Caring for patients since 1987, San Diego Heart & Vascular Associates implemented Dragon Medical Practice Edition with their Allscripts Enterprise EHR to improve documentation quality, reduce costs, and speed up turnaround time. By coupling speech recognition software with their EHR, physicians can create comprehensive patient notes in real-time instead of using transcription. This eliminated $20,000 in annual costs while improving communication with patients and other providers. Physicians reported that documentation quality and accuracy improved compared to using templates alone in the EHR.
San Diego Heart & Vascular Associates Case Study
1. Dra go n Medic a l P ra c tice Ed ition
San Diego Heart & Vascular Associates Couples
Dragon Medical Practice Edition with Allscripts
Enterprise EHR to Improve Level of Service, Enhance
Documentation Quality, and Reduce Costs
“ e took the opportunity to implement
W
Dragon Medical Practice Edition at this time
because we’d heard that its quality was at the
necessary level. I wasn’t disappointed.”
— aul Phillips, MD, Cardiologist
P
San Diego Heart Vascular Associates
San Diego, CA
CHALLENGE Summary
• ake advantage of CMS incentives for
T Caring for patients since 1987, San Diego Heart
EHR adoption, eliminate $20,000 annually Vascular Associates is one of the largest
in transcription costs, all while creating cardiology practices in San Diego with locations
comprehensive patient documentation in Hillcrest and Coronado and privileges at five
hospitals. Physicians are ABIM board-certified
in invasive and non-invasive cardiovascular
medicine and have been recognized for
Solution excellence in medical teaching and patient
• peech-enable the EHR by coupling
S satisfaction. The practice has been repeatedly
Dragon Medical Practice Edition with Allscripts cited as members of “San Diego Magazine
Enterprise EHR to create complete, real-time Top Doctors,” and “America’s Top Physicians.”
patient notes Physicians in the practice have published more
than 30 research articles, two books, and have
created a statin website.
results
• ragon Medical Practice Edition within
D The practice has recently deployed “front-
Allscripts Enterprise is now used by seven end,” real-time speech recognition with the
physicians to create high quality documentation Allscripts® Enterprise Electronic Health Record
unique to each patient encounter. Significant (EHR) to improve clinical workflow. The practice
annual cost savings include $20,000 of has significantly reduced costs, improved
transcription expenses. Turnaround time documentation quality for its EHR system,
for documentation has been reduced from and cut turnaround time for notes, referral letters
one week to one hour, which helps improve and patient handouts. Currently, seven out of
accuracy and allows the practice to better the practice’s eight physicians are using
communicate with patients and to more easily Dragon® Medical Practice Edition to complete their
share information with other physicians who documentation within Allscripts Enterprise EHR.
may be treating the patient.
h e a lt h c a r e
2. Dra go n Medic a l P ra c tice Ed ition
Enhancing Point-and-Click EHR Expert Consulting from Medical
Documentation Speech Solutions
The physicians at San Diego Heart Vascular The practice decided to implement
had long employed transcriptionists to create Dragon Medical Practice Edition three months
documentation, patient handouts and referral before installing Allscripts Enterprise EHR
letters. Recently, the practice adopted the to give its clinicians time to get comfortable
Allscripts Enterprise EHR in an effort to with speech recognition before turning their
participate in the EHR reimbursement program attention to the EHR. The implementation
available through the Center for Medicare and of Dragon Medical Practice Edition was
Medicaid Services (CMS) as specified by the overseen by Todd Ruddle, President of
Health Information Technology for Economic and Medical Speech Solutions, a reseller of
Clinical Health Act (HITECH). Dragon Medical Practice Edition. Ruddle trained
the physicians on how to install and use the system
As the practice prepared its move to the EHR, as well as how to set up templates and macros.
it was aware that the EHR’s “point and click” CHMB of Escondido, California implemented the
templates would limit the physicians’ ability Allscripts Enterprise EHR.
to enter relevant information into the patient’s
record. Since few physicians wish to type “At first, Todd came in for 30-40 minutes to show
lengthy notes into an EHR, the practice would me the basics,” said Dr. Phillips. “After that, he told
have needed to continue its use of the costly me to play with the system for five or six patients
transcription service. to determine what I needed help with, and then he
came back to answer my questions. The training
Additionally, the process of transcribing notes and was superb. Todd was always available, and I
integrating them into the EHR was cumbersome had a really good experience.” Once Allscripts
and complex. As Paul Phillips, MD, Cardiologist, Enterprise EHR was up and running, Ruddle
recalled, “We would have to dictate notes, returned to make sure the combined Dragon/EHR
send them out for transcription, and have the infrastructure worked well together.
transcribed notes emailed back. The physician
would then have to proofread the notes and send Expecting Great Things; Living Up To
them to a technician to locate the right place to Expectations
enter them into the EHR.” The practice went into the
Dragon Medical Practice Edition implementation
The Solution: Speech Recognition with high expectations. “We took the opportunity
The physicians determined that speech- to implement Dragon Medical Practice Edition at
enabling the Allscripts Enterprise EHR with this time because we’d heard that its quality was
Dragon Medical Practice Edition provided at the necessary level,” said Dr. Phillips. “I wasn’t
an optimal solution. (Today, over disappointed.”
25,000 physicians across the U.S. use
Dragon Medical Practice Edition to document Dr. Phillips got up to speed on
care into Allscripts EHR solutions, including Dragon Medical Practice Edition by first dictating
Enterprise.) Dragon Medical Practice Edition only new patients, then all patients. By the time
coupled with Allscripts Enterprise EHR promised the EHR was in place, he was ready to use
to provide the physicians a way to create Dragon Medical Practice Edition to enter any
complete, comprehensive, real-time patient notes. notes he wanted to into the EHR. He’s been
2
3. Dra go n Medic a l P ra c tice Ed ition
pleased with the results. Said Dr. Phillips, “I can The system also minimizes errors. Previously, if
talk at a regular pace. It’s amazingly accurate for the transcriptionist didn’t understand something
physical exams, which require shorter notes. I tend in a physician’s dictation, they’d leave it blank.
to be pretty expansive with free text. In that area, Then when the note came back several days later,
I’m still training Dragon and it’s still training me.” the doctor would have to remember what they
said. If Dragon Medical Practice Edition makes a
Strong Integration with the EHR mistake, the physician knows what they just said
Speeds Data Entry and can correct the notes on-the-spot – ensuring
Using Dragon Medical Practice Edition with the note is complete and done the first time.
Allscripts Enterprise has eliminated limitations
imposed by the EHR’s point and click interface Faster Turnaround Enhances
and “canned” notes. “I’m not much of a point Patient Care
and click person, I’d rather say things,” explained Using Dragon Medical Practice Edition has
Dr. Phillips. “I want to describe what the patient compressed the transcription process from one
tells me the way they say it. I also like to week to near real-time. Real-time turnaround
emphasize findings that my experience tells me means that physicians can enter information
are important, not what the EHR tells me I should into the EHR as well as send notes or letters to
focus on. As a result, whenever Allscripts gives referring physicians and to patients instantly.
me the option to do free form notes, I take it. Said Dr. Phillips. “For patients, timely transcription
Without Dragon Medical Practice Edition, that improves understanding and communication.
would slow me down.” Because patients can take assessment reports
home with them, they get the message more
Dragon Medical Practice Edition templates further clearly about what they need to do. Rapid
speed data entry. For example, the doctor does transcription also helps improve service to other
several stress tests, including standard exercise physicians. For example, if the patient needs
tests and exercise nuclear tests. Previously, semi-urgent surgery, it’s much easier for me to
he’d have to dictate all the text to describe his make sure the documentation is ready for the
results. Templates enable him to simply state the anesthesiologist and the surgeon.”
numerical test results. “That makes it really fast,”
said Dr. Phillips. Lower Transcription Costs
Costs are lower as well.
Overall, the integration between Dragon Medical Practice Edition has eliminated
Dragon Medical Practice Edition and Enterprise $20,000 a year in transcription costs.
is excellent. “The integration is better than
promised,” said Dr. Phillips. “Wherever I go in Conclusion
the program, I can dictate.”
Overall, Dragon Medical Practice Edition has
exceeded the practice’s expectations. “I would
Improving Quality of Notes Within
absolutely recommend it to other physicians,”
the EHR
said Dr. Phillips.
As a result of using Dragon Medical Practice Edition,
documentation quality within the EHR remains
high. “It’s easier to say things. Without
Dragon Medical Practice Edition, my documentation
would be much less personalized and recommen-
dations would be minimal,” said Dr. Phillips.
3