4. • Almost everyone has heard the saying, “If
you want to keep a friend, never talk about
religion or politics.” In regard to the
specific management of type 2 diabetes,
we can alter this phrase somewhat and
suggest, “If you want to keep a colleague,
never talk about diabetes guidelines!”
06:02:07
DIABETES CARE, VOLUME 35, JUNE 2012 1201
為了保有同事情誼
不要討論糖尿病治療指引
8. •糖尿病的藥物治療策略
1.依據證據醫學 ( 降血糖效果: A1C)
來選藥
2.依據病理生理學來矯正
3.Patient-Centered
ADA-EASD Position Statement
Management of Hyperglycemia in T2DM: A
Patient-Centered Approach
Diabetes Care April 2012
9. ADA consensus statement
DCCT and UKPDS : a strong correlation
between mean A1C levels over time and the
development and progression of retinopathy and
nephropathy
=> it is reasonable to judge and compare blood
glucose–lowering medications, as well as
combinations of such agents, primarily on the
basis of their capacity to decrease and maintain
A1C levels and according to their safety, specific
side effects, tolerability, ease of use, and
expense.
Diabetes Care 32:193–203, 2009
小血管病變的證據醫學:向 A1C 看齊
19. Figure 1
Diabetes Care, Diabetologia. 19 April 2012
(Adapted with permission from: Ismail-Beigi F, et al. Ann Intern Med 2011;154:554)
A1C 6-6.5% A1C 7.5-8%
25. KEY POINTS
• Glycemic targets & BG-lowering therapies must be
individualized.
• Diet, exercise, & education: foundation of any T2DM
therapy program
• Unless contraindicated, metformin = optimal 1st-line
drug.
• After metformin, data are limited.
with 1-2 other oral / injectable agents is reasonable;
minimize side effects.
• Ultimately, many patients will require insulin therapy
alone / in combination with other agents to maintain BG
control.
• All treatment decisions should be made in conjunction
with the patient (focus on preferences, needs & values.)
• Comprehensive CV risk reduction - a major focus of
therapy.
Diabetes Care, Diabetologia. 19 April 2012
Combination therapy
29. Adapted Recommendations: When Goal is to Avoid Weight Gain
• 血糖還是可以降不少
• 藥錢會花很大
• 但是賺到
• 不會低血糖
• 不會體重增加
• 保護 島細胞胰
不想變胖胖
錢花的 不值
得值 ?
30. Adapted Recommendations: When Goal is to Avoid Hypoglycemia
不要低血
糖
•血糖還是可以降不少
•藥錢會花很大
•但是賺到
•不會低血糖
•保護 島細胞胰
錢花得值
不 得值 ?
•TZD 增加體重、膀胱癌
(?)
31. Hazard Ratio
(HR lower
CL,
HR upper CL)
Hypoglycaemia – a major predictor of
cardiovascular death in the VADT study
Prior event
HbA1c
HDL
Age
3.116 (1.744, 5567)
1.213 (1.038,1.417)
0.699 (0.536, 0.910)
2.090 (1.518, 2877)
120 2 4 6 8 10
P Value
Hypoglycaemia 4.042 (1.449,11.276)
Duckworth W.(VADT): results. 2008. Available from
http://webcasts.prous.com/netadmin/webcast_viewer/Preview.aspx?
type=0&lid=3853, Accessed: 20 Oct 2009.
<0.01
0.02
0.01
<0.01
0.01
34. Metformin + other OADs 的降血糖效果
和低血糖風險
Adapted from: Phung, et al. JAMA. 2010;303(14):1410–1418
35. AACE 2010
Goals as priorities in the selection of medications
• Inclusion of major classes of FDA-approved glycemic
medication, including incretin-based therapies
• Minimizing risk and severity of hypoglycemia
• Minimizing risk and magnitude of weight gain
• Consideration of both fasting and postprandial
glucose levels as end points
• In many cases, delaying pharmacotherapy to allow for lifestyle
modifications is inappropriate because these interventions are usually not
adequate
• Consideration of total cost of therapy to the individual and
society at large, including costs related to medications, glucose monitoring
requirements, hypoglycemic events, drug-related adverse events, and
treatment of diabetes-associated complications
• The major cost is related to the treatment of the complications of diabetes. We
believe that identification of the safest and most efficacious agents is essential.
48. • Age: Older adults
– Reduced life expectancy
– Higher CVD burden
– Reduced GFR
– At risk for adverse events from polypharmacy
– More likely to be compromised from
hypoglycemia
Less ambitious target
HbA1c <7.5–8.0% if tighter targets not easily achieved
Focus on drug safety
Less ambitious target
HbA1c <7.5–8.0% if tighter targets not easily achieved
Focus on drug safety
49. 老人有沒有效?
a pooled analysis of five monotherapy trials comparing the effects of 24 weeks
of vildagliptin treatment in younger (<65 years, n = 1231) and older (>65 years, n
= 238) patients
Diabetes Obes Metab. 2011;13:55–64.
Depiction of the elements of decision-making used to determine appropriate efforts to achieve glycaemic targets. Greater concerns about a particular domain are represented by increasing height of the ramp. Thus, characteristics/predicaments towards the left justify more stringent efforts to lower HbA1c, whereas those towards the right are compatible with less stringent efforts. Where possible, such decisions should be made in conjunction with the patient, reflecting his or her preferences, needs and values. This ‘scale’ is not designed to be applied rigidly but to be used as a broad construct to help guide clinical decisions. Adapted with permission from Ismail-Beigi et al [ref 20]
Fig. 2C should be considered when the goal is to minimize costs. This reflects prevailing costs in the North America and Europe in early 2012; costs of certain drugs may vary considerably from country to country and as generic formulations become available.
Fig. 2A should be considered when the goal is to avoid hypoglycemia. Note that "hidden" agents may obviously still be used when required, but additional care is needed to avoid adverse events. Here, the risk of hypoglycemia when using the hidden agents will be, in part, dependent on the baseline degree of hyperglycemia, the treatment target, and the adequacy of patient education.
Fig. 2B should be considered when the goal is to avoid weight gain. Note that "hidden" agents may obviously still be used when required, but additional care is needed to avoid adverse events. Here, the chances of weight gain when using the hidden agents will be mitigated by more rigorous adherence to dietary recommendations and optimal dosing.
In the VADT study, hypoglycaemia, together with HbA 1c levels, HDL levels, age and a history of prior events, was a major predictor of cardiovascular mortality Reference: Duckworth W ( VADT): results. 2008. Available from http:// webcasts.prous.com/netadmin/webcast_viewer/Preview.aspx?type=0&lid=3853, Accessed: 20 Oct 2009.
Hypoglycemic events may trigger inflammation by inducing the release of C-reactive protein (CRP), IL-6, and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). Hypoglycemia also induces increased platelet and neutrophil activation. The sympathoadrenal response during hypoglycemia increases adrenaline secretion and may induce arrhythmias and increase cardiac workload. Underlying endothelial dysfunction leading to decreased vasodilation may also contribute to cardiovascular risk. Desouza CV et al. Hypoglycemia, Diabetes, and Cardiovascular Events. Diabetes Care. 2010; 33: 1389-1394.
Episodes of hypoglycemia, even asymptomatic episodes, impair defenses against subsequent hypoglycemia by causing hypoglycemia-associated autonomic failure (HAAF), the clinical syndromes of defective glucose counterregulation and hypoglycemia unawareness, and therefore a vicious cycle of recurrent hypoglycemia. The shift of the glycemic thresholds for sympathoadrenal responses to lower plasma glucose concentrations caused by recent antecedent hypoglycemia (or by sleep or prior exercise) could be the result of alterations in the peripheral afferent or efferent components of the autonomic nervous system or within the CNS. Cryer PE. Mechanisms of sympathoadrenal failure and hypoglycemia in diabetes. J. Clin. Invest. 2006;116:1470–1473
Model of ischemia-induced neovascularization in normal and high glucose. A, In the presence of normal glucose concentration, ischemia-stabilized HIF-1α forms heterodimers with ARNT which bind the coactivator p300. This complex binds to the hypoxia response element (HRE) and activates expression of genes required for neovascularization. B, High glucose–induced methylglyoxal (MG) modifies HIF-1α and p300, inhibiting complex binding to the HREs of genes required for neovascularization. Data are from Thangarajah et al34 and Ceradini et al.35 (Illustration Credit: Ben Smith/Cosmocyte).