SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 78
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Why KAM May Fail?
   Key Accounts Management in
     Pharmaceutical Industry
     February 14 & 15, 2013
      Hotel Avion, Mumbai

               Dr Ulhas Ganu
Advisors in Medico-Marketing & Management (AIMM)
                     Mumbai
               drukganu@gmail.com


                                                   1
                 KAM-Pharma 2012
Why KAM May Fail?

          • Can It Really Fail?
       • How Can We Make it Work?
• Can it be Applied by Every Organization?
• Aren’t Organizational Objectives & Goals
     a Determinant to its Application?

                                       2
http://assignmenthelpexperts.blogspot.in/2011/09/business-its-environment-and-objectives.html


                                                                       Core Attributes

                                                                      Intrinsic Attributes


                                                                                               R&D
                                                *                                              Base
                                                                           *
                                       Objectives                           
                  *                         of                             *
Customer                                 Business
Retention

                    *                          *                           *
                                                                                                   3
Information is the Key
      The Story of A Villager at Railway Station

    Inquiring About Trains at the Inquiry Counter
   The Apologetic Person at the Counter Told him:
      • No Train towards Mumbai for 2 hours
       • No Train Towards Nashik for 3 hours
Sarcastically adding……….
 • Not Even a Goods Train Movement in Day Time
• The Villager Thanked him for the information……
                                                    4
Information is the Key
          Turning to his Wife he Said……
Come Dear, it is Safe now to Cross the Railway Track!

       Safer than the Safest Possible Option
               Height of Precaution!
   Not So Much Overcautious, I Still Wondered….
  • Shouldn’t We Be Careful About KAM in India?
 • Should We At Least Check Coordinates Properly
    Before Accepting it Fully & Wholeheartedly….


                                                  5
Skeptic: Why KAM?
       Change is a Need Based Action

The Only Person Who Always Likes a Change is
                a Wet Baby

        Which it Can’t Do by Itself!
                     &
    Must Invite & Involve Others for Help


                                            6
Skeptic: Why KAM?
 What is Wrong with ‘The Age Old’
   ‘Traditional’ “4 P” Model?
     Hasn’t it Been Modified &
Used Highly Successfully for Decades?




                                        7
Skeptic: Why KAM?
    What is Wrong with ‘The Age Old’
      ‘Traditional’ “4 P” Model?
       Hasn’t it Been Modified &
  Used Highly Successfully for Decades?

Is KAM a Gimmick Used by the Consultants
           to Stay in Business ?
   Let Us See How Marketing Evolved
       Over the Last Few Decades……

                                           8
Age Old Successful Traditional 4 P Model

      Primary          Product            Attaining
Attributes Focused     Quality         The Desired Goal


                                  Person
                 Finance             &
                          Sr.      Place
                      Management
            Product                   Product
             Value         HR        Promotion


                                                    9
The 4 Ps & 4Cs                                  The Standard P:C Theme
(Caiibgbm marketing mgt module d)
                                    Marketing         Convenience
                                      Mix

                                                         Place
      Product


   Customer
    Solution
                            Price         Promotion


                                          Communication
                        Customer
                          Cost


                                                                  10
The Total Matrix                                 Evolved Model
                    • Medico-marketing
                                                            Product
                                Q                        Positioning
                http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=Revolving+s
     • Medical
             ubtractive+colour+wheel+illusion&start=138&hl
                                                      • Marketing
              =en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=WP
              UF7YU6UH6JXM:&imgrefurl=http://docs.gimp.o Place
              rg/en/glossary.html&docid=aJWbz-
                    • Finance           Attributes
              CoZ5h1aM&imgurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/im
              ages/glossary/color-model-
                                  Senior
              additive.png&w=300&h=285&ei=xh5rULLqFMH
              KrAfb7YGgDw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=724&vpy
                             Management
              =338&dur=346&hovh=219&hovw=230&tx=124
              &ty=95&sig=107126594954691788435&page=6
       •  Technical               Human
                                               • Quality
              &tbnh=177&tbnw=186&ndsp=24&ved=1t:429,r:
       •  Production
              15,s:138,i:222     Resource        Assurance
                             Development
       • R&D

                                                                    11
Communication      • Medico-marketing                    Limited Aspect

                                Q                        Communication
                                                            Product
                          Sale Only as                    Positioning
              http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=Revolving+sub
  • Medical tractive+colour+wheel+illusion&start=138&hl=en
                          the Focus                   • Marketing
            &biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=WPUF7YU
            6UH6JXM:&imgrefurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/glo
                    • Finance
            ssary.html&docid=aJWbz-
            CoZ5h1aM&imgurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/imag
            es/glossary/color-model-      Attributes
                                Senior
            additive.png&w=300&h=285&ei=xh5rULLqFMHKr
            Afb7YGgDw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=724&vpy=338
                             Management
            &dur=346&hovh=219&hovw=230&tx=124&ty=95
            &sig=107126594954691788435&page=6&tbnh=17
     •  Technical          Human Resource
            7&tbnw=186&ndsp=24&ved=1t:429,r:15,s:138,i:2 Assurance
                                             • Quality
                             Development
     •  Production
            22

     • R&D
 Limited Outside           Interaction          Limited Outside
   Interaction               Within               Interaction 12
Why Traditional Model Alone
          May Not Work Now….
It Largely Worked Earlier Because ……….
1. Not All Companies Followed it……

2. Not All Those Who Followed the ‘Quality
   Principles’ ‘Communicated’ it to the Customers

3. Those Doing Both Activities were Successful


                                                 13
The Changing Equations
1. The Model Was Consistently Modified Over Years

2. An Orientation to Working on Key Opinion Leaders
   & the Key Account Customers Evolved

3. CRM : the Customer Relationship Management
   became the Key word
4. Tender Business Extracts its Own Price

5. Retailers May Not be Friendly Customers but
   turned Hostile Adversaries

                                                 14
The Current Situation
•   High Competition, too Many Branded Generics!
•   Limitations of KOL to help with Direct Business
•   Fear of Losing KAC due to Extrinsic Factors*
•   Resultant Loss of Business

                       Need:
• The Communication Should Focus on Benefits
  that May Accrue to the Customer & Company
• Beginning of KAM Idea

                                                  15
KAM: Key Accounts Management
             Key (What is the Key)
          Accounts (What are they?)
   Managing (Who Would Manage# & Whom*)
             The Confusions Galore
               KOL / KAM / KAC
                     Are They
    Interchangeable / Similar/ Very Different
#: Shouldn’t the Personnel be Trained & Nurtured?
          Are they Nurtured as Required

                                                16
KOL: Key Opinion Leaders: Role
1. Leading Physicians & Scientists, Respected &
   Acknowledged as Leaders in a Subject Area
2. Influence Thinking & Treatment Paradigms
3. Provide Insight into Diseases & Rx Regimen
4. Provide Assessment of Competitive Therapies
The data is growing. Why aren't Insights? http://www.wipro.com/services/business-application-
services/key-opinion-leader.aspx

      Drug Discovery : Help Write the Protocol & Define
                  Efficacies of the Drug During the Study
                                    Medical Affairs
* Help Medical Affairs on Drug Usage & Defining Side Effects
Key Opinion Leaders Serve the Following Purpose
 The data is growing. Why aren't Insights? http://www.wipro.com/services/business-application-services/key-opinion-
                                                     leader.aspx



• Act as Leading Indicator of Therapy Acceptance
  (Protocols)
• Help in Diffusion of Information & can Increase
  Velocity of Product Adoption (e.g. Imatinib) or
• Even Relegation as well (e.g. Hydroxyurea/ Thiotepa/
     Total Parenteral Nutrition): Pays to know the trends early

• Physicians & Institutions Increasingly Rely on KOL
  Guidance for Prescribing New Drugs

                                                                                                             18
Key Targets
                       KOLs
1. May Help Expand the Market for a Product
   through Establishing New Protocol
2. May Help Sales Indirectly
3. Important to be Associated With….. Although
   they May Not Prescribe Your Products in Large
   Volumes. Meet if Possible, Follow Trend
      Aren’t KOL’s Key Customers? Partners?

                                               19
Key Targets
1. KACs: Prescribers & Directly Generate Revenue
   Important as Attached to Several Hospitals
2. Products Availability in Hospital Pharmacies a Must
   as Hospital Management Insist Purchase of Products
   from their Pharmacy Only
3. KAC’s Must be Met Very Regularly & Since Institute’s
   Price is Lower, Should be Audited for Sales Returns
4. Profitability Profiling Necessary……….
5. Determine GP Coverage? Or Consultant Coverage
   Only?

                                                   20
The Key Accounts Concept
1. Aren’t We Aware of It?
2. Product Availability in Pharmacies of Institutions
   Such as:
  * AIIMS / * Apollo Hospital Chain
  * Tata Memorial Hospital/ * Gujarat Civil Hospital
  * TNMSC/
* Many Other Government & Private Bodies
• Considered as Valued Clients & Help Position
  Products Elsewhere


                                                  21
Let Us Look At
The Different K’s Collectively
         vis-à-vis
Key Account - Management
              &
 The Corporate Objectives


                                 22
KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management
   The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are

    A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities
 Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar

              Varying in the Output

      Requiring Optimization of the Matrix


To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization

                                                23
KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management
   The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are

     A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities
 Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar
             Varying in the Output

      Requiring Optimization of the Matrix

To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization


                                                  24
KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management
   The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are

     A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities
 Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar
       Varying in the Degrees of Outcome

      Requiring Optimization of the Matrix

To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization


                                                  25
KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management
   The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are

     A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities
 Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar
       Varying in the Degrees of Outcome
       Helping Optimization of the Matrix

To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization


                                                  26
KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management
  The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are

   A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities
Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar
     Varying in the Degrees of Outcome
     Helping Optimization of the Matrix
  To Achieve the Primary Objectives of the
               Organization

                                                27
Good Product                                        ?

   ?                                                  Gifts   !        CMEs
                                                    Conferences    !
                                                      !
                                         Personal Tours
Company Needs
                         Literatures *                        Scientific
                                                              Updates
                   ?
           Detailing
   Free Samples*                               LBL/Visual Aid
                           Monograph



                                                                               28
Good Product                                     CRM
 Convenient
Appointment
                                                                    Customer
                                                                      Solution
     as
  Medical
 Advisor or
 Consultant                                           Gifts   !         CMEs
                                                    Conferences     !
                                                      !
                                         Personal Tours
                         Literatures *                         Scientific
                                                               Updates
                   ?
           Detailing
   Free Samples*                              LBL/Visual Aid
                          Monograph



                                                                               29
Interesting Current Model Vs Futuristic Model
             Influencing the Sale

                     &

       How it May Shape Up in India




                                                30
Today                       Future




 Can You Ignore Patient?



Ref: Developing Customer Process Orientation Alt_Puschmann BPMJ 2005
          Business Process Management J. 11 (2005)4: 297-315         31
Can You Ignore Patient Communication?
         Although Patient is the End User
   Traditionally, Doctor is the Client for Pharma
    Obviously, Instead of Ignoring the Patient,
    One May Have to Find Ways to Engage him
                  Albeit Ethically
        Costing May Have to be Controlled
Communicating Economically & Yet Effectively With
     the Patient Would Require Creativity

                                                    32
KAC vis-à-vis KAM Catch & Trap
    Extra Costs May Make the Model Weaker……
•   Hospital Bargains Hard For Price:
•   Innovator, L1 & L2 Approved is the Norm
•   At Least Three Competing Products in Pharmacy
•   Hospital as a ‘Key Account’ Has a Lot of Limitation
    vis-à-vis Company
•   Doctors Must be Won Over For Prescription or the
    Products Do Not Move in Pharmacy
•   Why Do Indian Companies Have to Compete as L1 &
    L2 When Quality could be As Good As MNC?

                                                      33
programmes/short-courses/designing-your-key-account-management-
                                                                                                             KAM
http://www.gibs.co.za/programmes/corporate-education-executive-

                                                                           Deliver         Provide
                                                                          Consistent       Ongoing          Concept
                                                                           Quality       Cooperation
                                                                    Deliver
                                                                   Consistent                      Communicate
                                                                  Performance     Trust Based        With Me
                                                                                   Customer
                                                                   Deliver        Relationship     Be Competitive
                                                                  Meaningful                       Not Necessarily
                                                                    Value                           the Cheapest
                                                                                  Demonstrate
                                                                                  Flexibility &
plan.aspx




                                                                                   Innovation

                                                                  Intrinsic Attributes            Extrinsic Attributes
                                                                                                                     34
The White
         Deliver       Provide
        Consistent
                                    Flag Means
                       Ongoing
         Quality     Cooperation     Surrender

  Deliver
                              Communicate
 Consistent
               Surrender        With Me
Performance
              Compulsions
  Deliver          or         Be Competitive
 Meaningful   Compromise      Not Necessarily
   Value                       the Cheapest
              Demonstrate
Intrinsic     Flexibility &        Extrinsic
Attributes     Innovation          Attributes
                                                35
Red Flag:
             Deliver       Provide       The White
 Drop in
            Consistent     Ongoing       Flag Means
Marketing
             Quality     Cooperation      Surrender
 Concept
     Deliver
                                  Communicate
    Consistent
                   Surrender        With Me
   Performance
                  Compulsions
     Deliver           or         Be Competitive
    Meaningful    Compromise      Not Necessarily
      Value                        the Cheapest
                  Demonstrate
Intrinsic         Flexibility &        Extrinsic
Attributes         Innovation          Attributes
                                                    36
Primary Attributes                           Primary Focus
                           Product
      Primary              Quality             Attaining
Attributes Focused                          The Desired Goal


                     KAM              KAC
                             Goal

            Product         Trade       Product
             Value           Sale      Positioning
                           Approach

                                                         37
Secondary Attributes              Primary Focus
 Marketing Focus        Trade Sale
      Lost              Approach
                          Price
  When
Quality &          Brand
                         Positioning
 Trust is
Breached
   KAM
                   Value
                             CRM
                           Goal
               KAC               Wrong
                          Interpretation
Would Fail
to Deliver    wrongly
 Desired     Interpreted Quality       as
 Results
                                   Transaction
                                      Model 38
Analyzing the Prescription Definition
A Prescription is an Order/Advice by the Doctor:
• To the Patient to Purchase the Drug & to Consume
   it in a Particular Manner
• To the Retailer to Sale the Drug to the Patient
• To the Company to Make it Available at the Counter

• There are A Lot Many Connected Activities &
  Since Substitution of Drug is Prohibited,
  Generation of Prescription Amounts to the Sale


                                                 39
Analyzing the Prescription Definition
• FF is the Signatory
• Authors Could be At the HO or in Field
• It is a Multi-numbered Lock
                      Field Force:
       Does Create, Enable & Sustain Prescription
•   Unfortunately Only the Sales & Not the Marketing
    Invariably Considered- Wrongly- as the Only Key
Their Customers Considered the only Key Customers!

                                                    40
Reaching & Staying at the Top
• Conceptualization
• Backward Integration With Quality Personnel is
  Equally Important,

• Backward Integration Ignored Consistently
• Quality First / Client as a Consequence

   • Without Innovation & Consistent Quality,
 Building Client Rapport & Long Term Relationship
              With Clients isn’t Possible,

                                               41
CRM in the
         Hands of Sales Personnel is Like
Schoolboy Concept of Essay on Rural India vis-à-vis
                   Football




                                                42
5 P Match                Package
                                                                to
               Product                           Product     Patient

 Positioning             Price to                            Positioning
                         Hospital

  Organization           Price           Price       Hospital

    Place                                                  Patient
            Personnel                            Personnel

Deliver Consistent Quality,         Deliver Consistent Performance,
Deliver Meaningful Value,           Provide Ongoing Cooperation,
Communicate With Me,                         Be Competitive
Demonstrate Flexibility & Innovation Not Necessarily the Cheapest
                                                               43
Skeptic: Why KAM?
       Change is a Need Based Action

The Only Person Who Always Likes a Change is
                a Wet Baby

         Which it Can’t Do by Itself
                     &
    Must Invite & Involve Others for Help


                                            44
Why KAM: International Genesis
                              Need Based
1. Pharma Encountered Economic Recession, earlier in
   (2005 & 2006).
2. “Sales Forces Bloated Earlier”
3. Pharma Sales Reps Started Losing Jobs in Thousands…..
4. “Hence No Other Way but to turn to technology.”
5. CRM software may be more critical than ever to the
   pharma Industry (Hagemeyer, Gartner Research Managing VP).
   (Ref. Market Focus: Pharmaceuticals -- CRM Undergoes an Experimental New
   Treatment, An older CRM vertical gets a new dose of on-demand technology)
                        By Lauren McKay
                                                                          45
KAM under the spotlight: by David Round
         The British Experience With KAM
       http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight


                                 Claims
* Hence Now Using More Sophisticated Approach to
   Sales & Marketing Activity
* Delivering More Efficient & Effective Commercial
   Model Using a Targeted KAM Methodology


                                                                               46
KAM under the spotlight: by David Round
          The British Experience With KAM
        http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight
• Dec 09 & Dec 10 –Working According to KAM ?
•   92.7% of UK GPs had a Face-to-Face Call or Meeting
    With a Medical Rep from Pharma
• This indicates, the industry was still carrying out
  almost blanket coverage of GPs.
•   The 2010 Merely Continued a Similar Trend from the
    years that preceded it –
•   Past Decade Annual Industry Coverage Consistently
    Reached Over 90% of the Total Prescriber Population.

                                                                                47
KAM under the spotlight: by David Round
            The British Experience With KAM continued
        http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight

•   July ’10 to June ’11, GPs Face-to-Face Call/Meeting
    with an Industry Representative dropped to 85
•   In the First 6 Months of 2011 the Total No. of GPs
    Who Have Had A Similar Contact Slumped to 73%.
•   Now Face-to-face calls/ rep/day falling year-on-year.
•   No. of meetings (per rep/day) has gradually risen
•   The Synmetrics data: more meetings taking place
    today than at any point in the past 10 years; and
•   Crucially in 2010 the No. of Meetings/Day Overtook
    the No. of face-to-face calls for the First Time.

                                                                                48
Current Trend: A Positive Shift Towards KAM
                Thrust Relatively New
•   Data shows: 17,000 GPs – (around 35%) didn’t receive a
    Face-to-Face call in the Last 12 Months of ‘10 – 11’
•   There’s a Concomitant Increase in the No. of meetings

•   A significant drop in face-to-face call activity,
•   Over 1/3rd of Pharma’s Traditional Customer
    Population Not Receiving a Single Call
•   It’s still too early to make definitive claims that the
    KAM model is firmly embedded in UK Pharma.
• KAM Picking Up or Call reduction by Compulsion?

                                                         49
Team Management: International Vs Indian Scene
•    Account Managers are Encouraged to Develop Their Own
     Call Plans
•     Become More Accountable for Their Own Business
•    Need Robust & Effective Data to Make Informed
     Targeting Decisions in the Process is Paramount
•    Strong Feedback System Desirable &
•    Sharing of the Collected Data Utmost Important
•    Liaison: Sales Team, PMT & KA Manager: Key to Success
•    Is Field Force Reduction a Compulsion in India?
•    If Not…. How Effectively to Use Them For Arranging
     Meetings For KA Manager & KOL/KAC…..

                                                       50
KAM Perspective
Lack of Understanding About KA Manager Job Function
          Understanding Attributes Required
                Developing Personnel
                 Internal Integration

                 Their Hospital Work
             Meaningful Communication
    Avoids Repeat Calls by different Sales Personnel
            to same Customer / Purchaser
All Round Knowledge & Focus on Company Perspective
             Helps Snatch Profitable Deal
Sales Personnel With Limited Strategic Understanding
          May Not be the Answer for KAM
     Key Account Managers Need More Freedom        51
How Do Consumers Choose….
            Among Products & Services?
 •   Performance > Expectations => Satisfaction
 # Performance < Expectations => Dissatisfaction
 Company Needs an “Uncompromising Attitude”
     Towards Maintaining “Product Quality”
           Integrated Communication
Keeping in Mind Company Perspectives Important
         Only A Senior & Mature Person
             Can Handle it Properly

                                                  52
http://www.whiteladderconsulting.com/cor
porate_training.html




                A Simple Sales Person Cannot Understand the Intricacies

      Key Account Management is a Specialized Function

                                                                     53
“MR or FLM” Conducted Activities Versus
                                             Key Accounts Manager Managed Activities
http://sites.cdnis.edu.hk/students/001771/




                                                                                         *
                 objectives/




                                                                                         *
                                                                                         *
                                                                                         54
Blake & Mouton
         9
                    1/9                    9/9




                                                              al_grid_model
                                                              http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manageri
              The customers            The problem
                  friend                  solver
                                 5/5
Concern for                   Compromise
 customer                      “Method”
                               approach
                     1/1                       9/1
                  The order                The pressure
                    taker                   salesman
         1
              1      Concern for making the sale          9


                                                               55
CAP: (Ward - Strategic Management Accounting)
  the “Customer Account Profitability” is
“The Total Sales Revenue Generated from
     a Customer or Customer Group....
                   Less
     All the Costs that are Incurred
               In Servicing
  that Customer or Customer Group.”

                                             56
CAP: (Ward - Strategic Management Accounting)
   the “Customer Account Profitability” is
“The Total Sales Revenue Generated from
     a Customer or Customer Group....
                   Less Where Would You Put KOL?
     All the Costs that are Incurred
               In Servicing
  that Customer or Customer Group.”

                                              57
11_01_archive.html
                                                                                                                                        http://mnama.blogspot.in/2010_
                           10%

                             30%                                                                  50-60%



                            60 %                                                                  30 – 35%
http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&start=191&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=mvjFuU
PExojbDM:&imgrefurl=http://mnama.blogspot.com/2010_11_01_archive.html&docid=WVzyJCpwO_i78M&imgurl=http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4YZAh7cfTLk/TO1mSjYZ
9bI/AAAAAAAAACo/Lfzs_LuAEqs/s1600/Untitled.png&w=493&h=284&ei=SPaAUISYOcSsrAesvoD4Dg&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=797&vpy=135&dur=12821&hovh=17

                                                                                                   10 to 15%
0&hovw=296&tx=160&ty=103&sig=107126594954691788435&page=7&tbnh=143&tbnw=249&ndsp=32&ved=1t:429,r:94,s:100,i:286




        Identify Your Important Customers
 Pareto’s 80:20 or 10:30:60 aren’t Absolute Ratios                                                                                              58
The List is More Likely to be Dynamic than Static



                            10%

                              30%
                                                                                                   50-60%

                                                                                                   30 – 35%
                             60 %
 http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&start=191&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=mvjFuU
 PExojbDM:&imgrefurl=http://mnama.blogspot.com/2010_11_01_archive.html&docid=WVzyJCpwO_i78M&imgurl=http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4YZAh7cfTLk/TO1mSjYZ
 9bI/AAAAAAAAACo/Lfzs_LuAEqs/s1600/Untitled.png&w=493&h=284&ei=SPaAUISYOcSsrAesvoD4Dg&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=797&vpy=135&dur=12821&hovh=17

                                                                                                    10 to 15%
 0&hovw=296&tx=160&ty=103&sig=107126594954691788435&page=7&tbnh=143&tbnw=249&ndsp=32&ved=1t:429,r:94,s:100,i:286




Pareto Principle Helps Identify Important Customers                                                                                        59
10%                                          30%

                     30%                                         60%



                    60 %                                         10%



                   Representative Chart Not Absolute Guide
                       % Marketing Spend Per Segment
Invert the Pyramid and Supercharge Your Profits, by Mark Price
                                                                       60
http://mnama.blogspot.in/2010_11_01_archive.html
Key




        http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=xqG
        0-
        PMeMDuwfM:&imgrefurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm%3Farticleid%3D1508902%26show%3Dhtml&docid=68GZFYf2T2C7QM&imgurl
        =http://www.emeraldinsight.com/content_images/fig/0200230404002.png&w=1363&h=838&ei=B_SAUKiPDdHQrQfB7IGQAQ&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=

                         Not Serving them is Not an Option
        399&vpy=160&dur=4497&hovh=176&hovw=286&tx=130&ty=109&sig=107126594954691788435&sqi=2&page=1&tbnh=137&tbnw=223&start=0&nds
        p=24&ved=1t:429,r:1,s:0,i:69


                        Find Economic Ways to Reach Them
http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=profit+revenue+pyramid+model&hl=en&tbo=d&biw=1525&bih=712&tbm=isch&tbnid=
xqG0-
PMeMDuwfM:&imgrefurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm%3Farticleid%3D1508902%26show%3Dhtml&doci
d=68GZFYf2T2C7QM&imgurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/content_images/fig/0200230404002.png&w=1363&h=838&ei=VbQKUbvtE8jKrAfD-61
YDwAg&zoom=1&ved=1t:3588,r:0,s:0,i:79&iact=rc&dur=2&sig=107126594954691788435&page=1&tbnh=176&tbnw=286&start=0&ndsp=17&tx=120&ty=100
Curry’s Pyramid: Classifying Customers
        Gold

        Silver

       Bronze


         White




http://www.expertprogrammanagement.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/currys-pyramid.png   62
Age Old Matrix for ‘Performance & Goal’ Audit

                      What do we
   Goal setting
                    want to achieve?
                          ⇓
  Performance            What is
  Measurement          happening?

                          ⇓
  Performance           Why is it
   Diagnosis           happening?
                          ⇓
Corrective Action    What should we
                      do about it?
                                            63
http://kmonadollaraday.wordpress.com/20
                                          64




10/11/
http://www.1000ventures.com/business_guide/crosscuttings/achievement_ability.html




                                                                                    65
With KAM in Place Why Not Special Consideration?
 Grade        1       2       3       4             5


Physician       With L1 & L2, There is Still Pressure to Work
            for Prescription With the Physician Independently
 Patient           In KAM, Why have L1, L2?
Hospital           Why not a Single Drug Choice
                   to the Prescribing Doctor?
                                  Or
                   Why not Commitment for a
Pharmacy
                   • Fixed Minimum Order &
                   • Non-returnable Supply?

                                                          66
http://www     Pharmaceuticals Distribution System in
.csas.ed.ac.   India, Center for International Health Policy
uk/__data/
assets/pdf_
file/0003/3
8829/Phar
maDistribut
ionIndia.pdf

Working
Paper July
2,3, 2007




                                                     67
Wholesaler
      A Potential Entry Point for Spurious Drugs?
Could Nurturing them For Clean Business be Important?

Encourage KAM & Hence the Direct Medical Supply
          to Institutions, Hospitals as a
  Good Channel to Prevent Spurious Drug Entry
       Can KAM be Positioned to Convince &
                 Influence Smaller
      Hospitals & Nursing Homes For Business

                                                 68
Key Account Manager
      Selection & Perpetuity is Important
            Hierarchy in the System
Cooperation from HO & Field Personnel Essential

      Training the Key Account Manager
Knowing Overall Aspects of Commerce & Quality

        Nurturing Key Account Manager
              Targets/Incentives

                                             69
How Many Key Accounts?
Visit the Business Triangle: Profit/Serviceable!
Corporate Hospitals or Government Business?
Layers or Gradations Possible Within Segment
Loss of a Single Account May Mean a Setback
    Cannot Possibly Ignore Trade Business
    to Protect From Sudden Account Loss?
Specialty Products? Liquidating Stocks Quickly?
     Product Centric? Company Centric?

                                               70
http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=key+account+
manager+skills&start=575&num=10&um=1&hl=e
n&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=rt0UC6P
GEXoJaM:&imgrefurl=http://freebookessay.com/c
                                                *
ontent/key-marketing-skills-
d4b330f31854e8963681d3819dc28ebc.html&doci
d=gubtck9feXtYsM&imgurl=http://www.iproceed.

                                                *
com/marketing/images/key-accounts-
metrics.jpg&w=345&h=289&ei=cA99UO3_FdGUiQ
fLxoDADg&zoom=1&iact=rc&dur=485&sig=10712
6594954691788435&page=16&tbnh=164&tbnw=
196&ndsp=31&ved=1t:429,r:98,s:500,i:298&tx=75
&ty=84


                                                *
                                                71
Newer Challenges: Paradigm Shift

Trend of Pharma Companies Setting Own Hospitals
               Why Would They Buy
      Crucial & Costly Products From Others

Hospital Chains Getting Own Products Manufactured
               Ophthalmic Lenses
                  Medicines
 Bound to Restrict the Space for Many Companies

                                              72
Challenges In Designing Business Strategy
1. Trade Business or Tender Business? Government
   Business or Corporate Hospitals?
2. Hospitals: Generally Injectables,
3. Trade: Oral Medications
4. Difficult to Evade Retailer Business, as…. Batch Scale
   Up/ Batch Economy Possible Only with Liquidation….
5. Quicker Liquidation: Fresh Batch on Shelf
6. Reaching Private Practitioners, Repeat Calls?
7. Ideal Blend of Call versus Business Needs to be
   Decided


                                                     73
Perspectives: Field Personnel Vs Organization
 The Mnemonic: SPICE Explains the Conflict
  • Salary on Time            • Sales/Revenue
   • Product/Price                 • Profit
     • Incentives               • Innovation
        • CRM                 • Competence &
(for Important Clients)     Commitment (from the
       consistently                Personnel)
      • Expenses          • Engagement With Key
    Reimbursement                Customers &
   on time Regularly              Institutions

                                                74
To Be or Not To Be?
1. KAM is Not a Transaction but a Win-Win Model,
2. Not Applicable to Every Organization
3. Choose Model Suitable for the Organization
4. The KA Manager Has to be a Senior Position
5. Select & Train The Key Accounts Managers
6. Nurture & Retain The Key Account Managers
7. Support from Sales & Marketing Absolute Must
8. Regular Auditing to Select / Deselect Accounts
   Desirable as Key Account = Profitability
9. KOLs May or May Not Be Key Accounts (Direct
   profitability) but Worth Following……

                                               75
Wonder, Who Can Possibly Handle the Job?
     Can Group Product Managers be Groomed?
          As they Help Define & Set Targets
      Know Products & Aware of Quality Profile
         Know Finances & Company Policies
Can Integrate & Reverse Integrate Seamlessly With
             Mfg./QA/ Finance/Sales
Why Not Have Jr. Product Managers at Metro Cities?
        Can Train Newly Inducted Personnel
            Work in Field in the Region
         Generate Feedbacks Useful for HO

                                                 76
Re-orientation of the Focus is the Key




Use Modern Techniques to:
 * Convert Data in to Useful Information
 * Audit Customers / Accounts
 *Select/Deselect According to Results Dispassionately



                                                  77
KAM Does Not Fail
      It is the Dilution
of Focus on Basic Attributes
               &
 Misfit With Business Type
             Which
     Derails the Process
       Thank You

                               78

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Concept Of Key Account Management
Concept Of Key Account ManagementConcept Of Key Account Management
Concept Of Key Account Management
Ravi Ayilavarapu
 
Key Account Management
Key Account ManagementKey Account Management
Key Account Management
Shahzad Khan
 
Chapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
Chapter 9 Creating Brand EquityChapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
Chapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
dona_sia
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Key account management vs Traditional sales - Quick comparison guide
Key account management vs Traditional sales - Quick comparison guide  Key account management vs Traditional sales - Quick comparison guide
Key account management vs Traditional sales - Quick comparison guide
 
Sales planning & training seminar workshop
Sales planning & training seminar workshopSales planning & training seminar workshop
Sales planning & training seminar workshop
 
Sales Enablement Maturity Model
Sales Enablement Maturity ModelSales Enablement Maturity Model
Sales Enablement Maturity Model
 
What is Key Account Management
What is Key Account ManagementWhat is Key Account Management
What is Key Account Management
 
Concept Of Key Account Management
Concept Of Key Account ManagementConcept Of Key Account Management
Concept Of Key Account Management
 
Sales Strategy PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Sales Strategy PowerPoint Presentation SlidesSales Strategy PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Sales Strategy PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 
The ultimate-blueprint-to-achieve-your-key-account-goals-in-2019-final
The ultimate-blueprint-to-achieve-your-key-account-goals-in-2019-finalThe ultimate-blueprint-to-achieve-your-key-account-goals-in-2019-final
The ultimate-blueprint-to-achieve-your-key-account-goals-in-2019-final
 
Sales force management
Sales force managementSales force management
Sales force management
 
desining a sales territory (Sales management)
desining a sales territory (Sales management) desining a sales territory (Sales management)
desining a sales territory (Sales management)
 
An overview about marketing, sales & distribution for fmcg sector
An overview about marketing, sales & distribution for fmcg sectorAn overview about marketing, sales & distribution for fmcg sector
An overview about marketing, sales & distribution for fmcg sector
 
Marketing assignment-Philip Kotler
Marketing  assignment-Philip KotlerMarketing  assignment-Philip Kotler
Marketing assignment-Philip Kotler
 
Key Account Management
Key Account ManagementKey Account Management
Key Account Management
 
Sell On Value
Sell On ValueSell On Value
Sell On Value
 
Marketing strategy
Marketing strategyMarketing strategy
Marketing strategy
 
Marketing Strategy Framework
Marketing Strategy FrameworkMarketing Strategy Framework
Marketing Strategy Framework
 
Chapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
Chapter 9 Creating Brand EquityChapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
Chapter 9 Creating Brand Equity
 
IBM Go to Market Strategy
IBM Go to Market StrategyIBM Go to Market Strategy
IBM Go to Market Strategy
 
Sales Enablement Framework
Sales Enablement FrameworkSales Enablement Framework
Sales Enablement Framework
 
5 Steps to Effective Key Accounts Management
5 Steps to Effective Key Accounts Management5 Steps to Effective Key Accounts Management
5 Steps to Effective Key Accounts Management
 
Joint business planning with channel partners
Joint business planning with channel partners Joint business planning with channel partners
Joint business planning with channel partners
 

Similar a Why kam fails 1302 pres show

Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start - productcamp...
Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start   - productcamp...Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start   - productcamp...
Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start - productcamp...
Pinkesh Shah
 
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's SuccessAIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
AIPMM Administration
 
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HSiLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
Harsh Vardhan Sharma
 
The Sweet Spot
The Sweet SpotThe Sweet Spot
The Sweet Spot
Dom Testa
 
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
Ola Odejayi
 

Similar a Why kam fails 1302 pres show (20)

Catalytic Advisors Capabilities V2
Catalytic Advisors Capabilities V2Catalytic Advisors Capabilities V2
Catalytic Advisors Capabilities V2
 
G K Lim\'s &quot;Selling Successfully to Corporate and Major Accounts,&quot; ...
G K Lim\'s &quot;Selling Successfully to Corporate and Major Accounts,&quot; ...G K Lim\'s &quot;Selling Successfully to Corporate and Major Accounts,&quot; ...
G K Lim\'s &quot;Selling Successfully to Corporate and Major Accounts,&quot; ...
 
Adaptive Product Management Professional AdaptivePMP India - Brochure
Adaptive Product Management Professional AdaptivePMP India - BrochureAdaptive Product Management Professional AdaptivePMP India - Brochure
Adaptive Product Management Professional AdaptivePMP India - Brochure
 
Adaptive Advanced Product Mgmt & Marketing Workshop
Adaptive Advanced Product Mgmt & Marketing WorkshopAdaptive Advanced Product Mgmt & Marketing Workshop
Adaptive Advanced Product Mgmt & Marketing Workshop
 
Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start - productcamp...
Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start   - productcamp...Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start   - productcamp...
Want to become a product manager but dont know where to start - productcamp...
 
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's SuccessAIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role Of Product Management To Your Company's Success
 
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role of Product Management
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role of Product ManagementAIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role of Product Management
AIPMM Webcast: Importance & Role of Product Management
 
Red7 Introduction to Product Management
Red7 Introduction to Product ManagementRed7 Introduction to Product Management
Red7 Introduction to Product Management
 
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HSiLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
iLEAD-iLEAD Consulting Preview-V01-HS
 
2 Page Brochure
2 Page Brochure2 Page Brochure
2 Page Brochure
 
Deploying the iPad to Sales & Managed Markets Teams: Training and Effectivene...
Deploying the iPad to Sales & Managed Markets Teams: Training and Effectivene...Deploying the iPad to Sales & Managed Markets Teams: Training and Effectivene...
Deploying the iPad to Sales & Managed Markets Teams: Training and Effectivene...
 
2011 10 corporate introduction
2011 10 corporate introduction2011 10 corporate introduction
2011 10 corporate introduction
 
Networking and career search discusion document
Networking and career search discusion documentNetworking and career search discusion document
Networking and career search discusion document
 
Milagrow Business and Knowledge Solutions Corporate PPT
Milagrow Business and Knowledge Solutions Corporate PPTMilagrow Business and Knowledge Solutions Corporate PPT
Milagrow Business and Knowledge Solutions Corporate PPT
 
Sales Ecosystem
Sales EcosystemSales Ecosystem
Sales Ecosystem
 
The Sweet Spot
The Sweet SpotThe Sweet Spot
The Sweet Spot
 
NRF Presentation - GE's Innovation Toolkit
NRF Presentation - GE's Innovation ToolkitNRF Presentation - GE's Innovation Toolkit
NRF Presentation - GE's Innovation Toolkit
 
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
Marketing Analytics Conference 2011
 
How to Start up a business in China
How to Start up a business in ChinaHow to Start up a business in China
How to Start up a business in China
 
Scottish Widows, CRM Executive Customer Panel Presentation - Oracle OpenWorld...
Scottish Widows, CRM Executive Customer Panel Presentation - Oracle OpenWorld...Scottish Widows, CRM Executive Customer Panel Presentation - Oracle OpenWorld...
Scottish Widows, CRM Executive Customer Panel Presentation - Oracle OpenWorld...
 

Why kam fails 1302 pres show

  • 1. Why KAM May Fail? Key Accounts Management in Pharmaceutical Industry February 14 & 15, 2013 Hotel Avion, Mumbai Dr Ulhas Ganu Advisors in Medico-Marketing & Management (AIMM) Mumbai drukganu@gmail.com 1 KAM-Pharma 2012
  • 2. Why KAM May Fail? • Can It Really Fail? • How Can We Make it Work? • Can it be Applied by Every Organization? • Aren’t Organizational Objectives & Goals a Determinant to its Application? 2
  • 3. http://assignmenthelpexperts.blogspot.in/2011/09/business-its-environment-and-objectives.html Core Attributes  Intrinsic Attributes R&D * Base *  Objectives  * of * Customer Business Retention * * * 3
  • 4. Information is the Key The Story of A Villager at Railway Station Inquiring About Trains at the Inquiry Counter The Apologetic Person at the Counter Told him: • No Train towards Mumbai for 2 hours • No Train Towards Nashik for 3 hours Sarcastically adding………. • Not Even a Goods Train Movement in Day Time • The Villager Thanked him for the information…… 4
  • 5. Information is the Key Turning to his Wife he Said…… Come Dear, it is Safe now to Cross the Railway Track! Safer than the Safest Possible Option Height of Precaution! Not So Much Overcautious, I Still Wondered…. • Shouldn’t We Be Careful About KAM in India? • Should We At Least Check Coordinates Properly Before Accepting it Fully & Wholeheartedly…. 5
  • 6. Skeptic: Why KAM? Change is a Need Based Action The Only Person Who Always Likes a Change is a Wet Baby Which it Can’t Do by Itself! & Must Invite & Involve Others for Help 6
  • 7. Skeptic: Why KAM? What is Wrong with ‘The Age Old’ ‘Traditional’ “4 P” Model? Hasn’t it Been Modified & Used Highly Successfully for Decades? 7
  • 8. Skeptic: Why KAM? What is Wrong with ‘The Age Old’ ‘Traditional’ “4 P” Model? Hasn’t it Been Modified & Used Highly Successfully for Decades? Is KAM a Gimmick Used by the Consultants to Stay in Business ? Let Us See How Marketing Evolved Over the Last Few Decades…… 8
  • 9. Age Old Successful Traditional 4 P Model Primary Product Attaining Attributes Focused Quality The Desired Goal Person Finance & Sr. Place Management Product Product Value HR Promotion 9
  • 10. The 4 Ps & 4Cs The Standard P:C Theme (Caiibgbm marketing mgt module d) Marketing Convenience Mix Place Product Customer Solution Price Promotion Communication Customer Cost 10
  • 11. The Total Matrix Evolved Model • Medico-marketing Product Q Positioning http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=Revolving+s • Medical ubtractive+colour+wheel+illusion&start=138&hl • Marketing =en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=WP UF7YU6UH6JXM:&imgrefurl=http://docs.gimp.o Place rg/en/glossary.html&docid=aJWbz- • Finance Attributes CoZ5h1aM&imgurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/im ages/glossary/color-model- Senior additive.png&w=300&h=285&ei=xh5rULLqFMH KrAfb7YGgDw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=724&vpy Management =338&dur=346&hovh=219&hovw=230&tx=124 &ty=95&sig=107126594954691788435&page=6 • Technical Human • Quality &tbnh=177&tbnw=186&ndsp=24&ved=1t:429,r: • Production 15,s:138,i:222 Resource Assurance Development • R&D 11
  • 12. Communication • Medico-marketing Limited Aspect Q Communication Product Sale Only as Positioning http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=Revolving+sub • Medical tractive+colour+wheel+illusion&start=138&hl=en the Focus • Marketing &biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=WPUF7YU 6UH6JXM:&imgrefurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/glo • Finance ssary.html&docid=aJWbz- CoZ5h1aM&imgurl=http://docs.gimp.org/en/imag es/glossary/color-model- Attributes Senior additive.png&w=300&h=285&ei=xh5rULLqFMHKr Afb7YGgDw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=724&vpy=338 Management &dur=346&hovh=219&hovw=230&tx=124&ty=95 &sig=107126594954691788435&page=6&tbnh=17 • Technical Human Resource 7&tbnw=186&ndsp=24&ved=1t:429,r:15,s:138,i:2 Assurance • Quality Development • Production 22 • R&D Limited Outside Interaction Limited Outside Interaction Within Interaction 12
  • 13. Why Traditional Model Alone May Not Work Now…. It Largely Worked Earlier Because ………. 1. Not All Companies Followed it…… 2. Not All Those Who Followed the ‘Quality Principles’ ‘Communicated’ it to the Customers 3. Those Doing Both Activities were Successful 13
  • 14. The Changing Equations 1. The Model Was Consistently Modified Over Years 2. An Orientation to Working on Key Opinion Leaders & the Key Account Customers Evolved 3. CRM : the Customer Relationship Management became the Key word 4. Tender Business Extracts its Own Price 5. Retailers May Not be Friendly Customers but turned Hostile Adversaries 14
  • 15. The Current Situation • High Competition, too Many Branded Generics! • Limitations of KOL to help with Direct Business • Fear of Losing KAC due to Extrinsic Factors* • Resultant Loss of Business Need: • The Communication Should Focus on Benefits that May Accrue to the Customer & Company • Beginning of KAM Idea 15
  • 16. KAM: Key Accounts Management Key (What is the Key) Accounts (What are they?) Managing (Who Would Manage# & Whom*) The Confusions Galore KOL / KAM / KAC Are They Interchangeable / Similar/ Very Different #: Shouldn’t the Personnel be Trained & Nurtured? Are they Nurtured as Required 16
  • 17. KOL: Key Opinion Leaders: Role 1. Leading Physicians & Scientists, Respected & Acknowledged as Leaders in a Subject Area 2. Influence Thinking & Treatment Paradigms 3. Provide Insight into Diseases & Rx Regimen 4. Provide Assessment of Competitive Therapies The data is growing. Why aren't Insights? http://www.wipro.com/services/business-application- services/key-opinion-leader.aspx Drug Discovery : Help Write the Protocol & Define Efficacies of the Drug During the Study Medical Affairs * Help Medical Affairs on Drug Usage & Defining Side Effects
  • 18. Key Opinion Leaders Serve the Following Purpose The data is growing. Why aren't Insights? http://www.wipro.com/services/business-application-services/key-opinion- leader.aspx • Act as Leading Indicator of Therapy Acceptance (Protocols) • Help in Diffusion of Information & can Increase Velocity of Product Adoption (e.g. Imatinib) or • Even Relegation as well (e.g. Hydroxyurea/ Thiotepa/ Total Parenteral Nutrition): Pays to know the trends early • Physicians & Institutions Increasingly Rely on KOL Guidance for Prescribing New Drugs 18
  • 19. Key Targets KOLs 1. May Help Expand the Market for a Product through Establishing New Protocol 2. May Help Sales Indirectly 3. Important to be Associated With….. Although they May Not Prescribe Your Products in Large Volumes. Meet if Possible, Follow Trend Aren’t KOL’s Key Customers? Partners? 19
  • 20. Key Targets 1. KACs: Prescribers & Directly Generate Revenue Important as Attached to Several Hospitals 2. Products Availability in Hospital Pharmacies a Must as Hospital Management Insist Purchase of Products from their Pharmacy Only 3. KAC’s Must be Met Very Regularly & Since Institute’s Price is Lower, Should be Audited for Sales Returns 4. Profitability Profiling Necessary………. 5. Determine GP Coverage? Or Consultant Coverage Only? 20
  • 21. The Key Accounts Concept 1. Aren’t We Aware of It? 2. Product Availability in Pharmacies of Institutions Such as: * AIIMS / * Apollo Hospital Chain * Tata Memorial Hospital/ * Gujarat Civil Hospital * TNMSC/ * Many Other Government & Private Bodies • Considered as Valued Clients & Help Position Products Elsewhere 21
  • 22. Let Us Look At The Different K’s Collectively vis-à-vis Key Account - Management & The Corporate Objectives 22
  • 23. KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar Varying in the Output Requiring Optimization of the Matrix To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization 23
  • 24. KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar Varying in the Output Requiring Optimization of the Matrix To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization 24
  • 25. KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar Varying in the Degrees of Outcome Requiring Optimization of the Matrix To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization 25
  • 26. KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar Varying in the Degrees of Outcome Helping Optimization of the Matrix To Achieve Primary Objectives of the Organization 26
  • 27. KOL / KAC / Key Account ---- Management The K’s vis-à-vis Corporate Objectives Are A Set of Potentially Profitable Activities Theoretically & Functionally Appearing Similar Varying in the Degrees of Outcome Helping Optimization of the Matrix To Achieve the Primary Objectives of the Organization 27
  • 28. Good Product ? ? Gifts ! CMEs Conferences ! ! Personal Tours Company Needs Literatures * Scientific Updates ? Detailing Free Samples* LBL/Visual Aid Monograph 28
  • 29. Good Product CRM Convenient Appointment  Customer Solution as Medical Advisor or Consultant Gifts ! CMEs Conferences ! ! Personal Tours Literatures * Scientific Updates ? Detailing Free Samples* LBL/Visual Aid Monograph 29
  • 30. Interesting Current Model Vs Futuristic Model Influencing the Sale & How it May Shape Up in India 30
  • 31. Today Future Can You Ignore Patient? Ref: Developing Customer Process Orientation Alt_Puschmann BPMJ 2005 Business Process Management J. 11 (2005)4: 297-315 31
  • 32. Can You Ignore Patient Communication? Although Patient is the End User Traditionally, Doctor is the Client for Pharma Obviously, Instead of Ignoring the Patient, One May Have to Find Ways to Engage him Albeit Ethically Costing May Have to be Controlled Communicating Economically & Yet Effectively With the Patient Would Require Creativity 32
  • 33. KAC vis-à-vis KAM Catch & Trap Extra Costs May Make the Model Weaker…… • Hospital Bargains Hard For Price: • Innovator, L1 & L2 Approved is the Norm • At Least Three Competing Products in Pharmacy • Hospital as a ‘Key Account’ Has a Lot of Limitation vis-à-vis Company • Doctors Must be Won Over For Prescription or the Products Do Not Move in Pharmacy • Why Do Indian Companies Have to Compete as L1 & L2 When Quality could be As Good As MNC? 33
  • 34. programmes/short-courses/designing-your-key-account-management- KAM http://www.gibs.co.za/programmes/corporate-education-executive- Deliver Provide Consistent Ongoing Concept Quality Cooperation Deliver Consistent Communicate Performance Trust Based With Me Customer Deliver Relationship Be Competitive Meaningful Not Necessarily Value the Cheapest Demonstrate Flexibility & plan.aspx Innovation Intrinsic Attributes Extrinsic Attributes 34
  • 35. The White Deliver Provide Consistent Flag Means Ongoing Quality Cooperation Surrender Deliver Communicate Consistent Surrender With Me Performance Compulsions Deliver or Be Competitive Meaningful Compromise Not Necessarily Value the Cheapest Demonstrate Intrinsic Flexibility & Extrinsic Attributes Innovation Attributes 35
  • 36. Red Flag: Deliver Provide The White Drop in Consistent Ongoing Flag Means Marketing Quality Cooperation Surrender Concept Deliver Communicate Consistent Surrender With Me Performance Compulsions Deliver or Be Competitive Meaningful Compromise Not Necessarily Value the Cheapest Demonstrate Intrinsic Flexibility & Extrinsic Attributes Innovation Attributes 36
  • 37. Primary Attributes Primary Focus Product Primary Quality Attaining Attributes Focused The Desired Goal KAM KAC Goal Product Trade Product Value Sale Positioning Approach 37
  • 38. Secondary Attributes Primary Focus Marketing Focus Trade Sale Lost Approach Price When Quality & Brand Positioning Trust is Breached KAM Value   CRM Goal KAC Wrong  Interpretation Would Fail to Deliver wrongly Desired Interpreted Quality as Results Transaction Model 38
  • 39. Analyzing the Prescription Definition A Prescription is an Order/Advice by the Doctor: • To the Patient to Purchase the Drug & to Consume it in a Particular Manner • To the Retailer to Sale the Drug to the Patient • To the Company to Make it Available at the Counter • There are A Lot Many Connected Activities & Since Substitution of Drug is Prohibited, Generation of Prescription Amounts to the Sale 39
  • 40. Analyzing the Prescription Definition • FF is the Signatory • Authors Could be At the HO or in Field • It is a Multi-numbered Lock Field Force: Does Create, Enable & Sustain Prescription • Unfortunately Only the Sales & Not the Marketing Invariably Considered- Wrongly- as the Only Key Their Customers Considered the only Key Customers! 40
  • 41. Reaching & Staying at the Top • Conceptualization • Backward Integration With Quality Personnel is Equally Important, • Backward Integration Ignored Consistently • Quality First / Client as a Consequence • Without Innovation & Consistent Quality, Building Client Rapport & Long Term Relationship With Clients isn’t Possible, 41
  • 42. CRM in the Hands of Sales Personnel is Like Schoolboy Concept of Essay on Rural India vis-à-vis Football 42
  • 43. 5 P Match Package to Product Product Patient Positioning Price to Positioning Hospital Organization Price Price Hospital Place Patient Personnel Personnel Deliver Consistent Quality, Deliver Consistent Performance, Deliver Meaningful Value, Provide Ongoing Cooperation, Communicate With Me, Be Competitive Demonstrate Flexibility & Innovation Not Necessarily the Cheapest 43
  • 44. Skeptic: Why KAM? Change is a Need Based Action The Only Person Who Always Likes a Change is a Wet Baby Which it Can’t Do by Itself & Must Invite & Involve Others for Help 44
  • 45. Why KAM: International Genesis Need Based 1. Pharma Encountered Economic Recession, earlier in (2005 & 2006). 2. “Sales Forces Bloated Earlier” 3. Pharma Sales Reps Started Losing Jobs in Thousands….. 4. “Hence No Other Way but to turn to technology.” 5. CRM software may be more critical than ever to the pharma Industry (Hagemeyer, Gartner Research Managing VP). (Ref. Market Focus: Pharmaceuticals -- CRM Undergoes an Experimental New Treatment, An older CRM vertical gets a new dose of on-demand technology) By Lauren McKay 45
  • 46. KAM under the spotlight: by David Round The British Experience With KAM http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight Claims * Hence Now Using More Sophisticated Approach to Sales & Marketing Activity * Delivering More Efficient & Effective Commercial Model Using a Targeted KAM Methodology 46
  • 47. KAM under the spotlight: by David Round The British Experience With KAM http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight • Dec 09 & Dec 10 –Working According to KAM ? • 92.7% of UK GPs had a Face-to-Face Call or Meeting With a Medical Rep from Pharma • This indicates, the industry was still carrying out almost blanket coverage of GPs. • The 2010 Merely Continued a Similar Trend from the years that preceded it – • Past Decade Annual Industry Coverage Consistently Reached Over 90% of the Total Prescriber Population. 47
  • 48. KAM under the spotlight: by David Round The British Experience With KAM continued http://www.pharmafield.co.uk/features/2011/12/KAM-under-the-spotlight • July ’10 to June ’11, GPs Face-to-Face Call/Meeting with an Industry Representative dropped to 85 • In the First 6 Months of 2011 the Total No. of GPs Who Have Had A Similar Contact Slumped to 73%. • Now Face-to-face calls/ rep/day falling year-on-year. • No. of meetings (per rep/day) has gradually risen • The Synmetrics data: more meetings taking place today than at any point in the past 10 years; and • Crucially in 2010 the No. of Meetings/Day Overtook the No. of face-to-face calls for the First Time. 48
  • 49. Current Trend: A Positive Shift Towards KAM Thrust Relatively New • Data shows: 17,000 GPs – (around 35%) didn’t receive a Face-to-Face call in the Last 12 Months of ‘10 – 11’ • There’s a Concomitant Increase in the No. of meetings • A significant drop in face-to-face call activity, • Over 1/3rd of Pharma’s Traditional Customer Population Not Receiving a Single Call • It’s still too early to make definitive claims that the KAM model is firmly embedded in UK Pharma. • KAM Picking Up or Call reduction by Compulsion? 49
  • 50. Team Management: International Vs Indian Scene • Account Managers are Encouraged to Develop Their Own Call Plans • Become More Accountable for Their Own Business • Need Robust & Effective Data to Make Informed Targeting Decisions in the Process is Paramount • Strong Feedback System Desirable & • Sharing of the Collected Data Utmost Important • Liaison: Sales Team, PMT & KA Manager: Key to Success • Is Field Force Reduction a Compulsion in India? • If Not…. How Effectively to Use Them For Arranging Meetings For KA Manager & KOL/KAC….. 50
  • 51. KAM Perspective Lack of Understanding About KA Manager Job Function Understanding Attributes Required Developing Personnel Internal Integration Their Hospital Work Meaningful Communication Avoids Repeat Calls by different Sales Personnel to same Customer / Purchaser All Round Knowledge & Focus on Company Perspective Helps Snatch Profitable Deal Sales Personnel With Limited Strategic Understanding May Not be the Answer for KAM Key Account Managers Need More Freedom 51
  • 52. How Do Consumers Choose…. Among Products & Services? • Performance > Expectations => Satisfaction # Performance < Expectations => Dissatisfaction Company Needs an “Uncompromising Attitude” Towards Maintaining “Product Quality” Integrated Communication Keeping in Mind Company Perspectives Important Only A Senior & Mature Person Can Handle it Properly 52
  • 53. http://www.whiteladderconsulting.com/cor porate_training.html A Simple Sales Person Cannot Understand the Intricacies Key Account Management is a Specialized Function 53
  • 54. “MR or FLM” Conducted Activities Versus Key Accounts Manager Managed Activities http://sites.cdnis.edu.hk/students/001771/ * objectives/ * * 54
  • 55. Blake & Mouton 9 1/9 9/9 al_grid_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manageri The customers The problem friend solver 5/5 Concern for Compromise customer “Method” approach 1/1 9/1 The order The pressure taker salesman 1 1 Concern for making the sale 9 55
  • 56. CAP: (Ward - Strategic Management Accounting) the “Customer Account Profitability” is “The Total Sales Revenue Generated from a Customer or Customer Group.... Less All the Costs that are Incurred In Servicing that Customer or Customer Group.” 56
  • 57. CAP: (Ward - Strategic Management Accounting) the “Customer Account Profitability” is “The Total Sales Revenue Generated from a Customer or Customer Group.... Less Where Would You Put KOL? All the Costs that are Incurred In Servicing that Customer or Customer Group.” 57
  • 58. 11_01_archive.html http://mnama.blogspot.in/2010_ 10% 30% 50-60% 60 % 30 – 35% http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&start=191&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=mvjFuU PExojbDM:&imgrefurl=http://mnama.blogspot.com/2010_11_01_archive.html&docid=WVzyJCpwO_i78M&imgurl=http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4YZAh7cfTLk/TO1mSjYZ 9bI/AAAAAAAAACo/Lfzs_LuAEqs/s1600/Untitled.png&w=493&h=284&ei=SPaAUISYOcSsrAesvoD4Dg&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=797&vpy=135&dur=12821&hovh=17 10 to 15% 0&hovw=296&tx=160&ty=103&sig=107126594954691788435&page=7&tbnh=143&tbnw=249&ndsp=32&ved=1t:429,r:94,s:100,i:286 Identify Your Important Customers Pareto’s 80:20 or 10:30:60 aren’t Absolute Ratios 58
  • 59. The List is More Likely to be Dynamic than Static 10% 30% 50-60% 30 – 35% 60 % http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&start=191&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=mvjFuU PExojbDM:&imgrefurl=http://mnama.blogspot.com/2010_11_01_archive.html&docid=WVzyJCpwO_i78M&imgurl=http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_4YZAh7cfTLk/TO1mSjYZ 9bI/AAAAAAAAACo/Lfzs_LuAEqs/s1600/Untitled.png&w=493&h=284&ei=SPaAUISYOcSsrAesvoD4Dg&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=797&vpy=135&dur=12821&hovh=17 10 to 15% 0&hovw=296&tx=160&ty=103&sig=107126594954691788435&page=7&tbnh=143&tbnw=249&ndsp=32&ved=1t:429,r:94,s:100,i:286 Pareto Principle Helps Identify Important Customers 59
  • 60. 10% 30% 30% 60% 60 % 10% Representative Chart Not Absolute Guide % Marketing Spend Per Segment Invert the Pyramid and Supercharge Your Profits, by Mark Price 60 http://mnama.blogspot.in/2010_11_01_archive.html
  • 61. Key http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=wrong+Key+Account+Customer+%2B+Pyramid&num=10&um=1&hl=en&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=xqG 0- PMeMDuwfM:&imgrefurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm%3Farticleid%3D1508902%26show%3Dhtml&docid=68GZFYf2T2C7QM&imgurl =http://www.emeraldinsight.com/content_images/fig/0200230404002.png&w=1363&h=838&ei=B_SAUKiPDdHQrQfB7IGQAQ&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx= Not Serving them is Not an Option 399&vpy=160&dur=4497&hovh=176&hovw=286&tx=130&ty=109&sig=107126594954691788435&sqi=2&page=1&tbnh=137&tbnw=223&start=0&nds p=24&ved=1t:429,r:1,s:0,i:69 Find Economic Ways to Reach Them http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=profit+revenue+pyramid+model&hl=en&tbo=d&biw=1525&bih=712&tbm=isch&tbnid= xqG0- PMeMDuwfM:&imgrefurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm%3Farticleid%3D1508902%26show%3Dhtml&doci d=68GZFYf2T2C7QM&imgurl=http://www.emeraldinsight.com/content_images/fig/0200230404002.png&w=1363&h=838&ei=VbQKUbvtE8jKrAfD-61 YDwAg&zoom=1&ved=1t:3588,r:0,s:0,i:79&iact=rc&dur=2&sig=107126594954691788435&page=1&tbnh=176&tbnw=286&start=0&ndsp=17&tx=120&ty=100
  • 62. Curry’s Pyramid: Classifying Customers Gold Silver Bronze White http://www.expertprogrammanagement.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/currys-pyramid.png 62
  • 63. Age Old Matrix for ‘Performance & Goal’ Audit What do we Goal setting want to achieve? ⇓ Performance What is Measurement happening? ⇓ Performance Why is it Diagnosis happening? ⇓ Corrective Action What should we do about it? 63
  • 66. With KAM in Place Why Not Special Consideration? Grade 1 2 3 4 5 Physician With L1 & L2, There is Still Pressure to Work for Prescription With the Physician Independently Patient In KAM, Why have L1, L2? Hospital Why not a Single Drug Choice to the Prescribing Doctor? Or Why not Commitment for a Pharmacy • Fixed Minimum Order & • Non-returnable Supply? 66
  • 67. http://www Pharmaceuticals Distribution System in .csas.ed.ac. India, Center for International Health Policy uk/__data/ assets/pdf_ file/0003/3 8829/Phar maDistribut ionIndia.pdf Working Paper July 2,3, 2007 67
  • 68. Wholesaler A Potential Entry Point for Spurious Drugs? Could Nurturing them For Clean Business be Important? Encourage KAM & Hence the Direct Medical Supply to Institutions, Hospitals as a Good Channel to Prevent Spurious Drug Entry Can KAM be Positioned to Convince & Influence Smaller Hospitals & Nursing Homes For Business 68
  • 69. Key Account Manager Selection & Perpetuity is Important Hierarchy in the System Cooperation from HO & Field Personnel Essential Training the Key Account Manager Knowing Overall Aspects of Commerce & Quality Nurturing Key Account Manager Targets/Incentives 69
  • 70. How Many Key Accounts? Visit the Business Triangle: Profit/Serviceable! Corporate Hospitals or Government Business? Layers or Gradations Possible Within Segment Loss of a Single Account May Mean a Setback Cannot Possibly Ignore Trade Business to Protect From Sudden Account Loss? Specialty Products? Liquidating Stocks Quickly? Product Centric? Company Centric? 70
  • 71. http://www.google.co.in/imgres?q=key+account+ manager+skills&start=575&num=10&um=1&hl=e n&biw=1525&bih=741&tbm=isch&tbnid=rt0UC6P GEXoJaM:&imgrefurl=http://freebookessay.com/c * ontent/key-marketing-skills- d4b330f31854e8963681d3819dc28ebc.html&doci d=gubtck9feXtYsM&imgurl=http://www.iproceed. * com/marketing/images/key-accounts- metrics.jpg&w=345&h=289&ei=cA99UO3_FdGUiQ fLxoDADg&zoom=1&iact=rc&dur=485&sig=10712 6594954691788435&page=16&tbnh=164&tbnw= 196&ndsp=31&ved=1t:429,r:98,s:500,i:298&tx=75 &ty=84 * 71
  • 72. Newer Challenges: Paradigm Shift Trend of Pharma Companies Setting Own Hospitals Why Would They Buy Crucial & Costly Products From Others Hospital Chains Getting Own Products Manufactured Ophthalmic Lenses Medicines Bound to Restrict the Space for Many Companies 72
  • 73. Challenges In Designing Business Strategy 1. Trade Business or Tender Business? Government Business or Corporate Hospitals? 2. Hospitals: Generally Injectables, 3. Trade: Oral Medications 4. Difficult to Evade Retailer Business, as…. Batch Scale Up/ Batch Economy Possible Only with Liquidation…. 5. Quicker Liquidation: Fresh Batch on Shelf 6. Reaching Private Practitioners, Repeat Calls? 7. Ideal Blend of Call versus Business Needs to be Decided 73
  • 74. Perspectives: Field Personnel Vs Organization The Mnemonic: SPICE Explains the Conflict • Salary on Time • Sales/Revenue • Product/Price • Profit • Incentives • Innovation • CRM • Competence & (for Important Clients) Commitment (from the consistently Personnel) • Expenses • Engagement With Key Reimbursement Customers & on time Regularly Institutions 74
  • 75. To Be or Not To Be? 1. KAM is Not a Transaction but a Win-Win Model, 2. Not Applicable to Every Organization 3. Choose Model Suitable for the Organization 4. The KA Manager Has to be a Senior Position 5. Select & Train The Key Accounts Managers 6. Nurture & Retain The Key Account Managers 7. Support from Sales & Marketing Absolute Must 8. Regular Auditing to Select / Deselect Accounts Desirable as Key Account = Profitability 9. KOLs May or May Not Be Key Accounts (Direct profitability) but Worth Following…… 75
  • 76. Wonder, Who Can Possibly Handle the Job? Can Group Product Managers be Groomed? As they Help Define & Set Targets Know Products & Aware of Quality Profile Know Finances & Company Policies Can Integrate & Reverse Integrate Seamlessly With Mfg./QA/ Finance/Sales Why Not Have Jr. Product Managers at Metro Cities? Can Train Newly Inducted Personnel Work in Field in the Region Generate Feedbacks Useful for HO 76
  • 77. Re-orientation of the Focus is the Key Use Modern Techniques to: * Convert Data in to Useful Information * Audit Customers / Accounts *Select/Deselect According to Results Dispassionately 77
  • 78. KAM Does Not Fail It is the Dilution of Focus on Basic Attributes & Misfit With Business Type Which Derails the Process Thank You 78