1) The document assesses country opportunity and feasibility for implementing an integrated prevention campaign (IPC) targeting HIV, malaria, and diarrhea.
2) An "Opportunity Index" (OI) was developed to summarize disease burden data from different sources and identify countries where IPC implementation potential is highest.
3) The OI considers factors like total disease burden, mortality rates, intervention coverage levels, and identifies the top 10 countries by total DALY burden as those with the greatest opportunity for impact through an IPC.
1. PANEL 2:
Selection of Priority
Geographic Areas
Judd L Walson, MD, MPH
University of Washington
Depts of Global Health, Internal Medicine (Infectious
Disease), Pediatrics and Epidemiology
Integrated Prevention Campaigns: Evidence for Impact and 07/25/2012
Efficiency, Global Potential, and Sustainability
3. Opportunity Index (OI)
Designed to:
Summarize large amount of data from
disparate sources
Summarize burden of diseases that may be
impacted by the IPC
Reflect existing relevant interventions that
may affect diarrhea, malaria, or HIV burden
Facilitate identification of countries where
opportunity for IPC implementation is
greatest
3
5. OI: Top 10 DALY Burden
Countries
Top 10 countries based on total DALY burden
(diarrhea, malaria, HIV):
Diarrhea Malaria HIV
Improved Pregnant
Total DALY DALYs per Diarrhea Annual Malaria burden Annual Annual
Country DALYs drinking water DALYs ITN coverage HIV burden DALYs women tested,
burden capita burden deaths (WHO) deaths deaths
coverage coverage
Nigeria 18,229,334 0.1151 18.7 201,368 6,151,810 58 2.7 217,357 6,640,275 49 3.6 220,000 5,437,250 14
India 11,648,828 0.0095 13.0 237,482 7,255,095 92 0.1 6,292 192,221 1 0.3 170,000 4,201,511 23
South Africa 7,855,389 0.1571 8.7 6,293 192,252 91 0.2 51 1,558 100* 17.8 310,000 7,661,579 >95
DRC 6,014,548 0.0912 18.5 102,679 3,136,852 45 35.5 94,196 2,877,696 69 Unknown Unknown Unknown 11
Uganda 3,810,069 0.1140 16.0 30,391 928,448 72 25.1 42,549 1,299,876 57 6.5 64,000 1,581,745 63
Kenya 3,793,934 0.0936 20.5 38,802 1,185,404 59 64.0 20,666 631,348 37 6.3 80,000 1,977,182 83
Tanzania 3,621,080 0.0808 11.6 20,211 617,448 53 35.3 28,745 878,162 100* 5.6 86,000 2,125,470 86
Ethiopia 2,906,138 0.0350 22.8 73,341 2,240,574 44 1.9 21,786 665,564 62 Unknown Unknown Unknown 26
Afghanistan 2,742,023 0.0797 28.9 89,709 2,740,618 50 0.1 46 1,405 13 Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown
Mozambique 2,650,507 0.1133 11.9 13,105 400,359 47 14.3 13,789 421,255 38 11.5 74,000 1,828,893 87
*PEPFAR countries
5
6. OI – A Closer Look
Diarrhea Malaria HIV
Improved Childhood Pregnant
Under-5 Overall Malaria ART
Total DALY DALYs per Life Diarrhea Annual drinking malaria Annual Total PAR ITN HIV Annual women
Country Population mortality mortality DALYs burden DALYs DALYs coverage
burden capita expectancy burden deaths water burden deaths (WHO) coverage burden deaths tested,
rate rate (WHO) (CD4<350)
coverage (IHME) coverage
Diarrhea
Improved
Under-5 Overall
Total DALY DALYs per Life Diarrhea Annual drinking
Country Population mortality mortality DALYs
burden capita expectancy burden deaths water
rate rate
coverage
Malaria HIV
Childhood Pregnant
Malaria ART
malaria Annual Total PAR ITN HIV Annual women
burden DALYs DALYs coverage
burden deaths (WHO) coverage burden deaths tested,
(WHO) (CD4<350)
(IHME) coverage
6
10. Feasibility Index
Identify key characteristics of successful
programs
Feasibility Indicator Source
Economic Risk Rating Euler Hermes Economic Country Risk
Rating
Violent conflict State Department country profile pages
Corruption Transparency International
Govt. investment in health Government health expenditure as % of
total government expenditure (WHO
data)
Grouped into high, medium and low feasibility
10
11. Feasibility Index
Economic Health
Country Violent conflict Corruption
Stability Expenditure
YES: Ongoing civil/rebel conflict in
Nigeria D 2.4 6.4
Niger River Delta
YES: Minor regional ongoing
India B civil/rebel conflict in northeast India 3.1 4.1
and on western border
South Africa BB YES: 4.1 9.3
DRC D YES: Ongoing civil/rebel conflict 2.0 1.7
YES: Minor ongoing rebel conflict in
Uganda C 2.4 11.6
the north
Kenya D YES: 2.2 5.4
Tanzania C NO 3.0 18.1
YES: Minor conflict on border with
Ethiopia D 2.7 11.4
Somalia
Afghanistan D YES: Ongoing civil/rebel conflict 1.5 3.7
Mozambique C NO 2.7 14.2
11
12. Country Profile
12
Expands on and provides context for
information in the Opportunity and Feasibility
Indices
Provides subnational information where
possible
Provides detailed information for planning
and implementation of campaigns, including
country specific cost data
13. Acknowledgments
• Aliya Jiwani • James G. Kahn
• Elliot Marseille • Alastair Matheson
• Stephane Verguet
Opportunity Index – Lisa Manhart, Gillian
Levine, Patricia Pavlinac, Adam
Akullian, Arianna Rubin
Notas del editor
Integrated Prevention Campaigns: Evidence for Impact and Efficiency, Global Potential, and SustainabilitySelection of priority geographic settingsIPC global applicability: potential coverage, health impacts, costs
Population: Total country population, 2010 data. Source: World Bank - http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTLTotal DALY burden: Total annual DALYs for diarrhea, malaria and HIV/AIDS. Source: calculated as sum of DALYs across the 3 diseases.DALYs per capita: DALYs per person, calculated as total DALY burden divided by population. Under-5 mortality rate: Deaths in children <5 yrs per 1,000 live births, in 2011. Source: IHME http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/ghdx/record/child-mortality-estimates-and-mdg-4-attainment-country-1990-2011Overall mortality (adult + child): Crude death rate, per 1,000 people (number of deaths per year, in 2010, estimated at midyear. Source: The World Bank. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CDRT.IN/countriesLife expectancy: Average LE for males and females at birth. Source: The World Bank. Life expectancy at birth, total (years): http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN.Diarrhea burden: proportion of childhood(<5) deaths due to diarrhea. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.Annual deaths: Total number of deaths from diarrheal disease in children <5 yrs. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.DALYs: Total DALYs from diarrheal disease in children < 5 yrs. Source: derivation.Improved drinking water coverage: % of population using an improved drinking water source, 2010 data. Source: Global Health Observatory Data Repository - Water, sanitation and hygiene, Exposure: http://apps.who.int/ghodata/?vid=360#Malaria burden (WHO): Malaria deaths per 100,000 people (all ages) per year. Source: WHOMalaria burden (IHME): Malaria deaths per 100,000 people (0–4 years) per year. Source: IHMEAnnual deaths: Total number of deaths from malaria in children <5 yrs. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.DALYs: Total DALYs from malaria in children < 5 yrs. Source: derivation.Total PAR (WHO): Percent of the population at risk for malaria (all types) in 2010. Value = total from high- and low-transmission areas. Source: WHO World Malaria Report 2011.Malaria endemicity: % of the population in malaria endemic areasITN coverage: % of households owning at least 1 insecticide-treated net. Countries with greater than 100% reported have been corrected to 100, and are designated with an asterisk. Source: World Malaria Report 2011, Annex 4. 2010 data. http://www.who.int/malaria/world_malaria_report_2011/en/HIV burden: Prevalence in 15-49 year olds. Source: AIDSInfo database, via Gapminder.orgAnnual deaths: Total number of deaths from HIV/AIDS (children+adults). Source: UNAIDS AIDSInfo database.DALYs: Total DALYs from HIV/AIDS. Source: derivation.Pregnant women tested, coverage: % of pregnant women tested for HIV based on facility registers for ANC, L&D and postpartum care. Denominator = # pregnant women giving birth in the last 12 months. Source: Global Health Observatory Data RepositoryART coverage (CD4<350): Source: Gapminder.org
Population: Total country population, 2010 data. Source: World Bank - http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTLTotal DALY burden: Total annual DALYs for diarrhea, malaria and HIV/AIDS. Source: calculated as sum of DALYs across the 3 diseases.DALYs per capita: DALYs per person, calculated as total DALY burden divided by population. Under-5 mortality rate: Deaths in children <5 yrs per 1,000 live births, in 2011. Source: IHME http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/ghdx/record/child-mortality-estimates-and-mdg-4-attainment-country-1990-2011Overall mortality (adult + child): Crude death rate, per 1,000 people (number of deaths per year, in 2010, estimated at midyear. Source: The World Bank. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CDRT.IN/countriesLife expectancy: Average LE for males and females at birth. Source: The World Bank. Life expectancy at birth, total (years): http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN.Diarrhea burden: proportion of childhood(<5) deaths due to diarrhea. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.Annual deaths: Total number of deaths from diarrheal disease in children <5 yrs. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.DALYs: Total DALYs from diarrheal disease in children < 5 yrs. Source: derivation.Improved drinking water coverage: % of population using an improved drinking water source, 2010 data. Source: Global Health Observatory Data Repository - Water, sanitation and hygiene, Exposure: http://apps.who.int/ghodata/?vid=360#Malaria burden (WHO): Malaria deaths per 100,000 people (all ages) per year. Source: WHOMalaria burden (IHME): Malaria deaths per 100,000 people (0–4 years) per year. Source: IHMEAnnual deaths: Total number of deaths from malaria in children <5 yrs. Source: Black et al, Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2008: a systematic analysis. Lancet 2010.DALYs: Total DALYs from malaria in children < 5 yrs. Source: derivation.Total PAR (WHO): Percent of the population at risk for malaria (all types) in 2010. Value = total from high- and low-transmission areas. Source: WHO World Malaria Report 2011.Malaria endemicity: % of the population in malaria endemic areasITN coverage: % of households owning at least 1 insecticide-treated net. Countries with greater than 100% reported have been corrected to 100, and are designated with an asterisk. Source: World Malaria Report 2011, Annex 4. 2010 data. http://www.who.int/malaria/world_malaria_report_2011/en/HIV burden: Prevalence in 15-49 year olds. Source: AIDSInfo database, via Gapminder.orgAnnual deaths: Total number of deaths from HIV/AIDS (children+adults). Source: UNAIDS AIDSInfo database.DALYs: Total DALYs from HIV/AIDS. Source: derivation.Pregnant women tested, coverage: % of pregnant women tested for HIV based on facility registers for ANC, L&D and postpartum care. Denominator = # pregnant women giving birth in the last 12 months. Source: Global Health Observatory Data RepositoryART coverage (CD4<350): Source: Gapminder.org
Number of existing MDA platforms: Number of LF, STH, SCH, and IPTp (malaria) MDA programs in place
Economic Stability: Euler Holmes Rating (AA-D)Violent conflict: In State of Conflict (yes or no) – State DepartmentCorruption: Corruption Rating (From 0 very corrupt to 10, very clean)Health Expenditure: Government expenditure on health as a percentage of total government expenditure 2010 (%)Physician Density: per 1,000 peopleNumber of existing MDA platforms: Number of LF, STH, SCH, and IPTp (malaria) MDA programs in place