SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 44
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Global Economic Outlook
  by Cecilia Hermansson                                                                     17 August 2011




                   Global growth is slowing – without reforms
                          the world economy is at risk
   Since our spring forecast, economic growth, primarily in the US but more recently in the
    euro zone as well, has slowed. Turbulence in the financial markets has increased and
    confidence is falling. We have revised our global GDP growth forecast downward to
    3.8% this year (4.1%) and expect it to remain just under 4% in 2012 and 2013.
   Our main scenario, which we give a probability of 60%, does not include a new global
    recession, but does anticipate a slower recovery in developed countries due to budget
    austerity. Economically and politically, we seem to be “muddling through”. Emerging
    countries are driving the global economy.
   The risk picture is weighted heavily to the downside. We give a less favourable
    scenario – where global GDP growth falls below 2% – a 30% probability. The debt
    crisis is worsening in the euro zone and causing a major stock market sell-off, currency
    worries and shrinking economies. Even emerging countries don't seem to be immune.
    On the other hand, we can’t totally exclude the possibility of stronger growth, upwards
    of last year's 5%. The probability is low, however, at 10%, and requires newfound faith
    in the political systems in the US, Japan and the euro zone.
   This report identifies the needed reforms in the US, the euro zone, China, emerging
    countries and across national borders. The time for denial is over. We need economic
    policies that will best help us to overcome the debt crisis that Western countries are
    now going through and the overheating that worries emerging countries. The EMU is
    already a transfer union, and a fiscal policy coordinated with the Eurobond market
    would be a more effective solution. Extensive reforms are needed to strengthen growth
    prospects over time. Until then decision-makers will have to apply both the gas and the
    brakes.
                                                                           Cecilia Hermansson


  Contents:                                                                   Page
  1. Our main scenario: Modest growth in spite of everything                    2
  2. An increasingly complex risk picture                                       6
  3. Economic policy: Few tools                                                 9
  4. Our assumptions about the commodity and financial markets                 15
  5. A lot depends on emerging economies                                       23
     - USA                                                                     24
     - China                                                                   28
     - Japan                                                                   30
     - India                                                                   32
     - Brazil                                                                  34
     - Euro zone                                                               36
     - UK                                                                      40
  6. Conclusions for our home markets                                          42




              Economic Research Department, Swedbank AB (publ), SE-105 34 Stockholm, tel +46-8-5859 7740
E-post: ek.sekr@swedbank.se Internet: www.swedbank.com Responsible publishers: Cecilia Hermansson, +46-8-5859 7720.
                Magnus Alvesson, +46-8-5859 3341, Jörgen Kennemar, +46-8-5859 7730, ISSN 1103-4897
1. Our main scenario: Modest growth in
spite of everything
Since our spring forecast, the global economy has continued to                                              Economic pessimism
muddle through while financial unrest has grown, which is clearly                                           and the debt crisis
reflected in the recent stock market sell-off around the world. Two                                         have caused a major
key factors are creating nervousness in the financial markets: the                                          stock sell-off
debt crisis in the US and Europe, and the risk of a new global
recession.

The debt crisis is largely a question of a loss of faith in politicians                                     The US debt crisis is
to manage crises. In the US, it took a long time to negotiate a                                             the fault of politicians
higher debt ceiling, at the same time that the medium-term debt
reduction was insufficient and poorly structured without any tax
increases. A debt downgrade by Standard and Poor’s followed
soon afterward.

In the euro zone, the debt crisis has spread from Greece, Ireland                                           The euro crisis is
and Portugal to larger countries such as Spain and Italy.                                                   worsening as larger
Inadequate institutional frameworks and increased nationalism                                               countries see interest
are undermining the euro cooperation and threatening the                                                    rates rise
currency's future. Interest rate differentials between fiscally
“sound” and “unsound” euro countries have been driven higher.
Poor growth prospects due to the competitive weakness of many
crisis countries also make it harder to manage the budget
consolidation process.

Although the most recent rescue package caused Greek, Irish
and Portuguese interest rates to fall, Spanish and Italian rates
have instead risen. The only way to stop this was for the
European Central Bank to buy bonds from these large countries,
which is hardly a long-term solution.

Interest rate differential between German and other EU 10-year government bonds


                     17,5

                     15,0

                     12,5
 Percentage points




                     10,0
                                                   G reece

                      7,5

                      5,0                      Ireland
                                 S pain
                                                P ortugal
                      2,5        Italy

                      0,0
                                          UK      F rance    B elgium
                                                                        S weden
                     -2,5
                            07     08              09             10                     11
                                                                         S o urce : R e u te rs E co W in




2                                                                       Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
The risk of a double dip recession has grown. In GDP terms, this                                  Growing fears of a
means global growth of less than 2%. The nervousness stems                                        double dip
partly from the purchasing managers indexes around the world,
which are now dangerously close to a reading of 50, signalling
that there is essentially no growth in industry, and partly from the
risk that the stock sell-off will have a negative wealth effect and
reduce confidence, in turn leading to lower global trade,
consumption and investment.

Purchasing managers index in various countries/regions 2006-2011

 65

 60

 55

 50

 45

 40            USA
               UK
               J a p an
 35            E u rola n d
               C h ina
               In d ia
 30            G lo ba l


 25
          07                  08     09               10                    11
                                                           S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in




Despite the worries in the financial markets, we haven’t changed                                 In spite of everything,
our view that the global economy will “muddle through”, although                                 we are sticking by our
we see growth prospects worsening compared with our spring                                       main scenario, i.e.,
forecast. We are also adding something new by extending our                                      that the economy will
forecast to 2013.                                                                                “muddle through”, but
                                                                                                 with weaker growth
Our growth revisions primarily concern the US and Japan,
                                                                                                 compared with last
although the euro zone is also expected to grow more slowly. For
                                                                                                 spring
the US, the key has been a significantly weaker than expected
recovery this year, which can't be blamed on temporary factors
alone, but stems more so from major structural problems in the
labour and housing markets as well as an antagonistic political
climate.

For Japan, the focus has naturally been on the earthquake                                        For 2011, we have
disaster in March, which has reduced activity this year, but is                                  revised the US and
very likely to raise it starting late this year and for several                                  Japan downward...
quarters to come as the reconstruction progresses. We have
also had to revise our GDP growth estimates upward in several
                                                                                                 … but we have also
countries. Germany has strong momentum and is benefitting
                                                                                                 revised the euro zone,
from demand from emerging countries, along with its relative
                                                                                                 through Germany and
fiscal strength, a fairly weak euro and low interest rates. Growth
                                                                                                 France, upward…
slowed more than expected during the second quarter, however,
including in France.




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                   3
China has surprised with stronger growth than we had projected.                        … while China has
Even though we see a slowdown in activity going forward, we                            also surprised on the
have revised our GDP growth forecast upward on the basis of the                        upside to date
strong results. Many emerging countries are raising interest rates
to reduce the risk of overheating, and this is gradually affecting
demand. When developed countries grow more slowly, it also
reduces the risk of a hard landing. In the event of a major
slowdown, economic tools are available, since interest rates can
be cut and the government budget can be allowed to expand.

Global GDP forecast

                              Autumn Forecast         Spring Forecast
GDP growth (%)             2010 2011 2012 2013        2010 2011 2012
US                          3,0   2,1  2,3    2,7      2,9    3,0   3,0

Euro zone:                   1,8   1,7    1,3   1,3    1,7     1,5   1,5
of which: Germany            3,6   2,9    1,8   1,6    3,6     2,4   1,9
           France            1,4   1,5    1,5   1,4    1,6     1,5   1,6
           Italy             1,3   0,8    0,7   1,0    1,3     0,9   1,0
           Spain            -0,1   0,6    0,8   1,2   -0,1     0,3   1,0
UK                           1,3   1,3    1,6   1,8    1,4     1,5   1,8

Japan                        4,0   -0,2   2,8   1,4    4,0     0,6   3,0
China                       10,3    9,0   8,4   8,0   10,3     8,8   8,4
India                       10,4    7,8   7,5   7,5    9,1     8,0   7,5

Brazil                       7,5   3,8    4,1   4,5    7,5     4,3   4,0
Russia                       4,0   4,5    4,4   4,2    4,0     4,6   4,5

Global GDP in PPP            5,0   3,8    3,9   3,8    4,9     4,1   4,2
Global GDP in US dollars     4,1   2,9    3,1   3,1    4,0     3,2   3,4

Sources: National statistics and Swedbank’s forecasts. Note: These countries
represent about 70% of the global economy. To arrive at total GDP growth,
approx. 0.3 percentage points should be added. The World Bank’s weights from
2009 have been used, which raises total figures by 0.1-0.2 percentage points
compared with our spring forecast, when 2009 weights were used.

Developed countries aren't in the same position as emerging                            Few economic tools
economies, since they have already used up their “ammunition”                          are left in the West if
in connection with the financial crisis and the global recession in                    economic conditions
2008-2009. We still feel, however, that a new slowdown in the                          worsen…
global economy like the one we saw after the Lehman Brothers
bankruptcy can be avoided. The global economy is better
prepared today. The financial system, though far from fully
repaired, is not as unbalanced. This time we don’t have as much
debt-financed activity, but there is overcapacity still hanging
around since the last recession. If the stock sell-off ends without
too much damage to the financial sector and the real economy,
the recovery can continue, though at a weaker pace.

Nonetheless, growth prospects can be considered fairly decent                          … but a new Lehman
despite the concerns that currently exist and which the financial                      Brothers-like crash can
markets won't be rid of anytime soon. Following are a number of                        be avoided
additional reasons why we believe that the global economy will
avoid a new recession:
        There is a greater awareness after the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy of
         the costs to the global economy of not addressing financial turbulence
         in time




4                                                            Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
   The financial system, though not yet healthy, is less imbalanced today

       Emerging countries would be affected by a slowdown, but still could
        resort to economic stimulus and gradually increase intraregional trade

       Emerging countries are “catching up,” which means high growth

       Slower global growth is contributing to lower demand for raw materials,
        which is slowing the rise in commodity prices, and in turn inflation

       High productivity and lower cost pressures through wages and raw
        materials are raising corporate profits  paving the way for investment
        and new hirings

       Extremely low interest rates for several years will keep investment
        costs down

       Major need for new investment in infrastructure, energy and climate

However, the recovery will still remain slow in the developed
economies going forward, and here is why:
       Continued debt restructuring in the private sector and low loan demand

       Fading impact of economic stimulus

       Negative impact on growth of budget consolidation

       Higher benchmark interest rates, though further in the future

       Little faith in the ability of politicians to resolve crises

       High volatility in the financial markets is a cause of concern

       Emerging countries will downshift when faced with overheating

       Weak labour markets are hurting consumption

       Stiffer regulation of the financial sector could make capital more
        expensive

       Remaining capacity surplus on a global level

A lot depends on emerging countries to keep the wheels of the                     The global economy is
global economy turning. Yet it is essential for them that                         dependent on
developed countries avoid a new recession and at least maintain                   emerging countries,
some growth in order to preserve demand for imports from                          and vice versa
emerging countries.

We are aware that the risks of an economic decline (or perhaps                    Huge swings make
an improvement) are great. In some sense, the situation is worse                  accurate forecasts
today than after Lehman Brothers if the global economy were to                    difficult – risks have to
truly slide into a new recession, since few economic tools are                    be carefully analysed
available to more developed countries – or they are no longer as
effective. In the next section, we discuss alternative scenarios
and what could trigger them. It’s also worth noting that it is very
difficult to build an accurate scenario for the years ahead at a
time of financial turbulence and when forecasting parameters
change on a daily basis.

In summary, the recovery will continue in our main scenario, but
it will be slower than in our spring forecast, and GDP growth will
average less than 4% in 2011-2013. Emerging countries
represent two thirds of growth during the period, at the same time
that developed countries are struggling with the debt crisis, a
crisis of political faith and structural problems after the financial
crisis, all factors that are restricting growth.



Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                    5
2. An increasingly complex risk picture
When the global economy is in a period of dramatic change, it is
difficult to make reliable forecasts. The assumptions about
various markets, political decisions and the reactions to them can
quickly prove inaccurate.

In the following chapter we discuss a number of factors that can            We also offer one
produce better or worse scenarios than our main scenario.                   better and one worse
What’s difficult is that the risk picture becomes more complex              scenario – but the risk
when risks affect each other. This makes it important not only to           picture is complex and
analyse risks individually, but also the dynamic between them.              skewed
The risk picture is skewed, and the forecast risks on the
downside are greater in number, more serious and larger than
the risks on the upside.

We discuss two scenarios other than our main scenario, one with
slower growth which we give a 30% probability, and a better
scenario with a 10% probability. Our main scenario is also
relatively uncertain, with a probability of 60%.

Main scenario/low growth scenario with global GDP growth
of 3.5-4%

In our main scenario, we have projected global GDP growth in                We give our main
PPP terms of 3.5-4% in 2011-2013. In this scenario, the debt                scenario with 3-4%
crisis doesn’t worsen appreciably in the developed countries, but           growth a 60%
budget austerity does further impact growth prospects. The                  probability, a better
political process, like the global economy, “muddles through”, as           scenario 10% and a
politicians react to the financial turbulence rather than being             worse scenario 30%
proactive. The market jitters will ease, but a significant rebound is
not in sight. Emerging countries will manage to maintain growth
reasonably well with stimulus measures and without major
inflation problems.

A recession scenario with global GDP growth in PPP terms
below 2% next year

       A global economic slowdown is already evident, and
        after a delay the stock market sell-off could lead to even
        lower demand through negative wealth effects and a
        further loss of confidence among households and
        businesses. An accelerated slowdown cannot be
        checked with interest-rate cuts or more expansive
        fiscal policies in developed countries. On the contrary,
        we head toward a period of government debt restructuring
        which constrains growth.

       A new recession in the US becomes more likely after
        the political crisis has worsened, US debt has been
        downgraded and households lose confidence, which
        translates into lower consumption. The labour and
        housing markets are already developing weakly, and if
        growth slows further we could see a negative spiral of
        lower confidence and growth as well as a weaker financial
        sector. The risk of deflation in the US economy will rise if




6                                                 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
growth slows significantly. The Federal Reserve can give
        asset prices a boost through quantitative easing, but
        can do little to strengthen the labour market or growth.
        Fiscal policy is too tight at present and too loose in the
        medium term, but American politicians lack the will and
        courage to do the opposite, which makes it difficult to lift
        the US out of a new recession.

       A new recession in the US would worsen growth
        prospects in the rest of the world, including the BRIC
        countries. Another quantitative easing would again
        increase overheating problems in emerging countries
        due to increased capital inflows to them and to commodity
        markets. This would also make it more difficult for
        emerging countries to rely on an economic stimulus,
        which could spark higher inflation. As a result, they may
        not be able to “rescue” the world this time. Increased
        capital inflows could also lead to a currency war and
        protectionism. Chaotic currency corrections have
        been avoided so far, but could be the outcome if the
        dollar and/or euro weaken substantially.

       An expanded debt crisis in the euro zone that spreads
        to Spain, Italy and even France would be the most
        important catalyst for a global recession by spreading to
        the banking system and real economy. This could be
        the result if political consensus and courage cannot be
        found to address a larger crisis. For example, the EFSF
        won’t be big enough if, in addition to Greece, Ireland
        and Portugal, Spain and Italy also have problems. This
        would require more than 1 500 billion euros, compared
        with the 440 billion euros the fund now has at its disposal.
        The next version of the fund, ESM, won't be enough
        either, at 700 billion euros. If the big euro countries have
        problems, responsibility will rest squarely with AAA-
        rated Germany, France and the Netherlands. The
        sovereign debt crisis would worsen at the same time that
        more banks go bankrupt or are rescued by already highly
        indebted governments. The euro’s collapse would no
        longer be unlikely if the political will can’t be mustered,
        which could be the case if responsibility rests squarely on
        Germany and the Germans tire of financing the rest of the
        euro zone’s overconsumption.

       A huge stock sell-off and anxiety in the financial
        markets that spreads to the real economy and
        banking system would be the outcome of a major debt
        crisis in the euro zone and a new recession in the US.

       Social unrest increases in the wake of high
        unemployment and a sharp decline in future confidence,
        particularly among young people. Violent protests,
        revolts and uprisings, especially in developed countries,
        pave the way for greater populism and nationalism.




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                    7
This leads to even greater political impotence, which in
        turn accelerates the collapse of the euro.

       An expanded crisis in connection with the democracy
        movement in the Arab world spreads to Saudi Arabia,
        causing oil prices to rise and threatening supplies.

       Another reason why commodity prices could stay high
        in a negative growth environment is if emerging countries
        develop fairly strongly with high demand for raw
        materials, while developed countries continue to slide
        backward with an increased risk of a stagflation
        scenario.

       Even if the effects on the global economy shouldn’t be
        overestimated, natural disasters, climate change,
        power shortages and other infrastructure problems,
        war and terror, and, not least, the “unknown factor”
        could also hurt future confidence and set back the
        economy, serving as a catalyst for a major slowdown in
        an already negative growth climate.

    A high-growth scenario with global GDP growth upwards
    of 5% or more next year

       Worries about a new recession turn out to be
        overblown, as evidenced by China's strong export data
        for June. Nervousness in the stock market eases and
        does not have a major impact on the economy. The
        recovery continues to gain momentum once sentiment
        changes from pessimism to optimism.

       The financial system has repaired the large part of its
        balance sheets and is ready to begin lending again, at
        the same time that consumer debt restructurings wind
        down, which leads to increased credit demand.

       Lower commodity prices and cost pressures create
        higher profits. With higher productivity and better
        confidence, the willingness to invest and recruit rebounds.

       Decision-makers find the strength and courage to
        address the current crisis. Instead of reacting, they take
        the initiative with respect to the euro cooperation, the US
        medium-term budget consolidation and Japan’s
        longstanding debt crisis and political crisis. Confidence
        grows when measures have a tangible effect. Politicians
        collaborate nationally across parties and also succeed in
        achieving greater international coordination. Although the
        measures could weaken growth through austerity, there
        are greater positive effects from increased confidence,
        which creates a willingness to invest and consume.




8                                                Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
3. Economic policy: Few tools
The same crisis – but it has expanded to the public sector

When the financial crisis erupted in 2008, few people predicted        The 2008 financial
that the debt problems in the private sector would spread to the       crisis is still alive and
public sector and that it would take years to overcome. An             has mutated
economic recovery may have begun in 2009, but with the
stimulus programs it was hard to tell how self-sustaining it was
and whether it was mostly just a bounceback after the severe
recession.

Countries with balance sheet problems such as the US, the UK,
Spain and Ireland have had a hard time recovering. The balance
sheet recession they face requires major structural changes to
the economy. The focus in their case is on debt restructuring and
less willingness to borrow and consume. Countries without
imbalances, such as Germany, Sweden and Finland, have
recovered reasonably well, in no small part due to strong growth
in Asia, Latin America, the Middle East and Africa.

The problem is that it is the larger industrialised countries          Nearly all industrialised
(Germany accepted) that are now reporting huge budget deficits         countries have debt
and swelling government debt. Countries that originally had            problems
problems with private debt are being joined by others with large
public debt such as Greece, Italy, Belgium and France.

There are fears that the public debt crisis will work its way back
to the private sector through the banking system and that the
next crisis will include not only credit problems but also currency
problems due to a collapse of the euro zone. There is also a risk
that the private and public debt restructuring will adversely affect
growth, without which any debt restructuring will be even more
difficult.

Economic tools – then and now

The realisation that politicians and central bankers do not have       The lack of
the same ammunition to stop a new recession that they did in           ammunition is a
2008/2009 is now baked into expectations. Back then benchmark          cause of concern
rates were cut to nearly zero, quantitative easing reduced long-
term interest rates and drove up stock prices, liquidity was
supplied, and banks were rescued, at the same time that fiscal
policy supported the economy through higher spending and/or
lower taxes.

Stimulus packages were coordinated around the world, including
with emerging countries, which gained a stronger voice through
the G20. It was fairly easy to be a politician, and the financial
markets appreciated the resolute efforts to support the financial
sector, asset markets and the economy. Economic policy has
now become more of a national concern, and in the absence of
any tools it has become much more difficult to be a policymaker.

An important distinction from an economic standpoint is that
interest rates are already low and that it is generally felt that




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                          9
another quantitative easing would have little effect. While an
easing could lead to higher stock prices, they won't last if the
global economy still shows signs of weakness. At the same time
a quantitative easing produces higher capital flows to asset and
commodity markets, with an increased risk of overheating.
Furthermore, demand for government bonds is relatively high in
countries with a balance sheet recession, since many investors
have to seek out safe havens. This is also evident by the decline
in long-term interest rates despite the stock market turbulence.

Another important distinction – including from a political                     A fiscal stimulus may
standpoint – is that there is little or no support for a new fiscal            be economically
stimulus. That includes countries where the financial market                   motivated…
could finance one without exorbitant risk premiums, such as the
US, Japan and the UK. For countries with balance sheet
recessions, monetary policy isn't the important thing, since
businesses and households have less interest in borrowing.
Instead, there is more focus on fiscal policy, especially in
combination with structural reforms, to raise growth potential.

The crisis in the euro zone leaves few alternatives other than                 … but there isn’t a
austerity, even at a point when the recovery is unravelling. For               political consensus
crisis countries, risk premiums are soaring and they are finding
hard to finance their deficits. In the US, the Tea Party movement
has made another stimulus, e.g., to help the labour market
recover more quickly, politically inexpedient. Instead, the
emphasis has shifted to reducing the size of the government
regardless of the potential impact.

Political leadership and economic advice

We have acknowledged that the job of politicians has been made
more difficult by a lack of tools. In addition, the scope of the crisis
has become more complex. When a crisis becomes less acute,
the focus shifts to moral hazards. The economy cannot be
stimulated without considering the driving forces, i.e., whether the
system is encouraging market participants to create or avoid a
similar crisis in the future. Crisis management now seems to
mean biding time. In the euro zone, politicians won't react until
the financial markets act, and usually ineffectually, which has led
to a steady succession of new summit meetings.

A lot of attention is being paid to how voters will react to political         The crisis
decisions. This is especially true in Germany, where the                       management
reluctance to pay for the debt problems of its undisciplined                   capabilities of
neighbours has grown. Nationalism has been allowed to fester,                  politicians leave much
and real problems are being obscured. Instead we hear a lot of                 to be desired …
sloganeering: “The euro is stable and secure” or “The euro won't
collapse”. What aren’t being discussed enough are a vision and
the benefits of an integrated Europe.

If crisis management has been a stumbling block for politicians,                … but contradictory
economists seem to disagree on the right advice, which certainty               advice from
doesn’t make it easier for politicians. Some suggest that another              economists hasn’t
quantitative easing is needed, while others want it to end. Some               helped




10                                                  Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
want to see a fiscal stimulus, while others want to see rapid, far-
reaching austerity programmes.

Another difference compared with 2008/2009 is the labour
market. Unemployment has soared in many crisis countries, or
taken longer to decline. Strikes, demonstrations and violent
unrest are a sign of resignation, anger and fear. Many young
people are at risk of becoming a “forgotten generation” with a
lower standard of living for the rest of their lives. Income gaps
and social tension are growing.

Political developments have become a source of growing                             Forecasters are
concern when assessing the economy. In addition to economics                       becoming increasingly
and psychology, political science has to be included for a holistic                interested in political
perspective. A lack of faith in the political process is affecting the             risks
willingness to invest and consume and hurting stock prices.

One area that has to be better explored is the euro zone’s
development from a democratic standpoint. Can political leaders
agree on changes at summits without having to rely on
commissions to voice objections and make improvements? How
do you create confidence in such a process, which is now
inexorably leading to greater supranationalism as a result of the
debt crisis?

In the US and Japan, the bigger question is how political
campaigns are financed and what it means to political decisions?
In the US, it is never easy to raise taxes on the rich, who not
insignificantly are the ones who pay for election campaigns. The
divide between politicians and voters is growing, which is making
it more difficult to reach effective economic policy decisions.

What’s a sensible policy from an economic perspective?

From an economic perspective, we suggest several measures
below to reduce the risk of a new recession and slow the crisis in
a few years’ time. We focus on developments in the US, the euro
zone, China and other emerging countries. We also offer
suggestions for better international accords.

USA
   President Obama has to explain the seriousness of the recession (a
    balance sheet recession) that the US is in, why the usual tools aren't
    working and why fiscal policy is more important than monetary policy at this
    juncture.

   Another fiscal stimulus targeting growth and jobs is needed in the short
    term, but with tighter budget consolidation in the medium term (the opposite
    of what is now being done). Greater clarity with regard to medium-term
    fiscal policy would strengthen confidence.

   Taxes and spending eventually have to be balanced by expanding the tax
    base, eliminating deductions and increasing taxes on the wealthy. A
    reassessment of the social security system and defence spending is
    needed.

   A new round of quantitative easing is reasonable only if there is another
    recession and deflation signals increase. The introduction of an inflation




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                 11
target to increase the independence of the central bank could improve
     confidence.

    Structural reforms are needed to improve the housing and labour markets,
     with a focus on encouraging hiring and employability, especially among the
     long-term unemployed.

    Reshaping the political system is also important to the economy. This
     includes reforming campaign financing laws, changing the size of voting
     districts and increasing the effectiveness of Congress.

The euro zone
    The currency union is irrevocable, which has to be realised. If a country is
     forced to leave (e.g., Greece), expectations are that its currency (drachma)
     will weaken, leading to capital flight and the spread of the banking crisis to
     other countries. This wouldn't apply to Germany, where expectations are
     the opposite, i.e., that the currency (D-mark) would strengthen and lead to
     capital flows from other countries. Of course in Germany’s case it would
     also mean lower exports due to a stronger currency and the crisis in the
     rest of the union. Rescuing one or more countries is less costly than
     breaking up the entire union.

    The time for denial should be over within the euro zone, including
     Germany. The euro zone’s debt crisis is not only a liquidity crisis but also a
     solvency crisis. Aid packages have to contain better terms and write-offs.
     For Greece, for example, the percentage agreed to on July 21 is too small,
     since its debt ratio will reach 150% of GDP and it will lose a decade in
     terms of GDP growth.

    The state of denial includes the euro zone’s banks. Excessive write-offs
     threaten their balance sheets and they therefore have to recapitalise in
     expectation of the next round of write-offs. The expansion of the European
     Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) is a step in the right direction, since it can
     now (if parliament ratifies the proposal) be used to support banks in crisis,
     not only countries in crisis.

    It is also time for the crisis countries to stop denying reality. They are
     waking up too late after risk premiums have risen and their deficits can no
     longer be financed. The crisis countries have to surprise the financial
     markets with more extensive reforms and a greater focus on growth and
     competitiveness – Italy’s nominal growth must exceed the interest rates on
     its debt. Austerity programmes have to be reasonable based on
     effectiveness and income distribution, with a sensible balance between
     spending cuts and higher taxes. The emphasis must be on eliminating
     bureaucracies, inefficiencies, tax evasion and the informal sector.
     Privatisations are often necessary, not least to raise productivity.

    The European Central Bank (ECB) has adopted a questionable attitude
     toward its responsibility as a lender of last resort. Although the ECB wasn't
     supposed to assume the responsibility of politicians to rescue governments
     in need, it has purchased nearly 100 billion euros in government bonds
     from Greece, Ireland, Portugal and most recently Spain and Italy. This is in
     addition to just over 400 billion euros in outstanding loans to banks in June,
     two thirds of which were to banks in Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain.
     The ECB is protective of its independence and now may have to ask
     governments in the euro zone for a recapitalisation. The question is how
     long the ECB can keep buying Italian and Spanish government obligations
     and where to draw the line, as well as what would happen if it withdraws its
     support?

    The idea that the EFSF, with an estimated size of 440 billion euros (its
     lending capacity is now 225 billion euros), would be big enough even if Italy
     faced major problems is questionable. Instead, the fund would have to
     triple in size to 1 500 billion euros or more to handle a more serious crisis.
     The question then is whether France and Germany could maintain their
     high credit ratings, which they need to get the best interest terms. When




12                                                             Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) takes effect in July 2013,
    conditions will be more stable with a lending capacity of 500 billion euros
    and a total facility of 700 billion euros. Of this amount, 80 billion euros will
    be paid through tax revenues and the rest of the capital can be called in or
    guaranteed.

   The ECB’s bond purchases and risk of recapitalisation, as well as the
    EFSF and ESM stability facilities, clearly show that the euro zone has
    already developed into a transfer union in spite of denials by politicians.
    The question is what’s the best way to facilitate transfers, so that they are
    effective economically and acceptable politically. The currency union has to
    be complemented by greater fiscal coordination, a common bank regulator
    and a central bank that takes responsibility as a lender of last resort. That
    would help to instil the confidence in the common currency that politicians
    are hoping for.

   A Eurobond market doesn't solve the immediate problem of the need for
    debt write-offs and support mechanisms. However, it would certainly go
    hand in hand with greater fiscal coordination and automatic sanctions if
    budget rules aren't followed. A proposal by the think tank Bruegel (“The
    Blue Bond Proposal” by Jacques Depla and Jakob von Weizsäcker) would
    pool Eurobonds up to 60% of GDP (about 5 600 billion euros) and assign
    this tranche – the blue bond – a lower interest rate than the current
    average. Thanks to the increased liquidity, even countries such as
    Germany might find the proposal appealing, and the euro’s position as a
    reserve currency would be strengthened. Member states themselves would
    have to manage debts in excess of 60% of their GDP. Lower liquidity and
    higher interest rates would be an incentive to reduce debt to 60%. This
    proposal addresses moral hazards and maintains budget discipline despite
    the joint Eurobond. In addition, an institution is needed to oversee the
    allocation of blue bonds, so that mismanaged countries are no longer
    allowed to participate. By extension, the federal budget has to expand as
    well and extend its focus beyond common agricultural and structural policy.

   The currency union is an economic project that complements the EU’s
    integration and strengthens the region’s position in the global economy. At
    the same time it is just as much a political project, which requires a political
    commitment to support the cooperation. The problem today is that national
    concerns have taken precedence at the same time that democracy has
    been overshadowed. It wouldn't be unreasonable to transition from poorly
    prepared and less-than-transparent summits to commissions that are given
    more time, produce reports and allow for objections and discussions.
    Complementing the currency union with a fiscal union, a common bank
    regulator and a central bank that takes full responsibility will take time, but
    the important thing is that the process begins with a vision and openness.

China
   A continued – and possibly faster – depreciation of the renminbi is needed
    to choke off inflation and strengthen domestic demand, which would also
    reduce global imbalances.

   It is important that Chinese financial sector and financial markets develop
    and that renminbi becomes convertible, but a deft touch is required, as well
    as a change in China’s growth model. Greater openness is needed for
    foreign players in China’s financial sector, in addition to greater
    opportunities for the Chinese to do business abroad. The process is under
    way, and it is important that it continues.

   Improvements to the social security system would reduce the need to save.
    Domestic demand could then increase and income gaps would eventually
    shrink.

   Increased transparency about debt is important on the part of the national
    government, public authorities and regions. Officially, government debt as a
    share of GDP is less than 20%, but all indications are that total debt is
    higher, 50-70%. To understand how much room there is for a stimulus,




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                    13
debt and inflation data have to be more transparent. Better GDP data is
     also needed.

Emerging economies
    Supply and demand have to be better balanced to avoid overheating, e.g.,
     in India.

    Fiscal policy has to be tightened where signs of overheating are strong and
     growth is high, e.g., Brazil.

    The peg to the dollar has to be removed to avoid external and internal
     imbalances, e.g., the Middle East.

    Subsidies have to be reduced to improve economic drivers and reduce
     budget deficits. This includes increased use of environmentally friendly
     energy, e.g., the Middle East, India.

    Efforts to reduce corruption must be intensified in a number of countries,
     including India, Brazil and China.

Across national borders
    The separation of responsibility between the Basel Committee and the
     Financial Stability Board (FSB) is unclear, as is the line between the
     banking system and the shadow banking system.

    Decisions to regulate capital flows and currencies are made at the national
     level despite international effects.

    The G20 has lost steam. Greater efforts are needed to determine whether
     the Basel III capital requirements are sufficient (which seems doubtful),
     how banking activities should be managed across national borders
     (including large institutions and what happens when they fail), and the role
     of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in managing global imbalances,
     volatile capital flows, exchange rate problems and uncertainties about the
     build-up of foreign exchange reserves.

    The desire of China and other countries to use Special Drawing Rights
     (SDR) as a new currency isn't realistic; it would make more sense to
     prepare for a transition from the dollar as a reserve currency to a
     triumvirate of the dollar, euro and renminbi – a reality in about a decade
     given that China’s financial sector will continue to develop and that there is
     still confidence in the dollar and euro as global currencies.




14                                                          Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
4. Our assumptions about the commodity
and financial markets
In the following, we describe the assumptions that support our
forecast with respect to the commodity, equity, fixed income and
currency markets. The basis for our assumptions consists of
growth and inflation estimates, psychological effects, political
commitments and crisis management expectations. Uncertainty
is great, and developments that significantly deviate from our
assumptions could materially change the economic outlook.

Commodity markets
The rise in commodity prices in 2010 and early this year has                                                            Slower global growth
levelled off. A weaker global economy is lowering demand for                                                            means lower
commodities. Supply problems in commodity markets have also                                                             commodity prices
eased. Droughts and fires had earlier caused food production to
drop, but supplies are now holding up better. The Arab Spring
has entered a second phase, and is worrying the oil market less.
The quantitative easing in the US has run its course, which has
meant less investor interest in the commodity markets. We also
believe that we have seen the worst of the dollar’s decline in
trade-weighted terms, leaving producers no reason to still
demand compensation for currency fluctuations.

Commodity prices (total), food prices and commodity prices excluding oil (index)


         175
                    T o ta l c o m m o d ity p ric e , e x c l o il


         150


         125
                    T o ta l c o m m o d ity p ric e
 Index




         100


          75


          50
                                                        F o o d p ric e s

          25
               00     01       02      03      04      05       06    07    08   09         10 11
                                                                                  S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in




In our spring forecast we predicted that oil, which was trading
around USD 115 at the time, would fall when uncertainty about
the Middle East and the global economy eased. It took a while to
prove true, and now the reason has more to do with weak global
economic growth. We saw last spring that the risks were on the
upside due to problems in the Middle East and Japan.

We therefore have to revise upward our previous estimate of                                                             Oil price estimates
USD 105 this year and USD 98 in 2012, since oil prices have                                                             have been revised
held up longer than we expected. Instead we anticipate a price of                                                       upward since the
USD 110 this year. As global growth slows, oil will gradually                                                           spring forecast
return to a level of just over USD 97 next year and USD 94 in



Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                                       15
2013. This is still relatively high and is based on continued strong
demand in emerging countries, which are gradually increasing
their consumption of raw materials.

Commodity prices and projections 2009-2013
(Brent crude oil in US dollars per barrel, food and metals in index 2010 = 100)


  140

  130

  120

  110

  100

  90                                                                                        Food
                                                                                            Metals
  80
                                                                                            Oil
  70

  60

  50

  40
        2009 
            2009 
                2009 
                    2009 
                        2010 
                            2010 
                                2010 
                                    2010 
                                        2011 
                                            2011 
                                                2011 
                                                    2011 
                                                        2012 
                                                            2012 
                                                                2012 
                                                                    2012 
                                                                        2013 
                                                                            2013 
                                                                                2013  
                                                                                    2013 
         Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4


We expect price declines for industrial metals (by 3-6%) and food
(by 4-7%) in 2012 and 2013, after they rose by 32% and 20%,
respectively, in 2011. Supplies should remain steady while                                               Precious metals rise –
demand declines, producing a downward trend. The opposite is                                             while industrial metals
true of precious metals (primarily gold and silver), which will                                          fall
continue to rise in price in the immediate future due to jittery
financial markets and the US credit downgrade.

The risk of lower commodity prices is related to a more                                                  The risks are still on
pessimistic growth scenario and unease in the financial markets.                                         the upside, and
There are also risks on the upside, which could be realised if we                                        emerging countries are
were to see faster global growth, another quantitative easing in                                         playing a more
the US and a further decline in the dollar. New supply problems                                          important role
in connection with disruptive weather and unrest in the Middle
East, for example, could contribute to higher prices. It should also
be noted that emerging countries are increasingly important to
prices in more developed countries. Since activity will increase
faster in Asia, Latin America and the Middle East than in more
developed countries, commodity prices could still rise more than
desired given weak growth prospects in the West.

Inflation and interest rates
Lower commodity prices are expected to contribute to a much
more favourable inflation outlook than in 2010 and 2011.
Basically all we need are more stable food and energy prices for
inflation to begin to fall on an annual basis. We think inflation will
soon peak for now and turn lower in both developed and
emerging countries.

The main factors affecting inflation in more developed countries                                         A weak job market and
are the budget consolidation and the weak labour market, which                                           budget consolidation
are slowing demand, including wage and price pressures. Europe                                           are restraining price
and the US face similar situations, with a lower inflation outlook.                                      and wage pressures
We expect Japanese inflation to be temporary against the




16                                                                             Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
backdrop of higher commodity prices, but once they fall we again
see a period of deflation in Japan.

Inflation (CPI) in a number of countries 2004-2011


           1 7 ,5
                                                           In d ia
           1 5 ,0

           1 2 ,5
                    C h in a
           1 0 ,0
 Percent




            7 ,5
                                               B ra z il
            5 ,0
                                         UK
            2 ,5                                                  US
                                      G e rm a n y
            0 ,0
                                                                  Japan
           -2 ,5
                          08                 09               10                      11
                                                                       S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in




Emerging countries are finding it harder to rein in inflation.                                               Overheating risks are
Tighter economic policies are helping to prevent an overheating,                                             easing in emerging
and capital inflows should also shrink due to the economic                                                   countries, but can’t be
weakness and the end to quantitative easing. The key for many                                                totally overlooked
emerging countries is to expand their capacity, so that supply
better meets demand.

Inflation outlook measured by the annual increase in CPI (%)

CPI                            2010   2011        2012     2013
US                              1,6    3,2         1,7      2,0

Eurozone                       1,6     2,8        2,0      2,0
UK                             3,3     4,1        2,5      2,0

Japan                          -0,7    0,2        0,7      0,5
China                          3,3     5,5        4,2      3,0
India                           9,2    8,5        6,5      5,2

Brazil                         5,9     6,4        5,0      4,2
Russia                         6,9     9,5        8,0      6,5
Global CPI                     2,8     4,2        3,0      2,6

Sources: National statistics and Swedbank’s forecasts.

We expect inflation to gradually fall from its current levels and                                            In our main scenario, a
that emerging countries as a group will avoid an economic hard                                               hard landing is averted
landing. Weaker growth in industrial countries will also impact
demand in emerging countries. India has already seen an
improvement compared with when monsoon rains caused food
prices to rise sharply. Brazil has to limit credit growth, and with
lower global growth and commodity prices its economy should
slow, reducing price pressures. Chinese inflation will soon peak,




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                             17
but a further economic tightening may be needed to sustainably
reduce inflation.

A more favourable inflation outlook will relieve central banks of                          The threat of
the worry of stagflation in the West. On April 13 the European                             stagflation will now
Central Bank (ECB) raised its benchmark rate by 25 bp to 1.25%                             become less evident
after inflation rose to high levels, and followed it on July 13 with a
new hike to 1.5% before pausing at its latest meeting in August.

US, British and Japanese central banks, on the other hand, have                            The ECB is pausing
kept their key rates unchanged. In the British case in particular,                         and others are
this has been criticised, since inflation peaked at 4.5% in April                          delaying rate hikes
and May before falling to 4.2% in June. The private consumption
deflator has also risen in the US, to nearly 2%, but with prospects
of lower growth and easing inflation, central banks can now wait
even longer before tightening monetary policy. The Bank of
England is waiting until the first half of 2013 to raise rates, and
any increases after that are likely to start slowly.

Benchmark rates 2000-2010

           8
                              N orway                   A ustralia
           7

                                Euroarea
           6                                           UK

           5
 Percent




           4

           3

           2
                                             S weden
           1         US
                                        Japan
           0
               00   01   02   03   04   05   06   07   08   09      10          11
                                                             Sou rce: R euters E co W in




In our spring forecast, we didn't think the Federal Reserve would                          We do not expect a US
have to raise rates until the second half of 2012, but due to                              rate increase before
weaker growth prospects and modest inflation it has decided to                             mid 2013
wait even longer. Chairman Ben Bernanke has now announced
that the Fed won’t raise rates until at least mid-2013. This is the
“easiest” way for the central bank to create more expansive
monetary policy.

The continued shakiness of the US recovery and weakness of                                 Little marginal benefit
the labour market – combined with greater difficulty financing the                         from an additional
budget deficit after the credit downgrade – is raising demands for                         quantitative easing
a new quantitative easing of some sort (QE3). We don't rule one
out, but expect that the Fed will want to see signs of deflation
before taking such a step. It should also be noted that QE2 didn’t
have much effect on long-term interest rates initially. In fact, they
rose after the programme was announced. The subsequent




18                                                               Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
decline was more likely the result of increased pessimism about
growth.

In addition, long-term interest rates are already so low that the
effects on the labour market of trying to push them lower still will
probably be minimal. The costs to expand the central bank’s
balance sheet, which would make exit strategies more
challenging, aren't negligible either. The easing – if there is one –
should perhaps be seen in light of concerns about financing the
huge budget deficit of about 10% of GDP, the risk of a larger
decline in the dollar, and most importantly the risk of deflation.

Given the worries about the euro zone’s growth and the
sovereign debt crisis in the periphery countries – coupled with a
lower benchmark rate in the US and slower inflation – the ECB
may pause until the second half of 2012 before raising rates. Not
until then do we anticipate a rate hike of 0.25 bp, to 1.75%, to be
followed by another hike in the first half of 2013. The core
countries of Germany and France may be the ones that have to
resort to further austerity to keep inflation around the ECB’s
target of just under 2%.

Benchmark interest rates 2011-2013

                  16 aug 11 31 dec 11 30 jun 12 31 dec 12 30 jun 13 31 dec 13
Federal Reserve     0,25       0,25     0,25       0,25      0,25      0,75
ECB                 1,50       1,50     1,50       1,75      2,00      2,00
Bank of England     0,50       0,50     0,50       0,50      1,00      1,50
Bank of Japan       0,10       0,10     0,10       0,10      0,10      0,10

We don’t expect the BOJ to raise its benchmark rate during the                  Japan is still struggling
forecast period. The risk of a new period of deflation is high,                 with deflation and a
especially since budget cutbacks to stabilise debt and afford the               strong yen
reconstruction will impact economic demand. The BOJ would like
to weaken the value of the yen and keep interest rates low for the
same reason.

Since our spring forecast, long-term market rates (10-year
government bonds) have retreated. British long-term rates have
dropped below the low levels seen in 2010, and rates in
Germany and the US are well on their way. A more downbeat
economic outlook, lower commodity prices and lower inflation are
keeping the trend pointed downward. Just as importantly, the
stock market sell-off is causing many investors to flee to safety,
which is also keeping US and European long-term interest rates
low.

Despite the credit downgrade, funding costs are now declining, a                Growth pessimism and
trend we also saw when Japan’s credit was downgraded in 2002.                   the stock sell-off are
Investors still turn to the US when stocks are volatile. Over the               reducing bond yields
forecast period, 10-year government bonds will rise by about 100
bp in Europe, 75 bp in the US and 50 bp in Japan.




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                 19
Long-term interest rates (10-year government bonds)

           6 ,0

           5 ,5

           5 ,0

           4 ,5                                 UK

           4 ,0
                  G e rm a ny
 Procent




           3 ,5

           3 ,0

           2 ,5                      USA
           2 ,0

           1 ,5                                        Jap an
           1 ,0

           0 ,5
                     07         08    09              10                   11
                                                           S o u rce : R e u te rs E co W in




Demand for safe havens – government bonds from financially                                     Interest rates are also
sound countries – will increase in the years ahead as Basel III                                affected by tighter
creates pressure to better capitalise banks. While this will                                   regulations
contribute to lower bond yields, the costs to maintain more capital
in the banking system are likely to mean permanently higher
margins, which in turn will lead to higher market rates. The
impact of Basel III is difficult to determine, however, especially
since a more stable financial sector could also help to reduce risk
premiums and thereby lower interest rates. This shows just how
much uncertainty there still is regarding the effects of Basel III.

Exchange rates
Since our spring forecast, the dollar has continued to weaken in                               The dollar has
nominal terms, and a number of emerging countries have seen                                    weakened since our
their currencies appreciate. Brazilian Finance Minister Guido                                  spring forecast, putting
Mantega, for one, is concerned. Developed countries such as                                    pressure on emerging
Switzerland and Japan have also tried to keep their currencies                                 countries
from appreciating by loosening monetary policy and intervening
in currency markets. Such interventions aren't usually very
effective or long lasting. In real terms, the Japanese yen isn't
especially overvalued either from a long-term perspective,
although the recent change has been a complicating factor for a
number of companies.




20                                                              Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
Nominal exchange rates in relation to the US dollar, index 2008-08-15 = 100

 160
                                                  Brazilean Real

 150                                                 Swedish Krona

                                                          Korean W on
 140


 130

                                                                                 Euro
 120


 110


 100
                                              Yuan

   90                                                              Swiss Franc

   80


   70
                                                                                 Yen
   60
         jan    m aj sep   jan    m aj sep     jan   m aj sep       jan   m aj sep      jan         m aj
                    07                08                 09                   10                     11
                                                                                     Source: R euters EcoW in




We anticipate that the debt crises in the euro zone and the US                                                               Debt problems in the
will keep the dollar-euro exchange rate fairly stable initially, after                                                       US and euro zone –
which the dollar could appreciate against the euro on the basis of                                                           euro/dollar exchange
slightly stronger growth and possibly how the debt crisis is                                                                 rate fairly stable at this
managed.                                                                                                                     point

US dollar, trade-weighted in nominal terms


         125
         120
         115
         110
         105
                    A v e ra g e 1 9 9 0 -2 0 1 1
         100
 Index




           95
           90
           85
           80
           75
           70
             90      92      94      96      98      00      02      04     06       08             10
                                                                                     S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in




A further credit downgrade could reduce interest in the dollar,                                                              If the euro zone
especially as emerging countries gradually diversify their                                                                   tackles its debt
currency portfolios and turn to other investments.                                                                           problems but the US
                                                                                                                             doesn’t, the dollar could
Exchange rates 2011-2013                                                                                                     fall
                           16 aug 11 31 dec 11 30 jun 12 31 dec 12 30 jun 13 31 dec 13
EUR/USD                      1,44       1,42     1,38       1,35      1,35      1,30
RMB/USD                      6,38       6,16     6,00       5,79      5,64      5,44
USD/JPY                       77         80        83        85        87        90
EUR/GBP                      0,88       0,88     0,85       0,83       0,8      0,77




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                                               21
China continues to allow the renminbi to appreciate against the
dollar by about 6% per year in nominal terms. Since China’s
inflation is higher than the majority of its trading partners, the
appreciation is even higher in real terms. Efforts to
internationalise the renminbi continue. Without a well-functioning
financial market and a convertible currency, China is still
dependent on the dollar, euro, yen and other international
currencies.

The Japanese yen is weakening in the wake of a shrinking trade                                     When the crisis
surplus and a slightly larger interest rate differential vis-à-vis                                 subsides, the yen
Europe and the US. Our assumption that the US won’t replace                                        should weaken
QE2 with QE3 should also contribute to a weaker yen.

Stock prices
Even before the recent slide, stock markets in developed
countries had performed modestly at best. While markets in
emerging countries nearly returned to their 2007 peak, stocks in
the US, euro zone and Japan have a long way to go. Recent
market jitters are the product of lower global growth expectations,
the debt crisis in developed countries, the US credit downgrade
and a severe crisis of confidence in the ability of decision-makers
to manage crises. Political risks are especially difficult to
evaluate, which is creating uncertainty and nervousness.

Corporate profits could be affected by poorer growth prospects,
though on the other hand cost pressures are easing due to lower                                    Political risks are
commodity and input goods prices. Negative news will garner a                                      influencing market
bigger reaction than positive news. Considering the challenges in                                  psychology right now
handling the debt crisis and euro cooperation, this will continue to
frustrate the market for some time to come. It is impossible,
however, to determine by how much and for how long the
markets will be hurt.

Equity prices in emerging countries ( MSCI EM), USA (S&P 500), the euro zone
(FTSE EZ 300) and Japan (Nikkei 225) 2007-2011, index January 2007 = 100

         150

         140                                                MSCI EM
         130

         120

         110

         100
 Index




                                                 U SA S& P 500
          90

          80
                                                         FTSE EZ 300
          70

          60

          50
                                                         N ik k e i 2 2 5
          40
               07          08            09            10                     11
                                                             S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in




22                                                          Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
5. A lot depends on emerging economies
The global economy has downshifted to a lower gear. The                                                                                             The global economy
recovery continues, but not as quickly as in 2010, a rebound year                                                                                   has now shifted into a
after the financial crisis and global recession. The risk picture has                                                                               lower gear
also become more negative. This year growth is being slowed by
higher commodity prices, the Japanese disaster and the
continuing balance sheet correction. Tighter economic policy will
then be an increasing drag on growth.

Annual GDP growth (%) in several major countries/regions


                           6,00

                           5,00

                           4,00

                           3,00                                                                                 BRIC‐countries
                                                                                                                OECD‐countries
                           2,00

                           1,00

                           0,00
                                        2010             2011              2012           2013


We expect the slowdown in emerging countries to be modest and                                                                                       Emerging countries
that this group will remain the biggest contributor to growth (65-                                                                                  account for over two
70%). Their growth has trended below the historical average, and                                                                                    thirds of global growth
without fiscal and monetary ammunition, reforms will be needed
to speed their structural transformation and improve the medium-
term outlook. Emerging economies have to implement reforms
that immediately reduce the problem of overheating and create
more sustainable domestic demand. That would also help to
reduce global imbalances.

US current account balance and China’s currency reserves

                            4 ,5                                                                                     100

                            4 ,0                                                                                             0

                            3 ,5                                                                                  -1 0 0

                            3 ,0                                                                                  -2 0 0
 USD (thousand billions)




                            2 ,5                                                                                  -3 0 0
                                                                                                                                   USD (billions)




                            2 ,0                                                                                  -4 0 0

                            1 ,5                                                                                  -5 0 0
                                     U S c u r re n t a c c o u n t
                            1 ,0     (rh s )                                                                      -6 0 0

                            0 ,5                                                                                  -7 0 0

                            0 ,0                                                                                  -8 0 0
                                             C h in a 's c u r r e n c y
                           -0 ,5             r e s e r v e s ( lh s )                                             -9 0 0
                                90     92    94     96     98     00       02   04   06    08    10
                                                                                                  S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                                                                    23
The US – structural problems are impacting
the economic outlook
              Major downward revision of GDP growth against the
               backdrop of weaker economic data and growing pessimism
               – growth is too weak to significantly impact unemployment

              The debt ceiling agreement is welcome, but the political
               process was a failure

              Debt restructuring is starting slowly, but the long-term cuts
               seem inadequate to stabilise the debt burden

The optimism surrounding the US economy late last year was                                         A deeper recession in
illusory. Rising unemployment, higher inflation, falling housing                                   2008-2009 and a
prices and political discord on fiscal policy have left Americans                                  slower recovery in
anxious. During the first half of 2011 GDP growth has been                                         2010-11
weaker than expected – 1.8% at an annual rate and 0.8% at an
annualized rate – which is also less than considered normal in a
recovery, when there is usually available capacity. We also now
know that the recession was deeper than indicated by previous
data, with GDP falling by 5.1% in 2008-2009 rather than 4%.

US GDP and inflation (annual change %), and unemployment (% of labour force)


          12,5                                                                  10,0
          10,0                                                                     9,5
                                           Unemployment --->
              7,5                                                                  9,0
                     CPI
              5,0                  GDP - annualized quarterly growth               8,5
              2,5                                                                  8,0
Percent




                                                                                         Percent




              0,0                                                                  7,5
           -2,5                        Private consumption                         7,0
           -5,0                        deflation                                   6,5
           -7,5                                                                    6,0
          -10,0                                                                    5,5
          -12,5                                                                    5,0
                    Q1       Q3   Q1     Q3      Q1       Q3       Q1
                           08          09               10           11
                                                                       Source: Reuters EcoWin



Temporary factors partly explain the slower development,                                           Both structural and
including the earthquake in Japan, unusual weather and                                             temporary factors
shrinking confidence in the ability of US politicians to solve the                                 explain the economic
budget and debt ceiling problems. The more important thing,                                        doldrums
however, is that the structural problems in the US economy
haven’t been resolved and that the labour, housing and credit
markets aren’t working normally in the wake of the financial
crisis. Balance sheets still need correcting. Without another fiscal
stimulus, the US economy will continue to trend below its
historical growth.




24                                                             Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
In addition to the economic crisis, a political crisis is under way. A                                                   The US faces both an
growing number of experts are characterising the political system                                                        economic and a
as dysfunctional. There is little willingness to compromise, and                                                         political crisis
the goal for politicians to get re-elected often overshadows the
goal to help the country grow. After the financial and real estate
crises, the US has to find a new identity in economic, political,
cultural and geopolitical terms. American households can no
longer be the growth engine for the global economy. Defence
spending will shrink and will affect the ability of the US to respond
in global hot spots. At home, a structural transformation is
needed, at the same time that the government’s role is shrinking
since tax hikes won't be tolerated by Congress. Income gaps are
growing, and it is becoming harder to help those who have
dropped out of the system. The negative confidence spiral has to
be broken.

Household and corporate expectations for the next half year (Conference Board)

 120

 110
                                                    H o u s e h o ld c o n f id e n c e
 100

  90

  80

  70

  60

  50

  40                       B u s in e s s c o n f id e n c e

  30
       97   98   99   00   01   02      03     04     05       06   07     08      09            10
                                                                                 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in




We expect GDP growth to top out at 2.1% this year. Activity will
increase during the second half year as gas prices fall slightly
and the Japan Effect tapers off at the same time that political
concerns ease, giving future confidence a needed boost. This
represents a significant downward revision from our spring
forecast of 3% and reflects the downturn in future confidence in
recent months in pace with weaker GDP and job numbers.

We still expect the growth engine in the form of consumer
spending to falter, at the same time that other components in the
supply balance aren’t able to raise growth above its average. In
2012, an election year, GDP growth will reach 2.3%, before
climbing to 2.7% in 2013, when confidence could grow with new
leadership. Monetary and fiscal policy will be tighter, however,
which will keep growth below 3%.




Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                                       25
The US Congress has had major problems agreeing on how to                                                                                      “You can always count
consolidate the budget in the years ahead. The increase in the                                                                                 on Americans to do the
debt ceiling was contingent on spending cuts, and at the last                                                                                  right thing – after
minute Republicans and Democrats agreed to raise the ceiling by                                                                                they’ve tried everything
USD 2.1- 2.4 trillion by the end of 2012, which means that it won’t                                                                            else”
be an issue in next year’s election campaign.
                                                                                                                                               - Winston Churchill
The debt ceiling will initially be raised by USD 400 billion, then by
another USD 500 billion unless blocked a Congressional
resolution. The remaining USD 1.2-1.5 trillion will be part of a
packaged agreement agreed to by a committee of
representatives from both parties and containing spending cuts,
tax reforms and other debt reductions. In the first years there will
be little in the way of cutbacks, and consolidation has instead
been pushed off to the future. While this may seem reasonable
given the weak recovery, it creates uncertainty, since another
Congress will have to implement today’s decision.

Total government debt now exceeds 100% of GDP, while the                                                                                       Gross public debt is
federal debt as a share of GDP is just over 70%. Had nothing                                                                                   now greater than GDP
been done, it would have risen to 90% of GDP by 2030 and then
about 200% in 2060, after the healthcare reform, which reduces
the debt burden by about 100% of GDP between 2011 and 2060.

Federal budget revenues, expenditures and balance

                  350                                                                                               50

                                                            F in a n c in g n e e d - - >
                  300                                                                                               25


                  250                                                                                                   0
 USD (billions)




                                                                                                                              USD (billions)




                  200                                                                                             -2 5


                  150                                                                                             -5 0
                               < --- B u d g e t
                               e x p e n d itu r e s
                  100                                                                                             -7 5


                   50                                   < --- B u d g e t re v e n u e s                      -1 0 0


                    0                                                                                         -1 2 5
                     70   75   80         85           90      95         00        05        10
                                                                                              S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in




The medium-term plan that would have been needed to stabilise                                                                                  Twice as large a
the debt burden in the second half of this decade is thought to be                                                                             budget consolidation
at least USD 4 trillion, or about 20% of GDP. Revised growth                                                                                   could be needed
prospects also will mean greater difficulty stabilising the debt as a
share of GDP. The plan now calling for cuts of just USD 2.1-2.4
trillion doesn’t go far enough. The US therefore risks another
credit downgrade. A lower rating could raise funding costs, add to
financial turbulence and weaken the dollar considerably.

The job market will be the focus of the campaign leading up to
the presidential election in November 2012. No president has
been re-elected in the last 50 years with unemployment higher
than 7.2%. In July it was 9.1%, which is still higher than at the




26                                                                                          Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
beginning of 2011 even after declining slightly from June. It was
also just a modest decline compared with the October 2009 peak
of 10.1%. Compared with before the crisis, unemployment has
more than doubled to 14 million. When you include those who
are working part-time not by choice and those who are no longer
actively looking for work, 29 million Americans are now counted
as unemployed, about half of whom can also be considered long-
term unemployed.

The housing market has yet to bounce back. Housing                                                                                                   The housing market
construction appears to have hit bottom, but will remain there for                                                                                   has hit bottom and will
some time. The same applies to new home prices and sales,                                                                                            stay there for a while
which have been fairly stagnant and where the latter are back at
their 1998 level. Low interest rates should have helped the
housing market more, but households are continuing to fix their
balance sheets at the same time that the credit market is having
problems with new lending. Another critical factor is the vast
inventory of unsold housing, which will keep prices low for some
time to come.

Housing market

                        8                                                                                                        27 5

                        7                                                                                                        25 0

                        6                                                                                                        22 5
 Number of (millions)




                              S ale s of n e w ho m e s
                        5                                                                                                        20 0
                                                                                                                                             Index




                        4                                                                                                        17 5

                                                                                        C as e/S h ille r
                        3       S ale s of e x isting h om e s                          h o use p ric es for                     15 0
                                                                                        1 0 cities --->
                        2                                                                                                        12 5

                        1                                                                                                        10 0
                                                                      R e side ntial co ns tru ctio n

                        0                                                                                                           75
                         90     92      94       96       98     00       02       04       06      08         10
                                                                                                                S o u rc e : R e u te rs E co W in




Inflation measured by CPI has risen due to higher energy and
food prices, although core inflation (excluding energy and food)
has also begun nearing uncomfortable levels, at just under 2%.
On the other hand, we expect that when food and gas prices
decline, inflation will ease, giving the Federal Reserve a respite
before launching a period of rate hikes. We don’t anticipate the
first hike until the second half of 2013, in line with the Fed’s
announcement.

This summer QE2 ended. Since deflation concerns have eased,                                                                                          Demands for QE3
we don’t anticipate another quantitative easing. Although a                                                                                          are gaining steam
gloomier growth outlook and higher unemployment are now
raising demands for a new easing to keep interest rates low and
strengthen asset prices, the Fed isn’t likely to consider one until
there are signs of deflation. Besides, another quantitative easing
may not have much impact on growth and jobs, and the side



Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011                                                                                                                      27
effects on global inflation, commodity prices and capital flows to
emerging countries can’t be overlooked.




China – growing faster than planned
              GDP growth has surprised on the upside, but is expected to
               slow in quarters to come

              Inflation will peak this year and drop to 3-4% in 2012-2013

              The goal to “rebalance” the economy will take time and
               require more reforms

Expectations that China’s GDP growth will more visibly slow did
not come to fruition earlier this year when GDP rose in the first
two quarters by 9.7% and 9.5% at an annual rate. Despite lower
credit growth and higher inflation, the economy continued to grow
at a rapid pace.

The wheels of the Chinese economy have since begun to slow                                                                            The wheels of the
slightly. This was caused by the rise in interest rates in order to                                                                   Chinese economy are
check inflation and is also evident in the purchasing managers                                                                        now rolling more
index, which indicates slower economic activity. Slower import                                                                        slowly
growth is also a sign of weaker domestic activity. A slight
slowdown is already evident on an adjusted quarterly basis, but
as usual there is reason to be cautious in interpreting these
sometimes dubious data.

However, we are revising GDP growth upward by 25 bp to 9.0%
this year on the basis of stronger results. GDP growth will then
fall to 8.4% in 2012 and 8.0% in 2013. This means that the goal
in China’s latest five-year plan of average GDP growth of 7% per
year in 2011-2016 in all likelihood will not be reached.

Growth in GDP, industrial production and auto sales

           2 0 ,0                                                                                                 90
                    < - - In d u s tr ia l p r o d u c tio n        C a r s a le s - - >
                                                                                                                  80
           1 7 ,5
                                                                                                                  70
           1 5 ,0
                                                                                                                  60
                    < - - G D P - g r o w th
           1 2 ,5                                                                                                 50
 Percent




                                                                                                                            Percent




           1 0 ,0                                                                                                 40

                                                                                                                  30
            7 ,5
                                                                                                                  20
            5 ,0
                                                                                                                  10
            2 ,5                                                                                                      0

            0 ,0                                                                                                -1 0
                    04         05          06          07      08          09          10
                                                                                            S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in




28                                                                                          Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The glass is half empty with focus on US growth
The glass is half empty with focus on US growthThe glass is half empty with focus on US growth
The glass is half empty with focus on US growthHantec Markets
 
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012Denny Setiady
 
Weekly markets perspectives october 15th 2012
Weekly markets perspectives    october 15th 2012Weekly markets perspectives    october 15th 2012
Weekly markets perspectives october 15th 2012Fincor Corretora
 
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this week
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this weekFOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this week
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this weekHantec Markets
 
From the Floor 10october11
From the Floor 10october11From the Floor 10october11
From the Floor 10october11ETX_Capital
 
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are key
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are keyTrump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are key
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are keyHantec Markets
 
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market moves
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market movesActive central banks and rising political risk key for market moves
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market movesRichard Perry
 
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets?
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets? Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets?
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets? Hantec Markets
 
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this week
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this weekUK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this week
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this weekHantec Markets
 
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this week
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this weekWith a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this week
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this weekRichard Perry
 
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this week
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this weekEscalation of the trade dispute remains key this week
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this weekHantec Markets
 
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?Hantec Markets
 
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this week
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this weekTrade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this week
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this weekHantec Markets
 
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?Richard Perry
 
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011Swedbank
 
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013Nordea Bank
 
The prospect of further safe haven buying this week
The prospect of further safe haven buying this weekThe prospect of further safe haven buying this week
The prospect of further safe haven buying this weekRichard Perry
 
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this week
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this weekECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this week
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this weekHantec Markets
 

La actualidad más candente (19)

The glass is half empty with focus on US growth
The glass is half empty with focus on US growthThe glass is half empty with focus on US growth
The glass is half empty with focus on US growth
 
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012
Citibank - Market Outlook September 2012
 
Weekly markets perspectives october 15th 2012
Weekly markets perspectives    october 15th 2012Weekly markets perspectives    october 15th 2012
Weekly markets perspectives october 15th 2012
 
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this week
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this weekFOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this week
FOMC, Advance GDP, Nonfarm Payrolls and Brexit all key this week
 
From the Floor 10october11
From the Floor 10october11From the Floor 10october11
From the Floor 10october11
 
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are key
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are keyTrump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are key
Trump's Twitter, currency manipulation and the trade dispute are key
 
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market moves
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market movesActive central banks and rising political risk key for market moves
Active central banks and rising political risk key for market moves
 
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets?
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets? Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets?
Could a turnaround last the distance for major markets?
 
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this week
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this weekUK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this week
UK inflation and Eurozone growth will be key this week
 
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this week
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this weekWith a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this week
With a dearth of US data the ECB will be key this week
 
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this week
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this weekEscalation of the trade dispute remains key this week
Escalation of the trade dispute remains key this week
 
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?
Could the Fed drive a Santa Claus rally this week?
 
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this week
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this weekTrade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this week
Trade negotiations and renewed dollar strength is key this week
 
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?
US dollar in under huge pressure but will it continue this week?
 
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011
Asia Analysis, No. 13, 16 March 2011
 
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013
Ekonomiska utsikter 4 sept 2013
 
How well is Europe doing?
How well is Europe doing?How well is Europe doing?
How well is Europe doing?
 
The prospect of further safe haven buying this week
The prospect of further safe haven buying this weekThe prospect of further safe haven buying this week
The prospect of further safe haven buying this week
 
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this week
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this weekECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this week
ECB and a new UK Prime Minister key this week
 

Destacado

נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmasters
נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmastersנגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmasters
נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmastersnagishcafe
 
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 Introduction
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 IntroductionMaximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 Introduction
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 IntroductionPlatypus
 
Olive garden printable coupon 2011
Olive garden printable coupon 2011Olive garden printable coupon 2011
Olive garden printable coupon 2011yomi18
 
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...Street Ecology
 
מצגת ללא כותרת
מצגת ללא כותרתמצגת ללא כותרת
מצגת ללא כותרתnagishcafe
 

Destacado (6)

נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmasters
נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmastersנגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmasters
נגיש קפה..בית קפה בסגנון אחר - Tutorial: Google for Webmasters
 
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 Introduction
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 IntroductionMaximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 Introduction
Maximising Online Resource Effectiveness Workshop Session 1/8 Introduction
 
Wealth Creation 09 09 Ver1 0
Wealth Creation 09 09 Ver1 0Wealth Creation 09 09 Ver1 0
Wealth Creation 09 09 Ver1 0
 
Olive garden printable coupon 2011
Olive garden printable coupon 2011Olive garden printable coupon 2011
Olive garden printable coupon 2011
 
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...
The shy entrepreneur: observations from the 2nd Annual Micro-enterprise bazaa...
 
מצגת ללא כותרת
מצגת ללא כותרתמצגת ללא כותרת
מצגת ללא כותרת
 

Similar a Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011

Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 March
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 MarchSwedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 March
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 MarchSwedbank
 
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract from
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract fromEconomic and Structural Report August 2008, extract from
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract fromSwedbank
 
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August
	Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August	Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 AugustSwedbank
 
The Global Economy No. 2 - February 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 2 -  February 16, 2012The Global Economy No. 2 -  February 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 2 - February 16, 2012Swedbank
 
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18Swedbank
 
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009Swedbank
 
The Global Economy, No 1/2011
The Global Economy, No 1/2011The Global Economy, No 1/2011
The Global Economy, No 1/2011Swedbank
 
Nordic Outlook November 2010
Nordic Outlook November 2010Nordic Outlook November 2010
Nordic Outlook November 2010The Benche
 
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009Swedbank
 
The Global Economy No. 1 - January 31, 2012
The Global Economy No. 1 -  January 31, 2012The Global Economy No. 1 -  January 31, 2012
The Global Economy No. 1 - January 31, 2012Swedbank
 
US update - No recession but slower growth
US update - No recession but slower growthUS update - No recession but slower growth
US update - No recession but slower growthNordea Bank
 
Caton's corner august economic update
Caton's corner august economic updateCaton's corner august economic update
Caton's corner august economic updateJosh Develop
 
The Global Economy No. 9 - December 20, 2011
The Global Economy No. 9 -  December 20, 2011The Global Economy No. 9 -  December 20, 2011
The Global Economy No. 9 - December 20, 2011Swedbank
 
Where Next For The World Economy
Where Next For The World EconomyWhere Next For The World Economy
Where Next For The World EconomyJustin Patrie
 
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011Swedbank
 
Investor spring 2012
Investor spring 2012Investor spring 2012
Investor spring 2012KateOD
 
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 final
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 finalMid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 final
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 finalRankia
 
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010Swedbank
 
The Global Economy No. 5 - August 7, 2012
The Global Economy No. 5 -  August 7, 2012The Global Economy No. 5 -  August 7, 2012
The Global Economy No. 5 - August 7, 2012Swedbank
 

Similar a Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011 (20)

Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 March
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 MarchSwedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 March
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2011 March
 
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract from
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract fromEconomic and Structural Report August 2008, extract from
Economic and Structural Report August 2008, extract from
 
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August
	Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August	Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 August
 
Economic outlook
Economic outlookEconomic outlook
Economic outlook
 
The Global Economy No. 2 - February 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 2 -  February 16, 2012The Global Economy No. 2 -  February 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 2 - February 16, 2012
 
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18
Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, 2010 March 18
 
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009
Global Economic Outlook 20 August 2009
 
The Global Economy, No 1/2011
The Global Economy, No 1/2011The Global Economy, No 1/2011
The Global Economy, No 1/2011
 
Nordic Outlook November 2010
Nordic Outlook November 2010Nordic Outlook November 2010
Nordic Outlook November 2010
 
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009
Swedbank Economic Outlook June 2009
 
The Global Economy No. 1 - January 31, 2012
The Global Economy No. 1 -  January 31, 2012The Global Economy No. 1 -  January 31, 2012
The Global Economy No. 1 - January 31, 2012
 
US update - No recession but slower growth
US update - No recession but slower growthUS update - No recession but slower growth
US update - No recession but slower growth
 
Caton's corner august economic update
Caton's corner august economic updateCaton's corner august economic update
Caton's corner august economic update
 
The Global Economy No. 9 - December 20, 2011
The Global Economy No. 9 -  December 20, 2011The Global Economy No. 9 -  December 20, 2011
The Global Economy No. 9 - December 20, 2011
 
Where Next For The World Economy
Where Next For The World EconomyWhere Next For The World Economy
Where Next For The World Economy
 
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011
The Global Economy No. 5 - June 23, 2011
 
Investor spring 2012
Investor spring 2012Investor spring 2012
Investor spring 2012
 
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 final
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 finalMid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 final
Mid year outlook market perspectives july 2012 final
 
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010
Swedbank Economic Outlook January 2010
 
The Global Economy No. 5 - August 7, 2012
The Global Economy No. 5 -  August 7, 2012The Global Economy No. 5 -  August 7, 2012
The Global Economy No. 5 - August 7, 2012
 

Más de Swedbank

Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank
 
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Swedbank
 
Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Swedbank
 
Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Swedbank
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank
 
Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Swedbank
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank
 

Más de Swedbank (20)

Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
 
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
 
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
 
Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017
 
Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
 
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
 
Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
 
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
 

Último

High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...ssifa0344
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...ssifa0344
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.Vinodha Devi
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdfFinTech Belgium
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfGale Pooley
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfGale Pooley
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfGale Pooley
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptxFinTech Belgium
 

Último (20)

High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...
VIP Call Girl Service Andheri West ⚡ 9920725232 What It Takes To Be The Best ...
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
 
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
 
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.
Gurley shaw Theory of Monetary Economics.
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Bandra West 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Esc...
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 25.pdf
 
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
(Vedika) Low Rate Call Girls in Pune Call Now 8250077686 Pune Escorts 24x7
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
 

Swedbank's Global Economic Outlook, August 2011

  • 1. Global Economic Outlook by Cecilia Hermansson 17 August 2011 Global growth is slowing – without reforms the world economy is at risk  Since our spring forecast, economic growth, primarily in the US but more recently in the euro zone as well, has slowed. Turbulence in the financial markets has increased and confidence is falling. We have revised our global GDP growth forecast downward to 3.8% this year (4.1%) and expect it to remain just under 4% in 2012 and 2013.  Our main scenario, which we give a probability of 60%, does not include a new global recession, but does anticipate a slower recovery in developed countries due to budget austerity. Economically and politically, we seem to be “muddling through”. Emerging countries are driving the global economy.  The risk picture is weighted heavily to the downside. We give a less favourable scenario – where global GDP growth falls below 2% – a 30% probability. The debt crisis is worsening in the euro zone and causing a major stock market sell-off, currency worries and shrinking economies. Even emerging countries don't seem to be immune. On the other hand, we can’t totally exclude the possibility of stronger growth, upwards of last year's 5%. The probability is low, however, at 10%, and requires newfound faith in the political systems in the US, Japan and the euro zone.  This report identifies the needed reforms in the US, the euro zone, China, emerging countries and across national borders. The time for denial is over. We need economic policies that will best help us to overcome the debt crisis that Western countries are now going through and the overheating that worries emerging countries. The EMU is already a transfer union, and a fiscal policy coordinated with the Eurobond market would be a more effective solution. Extensive reforms are needed to strengthen growth prospects over time. Until then decision-makers will have to apply both the gas and the brakes. Cecilia Hermansson Contents: Page 1. Our main scenario: Modest growth in spite of everything 2 2. An increasingly complex risk picture 6 3. Economic policy: Few tools 9 4. Our assumptions about the commodity and financial markets 15 5. A lot depends on emerging economies 23 - USA 24 - China 28 - Japan 30 - India 32 - Brazil 34 - Euro zone 36 - UK 40 6. Conclusions for our home markets 42 Economic Research Department, Swedbank AB (publ), SE-105 34 Stockholm, tel +46-8-5859 7740 E-post: ek.sekr@swedbank.se Internet: www.swedbank.com Responsible publishers: Cecilia Hermansson, +46-8-5859 7720. Magnus Alvesson, +46-8-5859 3341, Jörgen Kennemar, +46-8-5859 7730, ISSN 1103-4897
  • 2. 1. Our main scenario: Modest growth in spite of everything Since our spring forecast, the global economy has continued to Economic pessimism muddle through while financial unrest has grown, which is clearly and the debt crisis reflected in the recent stock market sell-off around the world. Two have caused a major key factors are creating nervousness in the financial markets: the stock sell-off debt crisis in the US and Europe, and the risk of a new global recession. The debt crisis is largely a question of a loss of faith in politicians The US debt crisis is to manage crises. In the US, it took a long time to negotiate a the fault of politicians higher debt ceiling, at the same time that the medium-term debt reduction was insufficient and poorly structured without any tax increases. A debt downgrade by Standard and Poor’s followed soon afterward. In the euro zone, the debt crisis has spread from Greece, Ireland The euro crisis is and Portugal to larger countries such as Spain and Italy. worsening as larger Inadequate institutional frameworks and increased nationalism countries see interest are undermining the euro cooperation and threatening the rates rise currency's future. Interest rate differentials between fiscally “sound” and “unsound” euro countries have been driven higher. Poor growth prospects due to the competitive weakness of many crisis countries also make it harder to manage the budget consolidation process. Although the most recent rescue package caused Greek, Irish and Portuguese interest rates to fall, Spanish and Italian rates have instead risen. The only way to stop this was for the European Central Bank to buy bonds from these large countries, which is hardly a long-term solution. Interest rate differential between German and other EU 10-year government bonds 17,5 15,0 12,5 Percentage points 10,0 G reece 7,5 5,0 Ireland S pain P ortugal 2,5 Italy 0,0 UK F rance B elgium S weden -2,5 07 08 09 10 11 S o urce : R e u te rs E co W in 2 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 3. The risk of a double dip recession has grown. In GDP terms, this Growing fears of a means global growth of less than 2%. The nervousness stems double dip partly from the purchasing managers indexes around the world, which are now dangerously close to a reading of 50, signalling that there is essentially no growth in industry, and partly from the risk that the stock sell-off will have a negative wealth effect and reduce confidence, in turn leading to lower global trade, consumption and investment. Purchasing managers index in various countries/regions 2006-2011 65 60 55 50 45 40 USA UK J a p an 35 E u rola n d C h ina In d ia 30 G lo ba l 25 07 08 09 10 11 S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in Despite the worries in the financial markets, we haven’t changed In spite of everything, our view that the global economy will “muddle through”, although we are sticking by our we see growth prospects worsening compared with our spring main scenario, i.e., forecast. We are also adding something new by extending our that the economy will forecast to 2013. “muddle through”, but with weaker growth Our growth revisions primarily concern the US and Japan, compared with last although the euro zone is also expected to grow more slowly. For spring the US, the key has been a significantly weaker than expected recovery this year, which can't be blamed on temporary factors alone, but stems more so from major structural problems in the labour and housing markets as well as an antagonistic political climate. For Japan, the focus has naturally been on the earthquake For 2011, we have disaster in March, which has reduced activity this year, but is revised the US and very likely to raise it starting late this year and for several Japan downward... quarters to come as the reconstruction progresses. We have also had to revise our GDP growth estimates upward in several … but we have also countries. Germany has strong momentum and is benefitting revised the euro zone, from demand from emerging countries, along with its relative through Germany and fiscal strength, a fairly weak euro and low interest rates. Growth France, upward… slowed more than expected during the second quarter, however, including in France. Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 3
  • 4. China has surprised with stronger growth than we had projected. … while China has Even though we see a slowdown in activity going forward, we also surprised on the have revised our GDP growth forecast upward on the basis of the upside to date strong results. Many emerging countries are raising interest rates to reduce the risk of overheating, and this is gradually affecting demand. When developed countries grow more slowly, it also reduces the risk of a hard landing. In the event of a major slowdown, economic tools are available, since interest rates can be cut and the government budget can be allowed to expand. Global GDP forecast Autumn Forecast Spring Forecast GDP growth (%) 2010 2011 2012 2013 2010 2011 2012 US 3,0 2,1 2,3 2,7 2,9 3,0 3,0 Euro zone: 1,8 1,7 1,3 1,3 1,7 1,5 1,5 of which: Germany 3,6 2,9 1,8 1,6 3,6 2,4 1,9 France 1,4 1,5 1,5 1,4 1,6 1,5 1,6 Italy 1,3 0,8 0,7 1,0 1,3 0,9 1,0 Spain -0,1 0,6 0,8 1,2 -0,1 0,3 1,0 UK 1,3 1,3 1,6 1,8 1,4 1,5 1,8 Japan 4,0 -0,2 2,8 1,4 4,0 0,6 3,0 China 10,3 9,0 8,4 8,0 10,3 8,8 8,4 India 10,4 7,8 7,5 7,5 9,1 8,0 7,5 Brazil 7,5 3,8 4,1 4,5 7,5 4,3 4,0 Russia 4,0 4,5 4,4 4,2 4,0 4,6 4,5 Global GDP in PPP 5,0 3,8 3,9 3,8 4,9 4,1 4,2 Global GDP in US dollars 4,1 2,9 3,1 3,1 4,0 3,2 3,4 Sources: National statistics and Swedbank’s forecasts. Note: These countries represent about 70% of the global economy. To arrive at total GDP growth, approx. 0.3 percentage points should be added. The World Bank’s weights from 2009 have been used, which raises total figures by 0.1-0.2 percentage points compared with our spring forecast, when 2009 weights were used. Developed countries aren't in the same position as emerging Few economic tools economies, since they have already used up their “ammunition” are left in the West if in connection with the financial crisis and the global recession in economic conditions 2008-2009. We still feel, however, that a new slowdown in the worsen… global economy like the one we saw after the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy can be avoided. The global economy is better prepared today. The financial system, though far from fully repaired, is not as unbalanced. This time we don’t have as much debt-financed activity, but there is overcapacity still hanging around since the last recession. If the stock sell-off ends without too much damage to the financial sector and the real economy, the recovery can continue, though at a weaker pace. Nonetheless, growth prospects can be considered fairly decent … but a new Lehman despite the concerns that currently exist and which the financial Brothers-like crash can markets won't be rid of anytime soon. Following are a number of be avoided additional reasons why we believe that the global economy will avoid a new recession:  There is a greater awareness after the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy of the costs to the global economy of not addressing financial turbulence in time 4 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 5. The financial system, though not yet healthy, is less imbalanced today  Emerging countries would be affected by a slowdown, but still could resort to economic stimulus and gradually increase intraregional trade  Emerging countries are “catching up,” which means high growth  Slower global growth is contributing to lower demand for raw materials, which is slowing the rise in commodity prices, and in turn inflation  High productivity and lower cost pressures through wages and raw materials are raising corporate profits  paving the way for investment and new hirings  Extremely low interest rates for several years will keep investment costs down  Major need for new investment in infrastructure, energy and climate However, the recovery will still remain slow in the developed economies going forward, and here is why:  Continued debt restructuring in the private sector and low loan demand  Fading impact of economic stimulus  Negative impact on growth of budget consolidation  Higher benchmark interest rates, though further in the future  Little faith in the ability of politicians to resolve crises  High volatility in the financial markets is a cause of concern  Emerging countries will downshift when faced with overheating  Weak labour markets are hurting consumption  Stiffer regulation of the financial sector could make capital more expensive  Remaining capacity surplus on a global level A lot depends on emerging countries to keep the wheels of the The global economy is global economy turning. Yet it is essential for them that dependent on developed countries avoid a new recession and at least maintain emerging countries, some growth in order to preserve demand for imports from and vice versa emerging countries. We are aware that the risks of an economic decline (or perhaps Huge swings make an improvement) are great. In some sense, the situation is worse accurate forecasts today than after Lehman Brothers if the global economy were to difficult – risks have to truly slide into a new recession, since few economic tools are be carefully analysed available to more developed countries – or they are no longer as effective. In the next section, we discuss alternative scenarios and what could trigger them. It’s also worth noting that it is very difficult to build an accurate scenario for the years ahead at a time of financial turbulence and when forecasting parameters change on a daily basis. In summary, the recovery will continue in our main scenario, but it will be slower than in our spring forecast, and GDP growth will average less than 4% in 2011-2013. Emerging countries represent two thirds of growth during the period, at the same time that developed countries are struggling with the debt crisis, a crisis of political faith and structural problems after the financial crisis, all factors that are restricting growth. Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 5
  • 6. 2. An increasingly complex risk picture When the global economy is in a period of dramatic change, it is difficult to make reliable forecasts. The assumptions about various markets, political decisions and the reactions to them can quickly prove inaccurate. In the following chapter we discuss a number of factors that can We also offer one produce better or worse scenarios than our main scenario. better and one worse What’s difficult is that the risk picture becomes more complex scenario – but the risk when risks affect each other. This makes it important not only to picture is complex and analyse risks individually, but also the dynamic between them. skewed The risk picture is skewed, and the forecast risks on the downside are greater in number, more serious and larger than the risks on the upside. We discuss two scenarios other than our main scenario, one with slower growth which we give a 30% probability, and a better scenario with a 10% probability. Our main scenario is also relatively uncertain, with a probability of 60%. Main scenario/low growth scenario with global GDP growth of 3.5-4% In our main scenario, we have projected global GDP growth in We give our main PPP terms of 3.5-4% in 2011-2013. In this scenario, the debt scenario with 3-4% crisis doesn’t worsen appreciably in the developed countries, but growth a 60% budget austerity does further impact growth prospects. The probability, a better political process, like the global economy, “muddles through”, as scenario 10% and a politicians react to the financial turbulence rather than being worse scenario 30% proactive. The market jitters will ease, but a significant rebound is not in sight. Emerging countries will manage to maintain growth reasonably well with stimulus measures and without major inflation problems. A recession scenario with global GDP growth in PPP terms below 2% next year  A global economic slowdown is already evident, and after a delay the stock market sell-off could lead to even lower demand through negative wealth effects and a further loss of confidence among households and businesses. An accelerated slowdown cannot be checked with interest-rate cuts or more expansive fiscal policies in developed countries. On the contrary, we head toward a period of government debt restructuring which constrains growth.  A new recession in the US becomes more likely after the political crisis has worsened, US debt has been downgraded and households lose confidence, which translates into lower consumption. The labour and housing markets are already developing weakly, and if growth slows further we could see a negative spiral of lower confidence and growth as well as a weaker financial sector. The risk of deflation in the US economy will rise if 6 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 7. growth slows significantly. The Federal Reserve can give asset prices a boost through quantitative easing, but can do little to strengthen the labour market or growth. Fiscal policy is too tight at present and too loose in the medium term, but American politicians lack the will and courage to do the opposite, which makes it difficult to lift the US out of a new recession.  A new recession in the US would worsen growth prospects in the rest of the world, including the BRIC countries. Another quantitative easing would again increase overheating problems in emerging countries due to increased capital inflows to them and to commodity markets. This would also make it more difficult for emerging countries to rely on an economic stimulus, which could spark higher inflation. As a result, they may not be able to “rescue” the world this time. Increased capital inflows could also lead to a currency war and protectionism. Chaotic currency corrections have been avoided so far, but could be the outcome if the dollar and/or euro weaken substantially.  An expanded debt crisis in the euro zone that spreads to Spain, Italy and even France would be the most important catalyst for a global recession by spreading to the banking system and real economy. This could be the result if political consensus and courage cannot be found to address a larger crisis. For example, the EFSF won’t be big enough if, in addition to Greece, Ireland and Portugal, Spain and Italy also have problems. This would require more than 1 500 billion euros, compared with the 440 billion euros the fund now has at its disposal. The next version of the fund, ESM, won't be enough either, at 700 billion euros. If the big euro countries have problems, responsibility will rest squarely with AAA- rated Germany, France and the Netherlands. The sovereign debt crisis would worsen at the same time that more banks go bankrupt or are rescued by already highly indebted governments. The euro’s collapse would no longer be unlikely if the political will can’t be mustered, which could be the case if responsibility rests squarely on Germany and the Germans tire of financing the rest of the euro zone’s overconsumption.  A huge stock sell-off and anxiety in the financial markets that spreads to the real economy and banking system would be the outcome of a major debt crisis in the euro zone and a new recession in the US.  Social unrest increases in the wake of high unemployment and a sharp decline in future confidence, particularly among young people. Violent protests, revolts and uprisings, especially in developed countries, pave the way for greater populism and nationalism. Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 7
  • 8. This leads to even greater political impotence, which in turn accelerates the collapse of the euro.  An expanded crisis in connection with the democracy movement in the Arab world spreads to Saudi Arabia, causing oil prices to rise and threatening supplies.  Another reason why commodity prices could stay high in a negative growth environment is if emerging countries develop fairly strongly with high demand for raw materials, while developed countries continue to slide backward with an increased risk of a stagflation scenario.  Even if the effects on the global economy shouldn’t be overestimated, natural disasters, climate change, power shortages and other infrastructure problems, war and terror, and, not least, the “unknown factor” could also hurt future confidence and set back the economy, serving as a catalyst for a major slowdown in an already negative growth climate. A high-growth scenario with global GDP growth upwards of 5% or more next year  Worries about a new recession turn out to be overblown, as evidenced by China's strong export data for June. Nervousness in the stock market eases and does not have a major impact on the economy. The recovery continues to gain momentum once sentiment changes from pessimism to optimism.  The financial system has repaired the large part of its balance sheets and is ready to begin lending again, at the same time that consumer debt restructurings wind down, which leads to increased credit demand.  Lower commodity prices and cost pressures create higher profits. With higher productivity and better confidence, the willingness to invest and recruit rebounds.  Decision-makers find the strength and courage to address the current crisis. Instead of reacting, they take the initiative with respect to the euro cooperation, the US medium-term budget consolidation and Japan’s longstanding debt crisis and political crisis. Confidence grows when measures have a tangible effect. Politicians collaborate nationally across parties and also succeed in achieving greater international coordination. Although the measures could weaken growth through austerity, there are greater positive effects from increased confidence, which creates a willingness to invest and consume. 8 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 9. 3. Economic policy: Few tools The same crisis – but it has expanded to the public sector When the financial crisis erupted in 2008, few people predicted The 2008 financial that the debt problems in the private sector would spread to the crisis is still alive and public sector and that it would take years to overcome. An has mutated economic recovery may have begun in 2009, but with the stimulus programs it was hard to tell how self-sustaining it was and whether it was mostly just a bounceback after the severe recession. Countries with balance sheet problems such as the US, the UK, Spain and Ireland have had a hard time recovering. The balance sheet recession they face requires major structural changes to the economy. The focus in their case is on debt restructuring and less willingness to borrow and consume. Countries without imbalances, such as Germany, Sweden and Finland, have recovered reasonably well, in no small part due to strong growth in Asia, Latin America, the Middle East and Africa. The problem is that it is the larger industrialised countries Nearly all industrialised (Germany accepted) that are now reporting huge budget deficits countries have debt and swelling government debt. Countries that originally had problems problems with private debt are being joined by others with large public debt such as Greece, Italy, Belgium and France. There are fears that the public debt crisis will work its way back to the private sector through the banking system and that the next crisis will include not only credit problems but also currency problems due to a collapse of the euro zone. There is also a risk that the private and public debt restructuring will adversely affect growth, without which any debt restructuring will be even more difficult. Economic tools – then and now The realisation that politicians and central bankers do not have The lack of the same ammunition to stop a new recession that they did in ammunition is a 2008/2009 is now baked into expectations. Back then benchmark cause of concern rates were cut to nearly zero, quantitative easing reduced long- term interest rates and drove up stock prices, liquidity was supplied, and banks were rescued, at the same time that fiscal policy supported the economy through higher spending and/or lower taxes. Stimulus packages were coordinated around the world, including with emerging countries, which gained a stronger voice through the G20. It was fairly easy to be a politician, and the financial markets appreciated the resolute efforts to support the financial sector, asset markets and the economy. Economic policy has now become more of a national concern, and in the absence of any tools it has become much more difficult to be a policymaker. An important distinction from an economic standpoint is that interest rates are already low and that it is generally felt that Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 9
  • 10. another quantitative easing would have little effect. While an easing could lead to higher stock prices, they won't last if the global economy still shows signs of weakness. At the same time a quantitative easing produces higher capital flows to asset and commodity markets, with an increased risk of overheating. Furthermore, demand for government bonds is relatively high in countries with a balance sheet recession, since many investors have to seek out safe havens. This is also evident by the decline in long-term interest rates despite the stock market turbulence. Another important distinction – including from a political A fiscal stimulus may standpoint – is that there is little or no support for a new fiscal be economically stimulus. That includes countries where the financial market motivated… could finance one without exorbitant risk premiums, such as the US, Japan and the UK. For countries with balance sheet recessions, monetary policy isn't the important thing, since businesses and households have less interest in borrowing. Instead, there is more focus on fiscal policy, especially in combination with structural reforms, to raise growth potential. The crisis in the euro zone leaves few alternatives other than … but there isn’t a austerity, even at a point when the recovery is unravelling. For political consensus crisis countries, risk premiums are soaring and they are finding hard to finance their deficits. In the US, the Tea Party movement has made another stimulus, e.g., to help the labour market recover more quickly, politically inexpedient. Instead, the emphasis has shifted to reducing the size of the government regardless of the potential impact. Political leadership and economic advice We have acknowledged that the job of politicians has been made more difficult by a lack of tools. In addition, the scope of the crisis has become more complex. When a crisis becomes less acute, the focus shifts to moral hazards. The economy cannot be stimulated without considering the driving forces, i.e., whether the system is encouraging market participants to create or avoid a similar crisis in the future. Crisis management now seems to mean biding time. In the euro zone, politicians won't react until the financial markets act, and usually ineffectually, which has led to a steady succession of new summit meetings. A lot of attention is being paid to how voters will react to political The crisis decisions. This is especially true in Germany, where the management reluctance to pay for the debt problems of its undisciplined capabilities of neighbours has grown. Nationalism has been allowed to fester, politicians leave much and real problems are being obscured. Instead we hear a lot of to be desired … sloganeering: “The euro is stable and secure” or “The euro won't collapse”. What aren’t being discussed enough are a vision and the benefits of an integrated Europe. If crisis management has been a stumbling block for politicians, … but contradictory economists seem to disagree on the right advice, which certainty advice from doesn’t make it easier for politicians. Some suggest that another economists hasn’t quantitative easing is needed, while others want it to end. Some helped 10 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 11. want to see a fiscal stimulus, while others want to see rapid, far- reaching austerity programmes. Another difference compared with 2008/2009 is the labour market. Unemployment has soared in many crisis countries, or taken longer to decline. Strikes, demonstrations and violent unrest are a sign of resignation, anger and fear. Many young people are at risk of becoming a “forgotten generation” with a lower standard of living for the rest of their lives. Income gaps and social tension are growing. Political developments have become a source of growing Forecasters are concern when assessing the economy. In addition to economics becoming increasingly and psychology, political science has to be included for a holistic interested in political perspective. A lack of faith in the political process is affecting the risks willingness to invest and consume and hurting stock prices. One area that has to be better explored is the euro zone’s development from a democratic standpoint. Can political leaders agree on changes at summits without having to rely on commissions to voice objections and make improvements? How do you create confidence in such a process, which is now inexorably leading to greater supranationalism as a result of the debt crisis? In the US and Japan, the bigger question is how political campaigns are financed and what it means to political decisions? In the US, it is never easy to raise taxes on the rich, who not insignificantly are the ones who pay for election campaigns. The divide between politicians and voters is growing, which is making it more difficult to reach effective economic policy decisions. What’s a sensible policy from an economic perspective? From an economic perspective, we suggest several measures below to reduce the risk of a new recession and slow the crisis in a few years’ time. We focus on developments in the US, the euro zone, China and other emerging countries. We also offer suggestions for better international accords. USA  President Obama has to explain the seriousness of the recession (a balance sheet recession) that the US is in, why the usual tools aren't working and why fiscal policy is more important than monetary policy at this juncture.  Another fiscal stimulus targeting growth and jobs is needed in the short term, but with tighter budget consolidation in the medium term (the opposite of what is now being done). Greater clarity with regard to medium-term fiscal policy would strengthen confidence.  Taxes and spending eventually have to be balanced by expanding the tax base, eliminating deductions and increasing taxes on the wealthy. A reassessment of the social security system and defence spending is needed.  A new round of quantitative easing is reasonable only if there is another recession and deflation signals increase. The introduction of an inflation Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 11
  • 12. target to increase the independence of the central bank could improve confidence.  Structural reforms are needed to improve the housing and labour markets, with a focus on encouraging hiring and employability, especially among the long-term unemployed.  Reshaping the political system is also important to the economy. This includes reforming campaign financing laws, changing the size of voting districts and increasing the effectiveness of Congress. The euro zone  The currency union is irrevocable, which has to be realised. If a country is forced to leave (e.g., Greece), expectations are that its currency (drachma) will weaken, leading to capital flight and the spread of the banking crisis to other countries. This wouldn't apply to Germany, where expectations are the opposite, i.e., that the currency (D-mark) would strengthen and lead to capital flows from other countries. Of course in Germany’s case it would also mean lower exports due to a stronger currency and the crisis in the rest of the union. Rescuing one or more countries is less costly than breaking up the entire union.  The time for denial should be over within the euro zone, including Germany. The euro zone’s debt crisis is not only a liquidity crisis but also a solvency crisis. Aid packages have to contain better terms and write-offs. For Greece, for example, the percentage agreed to on July 21 is too small, since its debt ratio will reach 150% of GDP and it will lose a decade in terms of GDP growth.  The state of denial includes the euro zone’s banks. Excessive write-offs threaten their balance sheets and they therefore have to recapitalise in expectation of the next round of write-offs. The expansion of the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) is a step in the right direction, since it can now (if parliament ratifies the proposal) be used to support banks in crisis, not only countries in crisis.  It is also time for the crisis countries to stop denying reality. They are waking up too late after risk premiums have risen and their deficits can no longer be financed. The crisis countries have to surprise the financial markets with more extensive reforms and a greater focus on growth and competitiveness – Italy’s nominal growth must exceed the interest rates on its debt. Austerity programmes have to be reasonable based on effectiveness and income distribution, with a sensible balance between spending cuts and higher taxes. The emphasis must be on eliminating bureaucracies, inefficiencies, tax evasion and the informal sector. Privatisations are often necessary, not least to raise productivity.  The European Central Bank (ECB) has adopted a questionable attitude toward its responsibility as a lender of last resort. Although the ECB wasn't supposed to assume the responsibility of politicians to rescue governments in need, it has purchased nearly 100 billion euros in government bonds from Greece, Ireland, Portugal and most recently Spain and Italy. This is in addition to just over 400 billion euros in outstanding loans to banks in June, two thirds of which were to banks in Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain. The ECB is protective of its independence and now may have to ask governments in the euro zone for a recapitalisation. The question is how long the ECB can keep buying Italian and Spanish government obligations and where to draw the line, as well as what would happen if it withdraws its support?  The idea that the EFSF, with an estimated size of 440 billion euros (its lending capacity is now 225 billion euros), would be big enough even if Italy faced major problems is questionable. Instead, the fund would have to triple in size to 1 500 billion euros or more to handle a more serious crisis. The question then is whether France and Germany could maintain their high credit ratings, which they need to get the best interest terms. When 12 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 13. the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) takes effect in July 2013, conditions will be more stable with a lending capacity of 500 billion euros and a total facility of 700 billion euros. Of this amount, 80 billion euros will be paid through tax revenues and the rest of the capital can be called in or guaranteed.  The ECB’s bond purchases and risk of recapitalisation, as well as the EFSF and ESM stability facilities, clearly show that the euro zone has already developed into a transfer union in spite of denials by politicians. The question is what’s the best way to facilitate transfers, so that they are effective economically and acceptable politically. The currency union has to be complemented by greater fiscal coordination, a common bank regulator and a central bank that takes responsibility as a lender of last resort. That would help to instil the confidence in the common currency that politicians are hoping for.  A Eurobond market doesn't solve the immediate problem of the need for debt write-offs and support mechanisms. However, it would certainly go hand in hand with greater fiscal coordination and automatic sanctions if budget rules aren't followed. A proposal by the think tank Bruegel (“The Blue Bond Proposal” by Jacques Depla and Jakob von Weizsäcker) would pool Eurobonds up to 60% of GDP (about 5 600 billion euros) and assign this tranche – the blue bond – a lower interest rate than the current average. Thanks to the increased liquidity, even countries such as Germany might find the proposal appealing, and the euro’s position as a reserve currency would be strengthened. Member states themselves would have to manage debts in excess of 60% of their GDP. Lower liquidity and higher interest rates would be an incentive to reduce debt to 60%. This proposal addresses moral hazards and maintains budget discipline despite the joint Eurobond. In addition, an institution is needed to oversee the allocation of blue bonds, so that mismanaged countries are no longer allowed to participate. By extension, the federal budget has to expand as well and extend its focus beyond common agricultural and structural policy.  The currency union is an economic project that complements the EU’s integration and strengthens the region’s position in the global economy. At the same time it is just as much a political project, which requires a political commitment to support the cooperation. The problem today is that national concerns have taken precedence at the same time that democracy has been overshadowed. It wouldn't be unreasonable to transition from poorly prepared and less-than-transparent summits to commissions that are given more time, produce reports and allow for objections and discussions. Complementing the currency union with a fiscal union, a common bank regulator and a central bank that takes full responsibility will take time, but the important thing is that the process begins with a vision and openness. China  A continued – and possibly faster – depreciation of the renminbi is needed to choke off inflation and strengthen domestic demand, which would also reduce global imbalances.  It is important that Chinese financial sector and financial markets develop and that renminbi becomes convertible, but a deft touch is required, as well as a change in China’s growth model. Greater openness is needed for foreign players in China’s financial sector, in addition to greater opportunities for the Chinese to do business abroad. The process is under way, and it is important that it continues.  Improvements to the social security system would reduce the need to save. Domestic demand could then increase and income gaps would eventually shrink.  Increased transparency about debt is important on the part of the national government, public authorities and regions. Officially, government debt as a share of GDP is less than 20%, but all indications are that total debt is higher, 50-70%. To understand how much room there is for a stimulus, Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 13
  • 14. debt and inflation data have to be more transparent. Better GDP data is also needed. Emerging economies  Supply and demand have to be better balanced to avoid overheating, e.g., in India.  Fiscal policy has to be tightened where signs of overheating are strong and growth is high, e.g., Brazil.  The peg to the dollar has to be removed to avoid external and internal imbalances, e.g., the Middle East.  Subsidies have to be reduced to improve economic drivers and reduce budget deficits. This includes increased use of environmentally friendly energy, e.g., the Middle East, India.  Efforts to reduce corruption must be intensified in a number of countries, including India, Brazil and China. Across national borders  The separation of responsibility between the Basel Committee and the Financial Stability Board (FSB) is unclear, as is the line between the banking system and the shadow banking system.  Decisions to regulate capital flows and currencies are made at the national level despite international effects.  The G20 has lost steam. Greater efforts are needed to determine whether the Basel III capital requirements are sufficient (which seems doubtful), how banking activities should be managed across national borders (including large institutions and what happens when they fail), and the role of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in managing global imbalances, volatile capital flows, exchange rate problems and uncertainties about the build-up of foreign exchange reserves.  The desire of China and other countries to use Special Drawing Rights (SDR) as a new currency isn't realistic; it would make more sense to prepare for a transition from the dollar as a reserve currency to a triumvirate of the dollar, euro and renminbi – a reality in about a decade given that China’s financial sector will continue to develop and that there is still confidence in the dollar and euro as global currencies. 14 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 15. 4. Our assumptions about the commodity and financial markets In the following, we describe the assumptions that support our forecast with respect to the commodity, equity, fixed income and currency markets. The basis for our assumptions consists of growth and inflation estimates, psychological effects, political commitments and crisis management expectations. Uncertainty is great, and developments that significantly deviate from our assumptions could materially change the economic outlook. Commodity markets The rise in commodity prices in 2010 and early this year has Slower global growth levelled off. A weaker global economy is lowering demand for means lower commodities. Supply problems in commodity markets have also commodity prices eased. Droughts and fires had earlier caused food production to drop, but supplies are now holding up better. The Arab Spring has entered a second phase, and is worrying the oil market less. The quantitative easing in the US has run its course, which has meant less investor interest in the commodity markets. We also believe that we have seen the worst of the dollar’s decline in trade-weighted terms, leaving producers no reason to still demand compensation for currency fluctuations. Commodity prices (total), food prices and commodity prices excluding oil (index) 175 T o ta l c o m m o d ity p ric e , e x c l o il 150 125 T o ta l c o m m o d ity p ric e Index 100 75 50 F o o d p ric e s 25 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in In our spring forecast we predicted that oil, which was trading around USD 115 at the time, would fall when uncertainty about the Middle East and the global economy eased. It took a while to prove true, and now the reason has more to do with weak global economic growth. We saw last spring that the risks were on the upside due to problems in the Middle East and Japan. We therefore have to revise upward our previous estimate of Oil price estimates USD 105 this year and USD 98 in 2012, since oil prices have have been revised held up longer than we expected. Instead we anticipate a price of upward since the USD 110 this year. As global growth slows, oil will gradually spring forecast return to a level of just over USD 97 next year and USD 94 in Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 15
  • 16. 2013. This is still relatively high and is based on continued strong demand in emerging countries, which are gradually increasing their consumption of raw materials. Commodity prices and projections 2009-2013 (Brent crude oil in US dollars per barrel, food and metals in index 2010 = 100) 140 130 120 110 100 90 Food Metals 80 Oil 70 60 50 40 2009  2009  2009  2009  2010  2010  2010  2010  2011  2011  2011  2011  2012  2012  2012  2012  2013  2013  2013   2013  Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 We expect price declines for industrial metals (by 3-6%) and food (by 4-7%) in 2012 and 2013, after they rose by 32% and 20%, respectively, in 2011. Supplies should remain steady while Precious metals rise – demand declines, producing a downward trend. The opposite is while industrial metals true of precious metals (primarily gold and silver), which will fall continue to rise in price in the immediate future due to jittery financial markets and the US credit downgrade. The risk of lower commodity prices is related to a more The risks are still on pessimistic growth scenario and unease in the financial markets. the upside, and There are also risks on the upside, which could be realised if we emerging countries are were to see faster global growth, another quantitative easing in playing a more the US and a further decline in the dollar. New supply problems important role in connection with disruptive weather and unrest in the Middle East, for example, could contribute to higher prices. It should also be noted that emerging countries are increasingly important to prices in more developed countries. Since activity will increase faster in Asia, Latin America and the Middle East than in more developed countries, commodity prices could still rise more than desired given weak growth prospects in the West. Inflation and interest rates Lower commodity prices are expected to contribute to a much more favourable inflation outlook than in 2010 and 2011. Basically all we need are more stable food and energy prices for inflation to begin to fall on an annual basis. We think inflation will soon peak for now and turn lower in both developed and emerging countries. The main factors affecting inflation in more developed countries A weak job market and are the budget consolidation and the weak labour market, which budget consolidation are slowing demand, including wage and price pressures. Europe are restraining price and the US face similar situations, with a lower inflation outlook. and wage pressures We expect Japanese inflation to be temporary against the 16 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 17. backdrop of higher commodity prices, but once they fall we again see a period of deflation in Japan. Inflation (CPI) in a number of countries 2004-2011 1 7 ,5 In d ia 1 5 ,0 1 2 ,5 C h in a 1 0 ,0 Percent 7 ,5 B ra z il 5 ,0 UK 2 ,5 US G e rm a n y 0 ,0 Japan -2 ,5 08 09 10 11 S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in Emerging countries are finding it harder to rein in inflation. Overheating risks are Tighter economic policies are helping to prevent an overheating, easing in emerging and capital inflows should also shrink due to the economic countries, but can’t be weakness and the end to quantitative easing. The key for many totally overlooked emerging countries is to expand their capacity, so that supply better meets demand. Inflation outlook measured by the annual increase in CPI (%) CPI 2010 2011 2012 2013 US 1,6 3,2 1,7 2,0 Eurozone 1,6 2,8 2,0 2,0 UK 3,3 4,1 2,5 2,0 Japan -0,7 0,2 0,7 0,5 China 3,3 5,5 4,2 3,0 India 9,2 8,5 6,5 5,2 Brazil 5,9 6,4 5,0 4,2 Russia 6,9 9,5 8,0 6,5 Global CPI 2,8 4,2 3,0 2,6 Sources: National statistics and Swedbank’s forecasts. We expect inflation to gradually fall from its current levels and In our main scenario, a that emerging countries as a group will avoid an economic hard hard landing is averted landing. Weaker growth in industrial countries will also impact demand in emerging countries. India has already seen an improvement compared with when monsoon rains caused food prices to rise sharply. Brazil has to limit credit growth, and with lower global growth and commodity prices its economy should slow, reducing price pressures. Chinese inflation will soon peak, Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 17
  • 18. but a further economic tightening may be needed to sustainably reduce inflation. A more favourable inflation outlook will relieve central banks of The threat of the worry of stagflation in the West. On April 13 the European stagflation will now Central Bank (ECB) raised its benchmark rate by 25 bp to 1.25% become less evident after inflation rose to high levels, and followed it on July 13 with a new hike to 1.5% before pausing at its latest meeting in August. US, British and Japanese central banks, on the other hand, have The ECB is pausing kept their key rates unchanged. In the British case in particular, and others are this has been criticised, since inflation peaked at 4.5% in April delaying rate hikes and May before falling to 4.2% in June. The private consumption deflator has also risen in the US, to nearly 2%, but with prospects of lower growth and easing inflation, central banks can now wait even longer before tightening monetary policy. The Bank of England is waiting until the first half of 2013 to raise rates, and any increases after that are likely to start slowly. Benchmark rates 2000-2010 8 N orway A ustralia 7 Euroarea 6 UK 5 Percent 4 3 2 S weden 1 US Japan 0 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 Sou rce: R euters E co W in In our spring forecast, we didn't think the Federal Reserve would We do not expect a US have to raise rates until the second half of 2012, but due to rate increase before weaker growth prospects and modest inflation it has decided to mid 2013 wait even longer. Chairman Ben Bernanke has now announced that the Fed won’t raise rates until at least mid-2013. This is the “easiest” way for the central bank to create more expansive monetary policy. The continued shakiness of the US recovery and weakness of Little marginal benefit the labour market – combined with greater difficulty financing the from an additional budget deficit after the credit downgrade – is raising demands for quantitative easing a new quantitative easing of some sort (QE3). We don't rule one out, but expect that the Fed will want to see signs of deflation before taking such a step. It should also be noted that QE2 didn’t have much effect on long-term interest rates initially. In fact, they rose after the programme was announced. The subsequent 18 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 19. decline was more likely the result of increased pessimism about growth. In addition, long-term interest rates are already so low that the effects on the labour market of trying to push them lower still will probably be minimal. The costs to expand the central bank’s balance sheet, which would make exit strategies more challenging, aren't negligible either. The easing – if there is one – should perhaps be seen in light of concerns about financing the huge budget deficit of about 10% of GDP, the risk of a larger decline in the dollar, and most importantly the risk of deflation. Given the worries about the euro zone’s growth and the sovereign debt crisis in the periphery countries – coupled with a lower benchmark rate in the US and slower inflation – the ECB may pause until the second half of 2012 before raising rates. Not until then do we anticipate a rate hike of 0.25 bp, to 1.75%, to be followed by another hike in the first half of 2013. The core countries of Germany and France may be the ones that have to resort to further austerity to keep inflation around the ECB’s target of just under 2%. Benchmark interest rates 2011-2013 16 aug 11 31 dec 11 30 jun 12 31 dec 12 30 jun 13 31 dec 13 Federal Reserve 0,25 0,25 0,25 0,25 0,25 0,75 ECB 1,50 1,50 1,50 1,75 2,00 2,00 Bank of England 0,50 0,50 0,50 0,50 1,00 1,50 Bank of Japan 0,10 0,10 0,10 0,10 0,10 0,10 We don’t expect the BOJ to raise its benchmark rate during the Japan is still struggling forecast period. The risk of a new period of deflation is high, with deflation and a especially since budget cutbacks to stabilise debt and afford the strong yen reconstruction will impact economic demand. The BOJ would like to weaken the value of the yen and keep interest rates low for the same reason. Since our spring forecast, long-term market rates (10-year government bonds) have retreated. British long-term rates have dropped below the low levels seen in 2010, and rates in Germany and the US are well on their way. A more downbeat economic outlook, lower commodity prices and lower inflation are keeping the trend pointed downward. Just as importantly, the stock market sell-off is causing many investors to flee to safety, which is also keeping US and European long-term interest rates low. Despite the credit downgrade, funding costs are now declining, a Growth pessimism and trend we also saw when Japan’s credit was downgraded in 2002. the stock sell-off are Investors still turn to the US when stocks are volatile. Over the reducing bond yields forecast period, 10-year government bonds will rise by about 100 bp in Europe, 75 bp in the US and 50 bp in Japan. Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 19
  • 20. Long-term interest rates (10-year government bonds) 6 ,0 5 ,5 5 ,0 4 ,5 UK 4 ,0 G e rm a ny Procent 3 ,5 3 ,0 2 ,5 USA 2 ,0 1 ,5 Jap an 1 ,0 0 ,5 07 08 09 10 11 S o u rce : R e u te rs E co W in Demand for safe havens – government bonds from financially Interest rates are also sound countries – will increase in the years ahead as Basel III affected by tighter creates pressure to better capitalise banks. While this will regulations contribute to lower bond yields, the costs to maintain more capital in the banking system are likely to mean permanently higher margins, which in turn will lead to higher market rates. The impact of Basel III is difficult to determine, however, especially since a more stable financial sector could also help to reduce risk premiums and thereby lower interest rates. This shows just how much uncertainty there still is regarding the effects of Basel III. Exchange rates Since our spring forecast, the dollar has continued to weaken in The dollar has nominal terms, and a number of emerging countries have seen weakened since our their currencies appreciate. Brazilian Finance Minister Guido spring forecast, putting Mantega, for one, is concerned. Developed countries such as pressure on emerging Switzerland and Japan have also tried to keep their currencies countries from appreciating by loosening monetary policy and intervening in currency markets. Such interventions aren't usually very effective or long lasting. In real terms, the Japanese yen isn't especially overvalued either from a long-term perspective, although the recent change has been a complicating factor for a number of companies. 20 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 21. Nominal exchange rates in relation to the US dollar, index 2008-08-15 = 100 160 Brazilean Real 150 Swedish Krona Korean W on 140 130 Euro 120 110 100 Yuan 90 Swiss Franc 80 70 Yen 60 jan m aj sep jan m aj sep jan m aj sep jan m aj sep jan m aj 07 08 09 10 11 Source: R euters EcoW in We anticipate that the debt crises in the euro zone and the US Debt problems in the will keep the dollar-euro exchange rate fairly stable initially, after US and euro zone – which the dollar could appreciate against the euro on the basis of euro/dollar exchange slightly stronger growth and possibly how the debt crisis is rate fairly stable at this managed. point US dollar, trade-weighted in nominal terms 125 120 115 110 105 A v e ra g e 1 9 9 0 -2 0 1 1 100 Index 95 90 85 80 75 70 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in A further credit downgrade could reduce interest in the dollar, If the euro zone especially as emerging countries gradually diversify their tackles its debt currency portfolios and turn to other investments. problems but the US doesn’t, the dollar could Exchange rates 2011-2013 fall 16 aug 11 31 dec 11 30 jun 12 31 dec 12 30 jun 13 31 dec 13 EUR/USD 1,44 1,42 1,38 1,35 1,35 1,30 RMB/USD 6,38 6,16 6,00 5,79 5,64 5,44 USD/JPY 77 80 83 85 87 90 EUR/GBP 0,88 0,88 0,85 0,83 0,8 0,77 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 21
  • 22. China continues to allow the renminbi to appreciate against the dollar by about 6% per year in nominal terms. Since China’s inflation is higher than the majority of its trading partners, the appreciation is even higher in real terms. Efforts to internationalise the renminbi continue. Without a well-functioning financial market and a convertible currency, China is still dependent on the dollar, euro, yen and other international currencies. The Japanese yen is weakening in the wake of a shrinking trade When the crisis surplus and a slightly larger interest rate differential vis-à-vis subsides, the yen Europe and the US. Our assumption that the US won’t replace should weaken QE2 with QE3 should also contribute to a weaker yen. Stock prices Even before the recent slide, stock markets in developed countries had performed modestly at best. While markets in emerging countries nearly returned to their 2007 peak, stocks in the US, euro zone and Japan have a long way to go. Recent market jitters are the product of lower global growth expectations, the debt crisis in developed countries, the US credit downgrade and a severe crisis of confidence in the ability of decision-makers to manage crises. Political risks are especially difficult to evaluate, which is creating uncertainty and nervousness. Corporate profits could be affected by poorer growth prospects, though on the other hand cost pressures are easing due to lower Political risks are commodity and input goods prices. Negative news will garner a influencing market bigger reaction than positive news. Considering the challenges in psychology right now handling the debt crisis and euro cooperation, this will continue to frustrate the market for some time to come. It is impossible, however, to determine by how much and for how long the markets will be hurt. Equity prices in emerging countries ( MSCI EM), USA (S&P 500), the euro zone (FTSE EZ 300) and Japan (Nikkei 225) 2007-2011, index January 2007 = 100 150 140 MSCI EM 130 120 110 100 Index U SA S& P 500 90 80 FTSE EZ 300 70 60 50 N ik k e i 2 2 5 40 07 08 09 10 11 S o u rc e : R e u te rs E c o W in 22 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 23. 5. A lot depends on emerging economies The global economy has downshifted to a lower gear. The The global economy recovery continues, but not as quickly as in 2010, a rebound year has now shifted into a after the financial crisis and global recession. The risk picture has lower gear also become more negative. This year growth is being slowed by higher commodity prices, the Japanese disaster and the continuing balance sheet correction. Tighter economic policy will then be an increasing drag on growth. Annual GDP growth (%) in several major countries/regions 6,00 5,00 4,00 3,00 BRIC‐countries OECD‐countries 2,00 1,00 0,00 2010 2011 2012 2013 We expect the slowdown in emerging countries to be modest and Emerging countries that this group will remain the biggest contributor to growth (65- account for over two 70%). Their growth has trended below the historical average, and thirds of global growth without fiscal and monetary ammunition, reforms will be needed to speed their structural transformation and improve the medium- term outlook. Emerging economies have to implement reforms that immediately reduce the problem of overheating and create more sustainable domestic demand. That would also help to reduce global imbalances. US current account balance and China’s currency reserves 4 ,5 100 4 ,0 0 3 ,5 -1 0 0 3 ,0 -2 0 0 USD (thousand billions) 2 ,5 -3 0 0 USD (billions) 2 ,0 -4 0 0 1 ,5 -5 0 0 U S c u r re n t a c c o u n t 1 ,0 (rh s ) -6 0 0 0 ,5 -7 0 0 0 ,0 -8 0 0 C h in a 's c u r r e n c y -0 ,5 r e s e r v e s ( lh s ) -9 0 0 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 23
  • 24. The US – structural problems are impacting the economic outlook  Major downward revision of GDP growth against the backdrop of weaker economic data and growing pessimism – growth is too weak to significantly impact unemployment  The debt ceiling agreement is welcome, but the political process was a failure  Debt restructuring is starting slowly, but the long-term cuts seem inadequate to stabilise the debt burden The optimism surrounding the US economy late last year was A deeper recession in illusory. Rising unemployment, higher inflation, falling housing 2008-2009 and a prices and political discord on fiscal policy have left Americans slower recovery in anxious. During the first half of 2011 GDP growth has been 2010-11 weaker than expected – 1.8% at an annual rate and 0.8% at an annualized rate – which is also less than considered normal in a recovery, when there is usually available capacity. We also now know that the recession was deeper than indicated by previous data, with GDP falling by 5.1% in 2008-2009 rather than 4%. US GDP and inflation (annual change %), and unemployment (% of labour force) 12,5 10,0 10,0 9,5 Unemployment ---> 7,5 9,0 CPI 5,0 GDP - annualized quarterly growth 8,5 2,5 8,0 Percent Percent 0,0 7,5 -2,5 Private consumption 7,0 -5,0 deflation 6,5 -7,5 6,0 -10,0 5,5 -12,5 5,0 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 08 09 10 11 Source: Reuters EcoWin Temporary factors partly explain the slower development, Both structural and including the earthquake in Japan, unusual weather and temporary factors shrinking confidence in the ability of US politicians to solve the explain the economic budget and debt ceiling problems. The more important thing, doldrums however, is that the structural problems in the US economy haven’t been resolved and that the labour, housing and credit markets aren’t working normally in the wake of the financial crisis. Balance sheets still need correcting. Without another fiscal stimulus, the US economy will continue to trend below its historical growth. 24 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 25. In addition to the economic crisis, a political crisis is under way. A The US faces both an growing number of experts are characterising the political system economic and a as dysfunctional. There is little willingness to compromise, and political crisis the goal for politicians to get re-elected often overshadows the goal to help the country grow. After the financial and real estate crises, the US has to find a new identity in economic, political, cultural and geopolitical terms. American households can no longer be the growth engine for the global economy. Defence spending will shrink and will affect the ability of the US to respond in global hot spots. At home, a structural transformation is needed, at the same time that the government’s role is shrinking since tax hikes won't be tolerated by Congress. Income gaps are growing, and it is becoming harder to help those who have dropped out of the system. The negative confidence spiral has to be broken. Household and corporate expectations for the next half year (Conference Board) 120 110 H o u s e h o ld c o n f id e n c e 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 B u s in e s s c o n f id e n c e 30 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in We expect GDP growth to top out at 2.1% this year. Activity will increase during the second half year as gas prices fall slightly and the Japan Effect tapers off at the same time that political concerns ease, giving future confidence a needed boost. This represents a significant downward revision from our spring forecast of 3% and reflects the downturn in future confidence in recent months in pace with weaker GDP and job numbers. We still expect the growth engine in the form of consumer spending to falter, at the same time that other components in the supply balance aren’t able to raise growth above its average. In 2012, an election year, GDP growth will reach 2.3%, before climbing to 2.7% in 2013, when confidence could grow with new leadership. Monetary and fiscal policy will be tighter, however, which will keep growth below 3%. Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 25
  • 26. The US Congress has had major problems agreeing on how to “You can always count consolidate the budget in the years ahead. The increase in the on Americans to do the debt ceiling was contingent on spending cuts, and at the last right thing – after minute Republicans and Democrats agreed to raise the ceiling by they’ve tried everything USD 2.1- 2.4 trillion by the end of 2012, which means that it won’t else” be an issue in next year’s election campaign. - Winston Churchill The debt ceiling will initially be raised by USD 400 billion, then by another USD 500 billion unless blocked a Congressional resolution. The remaining USD 1.2-1.5 trillion will be part of a packaged agreement agreed to by a committee of representatives from both parties and containing spending cuts, tax reforms and other debt reductions. In the first years there will be little in the way of cutbacks, and consolidation has instead been pushed off to the future. While this may seem reasonable given the weak recovery, it creates uncertainty, since another Congress will have to implement today’s decision. Total government debt now exceeds 100% of GDP, while the Gross public debt is federal debt as a share of GDP is just over 70%. Had nothing now greater than GDP been done, it would have risen to 90% of GDP by 2030 and then about 200% in 2060, after the healthcare reform, which reduces the debt burden by about 100% of GDP between 2011 and 2060. Federal budget revenues, expenditures and balance 350 50 F in a n c in g n e e d - - > 300 25 250 0 USD (billions) USD (billions) 200 -2 5 150 -5 0 < --- B u d g e t e x p e n d itu r e s 100 -7 5 50 < --- B u d g e t re v e n u e s -1 0 0 0 -1 2 5 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05 10 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in The medium-term plan that would have been needed to stabilise Twice as large a the debt burden in the second half of this decade is thought to be budget consolidation at least USD 4 trillion, or about 20% of GDP. Revised growth could be needed prospects also will mean greater difficulty stabilising the debt as a share of GDP. The plan now calling for cuts of just USD 2.1-2.4 trillion doesn’t go far enough. The US therefore risks another credit downgrade. A lower rating could raise funding costs, add to financial turbulence and weaken the dollar considerably. The job market will be the focus of the campaign leading up to the presidential election in November 2012. No president has been re-elected in the last 50 years with unemployment higher than 7.2%. In July it was 9.1%, which is still higher than at the 26 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011
  • 27. beginning of 2011 even after declining slightly from June. It was also just a modest decline compared with the October 2009 peak of 10.1%. Compared with before the crisis, unemployment has more than doubled to 14 million. When you include those who are working part-time not by choice and those who are no longer actively looking for work, 29 million Americans are now counted as unemployed, about half of whom can also be considered long- term unemployed. The housing market has yet to bounce back. Housing The housing market construction appears to have hit bottom, but will remain there for has hit bottom and will some time. The same applies to new home prices and sales, stay there for a while which have been fairly stagnant and where the latter are back at their 1998 level. Low interest rates should have helped the housing market more, but households are continuing to fix their balance sheets at the same time that the credit market is having problems with new lending. Another critical factor is the vast inventory of unsold housing, which will keep prices low for some time to come. Housing market 8 27 5 7 25 0 6 22 5 Number of (millions) S ale s of n e w ho m e s 5 20 0 Index 4 17 5 C as e/S h ille r 3 S ale s of e x isting h om e s h o use p ric es for 15 0 1 0 cities ---> 2 12 5 1 10 0 R e side ntial co ns tru ctio n 0 75 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 S o u rc e : R e u te rs E co W in Inflation measured by CPI has risen due to higher energy and food prices, although core inflation (excluding energy and food) has also begun nearing uncomfortable levels, at just under 2%. On the other hand, we expect that when food and gas prices decline, inflation will ease, giving the Federal Reserve a respite before launching a period of rate hikes. We don’t anticipate the first hike until the second half of 2013, in line with the Fed’s announcement. This summer QE2 ended. Since deflation concerns have eased, Demands for QE3 we don’t anticipate another quantitative easing. Although a are gaining steam gloomier growth outlook and higher unemployment are now raising demands for a new easing to keep interest rates low and strengthen asset prices, the Fed isn’t likely to consider one until there are signs of deflation. Besides, another quantitative easing may not have much impact on growth and jobs, and the side Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011 27
  • 28. effects on global inflation, commodity prices and capital flows to emerging countries can’t be overlooked. China – growing faster than planned  GDP growth has surprised on the upside, but is expected to slow in quarters to come  Inflation will peak this year and drop to 3-4% in 2012-2013  The goal to “rebalance” the economy will take time and require more reforms Expectations that China’s GDP growth will more visibly slow did not come to fruition earlier this year when GDP rose in the first two quarters by 9.7% and 9.5% at an annual rate. Despite lower credit growth and higher inflation, the economy continued to grow at a rapid pace. The wheels of the Chinese economy have since begun to slow The wheels of the slightly. This was caused by the rise in interest rates in order to Chinese economy are check inflation and is also evident in the purchasing managers now rolling more index, which indicates slower economic activity. Slower import slowly growth is also a sign of weaker domestic activity. A slight slowdown is already evident on an adjusted quarterly basis, but as usual there is reason to be cautious in interpreting these sometimes dubious data. However, we are revising GDP growth upward by 25 bp to 9.0% this year on the basis of stronger results. GDP growth will then fall to 8.4% in 2012 and 8.0% in 2013. This means that the goal in China’s latest five-year plan of average GDP growth of 7% per year in 2011-2016 in all likelihood will not be reached. Growth in GDP, industrial production and auto sales 2 0 ,0 90 < - - In d u s tr ia l p r o d u c tio n C a r s a le s - - > 80 1 7 ,5 70 1 5 ,0 60 < - - G D P - g r o w th 1 2 ,5 50 Percent Percent 1 0 ,0 40 30 7 ,5 20 5 ,0 10 2 ,5 0 0 ,0 -1 0 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 S o u r c e : R e u te r s E c o W in 28 Swedbank’s Global Economic Outlook • 17 August 2011