2. Wanting What You Can’t Have
•A Scientific Theory Can’t Give You:
• Theological or metaphysical truths
• An ethical or moral system
• The meaning of life !
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
3. Wanting What You Can’t Have
•A Scientific Theory Can’t Give You:
• Theological or metaphysical truths
• An ethical or moral system
• The meaning of life !
• A Good Scientific Theory Can:
• Reveal connections between seemingly disparate facts
• Motivate and guide a research program
• Predict new observations
• Answer one question and create two new ones
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
4. Biological
Evolution
Background and Basics
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
15. What is responsible
for all of this variety
in life forms?
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
16. Three Pre-Darwinian Beliefs
About Evolution
Special Creation
• Species created
independently. Unrelated to
each other
• Unchanging - created as
you see it right now
• Young Earth - 6000 years
old
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
17. Three Pre-Darwinian Beliefs
About Evolution
Special Creation Random Assembly
• Species created • Random
independently. Unrelated to
each other • Changing
• Unchanging - created as • Species related but
you see it right now random variations
• Young Earth - 6000 years on ancestral forms
old
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
18. Three Pre-Darwinian Beliefs
About Evolution
Special Creation Random Assembly
• Species created • Random
independently. Unrelated to
each other • Changing
• Unchanging - created as • Species related but
you see it right now random variations
• Young Earth - 6000 years on ancestral forms
old Lamark
• Evolution by necessity
• Acquired Characteristics
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
25. Random Generation of
Organisms is Mathematically
Implausible and Inconsistent
with Observed Order within
Ecosystems
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
26. Lamark
Lamarck's evolution theory of the early 1800's (before Darwin)
proposed that species evolved by necessity. According to Lamarck's
theory, for example, a short-necked giraffe initiates evolution of a longer
neck out of perceived necessity.
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
27. Darwin’s Alternative to Special
Creation, Acquired
Characteristics, and Random
Assembly
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
28. Basics of Natural Selection
n Variation in traits between members of a
species
n Some traits are passed across generations
(heritability)
n Some heritable traits affect reproductive
success
n Those traits gradually become more frequent
in a population
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
29. Basics of Natural Selection
n Variation in traits between members of a
species
n Some traits are passed across generations
(heritability)
n Some heritable traits affect reproductive
success
n Those traits gradually become more frequent
in a population
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
35. Basics of Natural Selection
n Variation in traits between members of a
species
n Some traits are passed across generations
(heritability)
n Some heritable traits affect reproductive
success
n Those traits gradually become more frequent
in a population
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
41. Humans selectively breed
plants and animals for certain
traits.
Nature automatically engages
in a selective breeding
program
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
43. Basics of Natural Selection
n Variation in traits between members of a
species
n Some traits are passed across generations
(heritability)
n Some heritable traits affect survival and
reproductive success
n Those traits gradually become more frequent
in a population
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
51. Basics of Natural Selection
n Variation in traits between members of a
species
n Some traits are passed across generations
(heritability)
n Some heritable traits affect survival and
reproductive success
n Those traits gradually become more frequent
in a population
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
52. • Antibiotic Resistant
Bacteria
• Influenza
• Alcoholic Fruit Flies
• Lactose Tolerant
Adult Humans
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
53. Basic Implications
• Ecosystem: Organisms are all part of a highly
interconnected web of life.
– When one variable changes, new survival
challenges spread through the system and drive
selection.
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
54. Basic Implications
• Ecosystem: Organisms are all part of a highly
interconnected web of life.
– When one variable changes, new survival
challenges spread through the system and drive
selection.
• Subtle factors drive big effects because
biological changes are cumulative.
– Compound interest
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
55. Basic Implications
• Ecosystem: Organisms are all part of a highly
interconnected web of life.
– When one variable changes, new survival
challenges spread through the system and drive
selection.
• Subtle factors drive big effects because
biological changes are cumulative.
– Compound interest
• Complexity emerges from the application of
simple laws
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
56. Summary
• Darwin Provided an Alternative to Uniformitarianism
and Random Assembly Accounts of Species.
• Natural Selection
• Same Underlying Inheritance and Variation
Mechanisms that Enable Domestic Selection
• Struggle for life
• Variation of characteristics
• Differences in reproductive success
• Inheritance
• Gradual, Cumulative Change
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
57. Closing Comments
Natural Selection is Silent on Issues Related to
Theology, Metaphysics, Ethics, Morality, and the
Meaning of Life.
Scientific theories:
Motivate research programs - answer one question
and create two.
Connect disparate facts
Predict observations
Wednesday, June 2, 2010