SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 24
Descargar para leer sin conexión
The Five Minds of a
Manager
Jonathan Gosling and Henry Mintzberg
HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW November 2003
The Five Managerial Mind-Sets
• the reflective mind-set
• the analytic mind-set
• the worldly mind-set
• the collaborative mind-
set
• the action mind-set
The Need for Reflective Mind-Set
Everything that every effective manager
does is sandwiched between action on
the ground and reflection in the
abstract. Action without reflection is
thoughtless; reflection without action is
passive.
ManagingSelf:TheReflectiveMind-Set
Reflection
Vision
Reflection
Events
Experience
The Need for Reflective Mind-Set
Managers need to step
back from the pressures
of their jobs and reflect
thoughtfully on their
experiences.
The Reflective Mind-Set
- Most people do not accumulate a
body of experience. Most people
go through life undergoing a
series of happenings, which pass
through their systems undigested.
- Happenings become experiences
when they are digested, when
they are reflected on, related to
general patterns, and synthesized.
The Reflective Mind-Set
The Reflective Mind-Set
society (history, economy, ethics,
spirituality)
organization (culture, structure,
knowledge)
relationships (with others, with groups)
job (managerial work, managing self,
managing time)
self (experience, style)
The Analytical Mind-Set
Good analysis provides a language for organizing; it
allows people to share an understanding of what is
driving their efforts; it provides measures for
performance.
And organizational structure itself is fundamentally
analytic- it is a means of decomposition to establish
the division of labor.
They analyzed the analyses of others- where these
people were coming from, what data and
assumptions they were using.
The Analytical Mind-Set
The problem for many managers
today, as well as the business
schools that train them, is not a
lack of analysis but too much of it -
at least, too much conventional
analysis.
How many reports have you
written so far?
ManagingOrganizations:TheAnalytical Mind-Set
Evaluation of Data
Cause-Effect
Relationships
Breaking into
Components
The Worldly Mind-Set
We should be getting into worlds
beyond our own-into other people's
circumstances, habits, cultures - so
that we can better know our own
world.
Being worldly does not require global
coverage, just as global coverage
does not a worldly mind-set make.
The Worldly Mind-Set
To manage context is to
manage on the edges, between
the organization and the
various worlds that surround it
- cultures, industries,
companies.
ManagingContext: TheWorldly Mind-
Set
Worlds beyond our own Seeing
differently out to reflect Manage
Interface – cultures
Responses to specific conditions
The Collaborative Mind-Set
People as independent actors, detachable human
"resources" or "assets“ that can be moved around,
bought and sold, combined, and "downsized."
That is not the collaborative mind-set.
Getting into a truly collaborative mind-set means
getting beyond empowerment-a word implying
that the people who know the work best must
somehow receive the blessing of their managers
to do it - and into commitment. It also means
getting away from the currently popular heroic
style of managing and moving toward a more
engaging style.
The Collaborative Mind-Set
Leaders don't do most of the things that
their organizations get done; they do not
even make them get done. Rather, they
help to establish the structures, conditions,
and attitudes through which things get
done. And that requires a collaborative
mind-set.
To be in a collaborative mind-set means to
be inside, involved, to manage throughout.
ManagingRelationships:TheCollaborative Mind-Set
Not managing people
but relationships
among people
Listen more than talk,
Feel more
Do less controlling
The Collaborative Mind-Set
Two Ways to Manage
The Collaborative Mind-Set
The Action Mind-Set
Change, to be successful, cannot
follow some mechanistic schedule
of steps, of formulation followed
by implementation.
Action and reflection have to blend
in a natural flow. And that has to
include collaboration.
ManagingChange:TheAction
Mind-Set
Develop sensitive awareness of the
Situation and team capability.
Set and maintain direction.
Mobilize energy around things that
need
changing, while maintaining the
rest.
Not mechanistic schedule of steps.
Blend Action and Reflection.
Energized action means remaining
curious, alert, experimental.
Weaving the Mind-Sets Together
These five mind-sets do not represent
hard-and-fast categories. We need
distinct labels for them, but they
obviously overlap, and they are more
than mere words.
The weaving often has to be
collaborative, like the sewing, as
managers come to understand one
another and combine their strengths.
Effective organizations tailor handsome
results out of the woven mind-sets of
their managers.
Weavethe FiveMind-Sets
WeavingTheMind-Sets
EffectivePerformance
Achieve Superior Results
EffectiveOrganizations
Woven
Mind-
Sets
Discussion time:
Which mindsets are in general the
strongest among the Chinese
managers?
Which mindset(s) of the millennial
managers (post 80s) have the most
room for improvement? How should
they proceed to do that?

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02
Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02
Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02Mehul Rasadiya
 
Contingency theory of management
Contingency theory of managementContingency theory of management
Contingency theory of managementARUN NAIK
 
Factors affecting organisational structure
Factors affecting organisational structureFactors affecting organisational structure
Factors affecting organisational structureScholarsPoint1
 
Presentation on Administrative management theory
Presentation on Administrative management theoryPresentation on Administrative management theory
Presentation on Administrative management theoryMandeep Neupanem
 
Planning- Function of Management.
Planning- Function of Management.Planning- Function of Management.
Planning- Function of Management.Anupom Sarker
 
Differences between efficiency and effectiveness
Differences between efficiency and effectivenessDifferences between efficiency and effectiveness
Differences between efficiency and effectivenessBrix Joshua Avergonzado
 
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmi
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmiLeadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmi
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmiRahat Kazmi
 
Principles and practices of Management
Principles and practices of ManagementPrinciples and practices of Management
Principles and practices of ManagementDr. Lalit Mohan Pant
 
Models of organizational behavior
Models of organizational behaviorModels of organizational behavior
Models of organizational behaviorSleeping Habib1P
 
Classical and Neo Classical Theory
Classical and Neo Classical TheoryClassical and Neo Classical Theory
Classical and Neo Classical TheoryDheeraj Rajput
 
Principles Of Management Unit 1
Principles Of Management Unit 1Principles Of Management Unit 1
Principles Of Management Unit 1Amit Sarkar
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

INTRODUCTION TO MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCTION TO MANAGEMENT INTRODUCTION TO MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCTION TO MANAGEMENT
 
Organisation behaviour
Organisation behaviourOrganisation behaviour
Organisation behaviour
 
Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02
Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02
Organizationalbehaviour 120626122600-phpapp02
 
Contingency theory of management
Contingency theory of managementContingency theory of management
Contingency theory of management
 
Factors affecting organisational structure
Factors affecting organisational structureFactors affecting organisational structure
Factors affecting organisational structure
 
Presentation on Administrative management theory
Presentation on Administrative management theoryPresentation on Administrative management theory
Presentation on Administrative management theory
 
Planning- Function of Management.
Planning- Function of Management.Planning- Function of Management.
Planning- Function of Management.
 
Differences between efficiency and effectiveness
Differences between efficiency and effectivenessDifferences between efficiency and effectiveness
Differences between efficiency and effectiveness
 
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmi
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmiLeadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmi
Leadership & change management, Lecture 2, by rahat kazmi
 
Organization Theory
Organization TheoryOrganization Theory
Organization Theory
 
Evaluation thought of Management.
Evaluation thought of Management.Evaluation thought of Management.
Evaluation thought of Management.
 
Principles and practices of Management
Principles and practices of ManagementPrinciples and practices of Management
Principles and practices of Management
 
Organisational Behaviour
Organisational BehaviourOrganisational Behaviour
Organisational Behaviour
 
Efficiency
Efficiency Efficiency
Efficiency
 
Models of organizational behavior
Models of organizational behaviorModels of organizational behavior
Models of organizational behavior
 
Management Skills
Management SkillsManagement Skills
Management Skills
 
Scientific management
Scientific managementScientific management
Scientific management
 
Classical and Neo Classical Theory
Classical and Neo Classical TheoryClassical and Neo Classical Theory
Classical and Neo Classical Theory
 
Management thought
Management thoughtManagement thought
Management thought
 
Principles Of Management Unit 1
Principles Of Management Unit 1Principles Of Management Unit 1
Principles Of Management Unit 1
 

Similar a The Five Managerial Mindsets.ppt

Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptx
Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptxManagerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptx
Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptxShivam7933
 
The Birth of a Values-Based Organization
The Birth of a Values-Based OrganizationThe Birth of a Values-Based Organization
The Birth of a Values-Based OrganizationJens Sørensen
 
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptx
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptxLeadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptx
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptxRichardBarrett6
 
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE Man.docx
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE      Man.docx32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE      Man.docx
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE Man.docxgilbertkpeters11344
 
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)Hsiang-Yi Lin (林湘儀)
 
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation research
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation researchGestalt methodolgies in organisation research
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation researchasg03
 
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour NotesMBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour NotesSuman Poudel
 
Cognition and organizational change
Cognition and organizational change Cognition and organizational change
Cognition and organizational change Megha_pareek
 
Chapter 4 Leadership
Chapter 4 LeadershipChapter 4 Leadership
Chapter 4 LeadershipPeleZain
 
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional Intelligence
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional IntelligenceVisionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional Intelligence
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional IntelligenceShubham Singhal
 
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth DisciplineThe Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth DisciplineVijay Krishnan Anantharaman
 
Key Focus Organizational Behavior
Key Focus Organizational BehaviorKey Focus Organizational Behavior
Key Focus Organizational BehaviorMs. Irene Delarmino
 
ppConscious Leaders v11.17
ppConscious Leaders v11.17ppConscious Leaders v11.17
ppConscious Leaders v11.17Greg Asbury
 
Conscious leadership v11.17
Conscious leadership v11.17Conscious leadership v11.17
Conscious leadership v11.17Greg Asbury
 

Similar a The Five Managerial Mindsets.ppt (20)

Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptx
Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptxManagerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptx
Managerial Psychology - Day 1 (1).pptx
 
The Birth of a Values-Based Organization
The Birth of a Values-Based OrganizationThe Birth of a Values-Based Organization
The Birth of a Values-Based Organization
 
Mkmb consulting change 08302013
Mkmb consulting change 08302013Mkmb consulting change 08302013
Mkmb consulting change 08302013
 
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptx
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptxLeadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptx
Leadership Getting Back to Basics v2.pptx
 
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE Man.docx
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE      Man.docx32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE      Man.docx
32 NOVEMBER•DECEMBER 2004 THE PHYSICIAN EXECUTIVE Man.docx
 
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)
MKMB CONSULTING - ESSENTIAL SKILLS TO EMBRACE CHANGE (PART I)
 
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation research
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation researchGestalt methodolgies in organisation research
Gestalt methodolgies in organisation research
 
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour NotesMBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
MBA 1s sem Organisational Behaviour Notes
 
Cognition and organizational change
Cognition and organizational change Cognition and organizational change
Cognition and organizational change
 
Personality development
Personality developmentPersonality development
Personality development
 
Chapter 4 Leadership
Chapter 4 LeadershipChapter 4 Leadership
Chapter 4 Leadership
 
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional Intelligence
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional IntelligenceVisionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional Intelligence
Visionary leadership and influence in the context of Emotional Intelligence
 
Organisational behaviour
Organisational behaviourOrganisational behaviour
Organisational behaviour
 
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth DisciplineThe Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline
The Art of Managing the Team Learning and Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline
 
Key Focus Organizational Behavior
Key Focus Organizational BehaviorKey Focus Organizational Behavior
Key Focus Organizational Behavior
 
ppConscious Leaders v11.17
ppConscious Leaders v11.17ppConscious Leaders v11.17
ppConscious Leaders v11.17
 
Conscious leadership v11.17
Conscious leadership v11.17Conscious leadership v11.17
Conscious leadership v11.17
 
The seven stages of strategic leadership
The seven stages of strategic leadershipThe seven stages of strategic leadership
The seven stages of strategic leadership
 
JF&A_7Habits_WP_4
JF&A_7Habits_WP_4JF&A_7Habits_WP_4
JF&A_7Habits_WP_4
 
باوردی
باوردیباوردی
باوردی
 

Último

Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace Excellence
Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace ExcellenceIntroduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace Excellence
Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace ExcellenceCIToolkit
 
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team Engagement
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team EngagementHow Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team Engagement
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team EngagementCIToolkit
 
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-Making
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-MakingPutting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-Making
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-MakingCIToolkit
 
BPMN tutorial by Draw Libre Office
BPMN  tutorial by Draw Libre OfficeBPMN  tutorial by Draw Libre Office
BPMN tutorial by Draw Libre OfficeMassimo Talia
 
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agile
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agileAgile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agile
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agileZuzana (Zuzi) Sochova
 
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna
 
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna
 
International Volunteer Programs presentation
International Volunteer Programs presentationInternational Volunteer Programs presentation
International Volunteer Programs presentationvwbinternational045
 
Creativity and Design Thinking - 2024.pdf
Creativity and Design Thinking  - 2024.pdfCreativity and Design Thinking  - 2024.pdf
Creativity and Design Thinking - 2024.pdfLuís Gustavo Martins
 
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix Method
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix MethodChoosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix Method
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix MethodCIToolkit
 
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your Project
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your ProjectUsing the RAID Log to Monitor Your Project
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your ProjectCIToolkit
 

Último (11)

Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace Excellence
Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace ExcellenceIntroduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace Excellence
Introduction to 5S: A Journey Towards Workplace Excellence
 
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team Engagement
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team EngagementHow Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team Engagement
How Force Field Analysis Enhances Decision-Making and Team Engagement
 
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-Making
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-MakingPutting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-Making
Putting Prioritization Matrix into Practice for Effective Decision-Making
 
BPMN tutorial by Draw Libre Office
BPMN  tutorial by Draw Libre OfficeBPMN  tutorial by Draw Libre Office
BPMN tutorial by Draw Libre Office
 
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agile
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agileAgile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agile
Agile Journey - Don’t DO agile, BE agile
 
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - Google Certifications - Senior Project Manager
 
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project ManagerMirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project Manager
Mirko Corna - ITIL Courses - Senior Project Manager
 
International Volunteer Programs presentation
International Volunteer Programs presentationInternational Volunteer Programs presentation
International Volunteer Programs presentation
 
Creativity and Design Thinking - 2024.pdf
Creativity and Design Thinking  - 2024.pdfCreativity and Design Thinking  - 2024.pdf
Creativity and Design Thinking - 2024.pdf
 
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix Method
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix MethodChoosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix Method
Choosing the Best Alternative Using the Pugh Matrix Method
 
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your Project
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your ProjectUsing the RAID Log to Monitor Your Project
Using the RAID Log to Monitor Your Project
 

The Five Managerial Mindsets.ppt

  • 1. The Five Minds of a Manager Jonathan Gosling and Henry Mintzberg HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW November 2003
  • 2. The Five Managerial Mind-Sets • the reflective mind-set • the analytic mind-set • the worldly mind-set • the collaborative mind- set • the action mind-set
  • 3. The Need for Reflective Mind-Set Everything that every effective manager does is sandwiched between action on the ground and reflection in the abstract. Action without reflection is thoughtless; reflection without action is passive.
  • 5. The Need for Reflective Mind-Set Managers need to step back from the pressures of their jobs and reflect thoughtfully on their experiences.
  • 6. The Reflective Mind-Set - Most people do not accumulate a body of experience. Most people go through life undergoing a series of happenings, which pass through their systems undigested. - Happenings become experiences when they are digested, when they are reflected on, related to general patterns, and synthesized.
  • 8. The Reflective Mind-Set society (history, economy, ethics, spirituality) organization (culture, structure, knowledge) relationships (with others, with groups) job (managerial work, managing self, managing time) self (experience, style)
  • 9. The Analytical Mind-Set Good analysis provides a language for organizing; it allows people to share an understanding of what is driving their efforts; it provides measures for performance. And organizational structure itself is fundamentally analytic- it is a means of decomposition to establish the division of labor. They analyzed the analyses of others- where these people were coming from, what data and assumptions they were using.
  • 10. The Analytical Mind-Set The problem for many managers today, as well as the business schools that train them, is not a lack of analysis but too much of it - at least, too much conventional analysis. How many reports have you written so far?
  • 11. ManagingOrganizations:TheAnalytical Mind-Set Evaluation of Data Cause-Effect Relationships Breaking into Components
  • 12. The Worldly Mind-Set We should be getting into worlds beyond our own-into other people's circumstances, habits, cultures - so that we can better know our own world. Being worldly does not require global coverage, just as global coverage does not a worldly mind-set make.
  • 13. The Worldly Mind-Set To manage context is to manage on the edges, between the organization and the various worlds that surround it - cultures, industries, companies.
  • 14. ManagingContext: TheWorldly Mind- Set Worlds beyond our own Seeing differently out to reflect Manage Interface – cultures Responses to specific conditions
  • 15. The Collaborative Mind-Set People as independent actors, detachable human "resources" or "assets“ that can be moved around, bought and sold, combined, and "downsized." That is not the collaborative mind-set. Getting into a truly collaborative mind-set means getting beyond empowerment-a word implying that the people who know the work best must somehow receive the blessing of their managers to do it - and into commitment. It also means getting away from the currently popular heroic style of managing and moving toward a more engaging style.
  • 16. The Collaborative Mind-Set Leaders don't do most of the things that their organizations get done; they do not even make them get done. Rather, they help to establish the structures, conditions, and attitudes through which things get done. And that requires a collaborative mind-set. To be in a collaborative mind-set means to be inside, involved, to manage throughout.
  • 17. ManagingRelationships:TheCollaborative Mind-Set Not managing people but relationships among people Listen more than talk, Feel more Do less controlling
  • 20. The Action Mind-Set Change, to be successful, cannot follow some mechanistic schedule of steps, of formulation followed by implementation. Action and reflection have to blend in a natural flow. And that has to include collaboration.
  • 21. ManagingChange:TheAction Mind-Set Develop sensitive awareness of the Situation and team capability. Set and maintain direction. Mobilize energy around things that need changing, while maintaining the rest. Not mechanistic schedule of steps. Blend Action and Reflection. Energized action means remaining curious, alert, experimental.
  • 22. Weaving the Mind-Sets Together These five mind-sets do not represent hard-and-fast categories. We need distinct labels for them, but they obviously overlap, and they are more than mere words. The weaving often has to be collaborative, like the sewing, as managers come to understand one another and combine their strengths. Effective organizations tailor handsome results out of the woven mind-sets of their managers.
  • 24. Discussion time: Which mindsets are in general the strongest among the Chinese managers? Which mindset(s) of the millennial managers (post 80s) have the most room for improvement? How should they proceed to do that?