A comparison between CBDI's Service Architecture and Engineering method and the Open Group's TOGAF (version 8.1.1)

1. TOGAF and CBDI Service Architecture & Engineering TM

3. Creating full service life cycle integration from business to execution TOGAF CBDI SAE Architecture method Business Architecture Architecture Views Inputs Deliverables Governance Organization Contracts Patterns Skills SO Model SOA Maturity & Adoption SO Business Modeling SO Business Improvement SO Architecture Methodology SO Solution Architecture Method SO Provisioning SO Delivery SO Assembly SO Platform Design SO Platform Delivery SO Governance SO Organization ITIL, FEAC, MoDAF, DoDAF, Zachman, Archimate, Prince EA Development Methodology Requirements Management Enterprise Continuum EA Scoping Methodology Technical Reference Architecture Platform Taxonomy Standards Information Base Integrated Information Infrastructure Reference Model EA Board Architecture Compliance Architecture Contracts Architecture Governance Architecture Maturity Models EA Patterns EA Principles EA Skills OTHER FRAMEWORKS

4. TOGAF and CBDI-SAE Compared Mature, federated SOA organization with managed service assets delivering improved ROI. The right balance between IT efficiency and innovation. Integrated IT strategy across the extended enterprise. Better return on ROI. Outcomes Enterprise and solution architects; business analysts, project and program managers, designers, asset managers, test managers, version managers. Enterprise Architects Users Defined process to integrate with other frameworks and methods Designed to integrate with other frameworks and methodologies Openness Based on detailed SOA meta concept model. Tasks, techniques and deliverable templates etc link to meta model for consistency. UML Profile guides architecture & design asset management. Reference models for: - technical reference model - Integrated Information Integration Reference Model Integrity SOA, SO Broad set of application styles Application style Business driven SOA Boundaryless information flow Vision SOA Adoption, Business design, Enterprise architecture, solution architecture, provisioning, legacy planning, delivery, governance, delivery management Enterprise Architecture and delivery governance Life cycle Detailed guidance on process, task, technique, deliverable, templates, model formats, and meta data for service architecture to delivery Detailed guidance on inputs, outputs, steps in EA Depth in technical reference architecture Detail Full service life cycle methodology for services, service based solutions and service based organizations Enterprise Architecture and delivery governance Scope CBDI SAE TOGAF Comparative criteria

8. CBDI-SAE TM Frameworks and Models Business View Service Perspective Service Catalog Logical Specification of Software Services Service = Service Specification Service = Software Service Impl. Service Packaging into Automation Units Deployment of Automation Units Service = Run-Time Software Service Business Service = Services offered by Organizational Units Business Service, Context for Software Services Sample Artifacts Specification Implementation Deployment Infrastructure e.g. Network Layout, ESB Infrastructure Service = Run-Time Platform Logical Network Services Physical Network Automation Unit Specification Service Platform Design Specification SO Business Plan Service Implementation Architecture Service Deployment Architecture Service Specification Architecture Technical Architecture Service Specification Service Level Agreement SO Business Model Service Implementation SO Security Architecture Service Portfolio Plan SO Reference Architecture Model SOA Principles Service Life Cycle SOA Meta Model Glossary Architecture Business Deployment Patterns Policy Techniques SOA Views Organization Roles & Structure Funding Models Project Profiles Models Deliverables SOA Best Practice Process Enable Consume Manage Provide Technology Standards Implementation Specification SAE Meta Model PROJECT & SYSTEM OUTCOMES SERVICE OUTCOMES BUSINESS OUTCOMES SERVICE ARCHITECTURE & ENGINEERING PROCESS LEADERSHIP & GOVERNANCE SOA PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT CAPABILITY ARCHITECTURAL CAPABILITY PROCESS / LIFECYCLE CAPABILITY INFRASTRUCTURE CAPABILITY PEOPLE & ORGANIZATION SOA Adoption & Excellence SO Process Coordinated Architecture Scope Solution Assembly/ Implementation Solution Design, Specification & Coordination SO Business Requirements Planning Legacy Transition Planning Service Implementation Solution/Service Deployment Solution/Service Platform Design & Installation Consume Provide Enable [Business Strategy & Architecture] [SOA Adoption Plan] [IT inventory] [IT Strategy & Architecture] [Solution Project Justification, Project Requirements [Deployed Services, Service Discovery Artifacts, Service Access Procs] [Guidelines (e.g. ITIL)] [IT Strategy & Architecture] [Legacy Transition Plan] [Project Charter] [Service Descriptions (part of Project Service Plan/SPP)] [Tested AU Units] [Service Deployment Instructions, Tested AU Units] [Solution Architecture, Component Descriptions, Solution Design Scope] SO Business Improvement [SOA Reference Framework] [Service Platform Design, Tested Service Platform, Installed Service Platform] Solution Certification [Solution Imp Design, Tested Software Solution (deployed)] Solution Provisioning Service Oriented Architecture & Design Solution/Services Platform Architecture [Solution/ Services Platform Architecture] [Project Service Architecture/SPP, SO Security Arch] [Business Models, Business Case for SOA, SO Business Design, Business Solution Requirements] Solution Architecture & Design [Service Specs, Usage SLA] [Solution Deployment Instructions, Tested Software Solution] [Solution Deployment Authorization/(Certified), Solution OLA] Solution/Service Operations & Measurement [Solution & Service Execution Metrics] [Deployed Software Solution] [SO Business Improvement Plan] [Business Results] SOA Adoption Plan Governance & Management Framework Manage [Project Service Plan/ SPP Fragment (approved)] Service Certification Service Provisioning Service Design, Specification & Coordination [Service Specs (approved) , AU Descriptions (approved)] [ Services (published)] [Business Process Execution Metrics] [ SPP, SO Security Architecture] [Project Service Plan] [Solution Design, Solution Test Plans, Component Specs Service Requirements SPP Fragment [Installed Service Platform] [Service Deployment Authorization/ Services (certified) , Service OLA] [(Service Catalog (updated)]] SOA Governance SOA Policy Hierarchy SOA Governance Process SOA Governance Maturity SOA Governance Infrastructure SOA Governance Organization Service Life Cycle Planned Specified Certified Published Operational Retired Being Provisioned Provisioned Archived CBDI-SAE TM SOA Reference Framework

9. CBDI-SAE Knowledgebase Structure - 1 Document Libraries Lists Web Part Pages Menu Model Process Disciplines Architecture Concept Meta Model Type Glossary Service Life Cycle State Discipline Process Unit Task SOA View SOA Best Practice Policy Standard Artifact Technique Pattern Principle Meta Model Package Process Pattern Service Classification

10. CBDI-SAE Knowledgebase Structure - 2 Document Libraries Lists Web Part Pages Menu SOA Adoption & Excellence SOA Governance Roadmap Phase Roadmap Stream SOA Capability SOA Scenarios Governance Capability Governance Framework View Governance Maturity View Capability Dependency Model SOA Policy Category SOA Policy Strategy Area SOA Policy Types SOA Meta Model Service Life Cycle Service Architecture Service Architecture Layer

11. CBDI-SAE Knowledgebase Structure - 3 Document Libraries Lists Web Part Pages Menu Resources Deliverable Templates Project Management Templates Models Capability Dependency Templates Organization Role Project Project Profile Funding Model Presentation Materials Policy Examples Guidance Start Here eLearning Materials

14. SAE Extends TOGAF in core areas of Architecture TOGAF ADM PHASE Objectives Approach Inputs Outputs SAE DISCIPLINE Process Unit Task Technique Pattern Policy Model Deliverable . . .

18. SAE: Key Business View Artifacts - I Rich pictures complemented by matrices that map domains to business concepts and business processes Separation of core concepts and processes into logical subdivisions of the business. May or may not mirror current organization Business Domains Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Ecosystem/Business Context Model (Part of SO Business Model) Products or Services offered by a Business or Organizational Unit and the use of those products or services by their customers and suppliers. BPMN diagrams, UML models including structure diagrams (e.g., package, class, component), behavior diagrams (e.g., Activity or Interaction Diagrams) other proprietary formats Business Goals (Part of SO Business Model) High-level goals of the business and the sub-goals they comprise. UML Object Diagram, other proprietary formats such as Hierarchy Diagram Event Response (Part of SO Business Model) Major business events and the organization’s response to them. BPMN Diagrams, or Activity Diagrams, other proprietary formats Business Process (Part of SO Business Model) Business processes that realize the services offered by the business. BPMN Diagrams, UML Activity Diagrams, other proprietary formats Business Rules A statement that constrains how the business operates. A textual table. More formal rule models use UML Class Diagrams with Constraints (in text or in OCL (Object Constraint Language)) or other proprietary formats Business Concept Model (Part of SO Business Model) High-level information entities that are important at a business level. UML Class Diagrams, ERDs, other proprietary formats with restricted detail

19. SAE: Key Business View Artifacts - II Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Organizational Structure (Often part of SO Business Model) Organizational units and roles therein that comprise a business or enterprise. Organizational Charts, UML Object Diagrams, other proprietary formats Business Case for SOA Justification for migrating to SOA. Key influence over SOA approach and architecture policy. E.g forecast cost and cycle time of delivery and adaptation by class of component and service Textual documents and spreadsheets SO Business Improvement Plan Plan for improving business operations by incorporating services Key driver of architecture decisions that enable agility E.g forecast change cycle time for classes of components and services Textual documents, project schedules, and spreadsheets Business Solution Requirements Solution requirements from a business perspective Textual documents and requirements models SO Business Plan Overall plan for moving the business forward including SO perspectives Composite artifact including SO Business Models, Business Case for SOA, and Business Solution Requirements SO Security Policies (part of SO Security Architecture) Detailed business rules and policies concerning security Textual document(s)

21. SAE - Key Specification View Artifacts Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Service Specification Architecture Complete logical model of the software services and their relationships to solutions, legacy applications and other 3 rd party applications. UML Model including structural diagrams (e.g., package, class, component) and behavioral diagrams (e.g., communication, sequence, state). Service Dependency Diagram (part of Service Specification Model) Architectural layers at a logical level and the structural relationships between the services in these layers. UML Package and Class Diagrams Service Orchestration Diagram (part of Service Specification Architecture ) Interactions between services that collaborate to provide services at a higher level. UML Interaction Diagrams (Communication and/or Sequence Diagrams) Service Information Model (part of Service Specification) Structure of the information used by services at a logical level. UML Class Diagrams or ERD Diagrams Service Description Overview of a service Textual document Service Specification Detailed specification of a particular service including both functional and non-functional requirements Textual document and UML models SO Security Specifications (part of SO Security Architecture) Specifications for security services/mechanisms and how they are used by other services in the architecture Textual documents and UML models

22. Key Implementation View Artifacts Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Service Implementation Architecture Structure of Automation Units and software modules that realize logic services UML model containing structural diagrams (e.g., package, component and class) and behavioral diagrams (e.g., communication and sequence) Solution Implementation Design Structure and orchestration of services that comprise composite applications UML model containing package, class and/or component diagrams Physical Data Model (often part of the Service Implementation Architecture) Physical structure of the data used by the service or set of services UML model containing package and class diagrams Service Message Structure (often part of the Service Implementation Architecture) Structure of messages transferred back and forth during service interactions UML model containing package and class diagrams Service Message Patterns (often part of the Service Implementation Architecture) Typical patterns of messages exchanged during service interactions UML interaction diagrams (communication and/or sequence diagrams) Automation Unit Description Overview description of a particular Automation Unit Textual document Automation Unit Specification Detailed Specification of an Automation Unit Textual document and UML models Solution Implementation Actual software that implements a solution Source code Service Implementation Actual software that implements a service Source code

23. Key Deployment View Artifacts Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Service Deployment Architecture Static structure and interactions of the Automation Units and their deployment to the Nodes on which they will run UML model containing deployment diagrams Runtime Communication Channels (part of the Service Deployment Architecture Communications Channels between the Nodes on which the Automation Units run UML model containing deployment diagrams Service Platform Design Specification (for example ESB) Detailed specification of the Service Platform including the infrastructure services provided by the platform Textual document and UML models

25. Key Technology View Artifacts Key Artifact Focus Typical Format Logical Network and Platform Services Design Model Logical network layout including processing nodes and network nodes, as well as communication channels between them and the services that run thereon. UML models containing class and object diagrams, UML deployment diagrams Technology Dependency Dependencies between technologies used to implement the SOA Textual documents, UML models containing class diagrams (showing dependencies), or other proprietary formats Physical Network Design (part of the Logical Network and Platform Services Design Model) Physical layout of the network Network diagrams in Visio or other proprietary notations, UML models containing class and object diagrams

31. Independent Guidance for Service Architecture and Engineering www.cbdiforum.com www.everware-cbdi.com