SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 19
Ch. 1. Sustainable sanitation
- a review
Management
& organisation
Residents´ views
& actions
Physical arrangements
including technology
The challenge is to
protect our health
and the environment
This challenge can be
addressed, if
management, residents,
policies, technology and
engagement are in place
1.1 Sanitary Conditions in the world
How do we perceive sanitary conditions?
What functions must a sustainable system fulfil?
Learning objective:
To become familiar with various sanitary
conditions in the world, functions of
sanitation, and to foster a critical under-
standing of statistics and other data.
Sanitation – ’the silent crises’
 2.5 billion people (35% of the world's population 2010)
lack so called improved sanitation
 18% of the world's population lack safe water supply
 10% of all wastewater in developing countries is treated
 Malnutrition is a major factor making us more vulnerable
to disease and death, thus food security is important
 The combined effects of poor personal and domestic
hygiene and lack of safe water and good environmental
sanitation is considered the most important risk factor
for disease and death
Proportion of households in major cities
connected to piped water and sewers
House or yard Connected to
connection for water (%) a sewer (%)
Africa 43 18
Asia 77 45
Latin America & 77 35
Caribbean
Oceania 73 15
Europe 96 82
North America 100 96
new
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Africa Asia LA & C America Europe
Wastewater - collected and treated by
effective treatment plants (median percentage)
Source: UNDP & UNICEF 2003 (Fig. 3.13)
Stormwater, solid and organic waste
Animals scavenging organic
material and clogged storm water
drains
Stormwater drainage as a
conduit for solid waste
Copyright: Jan-Olof Drangert
Copyright: Jan-Olof Drangert
Exercise: Upgrading environmental sanitation
in dense settlements
Thor-Axel Stenström, SMI, Sweden
before after
Thor-Axel Stenström, SMI, Sweden What Next?
After Improvemen
Sanitation ladder ....... upgrading
Outside house:
Private dry
urine-
diverting toilet
Communal
flush
Indoors:
Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping University, Sweden
Open
defecation
Björn Vinnerås Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping University, Sweden
Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping
University, Sweden
Diseases related to excreta and wastewater
Disease: Mortality
(death/year)
Burden of
disease*
Comments
Diarrhoea 1 800 000 62 000 000 99.8% of deaths occur in dev.
countries; 90% are children
Typhoid 600 000 no data Estimate: 16 million cases/year
Ascariasis 3 000 1 800 000 Estimate: 1.45 billion infections,
of which 350 million suffer
adverse health effects
Hookworm
disease
3 000 60 000 Estimate: 1.3 billion infections of
which 150 million suffer adverse
health effects
Schisto-
somiasis
15 000 1 700 000 Found in 74 countries, 200 million
estimated infected, 20 mi with
severe consequences
Hepatitis A no data no data Estimate: 1.4 million cases/yr.
Source: WHO, 2006
* DALYs/year estimates the time lost due to disability or death from a disease compared with long life free of that disease (See Ch
Source: UNICEF and World Health Organization, 2012
Sanitation coverage trends by developing
region, and urban-rural divide 1990-2010
Urban – rural divide
Improved urban sanitation coverage 2010
Source: UNICEF and World Health Organization, 2012
Proportion of the population in 59
developing
countries using both improved drinking
water
sources and improved sanitation (per cent)
What sanitation is about
• Personal and household hygiene
• Clean environment incl. water
• Solid waste management
• Greywater disposal and treatment
• Safe excreta disposal
• Stormwater handling
Traditional interpretation:
• Acceptance, affordable, convenience and pride
• Environmentally sustainable arrangements incl.
chemical risks and resource conservation
Additional perspectives:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Pathogen & hazardous waste reduction – indicators
depend on flow-stream
Nutrient reuse – (i) X% of excreted N, P, K is reused
for crop production, (ii) Y% of used water is reused
Nutrient & hazardous waste containment –
indicators depend on flow-stream
Integrated resource management –
indicators depend on flow-stream
Access – (i) 24-hr access to facility year-round, (ii) privacy, personal security and shelter,
(iii) no smell, (iv) preferrably indoors and accessible to men, women, children, elderly
Greywater management – (i) no stagnant water in compound or in streets,
(ii) no vectors, (iii) no avoidable pollution e.g. fat or paint residues
A sanitation ladder for improved functions
Adapted from Kvarnström et al., 2010
Excreta containment – (i) in use, (ii) no vectors, (iii) no faecal matter, (iv) hand-washing
facility in use (v) can withstand stormwater events
Sustainable - more than a catch word
The Bruntland Commission (1987) expressed sustainability as:
“…development that meets the needs of the present
without compromising the ability of future generations
to meet their own needs" …
Sustainability comprises a variety of perspectives:
Ecology, Economy, Social, Resource saving, Reuse, etc.
Sustainability criteria for sanitation arrangements may read (EcoSanRes):
- protecting and promoting human health,
- not contributing to environmental degradation or
depletion of the resource base,
- being technically and institutionally appropriate,
economically viable and socially acceptable
Crucial physical boundaries for human activities
Biodiversity
loss
Acid
oceans
Ozone
depletion
N & P
cycles
Land use
changes
Chemical
pollution
Source: Rockström et al., 2009
Freshwater
global use
Aerosol
loading
Climate
change
Planetary
boundary
Requirements on sanitation arrangements
Inside the home (old requirements):
- hygienic and protecting human health
- comfortable (indoors, no smell, easy to clean, security)
Outside of the home requirements (new! ):
- save resources (little/no water, reuse nutrients, little energy)
- protect the environment (ground & surface water, soil, air)
Lessons to consider:
• Requirements change over time, sometimes quickly
• Energy use is high for conveyance over long distances
and for advanced treatment technology
Epidemics rather than endemics have
shaped our views
After John Snow discovered (1854) that cholera can be trans-
mitted by contaminated well water, sanitary engineers focussed
their interest on organic matter in water as an indicator of faecal
contamination. Many rivers with high organic loads were
wrongly labelled as hazardous since the origin of the organic
matter was not from faeces but from humus! (Hamlin, 1990)
Example 2
Sanitary inspectors in Linköping (small town in Sweden) described the
sanitary conditions in the workers´ living quarters as deplorable with
stagnant storm water and awful smell, and causing ill health (1870s).
However, infant mortality in such areas did not differ from that in
richer areas with piped water and sewers. Lack of sanitary precaution
by all classes was the reason, and not until the general hygiene
improved did the death toll figures come down! (Nilsson 1994; Esrey, 1990)
Example1
Continued
Example 3
Water issues have been in focus to the detriment of appreciating
good sanitation. Cairncross (1989) and others have reached the
conclusion that water quantity is more important to good health
than water quality for many diseases. Enough water to clean the
hands and body, wash clothes, clean the house, etc. is more
important than improved drinking water quality at the margin.
Lesson to consider:
We need to measure the right parameters
to be able to draw useful conclusions.
• Sanitation viewed as less important
• People assumed to be uninterested
• Is less of a public concern, and
attracts little public investment in
poor urban areas up to now
• Residents do not perceive that they
pay for sanitation by eg poor health
Lessons to consider:
• The Millennium Development Goals deal more with water than
sanitation issues, but sanitation is picking up with the new emphasis.
• Separate planning for sanitation and water leads to installation of
piped supply long before proper disposal and treatment of wastewater
• Water ”will do the trick”
• Everyone wants water
• Water supply is a public
concern, and attracts public
and private investments
• Easy to charge for the water
- if the supply is regular
Sanitation versus Water

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide
7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide
7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guideGian Paolo Pezzi
 
Environmental problems in urban areas
Environmental problems in urban areasEnvironmental problems in urban areas
Environmental problems in urban areasMohammed Aslam
 
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentation
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentationWater, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentation
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentationWillie Mtwana
 
Do Clean, Get Green Report
Do Clean, Get Green ReportDo Clean, Get Green Report
Do Clean, Get Green ReportNikita Sanghvi
 
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmes
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmesWHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmes
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmesDrTundeAjibola
 
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...Alexander Decker
 
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold Richard Alan Russell
 
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeria
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeriaWomen and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeria
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeriaAlexander Decker
 
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...oafishcyberspac53
 
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, Haiti
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, HaitiCDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, Haiti
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, HaitiStanleylucas
 
Chapter 8 water demand management.ppt
Chapter 8  water demand management.pptChapter 8  water demand management.ppt
Chapter 8 water demand management.pptMohammed Salahat
 
Field trip report writeup
Field trip report writeupField trip report writeup
Field trip report writeupAmake
 
Environmental Health
Environmental HealthEnvironmental Health
Environmental HealthVineeta Singh
 
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...Alexander Decker
 
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackups
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackupsEPA 2006 preventing basementbackups
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackupsBerwyn Residents
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide
7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide
7191 . the right to water and sanitation - a practical guide
 
Environmental problems in urban areas
Environmental problems in urban areasEnvironmental problems in urban areas
Environmental problems in urban areas
 
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentation
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentationWater, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentation
Water, sanitation and diarrheal disease presentation
 
Do Clean, Get Green Report
Do Clean, Get Green ReportDo Clean, Get Green Report
Do Clean, Get Green Report
 
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmes
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmesWHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmes
WHO WASH project and planning & implementation of EH programmes
 
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...
Indiscriminate solid waste dioposal in bauchi causes and impacts on the commu...
 
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold
Grant Proposal Example, Arnold P Gold
 
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeria
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeriaWomen and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeria
Women and solid waste sgregation in bauchi nigeria
 
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...
Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and dispos...
 
VV2013
VV2013VV2013
VV2013
 
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, Haiti
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, HaitiCDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, Haiti
CDC: Understanding the Cholera Epidemic, Haiti
 
Unep post 2015_note_3
Unep post 2015_note_3Unep post 2015_note_3
Unep post 2015_note_3
 
Chapter 8 water demand management.ppt
Chapter 8  water demand management.pptChapter 8  water demand management.ppt
Chapter 8 water demand management.ppt
 
thesis
thesisthesis
thesis
 
Field trip report writeup
Field trip report writeupField trip report writeup
Field trip report writeup
 
Environmental Health
Environmental HealthEnvironmental Health
Environmental Health
 
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...
Impacts of agricultural wastes on groundwater pollution in lipakala farms, on...
 
Socio Economic impact
Socio Economic impactSocio Economic impact
Socio Economic impact
 
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackups
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackupsEPA 2006 preventing basementbackups
EPA 2006 preventing basementbackups
 
Water supply and sanitation
Water supply and sanitationWater supply and sanitation
Water supply and sanitation
 

Similar a Sanitary_Cond._in_the_World

Sustainable sanitation
Sustainable sanitationSustainable sanitation
Sustainable sanitationGourav Kumar
 
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities Global Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the Youths
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the YouthsSustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the Youths
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the YouthsCharles Anukwonke
 
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water CivilizationChallenge:Future
 
Sanitation and public health microbiology
Sanitation and public health microbiologySanitation and public health microbiology
Sanitation and public health microbiologyHasnaif Mohammad
 
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhsJohn Middleton
 
181017 long version middletonj planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar
181017 long version middletonj  planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar181017 long version middletonj  planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar
181017 long version middletonj planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltarJohn Middleton
 
Environmental Health Programs
Environmental Health ProgramsEnvironmental Health Programs
Environmental Health Programspccampo
 
Planetary health or Plexit?
Planetary health or Plexit?Planetary health or Plexit?
Planetary health or Plexit?John Middleton
 
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6MeghanaGhodake1
 
Caribbean studies
Caribbean studiesCaribbean studies
Caribbean studiesAndreen18
 
Planetary health or plexit?
Planetary health or  plexit?  Planetary health or  plexit?
Planetary health or plexit? John Middleton
 
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...water-decade
 
Climate change and health_ NAP Expo
Climate change and health_ NAP ExpoClimate change and health_ NAP Expo
Climate change and health_ NAP ExpoNAP Events
 

Similar a Sanitary_Cond._in_the_World (20)

Sustainable sanitation
Sustainable sanitationSustainable sanitation
Sustainable sanitation
 
PPT2_Env health 2022.pdf
PPT2_Env health 2022.pdfPPT2_Env health 2022.pdf
PPT2_Env health 2022.pdf
 
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities
Wastewater, Ecosystems and Health: Risks and Opportunities
 
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the Youths
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the YouthsSustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the Youths
Sustainable Water (Safe Water and Improved Sanitation): Engaging the Youths
 
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization
[Challenge:Future] Brown Water Civilization
 
5genius
5genius5genius
5genius
 
Water & sanitation
Water & sanitationWater & sanitation
Water & sanitation
 
Sanitation and public health microbiology
Sanitation and public health microbiologySanitation and public health microbiology
Sanitation and public health microbiology
 
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs
151218 2 middletonj save the planet save the nhs
 
181017 long version middletonj planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar
181017 long version middletonj  planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar181017 long version middletonj  planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar
181017 long version middletonj planetary health or plexit iiphf gibraltar
 
Environmental Health Programs
Environmental Health ProgramsEnvironmental Health Programs
Environmental Health Programs
 
Planetary health or Plexit?
Planetary health or Plexit?Planetary health or Plexit?
Planetary health or Plexit?
 
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6
Sustainable Developmental Goal no.6
 
Caribbean studies
Caribbean studiesCaribbean studies
Caribbean studies
 
SANITATION
SANITATIONSANITATION
SANITATION
 
Planetary health or plexit?
Planetary health or  plexit?  Planetary health or  plexit?
Planetary health or plexit?
 
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...
Governments: Leo Heller, UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to WASH, 16...
 
Clean Water & Sanitation for All: UNSDG # 6
Clean Water & Sanitation for All: UNSDG # 6Clean Water & Sanitation for All: UNSDG # 6
Clean Water & Sanitation for All: UNSDG # 6
 
Climate change and health_ NAP Expo
Climate change and health_ NAP ExpoClimate change and health_ NAP Expo
Climate change and health_ NAP Expo
 
Water & Sanitation
Water & Sanitation Water & Sanitation
Water & Sanitation
 

Sanitary_Cond._in_the_World

  • 1. Ch. 1. Sustainable sanitation - a review Management & organisation Residents´ views & actions Physical arrangements including technology The challenge is to protect our health and the environment This challenge can be addressed, if management, residents, policies, technology and engagement are in place
  • 2. 1.1 Sanitary Conditions in the world How do we perceive sanitary conditions? What functions must a sustainable system fulfil? Learning objective: To become familiar with various sanitary conditions in the world, functions of sanitation, and to foster a critical under- standing of statistics and other data.
  • 3. Sanitation – ’the silent crises’  2.5 billion people (35% of the world's population 2010) lack so called improved sanitation  18% of the world's population lack safe water supply  10% of all wastewater in developing countries is treated  Malnutrition is a major factor making us more vulnerable to disease and death, thus food security is important  The combined effects of poor personal and domestic hygiene and lack of safe water and good environmental sanitation is considered the most important risk factor for disease and death
  • 4. Proportion of households in major cities connected to piped water and sewers House or yard Connected to connection for water (%) a sewer (%) Africa 43 18 Asia 77 45 Latin America & 77 35 Caribbean Oceania 73 15 Europe 96 82 North America 100 96
  • 5. new 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Africa Asia LA & C America Europe Wastewater - collected and treated by effective treatment plants (median percentage) Source: UNDP & UNICEF 2003 (Fig. 3.13)
  • 6. Stormwater, solid and organic waste Animals scavenging organic material and clogged storm water drains Stormwater drainage as a conduit for solid waste Copyright: Jan-Olof Drangert Copyright: Jan-Olof Drangert
  • 7. Exercise: Upgrading environmental sanitation in dense settlements Thor-Axel Stenström, SMI, Sweden before after Thor-Axel Stenström, SMI, Sweden What Next? After Improvemen
  • 8. Sanitation ladder ....... upgrading Outside house: Private dry urine- diverting toilet Communal flush Indoors: Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping University, Sweden Open defecation Björn Vinnerås Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping University, Sweden Jan-Olof Drangert, Linköping University, Sweden
  • 9. Diseases related to excreta and wastewater Disease: Mortality (death/year) Burden of disease* Comments Diarrhoea 1 800 000 62 000 000 99.8% of deaths occur in dev. countries; 90% are children Typhoid 600 000 no data Estimate: 16 million cases/year Ascariasis 3 000 1 800 000 Estimate: 1.45 billion infections, of which 350 million suffer adverse health effects Hookworm disease 3 000 60 000 Estimate: 1.3 billion infections of which 150 million suffer adverse health effects Schisto- somiasis 15 000 1 700 000 Found in 74 countries, 200 million estimated infected, 20 mi with severe consequences Hepatitis A no data no data Estimate: 1.4 million cases/yr. Source: WHO, 2006 * DALYs/year estimates the time lost due to disability or death from a disease compared with long life free of that disease (See Ch
  • 10. Source: UNICEF and World Health Organization, 2012 Sanitation coverage trends by developing region, and urban-rural divide 1990-2010 Urban – rural divide
  • 11. Improved urban sanitation coverage 2010 Source: UNICEF and World Health Organization, 2012 Proportion of the population in 59 developing countries using both improved drinking water sources and improved sanitation (per cent)
  • 12. What sanitation is about • Personal and household hygiene • Clean environment incl. water • Solid waste management • Greywater disposal and treatment • Safe excreta disposal • Stormwater handling Traditional interpretation: • Acceptance, affordable, convenience and pride • Environmentally sustainable arrangements incl. chemical risks and resource conservation Additional perspectives:
  • 13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Pathogen & hazardous waste reduction – indicators depend on flow-stream Nutrient reuse – (i) X% of excreted N, P, K is reused for crop production, (ii) Y% of used water is reused Nutrient & hazardous waste containment – indicators depend on flow-stream Integrated resource management – indicators depend on flow-stream Access – (i) 24-hr access to facility year-round, (ii) privacy, personal security and shelter, (iii) no smell, (iv) preferrably indoors and accessible to men, women, children, elderly Greywater management – (i) no stagnant water in compound or in streets, (ii) no vectors, (iii) no avoidable pollution e.g. fat or paint residues A sanitation ladder for improved functions Adapted from Kvarnström et al., 2010 Excreta containment – (i) in use, (ii) no vectors, (iii) no faecal matter, (iv) hand-washing facility in use (v) can withstand stormwater events
  • 14. Sustainable - more than a catch word The Bruntland Commission (1987) expressed sustainability as: “…development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs" … Sustainability comprises a variety of perspectives: Ecology, Economy, Social, Resource saving, Reuse, etc. Sustainability criteria for sanitation arrangements may read (EcoSanRes): - protecting and promoting human health, - not contributing to environmental degradation or depletion of the resource base, - being technically and institutionally appropriate, economically viable and socially acceptable
  • 15. Crucial physical boundaries for human activities Biodiversity loss Acid oceans Ozone depletion N & P cycles Land use changes Chemical pollution Source: Rockström et al., 2009 Freshwater global use Aerosol loading Climate change Planetary boundary
  • 16. Requirements on sanitation arrangements Inside the home (old requirements): - hygienic and protecting human health - comfortable (indoors, no smell, easy to clean, security) Outside of the home requirements (new! ): - save resources (little/no water, reuse nutrients, little energy) - protect the environment (ground & surface water, soil, air) Lessons to consider: • Requirements change over time, sometimes quickly • Energy use is high for conveyance over long distances and for advanced treatment technology
  • 17. Epidemics rather than endemics have shaped our views After John Snow discovered (1854) that cholera can be trans- mitted by contaminated well water, sanitary engineers focussed their interest on organic matter in water as an indicator of faecal contamination. Many rivers with high organic loads were wrongly labelled as hazardous since the origin of the organic matter was not from faeces but from humus! (Hamlin, 1990) Example 2 Sanitary inspectors in Linköping (small town in Sweden) described the sanitary conditions in the workers´ living quarters as deplorable with stagnant storm water and awful smell, and causing ill health (1870s). However, infant mortality in such areas did not differ from that in richer areas with piped water and sewers. Lack of sanitary precaution by all classes was the reason, and not until the general hygiene improved did the death toll figures come down! (Nilsson 1994; Esrey, 1990) Example1
  • 18. Continued Example 3 Water issues have been in focus to the detriment of appreciating good sanitation. Cairncross (1989) and others have reached the conclusion that water quantity is more important to good health than water quality for many diseases. Enough water to clean the hands and body, wash clothes, clean the house, etc. is more important than improved drinking water quality at the margin. Lesson to consider: We need to measure the right parameters to be able to draw useful conclusions.
  • 19. • Sanitation viewed as less important • People assumed to be uninterested • Is less of a public concern, and attracts little public investment in poor urban areas up to now • Residents do not perceive that they pay for sanitation by eg poor health Lessons to consider: • The Millennium Development Goals deal more with water than sanitation issues, but sanitation is picking up with the new emphasis. • Separate planning for sanitation and water leads to installation of piped supply long before proper disposal and treatment of wastewater • Water ”will do the trick” • Everyone wants water • Water supply is a public concern, and attracts public and private investments • Easy to charge for the water - if the supply is regular Sanitation versus Water

Notas del editor

  1. The technology-based approach to monitoring and policy is quite standard and regulations and by-laws are in many cases formulated in a technology-prescriptive way, which facilitates the life for those responsible for enforcement and monitoring. The flipside of that coin is that regulations, by-laws and legislation formulated in this way might hamper the development and improvement of technology since technologies not specified in the regulatory framework will consequently not be authorized to use. Moreover, a regulatory framework formulated in this way will also become outdated if innovative sanitation technologies not covered in the regulatory framework do show up on the sanitation market. In contrast, some governments have moved towards more function-based policy, in an attempt to be more inclusive. For example, the South African White Paper on Sanitation (passed 2001) is based on principle rather than technology, stating that the minimum acceptable basic level of sanitation encompasses: In Sweden on-site sanitation regulation has undergone a remake over the last ten years, going from being technology-prescriptive to being function-oriented. 2006, the Environmental Protection Agency published new national guidelines on on-site sanitation, which focused not on sanitation technology per se but the function of the sanitation technology instead. The Swedish EPA thereby guides the local authorities on what kind of demands they should pose on the house owner. The national guidelines are especially emphasizing the need to reduce the phosphorus loads to the recipient water bodies and the importance of nutrients recycling. The new national guidelines are describing functions to be complied to within three different categories: (i) basic functions, (ii) health protection, and (iii) environmental protection. The two last categories are further specified into normal protection level and high protection level, where any of these levels can be applied depending on the local context (see Box 1). To help the local environmental authorities in their decision-making the Swedish EPA has produced a handbook explaining the regulatory implications on on-site sanitation. Moreover, some municipalities have produced living documents, where technologies fulfilling the function requirements in their municipality for the different protection levels are listed. In order for these documents to be up-to-date with the sanitation system development they need to be regularly updated. The functions on the first rung are focused on stopping the spread of fecal-oral disease through proper excreta containment and hand washing. This rung recognizes that the use of a public or shared latrine, with a functional hand-washing facility, will be able to count towards improved sanitation. This would be the equivalent to the rung "shared latrines" in the JMP ladder used today (Figure 2), although the JMP ladder does not include hand-washing. To break the disease chain the first rung should also eliminate flies. In addition, this rung addresses important issues for user satisfaction and acceptance by having aesthetic functions. The pleasantness of the user experience with a sanitation system can be a determiner of whether it is used properly and thus whether it is providing the necessary benefit. Therefore, it is important that the facilities are free of odours and pests (including flies, insects and rodents), and have regular cleaning and maintenance to preserve a clean/pleasant experience.
  2. Planetary boundaries are real. They define the safe operating space for humanity with respect to the Earth system and are associated with the planet´s biophysical subsystems and processes. Today, most of the thresholds can be given by a value for one or more control variables, such as carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere (350 parts per million by volume). Two of the identified 9 boundaries have no threshold values (see slide). The boundaries in three systems (rate of biodiversity loss, climate change and human interference with the nitrogen cycle counted as rate at which N2 is removed from the atmosphere and converted to reactive nitrogen), have already been exceeded. Humanity may soon be appreoaching the bounglobhwater use, change in land use,ocean acidification and interference with the global phosphorus cycle.. Although the planetary coundaries are described in terms o f invidividual quantities ans separate preceswses, the boundaries are tigthly coulpled. If one boundary is transgressed, then other boundaries are also iunder serious risk. For instance, significant lan-use changes in the Amazon could influence water resources as fdar away as Tibet.