SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 3
Case Five  Fourteenth Court of Appeals  CITY OF HOUSTON, et al., Plantiffs-Appellants,  v. GERALD KALLINA, Defendant-Appellee   No. 98-15946 LITIGANTS  Plantiffs-Appellants: CITY of HOUSTON. et. al  Defendant-Appellee: GERALD KALLINA  BACKGROUND  Kallina worked as division manager in the fixed-asset department of the City of Houston.  In the course of his duties, he conducted an inventory audit at a City warehouse where both abandoned and City-owned assets were stored.  It was his opinion that 800 items worth at least $400,000 were missing, and he concluded they must have been stolen.  According to Kallina, he initially made an oral report of his findings to his supervisor, Lathenia Harris.  He believed City policy required missing assets to be reported as stolen if not located after a thirty-day search, and eventually reported to the Mayor, the Controller, and perhaps City Council.  Shortly after Kallina put his final report on Harris=s desk, she abruptly informed him he had two days to resign or he would be fired.  He complied, but later sued.   FACTS   The City of Houston appeals from a judgment awarding $250,000 plus attorney=s fees to its former employee, Gerald Kallina, under the Texas Whistleblower Act.  On February 14, 2002, a panel of this Court modified the judgment by adding to it $65,000 in back pay,  and otherwise affirmed.  On May 9, 2002, the Supreme Court of Texas issued its opinion in Texas Department of Transportation v. Needham, 82 S.W.3d 314, (Tex. 2002), addressing for the first time the 1995 amendments defining Aan appropriate law enforcement authority@ under the Act.  See Act of May 25, 1995, 74th Leg., R.S. ch. 721, '' 1-12, 1995 Tex. Gen. Laws 3812 (current version at Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(b)).  We granted the City=s motion for rehearing en banc to consider the effect of the latter opinion on the former.  Finding that this new authority requires a different result, we withdraw the panel=s opinion and issue this en banc opinion.  DECISION  As an initial matter, the City argues the trial court lacked subject matter jurisdiction because Kallina did not initiate a grievance with the City as required.  See Tex.  Gov=t Code ' 554.006(a).  Assuming this requirement is jurisdictional, we hold it does not bar Kallina=s suit.   On January 19, 1998, Kallina sent a letter to Mayor Lee Brown claiming wrongful dismissal and requesting a hearing.  The City's response on February 16, 1998 stated Kallina 
had no civil service protection or other internal review procedure,
 pointing to a city document in which he acknowledged that he was an executive level employee and therefore exempt from all civil service protections and procedures.   A governmental entity may not frustrate an employee=s efforts to initiate a grievance and then challenge subject-matter jurisdiction on that basis.  Kallina's letter to the City stating his claim was sufficient to initiate a grievance in light of the City=s response that no other procedures applied to him.  The City=s first point is overruled.  DICTA  The Whistleblower Act prohibits termination of a government employee who in good faith reports a violation of law by the employing governmental entity or another public employee to an appropriate law enforcement authority.@  Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(a).  The Act defines the latter as a  governmental entity . . . that the employee in good faith believes is authorized to regulate under or enforce the law alleged to be violated in the report; or investigate or prosecute a violation of criminal law.@  Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(b).  Although the City and Kallina raised a number of other issues, we address only the City=s assertion that Kallina=s report to Harris did not fall within the scope of this definition.    IMPLICATIONS  The evidence strongly supports the jury=s finding that Kallina believed in good faith that Harris was an appropriate law enforcement authority as to the fixed-asset policies.  As the majority correctly states, the evidence showed that Harris had administrative responsibility for the assets in the Broad Street Warehouse and that she regulated and enforced departmental rules for protecting those assets.  Harris testified that she enforces the rules regarding inventory and that if somebody has a problem with these rules he can come to her about it.  Kallina and Harris both testified that Harris had the authority to enforce these policies regarding the inventory at the Broad Street Warehouse.  Considering the evidence in a light that tends to support the jury=s findings and disregarding all evidence and inferences to the contrary, there was legally sufficient evidence to support the jury=s finding that Kallina believed in good faith Harris was authorized to regulate under or enforce the fixed-asset policies and that this belief was reasonable in light of Kallina=s training and experience. 
City of Houston Appeals Whistleblower Act Judgment for Fired Division Manager
City of Houston Appeals Whistleblower Act Judgment for Fired Division Manager

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...
Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...
Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...William Kritsonis
 
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD   Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD William Kritsonis
 
Parents as leaders
Parents as leadersParents as leaders
Parents as leadersakshay wal
 
Word Press Power Point
Word Press Power PointWord Press Power Point
Word Press Power PointLisa Sjogren
 
E Maturity - From Theory to Practice
E Maturity - From Theory to PracticeE Maturity - From Theory to Practice
E Maturity - From Theory to PracticePeter Micheuz
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.William Kritsonis
 
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2Teresa Pelkie
 
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...William Kritsonis
 
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961Jamie Davies
 
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan Kritsonis
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan KritsonisCh 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan Kritsonis
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan KritsonisWilliam Kritsonis
 
Tecnologia Comunicacio2
Tecnologia Comunicacio2Tecnologia Comunicacio2
Tecnologia Comunicacio2Pedro Pablo
 
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg, Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg,   Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg,   Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg, Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...William Kritsonis
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...William Kritsonis
 
Ips Quotes 2
Ips Quotes 2Ips Quotes 2
Ips Quotes 2ips08
 
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evicted
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evictedTear gas and rubber bullets as families evicted
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evictedCAFOD
 
Mrs Lovdahls Class Procedures
Mrs Lovdahls Class ProceduresMrs Lovdahls Class Procedures
Mrs Lovdahls Class ProceduresStacy Lovdahl
 

Destacado (20)

Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...
Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...
Rebecca Duong, PhD Proposal Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertatio...
 
Isaiah 55
Isaiah 55Isaiah 55
Isaiah 55
 
Nature
NatureNature
Nature
 
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD   Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Due Process PPT. - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
 
Parents as leaders
Parents as leadersParents as leaders
Parents as leaders
 
Word Press Power Point
Word Press Power PointWord Press Power Point
Word Press Power Point
 
E Maturity - From Theory to Practice
E Maturity - From Theory to PracticeE Maturity - From Theory to Practice
E Maturity - From Theory to Practice
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis - Expression & Associational Rights PPT.
 
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2
CSIS 138 JavaScript Class2
 
Peer To Peer Coding
Peer To Peer CodingPeer To Peer Coding
Peer To Peer Coding
 
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...
NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A Group of National Refereed Journals on the Leadin...
 
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961
Week 5 Data Types and Gottesman and Shields 1961
 
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan Kritsonis
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan KritsonisCh 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan Kritsonis
Ch 15 Legalities Affecting Schooling - Dr. William Allan Kritsonis
 
Tecnologia Comunicacio2
Tecnologia Comunicacio2Tecnologia Comunicacio2
Tecnologia Comunicacio2
 
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg, Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg,   Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg,   Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...
Dr. Fred C. Lunenburg, Escalation of Commitment - Published in the INTERNAT...
 
Sahya Part 2
Sahya Part 2Sahya Part 2
Sahya Part 2
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Jennifer T. Butcher, Diss...
 
Ips Quotes 2
Ips Quotes 2Ips Quotes 2
Ips Quotes 2
 
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evicted
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evictedTear gas and rubber bullets as families evicted
Tear gas and rubber bullets as families evicted
 
Mrs Lovdahls Class Procedures
Mrs Lovdahls Class ProceduresMrs Lovdahls Class Procedures
Mrs Lovdahls Class Procedures
 

Similar a City of Houston Appeals Whistleblower Act Judgment for Fired Division Manager

171478120 tax-cases-1
171478120 tax-cases-1171478120 tax-cases-1
171478120 tax-cases-1homeworkping8
 
152689209 lei-case1-2tax
152689209 lei-case1-2tax152689209 lei-case1-2tax
152689209 lei-case1-2taxhomeworkping4
 
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...Elliot Engstrom
 
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016Bert M
 
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0Daniel Alouidor
 
Henne v. City of Yakima client alert
Henne v. City of Yakima client alertHenne v. City of Yakima client alert
Henne v. City of Yakima client alertJohn Drake
 
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panelDavid Leviss
 
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...Alex Baulf
 
Christian Schussele Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docx
Christian Schussele  Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docxChristian Schussele  Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docx
Christian Schussele Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docxtroutmanboris
 
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)Daniel Alouidor
 
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARIAMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARIFinni Rice
 
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdf
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdfAlicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdf
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdfElleAlamo
 
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional Courts
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional CourtsThe Pros And Cons Of Constitutional Courts
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional CourtsMelissa Luster
 
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...Gordon Smith
 
Cases that changed the conduct of business
Cases that changed the conduct of businessCases that changed the conduct of business
Cases that changed the conduct of businessCheapestPapers
 
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...Kevin O'Shea
 

Similar a City of Houston Appeals Whistleblower Act Judgment for Fired Division Manager (20)

171478120 tax-cases-1
171478120 tax-cases-1171478120 tax-cases-1
171478120 tax-cases-1
 
November Newsletter
November NewsletterNovember Newsletter
November Newsletter
 
152689209 lei-case1-2tax
152689209 lei-case1-2tax152689209 lei-case1-2tax
152689209 lei-case1-2tax
 
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
 
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016
Case brief on Muhammad v. DCCSCD 5th Cir Titile VII 2007 PDF 2016
 
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.51.0
 
152603696 print1
152603696 print1152603696 print1
152603696 print1
 
Henne v. City of Yakima client alert
Henne v. City of Yakima client alertHenne v. City of Yakima client alert
Henne v. City of Yakima client alert
 
supreme court cases
supreme court casessupreme court cases
supreme court cases
 
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel
2015 ABA_Conference_Qui_Tam_Defenses_panel
 
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...
USA SALT Alert: South Dakota Supreme Court Holds Law Challenging Quill’s Phys...
 
Christian Schussele Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docx
Christian Schussele  Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docxChristian Schussele  Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docx
Christian Schussele Men of ProgressOil on canvas, 1862Coope.docx
 
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)
Gov.uscourts.nyed.427196.48.0 (1)
 
Reflection Memo
Reflection MemoReflection Memo
Reflection Memo
 
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARIAMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
AMENDED MOTION TO STRIKE OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
 
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdf
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdfAlicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdf
Alicias, Jr. v. Baclig, A.C. No. 9919, July 19, 2017, 813 PHIL 893-900.pdf
 
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional Courts
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional CourtsThe Pros And Cons Of Constitutional Courts
The Pros And Cons Of Constitutional Courts
 
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...
Executive summary: Local Government Authority to Enact Inclusionary Zoning in...
 
Cases that changed the conduct of business
Cases that changed the conduct of businessCases that changed the conduct of business
Cases that changed the conduct of business
 
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...
The Cost of Litigation: A Case Study, Business Law, Plymouth State University...
 

Último

Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingTechSoup
 
9548086042 for call girls in Indira Nagar with room service
9548086042  for call girls in Indira Nagar  with room service9548086042  for call girls in Indira Nagar  with room service
9548086042 for call girls in Indira Nagar with room servicediscovermytutordmt
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphThiyagu K
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxVS Mahajan Coaching Centre
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAssociation for Project Management
 
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDMeasures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDThiyagu K
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp 9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp  9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp  9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp 9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...Pooja Nehwal
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104misteraugie
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...EduSkills OECD
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinRaunakKeshri1
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...Sapna Thakur
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfciinovamais
 
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...fonyou31
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3JemimahLaneBuaron
 

Último (20)

Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
 
9548086042 for call girls in Indira Nagar with room service
9548086042  for call girls in Indira Nagar  with room service9548086042  for call girls in Indira Nagar  with room service
9548086042 for call girls in Indira Nagar with room service
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDMeasures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp 9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp  9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp  9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...
Russian Call Girls in Andheri Airport Mumbai WhatsApp 9167673311 💞 Full Nigh...
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
 
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...
BAG TECHNIQUE Bag technique-a tool making use of public health bag through wh...
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptxINDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
 
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 

City of Houston Appeals Whistleblower Act Judgment for Fired Division Manager

  • 1. Case Five Fourteenth Court of Appeals CITY OF HOUSTON, et al., Plantiffs-Appellants, v. GERALD KALLINA, Defendant-Appellee No. 98-15946 LITIGANTS Plantiffs-Appellants: CITY of HOUSTON. et. al Defendant-Appellee: GERALD KALLINA BACKGROUND Kallina worked as division manager in the fixed-asset department of the City of Houston.  In the course of his duties, he conducted an inventory audit at a City warehouse where both abandoned and City-owned assets were stored.  It was his opinion that 800 items worth at least $400,000 were missing, and he concluded they must have been stolen. According to Kallina, he initially made an oral report of his findings to his supervisor, Lathenia Harris.  He believed City policy required missing assets to be reported as stolen if not located after a thirty-day search, and eventually reported to the Mayor, the Controller, and perhaps City Council.  Shortly after Kallina put his final report on Harris=s desk, she abruptly informed him he had two days to resign or he would be fired.  He complied, but later sued. FACTS The City of Houston appeals from a judgment awarding $250,000 plus attorney=s fees to its former employee, Gerald Kallina, under the Texas Whistleblower Act.  On February 14, 2002, a panel of this Court modified the judgment by adding to it $65,000 in back pay,  and otherwise affirmed. On May 9, 2002, the Supreme Court of Texas issued its opinion in Texas Department of Transportation v. Needham, 82 S.W.3d 314, (Tex. 2002), addressing for the first time the 1995 amendments defining Aan appropriate law enforcement authority@ under the Act.  See Act of May 25, 1995, 74th Leg., R.S. ch. 721, '' 1-12, 1995 Tex. Gen. Laws 3812 (current version at Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(b)).  We granted the City=s motion for rehearing en banc to consider the effect of the latter opinion on the former.  Finding that this new authority requires a different result, we withdraw the panel=s opinion and issue this en banc opinion. DECISION As an initial matter, the City argues the trial court lacked subject matter jurisdiction because Kallina did not initiate a grievance with the City as required.  See Tex.  Gov=t Code ' 554.006(a).  Assuming this requirement is jurisdictional, we hold it does not bar Kallina=s suit.  On January 19, 1998, Kallina sent a letter to Mayor Lee Brown claiming wrongful dismissal and requesting a hearing.  The City's response on February 16, 1998 stated Kallina had no civil service protection or other internal review procedure, pointing to a city document in which he acknowledged that he was an executive level employee and therefore exempt from all civil service protections and procedures.  A governmental entity may not frustrate an employee=s efforts to initiate a grievance and then challenge subject-matter jurisdiction on that basis.  Kallina's letter to the City stating his claim was sufficient to initiate a grievance in light of the City=s response that no other procedures applied to him.  The City=s first point is overruled. DICTA The Whistleblower Act prohibits termination of a government employee who in good faith reports a violation of law by the employing governmental entity or another public employee to an appropriate law enforcement authority.@  Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(a).  The Act defines the latter as a governmental entity . . . that the employee in good faith believes is authorized to regulate under or enforce the law alleged to be violated in the report; or investigate or prosecute a violation of criminal law.@  Tex. Gov=t Code ' 554.002(b).  Although the City and Kallina raised a number of other issues, we address only the City=s assertion that Kallina=s report to Harris did not fall within the scope of this definition. IMPLICATIONS The evidence strongly supports the jury=s finding that Kallina believed in good faith that Harris was an appropriate law enforcement authority as to the fixed-asset policies.  As the majority correctly states, the evidence showed that Harris had administrative responsibility for the assets in the Broad Street Warehouse and that she regulated and enforced departmental rules for protecting those assets.  Harris testified that she enforces the rules regarding inventory and that if somebody has a problem with these rules he can come to her about it.  Kallina and Harris both testified that Harris had the authority to enforce these policies regarding the inventory at the Broad Street Warehouse.  Considering the evidence in a light that tends to support the jury=s findings and disregarding all evidence and inferences to the contrary, there was legally sufficient evidence to support the jury=s finding that Kallina believed in good faith Harris was authorized to regulate under or enforce the fixed-asset policies and that this belief was reasonable in light of Kallina=s training and experience.