1. Complete Streets
………Smart Commute for Smart and Safer Cities
Asst.Prof. Ar. Leela Immadisetty B’Arch, MURP
(2000 – 2005 Batch in AUCE)
2. Some facts to know….
• What is the main /highest category of ground cover in a
city?
ROADS/ STREETS
• Do you know what % it covers?
Aprrox. 25-30%
• What is multi modal transportation?
Traveling in Automotive(cars, scooters, Autorikshaws
etc)
Public Transit (Buses, trains, air transport, ships etc)
Walking, Biking
• Most commute includes one mode of transport from start
point to end point…that is???
Walking
• For that what infrastructure do we need?
Proper Sidewalks/ Pedestrian
pathways/Bikelanes/Walkways etc.
3. What are “complete” streets?
Complete Streets are designed and operated to
be safe and accessible for pedestrians, transit
riders, bicyclists, and drivers—all users,
regardless of age or ability.
4. What do “complete” streets look like?
Vary by local context
Typically include
sidewalks and safe
crossing points in
urban and suburban
areas
Typically include bike
lanes or path on busier
roads
Include texturized curb
ramps for wheelchair
users and visually
impaired
9. Benefits of Complete Streets
Safety
Accessibility and independence
Health
Family transportation cost savings
Economic development / tourism
Environment
Quality of life and vibrancy
10. Complete Streets can help:
Health
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System from the 2008
Minnesota Obesity Plan
25 percent of
Minnesotans are obese
and an additional 37
percent are overweight
If left unchecked,
obesity could cost the
state $3.7 billion a
year by 2020
51 percent of
Minnesota adults do
not achieve
recommended physical
activity
Minnesota’s growing
obesity epidemic
11. Residents are 65% more likely to
walk in a neighborhood with
sidewalks
Cities with more bike lanes per
square mile have higher levels of
bicycle commuting
Complete Streets are
recommended by:
The Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention
Minnesota State Obesity Plan
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Minnesota, American Heart
Association, Minnesotans for
Healthy Kids Coalition, and
Minnesota Public Health
Association
Benefits: Health
12. Benefits: Health
Obesity is lower in places where people use bicycles,
public transportation, and their feet.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
U
SA
N
ew
Zealand
A
ustralia
Canada
Ireland
France
Finland
Italy
Spain
G
erm
any
Sweden
A
ustria
N
etherlands
Switzerland
D
enm
ark
PercentofObesity
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
PercentWalk,Bike,Transit
Obesity Walk, Bike, Transit
Pucher, “Walking and Cycling: Path to Improved Public Health,” Fit City Conference, NYC, June 2009
18. Why do we need Complete Streets?
500 Minnesota pedestrians
and bicyclists killed in the
last decade; more than
20,000 injured
Safety
19. Why do we need Complete Streets?
Access
40 percent of
Minnesotans do not
drive
20.
21. Current Situation in India
• India has been witnessing a sudden surge in the
number of cars on road.
• This trend has not only led to rise in traffic
problems, but a rise in number of road accidents
as well.
• A World Health Organisation (WHO) report has
found India's streets to be the most dangerous in
the world, where statistics show that aprox. 20
people are killed on the road every single hour.
28. Lets do planning and policies….
To provide political and community support for
architects, planners, engineers to design
“complete” streets
29. Why have a policy?
To change practice,
integrating the needs
of all road users into
everyday
transportation
planning and design
practices
Look to new road
construction,
reconstruction, and
repaving projects as
an opportunity
Include everything
from planning to
maintenance
30. Why have a policy?
To save
money: in
the long
run, retrofit
projects
always cost
more than
getting it
right the
first time
32. Getting started on Complete
Streets in your community
Most common process in Minnesota
1. Create the case for Complete Streets
2. Work group drafts a resolution of
support
3. Council/board approves resolution
4. Work group creates a full policy
5. Council/board approves policy
6. Implementation and reporting
33. Elements of a policy
1. Sets a vision.
2. Includes all modes.
3. Emphasizes connectivity.
4. Applies to all phases of all applicable
projects.
5. Specifies and limits exceptions, with
management approval required.
6. Uses latest design standards is flexible.
7. Is context-sensitive.
8. Sets performance standards.
9. Includes implementation steps.
Source: National Complete Streets Coalition
34. From policy to practice
An effective policy should prompt the
transportation planning agencies to:
restructure procedures, policies, and
programs
rewrite design manuals or standards (if
applicable)
offer training opportunities to planners and
engineers
create new performance measures
Source: National Complete Streets Coalition
This presentation was created by Ethan Fawley at Fresh Energy, a member of the Minnesota Complete Streets Coalition. Feel free to use with attribution. If you have any questions, you may contact Ethan at fawley@fresh-energy.org. Good luck with Complete Streets!
Photo of street in downtown Hastings (Dan Paterson)
STREETS in any cities take about 30% of the land area….
You start your commute with walking and end with walking.
Photos of 10th Avenue in Downtown Minneapolis (Ethan Fawley) and street in downtown Rosemount (Dan Paterson)
Grand Marais Main Street (left; Barb Thoman). Residential street in Minneapolis with low speeds and traffic volumes=fine for bikes and sidewalks for peds (top right; Ethan Fawley); rural road near Moorhead has paved shoulder and signs (lower right; Keely Hyland)
Stats from Trust for America's Health and Obesity and Future Health Care Costs, Blue Cross and
Blue Shield of Minnesota and the Minnesota Department of Health, 2008) and from the Minnesota Obesity Plan (2009)
Top picture is from Rochester (photo courtesy of Blue Cross and Blue Shield of MN)
Bottom picture is West Medicine Lake Drive in Plymouth (photo courtesy of Dorian Grilley)
Tremendous amount of evidence that when you put in sidewalks people will walk, and when you put in bike facilities, people will bike.
Sources: Giles-Corti, B., & Donovan, R.J. (2002). “The relative influence of individual, social, and physical environment determinants of physical activity.” Social Science & Medicine, 54 1793-1812.
Dill, Jennifer and Theresa Carr. (2003). “Bicycle Commuting and Facilities in Major US Cities: If You Build Them, Commuters Will Use Them.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, No. 1828, TRB, 2003, pp 116-123.
Special thanks to the National Complete Streets Coalition.
Source: Pucher, “Walking and Cycling: Path to Improved Public Health,” Fit City Conference, NYC, June 2009
(Special thanks to the National Complete Streets Coalition)
Photo from City of St. Peter
Photo from Minnesota Department of Transportation
Improvements include:
Curb extensions at intersections to reduce the crossing distance for pedestrians
Pedestrian medians to provide a refuge point for pedestrians and to make the road safer for drivers
Wider sidewalks
Additional street trees, benches, and other street furniture to support the pedestrian environment
Narrower car traffic lanes to reduce speeding and narrow the crossing distance
ADA-compliant curb ramps with truncated domes to serve visually impaired
Accessible Pedestrian Signals support access for people with disabilities
A conscious decision was made to improve the bicycling connections to an adjacent trail
Photo from Ethan Fawley
Franklin Avenue with wide sidewalks, curb ramps, three-lane road, more space for bicyclists, on-street parking, and better lighting and landscaping. Has lead to revitalization in the area, including the new bakery to the right and the new bank in the distance. Photo from Ethan Fawley.
Photo on left (from Barb Thoman) is from Hwy 41 in downtown Chaska, where an elderly man was hit and killed while trying to cross the street to attend mass at his local church. $540,000 in safety improvements are now planned for the street, but much of that money—and more importantly one man’s life—may have been saved if those safety considerations were part of the initial road design.
Photo on right (from Barb Thoman) is from Oakdale with 2-ft wide shoulders.
Photo on left from Cokato (Christine Goepfert); photo on right from Moorhead (Keely Hyland)
Data from the Federal Highway Administration
For many places during the last 60 years, road engineers have worked under the assumption that the public wants roads that maximize vehicle speed with few other considerations. Complete Streets gives talented engineers a new, more balanced, target. Instead of “move cars quickly” it becomes “provide safe mobility for all road users.” This shift allows engineers to unlock their knowledge and skills to help reach the new goal.
Picture is a rendering of Hwy 169 in St. Peter courtesy of the Minnesota Department of Transportation
Complete streets is as much a process as it is an outcome. A complete streets approach means changing expectations at the concept stage. It’s about planning ahead for your vision.
This point is also about operations and maintenance: making the vision applicable to all departments and agencies that work with the roadway. For example, thinking about older pedestrians when adjusting signal timing at intersections. It also helps in creating transit ready areas – providing the right-of-way improvements with transit goal in mind.
Special thanks to the National Complete Streets Coalition.
Early multi-modal scoping saves money by avoiding costly project delays. Without a policy, bicycle, pedestrian, and public transportation accommodations are often debated too late in the design process and are considered a disruption rather than necessary and beneficial project features. This creates expensive design revisions, time delays, and erodes public support. Furthermore, the failure to accommodate these user groups can trigger an expensive retrofit project at later date.
Photo and text courtesy of the National Complete Streets Coalition.
For more details, see the Minnesota Complete Streets Coalition’s
Local Government Toolkit (http://mncompletestreets.org/gfx/MnCSLocalGovtToolkit.pdf)
or Local Advocates Toolkit (http://mncompletestreets.org/gfx/MnCSLocalAdvocatesToolkit.pdf)
The elements of a policy merit a discussion all their own. For more information about each element, please visit http://www.completestreets.org/changing-policy/policy-elements/