SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 20
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction
                                                            Zohar Swaine, TD Ameritrade Institutional
                                                            Jaime Fitzgerald, Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc.




                                                                                                                                                        Architects of Fact-Based Decisions™
This material is designed for an investment professional audience, primarily Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) and is for illustrative and informational purposes only. TD Ameritrade Institutional,
Division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC/NFA. TD Ameritrade is a trademark jointly owned by TD Ameritrade IP Company, Inc. and The Toronto-Dominion Bank. © 2011 TD Ameritrade IP
Company, Inc. All rights reserved. Used with permission. TD Ameritrade and Fitzgerald Analytics are separate and unaffiliated companies and are not responsible for each other’s policies and services.
TD Ameritrade — Overview

           Approach to Serving the Individual Investor


         Client Needs                                Trading                          Investing          Advice


      Multi-Channel
            Delivery                       Web              Phone                 Branch     Education      RIAs


    Products/Open                           Full range of trading products, tools, and
      Architecture                         information; planning services; investment
                                                 and cash management products


Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                          2
The RIA Model is Winning

      Independent RIA Model Gaining Assets
                                Client Asset Growth: RIA Retail AUM vs. Wirehouse Retail AUM
      40%                                                                                                                                                                                                 +39%




      20%                                                                                                                                                                                        35 pts



                                                                                                                                                                                                          +4%
        0%




     -20%
         2005                                     2006                                 2007                                 2008                                 2009                                2010E
                                                                                         RIAs                          Wirehouses


      Sources: Cerulli “State of the Wirehouses” – Nov ’09, “RIA Service Agent Survey” – Q2 ’10, “Advisor Metrics” – 2010 Update. RIAs include dually registered advisors. 2010E represents estimated results based on
      industry publications, public filings, and TD Ameritrade internal analysis.


Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction               © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                                                                                    3
‘The problems of victory are more
        agreeable than those of defeat,
        but they are no less difficult.’

                                                                            -Winston Churchill



Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved        4
Our Moment of Truth:
        Growth Led to Declining Satisfaction with Service

                         Causes                                              Effects                               Consequences

                         Growth /                               In ‘07-’08, Customer
                           Scale                               Satisfaction Declined*

                                                                         Customer                                         Asset
                         System                                         Satisfaction                                     Growth
                       Complexity



                      Competition                                         Customer
                                                                           Loyalty                                    Profitability


                     Expectations


      * Based on Client Satisfaction and Net Promoter scores from monthly TD Ameritrade Institutional surveys of representative panel of ~200
      advisors, 2007 to 2008.

Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                       5
Service Matters to RIAs…More Than Any Other Factor

      Reasons Given by Advisors for Their Choice of Custodian


                              1. Service


                              2. Technology Platforms
           Decision Factors




                              3. Fees


                              4. Reputation


                              5. Execution Speed



      Source: “Cerulli Advisor Quantitative Update Report,” 2010, Cerulli Associates, in partnerships with the College for Financial Planning, the Financial
      Planning Association, the Investment Management Consultants Association, and Morningstar.

Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction          © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                               6
“If You Can Measure It, You CAN Manage It”




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved   7
Example: Account Opening Metrics

                                                                          Illustrative



            1                                                   2                           3
                    Mail Room                                           Application              Task Assigned
                     Receives                                          Scanned into                    to
                    Application                                          Workflow               Workflow Queue

                 Success: 90%                                       Success: 90%               Success: 90%




            4                                                  5                            6
                 Account Setup                                          Compliance                 Account
                    Process                                               Review                   Funding

                 Success: 90%                                       Success: 90%               Success: 90%




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                        8
Adapting the “Service Profit Chain” Framework

      Operating Strategy and Service Delivery System



                                                   Employee                                                                     Revenue
                                                   Retention                                                                    Growth

      Internal                                                               External
                           Employee                                                            Customer         Customer
      Service                                                                Service
                          Satisfaction                                                        Satisfaction       Loyalty
      Quality                                                                 Value
                                                   Employee
                                                  Productivity                                                                 Profitability



      workplace design
      job design
                                                                        service concept:                        retention
      employee selection
                                                                         results for customers                   repeat business
       and development
                                                                                                                 referral
      employee rewards
       and recognition
      tools for serving                                                                     service designed and
       customers                                                                              delivered to meet targeted
                                                                                              customers’ needs

      Source: James Heskett, Gary Loveman, Leonard Schlesinger et al.

Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                      9
Our Organizing Framework:
        The Service Chain with TD Ameritrade Institutional


               Factors Driving                                            Customer            Customer           Business
          the Customer Experience                                        Experience           Behavior            Impact

     Brand Values /
                                                                                                                  Attrition/
       Promises                                                                                  Loyalty
                                                                            Initiation                            Defection
      Products &
        Services                       Service
        (including tech             Expectations of                                                                 New
         functionality)                                                                        Advocacy
                                      Customers                                                                   Accounts
      Commitments                                                          Expansion
       Competitor                                                                                                   Asset
       Benchmarks                                                                                                  Inflow

                                                                            Routine                                Asset
                                                                                               Receptivity
                                                                            Services                              Outflow
                                         Service                                              (to new info,
       Our Service                      Provided                                               offers, etc.)
        Processes                   ( = Result of Our                                                           Bottom Line:
                                       Processes)                          Moments                             Profitable Asset
                                                                           of Truth                                Growth



      Source: Adapted from Heskett, et al, Harvard Business Review, July 1, 2008

Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction     © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                       10
Example Causal Map: New Account Opening

                                                                                              Customer Actions =
                     Customer Experience                             Customer Sentiment        Business Impact

                  Quality
                                                                             Customer
                            Accuracy Rate                                                         New Account
                                                                        Satisfaction Scores

                  Speed
                             Time to                                        Net Promoter
                                                                                                    Assets
                           Open Account                                        Scores


                  Experience
                     Quality of Exception-
                           Handling
                  Experience
                         Customer Service
                              Quality



Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                          11
Example: Account Opening Metrics

                                                                          Illustrative



            1                                                   2                           3
                    Mail Room                                           Application              Task Assigned
                     Receives                                          Scanned into                    to
                    Application                                          Workflow               Workflow Queue

                 Success: 90%                                       Success: 90%               Success: 90%




            4                                                  5                            6
                 Account Setup                                          Compliance                 Account
                    Process                                               Review                   Funding

                 Success: 90%                                       Success: 90%               Success: 90%




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                        12
And Metrics Alone Wouldn’t Change Customer Experience…




              Dashboards…                                       Gaps/Opportunities                Process Enhancements

                                              Made it                                         Which
                                              possible                                       pointed    1      2
                                                 to                                         to needs
                                              identify                                         for
                                                                                                        3      $




                                                          Which Created Better Results




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                13
Better Measurement Created a “Virtuous Cycle”




              TD                                                                            Led to
                                           Insights About                                                Improved
         Ameritrade
                                            Service Gaps                                                  Service
        Institutional



                                                   Led To



                                            Improvement                                      And      Client Operations
         Our Client/
                                           Opportunities                                             Improved with Our
         Customers
                                           For Our Clients                                                  Help…




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                 14
Impact on Results was Significant and Lasting

                              Client Satisfaction                                                                     Net Advocate

       95%                                                                                 75%                                                                75%

                                                                            91%
                                                                                           70%
       90%
                                                                                           65%


       85%                                                                                 60%


                                                                                           55%
       80%
                                                                                           50%
                78%                                                                                  49%
       75%                                                                                 45%
                J F M A M J J A S O ND J F M A M J J A S O ND                                       J F M A M J J A S O ND J F M A M J J A S O ND
                             2009                              2010                                              2009                              2010



      Scores are based on a 3-month rolling average. CSI is based on 11 point scale, that is, from 0 to 10, top 3 box = 8+9+10 rating points. Net Advocate is based
      on [10+9 ratings] – [0+1+2+3+4+5+6 ratings]. Results for Legacy TD Ameritrade and Legacy Fiserv Trust Company combined November 09 and forward.

Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction      © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                                          15
Our Journey: Data

        Maturity
          Level                 1. Early Stage                                 2. Mature         3. Next Generation


                           Barely exists in                     Exists in abundance, but    High impact metrics
               Data
                            usable form                           quality & value varies      Better data mgt / data quality


                                                                                              Key scorecards
                                                                 3-Inch Binders
         Analysis  Ad hoc                                                                    Decision tools & models
                                                                 Static
                                                                                              Data-driven learning


                                                                                              Fact-based optimization
           Mgmt
                   Gut decisions                                Informed / Educated         People / Process / Data
        Decisions
                                                                                               integrated


                           Opportunistic                        Short list / rough          Resource allocation optimal
       Initiatives
                           Reactive                              prioritization              ROI maximization



Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                       16
Our Journey: Support

      Maturity
                                    1. Early Stage                                     2. Mature      3. Next Generation
        Level


     Business
                                                                                                    Available, flexible,
  Intelligence  Scattered / Ad-hoc                                       Limited access
                                                                                                     dynamic
  Community


                                                                                                    Empowered by KPI
   Experience                                                             Overwhelmed by data
               Constrained by data gaps                                                             production, analysis of
      Analyst                                                              deluge
                                                                                                     drivers / causality



    Databases  Decentralized / Ad-hoc                                    Centralized              Made available




Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction     © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                    17
Diverse Benefits from CXP Measurement System


                                    1. People                                                                2. Process
         Incentive Changes                                                                   Workflow Changes
         Confidence in Decisions Up                                                          Six Sigma Process Improvements
         Cultural Shift                                                                      Earlier Detection of Issues/More Proactive
                                                                                               Resolution




                               3. Technology                                                                  4. Other
         Changes to Technology and Systems More                                              Less Trees Cut Down
          Efficient
                                                                                              More Transparency with Advisors
         Upgrades have been easier
                                                                                              Competitive Advantage in the Marketplace
         Additional innovation built on top of
          measurement platform



Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction    © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                                  18
Key Concepts

                              Concept                                                       Key Implications

        1. If you don’t measure what
                                                                        Agree on key drivers of results
           matters, you are managing the
                                                                        Measure the drivers and manage improvement
           wrong things!

                                                                        Beware of unintended incentives
        2. Better Metrics != Better Decisions                           “Walk through” processes carefully to find the real
                                                                         opportunities to improve

                                                                        Managers care about results the most, and process
                                                                         the least.
        3. Managers don’t care about
                                                                        This creates a challenge because process
           process…
                                                                         enhancements are essential to better results!
                                                                        A clear causal model helped us a lot

                                                                        Demonstrate the need (tie back to pain!)
        4. Executive buy-in essential                                   Create proof of concept with early wins
                                                                        Iteratively fund additional investments


Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                                      19
Key Frameworks Integrated



                                                                        Customer
                                                                       Experience


                                                   Balanced                                    Data
                                                  Scorecards                                Management




                                                                      Questions?



Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction   © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved                20

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

080310 watson - msft in banking
080310   watson - msft in banking080310   watson - msft in banking
080310 watson - msft in banking
Erick Watson
 
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex ITOHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
ApexIT_Help_Desk
 
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Petersemerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
finance12
 
Smart Micro Credit Business Suite
Smart Micro Credit Business SuiteSmart Micro Credit Business Suite
Smart Micro Credit Business Suite
Fahad Iftikhar
 
Dcongres bdma Engagement modelling
Dcongres bdma   Engagement modellingDcongres bdma   Engagement modelling
Dcongres bdma Engagement modelling
Stratics
 
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarkeChallenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
Shane Dempsey
 
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
MMMTechLaw
 
Financial Technology July Market Analysis
Financial Technology July Market AnalysisFinancial Technology July Market Analysis
Financial Technology July Market Analysis
MMMTechLaw
 

La actualidad más candente (18)

080310 watson - msft in banking
080310   watson - msft in banking080310   watson - msft in banking
080310 watson - msft in banking
 
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex ITOHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
OHUG 2012- HR Help Desk McKesson and Apex IT
 
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Petersemerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
emerson electricl 2009 Annual Investor Conference_Peters
 
Sudip Julian Workshop Presentation 23 3 10
Sudip Julian Workshop Presentation 23 3 10Sudip Julian Workshop Presentation 23 3 10
Sudip Julian Workshop Presentation 23 3 10
 
Smart Micro Credit Business Suite
Smart Micro Credit Business SuiteSmart Micro Credit Business Suite
Smart Micro Credit Business Suite
 
Dcongres bdma Engagement modelling
Dcongres bdma   Engagement modellingDcongres bdma   Engagement modelling
Dcongres bdma Engagement modelling
 
NICE Fizzback - Voice of the Customer
NICE Fizzback - Voice of the CustomerNICE Fizzback - Voice of the Customer
NICE Fizzback - Voice of the Customer
 
Future of the Public Sector Workforce
Future of the Public Sector WorkforceFuture of the Public Sector Workforce
Future of the Public Sector Workforce
 
Golden Rules [Best Practices] to tame the MDM/CDI Beast - A White Paper
Golden Rules [Best Practices] to tame the MDM/CDI Beast - A White PaperGolden Rules [Best Practices] to tame the MDM/CDI Beast - A White Paper
Golden Rules [Best Practices] to tame the MDM/CDI Beast - A White Paper
 
Analyze This - #SPSSac
Analyze This - #SPSSacAnalyze This - #SPSSac
Analyze This - #SPSSac
 
Business Intelligence - Journey towards an Intelligent Enterprise
Business Intelligence - Journey towards an Intelligent EnterpriseBusiness Intelligence - Journey towards an Intelligent Enterprise
Business Intelligence - Journey towards an Intelligent Enterprise
 
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarkeChallenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
Challenges financial information_systems_a_clarke
 
Barriers to Retail Growth - And How to Overcome Them
Barriers to Retail Growth - And How to Overcome ThemBarriers to Retail Growth - And How to Overcome Them
Barriers to Retail Growth - And How to Overcome Them
 
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
Financial Technology Market Analysis - March 2012
 
Introduction to SOA & its Open Source Framework
Introduction to SOA & its Open Source FrameworkIntroduction to SOA & its Open Source Framework
Introduction to SOA & its Open Source Framework
 
Global Credit & Collections for All Economies
Global Credit & Collections for All EconomiesGlobal Credit & Collections for All Economies
Global Credit & Collections for All Economies
 
Financial Technology July Market Analysis
Financial Technology July Market AnalysisFinancial Technology July Market Analysis
Financial Technology July Market Analysis
 
Function Point Analysis: Size Matters - No Matter What You Have Been Told!
Function Point Analysis: Size Matters - No Matter What You Have Been Told!Function Point Analysis: Size Matters - No Matter What You Have Been Told!
Function Point Analysis: Size Matters - No Matter What You Have Been Told!
 

Similar a Jaime fitzgerald on data driven customer experience in financial services and beyond

CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QACCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
Rebecca Gibson
 
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
MY HR
 
MY HR Corporate capability
MY HR Corporate capability MY HR Corporate capability
MY HR Corporate capability
MY HR
 
Zd sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
Zd   sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1Zd   sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
Zd sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
Richard Lee
 
You got your social in my crm
You got your social in my crmYou got your social in my crm
You got your social in my crm
Tristan Bishop
 
EDF2012 Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
EDF2012   Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the EnterpriseEDF2012   Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
EDF2012 Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
European Data Forum
 

Similar a Jaime fitzgerald on data driven customer experience in financial services and beyond (20)

ValueMomentum Company Overview 2013
ValueMomentum Company Overview 2013ValueMomentum Company Overview 2013
ValueMomentum Company Overview 2013
 
Big data meets customer profitability analytics april 10 cw slides
Big data meets customer profitability analytics   april 10 cw slidesBig data meets customer profitability analytics   april 10 cw slides
Big data meets customer profitability analytics april 10 cw slides
 
Guiding Principles for Mobile Payment Readiness
Guiding Principles for Mobile Payment ReadinessGuiding Principles for Mobile Payment Readiness
Guiding Principles for Mobile Payment Readiness
 
CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QACCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
CCA 2013 Harness the Potential of QA
 
Kneebone financial services presentation
Kneebone financial services  presentation Kneebone financial services  presentation
Kneebone financial services presentation
 
Ibm data governance framework
Ibm data governance frameworkIbm data governance framework
Ibm data governance framework
 
Mi fin financial product suite
Mi fin financial product suiteMi fin financial product suite
Mi fin financial product suite
 
How To Develop a Value Proposition That SELLS
How To Develop a Value Proposition That SELLSHow To Develop a Value Proposition That SELLS
How To Develop a Value Proposition That SELLS
 
Hybrid ITSM FrontRange & Gartner Webcast
Hybrid ITSM FrontRange & Gartner WebcastHybrid ITSM FrontRange & Gartner Webcast
Hybrid ITSM FrontRange & Gartner Webcast
 
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
MY HR supplier Corporate capability - final review v1
 
MY HR Corporate capability
MY HR Corporate capability MY HR Corporate capability
MY HR Corporate capability
 
Zd sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
Zd   sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1Zd   sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
Zd sap - predictive analytics - 3-26-13 r1
 
You got your social in my crm
You got your social in my crmYou got your social in my crm
You got your social in my crm
 
Running Successful User Surveys
Running Successful User SurveysRunning Successful User Surveys
Running Successful User Surveys
 
Customer Experience Management for Startups
Customer Experience Management for StartupsCustomer Experience Management for Startups
Customer Experience Management for Startups
 
Smarter Analytics giver dig indsigt i hele forretningen, Rich Holada, IBM US
Smarter Analytics giver dig indsigt i hele forretningen, Rich Holada, IBM USSmarter Analytics giver dig indsigt i hele forretningen, Rich Holada, IBM US
Smarter Analytics giver dig indsigt i hele forretningen, Rich Holada, IBM US
 
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best PracticesVoice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
 
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best PracticesVoice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
Voice of the Customer (VOC) Best Practices
 
EDF2012 Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
EDF2012   Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the EnterpriseEDF2012   Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
EDF2012 Wolfgang Nimfuehr - Bringing Big Data to the Enterprise
 
Gmid associates services offerings in analytics
Gmid associates  services offerings in analyticsGmid associates  services offerings in analytics
Gmid associates services offerings in analytics
 

Jaime fitzgerald on data driven customer experience in financial services and beyond

  • 1. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction Zohar Swaine, TD Ameritrade Institutional Jaime Fitzgerald, Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. Architects of Fact-Based Decisions™ This material is designed for an investment professional audience, primarily Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) and is for illustrative and informational purposes only. TD Ameritrade Institutional, Division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC/NFA. TD Ameritrade is a trademark jointly owned by TD Ameritrade IP Company, Inc. and The Toronto-Dominion Bank. © 2011 TD Ameritrade IP Company, Inc. All rights reserved. Used with permission. TD Ameritrade and Fitzgerald Analytics are separate and unaffiliated companies and are not responsible for each other’s policies and services.
  • 2. TD Ameritrade — Overview Approach to Serving the Individual Investor Client Needs Trading Investing Advice Multi-Channel Delivery Web Phone Branch Education RIAs Products/Open Full range of trading products, tools, and Architecture information; planning services; investment and cash management products Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 2
  • 3. The RIA Model is Winning Independent RIA Model Gaining Assets Client Asset Growth: RIA Retail AUM vs. Wirehouse Retail AUM 40% +39% 20% 35 pts +4% 0% -20% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010E RIAs Wirehouses Sources: Cerulli “State of the Wirehouses” – Nov ’09, “RIA Service Agent Survey” – Q2 ’10, “Advisor Metrics” – 2010 Update. RIAs include dually registered advisors. 2010E represents estimated results based on industry publications, public filings, and TD Ameritrade internal analysis. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 3
  • 4. ‘The problems of victory are more agreeable than those of defeat, but they are no less difficult.’ -Winston Churchill Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 4
  • 5. Our Moment of Truth: Growth Led to Declining Satisfaction with Service Causes Effects Consequences Growth / In ‘07-’08, Customer Scale Satisfaction Declined* Customer Asset System Satisfaction Growth Complexity Competition Customer Loyalty Profitability Expectations * Based on Client Satisfaction and Net Promoter scores from monthly TD Ameritrade Institutional surveys of representative panel of ~200 advisors, 2007 to 2008. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 5
  • 6. Service Matters to RIAs…More Than Any Other Factor Reasons Given by Advisors for Their Choice of Custodian 1. Service 2. Technology Platforms Decision Factors 3. Fees 4. Reputation 5. Execution Speed Source: “Cerulli Advisor Quantitative Update Report,” 2010, Cerulli Associates, in partnerships with the College for Financial Planning, the Financial Planning Association, the Investment Management Consultants Association, and Morningstar. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 6
  • 7. “If You Can Measure It, You CAN Manage It” Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 7
  • 8. Example: Account Opening Metrics Illustrative 1 2 3 Mail Room Application Task Assigned Receives Scanned into to Application Workflow Workflow Queue  Success: 90%  Success: 90%  Success: 90% 4 5 6 Account Setup Compliance Account Process Review Funding  Success: 90%  Success: 90%  Success: 90% Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 8
  • 9. Adapting the “Service Profit Chain” Framework Operating Strategy and Service Delivery System Employee Revenue Retention Growth Internal External Employee Customer Customer Service Service Satisfaction Satisfaction Loyalty Quality Value Employee Productivity Profitability  workplace design  job design  service concept:  retention  employee selection results for customers  repeat business and development  referral  employee rewards and recognition  tools for serving  service designed and customers delivered to meet targeted customers’ needs Source: James Heskett, Gary Loveman, Leonard Schlesinger et al. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 9
  • 10. Our Organizing Framework: The Service Chain with TD Ameritrade Institutional Factors Driving Customer Customer Business the Customer Experience Experience Behavior Impact Brand Values / Attrition/ Promises Loyalty Initiation Defection Products & Services Service (including tech Expectations of New functionality) Advocacy Customers Accounts Commitments Expansion Competitor Asset Benchmarks Inflow Routine Asset Receptivity Services Outflow Service (to new info, Our Service Provided offers, etc.) Processes ( = Result of Our Bottom Line: Processes) Moments Profitable Asset of Truth Growth Source: Adapted from Heskett, et al, Harvard Business Review, July 1, 2008 Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 10
  • 11. Example Causal Map: New Account Opening Customer Actions = Customer Experience Customer Sentiment Business Impact Quality Customer Accuracy Rate New Account Satisfaction Scores Speed Time to Net Promoter Assets Open Account Scores Experience Quality of Exception- Handling Experience Customer Service Quality Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 11
  • 12. Example: Account Opening Metrics Illustrative 1 2 3 Mail Room Application Task Assigned Receives Scanned into to Application Workflow Workflow Queue  Success: 90%  Success: 90%  Success: 90% 4 5 6 Account Setup Compliance Account Process Review Funding  Success: 90%  Success: 90%  Success: 90% Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 12
  • 13. And Metrics Alone Wouldn’t Change Customer Experience… Dashboards… Gaps/Opportunities Process Enhancements Made it Which possible pointed 1 2 to to needs identify for 3 $ Which Created Better Results Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 13
  • 14. Better Measurement Created a “Virtuous Cycle” TD Led to Insights About Improved Ameritrade Service Gaps Service Institutional Led To Improvement And Client Operations Our Client/ Opportunities Improved with Our Customers For Our Clients Help… Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 14
  • 15. Impact on Results was Significant and Lasting Client Satisfaction Net Advocate 95% 75% 75% 91% 70% 90% 65% 85% 60% 55% 80% 50% 78% 49% 75% 45% J F M A M J J A S O ND J F M A M J J A S O ND J F M A M J J A S O ND J F M A M J J A S O ND 2009 2010 2009 2010 Scores are based on a 3-month rolling average. CSI is based on 11 point scale, that is, from 0 to 10, top 3 box = 8+9+10 rating points. Net Advocate is based on [10+9 ratings] – [0+1+2+3+4+5+6 ratings]. Results for Legacy TD Ameritrade and Legacy Fiserv Trust Company combined November 09 and forward. Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 15
  • 16. Our Journey: Data Maturity Level 1. Early Stage 2. Mature 3. Next Generation  Barely exists in  Exists in abundance, but  High impact metrics Data usable form quality & value varies  Better data mgt / data quality  Key scorecards  3-Inch Binders Analysis  Ad hoc  Decision tools & models  Static  Data-driven learning  Fact-based optimization Mgmt  Gut decisions  Informed / Educated  People / Process / Data Decisions integrated  Opportunistic  Short list / rough  Resource allocation optimal Initiatives  Reactive prioritization  ROI maximization Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 16
  • 17. Our Journey: Support Maturity 1. Early Stage 2. Mature 3. Next Generation Level Business  Available, flexible, Intelligence  Scattered / Ad-hoc  Limited access dynamic Community  Empowered by KPI Experience  Overwhelmed by data  Constrained by data gaps production, analysis of Analyst deluge drivers / causality Databases  Decentralized / Ad-hoc  Centralized  Made available Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 17
  • 18. Diverse Benefits from CXP Measurement System 1. People 2. Process  Incentive Changes  Workflow Changes  Confidence in Decisions Up  Six Sigma Process Improvements  Cultural Shift  Earlier Detection of Issues/More Proactive Resolution 3. Technology 4. Other  Changes to Technology and Systems More  Less Trees Cut Down Efficient  More Transparency with Advisors  Upgrades have been easier  Competitive Advantage in the Marketplace  Additional innovation built on top of measurement platform Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 18
  • 19. Key Concepts Concept Key Implications 1. If you don’t measure what  Agree on key drivers of results matters, you are managing the  Measure the drivers and manage improvement wrong things!  Beware of unintended incentives 2. Better Metrics != Better Decisions  “Walk through” processes carefully to find the real opportunities to improve  Managers care about results the most, and process the least. 3. Managers don’t care about  This creates a challenge because process process… enhancements are essential to better results!  A clear causal model helped us a lot  Demonstrate the need (tie back to pain!) 4. Executive buy-in essential  Create proof of concept with early wins  Iteratively fund additional investments Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 19
  • 20. Key Frameworks Integrated Customer Experience Balanced Data Scorecards Management Questions? Data-Driven Customer Satisfaction © 2011 Fitzgerald Analytics, Inc. All Rights Reserved 20