SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 67
Descargar para leer sin conexión
THROUGH THE EYES
OF LOVE AND JUSTICE:
Revisioning a
MULTICULTURAL
Humanistic Psychology
Shelly P. Harrell, Ph.D., Keynote Address
Society for Humanistic Psychology
Santa Barbara, CA - March 3, 2013
GRATITUDE
• David Elkins
• Louis Hoffman
• Theopia Jackson
• My Students
• New Friends
“Wake up Everybody”
by John Legend, The Roots, & Common
THE QUESTIONS
• Is Humanistic Psychology inherently multicultural? If so, how is
that made credible through explicit discussion and visibility in
theory and practice?
• Does the community of Humanistic Psychology include the
multiple cultural expressions of humanity?
• Does the intellectual and theoretical work of humanistic
psychology include voices that speak to what it means to be
human and the existential dilemmas of our humanness from
diverse cultural traditions?
• Is the practice of Humanistic Psychology relevant to serving the
well-being of the marginalized, disenfranchised, and oppressed?
• In what ways is Humanistic Psychology in substantive dialogue
with those in psychology whose work focuses on diversity and
social justice? (e.g., Divisions 9, 27, 35, 44, 45, 48)
• Do the writings and work of Humanistic Psychology demonstrate
an understanding of systemic oppression, power, and privilege?
• Has Humanistic Psychology been willing to step into the
discomfort of differences and engage in some meaningful self-
evaluation around these issues?
On Walking the Talk
“One of the great tragedies of life is that [people] seldom
bridge the gulf between practice and profession, between
doing and saying. A persistent schizophrenia leaves so
many of us tragically divided against ourselves. On the one
hand, we proudly profess certain sublime and noble
principles, but on the other hand, we sadly practice the very
antithesis of these principles. How often are our lives
characterized by a high blood pressure of creeds and an
anemia of deeds!” -Martin Luther King, Jr.
OUR HUMAN
ADVENTURE
What more have we to give one
another than our 'truth' about
our human adventure as
honestly and as openly as we
know how?
-Rabbi Saul Rubin
THROUGH THE EYES
OF LOVE AND JUSTICE
Some of my favorite
“Love” Books
All About Love: New Visions by bell hooks
Strength to Love by Martin Luther King, Jr.
The Art of Loving by Erich Fromm
Love and Will by Rollo May
"When I speak of love … I am speaking
of that force which all of the great
religions have seen as the supreme
unifying principle of life. Love is
somehow the key that unlocks the door
which leads to ultimate reality."
~Martin Luther King, Jr.
“Love is the only sane and
satisfactory answer to the
problem of human
existence.”
–Erich Fromm
Agape Love
Love of humanity, of all of our sisters and
brothers in the human family
Experiencing and connecting to the “all”
through the uniqueness of the “one”
Deeply feeling the common humanity of
our oneness while honoring the different
cultural expressions and manifestations
of that oneness that makes us whole and
complete
Love is….
“Love is…” by Common
How beautiful love can be
On the streets love is hard to see
It's a place I got to be
Loving you is loving me
How beautiful love can be
On the streets love is hard to see
Gotta reach that frequency
Loving you is loving me
INTERCONNECTEDNESS
&
COMMUNITY
The African Ethic of Ubuntu
“I am because we are and because we are I am”.
Every living system (people, animals,
nature) exists in relationship to and
interdependent with every other living
system past, present, and future
We thrive and grow optimally when we are
in relationship
Bishop Desmond Tutu drew upon this
traditional African ethic of “Ubuntu” in his
work on reconciliation in South Africa
“My humanity is
bound up in yours,
for we can only be
human together.”
~Bishop Desmond Tutu
Nobles’ Extended Self
(African-centered Psychology)
 Nobles’ Extended Self (traditional African
conception of self)
African self-concept centered in “we”
“I am because we are and because we are I
am” (Ubuntu)
“We” includes family, community, culture,
ancestors, descendants, nature, spirit
We are not separate, finite beings and we can
only achieve our fullness through
connectedness and community
Implies the inseparability of the person,
environment, spirit, and nature
“There is no better place
to learn the art of loving
than in community.”
~bell hooks
What is a community?
 Locality-based Communities – based on geography
 Relational Communities
 People, groups, and organizations whose connections
are based upon commonalities or identification and are
not limited by place or geography
 Four types of relational communities
 Identity community
 Religion, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation
 Common interest community
 Social or recreational clubs, occupation
 Task-oriented community
 School, workplace, committee
 Collective power structure community
 Labor unions, advocacy groups

Some Characteristics of Communities
 Communities are dynamic systems that change
 The value and significance of our community memberships can
vary widely and can change over time and context
 Communities and subcommunities emerge and become
inactive as contexts and needs change
 Communities have identity
 Shaped and maintained by community narratives (stories) that
are shared and passed down
 Communities have intracommunity variability
 Communities are comprised of diverse individuals
 Issues of macrobelonging and microbelonging
 Intersectionality issues
 People within communities have multiple needs and priorities
Significance of
Community
 Sarason (1974) – A Psychological Sense of Community
 The loneliness and alienation that emerges from
individualism is the defining problem of many Western
societies
 Loss or dilution of strong community connections is the
most destructive dynamic in people’s lives
 Psychological well-being, quality of life, meaning and purpose,
self-esteem and positive behaviors are strongly related to
having a sense of belongingness, connection, and
identification with something larger than oneself
Sense of Community
 Early work of Sarason (1974) and McMillan & Chavis (1986)
 Connection to a larger whole characterized by sharing an emotional
bond or common condition; perception of similarity
 A feeling of belonging, identification, and security in relationship to a
larger group
 Acknowledgement of interdependence, a sense of being “in this
together”, that others “have my back”
 Feeling that members matter to one another and to the group
 Mutuality of Influence; being willing to contribute to the community and
be changed by the community
 Shared faith that members needs will be met through commitment to be
together
JUSTICE
Stand by Sly and The Family Stone
• Stand
In the end you'll still be you
One that's done all the things you set out to do
Stand
There's a cross for you to bear
Things to go through if you're going anywhere
Stand
For the things you know are right
It s the truth that the truth makes them so uptight
Stand
All the things you want are real
You have you to complete and there is no deal
Stand. stand, stand…Stand. stand, stand…Stand
You've been sitting much too long
There's a permanent crease in your right and wrong
Stand
There's a midget standing tall
And the giant beside him about to fall
Stand. stand, stand…Stand. stand, stand…Stand
They will try to make you crawl
And they know what you're saying makes sense and all
Stand
Don't you know that you are free
Well at least in your mind if you want to be
Power and Oppression
 Steven Biko: “The most potent weapon of the oppressor is the mind of
the oppressed.”
 Maulana Karenga (1996): “Power is the ability to define someone’s
else’s reality and get them to believe it as if it were their own.”
 Expressions of Power
 Riger (1993)
 Power Over – control and dominate
 Power To – pursue goals and opportunities
 Power From - resistance
 Satyagraha – Power of truth (Gandhi)
 Principles, active and openly expressed resistance to
oppression that is coupled with appeals to social justice
 Power With- capacity to build groups, bring people together , create
community
Revolution begins
with the self,
in the self.”
~Toni Cade Bambara
“The struggle has always
been inner, and is played out
in outer terrains. Awareness
of our situation must come
before inner changes, which
in turn comes before changes
in society.” ~Gloria Anzaldua
Critical Consciousness &
Sociopolitical Development
 Critical consciousness
The ability to observe, analyze, and reflect upon one’s
own conditions and the conditions of others
Independent thinking that challenges the status quo
 Critical consciousness is necessary to develop
independent thinking in the context of an
oppressive status quo
 Psychological empowerment
 Self-determination
 Independent thinking
 Critical thinking
Sociopolitical Development
 The developmental process of awareness and action
related to social asymmetries and inequities in valued
social, political, and economic resources
 Roderick Watts developed a developmental stage
framework to address the psychological process of
internalized oppression. Stages include: Acritical,
Adaptive, Precritical, Critical, and Liberation
 Involvement in social justice and community activism
requires higher stages of sociopolitical development;
speaks to the relationship between psychological
oppression and the maintainence of an oppressive
status quo
DIFFERENCE
We are all
AT THE SAME TIME
Like ALL others
Like SOME others
Like NO others
(paraphrased from Murray & Kluckhohn)
5 Ds of Difference
(Harrell, 1990)
• Denial
• Defensiveness
• Distancing
• Devaluing
• Discovery
From MLKs “Where do we go from here?”
Now, we got to get this thing right. What is needed
is a realization that power without love is
reckless and abusive, and that love without power is
sentimental and anemic. Power at its
best, power at its best is love implementing the
demands of justice, and justice
at its best is love correcting everything that stands
against love…. I have also decided to stick with love,
for I know that love is ultimately the only answer to
[hu]mankind's problems.
~Martin Luther King, Jr. (1967)
“Where is the Love?”by The Black Eyed Peas
What's wrong with the world, mama, People livin' like they ain't got no mamas
I think the whole world addicted to the drama,
Only attracted to things that'll bring you trauma
Overseas, yeah, we try to stop terrorism, But we still got terrorists here livin'
In the USA, the big CIA, The Bloods and The Crips and the KKK
But if you only have love for your own race,
Then you only leave space to discriminate
And to discriminate only generates hate,
And when you hate then you're bound to get irate, yeah
Madness is what you demonstrate,
And that's exactly how anger works and operates
Man, you gotta have love just to set it straight,
Take control of your mind and meditate;
Let your soul gravitate to the love, y'all
People killin', people dyin‘, Children hurt and you hear them cryin'
Can you practice what you preach, And would you turn the other cheek
Father, Father, Father help us, Send some guidance from above
'Cause people got me, got me questionin‘, Where is the love (Love)….
It just ain't the same, always unchanged,
New days are strange, is the world insane
If love and peace are so strong,
Why are there pieces of love that don't belong
Nations droppin' bombs, Chemical gasses fillin' lungs of little ones
With ongoin' sufferin' as the youth die young, So ask yourself is the lovin'
really gone
So I could ask myself really what is goin' wrong,
In this world that we livin' in people keep on givin' in
Makin' wrong decisions, only visions of them dividends
Not respectin' each other, deny thy brother
A war is goin' on but the reason's undercover
Where is the love?
The truth is kept secret, it's swept under the rug
If you never know truth then you never know love
Where's the love, y'all, come on (I don't know) Where's the truth, y'all, come on (I don't know)
Where's the love, y'all
People killin', people dyin‘, Children hurt and you hear them cryin'
Can you practice what you preach, And would you turn the other cheek
I feel the weight of the world on my shoulder, As I'm gettin' older, y'all, people gets colder
Most of us only care about money makin‘, Selfishness got us followin' our wrong direction
Wrong information always shown by the media, Negative images is the main criteria
Infecting the young minds faster than bacteria, Kids wanna act like what they see in the cinema
Yo', whatever happened to the values of humanity,
Whatever happened to the fairness in equality
Instead of spreading love we're spreading animosity,
Lack of understanding, leading us away from unity
That's the reason why sometimes I'm feelin' under, That's the reason why sometimes I'm feelin' down
There's no wonder why sometimes I'm feelin' under, Gotta keep my faith alive till love is found
Now ask yourself…Where is the love?
One world, one world (We only got), One world, one world (That's all we got),
One world, one world
And something's wrong with it (Yeah), Something's wrong with it (Yeah)
Something's wrong with the wo-wo-world, yeah
We only got (One world, one world)
Love and Justice
“Authentic commitment to social
justice is born out of
love…Enduring social justice
work is sustained by
love…Living social justice is the
highest expression of love.”
Harrell (2013)
Despair & Emotional
Expression
• Some of the most heart wrenching expressions of
despair come through the music and poetry of people
from oppressed groups
• African American tradition – “Soul” Music…music that
speaks to, touches the soul
• Speaks to potential role of expressive arts therapies in
therapy
Motherless Child by Paul Robeson
Sometimes I feel like a motherless child
A long ways from home
Oh my brother… A long ways from home
Sometimes I feel like I’m almos’ gone
A long ways from home
Oh my brother… A long ways from home
“The Message”
by GrandMaster Flash and the Furious Five
Broken glass everywhere
People pissing on the stairs, you know they just don't care
I can't take the smell, I can't take the noise
Got no money to move out, I guess I got no choice
Rats in the front room, roaches in the back
Junkies in the alley with the baseball bat
I tried to get away, but I couldn't get far
Cause a man with a tow-truck repossessed my car
Don't push me cause I'm close to the edge
I'm trying not to lose my head, ah huh-huh-huh
It’s like a jungle out there it makes me wonder
How I keep from going under
Existential Themes?
Implications for Therapy?
“I’ll Rise”by Ben Harper
You may write me down in history, With your bitter twisted lies
You may trod me down in the very dirt, And still like the dust I'll rise
Does my happiness upset you
Why are you best with gloom
Cause I laugh like I've got an oil well, Pumpin' in my living room
So you may shoot me with your words, You may cut me with your eyes
And I'll rise I'll rise I'll rise
Out of the shacks of history's shame, Up from a past rooted in pain
I'll rise I'll rise I'll rise
Now did you want to see me broken, Bowed head and lowered eyes
Shoulders fallen down like tear drops, Weakened by my soulful cries
Does my confidence upset you, Don't you take it awful hard
Cause I walk like I've got a diamond mine, Breakin up in my front yard
So you may write me down in history, With your bitter twisted lies
You may trod me down in the very dirt, And still like the dust I'll rise
Does my happiness upset you? Why are you beset with gloom?
Cause I laugh like I've got a goldmine, Diggin' up in my living room
•
Is there a place for these
stories, this soundtrack in
Humanistic Psychology?
Re-Visioning a
MULTICULTURAL
Humanistic Psychology
An Attempt at Integration:
Love, Justice, and Humanistic
Psychology
in Multicultural Context
First sentence of APA
Multicultural Guidelines
(APA Policy, 2002)
“All individuals exist in social, political,
historical and economic contexts and
psychologists are increasingly called
upon to understand the influence of
these contexts on individuals’
behavior.”
44
Importance of Ecological and
Contextual Variables
 Oppressive and unhealthy contexts can block the natural
human tendency toward optimal growth and
development and present challenges that impede optimal
human functioning and well-being, compromise or
confuse personal and collective identity, and suppress or
misdirect health-promoting behaviors.
Context affects conditions of living and access to
societal resources
Context determines exposure to particular societal,
sociocultural, and community narratives that define
self, acceptable roles, as well as appropriate
thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
Context impacts options for support and coping
Context influences opportunities for affirmation and
validation of person and community
45
A PsychoEcoCultural Perspective
 The Psychoecocultural perspective
approaches the study of the human mind,
experience, behavior, and transformation as
manifestations of the ongoing interplay
between interconnected psychological,
biological, ecological, and cultural
processes. (Harrell, 2012)
Contextualization of the Person
 Emerging from this literature is the theoretical position
that a decontextualized “self” is meaningless; our
existence is meaningful only in relationship (to
others, to community, to culture, to physical settings,
to ecological contexts, to nature, to God)
 Descriptions of human behavior and transformation
must reference the dynamic Person-Culture-
Context complex in order to fully capture the
transactional processes of the person as a living
system embedded in and interdependent with other
persons, as well as multiple cultural and ecological
systems
Humanistic-Existential Connections
 “The world…is the natural setting of, and field for, all my thoughts
and all my explicit perceptions…Man is in the world and only in the
world does he know himself.” –Maurice Merleau-Ponty
 “Understanding of one’s existence as such is always an
understanding of the world.” –Martin Heidegger
 “[A] bare subject without a world never ‘is’.” -Martin Heidegger
 “Through the Thou a man becomes I.” –Martin Buber
 “Be that self which one truly is.” -Soren Kierkegaard
48
Existential Psychology & Context
Existential Psychology is basically about the
human dilemma of making sense of our own
existence and its finitude while developing the
will to create meaning, live authentically,
manifest our highest potentialities, and fully
experience our lives in the context of the world in
which we live.
An individual’s relationship to the ultimate
concerns of existence is expressed through the
struggle to function optimally within the multiple
human created ecological systems and cultural
influences that create the contexts of our lives.
The Existential Paradox
and Related Ideas
• Face finitude and live life fully…Living fully and authentically
as we are dying…facing death and life simultaneously
• Related to the African-centered approach of diunital logic
o Both/and (vs. either/or) thinking and understanding of issues;
approaching a problem holding on to the co-existence of
opposite forces
o Identification of multiple truths in opposing perspectives and
that seemingly conflicting viewpoints can co-exist
• Dialectics- A process involving two seeming opposite or
contradictory energies or elements that acknowledges the
tension between them and seeks to hold and investigate that
tension
Dialectical Tensions in
Psychotherapy
• The dialectic of “Acceptance and Change” in
third-wave behavioral therapies (DBT, ACT,
IBCT)
• Dialectical tensions in relationships (identified by
Baxter) include: autonomy-connection,
predictability-novelty, openness-closedness,
inclusion-seclusion, conventionality-uniqueness,
and revelation-concealment
“Set Me Free” by Gina Rene
“I know the truth hurts but the pain is
gonna set me free.” –Gina Rene
African Existentialism
 African existentialism emphasizes the struggle to express
one’s authentic essence within contexts that actively work
against validation and affirmation of the person and
community.
 Fanon’s writings and Ralph Ellison’s “The Invisible Man”
reflect African existentialism
 According to the scholar Lewis Gordon
African Existentialism is about “The
existential demand for recognizing the
situation or lived-context of Africana people’s
“being-in-the-world”
For people of African descent, existential
questions relate to issues of identity and
liberation in the context of oppression
53
Paolo Freire’s Work as a Bridge between
Humanistic Psychology and the
Psychoecocultural Perspective
 Brazilian educator, author of Pedagogy of the Oppressed
 Committed to social injustice centered on illiterate peasants
 Among the influences on his thoughts and writings include
existential philosophy, French personalist Emmanuel Mounier,
Spanish poet and educator Miguel de Unamuno, psychiatrist
Erich Fromm, and activists Che Guevara & Martin Luther King Jr.
 Criticized for the connection of his writings with socialist thought
 Strong influence on Latin American Liberation Psychology
 Referenced in Community Psychology and Multicultural
Psychology
 KEY IDEAS: Humanization, Culture of Silence, Duality of the
Oppressed, LiberatingProblem-posing Education (vs. The
Banking Concept of Education), Critical Consciousness, Critical
Dialogue, Dialogic Action, Praxis
54
Freire’s Humanization through Dialogue
 Humanization as the process of relating to others as subjects
capable of knowing affirmation of one’s dignity and worth as a
human being. Dehumanization is the objectification of others as
“things”
 Humanization of both the oppressed and oppressor is required for
liberation and transformation
 Praxis is the methodology of reflection and action
 Dialogue is the humanizing process of learning and knowing
through sharing lived experience; it is the vehicle for
transformation of both the individual and the collective
 Requires mutual trust and is a horizontal relationship grounded in
love, humility and faith; faith in humankind is a requirement for
dialogue
 Alienation and oppression thwart, block, and impair our power as
human beings to create and transform ourselves and the world.
Experiencing oneself as subject vs. object (to be named and acted
upon) can be reborn through dialogue
55
Psychoecocultural and Humanistic Perspectives:
Nine Points of Convergence and Extension
1. Primacy on authentic relationship as the pathway to the
development of strong sense of self and optimal growth is
consistent with diverse cultural constructs such as Ubuntu,
Personalismo, Lovingkindness, etc. (Rogers)
2. Ultimate goal of becoming “fully human” reflects an individual level
of analysis. This can be extended to the idea of valuing the full
expression of collective humanity and diversity of humankind
3. Facilitating experiential awareness can be expanded in a
collective context to the idea of critical consciousness (Freire and
Liberation Psychology), which is also about attending more deeply
to what is observed and experienced in the world around us
4. Emphasis on meaning, purpose, and strengths in the context of
suffering; movement from oppression and powerlessness to
meaning, liberation, freedom, and choice (Frankl, May, African
Existentialism)
56
5. The human dilemma of “Being-in-the-World” as a focus of existentially-grounded
work can be broadened to incorporate more attention to “world” processes at
the sociopolitical and institutional levels of analysis (most existential approaches
emphasize the “Being” part)
6. Humanistic approaches have typically taken a less pathologizing view than
other therapeutic orientations, a view that has privileged and honored the client’s
freedom, choice, and self-determination; this implies a more collaborative and
empowering approach consistent with multicultural and community psychology
7. Humanistic perspectives converge with multicultural, feminist, community, and
liberation psychology in actively challenging rigid, symptom-focused,
medical model, cookbook (manualized) approaches
8. Most forms of therapy that have emerged from Humanistic Psychology
emphasize experiential processes such that attunement with and responsiveness
to the needs of the client are primary; this is consistent with the concept of
culturally-syntonic practice
9. The transpersonal view opens space for extending the conception of the person
to include the spiritual dimension of human experience that is so central to
many cultures
57
Benefits of the Psychoecocultural and
Humanistic-Existential Integration
 The integration of the psychoecocultural and humanistic-
existential perspectives has the following benefits:
 The concept of “Being-in-the-World” is consistent with
conceptualizing culture and context as central players in
the human condition
 An expansion of focus not only to the development of our
highest individual potentialities but also to our highest
collective potentialities in the context of community and as
citizens of the world.
 Optimal expression of our “humanness” through wellness
processes is more meaningfully pursued and successfully
facilitated when culturally and contextually situated
 Adversity and pain are conceptualized as an inevitable part
of human existence through the experience of “Being in the
World” and provide ongoing opportunities for liberation,
empowerment, and transformation
58
Humanistic Concepts through a
Multicultural Lens
 NECESSARY & SUFFICIENT CONDITIONS (“The Soil”)
 UNCONDITIONAL POSITIVE REGARD
 EMPATHY
 FULLY FUNCTIONING HUMAN
 INCONGRUENCE AND CONGRUENCE
 EXPERIENCING
 AUTHENTICITY
 ACTUALIZING TENDENCY
 SELF-ACTUALIZATION
 EXISTENTIAL PARADOX
 EXISTENTIAL GIVENS
 MEANING AND PURPOSE
 FREEDOM AND RESPONSIBILITY
Contextualized
Humanistic
Intervention
(CHI)
Contextualized Humanistic
Intervention
An Integrative Multicultural-Humanistic approach
that emphasizes the interconnectedness of
persons, contexts, and culture
thus expanding the base traditions of
Humanistic and Multicultural Psychologies
and their respective families.
Ultimately, CHI is about optimizing the full
expression of our humanity and the diversity of
humankind towards the elevation of our collective
functioning and well-being.
61
Three Core Emergent Ideas from
Culture-Centered Psychologies
Three common themes among culture-
centered and indigenous psychologies
1. Concepts of interrelatedness, connectedness,
and oneness
2. Centrality of spirituality
3. Challenge of achieving liberation, positive
identity, and optimal functioning in the context
of multiple threats and blocks embedded in the
conditions of living
62
CULTURE
“The superordinate context in which human experience,
functioning, and transformation occur by providing the
fundamental and organizing foundation for interpreting
and living in the world.”
~Wade Nobles
“Culture is learned, expressed, and passed along
through a vast network of shared material, social, and
ideological structures including ideas, values, beliefs,
sensibilities, social roles, language, communication
patterns, physical artifacts, rituals, and symbols.”
~David Matsumoto
63
CULTURE IS…
Embedded in our Environmental Contexts
Internalized into our Beliefs, Values, & Thoughts
Expressed through our Choices and Behaviors
 Culture can be demographically-based (e.g., ethnic culture, gay culture)
or experientially-based (e.g., occupational culture, 12-step culture)
 Individuals are exposed to and internalize multiple cultural influences
which intersect in particular ways to create identity
 Culture functions as an organizing and linking process between persons
and contexts, as well as being manifested in the transactions between
them
 The inclusion of culture in the analysis of human experience, behavior,
and transformation facilitates the identification of constructs, methods,
and strategies that enhance the effectiveness of applied work in diverse
cultural contexts
64
The Integrative and Foundational Role of Culture
THE QUESTIONS…AGAIN
• Is Humanistic Psychology inherently multicultural? If so, how is
that made credible through explicit discussion and visibility in
theory and practice?
• Does the community of Humanistic Psychology include the
multiple cultural expressions of humanity?
• Does the intellectual and theoretical work of humanistic
psychology include voices that speak to what it means to be
human and the existential dilemmas of our humanness from
diverse cultural traditions?
• Is the practice of Humanistic Psychology relevant to serving the
well-being of the marginalized, disenfranchised, and oppressed?
• In what ways is Humanistic Psychology in substantive dialogue
with those in psychology whose work focuses on diversity and
social justice? (e.g., Divisions 9, 27, 35, 44, 45, 48)
• Do the writings and work of Humanistic Psychology demonstrate
an understanding of systemic oppression, power, and privilege?
• Has Humanistic Psychology been willing to step into the
discomfort of differences and engage in some meaningful self-
evaluation around these issues?
My journey of despair
and hope during this
conference….
“We Shall Overcome”
by Mahalia Jackson
We shall overcome, we shall overcome,
We shall overcome someday;
Oh, deep in our hearts, we do believe,
We shall overcome someday.
We shall all have peace, We shall all have peace,
We shall all have peace someday;
Oh, deep in our hearts, I do believe,
We shall all have peace one day.
We will all be free, We will all be free,
We will all be free someday;
Oh, deep in our hearts, We do believe,
We shall all be free one day.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Liberalism in the Philippines
Liberalism in the PhilippinesLiberalism in the Philippines
Liberalism in the PhilippinesFnf Manila
 
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptx
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptxUnit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptx
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptxssuser375063
 
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionPositive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionNorlyn Traje
 
Traditional knowledge in the philippines
Traditional knowledge in the philippinesTraditional knowledge in the philippines
Traditional knowledge in the philippinesErnesto Empig
 
Humanities 101 Art Appreciation
Humanities 101 Art AppreciationHumanities 101 Art Appreciation
Humanities 101 Art AppreciationEl Cid
 
Notes in Philippine Politics and Governance
Notes in Philippine Politics and GovernanceNotes in Philippine Politics and Governance
Notes in Philippine Politics and GovernanceJerlyn Mae Quiliope
 
Women in the Philippines
Women in the PhilippinesWomen in the Philippines
Women in the PhilippinesRuby Wilson
 
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate Change
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate ChangeUnit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate Change
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate ChangeMiss Chey
 
Filipino culture and values
Filipino culture and valuesFilipino culture and values
Filipino culture and valuesdancinglady023
 
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITY
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITYBELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITY
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITYMa Alvaro
 
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...Enjielou
 
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...hanzjennicaenonbombita
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Liberalism in the Philippines
Liberalism in the PhilippinesLiberalism in the Philippines
Liberalism in the Philippines
 
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptx
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptxUnit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptx
Unit 1 Meaning and Relevance of History.pptx
 
Human Acts
Human ActsHuman Acts
Human Acts
 
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionPositive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
 
Institutional Perspectives
Institutional PerspectivesInstitutional Perspectives
Institutional Perspectives
 
Traditional knowledge in the philippines
Traditional knowledge in the philippinesTraditional knowledge in the philippines
Traditional knowledge in the philippines
 
Installation Art
Installation ArtInstallation Art
Installation Art
 
Humanities 101 Art Appreciation
Humanities 101 Art AppreciationHumanities 101 Art Appreciation
Humanities 101 Art Appreciation
 
Notes in Philippine Politics and Governance
Notes in Philippine Politics and GovernanceNotes in Philippine Politics and Governance
Notes in Philippine Politics and Governance
 
How to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique ArtHow to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique Art
 
Women in the Philippines
Women in the PhilippinesWomen in the Philippines
Women in the Philippines
 
Shintoism
ShintoismShintoism
Shintoism
 
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate Change
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate ChangeUnit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate Change
Unit 4: Planetary Networks: Climate Change
 
Global Migration
Global MigrationGlobal Migration
Global Migration
 
Filipino culture and values
Filipino culture and valuesFilipino culture and values
Filipino culture and values
 
Philippines Art
Philippines ArtPhilippines Art
Philippines Art
 
Handouts 1 artists and artisans
Handouts 1 artists and artisansHandouts 1 artists and artisans
Handouts 1 artists and artisans
 
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITY
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITYBELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITY
BELIEF CONCEPTUAL AND AESTHETIC VALUE ELEMENT OF COMMUNITY
 
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...all about Painting  (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
all about Painting (definition, elements, types, styles, history of Philippi...
 
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...
How have Contemporary Artist Expanded the Range of Medium and Techniques they...
 

Destacado

Forgive Thy Neighbor
Forgive Thy NeighborForgive Thy Neighbor
Forgive Thy NeighborTullia
 
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - Pakistan
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - PakistanFoundation of Women & Youth Agape - Pakistan
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - PakistanRazzaq i
 
if god is one, then why so many religions
if god is one, then why so many religionsif god is one, then why so many religions
if god is one, then why so many religionsKrishna Ram
 
Discovering Your Purpose
Discovering Your PurposeDiscovering Your Purpose
Discovering Your PurposeKenBoa.org
 
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010Radu Iacob
 
Benefits Of Team Spirit
Benefits Of  Team  SpiritBenefits Of  Team  Spirit
Benefits Of Team SpiritToptexsyria
 
The Art of Conversation
The Art of Conversation The Art of Conversation
The Art of Conversation krissylovess
 
Knowledge Management in Project-Based Organizations
Knowledge Management in Project-Based OrganizationsKnowledge Management in Project-Based Organizations
Knowledge Management in Project-Based OrganizationsOlivier Serrat
 
The Importance of Team Spirit
The Importance of Team SpiritThe Importance of Team Spirit
The Importance of Team SpiritRaihan Sayeed
 
Power in the Workplace - Natasha Hansman
Power in the Workplace - Natasha HansmanPower in the Workplace - Natasha Hansman
Power in the Workplace - Natasha HansmanNatasha Hansman
 
Communication and art of listening
Communication and art of listening Communication and art of listening
Communication and art of listening gayathri2srcm
 
The Art Of Listening
The Art Of  ListeningThe Art Of  Listening
The Art Of Listeningmongyamba
 

Destacado (20)

Love splintered
Love splinteredLove splintered
Love splintered
 
Forgive Thy Neighbor
Forgive Thy NeighborForgive Thy Neighbor
Forgive Thy Neighbor
 
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - Pakistan
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - PakistanFoundation of Women & Youth Agape - Pakistan
Foundation of Women & Youth Agape - Pakistan
 
Interfaith Harmony Week 2012
Interfaith Harmony Week 2012Interfaith Harmony Week 2012
Interfaith Harmony Week 2012
 
if god is one, then why so many religions
if god is one, then why so many religionsif god is one, then why so many religions
if god is one, then why so many religions
 
Discovering Your Purpose
Discovering Your PurposeDiscovering Your Purpose
Discovering Your Purpose
 
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010
Theology of love presentation 17 12-2010
 
Ambassador for Peace Principles
Ambassador for Peace PrinciplesAmbassador for Peace Principles
Ambassador for Peace Principles
 
Benefits Of Team Spirit
Benefits Of  Team  SpiritBenefits Of  Team  Spirit
Benefits Of Team Spirit
 
Art of conversation
Art of conversationArt of conversation
Art of conversation
 
The Art of Conversation
The Art of Conversation The Art of Conversation
The Art of Conversation
 
Team spirit
Team spiritTeam spirit
Team spirit
 
Knowledge Management in Project-Based Organizations
Knowledge Management in Project-Based OrganizationsKnowledge Management in Project-Based Organizations
Knowledge Management in Project-Based Organizations
 
The Importance of Team Spirit
The Importance of Team SpiritThe Importance of Team Spirit
The Importance of Team Spirit
 
Power in the Workplace - Natasha Hansman
Power in the Workplace - Natasha HansmanPower in the Workplace - Natasha Hansman
Power in the Workplace - Natasha Hansman
 
Communication and art of listening
Communication and art of listening Communication and art of listening
Communication and art of listening
 
The Art Of Listening
The Art Of  ListeningThe Art Of  Listening
The Art Of Listening
 
Symphony Of Love
Symphony Of  LoveSymphony Of  Love
Symphony Of Love
 
Art of listening
Art of listeningArt of listening
Art of listening
 
Will power
Will powerWill power
Will power
 

Similar a THROUGH THE EYES OF LOVE AND JUSTICE

Transcendentalism.ppt
Transcendentalism.pptTranscendentalism.ppt
Transcendentalism.pptssuser76f021
 
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptx
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptxUTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptx
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptxKryzzleTritz
 
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...Jill Morris
 
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdfChristine Love
 
Young Adult Literature
Young Adult LiteratureYoung Adult Literature
Young Adult LiteratureMary Hendra
 
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learning
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learningPerspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learning
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learningalleekatt
 
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptx
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptxslide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptx
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptxArslanRaees
 
Queering Open Pedagogy
Queering Open PedagogyQueering Open Pedagogy
Queering Open PedagogyJesse Stommel
 
Hofstede's cultural dimensions
Hofstede's cultural dimensionsHofstede's cultural dimensions
Hofstede's cultural dimensionsawidzinska
 
Existential psychotherapy
Existential psychotherapyExistential psychotherapy
Existential psychotherapyAoun Ali
 
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, Australia
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, AustraliaThe Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, Australia
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, AustraliaRick Hanson
 

Similar a THROUGH THE EYES OF LOVE AND JUSTICE (20)

Humanities 31
Humanities 31Humanities 31
Humanities 31
 
Humanities 31
Humanities 31Humanities 31
Humanities 31
 
Humanities 31
Humanities 31Humanities 31
Humanities 31
 
Transcendentalism.ppt
Transcendentalism.pptTranscendentalism.ppt
Transcendentalism.ppt
 
It's all about bodies.pptx
It's all about bodies.pptxIt's all about bodies.pptx
It's all about bodies.pptx
 
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptx
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptxUTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptx
UTS - The Self, Society, and Culture.pptx
 
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...
Looking Through a Natural Systems Lens: Culture, Diversity and Differentiatio...
 
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf
500 Word Essay On Responsibility.pdf
 
Interpretive
InterpretiveInterpretive
Interpretive
 
Feminist Pedagogies
Feminist PedagogiesFeminist Pedagogies
Feminist Pedagogies
 
Young Adult Literature
Young Adult LiteratureYoung Adult Literature
Young Adult Literature
 
Cultural competency in the real world cheives
Cultural competency in the real world cheivesCultural competency in the real world cheives
Cultural competency in the real world cheives
 
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learning
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learningPerspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learning
Perspectives of anti oppressive education in adult learning
 
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptx
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptxslide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptx
slide-1-topic-2-week-7-8issues-in-ccc.pptx
 
Queering Open Pedagogy
Queering Open PedagogyQueering Open Pedagogy
Queering Open Pedagogy
 
PHILOE_1.PPT
PHILOE_1.PPTPHILOE_1.PPT
PHILOE_1.PPT
 
Hofstede's cultural dimensions
Hofstede's cultural dimensionsHofstede's cultural dimensions
Hofstede's cultural dimensions
 
Existential psychotherapy
Existential psychotherapyExistential psychotherapy
Existential psychotherapy
 
C1-Lesson-2.pptx
C1-Lesson-2.pptxC1-Lesson-2.pptx
C1-Lesson-2.pptx
 
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, Australia
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, AustraliaThe Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, Australia
The Neurodharma of Love and Power - Rick Hanson - Openground, Australia
 

Más de Shelly Harrell

Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018
Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018
Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018Shelly Harrell
 
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019Shelly Harrell
 
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...Shelly Harrell
 
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentation
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentationHarrell - Meditation with Soul presentation
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentationShelly Harrell
 
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - Harrell
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - HarrellMultidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - Harrell
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - HarrellShelly Harrell
 
APA2018 Harrell Soulfulness poster final
APA2018   Harrell Soulfulness poster finalAPA2018   Harrell Soulfulness poster final
APA2018 Harrell Soulfulness poster finalShelly Harrell
 
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)Shelly Harrell
 
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...Shelly Harrell
 
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...Shelly Harrell
 
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...Shelly Harrell
 
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for Groups
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for GroupsCollective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for Groups
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for GroupsShelly Harrell
 
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative Change
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative ChangeThe 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative Change
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative ChangeShelly Harrell
 
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...Shelly Harrell
 
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...Shelly Harrell
 
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)Shelly Harrell
 
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-Being
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-BeingLiving Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-Being
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-BeingShelly Harrell
 
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural Supervision
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural SupervisionCompetencies and Strategies for Multicultural Supervision
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural SupervisionShelly Harrell
 
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...Shelly Harrell
 
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...Shelly Harrell
 
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 Conference
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 ConferenceHarrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 Conference
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 ConferenceShelly Harrell
 

Más de Shelly Harrell (20)

Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018
Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018
Harrell "I Got Soul" Workshop at ACMHE 2018
 
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019
Harrell Soulfulness presentation at NMCS 2019
 
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...
African-centered cultural considerations for contemplative practices (ce symp...
 
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentation
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentationHarrell - Meditation with Soul presentation
Harrell - Meditation with Soul presentation
 
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - Harrell
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - HarrellMultidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - Harrell
Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (WPPA 2018) - Harrell
 
APA2018 Harrell Soulfulness poster final
APA2018   Harrell Soulfulness poster finalAPA2018   Harrell Soulfulness poster final
APA2018 Harrell Soulfulness poster final
 
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)
Harrell - PEaCE Person Environment Culture Transactional Framework 2018 (rev3)
 
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...
Culture and Context Adaptations in the Development of a Resilience-Oriented S...
 
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...
Awareness, Allies, and Action: The Three Pillars of Resilience as a Culturall...
 
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...
Building Resilience and Promoting Wellness Through Person-in-Culture-in-Conte...
 
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for Groups
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for GroupsCollective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for Groups
Collective Wisdom Emergence (CWE): A Communal-Contemplative Practice for Groups
 
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative Change
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative ChangeThe 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative Change
The 12 Ds: Diversity Principles for Interaction and Transformative Change
 
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...
Beyond Sensitivity: Integrating Culture and Context in the Psychological Care...
 
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...
Psychoecocultural Flexibility: A More Explicit Culture- and Context- Consciou...
 
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)
Introducing the Multidimensional Well-Being Assessment (MWA)
 
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-Being
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-BeingLiving Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-Being
Living Positive Psychology: Focus, Flow, & Well-Being
 
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural Supervision
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural SupervisionCompetencies and Strategies for Multicultural Supervision
Competencies and Strategies for Multicultural Supervision
 
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...
Getting Some R&R: The "Resilience and Reconnection" Group Intervention as a P...
 
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...
Communal, Contemplative, and Empowerment Processes: Culturally-Syntonic Pract...
 
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 Conference
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 ConferenceHarrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 Conference
Harrell - Practicing PEaCE- UCLA IPNB 2016 Conference
 

THROUGH THE EYES OF LOVE AND JUSTICE

  • 1. THROUGH THE EYES OF LOVE AND JUSTICE: Revisioning a MULTICULTURAL Humanistic Psychology Shelly P. Harrell, Ph.D., Keynote Address Society for Humanistic Psychology Santa Barbara, CA - March 3, 2013
  • 2. GRATITUDE • David Elkins • Louis Hoffman • Theopia Jackson • My Students • New Friends
  • 3. “Wake up Everybody” by John Legend, The Roots, & Common
  • 4. THE QUESTIONS • Is Humanistic Psychology inherently multicultural? If so, how is that made credible through explicit discussion and visibility in theory and practice? • Does the community of Humanistic Psychology include the multiple cultural expressions of humanity? • Does the intellectual and theoretical work of humanistic psychology include voices that speak to what it means to be human and the existential dilemmas of our humanness from diverse cultural traditions? • Is the practice of Humanistic Psychology relevant to serving the well-being of the marginalized, disenfranchised, and oppressed? • In what ways is Humanistic Psychology in substantive dialogue with those in psychology whose work focuses on diversity and social justice? (e.g., Divisions 9, 27, 35, 44, 45, 48) • Do the writings and work of Humanistic Psychology demonstrate an understanding of systemic oppression, power, and privilege? • Has Humanistic Psychology been willing to step into the discomfort of differences and engage in some meaningful self- evaluation around these issues?
  • 5. On Walking the Talk “One of the great tragedies of life is that [people] seldom bridge the gulf between practice and profession, between doing and saying. A persistent schizophrenia leaves so many of us tragically divided against ourselves. On the one hand, we proudly profess certain sublime and noble principles, but on the other hand, we sadly practice the very antithesis of these principles. How often are our lives characterized by a high blood pressure of creeds and an anemia of deeds!” -Martin Luther King, Jr.
  • 6. OUR HUMAN ADVENTURE What more have we to give one another than our 'truth' about our human adventure as honestly and as openly as we know how? -Rabbi Saul Rubin
  • 7. THROUGH THE EYES OF LOVE AND JUSTICE
  • 8. Some of my favorite “Love” Books All About Love: New Visions by bell hooks Strength to Love by Martin Luther King, Jr. The Art of Loving by Erich Fromm Love and Will by Rollo May
  • 9. "When I speak of love … I am speaking of that force which all of the great religions have seen as the supreme unifying principle of life. Love is somehow the key that unlocks the door which leads to ultimate reality." ~Martin Luther King, Jr.
  • 10. “Love is the only sane and satisfactory answer to the problem of human existence.” –Erich Fromm
  • 11. Agape Love Love of humanity, of all of our sisters and brothers in the human family Experiencing and connecting to the “all” through the uniqueness of the “one” Deeply feeling the common humanity of our oneness while honoring the different cultural expressions and manifestations of that oneness that makes us whole and complete
  • 13. “Love is…” by Common How beautiful love can be On the streets love is hard to see It's a place I got to be Loving you is loving me How beautiful love can be On the streets love is hard to see Gotta reach that frequency Loving you is loving me
  • 15. The African Ethic of Ubuntu “I am because we are and because we are I am”. Every living system (people, animals, nature) exists in relationship to and interdependent with every other living system past, present, and future We thrive and grow optimally when we are in relationship Bishop Desmond Tutu drew upon this traditional African ethic of “Ubuntu” in his work on reconciliation in South Africa
  • 16. “My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human together.” ~Bishop Desmond Tutu
  • 17. Nobles’ Extended Self (African-centered Psychology)  Nobles’ Extended Self (traditional African conception of self) African self-concept centered in “we” “I am because we are and because we are I am” (Ubuntu) “We” includes family, community, culture, ancestors, descendants, nature, spirit We are not separate, finite beings and we can only achieve our fullness through connectedness and community Implies the inseparability of the person, environment, spirit, and nature
  • 18. “There is no better place to learn the art of loving than in community.” ~bell hooks
  • 19. What is a community?  Locality-based Communities – based on geography  Relational Communities  People, groups, and organizations whose connections are based upon commonalities or identification and are not limited by place or geography  Four types of relational communities  Identity community  Religion, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation  Common interest community  Social or recreational clubs, occupation  Task-oriented community  School, workplace, committee  Collective power structure community  Labor unions, advocacy groups 
  • 20. Some Characteristics of Communities  Communities are dynamic systems that change  The value and significance of our community memberships can vary widely and can change over time and context  Communities and subcommunities emerge and become inactive as contexts and needs change  Communities have identity  Shaped and maintained by community narratives (stories) that are shared and passed down  Communities have intracommunity variability  Communities are comprised of diverse individuals  Issues of macrobelonging and microbelonging  Intersectionality issues  People within communities have multiple needs and priorities
  • 21. Significance of Community  Sarason (1974) – A Psychological Sense of Community  The loneliness and alienation that emerges from individualism is the defining problem of many Western societies  Loss or dilution of strong community connections is the most destructive dynamic in people’s lives  Psychological well-being, quality of life, meaning and purpose, self-esteem and positive behaviors are strongly related to having a sense of belongingness, connection, and identification with something larger than oneself
  • 22. Sense of Community  Early work of Sarason (1974) and McMillan & Chavis (1986)  Connection to a larger whole characterized by sharing an emotional bond or common condition; perception of similarity  A feeling of belonging, identification, and security in relationship to a larger group  Acknowledgement of interdependence, a sense of being “in this together”, that others “have my back”  Feeling that members matter to one another and to the group  Mutuality of Influence; being willing to contribute to the community and be changed by the community  Shared faith that members needs will be met through commitment to be together
  • 24. Stand by Sly and The Family Stone • Stand In the end you'll still be you One that's done all the things you set out to do Stand There's a cross for you to bear Things to go through if you're going anywhere Stand For the things you know are right It s the truth that the truth makes them so uptight Stand All the things you want are real You have you to complete and there is no deal Stand. stand, stand…Stand. stand, stand…Stand You've been sitting much too long There's a permanent crease in your right and wrong Stand There's a midget standing tall And the giant beside him about to fall Stand. stand, stand…Stand. stand, stand…Stand They will try to make you crawl And they know what you're saying makes sense and all Stand Don't you know that you are free Well at least in your mind if you want to be
  • 25. Power and Oppression  Steven Biko: “The most potent weapon of the oppressor is the mind of the oppressed.”  Maulana Karenga (1996): “Power is the ability to define someone’s else’s reality and get them to believe it as if it were their own.”  Expressions of Power  Riger (1993)  Power Over – control and dominate  Power To – pursue goals and opportunities  Power From - resistance  Satyagraha – Power of truth (Gandhi)  Principles, active and openly expressed resistance to oppression that is coupled with appeals to social justice  Power With- capacity to build groups, bring people together , create community
  • 26. Revolution begins with the self, in the self.” ~Toni Cade Bambara
  • 27. “The struggle has always been inner, and is played out in outer terrains. Awareness of our situation must come before inner changes, which in turn comes before changes in society.” ~Gloria Anzaldua
  • 28. Critical Consciousness & Sociopolitical Development  Critical consciousness The ability to observe, analyze, and reflect upon one’s own conditions and the conditions of others Independent thinking that challenges the status quo  Critical consciousness is necessary to develop independent thinking in the context of an oppressive status quo  Psychological empowerment  Self-determination  Independent thinking  Critical thinking
  • 29. Sociopolitical Development  The developmental process of awareness and action related to social asymmetries and inequities in valued social, political, and economic resources  Roderick Watts developed a developmental stage framework to address the psychological process of internalized oppression. Stages include: Acritical, Adaptive, Precritical, Critical, and Liberation  Involvement in social justice and community activism requires higher stages of sociopolitical development; speaks to the relationship between psychological oppression and the maintainence of an oppressive status quo
  • 30. DIFFERENCE We are all AT THE SAME TIME Like ALL others Like SOME others Like NO others (paraphrased from Murray & Kluckhohn)
  • 31. 5 Ds of Difference (Harrell, 1990) • Denial • Defensiveness • Distancing • Devaluing • Discovery
  • 32. From MLKs “Where do we go from here?” Now, we got to get this thing right. What is needed is a realization that power without love is reckless and abusive, and that love without power is sentimental and anemic. Power at its best, power at its best is love implementing the demands of justice, and justice at its best is love correcting everything that stands against love…. I have also decided to stick with love, for I know that love is ultimately the only answer to [hu]mankind's problems. ~Martin Luther King, Jr. (1967)
  • 33. “Where is the Love?”by The Black Eyed Peas What's wrong with the world, mama, People livin' like they ain't got no mamas I think the whole world addicted to the drama, Only attracted to things that'll bring you trauma Overseas, yeah, we try to stop terrorism, But we still got terrorists here livin' In the USA, the big CIA, The Bloods and The Crips and the KKK But if you only have love for your own race, Then you only leave space to discriminate And to discriminate only generates hate, And when you hate then you're bound to get irate, yeah Madness is what you demonstrate, And that's exactly how anger works and operates Man, you gotta have love just to set it straight, Take control of your mind and meditate; Let your soul gravitate to the love, y'all
  • 34. People killin', people dyin‘, Children hurt and you hear them cryin' Can you practice what you preach, And would you turn the other cheek Father, Father, Father help us, Send some guidance from above 'Cause people got me, got me questionin‘, Where is the love (Love)…. It just ain't the same, always unchanged, New days are strange, is the world insane If love and peace are so strong, Why are there pieces of love that don't belong Nations droppin' bombs, Chemical gasses fillin' lungs of little ones With ongoin' sufferin' as the youth die young, So ask yourself is the lovin' really gone So I could ask myself really what is goin' wrong, In this world that we livin' in people keep on givin' in Makin' wrong decisions, only visions of them dividends Not respectin' each other, deny thy brother A war is goin' on but the reason's undercover Where is the love?
  • 35. The truth is kept secret, it's swept under the rug If you never know truth then you never know love Where's the love, y'all, come on (I don't know) Where's the truth, y'all, come on (I don't know) Where's the love, y'all People killin', people dyin‘, Children hurt and you hear them cryin' Can you practice what you preach, And would you turn the other cheek I feel the weight of the world on my shoulder, As I'm gettin' older, y'all, people gets colder Most of us only care about money makin‘, Selfishness got us followin' our wrong direction Wrong information always shown by the media, Negative images is the main criteria Infecting the young minds faster than bacteria, Kids wanna act like what they see in the cinema Yo', whatever happened to the values of humanity, Whatever happened to the fairness in equality Instead of spreading love we're spreading animosity, Lack of understanding, leading us away from unity That's the reason why sometimes I'm feelin' under, That's the reason why sometimes I'm feelin' down There's no wonder why sometimes I'm feelin' under, Gotta keep my faith alive till love is found Now ask yourself…Where is the love? One world, one world (We only got), One world, one world (That's all we got), One world, one world And something's wrong with it (Yeah), Something's wrong with it (Yeah) Something's wrong with the wo-wo-world, yeah We only got (One world, one world)
  • 36. Love and Justice “Authentic commitment to social justice is born out of love…Enduring social justice work is sustained by love…Living social justice is the highest expression of love.” Harrell (2013)
  • 37. Despair & Emotional Expression • Some of the most heart wrenching expressions of despair come through the music and poetry of people from oppressed groups • African American tradition – “Soul” Music…music that speaks to, touches the soul • Speaks to potential role of expressive arts therapies in therapy
  • 38. Motherless Child by Paul Robeson Sometimes I feel like a motherless child A long ways from home Oh my brother… A long ways from home Sometimes I feel like I’m almos’ gone A long ways from home Oh my brother… A long ways from home
  • 39. “The Message” by GrandMaster Flash and the Furious Five Broken glass everywhere People pissing on the stairs, you know they just don't care I can't take the smell, I can't take the noise Got no money to move out, I guess I got no choice Rats in the front room, roaches in the back Junkies in the alley with the baseball bat I tried to get away, but I couldn't get far Cause a man with a tow-truck repossessed my car Don't push me cause I'm close to the edge I'm trying not to lose my head, ah huh-huh-huh It’s like a jungle out there it makes me wonder How I keep from going under
  • 41. “I’ll Rise”by Ben Harper You may write me down in history, With your bitter twisted lies You may trod me down in the very dirt, And still like the dust I'll rise Does my happiness upset you Why are you best with gloom Cause I laugh like I've got an oil well, Pumpin' in my living room So you may shoot me with your words, You may cut me with your eyes And I'll rise I'll rise I'll rise Out of the shacks of history's shame, Up from a past rooted in pain I'll rise I'll rise I'll rise Now did you want to see me broken, Bowed head and lowered eyes Shoulders fallen down like tear drops, Weakened by my soulful cries Does my confidence upset you, Don't you take it awful hard Cause I walk like I've got a diamond mine, Breakin up in my front yard So you may write me down in history, With your bitter twisted lies You may trod me down in the very dirt, And still like the dust I'll rise Does my happiness upset you? Why are you beset with gloom? Cause I laugh like I've got a goldmine, Diggin' up in my living room •
  • 42. Is there a place for these stories, this soundtrack in Humanistic Psychology?
  • 43. Re-Visioning a MULTICULTURAL Humanistic Psychology An Attempt at Integration: Love, Justice, and Humanistic Psychology in Multicultural Context
  • 44. First sentence of APA Multicultural Guidelines (APA Policy, 2002) “All individuals exist in social, political, historical and economic contexts and psychologists are increasingly called upon to understand the influence of these contexts on individuals’ behavior.” 44
  • 45. Importance of Ecological and Contextual Variables  Oppressive and unhealthy contexts can block the natural human tendency toward optimal growth and development and present challenges that impede optimal human functioning and well-being, compromise or confuse personal and collective identity, and suppress or misdirect health-promoting behaviors. Context affects conditions of living and access to societal resources Context determines exposure to particular societal, sociocultural, and community narratives that define self, acceptable roles, as well as appropriate thoughts, feelings, and behaviors Context impacts options for support and coping Context influences opportunities for affirmation and validation of person and community 45
  • 46. A PsychoEcoCultural Perspective  The Psychoecocultural perspective approaches the study of the human mind, experience, behavior, and transformation as manifestations of the ongoing interplay between interconnected psychological, biological, ecological, and cultural processes. (Harrell, 2012)
  • 47. Contextualization of the Person  Emerging from this literature is the theoretical position that a decontextualized “self” is meaningless; our existence is meaningful only in relationship (to others, to community, to culture, to physical settings, to ecological contexts, to nature, to God)  Descriptions of human behavior and transformation must reference the dynamic Person-Culture- Context complex in order to fully capture the transactional processes of the person as a living system embedded in and interdependent with other persons, as well as multiple cultural and ecological systems
  • 48. Humanistic-Existential Connections  “The world…is the natural setting of, and field for, all my thoughts and all my explicit perceptions…Man is in the world and only in the world does he know himself.” –Maurice Merleau-Ponty  “Understanding of one’s existence as such is always an understanding of the world.” –Martin Heidegger  “[A] bare subject without a world never ‘is’.” -Martin Heidegger  “Through the Thou a man becomes I.” –Martin Buber  “Be that self which one truly is.” -Soren Kierkegaard 48
  • 49. Existential Psychology & Context Existential Psychology is basically about the human dilemma of making sense of our own existence and its finitude while developing the will to create meaning, live authentically, manifest our highest potentialities, and fully experience our lives in the context of the world in which we live. An individual’s relationship to the ultimate concerns of existence is expressed through the struggle to function optimally within the multiple human created ecological systems and cultural influences that create the contexts of our lives.
  • 50. The Existential Paradox and Related Ideas • Face finitude and live life fully…Living fully and authentically as we are dying…facing death and life simultaneously • Related to the African-centered approach of diunital logic o Both/and (vs. either/or) thinking and understanding of issues; approaching a problem holding on to the co-existence of opposite forces o Identification of multiple truths in opposing perspectives and that seemingly conflicting viewpoints can co-exist • Dialectics- A process involving two seeming opposite or contradictory energies or elements that acknowledges the tension between them and seeks to hold and investigate that tension
  • 51. Dialectical Tensions in Psychotherapy • The dialectic of “Acceptance and Change” in third-wave behavioral therapies (DBT, ACT, IBCT) • Dialectical tensions in relationships (identified by Baxter) include: autonomy-connection, predictability-novelty, openness-closedness, inclusion-seclusion, conventionality-uniqueness, and revelation-concealment
  • 52. “Set Me Free” by Gina Rene “I know the truth hurts but the pain is gonna set me free.” –Gina Rene
  • 53. African Existentialism  African existentialism emphasizes the struggle to express one’s authentic essence within contexts that actively work against validation and affirmation of the person and community.  Fanon’s writings and Ralph Ellison’s “The Invisible Man” reflect African existentialism  According to the scholar Lewis Gordon African Existentialism is about “The existential demand for recognizing the situation or lived-context of Africana people’s “being-in-the-world” For people of African descent, existential questions relate to issues of identity and liberation in the context of oppression 53
  • 54. Paolo Freire’s Work as a Bridge between Humanistic Psychology and the Psychoecocultural Perspective  Brazilian educator, author of Pedagogy of the Oppressed  Committed to social injustice centered on illiterate peasants  Among the influences on his thoughts and writings include existential philosophy, French personalist Emmanuel Mounier, Spanish poet and educator Miguel de Unamuno, psychiatrist Erich Fromm, and activists Che Guevara & Martin Luther King Jr.  Criticized for the connection of his writings with socialist thought  Strong influence on Latin American Liberation Psychology  Referenced in Community Psychology and Multicultural Psychology  KEY IDEAS: Humanization, Culture of Silence, Duality of the Oppressed, LiberatingProblem-posing Education (vs. The Banking Concept of Education), Critical Consciousness, Critical Dialogue, Dialogic Action, Praxis 54
  • 55. Freire’s Humanization through Dialogue  Humanization as the process of relating to others as subjects capable of knowing affirmation of one’s dignity and worth as a human being. Dehumanization is the objectification of others as “things”  Humanization of both the oppressed and oppressor is required for liberation and transformation  Praxis is the methodology of reflection and action  Dialogue is the humanizing process of learning and knowing through sharing lived experience; it is the vehicle for transformation of both the individual and the collective  Requires mutual trust and is a horizontal relationship grounded in love, humility and faith; faith in humankind is a requirement for dialogue  Alienation and oppression thwart, block, and impair our power as human beings to create and transform ourselves and the world. Experiencing oneself as subject vs. object (to be named and acted upon) can be reborn through dialogue 55
  • 56. Psychoecocultural and Humanistic Perspectives: Nine Points of Convergence and Extension 1. Primacy on authentic relationship as the pathway to the development of strong sense of self and optimal growth is consistent with diverse cultural constructs such as Ubuntu, Personalismo, Lovingkindness, etc. (Rogers) 2. Ultimate goal of becoming “fully human” reflects an individual level of analysis. This can be extended to the idea of valuing the full expression of collective humanity and diversity of humankind 3. Facilitating experiential awareness can be expanded in a collective context to the idea of critical consciousness (Freire and Liberation Psychology), which is also about attending more deeply to what is observed and experienced in the world around us 4. Emphasis on meaning, purpose, and strengths in the context of suffering; movement from oppression and powerlessness to meaning, liberation, freedom, and choice (Frankl, May, African Existentialism) 56
  • 57. 5. The human dilemma of “Being-in-the-World” as a focus of existentially-grounded work can be broadened to incorporate more attention to “world” processes at the sociopolitical and institutional levels of analysis (most existential approaches emphasize the “Being” part) 6. Humanistic approaches have typically taken a less pathologizing view than other therapeutic orientations, a view that has privileged and honored the client’s freedom, choice, and self-determination; this implies a more collaborative and empowering approach consistent with multicultural and community psychology 7. Humanistic perspectives converge with multicultural, feminist, community, and liberation psychology in actively challenging rigid, symptom-focused, medical model, cookbook (manualized) approaches 8. Most forms of therapy that have emerged from Humanistic Psychology emphasize experiential processes such that attunement with and responsiveness to the needs of the client are primary; this is consistent with the concept of culturally-syntonic practice 9. The transpersonal view opens space for extending the conception of the person to include the spiritual dimension of human experience that is so central to many cultures 57
  • 58. Benefits of the Psychoecocultural and Humanistic-Existential Integration  The integration of the psychoecocultural and humanistic- existential perspectives has the following benefits:  The concept of “Being-in-the-World” is consistent with conceptualizing culture and context as central players in the human condition  An expansion of focus not only to the development of our highest individual potentialities but also to our highest collective potentialities in the context of community and as citizens of the world.  Optimal expression of our “humanness” through wellness processes is more meaningfully pursued and successfully facilitated when culturally and contextually situated  Adversity and pain are conceptualized as an inevitable part of human existence through the experience of “Being in the World” and provide ongoing opportunities for liberation, empowerment, and transformation 58
  • 59. Humanistic Concepts through a Multicultural Lens  NECESSARY & SUFFICIENT CONDITIONS (“The Soil”)  UNCONDITIONAL POSITIVE REGARD  EMPATHY  FULLY FUNCTIONING HUMAN  INCONGRUENCE AND CONGRUENCE  EXPERIENCING  AUTHENTICITY  ACTUALIZING TENDENCY  SELF-ACTUALIZATION  EXISTENTIAL PARADOX  EXISTENTIAL GIVENS  MEANING AND PURPOSE  FREEDOM AND RESPONSIBILITY
  • 61. Contextualized Humanistic Intervention An Integrative Multicultural-Humanistic approach that emphasizes the interconnectedness of persons, contexts, and culture thus expanding the base traditions of Humanistic and Multicultural Psychologies and their respective families. Ultimately, CHI is about optimizing the full expression of our humanity and the diversity of humankind towards the elevation of our collective functioning and well-being. 61
  • 62. Three Core Emergent Ideas from Culture-Centered Psychologies Three common themes among culture- centered and indigenous psychologies 1. Concepts of interrelatedness, connectedness, and oneness 2. Centrality of spirituality 3. Challenge of achieving liberation, positive identity, and optimal functioning in the context of multiple threats and blocks embedded in the conditions of living 62
  • 63. CULTURE “The superordinate context in which human experience, functioning, and transformation occur by providing the fundamental and organizing foundation for interpreting and living in the world.” ~Wade Nobles “Culture is learned, expressed, and passed along through a vast network of shared material, social, and ideological structures including ideas, values, beliefs, sensibilities, social roles, language, communication patterns, physical artifacts, rituals, and symbols.” ~David Matsumoto 63
  • 64. CULTURE IS… Embedded in our Environmental Contexts Internalized into our Beliefs, Values, & Thoughts Expressed through our Choices and Behaviors  Culture can be demographically-based (e.g., ethnic culture, gay culture) or experientially-based (e.g., occupational culture, 12-step culture)  Individuals are exposed to and internalize multiple cultural influences which intersect in particular ways to create identity  Culture functions as an organizing and linking process between persons and contexts, as well as being manifested in the transactions between them  The inclusion of culture in the analysis of human experience, behavior, and transformation facilitates the identification of constructs, methods, and strategies that enhance the effectiveness of applied work in diverse cultural contexts 64 The Integrative and Foundational Role of Culture
  • 65. THE QUESTIONS…AGAIN • Is Humanistic Psychology inherently multicultural? If so, how is that made credible through explicit discussion and visibility in theory and practice? • Does the community of Humanistic Psychology include the multiple cultural expressions of humanity? • Does the intellectual and theoretical work of humanistic psychology include voices that speak to what it means to be human and the existential dilemmas of our humanness from diverse cultural traditions? • Is the practice of Humanistic Psychology relevant to serving the well-being of the marginalized, disenfranchised, and oppressed? • In what ways is Humanistic Psychology in substantive dialogue with those in psychology whose work focuses on diversity and social justice? (e.g., Divisions 9, 27, 35, 44, 45, 48) • Do the writings and work of Humanistic Psychology demonstrate an understanding of systemic oppression, power, and privilege? • Has Humanistic Psychology been willing to step into the discomfort of differences and engage in some meaningful self- evaluation around these issues?
  • 66. My journey of despair and hope during this conference….
  • 67. “We Shall Overcome” by Mahalia Jackson We shall overcome, we shall overcome, We shall overcome someday; Oh, deep in our hearts, we do believe, We shall overcome someday. We shall all have peace, We shall all have peace, We shall all have peace someday; Oh, deep in our hearts, I do believe, We shall all have peace one day. We will all be free, We will all be free, We will all be free someday; Oh, deep in our hearts, We do believe, We shall all be free one day.