Ambient Air Quality Monitoring in Southern Alberta
1. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
in Southern Alberta
November 19, 2014
Frauke Spurrell
Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development
2. Presentation Overview
• What is ambient air quality?
• Why do we monitor ambient air?
• What is monitored?
• Who conducts air monitoring?
• How is ambient air monitored?
• Where is the monitoring conducted?
• What is the data showing us?
• Research and special studies
2
3. What is ambient air quality?
• Ambient air quality refers to the quality of
outdoor air in our surrounding environment
• Air quality can be quantified by
concentrations of substances identified
through monitoring
– It is typically measured near ground level, away from
direct sources of pollution
3
4. What is ambient air quality?
• Types of emission sources impacting air
quality include:
– Anthropogenic
• Transportation (motor vehicles, rail, air)
• Heating (residential, commercial, wood burning)
• Industry (oil and gas, forestry, construction, electrical
generation, aggregate etc.)
• Agriculture (confined feeding operations, tilling)
– Biogenic (vegetation)
– Natural events
(forest fires, grass fires)
4
5. Why do we monitor ambient air?
• To ensure there is no adverse effect from
licensed activity emissions (industry)
• To provide information for the management of
cumulative effects 5
6. Why do we monitor ambient air?
• To provide assurance to stakeholder
communities
• To provide a tool for the community to ‘plan a
healthy day’
6
7. What is monitored?
• Any compound that is measurable and is
known to have impact on the ecosystem and
human health
• Measured concentrations are compared to
Alberta Ambient Air Quality Objectives
(AAAQOs) and/or Canadian Ambient Air
Quality Standards (CAAQS)
– AAAQOs are developed under the Alberta
Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act
(EPEA) for all of the province to protect Alberta’s air
quality
– Objectives are based on an evaluation of scientific,
social, technical, and economic factors
7
8. What is monitored?
• An example of what is monitored at the
Lethbridge ambient air monitoring station
8
Carbon Monoxide Wind Speed
Sulphur Dioxide Wind Direction
Hydrogen Sulphide Std. Dev. of Wind Direction
Nitric Oxide Outdoor Air Temperature
Nitrogen Dioxide Relative Humidity
Total Oxides Of Nitrogen
Ammonia
Total Hydrocarbons
Non-methane Hydrocarbons
Methane
Ozone
PM2.5 Mass
Air Quality Health Index
9. Who conducts
ambient air
monitoring?
• Alberta Environmental
Monitoring, Evaluation
and Reporting Agency
(AEMERA)
• Alberta Airshed
Organizations
• Industry
• Environment Canada
9
10. How is ambient air monitored?
10
• Permanent monitoring
can be:
– Continuous
• Near instantaneous
measurements
• Costly due to capital
and operating costs
• Require power and
road access
Image source: FOCUS Corp
11. How is ambient air monitored?
11
Image source: PAS www.palliserairshed.com
Image source: PAMZ www.PAMZ.org
• Or permanent monitoring can
be:
– Passive
• Long-term measurements (monthly)
• Portable, user friendly, cost effective
12. How is ambient air monitored?
12
• Temporary monitoring
can include:
– Mobile Air Monitoring
Laboratory (MAML)
– Portable Air monitoring
(PAML)
– E-BAM (Particulate matter)
– Air Pointer
– Canister
(Volatile Organic Compounds)
13. How is ambient air monitored?
• If data is supplied to ESRD/AEMERA:
– monitoring must follow requirements in the Alberta Air
Monitoring Directive (AMD)
• Ensures consistency, use of proper technology, siting
requirements etc.
• Allows for quality assurance and comparability of data
13
14. How is ambient air monitored?
• Data from the AEMERA and airshed stations
are submitted to the CASA Data Warehouse
• Industry submits data directly to ESRD or
Alberta Energy Regulator
14
http://www.casadata.org/
15. Source: Ambient Air Monitoring Network Assessment of The South Saskatchewan Region, 2014 STI Technologies (http://esrd.alberta.ca/air/reports-
data/documents/AmbientAirMonitoringSouthSaskatchewan-2014.pdf)
Where are the ambient air monitoring stations in
Southern Alberta?
15
20. Research: Monitoring Network
Assessment for Southern Alberta
• The existing network was analyzed to identify
whether the monitoring objectives are being met
• Monitoring objectives included:
– monitoring for Ambient Air Quality Objectives (AAAQO)
and Environment Protection and Enhancement Act
(EPEA) compliance
– National Air Pollution Surveillance (NAPS) program and
Canadian Ambient Air Quality Standards (CAAQS)
reporting requirements
– implementation of regional plans and cumulative effects
– management needs: identification of pollutant trends and
spatial distributions etc.
20
Study available at: http://esrd.alberta.ca/air/reports-data/documents/AmbientAirMonitoringSouthSaskatchewan-2014.pdf
21. Research: Monitoring Network
Assessment for Southern Alberta
• Data used for analyzing a monitoring network:
– Measured concentrations
– Emissions (industrial, urban, biogenic)
– Area, topography, land-use
– Existing stations
– Population
21
23. Research: Emissions modelling
• In areas without monitoring data concentrations can be
predicted through modelling
– Air Quality Modelling Exercise using Community
Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) Model for Southern Alberta
• 2006-2008 base case year with 2020 and 2050 future
predictions
• Modelled: O3, PM, total VOCs, NO2, SO2, NH3, CO, wet and
dry deposition
Study available at: http://environment.gov.ab.ca/info/library/8875.pdf
AAAQOCMAQ estimated NO2 Concentrations 2006-2008 CMAQ estimated future NO2 Concentrations 2020
Good air quality refers to clean, clear, unpolluted air.
Clean air is essential to maintaining the delicate balance of life on this planet — not just for humans, but wildlife, vegetation, water and soil.
Poor air quality is a result of a number of factors, including emissions from various sources, both natural and “human-caused.”
Poor air quality occurs when pollutants reach high enough concentrations to endanger human health and/or the environment.
Ambient monitoring requirements through Environmental Protection Enhancement Act approvals
Monitoring to support Air Quality Frameworks through South Saskatchewan Regional Plan, national Air Quality Management system
ESRD works with a variety of stakeholders, including other government departments, the scientific community, environmental organizations, industry and the general public to prioritize substances and to review Objectives and Guidelines
Pollutants on the left, meteorological conditions on right
Of note: this station monitors ammonia (unlike other urban stations) due to the higher concentration of CFO’s in the vicinity
AEMERA, relatively new (transition still occurring), took over ESRD stations and monitoring staff/equipment. (5 Stations)
Airsheds – grass roots organizations, monitor on behalf of AEMERA/ESRSD and industry as well as their own stations (~56 stations)
Industry – as part of EPEA approval requirements to ensure they are in compliance (almost 100 stations)
EC – Research stations: Esther GHGs, LacLabiche
Images show examples of monitoring stations
Note: the infrastructure required for the continuous station (road access, power, building, expensive analyzers) versus the passive station (no power, attached to fence post)
Images show examples of monitoring stations
Note: the infrastructure required for the continuous station (road access, power, building, expensive analyzers) versus the passive station (no power, attached to fence post)
MAML – provides continuous measurements, often used for emergency response i.e., dump fire, train derailment
PAML – often runs on generator, not sustainable for extended periods…
Canisters take samples that are sent into the lab for analysis
Airpointer – can monitor up to ~7 compounds
The data on the casadatawarehouse is accessible to the public
Annual average NO2 concentrations have generally remained constant or decreased since 2004
The decreasing trend in NO2 is consistent across the province and is mainly a result of improvements in industrial and vehicle emission controls. It is anticipated that NO2 levels will continue to decline as technology improves and alternate fuel sources are explored.
Ground level O3 is not directly emitted, but is a secondary pollutant, and formed from other emissions like NOx and VOCs reacting with sunlight…O3 season in summer
Annual average O3 concentrations have remained relatively constant since 2004.
Very low SO2 concentrations, often near detection limit
Annual average PM2.5 concentrations increased at all monitoring stations after 2009. This change is largely a result of new PM2.5 monitoring technology being implemented in the province in 2009. The new technology captures a more complete sample of PM2.5 and therefore results in a larger recorded concentration than previously.
While the trend has increased, it does not necessarily represent a change in air quality. Data from the new technology does however give a more accurate representation of ambient air quality with respect to PM2.5.
Lower concentrations than larger urban centre i.e., Calgary or Edmonton
Considers all factors: area, population emissions served.
Map does not show industrial stations; note optimal locations around Shell Waterton Plant
CMAQ air quality modelling done for 2006-2008 base case years and 2020/2050 future
Future projections based on forecasted anthropogenic emissions
Overall hot spots remained where they were
Emission factor issues did result in over predictions, but generally the results showed that PM2.5 would experience the greatest increase
Consistent with what has occurred in other areas nationally, and why it is one of the first substances the national AQMS system