintenance –Sticking to change for 6 months +
27. TTM Model Cont. (pp. 370-371)
People react differently to health promotion efforts
depending on their current stage
Need to gauge and plan accordingly with
campaign
Wise to seek incremental changes rather than
radical changes
People will not automatically overhaul behavior
with every piece of information
28. Critical Cultural Approach (p. 372)
Cognitive models share common focus: Treat health
as product of choices we make as individuals
Acknowledge choices influenced by range of
factors
Critical-cultural approach (Dutta): proposed that
health is not merely the result of individual choices,
but intertwined with issues of culture, power,
control, identity, and social consciousness
More pervasive than any one individual
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=chXsLtHqf
dM
29. EPPM
Extended Parallel Process Model (Witte)
If people are anxious they avoid subject
People evaluate threatening message (first) to
determine if they are personally at risk and (second)
to judge whether they can prevent a harmful
outcome
If they perceive a risk, but feel they can’t avoid bad
outcome, they will soothe their anxiety by avoiding the
issue
30. EPPM (p. 372)
Specificity – Variables problematic
Predictive Power Other theories lacked this
Success v. Failure No prediction when
campaigns could succeed or fail
Complex!
It started getting kids in H.S. trying to brush teeth!
Witte (1992) came along and tried to investigate
why health campaigns succeeded or failed…
31. Pilot The Campaign
Piloting: selecting members from the target
audience to review campaign and comment on
materials
Written messages easy to read
and understand?
Recorded messages easy to understand?
Relevant and important?
Appealing?
Spokesperson effective?
Information controversial or offensive?
32. Evaluate & Maintain
Requires campaign managers to
evaluate success of project,
help community members
maintain any positive changes
made, and refine and develop
future campaign messages
Evaluation
Pretest-posttest design
Survey people before and after
campaign for attitude, knowledge,
and action change
Study actual behavior changes
Sometimes success occurs by what
does not happen over time
Maintenance
• Continued
encouragement and
skills training
• People need continued
education
Encouragement,
incentives, and
continued skills training
can help overcome
setback that may occur
Notas del editor
High involvement: Audience sees relevance in their own life
Low Involvement: Audience does not see the connection to their own life
ELM essentially predicts that people have different abilities and motivations, which affect their likelihood to consider, and mode of processing a persuasive message
This image shows peripheral and central route paths to persuasion
People will differ in how they process a message
Example:
Tuition cost hike in 10 years not as relevant if it is in the immediate future
Also not as relevant if it is at another University.
As involvement increases, the likelihood participants will elaborate increases (Petty & Cacioppo, 1990)
Useful to survey people before and after campaign for changes in attitudes, knowledge, and intentions
Do follow-up survey to see how much they remember
Refine anything necessary after pilot
Distribute message through chosen channels
May have direct contact with community
Also rely on others to share messages
Sometimes unintended or undesirable consequences
Audiences turned off by message, avoid subject or lose interest in sender
For better or worse, try to evaluate the reach (number of people exposed to campaign message) and specificity (type of people exposed to campaign)
Can survey those necessary for results
Continued encouragement and skills training
People need continued education to fully understand benefits and reasons for behaviors
Encouragement, incentives, and continued skills training can help overcome setback that may occur