2009 CAADRIA

1. Is An On-Virtu Digital Sketching Environment Cognitively Identical To In-Situ Free-Hand Sketching? Hsien-Hui Tang, Yu-Ying Lee, Wen-Ko Chiou National Taiwan University of Science and Technology & CGU

5. TWO ENVIRONMENTS [email_address]

6. Traditional Environment [email_address]

7. Digital Environment [email_address]

8. Setting Details [email_address] Traditional Envir. Digital Envir. Location Co-located Virtually Co-loacted Physically in two separate rooms Ultra VNC (Sharing Desktop) Communication Face-to-Face Virtually Face-to-Face MSN (Net Conferencing + extra LCD monitor Media Pen-and-Paper Digital Pen-and-Paper (Wacon Cintiq 21 + Alias Sketches Book Pro) Recording DV X 4 Camtasia + DV x 2 Name In-Situ On-Virtu

9. METHOD AND STEPS [email_address]

13. Coding Example [email_address] 1 2

14. STATISTICAL RESULTS [email_address]

16. FBS Result [email_address] Traditional Media Digital Media Team F B S F B S A 36 716 27 35 651 16 B 32 474 10 19 476 6 C 36 474 15 26 483 21 D 19 187 10 13 156 6 E 31 352 14 27 369 7 F 18 414 12 12 393 11 G 16 333 10 14 344 14 H 11 316 8 15 304 15 I 19 497 18 14 460 27 J 19 344 12 20 349 12

17. FMNR Result [email_address] Traditional Media Digital Media Team F M N R F M N R A 16 632 36 95 23 547 34 98 B 15 390 32 79 12 402 19 73 C 10 430 36 49 8 456 26 40 D 7 159 19 31 8 126 13 31 E 12 304 31 50 18 316 27 42 F 14 344 18 69 14 333 12 57 G 16 279 16 48 15 299 11 47 H 12 267 11 45 13 268 9 44 I 14 447 17 56 10 418 14 59 J 22 294 19 40 11 325 13 32