1. USPS.com® - Track & Confirm https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction.action
YOUR LABEL NUMBER SERVICE STATUS OF YOUR ITEM DATE & TIME LOCATION FEATURES
®
03120090000050973601 Priority Mail Delivered June 09, 2012, 10:28 am CINCINNATI, OH 45202 Expected Delivery By:
June 11, 2012
Hide Details Delivery Confirmation™
Out for Delivery June 09, 2012, 9:15 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Sorting Complete June 09, 2012, 9:05 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Arrival at Post Office June 09, 2012, 5:19 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Depart USPS Sort June 09, 2012 CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Facility
Processed through June 08, 2012, 11:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45235
USPS Sort Facility
Acceptance June 08, 2012, 6:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45234
®
03102010000042767898
042767 Priority Mail Delivered June 09, 2012, 8:26 am COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Expected Delivery By:
June 11, 2012
Hide Details Delivery Confirmation™
Arrival at Post Office June 09, 2012, 5:48 am COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Processed through June 09, 2012, 4:34 am COLUMBUS, OH 43218
USPS Sort Facility
Depart USPS Sort June 09, 2012 CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Facility
Processed at USPS June 08, 2012, 10:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Origin Sort Facility
Acceptance June 08, 2012, 6:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45234
NOTE: Correct Tracking No. For Ohio Civil Rights Commission Is: 03102010000042767898
042767
6/14/2012 2:50 PM

2. , , EEOC " "
- ,
" " TITLE / ,
, ; 31,
2012 ;" CHARGE
9, 2012
;" " 2 " [1]
: 8, 2012
: MAIL - 03120090000050973601
("EEOC")
ATTN: -
/ ಒ Attn: Javey ( )
550 , 10
, 45202
MAIL - 03102010000042477898
("OCRC")
ATTN: ( ).
30 ,5
, 43215
EEOC OMPLAINT: 473-2012-00832 (Garretson , )
473-2012-00837 (Messina Staffing / Messina )
/ (" ")
: 14731
, 45250
: (513) 680-2922
/ ( ) Garretson ,
( ): Attn: ( )

3. Attn: Garretson ( / )
7775
: (513) 575-7167 (513) 794-0400 / (888) 556-7526
:
** 50 +
Messina Staffing / Messina
Attn: Messina ( )
11811 -
, 45249
(513) 774-9187
R, (" ") ,
, EEOC " "
- , " "
TITLE / ,
, ; 31, 2012
;" CHARGE
9, 2012 ;"
" 2 " ("RFROD NOR ..." ):
" / GARRETSON
/ MESSINA STAFFING /
MESSINA -
-
- ;

4. " 30, 2012 ( " /
")
, waiving , " / "
"RFROD NOR . . . ":
.
, 610 F.2 241 (1980) - [2] EEOC
ಒ ಒ
90
ಒ 90- ಒ
. 1964 , § 706 ( ) 42 USCA § 2000e-5
( ) (1) .
29 CFR § 1601,18
: :
(ಒ ) , ,
, aggrieved
,
, ...
( ) , aggrieved
, ;
ಒ , ; § 1601.28 ( ) (2)
. § 1601,28 .
( ) ;
, , , , §
1601.21 ( ) .
(ಒ ) ( ) ( ) , § 1601.21 ( )
. ,
§ 1601.21 ( ) ( )
.
29 CFR § 1601,19
: .
(ಒ )

5. ,
.
. aggrieved
ಒ 90
.. .
( )
ಒ ,
.
ಒ
,
.
aggrieved
ಒ 90
§ 1601.28 (ಒ ) (1) (2),
90
. 90
, , § 1601.28
(ಒ ) (1) (2),
, 90
. ,
ಒ . 90
, 90
. ಒ ,
.
29 CFR § 1601,21
: .
(ಒ ) § 1601,19
ಒ
, ಒ
,
.
,
.
( ) aggrieved
(ಒ ) ಒ ,
, , ಒ ,
,
.
, ,

6. , ,
§ 1601,25
.
(1)
,
.
90
§ 1601.28 (ಒ ) (1)
(2),
. 90 ,
, § 1601.28 (ಒ ) (1)
(2),
,
. .
, , § 1601,28 ,
90 ಒ
.
(2) aggrieved
,,
ಒ , ,
, ಒ ,
, .
( ) ಒ ,
.
( ) , , ,
;
, , , ,
ಒ ,
, , ಒ
.
. ,
, , ;
; ;
,,
§ 1601,25
ಒ ,
.
(1)

7. ,
.
90
§ 1601.28 (ಒ ) (1)
(2),
. 90 , ,
§ 1601.28 (ಒ ) (1) (2),
,
.
.
, , § 1601,28 ,
90 ಒ
.
(2) , aggrieved
, ,
ಒ , , ,
,
.
( ) ,
defers FEP
§ 1601,13 .
, :
(1) " " :
( ) thereto
ಒ FEP ;
(II) ಒ ಒ FEP
.
,ಒ FEP
aggrieved FEP
, ;
, ,
,
.
(2) " "
, ,

8. :
( ) ;
(II)
;
(III) ,
: , ಒ FEP
,
,.
1. ,
, , ,
, /
.
2.
, . 31
, Garretson Messina Staffing / Messina
2012 " "
" " .
3. 30, 2012 , 196 86
ಒ " / "- / :
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
4. " / " 109
ಒ :( ) , (ii)
, (III) , / (IV) ,( )
, (VI) ,( ) , (VIII) / , (IX) / ,
( ) Employment-At-Will/Protected , ( ) , (XII) , (XIII) ,
(XIV) , (XV) , (XVI) .
5. / ಒ
" / " /

9. ,
.
6. ,
/ " /
" ! , / ,
ಒ " / "
capricious
.
7. " / "
ERRED " ."
8. /
-
" / "
ERRED. ಒ " "
240 "
/ " .
9. " / " ,
.
10. / ERRED
/ , EEOC , "
" " "
" /
." EEOC
" / "ಒ
, EEOC
" ." , ,
/ EEOC
, " / "
ಒ 30, " / "
2012 http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f

10. 24, 2012
"Derwin 8, 2012 ":
http://www.slideshare. net/VogelDenise/052412-response-to-eeoc-letter-of-050812
11. EEOC " "
/
.
12. / , EEOC "
/ " 8 "
( ) , 2012 Derwin
. " , ಒ / EEOC
capricious .
13. EEOC
" " ERRED ( ) .
, , /
EEOC " " (
). , EEOC
, " / "
" "
!
14. EEOC /
/ ,
EEOC
/
.
15. / EEOC ,
" "!
16. ಒ EEOC / Javey,
" "
. , EEOC / /
.

11. 17. EEOC
ERRED " / ." , EEOC "
"ಒ
/ " " Derwin 8, 2012 ."
29 CFR § 1601,8 ಒ :
ಒ
...
29 CFR § 1601,9 :
ಒ .
29 CFR § 1601,12 ; :
(ಒ ) :
§ 1601,7 (1) ,
;
(2) ( )
;
,
(3) ಒ ,: § 1601.15 ( ) ;
(4) ,
, ;
(5) ಒ
ಒ
, ,
.
,
( )
(ಒ ) , ಒ . ಒ
,
, .
.
ಒ redeferred .

12. 18.
" / " . ,
" ."
19. " / " ," "
/ ,
ಒ "TYPEWRITTEN" .
20. " / " "
" : (1) ,
; (2) ;
ಒ , , (3) ಒ
; (4) ,
; ಒ ,
, ಒ
(5)
.
21. ewsome " / "
" : (1) ; (2) ; (3) ; (4) - ( )
; (5) "- 2 .
22. 8, 2012 , ಒ
" " ( Garretson , Messina Staffing /
Messina ) ಒ .
23. 9, 2012 , "
", ಒ :
" Garretson
, Messina Staffing
. , 21, 2011
. 2, 2012 .
, ಒ
, 4112
.

13. ಒ .
300
.
, ,
,, 4112
, , , , ,
,
, , ...
,
ಒ .
,
..."
Aukeman /
ಒ .
9, 2012 " ."
24. , OCRC " /
" submittal .
/ 180 , 240
OCRC .
, , ಒ 3, 679 F.Supp
Alsup . 716 ( 1987.)
- EEOC defers
, " " , ಒ EEOC
300 . 1964
, § 706 ( ),, 42 USCA § 2000e-5 ( ) (1). . .
ಒ
" ," EEOC
. . . ,
ಒ claimant

14. 240 . 1964
, § 706 ( ),, 42 USCA § 2000e-5 ( ) (1). . .
Mohasco vs , 447 807, 814 . 16, 100 S.Ct. 2486,
2491 . 16, 65 L.Ed.2d 532 (1980).
, OCRC " / " EEOC
ERRED . ,
EEOC OCRC " "
ERRED / EEOC " ."
25. ಒ hio (" ")
/ , , / ,
"
/ " / /
ಒ ,
" / " OCRC
/
OCRC ಒ ಒ
.:
Weise , 522 F.2 524 (2 ND
1975.), 33 BNA FEP
CAS 544 - EEOC
EEOC ,
;
EEOC ,
(
) , .
, , - 65 FRD 94 (1974)
EEOC
INAPPLICABLE ;
,
- .
Grohal Stauffer , 385 F.Supp 1267 (1974), 10 BNA FEP
CAS 785 - ,

15. WAIVED;
.
vs , 599 F.Supp 136, 36 BNA FEP
CAS 875 (1984) - 180 ,
Related ,
ಒ
" "
.
Marinelli , 222 F.Supp 2d 402 (2002) -. § § 2000e
1964, 42 USCS
.
Austion , 244 Fed.Appx. 639 ( 6, 2007) - "
"ಒ 300
. , 1964 § 706 ( ) (1), 42 USCA § 2000e-5 ( ) (1)
.
" / "
/ . ( )
26, 38, 58, 64 66, 69, 105, 135 189 . ,
12, 28, 55, 68, 74, 79, 81, 116 - 3 118, 120, 129, 136 138, Garretson
, 2012 .
Docket ಒ / :
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
( ) , ಒ
. ,
ಒ , ,
. ಒ ,
ಒ ,
. (Am.
Jur , § 9.) ಒ -.
ಒ ಒ
ಒ , .

16. .
, .
ಒ .
26. " / "
, ಒ :
, 615 F.2 1265 (1980), 22 BNA FEP CAS 1053
-
, .
Kassaye , 999 F.2 603 (1993), 62 BNA FEP CAS 724 -
;
,
.
, 615 F.2 1265 (1980) - [18] ಒ
ಒ . 1964 ,§
701 . 42 USCA § 2000e .
[19] ಒ ,
. 1964 , § 706 42 USCA § 2000e-5 .
, "XIV; Nos. 7, 14, 16, 17, 19, 20, 29, 33, 37, 38, 55, 63, 71, 73, 76, 87, 96, 99,
100 . / " " . "
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
29 CFR § 1601.28 (3) : :
. . . ;; ; ; (3)
, ; ,
,
. ಒ
.
(4) deems
.

17. 27. /
" / ."
28. EEOC H /
,
, ಒ .
29. RECOrd , ಒ ,
" /
" " " ಒ ,
/ typewritten /
" ಒ " .
24, 2012 "Derwin 8, 2012 " -
: http://www.slideshare.net/VogelDenise/052412-response-to-
eeoc-letter 050812
30. "
/
."
.
, , 471 NE2d 471 ( , 1984) -
ಒ .
1967 , § 14, 29 USCA § 633.
Piecuch Mfg. , 626 F.Supp. 65 ( E.Div, 1985..) -
, . 1967
, § 14 ( ), 29 USCA § 633 ( ).
31. " / "
deferring " "
/
/ / .

18. 32. " / " " " ;
, / /
.
33. "
" ERRED 90- .
EEOC ,
, " " "
" " / ." , OCRC, /
/ / . OCRC
9, 2012, ಒ " / ."
, 586 F.2 1315 (1978) - [4]
EEOC
,
EEOC
. 1964 ,§
706 ( ) 42 USCA § 2000e-5 ( ) .
... EEOC 2000e-5 ( )
, EEOC
"
. "(Gallego (9
. 1977) 550 F.2 456, 457. . EEOC (9
. 1974 ) 499 F.2 187, 189 n.3 () "
deprives ಒ ".)
, EEOC ಒ
ಒ . (
(5 1969) 408 F.2 283, 291 ("EEOC
grievant
.") ;. .- (9 . 1974) 492
F.2 292, 295.) EEOC
,
erred 1974 .
Judulang , 132 S.Ct. 476 (2011) - (APA)
,
, , ಒ
, . 5 USCA § 706 (2) ( ).

19. 34. " "
/ . ,
!
NLRB Ass'n, , , ,
. , ಒ 638, 97 S.Ct. 891
(1977) Pipefitters - ,
.
, 73 S.Ct. 85 (1952) -
ಒ
.
, § 313 ( ),, 16 USCA § 825 ( ).
35.
,
.
36. .
, / ,
FACT
ಒ . , " / "
.
37. rECOrd NOR
, , / "
/ "
/
/ / .
38. " /
"
CAPRICIOUS / /
.

20. 39. "
"
" /
."
40.
" " "ಒ
/ ;
Derwin 8, 2012 " 24, 2012 " /
" , EEOC
" ".
41.
" "ಒ /
" / " "
Derwin 8, 2012 ."
(APA) capricious ,
- , 286 F.3d 382 (. 6
2002)
,
capricious . 5 USCA § § 701
., 706 (2) ( ).
, ,
115 S.Ct. 1278 ( , 1995) , - ,
,
. 5 USCA § 702.
Lujan , 110 S.Ct. 3177 (1990) -
,
ಒ aggrieved
. 5 USCA § 702.
Lueckel, 417 F.3d 532 (. 6 2005) -
(APA) ,

21. ,
. 5 USCA § 551 .
Com'n , 75 S.Ct. 467 (1955) -
. , § 10 ( ), 5 USCA § 1009 ( ).
42. /
" / ,"
EEOC /
,, , , ,
/ ಒ . ,
/
ಒ . EEOC /
" / " EEOC
/ / ಒ
.
43. /
" / "
OCRC / / ಒ
/
.
44. /
" / "
: (ಒ ) particularized OCRC
/ 240 /
OCRC " / "
ಒ . ( )
" "ಒ depriving
/ OCRC EEOC . ,
/ EEOC ಒ ಒ
. EEOC " / "
OCRC , EEOC

22. / . OCRC EEOC
,
" / ." ( )
/ ಒ REDRESSED
/ OCRC / EEOC
/ EEOC OCRC
/ / " /
."
, 297 F.3d 455 (6 , 2002.) - (APA)
, " ...
ಒ "
. 5 USCA § 702. . . .
[4] III - - ,
: particularized
(1) ಒ ; (2) ,
;
redressed (3) ಒ . USCAConst. 3, § 2, CL. 1
[5] [6] 10 (ಒ ) (APA)
. 5 USC § 702 (" ಒ
, aggrieved ,
."). APA
ಒ ,
, . Nat'l
. Nat'l , 522 479, 488, 118 S.Ct. 927,
140 L.Ed.2d 1 (1998) (NCUA) (" III , ಒ
APA (ಒ ) § 10 ಒ
. ").
"
... ." . ( ) ( Serv Ass'n .
Orgs., , 397 150, 153, 90 S.Ct. 827, 25 L.Ed.2d 184 (1970)).
Bunten Bunten, 710 NE2d 757 (.. App.3.Dist, 1998) -
;
.
Civ.Proc., 52.

23. Yee , 267 F.2 206 (9 1959.) -
ಒ
.
45.
" / " 24, 2012 "Derwin
8, 2012 " , pleadings
, " "
.
46.
/ .
47. " / " 24, 2012
"Derwin
8, 2012 ,"
/
" "
.
48. , /
/ EEOC
" " . , OCRC EEOC
ERRED " / ."
49. ಒ " " , EEOC
" ." EEOC
OCRC
/ , , , .
50. EEOC /
ERRED .
51. " / "
24, 2012 "Derwin 8, 2012 ,"
pleadings / . /
.

24. III. , " " TITLE
/ - EEOC " "
, 2011- -1370 ( App.8.Dist, 2011..) -
, , "reliabl "
;, confidently .
Sarr , 485 F.3d 354 (6 2007.) -
,
, .
, , 365 F.3d 435 (. 6 2004)
ಒ - ,
capricious ....
(APA)
evidentiary . 5
USCA § 551 .
52. "RFROD NOR. . . / "
24, 2012" Derwin 8, 2012 . ""
ಒ "
53. 24, 2012 " /
" ERRED "Derwin 8, 2012
."
54. "
/ " ERRED .
55. "RFROD NOR . . . " ,
( )
, ಒ .
56. /
" / ."

25. , OCRC " / "
OCRC / " ."
57. ",
Garretson , Messina Staffing
. , " ,ಒ /
/ "
!
58. /
/
, ."
59. /
" capricious .
60. / "
/ capricious
.
61.
/ "
CAPRICIOUS ! /
240 .
62. /
" ,"
ಒ
. " " "
.
29 CFR § 1601.15 ( ) :
(ಒ ) , ,
.
ಒ
,
. , aggrieved

26. ,
, .
( ) , ಒ
aggrieved :
(1)
;
(2) ,ಒ ,
;
(3) , , aggrieved
, aggrieved
.
( ) ಒ
.
ಒ ,
ascertain
.
( ) ( ), ( ) , (ಒ )
.
63. " / "
24, 2012 "Derwin
8, 2012 " . ,
( )
/ " "
.
64. " / " 24, 2012
"Derwin 8, 2012 "
, ಒ . ,
" / " 24, 2012
"Derwin 8, 2012 ."
65. " / "
" " .
66. "RFROD NOR . . . ",
,

27. ' " / "
/ ( ) .
67. "RFROD NOR .. / .
" , / ,
". "
68. : - Garretson Messina Staffi ng / Messina
- / Javey
" Garretson , ( 473-2012-00832)
.
ಒ .
,
.
.
. ಒ
...."
" Messina Staffing Messina ( 473-2012-
00837) .
ಒ .
,
.
.
. ಒ
...."
:
: "EEOC : ,
EEOC .
.
."
: "EEOC
."

28. "RFROD NOR. . . " ಒ
"
", 2012 24 " / 8, 2012
Derwin ."
, / "EEOC
" /
" / "
.
69. "RFROD NOR . . ." ,
" /
' / ಒ .
70. " / "
.
Gladieux . BD, 728 NE2d 459 (Ohio. App.10.Dist 1999.) -.
" " ಒ
, .
71. /
.
72. "RFROD NOR ... /
" ,
". "" ,
ಒ " / .
, , 732 NE2d 465 (
App.2.Dist 1999..) -.
,
,
.

29. 73. , "RFROD NOR
..." .
74. ,
. , OCRC
" / "
!
Wurzelbacher Colerain Twp. BD. , 663 NE2d :713 ( App.1.Dist
, 1995...) - ,
. . .
, .
, 892 F.Supp. 973 ( W.Div,
1995..) -
. 5
USCA § 706 (2) ( ).
, 595 F.3d 297 (6 2010.) -. . .
, ಒ ...
, .
75. "RFROD NOR ... /
" " ""
ಒ , " .
"typewritten / "
/ capricious ,
.
76. "RFROD NOR ..." ,
ಒ ಒ "' /
' " "
." / " ,
EEOC " capricious
. , /
.

30. USEPA, 553 F.3d 927 (6 2009.) -
(APA) " capricious"
ಒ
ಒ . 5 USCA § 706 (2) ( ).
77. "RFROD NOR. . . EEOC ' ' "
"- ' '
/ " /
" /
" " "
ಒ .
, 529 F.3d 763 (. 6 2008) ಒ -
capricious ,
ಒ ,
implausible
ಒ ...
....
capricious ಒ
ಒ canvass
; ,
.
Philpot, 130 SW3d 560 (2004) - ಒ
ಒ ;
....
ಒ
,
ಒ
ಒ
.
Gashgai , 390 A.2d 1080 (1978) -
.