5. Defining Terms (for this talk)
• Goals – what you want to achieve
• Strategy – plan for achieving goals
• Tactics – specific activities
• Organizations have purpose, goals
– Business
– Govt agency
– Association
– Non-profit
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
6. Descriptive of Strategy?
Yes
• Rationality
• Logic
• Goals
• Intentionality
• Reasoning
Not so much
• Intuition
• Emotion
• Bias
• Good enough
• Quick
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
7. Myth of the Rational Agent
Choices based on
• All available information
• Probabilities of events
• Potential costs & benefits
Always maximizes utility in
his own interest
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
8. Strategic Thought is not Natural
• Conclusions on few
facts
• Certain we’re right
• Dismiss inconsistent
evidence
• Use heuristics
• Overgeneralize, exhibit
bias
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
9. Who we think we are Who we really are
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
It’s Counterintuitive…
10. • Automatic, effortless, quick
• Largely unconscious,
difficult/impossible to control
• Intuition, expertise, skill
• Does most of the work of thinking
• Controlled, effortful, slow
• Usually conscious
• Logically coherent, rule-governed
• Lazy
• Easily overwhelmed
Two Systems of Thinking
@Seymour188
System 1 System 2
cassandramoorephd
11. Thinking is Hard
• Persuasion, sales,
voting, even behavior
change, appeals to
emotions and values
• It works because our
everyday thought is
based on heuristics,
intuitions, emotions
@Seymour188
13. Algorithms Engage System 2
• Use algorithms
• Explicit consideration
of each component of
a decision
• Leads to more rational
choices
• Important to choose
the right criteria
@Seymour188
14. Surgical Checklist
• Surgery has become so
complicated, expert
surgeons can forget a step
• Expertise is not enough. It
relies on System 1
• Checklists reduce medical
errors dramatically
• Slows the team, engages
System 2
@Seymour188
15. Checklist for Regulatory Impact Analysis
• Changing Federal Regulations
has broad impact, huge cost if
incorrect or incomplete
• Instituted by Cass Sunstein
(Harvard Law faculty) in the
Obama administration
• Requires evidentiary support,
explicit reflection, and reason-
giving
• Provides criteria for deciding
what to do, what NOT to do
RIA (Sample of Questions)
Does the RIA include a reasonably detailed description of
the need for the regulatory action?
Does the RIA include an explanation of how the
regulatory action will meet that need?
Does the RIA use an appropriate baseline?
Is the information in the RIA based on the best
reasonably obtainable scientific, technical, and
economic information and is it presented in an accurate,
clear, complete, and unbiased manner?
Does the RIA explain and support a reasoned
determination that the benefits of the intended
regulation justify its costs (recognizing that some
benefits and costs are difficult to quantify)?
@Seymour188
16. Strategy
Before creating an Experience Strategy, we need
the right criteria for deciding what to do. Criteria
are supplied by business goals.
@Seymour188
18. Seek to Understand the Organization
• Approach with curiosity
– What are their goals? Challenges?
– What do they offer to customers?
– What is the value proposition?
– How do they want the customer to interact with
them?
– How do they differentiate themselves from
organizations with similar offerings?
@Seymour188
19. Business Strategy ala Michael Porter
A collection of activities that an organization chooses to
undertake to deliver a series of (positive, exceptional)
interactions which, when taken together, constitute an (product
or service) offering that is superior in some meaningful, hard-to-
replicate way; that is unique, distinct & distinguishable from that
available from a competitor.
• Replace “is” with “the customer believes”. Knowing what the
customer thinks is the critical support for the whole strategy
• Many products, e.g., Internet service, cable, are essentially
the same. The differentiator can be customer experience
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
20. The Elusive Business Strategy
• Most organizations don’t have an explicit strategy
(please write if you find one!)
• Org strategies are very difficult to write and to agree
upon. Efforts are often abandoned mid-stream
• Usually, you will be hunting for clues about the
implicit goals of the organization
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
21. Hunting for Org (Business) Strategy
• At the organizational level look for
– Vision or mission statements
– ‘About Us’ description
– C-level newsletters, speeches, blogs
– Articles about the organization or their mandate
• At the department level look for
– Department goals, KPIs, success measures
– RFP, proposals for the project
– Vision & scope of project
– Business requirements
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
22. Make Straw Man Goals
• Evaluate the evidence gathered
• Get input from team members
with different perspectives
– Developers, designers, project
managers
• Make a prioritized list of
organizational goals
• Think about which problem or
opportunity each goal addresses
• Be willing to be wrong
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
23. Verify the List with Stakeholders
• Ask stakeholders to evaluate the straw man
– Do they agree with the goals?
– Do they agree with the prioritization?
– Have we left anything out?
– Are there constrains or challenges we haven’t
considered?
• Simply asking “what are your goals?” invites
use of the Homer system.
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
24. Listen with Empathy
• Try to understand stakeholder’s perspective
• Take note of any challenges or dismissals
(we can’t do that because…)
• Remember who is concerned about what
• Note assumptions and opinions about
customer behavior (and test them later)
• Consider making a list of stakeholders with
notes about their concerns
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
25. Revise the Goals List
• Review stakeholder input, note agreement level
• Have problems or opportunities been overlooked?
• Which are short-term vs. long-term goals?
• Consider the broader technology landscape
– Are they missing anything, e.g., a CMS or CRM?
– Are the solutions they’re considering future friendly?
• Goals provide criteria for selecting UX activities
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
27. Thinking about an Experience Strategy
• How can UX help achieve the
business goals?
• What activities will provide
data/evidence?
• Which goal does each UX activity
address?
• How does the activity contribute to
the goal?
• Is the activity the most efficient
way of reaching the goal?
• If it doesn’t contribute in a
meaningful way, don’t do it
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
28. Planning for the Future
@Seymour188
• Strategic plans should look to the future
• Some problems can be solved now, but others
must wait (equipment, time, budget, etc.)
• What are the future challenges likely to be?
• Are today’s solutions readying the
organization to meet future challenges?
cassandramoorephd
29. Formulating the Experience Strategy
• A plan of activities on a timeline
• What each activity will
accomplish – data, evidence
• Why the accomplishment is
important – reason-giving
• How you will measure outcomes
– Contribution to the customer
experience
– Contribution to achieving business
goals
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
30. Communicating the Strategy
• Talk to Homer, not Spock
– Keep it simple
– Connect on an emotional level
– Reference values
– Make it fun
– Tell a story
• Assume people skim text and
look at pictures
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
31. Communication Tools
• Discuss the plan with your team
– Dev, PM, content strategists, product owners, etc.
– Be flexible. Remember, it’s a team effort!
• Make a poster, put it on the wall
– Stakeholders see what you’re doing and when
– Promotes a user-centric mindset
– Provides a context for the customer story you’ll
tell with personas, journey maps, sketches
@Seymour188cassandramoorephd
32. Circling Back to Business Strategy
@Seymour188
• User research provides the foundation for an
evidence-based strategy
• User research can legitimize the value
proposition
• Communication of the findings is crucial
cassandramoorephd
33. What can you do right now?
@Seymour188
• Understand the organization, its goals and
challenges
• Look for problems, pain points
• Offer solutions that align with business goals
and make the connection explicit
cassandramoorephd
34. THANK YOU!
FIN
@Seymour188
Presentation at slideshare.net/SeymourInfoArchitect/ux-strategy-64254598
cassandramoorephd on LinkedIn
@Seymour188 on Twitter
cassandramoorephd
Notas del editor
Taking a more strategic approach to customer/user experience can provide more meaning, enable us to be more influential in our workplaces.
Mapping our UX Strategy to larger goals of the organization expands our sphere of influence, demonstrating that strategic customer experience can effect the bottom line.
I’ll be talking about commercial business, government agencies, and other organizations interchangeably. Most orgs have a purpose for existing and goals they aspire to achieve
Previously economists thought of people as rational agents that always acted in their own self-interest.
Two cognitive psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky demonstrated that our choices, including large investments were anything but strategic.
Danny Kahneman won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002 based on this work, and the field of behavioral economics has since blossomed.
These findings are very counterintuitive. We experience ourselves as Spock-like when it comes to decisions, but we’re actually a bit more like Homer Simpson.
Kahneman proposed a two systems approach – two general families or categories of thinking.
Which is not to say that you have two little homunculi in your head – but naming them makes it easier to think about their characteristics
System 1 is the older system, perfected for escaping predation, surviving in the Serengeti, still the default.
“Anything orange is dangerous” enables you to act quickly when a tiger may be present, but you may also run from a few giraffes.
System 2 – is the rational system, it does math in restaurants. When we talk about cognitive strain we’re referring to System 2.
Not that we can’t think rationally, it’s just that thinking is effortful we have to engage System 2
So how do we engage System 2 in order to think strategically?
Goal is to have a successful army.
Strategy is to identify recruits who exhibit certain traits. Criteria for selection,
Measure predictive value of those criteria
To Err is Human – enormous number of medical errors, even by experts
Goal is fewer medical errors
Strategy is checklist; consideration of each component slows the team down, engages the rational thinking of System 2
Cass Sunstein, a law professor at Harvard and past member of President Obama’s administration instituted a similar procedure. Before making changes to federal regulations, regulators used this checklist to engage System 2 and make more strategic decisions.
Criteria for deciding what to do, what NOT to do
Evidentiary support, reflection, reason-giving
“Deliberative Democracy”
“Evidence-based Medicine”
Cass Sunstein, 2009, Administrator of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs
https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/inforeg/regpol/RIA_Checklist.pdf
Value proposition – that is why the organization believes a customer would want what they’re offering. What benefit do they believe they’re providing to the customer? Valuable customer experience.
Goals – why does this org exist? Created by congressional act?
Challenges can be competition, regulations, mandates
An experience strategy is that collection of activities that an organization chooses to undertake to deliver a series of (positive, exceptional) interactions which, when taken together, constitute an (product or service) offering that is superior in some meaningful, hard-to-replicate way; that is unique, distinct & distinguishable from that available from a competitor.
What we propose to do should be based upon the goals and strategy of the organization
Commoditization – product offered by different sellers does not differ (e.g., corn)
Differentiation – an offer that is superior in some meaningful
Will collect lots of evidence from artifacts, review it, evaluate it, look for themes, constraints
Note differences of opinion and check those out with stakeholders
Your list will help stakeholders think through the question. You’re engaging them in reasoning, asking them to be Spock for a few minutes. Consider asking why the goals are important or why they prioritized as they did.
Note that you’re verifying the criteria you’ve selected
Be on the lookout for revelations about problems, e.g., we can’t do anything about it because…
Consider a list of stakeholders and their concerns
Simply asking “what are your goals?” invites use of the Homer system. Quick answers, no reflection, heuristics, over-confidence.
Your list will help stakeholders think through the question. You’re engaging them in reasoning, asking them to be Spock for a few minutes. Consider asking why the goals are important or why they prioritized as they did.
Note that you’re verifying the criteria you’ve selected
Be on the lookout for revelations about problems, e.g., we can’t do anything about it because…
Consider a list of stakeholders and their concerns
Simply asking “what are your goals?” invites use of the Homer system. Quick answers, no reflection, heuristics, over-confidence.
Align the experience strategy with the business strategy.
Strategic plans should look to the future
Are you doing research that will evidence for decision making next year?
As you think through each of these, you’re engaging your Spock System, you are thinking strategically.
Suggesting innovative ways of solving business problems.
Examining the meaningfulness of each thing you’re proposing.
Flow state is quite possible
Discussion provides an opportunity for creating a shared vision
Alerts you to time and/or budget constraints
Is your user experience an expression of your brand values (and vice versa)?
Is your vision for user experience consistently understood and supported across your business?
Without research it’s a war of opinions. But data must be reliable, findings should be replicable. The story you tell needs to resonate with stakeholders in the organization. For example, video of customer responses has a big impact.
Do users see the value you see in your product?
Not everyone can leave here and become a strategist, but I hope we’ve provided some tools for thinking strategically. Look for the problems, find solutions
When you offer solutions that resonate, you’re more likely to influence the work you’re assigned, find it more meaningful, and may even be invited to the strategy table
Not everyone can leave here and become a strategist, but I hope we’ve provided some tools for thinking strategically. Look for the problems, find solutions
When you offer solutions that resonate, you’re more likely to influence the work you’re assigned, and may even be invited to the strategy table
http://www.slideshare.net/SeymourInfoArchitect/ux-strategy-64254598