A presentation delivered by Jason Bernier, CBCL Limited on March 6, 2017 at the Sea Water Air Conditioning in the Caribbean Workshop at the Caribbean Development Bank.
2. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Overview
Environmental Permitting and Regulatory
Considerations
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
Environmental Data Gathering
Requirements to facilitate Project Design,
EIA and Permitting
Environmental Monitoring during
construction and operation
Construction Risk Considerations from an
Environmental Perspective
2
3. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Permitting & Regulatory Approvals
Jurisdiction Specific
Regulatory requirements are
predominantly defined based on
Project activities and the spatial and
temporal environment within which
they interact.
Objective is fundamentally to protect
the environment from significant
adverse effects.
3
4. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Environmental Impact Assessment
EIA is often required by
regulators as a means of
evaluating the project to
determine the potential for
significant adverse
environmental effects.
4
5. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
EIA is a process through which the
environmental impacts potentially resulting from
a proposed project are identified and assessed
early in the planning process.
EIA identifies steps that can be taken to avoid
negative environmental impacts or reduce them
to acceptable levels before they occur. EIA
therefore, represents a proactive, preventative
approach to environmental management and
protection.
5
Environmental Impact Assessment
6. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Initiation of EIA planning early
in project lifecycle
Define spatial and temporal
boundaries
Requires development of a
thorough Project Description
• Commencing during concept
development & finalized during
preliminary design
6
Environmental Impact Assessment
7. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Defining the Project
Project Description
• Defines the project
• Typically finalized when a
preliminary design is established
Used to determine data gathering
and field study requirements
Establishes a basis for Impact
Assessment
7
8. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
EIA
Data gathering to define
geophysical and biophysical
environment.
Often an iterative process,
commencing at a desktop and
database level, and progressing
to detailed field studies.
8
9. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Concept Development
Concept Development
Commences at Regional Level
Focuses in on Site Selection
Proposed Corridor Alignments
9
13. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Initial Planning
13
Regional level planning is the first planning phase
and identifying where regional level constraints
will occur.
Environmental biologists conduct a desktop
analysis using preexisting biological data.
During this phase, maps highlighting biological
constraints are developed. Maps assist to
minimize or avoid adverse environmental effects.
Examples of biological constraints to avoid could
include critical habitat, species at risk, and
migration routes.
16. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Bathymatry
16
Bathymetry surveys measure the depth of
water in oceans and other bodies of water. A
bathymetric chart is the submerged equivalent
of an above-water topographic map
Various methods can be used
• Single-Beam Soar
• Multi-Bean Sonar
• Sidescan Sonar
• LiDAR
21. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Environmental Baseline
Initiate project specific field
studies
Establish Existing
Environmental Conditions
21
22. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Field Surveys
Marine Resources
• Various studies
• Tides and Currents
• Water Quality and Temperature
• Marine Biota – Benthic and Pelagic
22
Terrestrial Resources
• Terrestrial Biota
• Describe topography, geology,
climate and air quality
23. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Studies
Shipping and Navigation
Fishing Operations
Military, Research & Recreation
Social & Economic Resources
Natural Hazards
• Hurricanes, Seismic, Flooding
Cumulative Effects
23
24. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
24
Coastal engineers would study the local wave climate
through a desktop analysis by running wave models.
Water Modelling
25. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Water Temperature
25
Important to ensure that water
temperature is consistent at the
intake location.
Water temperature should also
be recorded at discharge area.
Water temperature surveys
should occur for at least 1 year.
One survey example is to use a
fixed position temperature
sensor at specified depths.
26. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Water Quality
Preconstruction water quality samples should be
recorded. Parameters of interest can include:
• Salinity
• Density
• pH
• Dissolved Gases
• Nutrients
• Temperature
26
27. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Benthic Habitat Surveys
27
Marine Benthic Habitat Survey and
Shallow Water Surveys
Surveys are conducted by a
drop camera, scuba diver, or
ROV.
Underwater video spot checks
Underwater video transects
Analysis is conducted to
classify:
Depth
Substrate composition
Habitat type
Macrofauna and macroflora
28. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Benthic Habitat Surveys
28
Using video footage and
photographs, biologists are
able to identify:
Substrate composition
Habitat type
Species (plants and
animals)
Using data collected, habitat assessments can be
conducted to determine the function of each habitat.
30. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Benthic and Pelagic
30
The waters surrounding a Project area potentially provides
habitat for numerous aquatic and marine species, including
birds, fish, turtles, and marine mammals that are protected
by a variety of environmental regulations.
Need to describe the marine mammal species with possible or
known occurrence around the Project area.
31. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Pelagic
Biologists are able to determine which species may
occur within the Project area through:
• Conducting a desktop analysis of existing data (i.e.,
visual observations or acoustic detections)
• Identifying which species may occur based on the
habitat identified within the Project area.
31
33. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Terrestrial
33
Terrestrial sites need to be selected for:
• permanent district cooling plant
• temporary staging areas for project equipment (pipes)
34. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Terrestrial
34
In consultation with local regulators, biologists develop
survey protocols to collect baseline data and the presence
of unique, rare, or protected terrestrial biological resources.
Surveys for sensitive habitats such as wetlands, are
conducted. Wetland surveys consist of wetland
identification, delineation, and functional assessment.
35. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
35
Terrestrial
The presence of unique, rare or protected terrestrial
biological resources in the Project area will be identified
and investigated.
Critical habitat
Important nesting areas (i.e., sea turtles, birds)
Species at risk specific surveys (mammals, reptiles, birds,
vegetation)
Breeding bird surveys
Vegetation surveys
37. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Impact Assessment & Mitigation
37
After surveys are complete, we are now aware of
species and any sensitive habitat that occur within the
Project area.
Need to identify sensitive time periods (i.e., nesting,
breeding, peak periods) for species that occur within
the Project area. These periods not only dictate when
surveys need to be conducted but they guide the
planning for construction (times and periods to avoid).
Need to identify and evaluate potential Project effects
and to develop strategies to manage these effects
(mitigation).
38. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Impact Assessment
Typically when Preliminary Design has been
established
Design Alternates for specific elements are
developed
Assess how the project will interact with
existing environment
• Before, During, After construction
Identify Potential Adverse Impacts
• Direct & Indirect
38
40. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Impact Analysis
Impact considerations include:
Habitat Alteration, Disturbance,
Destruction
Critical Habitat
• Coral, Seagrass
Harassment and harm to
endangered and threatened
species
40
41. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Impact Analysis
Human Uses
• Traffic
• Fishing, Navigation
Social & Economic
Cultural and Archaeological
Visual Resources
Etc.
41
42. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Sea Water for Cooling
42
43. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Impact Assessment
Sea Water Circulation
• Cold deep water (4-6oC)
• High in nutrients
• Unique organisms
• Low Dissolved oxygen
• Discharge at (11-14oC)
• Into differing environmental
conditions
43
44. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
44
Water Modelling
To determine the placement and influence of the
outflow, effluent dispersion modelling is
conducted at ‘near field’ and at ‘far field’.
Near field: identifies the need for a diffuser.
Far field: identifies the large scale impact of the
plume (footprint).
The following slide illustrates effluent dispersion
modelling in 3D that was conducted in New
Brunswick, Canada.
46. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Mitigation
Development of Mitigation
Measures to prevent adverse
environmental impacts
Design Modifications
Monitoring Protocols
Avoidance
Compensation
46
47. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Mitigation and Monitoring example
SWAC project offshore Honolulu, HI.
During baseline assessments, biologists identified humpback
whales could occur within the vicinity of the Project area.
Marine Mammal Protection Act 1972 protects marine
mammals and permits for construction are required.
Pile driving activities could result in incidental harassment of
marine mammals.
To minimize impact on humpback whales, mitigation and
monitoring measures were developed.
47
48. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Mitigation example
Temporal restrictions – pile driving would not be conducted
between Dec 1 and March 31 as it is peak humpback whale
season in Hawaii and a humpback whale may occur within the
proposed Project area during that time.
Established an exclusion zone – developed a buffer zone
around the Project area. If a marine mammal enters this buffer
zone, operations must stop.
Pile driving shut down and delay procedures – have a
biologist observing for marine mammals approaching or entering
the exclusion zone. If a whale was observed approaching the
exclusion zone the biologist would inform the on-site manager
who would then delay pile driving until the marine mammal has
moved and a period of time has lapsed since the last sighting.
48
49. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
49
Monitoring example
At least one biologically-trained individual equipped with
specialized gear to effectively monitor marine mammals (high-
quality binoculars, range-finder) will be stationed on the pile
driving rig. The biologist will be responsible for monitoring the
buffer zones. Monitoring would occur 40mins prior to operations
and continue during work. Biologist would record all marine
mammal sightings and behavior.
In-situ underwater sound monitoring is required during pile
driving to facilitate compliance. Exposure to elevated sound levels
from vibratory and impact pile driving may result in temporary
impacts to marine mammal hearing and behavior and mask
naturally occurring sounds.
50. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Avoidance
Micro tunneling or directional drilling
to avoid sensitive near shore habitat
and constraints.
50
51. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Post - construction
51
Post construction monitoring required will be
determined through the regulatory process.
For example, post construction monitoring
may be deemed necessary by regulators at
the outflow location. Monitoring would
include water temperature and quality
measurements.
52. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Project Risk Considerations
Lack of integration between design
and environmental teams
Lack of early regulatory consultation
Public Perception
• Necessitates stakeholder engagement
and consultation
Presence of species at risk or critical
habitat
Habitat Compensation can be
significant
52
53. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Project Risk Considerations
Natural Hazards, e.g. Hurricanes, Flooding
Climate Change
Seismic, e.g. Underwater landslides
Staging and storage of significant lengths
of pipeline during construction
Transport and controlled sinking of
pipeline
Pipeline damage from marine vessel
operations, e.g. fishing, anchoring
53
54. Comprehensive Engineering and Environmental Consulting Services
Experience
Vision
Commitment
Project Risk Considerations
Disposal of excavated soils &
dredge spoils
• Contaminants
• Salt contamination in sediments
destined for upland disposal
Encountering archaeological
resources
Cumulative effects from
existing activities in the area
54