SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 152
Astronomy in Bharat-varsha*




       *the   ancient name of India
A presentation summarizing and based on
                 the publication
“Remarks on the astronomy of the Brahmins”

                    by
           John Playfair (FRSE, FRS)

           Transactions of the
       Royal Society of Edinburgh,
                   1790
motivation
 Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often
distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the
colonial agenda.
 Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often
distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the
colonial agenda.

 These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions
made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which
modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.
 Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often
distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the
colonial agenda.

 These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions
made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which
modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.

 A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left
by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful
observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for
gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.
 Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often
distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the
colonial agenda.

 These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions
made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which
modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.

 A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left
by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful
observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for
gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.

 A perusal of such records is necessary for dispelling stereotypical
notions and myths regarding ancient Bharat-Varsha.
 Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often
distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the
colonial agenda.

 These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions
made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which
modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.

 A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left
by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful
observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for
gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.

 A perusal of such records is necessary for dispelling stereotypical
notions and myths regarding ancient Bharat-Varsha.

 And hence, this discussion regarding the publication mentioned, is
meant to serve as a small step in this direction.
What this publication discusses
What this publication discusses

Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India
What this publication discusses

Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India


                          (1)

         Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe
What this publication discusses

Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India


                          (1)

         Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe

                          (2)

   Sent from Krishnapuram in about 1750 to Europe
What this publication discusses

Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India


                          (1)

         Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe

                          (2)

   Sent from Krishnapuram in about 1750 to Europe

                          (3)

     Brought from Tiruvallur in 1772 from Europe
An example of one of the tables from Krishnapuram




published in the book “Traité de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, by
M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
“From the materials furnished by Monsieur Le Gentil and
Monsieur Le Bailly, Mr. Playfair has gone even beyond those
authors, in establishing, by scientific proof, the originality of the
Hindoo astronomy, and its superior antiquity to any other that is
known.”


-Quentin Craufurd, ‘Sketches chiefly relating the history,
religion, learning, and manners, of the Hindoos’, Vol I, 1792.
some astronomical concepts
(1) Celestial Sphere
Celestial sphere- An imaginary sphere of arbitrarily large radius centered at the
earth, useful for describing positions of heavenly objects observed from the
earth.

Celestial coordinates- Coordinates used for describing the position of a
heavenly object on the celestial sphere.

Celestial equator- Intersection of the equatorial plane of the earth with the
celestial sphere.

Ecliptic- The circle on the celestial sphere in which the sun appears to revolve
around the earth in the course of a year. This motion is due to the orbital motion
of the earth around the sun. The ecliptic plane and the celestial equatorial plane
are tilted by about 23.50. This tilt is called obliquity of the ecliptic, and gives
rise to the seasonal variations.

Points of Equinox- The points where the ecliptic and the celestial equator
appear to intersect. This happens twice a year at diametrically opposite points of
the celestial sphere: once during spring (spring/vernal equinox) and once during
autumn (autumnal equinox).
(2) Precession of the equinoxes




 The direction of the earth’s axis of rotation itself precesses (rotates)
 about a direction perpendicular to the ecliptic plane tracing out a cone
 with semi-angle 23.5o. A full precession is completed in about 26,000 yrs.
Implications

Due to precession of the earth’s axis of rotation, every time the earth
completes one revolution around the sun, the orientation of the earth’s axis of
rotation, with respect to the sun, would have changed slightly.

This implies that the periodic change of the seasons occurs with a regularity
that is slightly different from the time taken by the earth to complete one
revolution around the sun, and this difference accumulates with time.

This leads us to two definitions of the year:

SIDEREAL YEAR and TROPICAL YEAR:
SIDEREAL YEAR:

The time taken by the earth to complete one revolution around the sun
with respect to the fixed stars.
SIDEREAL YEAR:

The time taken by the earth to complete one revolution around the sun
with respect to the fixed stars.



TROPICAL YEAR:

The time taken by the earth to return to the same cycle of seasons. It
can also be defined as the time required by the sun to traverse around
the ecliptic from, say, the vernal equinox and back again to the vernal
equinox, and thus returning back to the cycle of seasons.
 The sidereal year is longer than the tropical year by about 20 minutes. This
means that the vernal equinox shifts slightly westwards as seen from the
earth, with respect to the fixed stars, after each revolution of the sun along the
ecliptic.



 Earth's precession was historically called precession of the equinoxes
because the equinoxes move westward along the ecliptic relative to the fixed
stars, opposite to the motion of the Sun along the ecliptic.
The tables
What they contain:


Positions of the sun, moon and the planets on the celestial
sphere calculated for different times, and the times of eclipses.
Consequently, they give information on the ellipticity of the
earth’s and the moon’s motion, precession of the equinoxes,
and other details to a high level of precision.
Why they are special:
Why they are special:

 Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were
carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not
considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later
civilizations.
Why they are special:

 Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were
carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not
considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later
civilizations.


 Most of the predictions are in general agreement with
contemporary observations and theoretical calculations based
on the theory of gravitation.
Why they are special:

 Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were
carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not
considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later
civilizations.


 Most of the predictions are in general agreement with
contemporary observations and theoretical calculations based
on the theory of gravitation.


 Since predicting the positions of heavenly objects is a task
involving considerable complexity, these tables offer a
tantalizing glimpse into the level of mathematical sophistication
achieved in Bharat-Varsha, and as such point to the existence of
an age of which almost every vestige has been lost.
Some terms…
Some terms…

(1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are
carried out, and which serve as the reference for
calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future
instant of time.
Some terms…

(1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are
carried out, and which serve as the reference for
calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future
instant of time.

(2) Mean motion/position: This refers to position of a
heavenly object in the celestial sphere at a given instant in
time if its motion is subjected to no irregularities.
Some terms…

(1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are
carried out, and which serve as the reference for
calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future
instant of time.

(2) Mean motion/position: This refers to position of a
heavenly object in the celestial sphere at a given instant in
time if its motion is subjected to no irregularities.

(3) Correction: This refers to the correction, arising due
to irregularities, which must be added/subtracted to the
mean position of a heavenly object in order to obtain its
true position at a given instant of time. The irregularities
are caused by factors such as ellipticity of the orbits,
precession of the equinoxes, or perturbing effects of other
planets.
Thus the tables contain…
Thus the tables contain…




The mean positions for the sun, moon and the planets at
various times, the corrections that must be added to the
mean positions at the various times, and the rules for
adding these corrections depending on the time one wants
the position of a heavenly object.
The tables from Siam
The tables from Siam

Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French
astronomer Cassini.
The tables from Siam

Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French
astronomer Cassini.

Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by
Cassini.
The tables from Siam

Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French
astronomer Cassini.

Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by
Cassini.

Sidereal year according to the tables: 365d, 6h, 12’, 36” *
Tropical year according to the tablesϯ: 365d, 5h, 50’, 41” ϯϯ




*   d = days, h = hours, ( ’ ) = minutes, ( ” )=seconds.
ϯ Thus the equinoxes precess at a rate of once every 24,000 years, which is slightly more than
the current rate of once every 26,000 years.

ϯϯThe duration of the sidereal and tropical years is nearly the same in all the other tables, and
hence the rate of the precession of the equinoxes is about once in 24,000 years.
The tables from Siam

Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French
astronomer Cassini.

Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by
Cassini.

Sidereal year according to the tables: 365d, 6h, 12’, 36” *
Tropical year according to the tablesϯ: 365d, 5h, 50’, 41” ϯϯ

“This determination of the length of the year is but 1’, 53” greater than
that of De La Caille, which is a degree of accuracy beyond what is to be
found in the more ancient tables of our astronomy.” **


*   d = days, h = hours, ( ’ ) = minutes, ( ” )=seconds.
ϯ Thus the equinoxes precess at a rate of once every 24,000 years, which is slightly more than
the current rate of once every 26,000 years.

ϯϯThe duration of the sidereal and tropical years is nearly the same in all the other tables, and
hence the rate of the precession of the equinoxes is about once in 24,000 years.

**Statements within quotes, unless otherwise stated, should be understood as being directly
quoted from the article.
The tables from Siam


On the motion of the moon - I




According to the Siamese (and presumably other) tables, the
moon completes 235 revolutions with respect to the line joining
the earth and the sun* in a period of about 19 years. The
discovery of this so-called Metonic cycle is attributed to the
Greek astronomer Meton, even though Indian astronomy seems
to have been independently well aware of this fact.



*   i.e., 235 lunar months.
The tables from Siam

On the motion of the moon - II

According to these tables, the apogee* of the moon was in the beginning
of the moveable Zodiac 621 days after the epoch. This matches with
contemporary records to within a degree.

And from this point, the apogee of the moon is supposed to make an
entire revolution in the heavens in the space of 3232 days. This differs
from contemporary records only by 11h, 14’, 31”.

“and if it be considered that the apogee is an ideal point in the heavens
which even the eyes of an astronomer cannot directly perceive, to have
discovered its true motion, so nearly, argues no small correctness of
observation.”



* The apogee is the point where the moon is farthest from the earth. The motion is
slowest at the apogee.
The tables from Krishnapuram
The tables from Krishnapuram

Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see,
probably much older.
The tables from Krishnapuram

Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see,
probably much older.

“The places which they assign at that time (epoch) to the sun
and moon agree very well with the calculations made from the
tables of Mayer * and De La Caille.**”




* Tobias   Mayer (1723-1762), German astronomer famous for his tables of the moon.

** Abbé   Nicolas Louis de Lacaille (1713-1762), French astronomer.
The tables from Krishnapuram

Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see,
probably much older.

“The places which they assign at that time (epoch) to the sun
and moon agree very well with the calculations made from the
tables of Mayer * and De La Caille.**”

Equationϯ of the sun’s center: 2o, 10’, 30” ‡
Equation of the moon’s center: 5o, 2’, 47”




* Tobias   Mayer (1723-1762), German astronomer famous for his tables of the moon.

** Abbé   Nicolas Louis de Lacaille (1713-1762), French astronomer.

ϯThe equation of the center is, roughly speaking, a measure of the ellipticity of the orbit and is
measured in units of the angle.

‡ The angle is measured in units of degrees (o), minutes (’) and seconds (”) . One degree equals
sixty minutes and one minute equals sixty seconds.
The tables from Tiruvallur
Epoch:
Epoch:

3102 B.C.
Epoch:

         3102 B.C.

Commencement of the Kali Yuga
THE QUESTION:
GENUINE?
OR
FAKE?
The tables of Tiruvallur




“We must, therefore, enquire, whether this epoch is real or fictitious, that
is, whether it has been determined by actual observation, or has been
calculated from the modern epochs of the other tables. For it may
naturally be supposed, that the Brahmins, having made observations in
later times, or having borrowed from the astronomical knowledge of
other nations…have only calculated what they pretend that their
ancestors observed.”
The tables of Tiruvallur




“In doing this, however, the Brahmins must have furnished us with
means, almost infallible, of detecting their imposture. It is only for
astronomy, in its most perfect state, to go back to the distance of forty-
six centuries, and to ascertain the situation of the heavenly bodies at so
remote a period. The modern astronomy of Europe…could not venture on
so difficult a task, were it not assisted by the theory of gravitation, and
had not the integral calculus…been able, at last, to determine the
disturbances in our system, which arise from the action of the planets on
one another.”
The tables of Tiruvallur




“Unless the corrections for these disturbances be taken into account, any
system of astronomical tables, however accurate at the time of its
formation, and however diligently copied from the heavens, will be found
less exact for every instant, either before or after that time, and will
continually diverge more and more from the truth, both for future and
past ages.”
The tables of Tiruvallur




“…it may (therefore) be established as a maxim, that, if there be given a
system of astronomical tables, founded on observations of an unknown
date (epoch), that date may be found, by taking the time when the tables
represent the celestial motions most exactly.”

“Here, therefore, we have a criterion, by which we are to judge of the
pretensions of the Indian astronomy to so great antiquity.”
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.


                                According to the tables from Tiruvallur




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.


                                According to the tables from Tiruvallur




                              40’ minutes before the vernal equinox
                                          in 3102 B.C.




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.


                               According to contemporary calculations




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.


                               According to contemporary calculations


                                1) If the rate of precession of equinoxes
                                is assumed constant, it was 1o, 32’
                                before the vernal equinox in 3102 B.C.,
                                based on observations made in 1750.




Aldebaran
The tables of Tiruvallur

            The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.


                               According to contemporary calculations


                                1) If the rate of precession of equinoxes
                                is assumed constant, it was 1o, 32’
                                before the vernal equinox in 3102 B.C.,
                                based on observations made in 1750.


                                2) But the rate of precession of the
                                equinoxes is itself variable, as discovered
                                by La Grange, and “this result is to be
Aldebaran                       corrected…by the addition of 1o, 45’, 22”
                                to the longitude of Aldebaran, which
                                gives the longitude of that star 13’ from
                                the vernal equinox, at the time of the
                                Calyougham      (Kali-yugam),    agreeing,
                                within 53’, with the determination of the
                                Indian astronomy.”
The tables of Tiruvallur

                   The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.

“This agreement is the more remarkable, that the Brahmins, by their own
rules for computing the motion of the fixed stars, could not have
assigned this place to Aldebaran for the beginning of the Calyougham,
had they calculated it from a modern observation. For as they make the
motion of the fixed stars too great by more than 3” annually,* if they had
calculated backward from 1491, they would have placed the fixed stars
less advanced by 4o or 5o, at their ancient epoch, than they have actually
done.”




*i.e., the rate of precession of equinoxes is faster than the observed rate of once every 26,000
years in Indian astronomy.
The tables of Tiruvallur

                   The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.

“This agreement is the more remarkable, that the Brahmins, by their own
rules for computing the motion of the fixed stars, could not have
assigned this place to Aldebaran for the beginning of the Calyougham,
had they calculated it from a modern observation. For as they make the
motion of the fixed stars too great by more than 3” annually,* if they had
calculated backward from 1491, they would have placed the fixed stars
less advanced by 4o or 5o, at their ancient epoch, than they have actually
done.”

“This argument carries with it a great deal of force, and even were it the
only one we had to produce, it would render it, in a high degree,
probable, that the Indian Zodiac was as old as the Calyougham.”




*i.e., the rate of precession of equinoxes is faster than the observed rate of once every 26,000
years in Indian astronomy.
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


 According to the tables from Tiruvallur
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


 According to the tables from Tiruvallur




           10s, 3o, 38’, 13”

           (Mean position)
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


According to contemporary calculations
The tables of Tiruvallur

     The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


      According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes,
it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o,
5’, 57”.
The tables of Tiruvallur

     The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


      According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes,
it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o,
5’, 57”.

2) After adding the correction by La Grange due to the
variation in the rate of precession, it is 10s, 2o, 51’, 19”.
The tables of Tiruvallur

     The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.


      According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes,
it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o,
5’, 57”.

2) After adding the correction by La Grange due to the
variation in the rate of precession, it is 10s, 2o, 51’, 19”.


“…not more than 47’ from the radical place in the tables of
Tirvalore. This agreement is near enough to afford a strong
proof of the reality of the ancient epoch…”
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


 According to the tables from Tiruvallur
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


 According to the tables from Tiruvallur




              10s, 6o, 38’

           (Mean position)
The tables of Tiruvallur

The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


According to contemporary calculations
The tables of Tiruvallur

        The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


         According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its
mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’,
16”.
The tables of Tiruvallur

        The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


         According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its
mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’,
16”.

2) “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is
subject to a small, but uniform acceleration…the real mean
place of the moon, at the astronomical epoch of the
Calyougham…is therefore 10s, 6o, 37’ .”
The tables of Tiruvallur

        The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.


         According to contemporary calculations


1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its
mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’,
16”.

2) “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is
subject to a small, but uniform acceleration…the real mean
place of the moon, at the astronomical epoch of the
Calyougham…is therefore 10s, 6o, 37’ .”


“…a degree of accuracy that nothing but actual observation
could have produced.”
On the acceleration of the moon
On the acceleration of the moon

(according to data from Mayer’s tables)
On the acceleration of the moon

           (according to data from Mayer’s tables)




 “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is subject to
a small, but uniform acceleration, such, that her angular motion,
in any one age, is 9” greater than in the preceding, which in an
interval of 4801 years, must have amounted to 5o, 45’, 44”.
On the acceleration of the moon

(according to the theory of gravity)
On the acceleration of the moon

                         (according to the theory of gravity)

“…that acceleration…is a phenomenon, which M. De La Place* has, with
great ability, deduced from the principle of universal gravitation, and
shown to be necessarily connected with the changes in the eccentricity
of the earth’s orbit, discovered by M. De La Grange; so that the
acceleration of the moon is indirectly produced by the action of the
planets, which alternately increasing and diminishing the said
eccentricity, subjects the moon to different degrees of that force by
which the sun disturbs the time of her revolution around the earth. It is
therefore a periodical inequality, by which the moon’s motion in the
course of ages, will be as much retarded as accelerated; but its changes
are so slow, that her motion has been constantly accelerated, even for a
longer period than that to which the observations of India extend.”




*   Pierre-Simon, marquis de Laplace (1749-1827), French astronomer and mathematician.
On the acceleration of the moon

(according to the tables of Krishnapuram)
On the acceleration of the moon

            (according to the tables of Krishnapuram)

“The moon’s motion in 4383 years, 94 days, taken from those of
Chrisnabouram, is 3o, 2’, 10” less than in the tables of Tirvalore,
from which it is reasonable to conclude, with M. Bailly, that the
former are, in reality, more ancient than the latter…and hence also,
the tables of Chrisnabouram make the moon’s motion less than
Mayer’s, by the above mentioned interval, by 5o, 44’, 14”, which
therefore is, according to them, the quantity of the acceleration.”

 The angular motion of the moon predicted by the tables of
Krishnapuram for 4383 years, 94 days from the commencement of
the Kali Yuga, is 5o, 44’, 14”.

 The tables thus capture the subtle effects of the gravitational
force exerted by other planets on the motion of the moon.

 Antiquity of the Krishnapuram tables is probably even older than
those from Tiruvallur.
“…observations made in India, when all Europe was barbarous or
uninhabited, and investigations into the most subtle effects of
gravitation made in Europe, near five thousand years afterwards…
thus come in mutual support of one another.”
On the antiquity of the tables
On the antiquity of the tables

Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
  years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.

 However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement
with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the
commencement of the Kali-Yuga.
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.

 However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement
with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the
commencement of the Kali-Yuga.

 The three quantities are:
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.

 However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement
with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the
commencement of the Kali-Yuga.

 The three quantities are:

  1) The length of the tropical year,
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.

 However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement
with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the
commencement of the Kali-Yuga.

 The three quantities are:

  1) The length of the tropical year,

  2) The equation of the sun’s center, and
On the antiquity of the tables

   Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200
     years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga

 The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the
beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation
and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch
compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.

 However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement
with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the
commencement of the Kali-Yuga.

 The three quantities are:

  1) The length of the tropical year,

  2) The equation of the sun’s center, and

  3) The obliquity of the ecliptic.
On the antiquity of the tables

The length of the tropical year
On the antiquity of the tables

                     The length of the tropical year

 365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.
On the antiquity of the tables

                     The length of the tropical year

 365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.

 1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.
On the antiquity of the tables

                     The length of the tropical year

 365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.

 1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.

 But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,”
as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and
unequal alternations of diminution and increase.
On the antiquity of the tables

                     The length of the tropical year

 365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.

 1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.

 But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,”
as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and
unequal alternations of diminution and increase.

 “If we suppose these observations to have been made in that period of 2400
years, immediately preceding the Calyougham,…we shall find, that, at the middle
of this period, or 1200 years before the beginning of the Calyougham, the length
of the year was 365d, 5h, 50’, 41”, almost precisely as in the tables of Tirvalore.”
On the antiquity of the tables

                     The length of the tropical year

 365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.

 1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.

 But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,”
as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and
unequal alternations of diminution and increase.

 “If we suppose these observations to have been made in that period of 2400
years, immediately preceding the Calyougham,…we shall find, that, at the middle
of this period, or 1200 years before the beginning of the Calyougham, the length
of the year was 365d, 5h, 50’, 41”, almost precisely as in the tables of Tirvalore.”

 “And hence it is natural to conclude, that this determination of the solar year is
as ancient as the year 1200 before the Calyougham, or 4300 before the Christian
era.”
On the antiquity of the tables

The equation of the sun’s center
On the antiquity of the tables

                    The equation of the sun’s center

 Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.
On the antiquity of the tables

                    The equation of the sun’s center

 Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.

 Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than
in the Indian tables.
On the antiquity of the tables

                    The equation of the sun’s center

 Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.

 Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than
in the Indian tables.

 But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many
ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the
Indian tables.
On the antiquity of the tables

                    The equation of the sun’s center

 Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.

 Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than
in the Indian tables.

 But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many
ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the
Indian tables.

 But if calculated for 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga,
the agreement is still more exact.
On the antiquity of the tables

                    The equation of the sun’s center

 Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.

 Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than
in the Indian tables.

 But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many
ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the
Indian tables.

 But if calculated for 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga,
the agreement is still more exact.

 “1200 years before the commencement of that period (Kali-Yuga)…it appears,
by computing from M. De La Grange’s formula, that the equation of the sun’s
center was actually 2o, 8’, 16”, so that if the Indian astronomy be as old as that
period, its error with respect to this equation is but of 2’. ”
On the antiquity of the tables

Obliquity of the ecliptic
On the antiquity of the tables

                         Obliquity of the ecliptic

 The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary
European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.
On the antiquity of the tables

                         Obliquity of the ecliptic

 The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary
European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.

 But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the
equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of
the other planets.
On the antiquity of the tables

                          Obliquity of the ecliptic

 The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary
European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.

 But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the
equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of
the other planets.

 Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives
22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took
place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”,
short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”
On the antiquity of the tables

                          Obliquity of the ecliptic

 The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary
European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.

 But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the
equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of
the other planets.

 Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives
22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took
place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”,
short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”

 If the obliquity is calculated for 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, the
agreement is still more exact.
On the antiquity of the tables

                          Obliquity of the ecliptic

 The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary
European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.

 But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the
equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of
the other planets.

 Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives
22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took
place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”,
short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”

 If the obliquity is calculated for 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, the
agreement is still more exact.

 “But if we suppose, … , that the observations on which this determination is
founded, were made 1200 years before the Calyougham, we shall find that the
obliquity of the ecliptic was 23o, 53’, 45”, and that the error of the tables did not
much exceed 2’. ”
On the antiquity of the tables




 Thus three entirely independent elements separately answer to belong
to an age 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, or about 6300 years
from today. Too much to be a matter of chance!

 “This coincidence … cannot be the effect of chance…there is no other
alternative…but to acknowledge that the Indian astronomy is as ancient
as one, or other of the periods above mentioned.”
On the planets
On the planets


                       (1)

The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter
On the planets


                       (1)

The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter

                       (2)

         The equation of Saturn’s center
On the planets


                       (1)

The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter

                       (2)

         The equation of Saturn’s center

                       (3)

The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter
On the planets

          The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter

Retrograde motion: The apparent occasional motion of a planet opposite to that
usually observed, due to the projection of the planet’s motion on the celestial
sphere.




Aphelion: The point in a
planet’s orbit which is farthest
from the sun. The motion is
slowest at this point.




                              Figure illustrating the retrograde motion of the planets
On the planets

The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter
On the planets

           The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter


According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000
years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the
Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from
the equinox.
On the planets

           The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter


According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000
years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the
Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from
the equinox.

Calculating back from contemporary European records gives for the aphelion of
Jupiter in 3102 B.C. as 3s, 16o, 48’, 58”, “so that there would seem to be an error of
more than 10o in the tables of the Brahmins.”
On the planets

           The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter


According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000
years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the
Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from
the equinox.

Calculating back from contemporary European records gives for the aphelion of
Jupiter in 3102 B.C. as 3s, 16o, 48’, 58”, “so that there would seem to be an error of
more than 10o in the tables of the Brahmins.”

But Jupiter’s orbit is subject to great disturbances from the action of Saturn, which
the above calculation ignores. Including these disturbances (by making use of a
formula due to La Grange), gives for the aphelion of Jupiter at the beginning of Kali-
Yuga (3102 B.C.), as 3s, 26o, 50’, 40”, “which is but 10’, 40” different from the
tables of Krishnapuram.”
On the planets

The equation of Saturn’s center
On the planets

                    The equation of Saturn’s center




“The equation of Saturn’s center is an instance of the same kind. That
equation, at present, is according to M. De La Lande, 6o, 23’ 19”; and
hence, by means of one of the formulas above mentioned, M. Bailly
calculates, that, 3102 years before Christ, it was 7o, 41’, 22”. The tables
of the Brahmins make it 7o, 39’, 44”, which is less only by 1’, 38”, than
the preceding equation…”
On the planets

The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter
On the planets

                 The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter



“Since the publication of M. Bailly’s work*, two other instances of an exact
agreement, between the elements of these tables, and the conclusions
deduced from the theory of gravity, have been observed, and
communicated to him by M. De La Place, in a letter, inserted in the
Journal des Savans.”




*Traité   de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
On the planets

                 The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter



“Since the publication of M. Bailly’s work*, two other instances of an exact
agreement, between the elements of these tables, and the conclusions
deduced from the theory of gravity, have been observed, and
communicated to him by M. De La Place, in a letter, inserted in the
Journal des Savans.”

“M. De La Place has discovered, that there are inequalities belonging to
both these planets (Saturn and Jupiter), arising from their mutual action
on one another, which have long periods, one of them no less than 877
years; so that the mean motion must appear different, if it be determined
from observations made in different parts of those periods.”



*Traité   de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
On the planets

           The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter



Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair):
On the planets

           The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter



Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair):


“Now I find, by my theory, that at the Indian epoch of 3102 years before
Christ, the apparent and annual mean motion of Saturn was 12o, 13’, 14”,
and the Indian tables make it 12o, 13’, 13”. ”
On the planets

           The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter



Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair):


“Now I find, by my theory, that at the Indian epoch of 3102 years before
Christ, the apparent and annual mean motion of Saturn was 12o, 13’, 14”,
and the Indian tables make it 12o, 13’, 13”. ”

“In like manner, I find, that the annual and apparent mean motion of
Jupiter at that epoch was 30o, 20’, 42”, precisely as in the Indian
astronomy.”
General conclusions
General conclusions


 Astronomy in Bharat-Varsha goes back to at least 6300 years ago, and
its development had no influence from any other systems of astronomy
anywhere else in the world.


“It is …certain that the astronomy of the Brahmins is neither derived from
that of the Greeks, the Arabians, the Persians or the Tartars.”
General conclusions


 The principles underlying the rules for calculating the positions of
heavenly objects implies a high level mathematical sophistication, and
much of the geometry attributed to the Greeks has originated in India.
General conclusions

 This is certainly true of the theorem attributed to Pythagoras,* for the
method of calculating the duration of a lunar or solar eclipse according to
the Indian tables is based on this theorem.

“These operations (for finding the duration of eclipses) are all founded on
a very distinct conception of what happens in the case of an eclipse, and
on the knowledge of this theorem, that, in a right angled triangle, the
square of the hypotenuse is equal to the squares of the other two sides. It
is curious to find the theorem of Pythagoras in India, where, for aught we
know, it may have been discovered, and from whence that philosopher
may have derived some of the solid, as well as the visionary speculations,
with which he delighted to instruct or amuse his disciples.”


*The earliest mention of this theorem is to be found in the Sulbasutras credited to Bodhayana
(c. 800 B.C.), but it is clear from these astronomical tables that the knowledge of this theorem
was prevalent since much earlier.
General conclusions

 Regarding Pythagoras, it is interesting to note the following
remarks from another article:


“we know that he (Pythagoras) went to India to be instructed; but the
capacity of the learner determines his degree of proficiency, and if
Pythagoras on his return had so little knowledge in geometry as to
consider the forty-seventh of Euclid as a great discovery, he certainly was
entirely incapable of acquiring the Indian method of calculation, through
his deficiency of preparatory knowledge …

…each teacher, or head of sect that drew his knowledge from Indian
sources, might conceal his instructors to be reckoned an inventor.”


     -Reuben Burrow, ‘Hints concerning the observatory at Benares’ c. 1783.
General conclusions


 The principles underlying the rules for using the tables also supposes
a deep knowledge of trigonometry and spherical trigonometry. That these
were carried to a high level of perfection in Bharat-Varsha, is amply
demonstrated by the ancient Sanskrit texts, the Surya Siddhanta.*




*See, for example, John Playfair, “Observations on the trigonometrical tables of the Brahmins”,
Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Vol. IV. (1798).
General conclusions

 The classic problem of the quadrature of the circle, or the ratio of the
circumference to the diameter of the circle (commonly known as π), was
solved in India much before the Greek mathematicians, and to much
greater precision.*

“…the Hindoos suppose the diameter of a circle to be to its circumference
as 1250 to 3927, and where the author, who knew that this was more
accurate than the proportion of Archimedes, (7 to 22), … expresses his
astonishment, that among so simple a people, there should be found a
truth, which, among the wisest and most learned nations, had been
sought for in vain.”



*   Also see, “On the Hindu quadrature of the circle, and the infinite series of the proportion of
the circumference to the diameter exhibited in the four Sastras, the Tantra Sangraham, Yucti
Bhasha, Carana Padhati, and Sadratnamala”, by Charles M. Whish, published in the
Transactions of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, Vol. III (1835).
Comparison of the days of the week in the Indian system
and the European system




   (Table scanned from the book ‘Sketches chiefly relating the history,
   religion, learning, and manners, of the Hindoos’, Vol. I, by Quentin
   Craufurd, 1792. “the days are arranged exactly in the same order
   that has been adopted by the Europeans.”)
“If to this we add the great extent of geometrical knowledge requisite to
combine this, and the other principles of their astronomy together and to
deduce from them the just conclusions; the possession of a calculus
equivalent to trigonometry; and, lastly, their approximation to the
quadrature of the circle, we shall be astonished at the magnitude of that
body of science, which must have enlightened the inhabitants of India in
some remote age, and which, whatever it may have communicated to the
western nations, appears to have received nothing from them.”
Final reflections
Final reflections

 It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation
sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no
way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed,
considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in
making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.
Final reflections

 It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation
sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no
way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed,
considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in
making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.


 In spite of there being abundant evidence concerning the achievements
of Bharat-Varsha in the mathematics and the sciences, all references to
Indian science and technology have been either eliminated or ignored;
not just by the world at large, but by the majority of Indians themselves.
Final reflections

 It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation
sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no
way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed,
considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in
making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.


 In spite of there being abundant evidence concerning the achievements
of Bharat-Varsha in the mathematics and the sciences, all references to
Indian science and technology have been either eliminated or ignored;
not just by the world at large, but by the majority of Indians themselves.


 It is time to undo this damage by learning about the true history and
contributions of Bharat-Varsha, instead of depending on borrowed
histories and identities.
Acknowledgements

A deep sense of appreciation is expressed to Shri Dharampal (1922-
2006), for having compiled several publications on Indian science and
technology in the book, ‘Indian science and technology in the eighteenth
century’. The article discussed in this presentation is included in this
book.

This book, and several others, can be downloaded for free from the
website: www.samanvaya.com/dharampal/

Most of the references mentioned in this presentation are available for
free at www.books.google.com. The effort in making these documents
available to the general public is sincerely appreciated.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciences
The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciencesThe contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciences
The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciencesAin Atiya Azmi
 
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition: Characteristics and accomplishments
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition:  Characteristics and accomplishmentsAncient Indian astronomical tradition:  Characteristics and accomplishments
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition: Characteristics and accomplishmentsRajesh Kochhar
 
Muslim Contributions in Astronomy
Muslim Contributions in AstronomyMuslim Contributions in Astronomy
Muslim Contributions in AstronomyAli Usman
 
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHY
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHYCONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHY
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHYABDUL MUHAIMIN K
 
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh II
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh IIAstronomical Observatories of Jai Singh II
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh IIAjai Singh
 
Claudius ptolemy by sanjita
Claudius ptolemy  by sanjitaClaudius ptolemy  by sanjita
Claudius ptolemy by sanjitaSanjeetasamaddar
 
Astronomical event before the advent of telescope
Astronomical event before the advent of telescopeAstronomical event before the advent of telescope
Astronomical event before the advent of telescopeoryzasativa0720
 
Introduction to cosmology
Introduction to cosmologyIntroduction to cosmology
Introduction to cosmologyChristian Costa
 
Jantar Mantar
Jantar MantarJantar Mantar
Jantar MantarAnjani
 
History of astrology
History of astrologyHistory of astrology
History of astrologyEmilyn Ragasa
 
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the ages
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the agesSky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the ages
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the agesRajesh Kochhar
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Al BIRUNI
Al BIRUNI Al BIRUNI
Al BIRUNI
 
Jantar Mantar
Jantar MantarJantar Mantar
Jantar Mantar
 
The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciences
The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciencesThe contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciences
The contribution of muslim scholars in natural sciences
 
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition: Characteristics and accomplishments
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition:  Characteristics and accomplishmentsAncient Indian astronomical tradition:  Characteristics and accomplishments
Ancient Indian astronomical tradition: Characteristics and accomplishments
 
Muslim Contributions in Astronomy
Muslim Contributions in AstronomyMuslim Contributions in Astronomy
Muslim Contributions in Astronomy
 
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHY
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHYCONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHY
CONTRIBUTION OF ARABS IN TO GEOGRAPHY
 
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh II
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh IIAstronomical Observatories of Jai Singh II
Astronomical Observatories of Jai Singh II
 
Age of enlightenment astronomers
Age of enlightenment astronomersAge of enlightenment astronomers
Age of enlightenment astronomers
 
Claudius ptolemy by sanjita
Claudius ptolemy  by sanjitaClaudius ptolemy  by sanjita
Claudius ptolemy by sanjita
 
Orbital mechanics (1)
Orbital mechanics (1)Orbital mechanics (1)
Orbital mechanics (1)
 
Astronomical event before the advent of telescope
Astronomical event before the advent of telescopeAstronomical event before the advent of telescope
Astronomical event before the advent of telescope
 
The beginnings of astronomy
The beginnings of astronomyThe beginnings of astronomy
The beginnings of astronomy
 
Introduction to cosmology
Introduction to cosmologyIntroduction to cosmology
Introduction to cosmology
 
Jantar Mantar
Jantar MantarJantar Mantar
Jantar Mantar
 
Pythagoras(final)
Pythagoras(final)Pythagoras(final)
Pythagoras(final)
 
History Of Astronomy
History Of AstronomyHistory Of Astronomy
History Of Astronomy
 
Hari love sachin
Hari love sachinHari love sachin
Hari love sachin
 
History of astrology
History of astrologyHistory of astrology
History of astrology
 
Eratosthenes
EratosthenesEratosthenes
Eratosthenes
 
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the ages
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the agesSky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the ages
Sky as a bridge: Astronomical interactions in Eurasia through the ages
 

Destacado

Animal language
Animal languageAnimal language
Animal languagelisseth018
 
nursing home indicators of quality janis omeara
nursing home indicators of quality janis omearanursing home indicators of quality janis omeara
nursing home indicators of quality janis omearaJanis O'Meara
 
deepika_management information
deepika_management informationdeepika_management information
deepika_management informationDeepi Deepika
 
4406 4410.output
4406 4410.output4406 4410.output
4406 4410.outputj1075017
 
LIA-utvärdering, Fredrik
LIA-utvärdering, FredrikLIA-utvärdering, Fredrik
LIA-utvärdering, FredrikFredrik Krantz
 
dsharp_logo_page_2016_color
dsharp_logo_page_2016_colordsharp_logo_page_2016_color
dsharp_logo_page_2016_colorDaniel Sharp
 
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigma
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigmaSeminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigma
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigmaDeepi Deepika
 
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐzkagcda264
 
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215Maria Padilla
 
4431 4435.output
4431 4435.output4431 4435.output
4431 4435.outputj1075017
 
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more : The Leiden talk
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more  : The Leiden talkSocial Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more  : The Leiden talk
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more : The Leiden talkGuus van den Brekel
 
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017Maestría en Docencia Superior
 
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-bangaloreenvironment
 
Motions and seasons of earth
Motions and seasons of earthMotions and seasons of earth
Motions and seasons of earthUday Gupta
 

Destacado (20)

Animal language
Animal languageAnimal language
Animal language
 
nursing home indicators of quality janis omeara
nursing home indicators of quality janis omearanursing home indicators of quality janis omeara
nursing home indicators of quality janis omeara
 
deepika_management information
deepika_management informationdeepika_management information
deepika_management information
 
4406 4410.output
4406 4410.output4406 4410.output
4406 4410.output
 
LIA-utvärdering, Fredrik
LIA-utvärdering, FredrikLIA-utvärdering, Fredrik
LIA-utvärdering, Fredrik
 
Bataling Part III
Bataling Part IIIBataling Part III
Bataling Part III
 
dsharp_logo_page_2016_color
dsharp_logo_page_2016_colordsharp_logo_page_2016_color
dsharp_logo_page_2016_color
 
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigma
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigmaSeminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigma
Seminar 2 2_nd sem_deepika_six sigma
 
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ
해외카지노ゐ☆『JATA7.COM』☆ゐ
 
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215
Banker Info Flyer- Maria Hunter_0215
 
780045
780045780045
780045
 
4431 4435.output
4431 4435.output4431 4435.output
4431 4435.output
 
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more : The Leiden talk
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more  : The Leiden talkSocial Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more  : The Leiden talk
Social Media, Keeping up to date, Pure and more : The Leiden talk
 
780041
780041780041
780041
 
Initial client meeting
Initial client meetingInitial client meeting
Initial client meeting
 
Nivel del ingeniero
Nivel del ingenieroNivel del ingeniero
Nivel del ingeniero
 
Pruebas de campo ugc
Pruebas de campo ugcPruebas de campo ugc
Pruebas de campo ugc
 
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017
Lista de equipos clasificados de la RoboCupJunior Panamá 2017
 
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-
New ulsoor lake blog presentation by_kpk_-
 
Motions and seasons of earth
Motions and seasons of earthMotions and seasons of earth
Motions and seasons of earth
 

Similar a Astronomy in Bharat Varsha

Astronomy in ancient india
Astronomy in ancient indiaAstronomy in ancient india
Astronomy in ancient indiaBhaskar Kamble
 
1. ancient beliefs on astronomy
1. ancient beliefs on astronomy1. ancient beliefs on astronomy
1. ancient beliefs on astronomyMontecriZz
 
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptEarly Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptcarlmanaay
 
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptEarly Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptYaySandoval1
 
Early Observers Astronomers.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers.pptEarly Observers Astronomers.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers.pptcarlmanaay
 
History of Astronomy
History of AstronomyHistory of Astronomy
History of AstronomyBob Smullen
 
Discovering the Universe - Gravitiation
Discovering the Universe - GravitiationDiscovering the Universe - Gravitiation
Discovering the Universe - Gravitiationbrycetbolin
 
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdf
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdfIndian Astronomy PDF.pdf
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdfssuseracc76d
 
Ancient Astronomy.pptx
Ancient Astronomy.pptxAncient Astronomy.pptx
Ancient Astronomy.pptxDevsFusato
 
Guest lecture indian science i
Guest lecture indian science iGuest lecture indian science i
Guest lecture indian science iswasticcc
 
Heliocentric Theory By: Aristarchus
Heliocentric Theory By: AristarchusHeliocentric Theory By: Aristarchus
Heliocentric Theory By: AristarchusJovyMilanes
 
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02Asma Said,PhD
 
Transits of Venus and modern astronomy in India
Transits of Venus and modern  astronomy in IndiaTransits of Venus and modern  astronomy in India
Transits of Venus and modern astronomy in IndiaRajesh Kochhar
 
Astronomy lesson thursday
Astronomy lesson thursdayAstronomy lesson thursday
Astronomy lesson thursdayFelix Bunagan
 

Similar a Astronomy in Bharat Varsha (20)

Astronomy in ancient india
Astronomy in ancient indiaAstronomy in ancient india
Astronomy in ancient india
 
1. ancient beliefs on astronomy
1. ancient beliefs on astronomy1. ancient beliefs on astronomy
1. ancient beliefs on astronomy
 
ppt college.pptx
ppt  college.pptxppt  college.pptx
ppt college.pptx
 
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptEarly Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
 
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.pptEarly Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers ppt jshay v1.ppt
 
Early Observers Astronomers.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers.pptEarly Observers Astronomers.ppt
Early Observers Astronomers.ppt
 
History of Astronomy
History of AstronomyHistory of Astronomy
History of Astronomy
 
Astronomy by victor r
Astronomy by victor rAstronomy by victor r
Astronomy by victor r
 
AstronomyChapter1.pdf
AstronomyChapter1.pdfAstronomyChapter1.pdf
AstronomyChapter1.pdf
 
Discovering the Universe - Gravitiation
Discovering the Universe - GravitiationDiscovering the Universe - Gravitiation
Discovering the Universe - Gravitiation
 
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdf
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdfIndian Astronomy PDF.pdf
Indian Astronomy PDF.pdf
 
Ancient Astronomy.pptx
Ancient Astronomy.pptxAncient Astronomy.pptx
Ancient Astronomy.pptx
 
Guest lecture indian science i
Guest lecture indian science iGuest lecture indian science i
Guest lecture indian science i
 
Unit 4: Eratosthenes of Cyrene
Unit 4: Eratosthenes of CyreneUnit 4: Eratosthenes of Cyrene
Unit 4: Eratosthenes of Cyrene
 
Astronomy by Victor R. Oribe
Astronomy by Victor R. OribeAstronomy by Victor R. Oribe
Astronomy by Victor R. Oribe
 
Heliocentric Theory By: Aristarchus
Heliocentric Theory By: AristarchusHeliocentric Theory By: Aristarchus
Heliocentric Theory By: Aristarchus
 
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02
Dtu10e lecture ppt_ch02
 
Transits of Venus and modern astronomy in India
Transits of Venus and modern  astronomy in IndiaTransits of Venus and modern  astronomy in India
Transits of Venus and modern astronomy in India
 
Astronomy lesson thursday
Astronomy lesson thursdayAstronomy lesson thursday
Astronomy lesson thursday
 
Math
MathMath
Math
 

Último

Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024The Digital Insurer
 
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with NanonetsHow to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonetsnaman860154
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024The Digital Insurer
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024Rafal Los
 
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProduct Anonymous
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationSafe Software
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdfGenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdflior mazor
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonAnna Loughnan Colquhoun
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘RTylerCroy
 
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed textsHandwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed textsMaria Levchenko
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerThousandEyes
 
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organizationScaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organizationRadu Cotescu
 
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...Martijn de Jong
 
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)Gabriella Davis
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerThousandEyes
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationGenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationMichael W. Hawkins
 
Evaluating the top large language models.pdf
Evaluating the top large language models.pdfEvaluating the top large language models.pdf
Evaluating the top large language models.pdfChristopherTHyatt
 

Último (20)

Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
 
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with NanonetsHow to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
 
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
 
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdfGenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
GenAI Risks & Security Meetup 01052024.pdf
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
 
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed textsHandwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organizationScaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
 
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
 
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
 
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationGenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
 
Evaluating the top large language models.pdf
Evaluating the top large language models.pdfEvaluating the top large language models.pdf
Evaluating the top large language models.pdf
 

Astronomy in Bharat Varsha

  • 1. Astronomy in Bharat-varsha* *the ancient name of India
  • 2. A presentation summarizing and based on the publication “Remarks on the astronomy of the Brahmins” by John Playfair (FRSE, FRS) Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 1790
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 8.  Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the colonial agenda.
  • 9.  Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the colonial agenda.  These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.
  • 10.  Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the colonial agenda.  These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.  A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.
  • 11.  Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the colonial agenda.  These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.  A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.  A perusal of such records is necessary for dispelling stereotypical notions and myths regarding ancient Bharat-Varsha.
  • 12.  Modern day interpretations of ancient Bharat-Varsha (India) are often distorted by biases introduced by British colonizers, in line with the colonial agenda.  These interpretations obscure/ignore the fundamental contributions made by Bharat-Varsha to science and technology, and the debt which modern civilization owes to the Indian civilization.  A more unbiased and reliable picture emerges from the records left by early colonizers and scientists in the 18th century, by whom a careful observation of Indian society and traditions was undertaken, both for gathering technological know-how and for establishing political control.  A perusal of such records is necessary for dispelling stereotypical notions and myths regarding ancient Bharat-Varsha.  And hence, this discussion regarding the publication mentioned, is meant to serve as a small step in this direction.
  • 14. What this publication discusses Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India
  • 15. What this publication discusses Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India (1) Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe
  • 16. What this publication discusses Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India (1) Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe (2) Sent from Krishnapuram in about 1750 to Europe
  • 17. What this publication discusses Three sets of astronomical tables originating from India (1) Brought from Siam in 1687 to Europe (2) Sent from Krishnapuram in about 1750 to Europe (3) Brought from Tiruvallur in 1772 from Europe
  • 18. An example of one of the tables from Krishnapuram published in the book “Traité de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, by M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
  • 19. “From the materials furnished by Monsieur Le Gentil and Monsieur Le Bailly, Mr. Playfair has gone even beyond those authors, in establishing, by scientific proof, the originality of the Hindoo astronomy, and its superior antiquity to any other that is known.” -Quentin Craufurd, ‘Sketches chiefly relating the history, religion, learning, and manners, of the Hindoos’, Vol I, 1792.
  • 22. Celestial sphere- An imaginary sphere of arbitrarily large radius centered at the earth, useful for describing positions of heavenly objects observed from the earth. Celestial coordinates- Coordinates used for describing the position of a heavenly object on the celestial sphere. Celestial equator- Intersection of the equatorial plane of the earth with the celestial sphere. Ecliptic- The circle on the celestial sphere in which the sun appears to revolve around the earth in the course of a year. This motion is due to the orbital motion of the earth around the sun. The ecliptic plane and the celestial equatorial plane are tilted by about 23.50. This tilt is called obliquity of the ecliptic, and gives rise to the seasonal variations. Points of Equinox- The points where the ecliptic and the celestial equator appear to intersect. This happens twice a year at diametrically opposite points of the celestial sphere: once during spring (spring/vernal equinox) and once during autumn (autumnal equinox).
  • 23. (2) Precession of the equinoxes The direction of the earth’s axis of rotation itself precesses (rotates) about a direction perpendicular to the ecliptic plane tracing out a cone with semi-angle 23.5o. A full precession is completed in about 26,000 yrs.
  • 24. Implications Due to precession of the earth’s axis of rotation, every time the earth completes one revolution around the sun, the orientation of the earth’s axis of rotation, with respect to the sun, would have changed slightly. This implies that the periodic change of the seasons occurs with a regularity that is slightly different from the time taken by the earth to complete one revolution around the sun, and this difference accumulates with time. This leads us to two definitions of the year: SIDEREAL YEAR and TROPICAL YEAR:
  • 25. SIDEREAL YEAR: The time taken by the earth to complete one revolution around the sun with respect to the fixed stars.
  • 26. SIDEREAL YEAR: The time taken by the earth to complete one revolution around the sun with respect to the fixed stars. TROPICAL YEAR: The time taken by the earth to return to the same cycle of seasons. It can also be defined as the time required by the sun to traverse around the ecliptic from, say, the vernal equinox and back again to the vernal equinox, and thus returning back to the cycle of seasons.
  • 27.  The sidereal year is longer than the tropical year by about 20 minutes. This means that the vernal equinox shifts slightly westwards as seen from the earth, with respect to the fixed stars, after each revolution of the sun along the ecliptic.  Earth's precession was historically called precession of the equinoxes because the equinoxes move westward along the ecliptic relative to the fixed stars, opposite to the motion of the Sun along the ecliptic.
  • 29. What they contain: Positions of the sun, moon and the planets on the celestial sphere calculated for different times, and the times of eclipses. Consequently, they give information on the ellipticity of the earth’s and the moon’s motion, precession of the equinoxes, and other details to a high level of precision.
  • 30. Why they are special:
  • 31. Why they are special:  Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later civilizations.
  • 32. Why they are special:  Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later civilizations.  Most of the predictions are in general agreement with contemporary observations and theoretical calculations based on the theory of gravitation.
  • 33. Why they are special:  Offer solid evidence that astronomical observations were carried out in Bharata-Varsha at least 5000 years ago, if not considerably earlier, and with no inputs from any of the later civilizations.  Most of the predictions are in general agreement with contemporary observations and theoretical calculations based on the theory of gravitation.  Since predicting the positions of heavenly objects is a task involving considerable complexity, these tables offer a tantalizing glimpse into the level of mathematical sophistication achieved in Bharat-Varsha, and as such point to the existence of an age of which almost every vestige has been lost.
  • 35. Some terms… (1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are carried out, and which serve as the reference for calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future instant of time.
  • 36. Some terms… (1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are carried out, and which serve as the reference for calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future instant of time. (2) Mean motion/position: This refers to position of a heavenly object in the celestial sphere at a given instant in time if its motion is subjected to no irregularities.
  • 37. Some terms… (1) Epoch: The time at which actual observations are carried out, and which serve as the reference for calculating the positions of heavenly objects at a future instant of time. (2) Mean motion/position: This refers to position of a heavenly object in the celestial sphere at a given instant in time if its motion is subjected to no irregularities. (3) Correction: This refers to the correction, arising due to irregularities, which must be added/subtracted to the mean position of a heavenly object in order to obtain its true position at a given instant of time. The irregularities are caused by factors such as ellipticity of the orbits, precession of the equinoxes, or perturbing effects of other planets.
  • 38. Thus the tables contain…
  • 39. Thus the tables contain… The mean positions for the sun, moon and the planets at various times, the corrections that must be added to the mean positions at the various times, and the rules for adding these corrections depending on the time one wants the position of a heavenly object.
  • 41. The tables from Siam Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French astronomer Cassini.
  • 42. The tables from Siam Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French astronomer Cassini. Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by Cassini.
  • 43. The tables from Siam Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French astronomer Cassini. Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by Cassini. Sidereal year according to the tables: 365d, 6h, 12’, 36” * Tropical year according to the tablesϯ: 365d, 5h, 50’, 41” ϯϯ * d = days, h = hours, ( ’ ) = minutes, ( ” )=seconds. ϯ Thus the equinoxes precess at a rate of once every 24,000 years, which is slightly more than the current rate of once every 26,000 years. ϯϯThe duration of the sidereal and tropical years is nearly the same in all the other tables, and hence the rate of the precession of the equinoxes is about once in 24,000 years.
  • 44. The tables from Siam Originally meant for the location of Benares, as deduced by the French astronomer Cassini. Supposed epoch of the tables: 21st March, year 638, as deduced by Cassini. Sidereal year according to the tables: 365d, 6h, 12’, 36” * Tropical year according to the tablesϯ: 365d, 5h, 50’, 41” ϯϯ “This determination of the length of the year is but 1’, 53” greater than that of De La Caille, which is a degree of accuracy beyond what is to be found in the more ancient tables of our astronomy.” ** * d = days, h = hours, ( ’ ) = minutes, ( ” )=seconds. ϯ Thus the equinoxes precess at a rate of once every 24,000 years, which is slightly more than the current rate of once every 26,000 years. ϯϯThe duration of the sidereal and tropical years is nearly the same in all the other tables, and hence the rate of the precession of the equinoxes is about once in 24,000 years. **Statements within quotes, unless otherwise stated, should be understood as being directly quoted from the article.
  • 45. The tables from Siam On the motion of the moon - I According to the Siamese (and presumably other) tables, the moon completes 235 revolutions with respect to the line joining the earth and the sun* in a period of about 19 years. The discovery of this so-called Metonic cycle is attributed to the Greek astronomer Meton, even though Indian astronomy seems to have been independently well aware of this fact. * i.e., 235 lunar months.
  • 46. The tables from Siam On the motion of the moon - II According to these tables, the apogee* of the moon was in the beginning of the moveable Zodiac 621 days after the epoch. This matches with contemporary records to within a degree. And from this point, the apogee of the moon is supposed to make an entire revolution in the heavens in the space of 3232 days. This differs from contemporary records only by 11h, 14’, 31”. “and if it be considered that the apogee is an ideal point in the heavens which even the eyes of an astronomer cannot directly perceive, to have discovered its true motion, so nearly, argues no small correctness of observation.” * The apogee is the point where the moon is farthest from the earth. The motion is slowest at the apogee.
  • 47. The tables from Krishnapuram
  • 48. The tables from Krishnapuram Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see, probably much older.
  • 49. The tables from Krishnapuram Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see, probably much older. “The places which they assign at that time (epoch) to the sun and moon agree very well with the calculations made from the tables of Mayer * and De La Caille.**” * Tobias Mayer (1723-1762), German astronomer famous for his tables of the moon. ** Abbé Nicolas Louis de Lacaille (1713-1762), French astronomer.
  • 50. The tables from Krishnapuram Epoch: Supposed to be 10th March, 1491, but as we shall see, probably much older. “The places which they assign at that time (epoch) to the sun and moon agree very well with the calculations made from the tables of Mayer * and De La Caille.**” Equationϯ of the sun’s center: 2o, 10’, 30” ‡ Equation of the moon’s center: 5o, 2’, 47” * Tobias Mayer (1723-1762), German astronomer famous for his tables of the moon. ** Abbé Nicolas Louis de Lacaille (1713-1762), French astronomer. ϯThe equation of the center is, roughly speaking, a measure of the ellipticity of the orbit and is measured in units of the angle. ‡ The angle is measured in units of degrees (o), minutes (’) and seconds (”) . One degree equals sixty minutes and one minute equals sixty seconds.
  • 51. The tables from Tiruvallur
  • 54. Epoch: 3102 B.C. Commencement of the Kali Yuga
  • 57. OR
  • 58. FAKE?
  • 59. The tables of Tiruvallur “We must, therefore, enquire, whether this epoch is real or fictitious, that is, whether it has been determined by actual observation, or has been calculated from the modern epochs of the other tables. For it may naturally be supposed, that the Brahmins, having made observations in later times, or having borrowed from the astronomical knowledge of other nations…have only calculated what they pretend that their ancestors observed.”
  • 60. The tables of Tiruvallur “In doing this, however, the Brahmins must have furnished us with means, almost infallible, of detecting their imposture. It is only for astronomy, in its most perfect state, to go back to the distance of forty- six centuries, and to ascertain the situation of the heavenly bodies at so remote a period. The modern astronomy of Europe…could not venture on so difficult a task, were it not assisted by the theory of gravitation, and had not the integral calculus…been able, at last, to determine the disturbances in our system, which arise from the action of the planets on one another.”
  • 61. The tables of Tiruvallur “Unless the corrections for these disturbances be taken into account, any system of astronomical tables, however accurate at the time of its formation, and however diligently copied from the heavens, will be found less exact for every instant, either before or after that time, and will continually diverge more and more from the truth, both for future and past ages.”
  • 62. The tables of Tiruvallur “…it may (therefore) be established as a maxim, that, if there be given a system of astronomical tables, founded on observations of an unknown date (epoch), that date may be found, by taking the time when the tables represent the celestial motions most exactly.” “Here, therefore, we have a criterion, by which we are to judge of the pretensions of the Indian astronomy to so great antiquity.”
  • 63. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C.
  • 64. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. Aldebaran
  • 65. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur Aldebaran
  • 66. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur 40’ minutes before the vernal equinox in 3102 B.C. Aldebaran
  • 67. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. Aldebaran
  • 68. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations Aldebaran
  • 69. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) If the rate of precession of equinoxes is assumed constant, it was 1o, 32’ before the vernal equinox in 3102 B.C., based on observations made in 1750. Aldebaran
  • 70. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) If the rate of precession of equinoxes is assumed constant, it was 1o, 32’ before the vernal equinox in 3102 B.C., based on observations made in 1750. 2) But the rate of precession of the equinoxes is itself variable, as discovered by La Grange, and “this result is to be Aldebaran corrected…by the addition of 1o, 45’, 22” to the longitude of Aldebaran, which gives the longitude of that star 13’ from the vernal equinox, at the time of the Calyougham (Kali-yugam), agreeing, within 53’, with the determination of the Indian astronomy.”
  • 71. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. “This agreement is the more remarkable, that the Brahmins, by their own rules for computing the motion of the fixed stars, could not have assigned this place to Aldebaran for the beginning of the Calyougham, had they calculated it from a modern observation. For as they make the motion of the fixed stars too great by more than 3” annually,* if they had calculated backward from 1491, they would have placed the fixed stars less advanced by 4o or 5o, at their ancient epoch, than they have actually done.” *i.e., the rate of precession of equinoxes is faster than the observed rate of once every 26,000 years in Indian astronomy.
  • 72. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of Aldebaran in 3102 B.C. “This agreement is the more remarkable, that the Brahmins, by their own rules for computing the motion of the fixed stars, could not have assigned this place to Aldebaran for the beginning of the Calyougham, had they calculated it from a modern observation. For as they make the motion of the fixed stars too great by more than 3” annually,* if they had calculated backward from 1491, they would have placed the fixed stars less advanced by 4o or 5o, at their ancient epoch, than they have actually done.” “This argument carries with it a great deal of force, and even were it the only one we had to produce, it would render it, in a high degree, probable, that the Indian Zodiac was as old as the Calyougham.” *i.e., the rate of precession of equinoxes is faster than the observed rate of once every 26,000 years in Indian astronomy.
  • 73. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C.
  • 74. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur
  • 75. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur 10s, 3o, 38’, 13” (Mean position)
  • 76. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations
  • 77. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes, it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o, 5’, 57”.
  • 78. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes, it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o, 5’, 57”. 2) After adding the correction by La Grange due to the variation in the rate of precession, it is 10s, 2o, 51’, 19”.
  • 79. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Sun in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a uniform rate of precession of the equinoxes, it was, calculating back from later observations, at 10s, 1o, 5’, 57”. 2) After adding the correction by La Grange due to the variation in the rate of precession, it is 10s, 2o, 51’, 19”. “…not more than 47’ from the radical place in the tables of Tirvalore. This agreement is near enough to afford a strong proof of the reality of the ancient epoch…”
  • 80. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C.
  • 81. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur
  • 82. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to the tables from Tiruvallur 10s, 6o, 38’ (Mean position)
  • 83. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations
  • 84. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’, 16”.
  • 85. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’, 16”. 2) “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is subject to a small, but uniform acceleration…the real mean place of the moon, at the astronomical epoch of the Calyougham…is therefore 10s, 6o, 37’ .”
  • 86. The tables of Tiruvallur The location of the Moon in 3102 B.C. According to contemporary calculations 1) Assuming a constant rate of motion for the moon, its mean place, calculated by Mayer’s tables, is 10s, 0o, 51’, 16”. 2) “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is subject to a small, but uniform acceleration…the real mean place of the moon, at the astronomical epoch of the Calyougham…is therefore 10s, 6o, 37’ .” “…a degree of accuracy that nothing but actual observation could have produced.”
  • 87. On the acceleration of the moon
  • 88. On the acceleration of the moon (according to data from Mayer’s tables)
  • 89. On the acceleration of the moon (according to data from Mayer’s tables) “But, according to the same astronomer, the moon is subject to a small, but uniform acceleration, such, that her angular motion, in any one age, is 9” greater than in the preceding, which in an interval of 4801 years, must have amounted to 5o, 45’, 44”.
  • 90. On the acceleration of the moon (according to the theory of gravity)
  • 91. On the acceleration of the moon (according to the theory of gravity) “…that acceleration…is a phenomenon, which M. De La Place* has, with great ability, deduced from the principle of universal gravitation, and shown to be necessarily connected with the changes in the eccentricity of the earth’s orbit, discovered by M. De La Grange; so that the acceleration of the moon is indirectly produced by the action of the planets, which alternately increasing and diminishing the said eccentricity, subjects the moon to different degrees of that force by which the sun disturbs the time of her revolution around the earth. It is therefore a periodical inequality, by which the moon’s motion in the course of ages, will be as much retarded as accelerated; but its changes are so slow, that her motion has been constantly accelerated, even for a longer period than that to which the observations of India extend.” * Pierre-Simon, marquis de Laplace (1749-1827), French astronomer and mathematician.
  • 92. On the acceleration of the moon (according to the tables of Krishnapuram)
  • 93. On the acceleration of the moon (according to the tables of Krishnapuram) “The moon’s motion in 4383 years, 94 days, taken from those of Chrisnabouram, is 3o, 2’, 10” less than in the tables of Tirvalore, from which it is reasonable to conclude, with M. Bailly, that the former are, in reality, more ancient than the latter…and hence also, the tables of Chrisnabouram make the moon’s motion less than Mayer’s, by the above mentioned interval, by 5o, 44’, 14”, which therefore is, according to them, the quantity of the acceleration.”  The angular motion of the moon predicted by the tables of Krishnapuram for 4383 years, 94 days from the commencement of the Kali Yuga, is 5o, 44’, 14”.  The tables thus capture the subtle effects of the gravitational force exerted by other planets on the motion of the moon.  Antiquity of the Krishnapuram tables is probably even older than those from Tiruvallur.
  • 94. “…observations made in India, when all Europe was barbarous or uninhabited, and investigations into the most subtle effects of gravitation made in Europe, near five thousand years afterwards… thus come in mutual support of one another.”
  • 95. On the antiquity of the tables
  • 96. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga
  • 97. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.
  • 98. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.  However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga.
  • 99. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.  However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga.  The three quantities are:
  • 100. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.  However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga.  The three quantities are: 1) The length of the tropical year,
  • 101. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.  However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga.  The three quantities are: 1) The length of the tropical year, 2) The equation of the sun’s center, and
  • 102. On the antiquity of the tables Why it is highly probable that the tables go back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga  The values of three independent quantities, calculated back for the beginning of the Kali-Yuga (3102 B.C.), using the theory of gravitation and contemporary astronomical tables, show a slight mismatch compared to the values assigned to them in the Indian tables.  However, the same three quantities show a very good agreement with the Indian tables when calculated back to 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga.  The three quantities are: 1) The length of the tropical year, 2) The equation of the sun’s center, and 3) The obliquity of the ecliptic.
  • 103. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year
  • 104. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year  365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.
  • 105. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year  365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.  1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.
  • 106. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year  365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.  1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.  But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,” as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and unequal alternations of diminution and increase.
  • 107. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year  365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.  1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.  But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,” as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and unequal alternations of diminution and increase.  “If we suppose these observations to have been made in that period of 2400 years, immediately preceding the Calyougham,…we shall find, that, at the middle of this period, or 1200 years before the beginning of the Calyougham, the length of the year was 365d, 5h, 50’, 41”, almost precisely as in the tables of Tirvalore.”
  • 108. On the antiquity of the tables The length of the tropical year  365d, 5h, 50’, 35”, according to the tables from Tiruvallur.  1’, 46” longer than contemporary records.  But, “the tropical year was in reality longer at that time than it is at present,” as it is affected by the precession of the equinoxes and is subjected to slow and unequal alternations of diminution and increase.  “If we suppose these observations to have been made in that period of 2400 years, immediately preceding the Calyougham,…we shall find, that, at the middle of this period, or 1200 years before the beginning of the Calyougham, the length of the year was 365d, 5h, 50’, 41”, almost precisely as in the tables of Tirvalore.”  “And hence it is natural to conclude, that this determination of the solar year is as ancient as the year 1200 before the Calyougham, or 4300 before the Christian era.”
  • 109. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center
  • 110. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center  Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.
  • 111. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center  Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.  Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than in the Indian tables.
  • 112. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center  Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.  Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than in the Indian tables.  But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the Indian tables.
  • 113. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center  Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.  Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than in the Indian tables.  But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the Indian tables.  But if calculated for 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga, the agreement is still more exact.
  • 114. On the antiquity of the tables The equation of the sun’s center  Fixed in the tables at 2o, 10’, 32”.  Present value according to contemporary records: 1o, 551/₂’ , i.e., 15’ less than in the Indian tables.  But as shown by La Grange, the sun’s equation has been diminishing for many ages. In 3102 B.C., it was therefore 2o, 6’, 281/₂”, i.e., only 4’ less than in the Indian tables.  But if calculated for 1200 years before the commencement of the Kali-Yuga, the agreement is still more exact.  “1200 years before the commencement of that period (Kali-Yuga)…it appears, by computing from M. De La Grange’s formula, that the equation of the sun’s center was actually 2o, 8’, 16”, so that if the Indian astronomy be as old as that period, its error with respect to this equation is but of 2’. ”
  • 115. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic
  • 116. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic  The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.
  • 117. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic  The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.  But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of the other planets.
  • 118. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic  The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.  But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of the other planets.  Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives 22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”, short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”
  • 119. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic  The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.  But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of the other planets.  Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives 22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”, short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”  If the obliquity is calculated for 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, the agreement is still more exact.
  • 120. On the antiquity of the tables Obliquity of the ecliptic  The Indian tables take the obliquity of the ecliptic to be 24o. But contemporary European records in the year 1700 take it to be 23o, 28’, 41”.  But the obliquity itself, like the rate of precession of equinoxes, and the equation of the sun’s center, slowly varies with time due to perturbing effects of the other planets.  Therefore, “M. De La Grange’s formula for the variation of the obliquity, gives 22’, 32”, to be added to its obliquity in 1700, … , in order to have that which took place in the year 3102 before our era. This gives us 23o, 51’, 13”, which is 8’, 47”, short of the determination of the Indian astronomers.”  If the obliquity is calculated for 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, the agreement is still more exact.  “But if we suppose, … , that the observations on which this determination is founded, were made 1200 years before the Calyougham, we shall find that the obliquity of the ecliptic was 23o, 53’, 45”, and that the error of the tables did not much exceed 2’. ”
  • 121. On the antiquity of the tables  Thus three entirely independent elements separately answer to belong to an age 1200 years before the Kali-Yuga set in, or about 6300 years from today. Too much to be a matter of chance!  “This coincidence … cannot be the effect of chance…there is no other alternative…but to acknowledge that the Indian astronomy is as ancient as one, or other of the periods above mentioned.”
  • 123. On the planets (1) The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter
  • 124. On the planets (1) The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter (2) The equation of Saturn’s center
  • 125. On the planets (1) The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter (2) The equation of Saturn’s center (3) The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter
  • 126. On the planets The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter Retrograde motion: The apparent occasional motion of a planet opposite to that usually observed, due to the projection of the planet’s motion on the celestial sphere. Aphelion: The point in a planet’s orbit which is farthest from the sun. The motion is slowest at this point. Figure illustrating the retrograde motion of the planets
  • 127. On the planets The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter
  • 128. On the planets The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000 years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from the equinox.
  • 129. On the planets The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000 years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from the equinox. Calculating back from contemporary European records gives for the aphelion of Jupiter in 3102 B.C. as 3s, 16o, 48’, 58”, “so that there would seem to be an error of more than 10o in the tables of the Brahmins.”
  • 130. On the planets The retrograde motion and the aphelion of Jupiter According to the Indian tables, Jupiter has a retrograde motion of 15o in 200,000 years, and thus, calculating back from Jupiter’s position in 1491 as given in the Krishnapuram tables, its aphelion at the onset of Kali-Yuga was at 3s, 27o, 0’ from the equinox. Calculating back from contemporary European records gives for the aphelion of Jupiter in 3102 B.C. as 3s, 16o, 48’, 58”, “so that there would seem to be an error of more than 10o in the tables of the Brahmins.” But Jupiter’s orbit is subject to great disturbances from the action of Saturn, which the above calculation ignores. Including these disturbances (by making use of a formula due to La Grange), gives for the aphelion of Jupiter at the beginning of Kali- Yuga (3102 B.C.), as 3s, 26o, 50’, 40”, “which is but 10’, 40” different from the tables of Krishnapuram.”
  • 131. On the planets The equation of Saturn’s center
  • 132. On the planets The equation of Saturn’s center “The equation of Saturn’s center is an instance of the same kind. That equation, at present, is according to M. De La Lande, 6o, 23’ 19”; and hence, by means of one of the formulas above mentioned, M. Bailly calculates, that, 3102 years before Christ, it was 7o, 41’, 22”. The tables of the Brahmins make it 7o, 39’, 44”, which is less only by 1’, 38”, than the preceding equation…”
  • 133. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter
  • 134. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter “Since the publication of M. Bailly’s work*, two other instances of an exact agreement, between the elements of these tables, and the conclusions deduced from the theory of gravity, have been observed, and communicated to him by M. De La Place, in a letter, inserted in the Journal des Savans.” *Traité de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
  • 135. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter “Since the publication of M. Bailly’s work*, two other instances of an exact agreement, between the elements of these tables, and the conclusions deduced from the theory of gravity, have been observed, and communicated to him by M. De La Place, in a letter, inserted in the Journal des Savans.” “M. De La Place has discovered, that there are inequalities belonging to both these planets (Saturn and Jupiter), arising from their mutual action on one another, which have long periods, one of them no less than 877 years; so that the mean motion must appear different, if it be determined from observations made in different parts of those periods.” *Traité de l’astronomie Indienne et orientale”, M. Bailly, Paris, 1787.
  • 136. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair):
  • 137. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair): “Now I find, by my theory, that at the Indian epoch of 3102 years before Christ, the apparent and annual mean motion of Saturn was 12o, 13’, 14”, and the Indian tables make it 12o, 13’, 13”. ”
  • 138. On the planets The mutual interaction between Saturn and Jupiter Says M. De La Place (as quoted in the article by Playfair): “Now I find, by my theory, that at the Indian epoch of 3102 years before Christ, the apparent and annual mean motion of Saturn was 12o, 13’, 14”, and the Indian tables make it 12o, 13’, 13”. ” “In like manner, I find, that the annual and apparent mean motion of Jupiter at that epoch was 30o, 20’, 42”, precisely as in the Indian astronomy.”
  • 140. General conclusions  Astronomy in Bharat-Varsha goes back to at least 6300 years ago, and its development had no influence from any other systems of astronomy anywhere else in the world. “It is …certain that the astronomy of the Brahmins is neither derived from that of the Greeks, the Arabians, the Persians or the Tartars.”
  • 141. General conclusions  The principles underlying the rules for calculating the positions of heavenly objects implies a high level mathematical sophistication, and much of the geometry attributed to the Greeks has originated in India.
  • 142. General conclusions  This is certainly true of the theorem attributed to Pythagoras,* for the method of calculating the duration of a lunar or solar eclipse according to the Indian tables is based on this theorem. “These operations (for finding the duration of eclipses) are all founded on a very distinct conception of what happens in the case of an eclipse, and on the knowledge of this theorem, that, in a right angled triangle, the square of the hypotenuse is equal to the squares of the other two sides. It is curious to find the theorem of Pythagoras in India, where, for aught we know, it may have been discovered, and from whence that philosopher may have derived some of the solid, as well as the visionary speculations, with which he delighted to instruct or amuse his disciples.” *The earliest mention of this theorem is to be found in the Sulbasutras credited to Bodhayana (c. 800 B.C.), but it is clear from these astronomical tables that the knowledge of this theorem was prevalent since much earlier.
  • 143. General conclusions  Regarding Pythagoras, it is interesting to note the following remarks from another article: “we know that he (Pythagoras) went to India to be instructed; but the capacity of the learner determines his degree of proficiency, and if Pythagoras on his return had so little knowledge in geometry as to consider the forty-seventh of Euclid as a great discovery, he certainly was entirely incapable of acquiring the Indian method of calculation, through his deficiency of preparatory knowledge … …each teacher, or head of sect that drew his knowledge from Indian sources, might conceal his instructors to be reckoned an inventor.” -Reuben Burrow, ‘Hints concerning the observatory at Benares’ c. 1783.
  • 144. General conclusions  The principles underlying the rules for using the tables also supposes a deep knowledge of trigonometry and spherical trigonometry. That these were carried to a high level of perfection in Bharat-Varsha, is amply demonstrated by the ancient Sanskrit texts, the Surya Siddhanta.* *See, for example, John Playfair, “Observations on the trigonometrical tables of the Brahmins”, Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Vol. IV. (1798).
  • 145. General conclusions  The classic problem of the quadrature of the circle, or the ratio of the circumference to the diameter of the circle (commonly known as π), was solved in India much before the Greek mathematicians, and to much greater precision.* “…the Hindoos suppose the diameter of a circle to be to its circumference as 1250 to 3927, and where the author, who knew that this was more accurate than the proportion of Archimedes, (7 to 22), … expresses his astonishment, that among so simple a people, there should be found a truth, which, among the wisest and most learned nations, had been sought for in vain.” * Also see, “On the Hindu quadrature of the circle, and the infinite series of the proportion of the circumference to the diameter exhibited in the four Sastras, the Tantra Sangraham, Yucti Bhasha, Carana Padhati, and Sadratnamala”, by Charles M. Whish, published in the Transactions of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, Vol. III (1835).
  • 146. Comparison of the days of the week in the Indian system and the European system (Table scanned from the book ‘Sketches chiefly relating the history, religion, learning, and manners, of the Hindoos’, Vol. I, by Quentin Craufurd, 1792. “the days are arranged exactly in the same order that has been adopted by the Europeans.”)
  • 147. “If to this we add the great extent of geometrical knowledge requisite to combine this, and the other principles of their astronomy together and to deduce from them the just conclusions; the possession of a calculus equivalent to trigonometry; and, lastly, their approximation to the quadrature of the circle, we shall be astonished at the magnitude of that body of science, which must have enlightened the inhabitants of India in some remote age, and which, whatever it may have communicated to the western nations, appears to have received nothing from them.”
  • 149. Final reflections  It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed, considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.
  • 150. Final reflections  It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed, considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.  In spite of there being abundant evidence concerning the achievements of Bharat-Varsha in the mathematics and the sciences, all references to Indian science and technology have been either eliminated or ignored; not just by the world at large, but by the majority of Indians themselves.
  • 151. Final reflections  It should be noted that Playfair’s article discussed in this presentation sets only a lower limit for the antiquity of Indian astronomy, and in no way rules out the possibility that it could be much more ancient. Indeed, considering the level of mathematical and astronomical skills used in making these tables, this certainly seems to be the case.  In spite of there being abundant evidence concerning the achievements of Bharat-Varsha in the mathematics and the sciences, all references to Indian science and technology have been either eliminated or ignored; not just by the world at large, but by the majority of Indians themselves.  It is time to undo this damage by learning about the true history and contributions of Bharat-Varsha, instead of depending on borrowed histories and identities.
  • 152. Acknowledgements A deep sense of appreciation is expressed to Shri Dharampal (1922- 2006), for having compiled several publications on Indian science and technology in the book, ‘Indian science and technology in the eighteenth century’. The article discussed in this presentation is included in this book. This book, and several others, can be downloaded for free from the website: www.samanvaya.com/dharampal/ Most of the references mentioned in this presentation are available for free at www.books.google.com. The effort in making these documents available to the general public is sincerely appreciated.