2. Understanding SCF
Reverse Factoring
Towards an integrated platform
Alternative Business Models
Contents
2getting paid much earlier
3. SCF stands for a set of solutions that:
.. provides Early Payment to suppliers
.. lengthens Payment Terms for buyers
.. minimizes risk throughout chains
SCF is about managing Cash flows
getting paid much earlier 3
Supply Chain Finance optimizes cash flow throughout
value chains
4. Optimizing Cash Flow
T60 T30 T10
T10 T30 T60
sales
procurement
EP LP EP LP
S
T
R
E
S
S
S
T
R
E
S
S
getting paid much earlier 4
5. Reverse
Factoring
turning unpaid
invoices into cash
Invoice
Discounting
Factoring
the lender assumes
control of payment
collection from your
customers.
many variations exist .. it is sometimes
hard to distinguish between the two
concepts
Invoice Discounting vs Factoring
getting paid much earlier 5
6. A global $2 trillion dollar market
getting paid much earlier 6
Africa accounts for 1% of the global market
10. Buyer / Seller
Distributor
INV
$50
/30
Supplier
INV
$100
/30
LATE PAYMENT
SOLUTION
EARLY PAYMENT
SOLUTION
$97 /
DAY
2
FACTORING
SOLUTION
LATE PAYMENT
SOLUTION
Distributor FinancingSeller FinancingBuyer FinancingSupplier Financing
$47 /
DAY
2
$50 /
DAY
30
$100/
DAY
30
$103/
DAY
60
$53 /
DAY
60
Supply Chain Finance means different products
10getting paid much earlier
13. supplier
Buyer
B ?
Relationship Bank will only discount invoices for established (SME) clients
Verification Bank will need to assess status + standing of each BUYER
Confirmation Bank will need to confirm authenticity of each invoice
Value Bank will focus on larger tickets (in view of laborious process)
Margin Bank will maintain a buffer margin and only advance 60-80%
Recourse Bank will retain recourse on SUPPLIER (in case BUYER reneges)
SME Banking
client
The problem with Invoice Discounting
labour intensive process
fraud sensitive
Buyer
A
getting paid much earlier 13
14. Reverse Factoring started in the 80’s when the
automotive industry (Fiat) used it as a financing
tool for its suppliers;
Spain, lead by Banco Santander, was the market
where they picked up the concept (they call it
“confirming”) quickly. Today, the confirming
market makes up for 5,3% of the GDP of Spain;
About ten years ago, electronic platforms were
introduced in order to role out reverse factoring
on a large scale;
Nowadays, every major bank offers reverse
factoring and it is part of a broader Supply Chain
Finance program;
Supply Chain Finance is not just ‘another’
product …. it is totally focused Business Line
Another way
14getting paid much earlier
15. Supplier
B
Corporate Banking
client
Supplier
A
Supplier
C
Buyer
Reverse Factoring = Buyer driven
Relationship Bank will take BUYER relationship as starting point
Verification BUYER pre-approves invoices … verification no longer necessary
Confirmation BUYER allows Bank to make early payment on selected invoices
Value Bank works off SCF platform allowing large volumes + small tickets
Margin Bank will pay 100% of invoice to SUPPLIER (-/- discounted interest)
Recourse Bank will not retain recourse on SUPPLIER (but insure the exposure)
automated STP process
fraud significantly reduced
getting paid much earlier 15
16. Invoice Discounting Reverse Factoring
Seller-centric model;
One supplier > many buyers;
Risk is on supplier;
This is often a smaller SME;
Existing SME credit relationship;
Lack of control re ‘performance’;
Invoice discounted at margin.
Both models are similar in the sense that they:
- deal with a commercial relationship between Buyer and Seller;
- provide EARLY PAYMENT to suppliers of goods or services.
Same Product Different Risk
Buyer-centric model;
One buyer > many suppliers
Risk is on buyer;
This is often a Corporate client;
Existing CORP relationship;
Performance always confirmed;
Invoice discounted at face value.
getting paid much earlier 16
17. Advantage Supplier
Perspective
Quick & Easy funding (on-demand)
Get 100% funding of invoice
Control
Lower Financial costs
Unsecured borrowing
Cash Flow transparency
Alternative source of liquidity
No Investments
Automated, paperless solution
Free up
working capital
and improved
Financial position
17getting paid much earlier
18. Advantage Buyer
Perspective
Improve relationship with Suppliers
Improve Commercial Terms (discounts)
Competitive advantage
Cash Flow Predictability (Buyer Finance)
Reduce risk in the Supply Chain (loyalty)
Automated, paperless solution (costs)
Control
Sometimes: revenue share ! (cash)
Reduced Risk
in the
Supply Chain
18getting paid much earlier
19. Advantage Bank
Perspective
Eliminate laborious verification issues
Better Control & Less Work (Fraud)
Automated, paperless solution (Costs)
Cross Sell Opportunities (SMEs)
Strengthen Business Relationships
Utilization Credit Limits (Corp)
Turn-around-Time
Expand client base (SMEs or Farmers)
One Buyer
relationship
delivers hundreds
of new customers
19getting paid much earlier
21. Bank Considerations
21getting paid much earlier
What is needed for a successful SCF roll-out
1. A world-class scalable technology platform
2. An effective Business Model
3. A sensible product / risk strategy
4. A targeted marketing / sales strategy
5. 1st line help-desk support (for Buyers and Suppliers)
6. 2nd and 3rd line business and technical support (for Bank)
7. An onboarding methodology (for Suppliers & Buyers)
8. Training … and more training
22. Model 1: buy the IT solution
22getting paid much earlier
What is needed for a successful SCF roll-out
1. A world-class scalable technology platform
2. An effective Business Model
3. A sensible product / risk strategy
4. A targeted marketing/sales strategy
5. 1st line help-desk support (for Buyers and Suppliers)
6. 2nd and 3rd line business and technical support (for Bank)
7. An onboarding methodology (for Suppliers & Buyers)
8. Training … and more training
23. Model 2: go for a PaaS solution
23getting paid much earlier
What is needed for a successful SCF roll-out
1. A world-class scalable technology platform
2. An effective Business Model
3. A sensible product / risk strategy
4. A targeted marketing/sales strategy
5. 1st line help-desk support (for Buyers and Suppliers)
6. 2nd and 3rd line business and technical support (for Buyers, Suppliers)
7. An onboarding methodology (for Suppliers & Buyers)
8. Training … and more training
24. Model 3: go for a SaaS solution
24getting paid much earlier
What is needed for a successful SCF roll-out
1. A world-class scalable technology platform
2. An effective Business Model
3. A sensible product / risk strategy
4. A targeted marketing/sales strategy
5. 1st line help-desk support (for Buyers and Suppliers)
6. 2nd and 3rd line business and technical support (for Bank)
7. An onboarding methodology (for Suppliers & Buyers)
8. Training … and more training
25. Model 4: SCF partnering approach
25getting paid much earlier
What is needed for a successful SCF roll-out
1. A world-class scalable technology platform
2. An effective Business Model
3. A sensible product / risk strategy
4. A targeted marketing/sales strategy
5. 1st line help-desk support (for Buyers and Suppliers)
6. 2nd and 3rd line business and technical support (for Bank)
7. An onboarding methodology (for Suppliers & Buyers)
8. Training … and more training
26. Model 5: Our Prediction ….
26getting paid much earlier
Within 5 – 10 years
Totally accepted financing method
Multi-bankTrading Platforms (auction structure ?)
Non-bank financial providers
If you want to see the future, look at … South America
28. REASON EXPLANATION
1
DRIVE REVENUE
GROWTH
1 BUYER gives access to 10s/100s of SUPPLIERS
Compete against banks who do NOT deploy a system
Reverse Factoring = SME pricing @ CORP risk
2 SCALE
Large volume/ Small ticket transactions can only be
executed on a dedicated and automated platform
Enormous expansion of potential prospect market
3 OPERATIONALCOST
StraightThrough Processing (STP) reduces human
intervention (especially with volumes going up)
System is priced on SAAS basis : no write-offs
4 TAT
TAT reduced to “guaranteed next day payment”
If anything, this positively contributes to client retention
(loyalty factor)
8 reasons to roll-out a SCF platform …
28getting paid much earlier
29. REASON EXPLANATION
5 RISK
A structured programme approach offers excellent
opportunities to mitigate risk through credit portfolio
insurance (on both sides of the chain).
6 FRAUD
BUYER uploading approved invoices eliminates a very
laborious (and costly) verification process
Maker/Checker methodology applied throughout
7 INFORMATION
Capturing transactions on both ends of the Supply
Chain gives a true and holistic picture of client
performance
8 CONTROL
Bringing all product limits and sub-limits together for
BUYERS + associated SELLERS gives an unparalleled
sense of control
8 reasons to roll-out a SCF platform …
29getting paid much earlier
31. Conclusion: it’s all about predictability
“ … our biggest problem is the uncertainty, the
timing of Cash Flows ..
.. If we can somehow lock in predictability, we’d
be happy to pay a reasonable price for that …”
CEO
Comcraft Group
March 2015
31getting paid (much earlier