This example also shows that some simple editing with EssayAudit can give a more satisfying read.

1. Reader Impact
High Paragraph Thinking Indices
Medium
Low
Most
analysis/opinion
Reader Impact
High Paragraph Thinking Indices
Medium
Low
Most
analysis/opinion
Original
Ancient Warfare (Vol. III Issue 2) dropped through my letterbox, and I immediately did
what I do with all magazines at first flick through quickly and look at the pictures. In the
minute or so it took me to do this, I could see that this was a magazine that I would read
cover to cover, review or no review pending. I was greeted by a series of detailed maps,
wonderful reconstruction paintings, detailed articles and mouth watering ads full of
enticing books and re-enactment gear.
The general theme of this issue was Alexander’s Funeral Games: the Wars of the
Successors. Looking at the back numbers, it appears that the magazine follows a theme
each month, with roughly two thirds of the magazines content directed towards that
theme, the rest covering everything else. Now, I have often avoided the study of the
Hellenistic period, finding it a confusing entangled time in which a broadly uniform
culture spent 150 years hacking itself to pieces. I was pleasantly relieved of this
misconception by what then followed.

2. The first article, Alexander’s Funeral Games neatly summarised the immediate aftermath
of Alexander’s death, giving a coherent explanation as to how and why his erstwhile
generals fell out, and how the Hellenistic world took shape as a result. An article on
Philon of Byzantium followed a brief summary of the primary source Poliorketika in
which the military engineer himself gives us some valuable tips on fortifying ones city.
The writer of the article, Dr. Konstantin Nossov, then goes on to give existing examples
of military works which appear to have been inspired by Philon’s suggestions, and
provides us with some detailed plans, diagrams and photographs. The story of Demetrius
Poliorcetes (Antigonus’ son) came next, followed by a piece on the development of
Hellenistic armies during and after the age of the successors. The Battle of Gabiene was
featured in great detail, complete with clear battle diagrams and a dramatic painting of
the collapse of Antigonus’ phalanx; to complete the theme, we have a piece on Sarissa
(pike) finds from an archaeological excavation at Vergina, Northern Greece.
The remainder of the magazine contained a number of shorter articles on various subjects
- one section discussed amphitheatres attached to forts and fortresses, informing me of
several in Britain I was unaware of. A feature on a marine whose body and equipment
were found at Herculaneum displayed detailed photographs and a splendid artistic
reconstruction.
Towards the end was a little feature I particularly liked. The quiz content of the magazine
invited us to re-fight the battle of Strasbourg. To help us in this task there are extracts
from Vegetius’ treatise, and a map of the battle showing just the German forces. The
Roman forces are laid out below the map for us to arrange as we see fit, as are
instructions to cut, paste and submit answers to the Ancient Warfare Forum - which,
incidentally, happens to be www.ancient-warfare.com/forum.
The magazine itself is very well produced and set out, with a mix of text and illustration
which seems just about right. The articles themselves are written by published authors
and scholars of repute, and end with suggestions for further reading. Themes of back
issues, which are still available, include: The Campaigns of Caesar, Roman Crisis: The
Third Century AD, Warfare in the Ancient Near East, and The Age of the Trireme.
Future themes will include: Gods, Kings and Heroes, The Barcid Family at War, Rome
vs. Parthia, and Tactics, Standards and Military Music.
Improved
Ancient Warfare (Vol. III Issue 2) dropped through my letterbox, and I immediately did
what I do with all magazines at first flick through quickly and look at the pictures. In the
minute or so it took me to do this, I could see that this was a magazine that I would read
cover to cover, review or no review pending. I was greeted by a series of detailed maps,
wonderful reconstruction paintings, detailed articles and mouth watering ads full of
enticing books and re-enactment gear.

3. The general theme of this issue was Alexander’s Funeral Games: the Wars of the
Successors. Looking at the back numbers, it appears that the magazine follows a theme
each month, with roughly two thirds of the magazines content directed towards that
theme, the rest covering everything else. Now, I have often avoided the study of the
Hellenistic period, finding it a confusing entangled time in which a broadly uniform
culture spent 150 years hacking itself to pieces. I was pleasantly relieved of this
misconception by what then followed.
Towards the end was a little feature I particularly liked. The quiz content of the magazine
invited us to re-fight the battle of Strasbourg. To help us in this task there are extracts
from Vegetius’ treatise, and a map of the battle showing just the German forces. The
Roman forces are laid out below the map for us to arrange as we see fit, as are
instructions to cut, paste and submit answers to the Ancient Warfare Forum - which,
incidentally, happens to be www.ancient-warfare.com/forum.
The magazine itself is very well produced and set out, with a mix of text and illustration
which seems just about right. The articles themselves are written by published authors
and scholars of repute, and end with suggestions for further reading. Themes of back
issues, which are still available, include: The Campaigns of Caesar, Roman Crisis: The
Third Century AD, Warfare in the Ancient Near East, and The Age of the Trireme.
Future themes will include: Gods, Kings and Heroes, The Barcid Family at War, Rome
vs. Parthia, and Tactics, Standards and Military Music.
The first article, Alexander’s Funeral Games neatly summarised the immediate aftermath
of Alexander’s death, giving a coherent explanation as to how and why his erstwhile
generals fell out, and how the Hellenistic world took shape as a result. An article on
Philon of Byzantium followed a brief summary of the primary source Poliorketika in
which the military engineer himself gives us some valuable tips on fortifying ones city.
The writer of the article, Dr. Konstantin Nossov, then goes on to give existing examples
of military works which appear to have been inspired by Philon’s suggestions, and
provides us with some detailed plans, diagrams and photographs. The story of Demetrius
Poliorcetes (Antigonus’ son) came next, followed by a piece on the development of
Hellenistic armies during and after the age of the successors. The Battle of Gabiene was
featured in great detail, complete with clear battle diagrams and a dramatic painting of
the collapse of Antigonus’ phalanx; to complete the theme, we have a piece on Sarissa
(pike) finds from an archaeological excavation at Vergina, Northern Greece.
The remainder of the magazine contained a number of shorter articles on various subjects
- one section discussed amphitheatres attached to forts and fortresses, informing me of
several in Britain I was unaware of. A feature on a marine whose body and equipment
were found at Herculaneum displayed detailed photographs and a splendid artistic
reconstruction.
More information? Simply ask: ron@sepado.com