Pravir Malik is the founder of Aurosoorya, a pioneering technology and consulting company that isolates organizational-fractals to help organizations make shifts, one pattern at a time. Pravir spoke with the SBODN community about this topic in May 2012. Join SBODN at upcoming events through SBODN.com.
Leveraging Fractal Technology to Scale Change Initiatives
1. Leveraging Fractal Technology to Scale
Change Initiatives
Pravir Malik
Aurosoorya
San Francisco
USA
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com
2. The Most Beautiful Thing We can Experience is the
Mysterious. It is the Source of All True Art and Science
(Albert Einstein)
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 2
3. Contents
• Overview of Fractals
• Fractals in Organizations
• Scaling Change in Organizations
• Change at the Global Level through Fractal Technology
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 3
6. Fractals in Nature
(Fractal = a pattern that repeats itself on different scale)
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 6
7. “Fractal geometry will make you see everything
differently…Never again will your interpretation of
these things be quite the same. ”
— Michael F. Barnsley
Fractals Everywhere (2000)
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 7
9. Differences, borders, lines, surfaces and boundaries do not really divide things
from each other at all, they join them together. All boundaries are held in
common. Alan Watts
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 9
10. Organization Landscape: Comprised of Repeating Patterns
(Source: Cover of „Connecting Inner Power with Global Change: The Fractal Ladder‟ )
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 10
11. Physical, Vital, Mental – Architecture of the Organizational
Fractal
PHYSICAL
• Impulse to keep things as they are
• Rule of thumb: defined by “what the
Mental
Physical
eye can see”
MENTAL
• Change dictated by thought and order
• Rule of thumb: defined by “thought
and the idea”
VITAL
Vital
• Impulse to change things, employing
energy
• Rule of thumb: defined by “assertiveness
and play of energies”
A CLAIM: Every single organization dynamic we encounter or can envision can be
understood in terms of the physical, vital, and mental components and orientations
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 11
11
12. The Human Level – Perceptions of Life
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Purpose
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Randomness
Physical Deterministic
World is what the Many random Conscious
eye can see; Genetics forces: strongest design; personal
determine prevails purpose
possibilities
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 12
13. The Human Level - Successfully Managing States of Being
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Reason
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Passion, Anger
Physical Boredom
Fixed world with Bringing in Bringing in
not much to do movement intelligence, thou
ght
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 13
14. The Human Level – Progression Through Life
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Reflection
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Assertiveness
Physical Stability
Taking care of Experimentation Contemplation
the basics and increased and deeper
dynamism reflection
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 14
15. The System Level - Economy
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Digital
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Industrial
Physical Agricultural
Physical Creation of flows: Concept-
labor, physical transportation, co driven, idea
devices, physical mmunication, reso leading to
products urces formation –
company, industry
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 15
16. The System Level – Digital Economy
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Value-Web
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital eCommerce
Physical Brochureware
Digital Mapping of Redesign of
representation of selected business business model
existing materials flows onto based on Internet
Internet characteristics
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 16
17. The Organization Level - Innovation in the Business World
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Conceptual
Vital Financial
Operational
Level
Physical
Material
Traditional Financial Concept-
products, performance, sal driven, free of
markets, es growth old boundaries
approaches
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 17
18. The System Level - Physics
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Unified Theory
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Quantum View
Physical Atomic View
Isolated building Process/flow Conceptual view
blocks orientation
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 18
19. The System Level – Macroeconomics (Currency Exchange)
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Demand-supply
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Balance of power
Physical Gold standard
Physical standard Manipulation Global demand
based on and supply
perceived
power
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 19
20. The System Level – Global Politics
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Globalization
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Cold War
Physical WW1, WW2
Physical Leverage on Sophisticated
confrontation, phys emotions - fear planning
ical restructuring
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 20
21. The System Level - Making Sense of Market Crashes
Democratization of Markets:
Amazon
Google
eBay
Yahoo
Fundamental
struggle of
contradictory
Entire financial edifice toxic
forces
West – Japan – S.E. Asia - Russia
Mortgage-based bonds
DJIA plunges 20% in 1 day
Pharma WEALTH?
No due diligence
O&G
From multi-dimensional to surface Retail Occupy
value F&A
Change in Stock mkt Toxic assets as collateral Banking
exchange rates; crashes; value –
loosening of global casino
money supply; mentality
Inflation;
notion of wealth
+ OPEC oil
embargo
=>> mkts down
by 40%
Abandon: gold
standard; US$
currency peg
1973-74 1987 Global 1990s 1998 2000 2004 US 2007 – 09
US Bear Synchronized Japanese Russian Dotcom Housing Bear
Market Crash Asset, Asian Financial Crisis Market Market 2010 – 12
Crises Crisis Greek
Debt, EU
Sovereign
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 21 Debt
22. Millennial Shifts Level - Evolution of Life on Earth
Millennial Shifts
Environment/System/Market
Organization
Human
Mental Animal & Man
Natural
Progression
of Time Vital Simple Life
Physical Inanimate Matter
Stones, basic Single-celled life, Rudimentary
elements more complex mind, more
forms, plants complex mind
Degrees of Freedom
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 22
23. All Habits – Limiting or Helpful - That Individuals Display Are
Constituted By the Same Components
Physical
Mental
Vital
Persistence = neural networks
Persistence = neural networks
“No point trying to
Inertia change anything, it will
not succeed”
“I get what I want”
Anger
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 23
24. Scaling Change in
Organizations
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 24
25. Scaling Change in Organizations
• By many estimates as many as 70 – 90% of change initiatives
fail
• The “Team” is the lynch-pin in orchestrating change
• Need to understand and shift fractal dynamics occurring at the
level of the team
Scaling change in organizations
requires the emergence and
reinforcement of fractals of
harmony
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 25
26. Stages of Team Development
Level of Productivity
Performing
Mental
Norming
Vital Storming
Physical Forming
Safe, Energetic, Rational,
Status Quo Irrational Productive
Physical Vital Mental
Nature of Interaction
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 26
27. Stage 1 – Forming (Physical)
• Desire to be accepted by others
• Avoid controversy and conflict (a lot may not get done as a
result)
• Serious issues and feelings are avoided
• Focus is on being busy with routines (roles, organization etc.)
• Individuals are gathering information and impressions about
each other
• Members tend to be quite independent of each other
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 27
27
28. Stage 2 – Storming (Vital)
• Different ideas compete for consideration
• Team begins to focus on what problems they are really trying
to solve
• Team members confront each others‟ ideas
• Some team members will focus on minutiae to evade real
issues
• This stage can be contentious, unpleasant, even painful to
members who are averse to conflict
• Tolerance of each team member is critical
• Some teams will never develop past this stage
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 28
28
29. Stage 3 – Norming (Mental-I)
• Team comes up with one goal and a mutual plan
• Members respect each other‟s opinions and value their
differences
• Team is putting team operating guidelines into practice
• Trust between team members increases
• Responsibility shifts from self-achievement to team-
achievement
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 29
29
30. Stage 4 – Performing (Mental-II)
• Get to a high-performing level: job is done smoothly without
inappropriate conflict
• Team members are interdependent
• Team members are competent, autonomous, and make
decisions effectively
• Dissent is allowed and channeled effectively
• Supervisors are participative as opposed to directive
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 30
30
31. General Questions To Understand Nature of
Interaction
• How do members respond to pressure?
• How do members get along with one another? What is the level of tolerance between team
members?
• Are there serious issues and feelings that have been avoided? Are real issues being addressed
by the team?
• What is the level of confrontation? How does this show up in the team?
• What leadership patterns have emerged?
• Does the team agree on a single goal and a mutual plan?
• What is the nature and result of conflict? How is conflict managed?
• How are decisions made?
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 31
37. State-Based Summary Snapshot
Assessment:
•There is a lot of good-will and positive energy in the group. The intention to do the right thing is there.
•At the same time physical, emotional, and mental capacity of the team is being drained (looking at the Opportunity-based
patterns) because of some recurring themes.
•Overall the team needs to break through to the „Norming‟ Stage. This will require more process-based dialog and effort by
the team.
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 37
38. High Intensity Themes
Intensity State Event Origin
10 Complacency I want more direct communication and feedback from my team members. Physical
9 Fatigue re: their is really a discrepancy in what some people feel they are giving and what others perceive they are giving Physical
9 Fatigue There is more work to do than hours do it in. Physical
9 Flexibility conflict requires flexibility - this team is very flexible - changing priorities constantly Physical
9 Sensitiveness It is difficult for people to give me feedback because I take things too personally. Vital
Unclear about ultimate goals. Each member might have a different view of a central and single goal that will have
8 Fragmentary greatest impact. Mental
Because the demands placed on the team are great, the members avoid exposing their true feelings for one 's sense
8 Sensitiveness of safety and to avoid misunderstandings. Vital
8 Sensitiveness Some decisions are reached by consensus which at times backfires. Vital
8 Fear fear of confrontation Vital
8 Anxiety Is there enough trust in the group to be really honest with each other to change the team dynamics. Mental
8 Haste Sometimes too much haste before there is a real vision of the goal. re: working under pressure Vital
High Intensity Significance:
Key Themes: • High intensity states point to immediate opportunities that need to be
• Protocols for Feedback/Confrontation managed quickly
• Clarity around Goals • Failure to manage what the state is pointing to will mean that the
• Trust-Building underlying issue will become persistent
• As a result safety of an environment will be eroded
• If this happens the team will then tend to stagnate around suggested
patterns of dysfunction
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 38
39. High Duration States
Duration State Event Origin
300 Fatigue re: their is really a discrepancy in what some people feel they are giving and what others perceive they are giving Physical
300 Fragmentary Unclear about ultimate goals. Each member might have a different view of a central and single goal that will have greatest impact. Mental
Because the demands placed on the team are great, the members avoid exposing their true feelings for one 's sense of safety and to
300 Sensitiveness avoid misunderstandings. Vital
190 Repeatability leadership quality Physical
It is a joy to work with each other. However, under extreme duress the team's functionality suffers and we treat each other with less
180 Joy tolerance. Vital
180 Sensitiveness Some decisions are reached by consensus which at times backfires. Vital
145 Fear fear of confrontation Vital
145 Inertia some team members feel inertia when dealing with serious issues. Physical
120 Energy Most team members are very energetic dedicating an enormous amount of effort to produce positive results. Vital
100 Anxiety Is there enough trust in the group to be really honest with each other to change the team dynamics. Mental
100 Determination We all want to be a highly functioning team. Vital
working under pressure: sometimes don't have all the pieces . Some people seem to know what’s going on and others don't have the
100 Fragmentary information Mental
100 Haste Sometimes too much haste before there is a real vision of the goal. re: working under pressure Vital
100 Perseverance working under pressure: persistance Vital
100 Short-sighted re; dealing with serious issues Mental
75 Complacency I want more direct communication and feedback from my team members. Physical
High Duration Significance:
Key States:
• High duration states implies that that state is becoming persistent
• Fatigue • Anxiety • The state becomes an underlying state of team dynamics and exceeds the boundaries of a
• Fragmentary thinking • Haste single team meeting. It contributes to the „culture‟ of the team
• Sensitiveness • Complacency • The event is only a trigger, since now the state occupies more of the processing capacity
• Lack of Tolerance
of team members. However, the event can be used as an occasion to alter the state
• Fear
• It is necessary that the team reverse the state if negative
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 39
40. High Duration + Intensity States
Duration Intensity State Event Origin
300 9 Fatigue re: their is really a discrepancy in what some people feel they are giving and what others perceive they are giving Physical
300 8 Fragmentary Unclear about ultimate goals. Each member might have a different view of a central and single goal that will have greatest impact. Mental
Because the demands placed on the team are great, the members avoid exposing their true feelings for one 's sense of safety and to
300 8 Sensitiveness avoid misunderstandings. Vital
190 5 Repeatability leadership quality Physical
180 8 Sensitiveness Some decisions are reached by consensus which at times backfires. Vital
It is a joy to work with each other. However, under extreme duress the team's functionality suffers and we treat each other with less
180 5 Joy tolerance. Vital
145 8 Fear fear of confrontation Vital
145 7 Inertia some team members feel inertia when dealing with serious issues. Physical
120 6 Energy Most team members are very energetic dedicating an enormous amount of effort to produce positive results. Vital
100 8 Anxiety Is there enough trust in the group to be really honest with each other to change the team dynamics. Mental
100 8 Haste Sometimes too much haste before there is a real vision of the goal. re: working under pressure Vital
100 8 Perseverance working under pressure: persistance Vital
High Duration + Intensity Significance:
• High duration + intensity states implies that that state is becoming persistent faster and
Key States:
needs to be managed more urgently
• Fatigue • Anxiety
• The state becomes an underlying state of team dynamics and exceeds the boundaries of a
• Fragmentary thinking • Haste
single team meeting. It contributes to the „culture‟ of the team
• Sensitiveness
• The event is only a trigger, since now the state occupies more of the processing capacity
• Lack of Tolerance
of team members. However, the event can be used as an occasion to alter the state
• Fear
• It is necessary that the team reverse the state if negative
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 40
41. State-Based Details
State Intensity Duration Event Origin
Anxiety 8 100 Is there enough trust in the group to be really honest with each other to change the team dynamics. Mental
There seems to be to many goals and if we were to try and cover them all a Patty meeting would be 8-12 hours
Anxiety 5 60 long. Mental
Calm 3 15 members get along with each other very calmly - outwardly Mental
Complacency 10 75 I want more direct communication and feedback from my team members. Physical
Members seem to get along. But this is an area I would like to see us grow together. Tolerence is okay but it
Complacency 4 60 doesn't allow us to grow at times. Physical
Complacency 4 30 Minimal episodes of confrontation which gives us a sense that all is well. Physical
Depression 5 60 There are some serious issues with communication. I am part of this problem but not sure how to resolve it. help! Vital
Depression 3 60 Conflict is withheld or delt with in the nature of bad news. Vital
Determination 7 60 dealing with serious issues Vital
Determination 6 100 We all want to be a highly functioning team. Vital
Energy 6 120 Most team members are very energetic dedicating an enormous amount of effort to produce positive results. Vital
Enthusiasm 5 20 team agrees on goals and gets positive energy once consenus is attained Vital
Enthusiasm 4 30 we do get enthusistic after most meetings when we feel things have been discussed and resolved Vital
Fatigue 9 300 re: their is really a discrepancy in what some people feel they are giving and what others perceive they are giving Physical
Fatigue 9 60 There is more work to do than hours do do it in. Physical
Fatigue 6 60 The work load is not evenly divided among team members. Physical
Fatigue 5 60 decisions seem to be made from outside the team. as if there is no control Physical
Fear 8 145 fear of confronation Vital
Flexibility 9 50 conflict requires flexibility - this team is very flexible - changing priorities constantly Physical
Flexibility 7 20 real issues of the unit are being adressed and progress slowly Physical
Flexibility 7 20 Team members are willing to help each other out when they are aware of their needs. Physical
Flexibility 4 60 Everybody is very is flexible in helping out the unit when we have been extremely busy. Physical
Unclear about ultimate goals. Each member might have a different view of a central and single goal that will have
Fragmentary 8 300 greatest impact. Mental
working under pressure: sometimes don't have all the pieces . Some people seem to know whats going on and
Fragmentary 6 100 others don't have the information Mental
Gratitude 8 30 My team members care about my personal well being. Vital
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 41
42. Recommendations
• Team appears to be between the Forming – Storming Stage. Needs to
develop to get to the „Norming‟ Stage
• Conscious effort to reverse underlying and forming team culture as
indicated by high duration states of sensitiveness, fear, fatigue,
fragmentary thinking, anxiety, haste, complacency, needs to occur quickly
• Protocols for dialog/confrontation need to be put in place. More safe
dialog around serious issues needs to occur
• Further, Group norms/principles need to be put in place
• Goals and roles need to be further clarified
• Trust-building exercises/dialog needs to occur
• Continue use of Team Dynamics tool and have bi-weekly dialogues as a
leadership team to address themes/issues that have surfaced
• Decide on any guidelines for entering data into the tool (ex: focusing on key
projects, referring to these in comments etc.)
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 42
44. Change at the Global Level
through Fractal Technology
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 44
45. Self-Repeating Distortions Leading to Global Problems
Physical
Physical
Physical
Physical
Mental
Physical
Mental
Mental
Vital
Mental
Physical
Mental
Physical Vital
Vital
Mental Vital
Vital
Vital
Mental
Vital
Individual Team Department Organization Market System
Local Global
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 45
46. An Example: Leveraging Fractal Technology to
Manage a Global Problem - Climate Change
Global
Financial
Global Business Fractal Crises; Climate
Change
Global System Fractal
Global Economy Fractal
Consumerism Fractal
Global Society Fractal
Does this make OD
Human the most important
Decision-Making Fractal
Flower/Body Orientations profession in the
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com world?
46
47. By giving employees more
control over changing their job
satisfaction…
Fractal Dynamics
…we expect to see shifts in a
range of global events
(Source: JobSatisfactionGuru.com)
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 47
48. Pravir Malik
Founder, Aurosoorya
pravirmalik at aurosoorya.com
Copyright Aurosoorya. www.aurosoorya.com 48