SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 65
Don’t Be A Cannibal
Limor Barenholtz | Similarweb
SLIDESHARE.NET/LIMORBARENHOLTZ1
@LEM4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 2
Don't be a cannibal
Identifying and avoiding keyword cannibalization
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 3
Keyword
Cannibalization
What is it?
Why is it bad?
Where can I find it?
How can I fix it?
How can I prevent it?
How does it look?
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 4
What is keyword
cannibalization?
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 5
Keyword cannibalization is the common
term used for when several different
pages on the same site contain the
same or similar keywords.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 6
Why is keyword
cannibalization bad?
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 7
Unclear keyword targeting can bite
Keywords Rankings Traffic
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 8
The result?
Both Google and users may choose the
wrong path…
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 9
Clarity is key.
If users become unclear about your
website content or various products,
you may lose traffic on a long term
basis due to loss of trust.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 10
With PPC, it can be
money down the drain.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 11
When the conflict occurs with your
PPC activity, you can find yourself both
losing traffic to your optimized page,
and paying for clicks on your ad.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 12
Cannibalization hurts your website’s:
Authority
Ranking
Performance
Conversion
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 13
Common Types of Keyword
Cannibalization
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 14
Several Pages with the
same target keywords
1
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 15
https://www.bodybuilding.com
https://www.bodybuilding.com
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 16
Paid activity vs. organic
results cannibalization
2
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 17
Paid
Paid
Organic
Organic
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 18
UGC
3
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 19
“Keyword research tool” in forum results
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 20
Automated/Data-Driven Content
4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 21
Dynamic parameters can hurt content flexibility
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 22
How To Identify Cannibalization
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 23
Monitor your ranking performance
Are your target phrases fluctuating in
SERP? You might be a cannibal.
1
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 24
Analyze rank fluctuations in
target phrases
2
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 25
Check GSC - How many pages
rank for the exact term?
More than one?
3
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 26
1 Exact Query -
5 Pages -
1 Year
C
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 27
Use site: search + “target phrase”
4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 28
Site: moz.com "duplicate content"
* To avoid result
grouping you can add
“&filter=0” to the SERP
URL
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 29
Keep a detailed map of URLs-to-keywords
5
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 30
Organized mapping will help you identify
keyword overlaps quickly
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 31
Monitor organic traffic share
6
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 32
Identify traffic share changes over time
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 33
Drill down on paid vs. organic keyword share
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 34
Finalize with organic CTR data from GSC.
Has it dropped in correlating with your PPC
campaigns?
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 35
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 36
How can I fix keyword
cannibalization?
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 37
Build a detailed SEO map
1
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 38
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 39
Isolate duplications in your SEO map
2
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 40
Adjust SEO map so every URL has unique
matched phrases
3
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 41
Use a keyword generator to
find relevant terms
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 42
Roll out onto your conflicting pages
4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 43
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 44
One clear and authoritative
page can rank much higher
than two split-signal
results.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 45
Align internal linking
structure in your site
5
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 46
Yes, it’s important enough to
have its own bullet.
YES
NO
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 47
Align outreach
activities to the
new map
6
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 48
Align paid activities with organic efforts.
Set rules and guidelines.
Always keep testing joined CTR.
7
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 49
This all works for data-driven content
as well. Changing one faulty template
can fix a large volume of pages causing
conflicts.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 50
How can I avoid keyword
cannibalization
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 51
Format your SEO Map to show duplicates
1
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 52
That’s 80% of the work, right there.
Click to D/L SEO Map
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 53
Focus on topic clusters
before keywords
2
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 54
Clusters help create order
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 55
Regularly audit your content
3
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 56
Regularly audit your rankings
4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 57
Set strict UGC policies, or block to avoid
5
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 58
rel=”ugc”
UGC stands for User
Generated Content, and the
ugc attribute value is
recommended for links within
user generated content, such
as comments forum posts.
rel=”nofollow”
Use this attribute to tag
outgoing links in UGC areas
to avoid linking conflicts &
Spam
rel=”sponsored”
Use the sponsored attribute to
identify links on your site that
were created as part of
advertisements, sponsorships
or other comprehension
agreements
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 59
<meta name="robots" content="noindex, nofollow" />
Use the meta robots tag to avoid indexing of UGC
pages entirely. This solution will prevent the need to
manage the area.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 60
What did we learn today?
Identifying cannibalized terms
How to fix and avoid cannibalization
The meaning of cannibalization
How to analyze cannibalization
factors
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 61
What can we do tomorrow?
Align our SEO mapping
Set rules & formats for the future
Audit our content performance
Fix cannibalization issues
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 62
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 63
I’m Limor Barenholtz
Director of SEO @ Similarweb
Have been doing SEO for 20 years
Mom + 2
Former Athlete
Former Gamer
Former Hacker
Carnivor, not Cannibal
@Lem4
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 64
Thank You.
Business Proprietary & Confidential | 65
Question/comments?

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

La actualidad más candente (20)

How to Use Search Intent to Dominate Google Discover
How to Use Search Intent to Dominate Google DiscoverHow to Use Search Intent to Dominate Google Discover
How to Use Search Intent to Dominate Google Discover
 
How to Implement Machine Learning in Your Internal Linking Audit - Lazarina S...
How to Implement Machine Learning in Your Internal Linking Audit - Lazarina S...How to Implement Machine Learning in Your Internal Linking Audit - Lazarina S...
How to Implement Machine Learning in Your Internal Linking Audit - Lazarina S...
 
SEO at Scale - BrightonSEO April 2022
SEO at Scale - BrightonSEO April 2022SEO at Scale - BrightonSEO April 2022
SEO at Scale - BrightonSEO April 2022
 
BrightonSEO - Apr 2022 - No excuses for doing UX
BrightonSEO - Apr 2022 - No excuses for doing UXBrightonSEO - Apr 2022 - No excuses for doing UX
BrightonSEO - Apr 2022 - No excuses for doing UX
 
SEO Automation Without Using Hard Code by Tevfik Mert Azizoglu - BrightonSEO ...
SEO Automation Without Using Hard Code by Tevfik Mert Azizoglu - BrightonSEO ...SEO Automation Without Using Hard Code by Tevfik Mert Azizoglu - BrightonSEO ...
SEO Automation Without Using Hard Code by Tevfik Mert Azizoglu - BrightonSEO ...
 
Improving Crawling and Indexing using Real-Time Log File Insights
Improving Crawling and Indexing using Real-Time Log File InsightsImproving Crawling and Indexing using Real-Time Log File Insights
Improving Crawling and Indexing using Real-Time Log File Insights
 
How to go viral on a budget using Digital PR.pptx
How to go viral on a budget using Digital PR.pptxHow to go viral on a budget using Digital PR.pptx
How to go viral on a budget using Digital PR.pptx
 
How to produce great multilingual content, even when you can't read it | Laur...
How to produce great multilingual content, even when you can't read it | Laur...How to produce great multilingual content, even when you can't read it | Laur...
How to produce great multilingual content, even when you can't read it | Laur...
 
SEO Reporting: Slay the Time-Sucking Monster and Deliver Amazing Reports
SEO Reporting: Slay the Time-Sucking Monster and Deliver Amazing ReportsSEO Reporting: Slay the Time-Sucking Monster and Deliver Amazing Reports
SEO Reporting: Slay the Time-Sucking Monster and Deliver Amazing Reports
 
How to improve Core Web Vitals on a WordPress website
How to improve Core Web Vitals on a WordPress websiteHow to improve Core Web Vitals on a WordPress website
How to improve Core Web Vitals on a WordPress website
 
Martin McGarry - SEO strategy c/o England manager Gareth Southgate
Martin McGarry - SEO strategy c/o England manager Gareth SouthgateMartin McGarry - SEO strategy c/o England manager Gareth Southgate
Martin McGarry - SEO strategy c/o England manager Gareth Southgate
 
Brighton SEO - Luis Bueno Tabernero - How to do an ASO Audit like in the 90's...
Brighton SEO - Luis Bueno Tabernero - How to do an ASO Audit like in the 90's...Brighton SEO - Luis Bueno Tabernero - How to do an ASO Audit like in the 90's...
Brighton SEO - Luis Bueno Tabernero - How to do an ASO Audit like in the 90's...
 
BrightonSEO - Master Crawl Budget Optimization for Enterprise Websites
BrightonSEO - Master Crawl Budget Optimization for Enterprise WebsitesBrightonSEO - Master Crawl Budget Optimization for Enterprise Websites
BrightonSEO - Master Crawl Budget Optimization for Enterprise Websites
 
Diginius - DuckDuckGo, Privacy and the Future of Search
Diginius - DuckDuckGo, Privacy and the Future of Search Diginius - DuckDuckGo, Privacy and the Future of Search
Diginius - DuckDuckGo, Privacy and the Future of Search
 
How to Incorporate ML in your SERP Analysis, Lazarina Stoy -BrightonSEO Oct, ...
How to Incorporate ML in your SERP Analysis, Lazarina Stoy -BrightonSEO Oct, ...How to Incorporate ML in your SERP Analysis, Lazarina Stoy -BrightonSEO Oct, ...
How to Incorporate ML in your SERP Analysis, Lazarina Stoy -BrightonSEO Oct, ...
 
Goodbye SEO fck ups! Learn to set an SEO Quality Assurance Framework
Goodbye SEO fck ups! Learn to set an SEO Quality Assurance FrameworkGoodbye SEO fck ups! Learn to set an SEO Quality Assurance Framework
Goodbye SEO fck ups! Learn to set an SEO Quality Assurance Framework
 
How SEO changes, as we say bye bye to cookies
How SEO changes, as we say bye bye to cookiesHow SEO changes, as we say bye bye to cookies
How SEO changes, as we say bye bye to cookies
 
How to get more traffic with less content - BrightonSEO
How to get more traffic with less content - BrightonSEOHow to get more traffic with less content - BrightonSEO
How to get more traffic with less content - BrightonSEO
 
TECHNICAL SEO QA - SHINING A LIGHT ON INVISIBLE WORK (BrightonSEO April 2022)
TECHNICAL SEO QA - SHINING A LIGHT ON INVISIBLE WORK (BrightonSEO April 2022)TECHNICAL SEO QA - SHINING A LIGHT ON INVISIBLE WORK (BrightonSEO April 2022)
TECHNICAL SEO QA - SHINING A LIGHT ON INVISIBLE WORK (BrightonSEO April 2022)
 
[BrightonSEO 2022] Unlocking the Hidden Potential of Product Listing Pages
[BrightonSEO 2022] Unlocking the Hidden Potential of Product Listing Pages[BrightonSEO 2022] Unlocking the Hidden Potential of Product Listing Pages
[BrightonSEO 2022] Unlocking the Hidden Potential of Product Listing Pages
 

Similar a Don't be a cannibal

The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
DemandWave
 
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics Webinar
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics   WebinarIntegrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics   Webinar
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics Webinar
WebsiteBiz
 

Similar a Don't be a cannibal (20)

Improving your online presence search, ppc and social
Improving your online presence search, ppc and socialImproving your online presence search, ppc and social
Improving your online presence search, ppc and social
 
Introduction To Search Marketing
Introduction To Search MarketingIntroduction To Search Marketing
Introduction To Search Marketing
 
The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
The New Digital Marketing Playbook - slides 10-08-13
 
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics Webinar
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics   WebinarIntegrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics   Webinar
Integrating Social Media, SEO, and Web Analytics Webinar
 
Spring 2018 Roofer's Digital Marketing Boot Camp
Spring 2018 Roofer's Digital Marketing Boot CampSpring 2018 Roofer's Digital Marketing Boot Camp
Spring 2018 Roofer's Digital Marketing Boot Camp
 
Increase_Website_Traffic_Adaptive_Eddie-Prentice
Increase_Website_Traffic_Adaptive_Eddie-PrenticeIncrease_Website_Traffic_Adaptive_Eddie-Prentice
Increase_Website_Traffic_Adaptive_Eddie-Prentice
 
SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION SIMPLIFIED
SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION SIMPLIFIEDSEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION SIMPLIFIED
SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION SIMPLIFIED
 
Similarweb 2016: new tricks and treats by Boaz Sasson
Similarweb 2016: new tricks and treats by Boaz SassonSimilarweb 2016: new tricks and treats by Boaz Sasson
Similarweb 2016: new tricks and treats by Boaz Sasson
 
New tricks and treats of Similarweb 2016
New tricks and treats of Similarweb 2016New tricks and treats of Similarweb 2016
New tricks and treats of Similarweb 2016
 
SimilarWeb PRO for SEO
SimilarWeb PRO for SEOSimilarWeb PRO for SEO
SimilarWeb PRO for SEO
 
Killer Landing Pages Get You Better PPC Results: WordStream & Unbounce Joint ...
Killer Landing Pages Get You Better PPC Results: WordStream & Unbounce Joint ...Killer Landing Pages Get You Better PPC Results: WordStream & Unbounce Joint ...
Killer Landing Pages Get You Better PPC Results: WordStream & Unbounce Joint ...
 
Product SEO and Why It Can Fail
Product SEO and Why It Can FailProduct SEO and Why It Can Fail
Product SEO and Why It Can Fail
 
Digital Marketing Talk for RIBA Salisbury
Digital Marketing Talk for RIBA SalisburyDigital Marketing Talk for RIBA Salisbury
Digital Marketing Talk for RIBA Salisbury
 
4 Signs That Your Agency is Underperforming
4 Signs That Your Agency is Underperforming4 Signs That Your Agency is Underperforming
4 Signs That Your Agency is Underperforming
 
Richard Lawrence - How to measure the impact of LinkedIn ads with zero clicks...
Richard Lawrence - How to measure the impact of LinkedIn ads with zero clicks...Richard Lawrence - How to measure the impact of LinkedIn ads with zero clicks...
Richard Lawrence - How to measure the impact of LinkedIn ads with zero clicks...
 
SEO TRENDS.pptx
SEO TRENDS.pptxSEO TRENDS.pptx
SEO TRENDS.pptx
 
BrightonSEO April'19 Key Takeaways
BrightonSEO April'19 Key TakeawaysBrightonSEO April'19 Key Takeaways
BrightonSEO April'19 Key Takeaways
 
Client Retention Workshop: How To Audit, Price, & Pitch Landing Page Optimiza...
Client Retention Workshop: How To Audit, Price, & Pitch Landing Page Optimiza...Client Retention Workshop: How To Audit, Price, & Pitch Landing Page Optimiza...
Client Retention Workshop: How To Audit, Price, & Pitch Landing Page Optimiza...
 
Introduction to digital marketing - mylivpro
Introduction to digital marketing - mylivproIntroduction to digital marketing - mylivpro
Introduction to digital marketing - mylivpro
 
Best Content Writing and digital marketing Services-iContent
Best Content Writing and digital marketing Services-iContent Best Content Writing and digital marketing Services-iContent
Best Content Writing and digital marketing Services-iContent
 

Último

The 100x Factor Growth with AI - Susan Diaz
The 100x Factor  Growth with AI - Susan DiazThe 100x Factor  Growth with AI - Susan Diaz

Último (20)

Uncover Insightful User Journey Secrets Using GA4 Reports
Uncover Insightful User Journey Secrets Using GA4 ReportsUncover Insightful User Journey Secrets Using GA4 Reports
Uncover Insightful User Journey Secrets Using GA4 Reports
 
No Cookies No Problem - Steve Krull, Be Found Online
No Cookies No Problem - Steve Krull, Be Found OnlineNo Cookies No Problem - Steve Krull, Be Found Online
No Cookies No Problem - Steve Krull, Be Found Online
 
Martal Group - B2B Lead Gen Agency - Onboarding Overview
Martal Group - B2B Lead Gen Agency - Onboarding OverviewMartal Group - B2B Lead Gen Agency - Onboarding Overview
Martal Group - B2B Lead Gen Agency - Onboarding Overview
 
A.I. and The Social Media Shift - Mohit Rajhans
A.I. and The Social Media Shift - Mohit RajhansA.I. and The Social Media Shift - Mohit Rajhans
A.I. and The Social Media Shift - Mohit Rajhans
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 128 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 128 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 128 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 128 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
Major SEO Trends in 2024 - Banyanbrain Digital
Major SEO Trends in 2024 - Banyanbrain DigitalMajor SEO Trends in 2024 - Banyanbrain Digital
Major SEO Trends in 2024 - Banyanbrain Digital
 
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Dlf City Phase 4 Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Dlf City Phase 4 Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceEnjoy Night⚡Call Girls Dlf City Phase 4 Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Dlf City Phase 4 Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
Unlocking the Mystery of the Voynich Manuscript
Unlocking the Mystery of the Voynich ManuscriptUnlocking the Mystery of the Voynich Manuscript
Unlocking the Mystery of the Voynich Manuscript
 
Top 5 Breakthrough AI Innovations Elevating Content Creation and Personalizat...
Top 5 Breakthrough AI Innovations Elevating Content Creation and Personalizat...Top 5 Breakthrough AI Innovations Elevating Content Creation and Personalizat...
Top 5 Breakthrough AI Innovations Elevating Content Creation and Personalizat...
 
Chat GPT Master Class - Leslie Hughes, PUNCH Media
Chat GPT Master Class - Leslie Hughes, PUNCH MediaChat GPT Master Class - Leslie Hughes, PUNCH Media
Chat GPT Master Class - Leslie Hughes, PUNCH Media
 
Brand Strategy Master Class - Juntae DeLane
Brand Strategy Master Class - Juntae DeLaneBrand Strategy Master Class - Juntae DeLane
Brand Strategy Master Class - Juntae DeLane
 
The 100x Factor Growth with AI - Susan Diaz
The 100x Factor  Growth with AI - Susan DiazThe 100x Factor  Growth with AI - Susan Diaz
The 100x Factor Growth with AI - Susan Diaz
 
How to Create a Social Media Plan Like a Pro - Jordan Scheltgen
How to Create a Social Media Plan Like a Pro - Jordan ScheltgenHow to Create a Social Media Plan Like a Pro - Jordan Scheltgen
How to Create a Social Media Plan Like a Pro - Jordan Scheltgen
 
Situation Analysis | Management Company.
Situation Analysis | Management Company.Situation Analysis | Management Company.
Situation Analysis | Management Company.
 
Cash payment girl 9257726604 Hand ✋ to Hand over girl
Cash payment girl 9257726604 Hand ✋ to Hand over girlCash payment girl 9257726604 Hand ✋ to Hand over girl
Cash payment girl 9257726604 Hand ✋ to Hand over girl
 
Alpha Media March 2024 Buyers Guide.pptx
Alpha Media March 2024 Buyers Guide.pptxAlpha Media March 2024 Buyers Guide.pptx
Alpha Media March 2024 Buyers Guide.pptx
 
Generative AI Master Class - Generative AI, Unleash Creative Opportunity - Pe...
Generative AI Master Class - Generative AI, Unleash Creative Opportunity - Pe...Generative AI Master Class - Generative AI, Unleash Creative Opportunity - Pe...
Generative AI Master Class - Generative AI, Unleash Creative Opportunity - Pe...
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 150 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 150 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 150 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 150 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
Creator Influencer Strategy Master Class - Corinne Rose Guirgis
Creator Influencer Strategy Master Class - Corinne Rose GuirgisCreator Influencer Strategy Master Class - Corinne Rose Guirgis
Creator Influencer Strategy Master Class - Corinne Rose Guirgis
 
How to Leverage Behavioral Science Insights for Direct Mail Success
How to Leverage Behavioral Science Insights for Direct Mail SuccessHow to Leverage Behavioral Science Insights for Direct Mail Success
How to Leverage Behavioral Science Insights for Direct Mail Success
 

Don't be a cannibal

Notas del editor

  1. This effectively turns them to competitors in search results Which often results in search engines starting to swap those pages in SERP to determine which is the best fit for the search term
  2. Unclear keyword targeting = Opening for misunderstandings by search engines
  3. When Google swaps the chosen page in SERP there’s no guarantee that page will rank as well as the conflicting page, as a result we might lose traffic When you get a search engine conflicting between 2 pages you never know which one it will choose to show in SERP for your target phrase, and it may not be the page you wanted to rank for it In the case you have 2 results - you’re splitting your CTR, preventing your target page from gaining authority, and might already be losing traffic & conversions. In the case you have 2 results - you might be diluting your backlink efforts If users also become unclear about your website content or various products, you may lose traffic on a long term basis due to loss of trust
  4. When the conflict occurs with your PPC activity you can find yourself both losing traffic to your optimized page, and paying for clicks on your ad - So this is something that needs to be managed, not always avoided
  5. UGC is a hotbed for cannibalization & duplication
  6. See “search engine market share” results in Similarweb. Which is best? Which is the best answer for the user’s query? How should Google choose?
  7. , if you haven’t yet
  8. It’s time to refine & adjust your keyword research
  9. Make sure all your website’s pages reflect a clear and unique message through all relevant on-page signals Optimize/De-Optimize Delete & Redirect Canonicalize Remember: 1 clear & authoritative page can rank much higher than 2 split-signal results
  10. I.e - update your link requests, reach out to publishers of existing backlinks and ask for an update, or try to replace the article with a fresh one
  11. Cannibalizing can be managed if the joint efforts bring higher numbers If total clicks and total CTR rises from the joined activity than the loss of organic CTR is meaningless in the business-wide view The trick is to always monitor
  12. Focusing on clusters first, instead of keywords in general, helps make sure you will cover your topics in an organized way, minimizing chances of cannibalization later on
  13. This solution also has 2 sides, since good content can also come from UGC, and such content can enrich your offering as a whole. You can at this point choose to allow indexing of specific content, but then you’ll need to return to managing it. Other solutions can be indexing only specific contributors you recognize, or even get moderators for these sections.