SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 40
Physician Practice Acquisitions  by Hospitals  Presented by W. James Lloyd, CPA/ABV, ASA Tennessee Society of CPAs 2010 Healthcare Conference November 30, 2010
Speaker Biography –  W. James Lloyd ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Agenda Page
Common Types of Physician  Alignment Strategies Page
Physician Practice Acquisitions -  “Buy and Employ” Transactions Page
Transaction Drivers Lifestyle preference and practice patterns Increasing specialization/aging Decreasing  supply… Increasing  pressure… Healthcare reform  Operating costs Page
“ Buy and Employ” Transactions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page  “ Buy and Employ”  Transactions
Buy and Employ Transactions –  Key Issues ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page  “ Buy and Employ”  Transactions
Navigating the Regulatory Environment Page  IRS Stark Anti- Kickback
Compliance Issues Regarding  Hospital-Physician Financial Relationships Fair Market  Value ________________________________________________________________________ Cents ________________________________________________________________________ Scope : Range of Dollars Only Key Question :  “How Much”? Commercial Reasonableness ________________________________________________________________________ Sense ________________________________________________________________________ Scope : Overall Arrangement Key Question :  “Why”? Two Components Page
Commercial Reasonableness ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],1  63 Fed. Reg. 1700 (Jan. 9, 1998). 2  69 Fed. Reg. 16093 (March 26, 2004). 3 “OIG Compliance Program For Individual and Small Group Physician Practices,” Notice, 65 Fed. Reg. 59434 (Oct. 5, 2000); OIG Advisory Opinion No. 07-10, September 20, 2007, pg. 6, 10; “OIG Supplemental Compliance Program Guidance for Hospitals,” Notice, 70 Fed. Reg. 4858 (Jan. 31, 2005).  Page
Factors in Determining CR Business Purpose Provider Analysis Facility Analysis Resource Analysis  Independence & Oversight Commercial Reasonableness Determination Page
Fair Market Value ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],1 Estate Tax Reg. 20.2031.1-1(b); Revenue Ruling 59-60, 1959-1, C.B. 237. 2 Federal Register / Vol. 69, No. 59 / Friday, March 26, 2004 / Rules and Regulations. Page
FMV of the Practice –  Key Concepts  Page
Methods Typically Used to Value Physician Practices Page
Which Method is Appropriate? ,[object Object],[object Object],It Depends… Page
Enterprise Value vs.  Intangible Value ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Assessing Intangible Value The existence of intangible value primarily comes down to cash flow Physician groups that generate positive cash flow (above the physician’s “normalized” compensation based on professional productivity) will normally have some level of intangible value Practices that do not produce such positive cash flow, generally will not have intangible value Page
Certain practices are more likely to  have intangible value ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Inappropriate Methods/Approaches Page
1992 Mac Thornton “no goodwill” letter ,[object Object],[object Object],Page
Financial Analysis and  Due Diligence ,[object Object],[object Object],Page
Buyer’s Side Due Diligence Page
Balance Sheet Analysis Page
Balance Sheet Analysis ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page  ,[object Object],[object Object],Fixed Assets
Balance Sheet Analysis Page
Revenue Analysis  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Net revenue per provider (assess risk) ,[object Object],[object Object],Page
Operating Expenses ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Physician compensation should be “normalized”  based on productivity (collections or wRVUs) Physician compensation used to value the practice should be reflective of the expected post-transaction compensation Page
Accounting for the Transaction Hospitals acquiring physician practices must account for the transaction under the “acquisition” method. Accordingly, the transaction price (including debt assumed) must be allocated among the identifiable assets acquired from the transaction. Goodwill is recorded as the difference between the transaction price and the identifiable assets. Page
ASC 805, Business Combinations  (SFAS 141R) Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Categories of Intangible Assets  (Separable From Goodwill) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Key Terms and Definitions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Applicability to Physician Practices ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page
Applicability to Physician Practices – Con’t  ,[object Object],Page
Questions? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Page

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSIONZhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
Jaklin Oleva
 
Attrition Calculation
Attrition CalculationAttrition Calculation
Attrition Calculation
swati18
 
Team work on stock maarket
Team work on stock maarketTeam work on stock maarket
Team work on stock maarket
Jewel Rana
 
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
av vedpuriswar
 
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
Abhijit Kumar Singh
 
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
oircjournals
 
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
oircjournals
 

La actualidad más candente (17)

Business Valuation in the Context of Fraud or Misrepresentation (FTI Consulting)
Business Valuation in the Context of Fraud or Misrepresentation (FTI Consulting)Business Valuation in the Context of Fraud or Misrepresentation (FTI Consulting)
Business Valuation in the Context of Fraud or Misrepresentation (FTI Consulting)
 
Lecture03
Lecture03Lecture03
Lecture03
 
Accounting measurement of owners’ equity and its impact on the going concern ...
Accounting measurement of owners’ equity and its impact on the going concern ...Accounting measurement of owners’ equity and its impact on the going concern ...
Accounting measurement of owners’ equity and its impact on the going concern ...
 
IBANK, EPM, BPM, OBIEE, HYPERION, OFSAA
IBANK, EPM, BPM, OBIEE, HYPERION, OFSAAIBANK, EPM, BPM, OBIEE, HYPERION, OFSAA
IBANK, EPM, BPM, OBIEE, HYPERION, OFSAA
 
Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSIONZhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
Zhaklin Oleva FINAL_VERSION
 
Attrition Calculation
Attrition CalculationAttrition Calculation
Attrition Calculation
 
Team work on stock maarket
Team work on stock maarketTeam work on stock maarket
Team work on stock maarket
 
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
 
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
Pub ccd guideline_companies_valuation_1008
 
Not-For-Profit Audit Committee Briefing
Not-For-Profit Audit Committee Briefing Not-For-Profit Audit Committee Briefing
Not-For-Profit Audit Committee Briefing
 
impairment-part1
impairment-part1impairment-part1
impairment-part1
 
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
Establishing the-effectiveness-of-market-ratios-in-predicting-financial-distr...
 
Lecture03
Lecture03Lecture03
Lecture03
 
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2016
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2016Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2016
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2016
 
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
Establishing the effectiveness of market ratios in predicting financial distr...
 
Market approaches
Market approachesMarket approaches
Market approaches
 
Wendys company 10 k.pdf united statessecurities and ex
Wendys company 10 k.pdf united statessecurities and exWendys company 10 k.pdf united statessecurities and ex
Wendys company 10 k.pdf united statessecurities and ex
 

Destacado (6)

Finalmgr providence fraudulent accounting and theft123june29
Finalmgr providence fraudulent accounting and theft123june29Finalmgr providence fraudulent accounting and theft123june29
Finalmgr providence fraudulent accounting and theft123june29
 
Mixing Forensic Acctg And Valuation In Litigation
Mixing Forensic Acctg And Valuation In LitigationMixing Forensic Acctg And Valuation In Litigation
Mixing Forensic Acctg And Valuation In Litigation
 
Valuing Privately-Held Businesses for Divorce
Valuing Privately-Held Businesses for DivorceValuing Privately-Held Businesses for Divorce
Valuing Privately-Held Businesses for Divorce
 
Managing And Assessing The Risk Of Fraudulent Financial Statements
Managing And Assessing The Risk Of Fraudulent Financial StatementsManaging And Assessing The Risk Of Fraudulent Financial Statements
Managing And Assessing The Risk Of Fraudulent Financial Statements
 
Creating Shareholder Value
Creating Shareholder ValueCreating Shareholder Value
Creating Shareholder Value
 
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheHow to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
 

Similar a Physician Practice Acquisitions by Hospitals

healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmchealthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
Shannon Farr
 
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healtIn Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
rafbolet0
 

Similar a Physician Practice Acquisitions by Hospitals (20)

Determining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a Practice
Determining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a PracticeDetermining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a Practice
Determining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a Practice
 
Key Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologies
Key Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologiesKey Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologies
Key Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologies
 
Practice Price vs Value
Practice Price vs ValuePractice Price vs Value
Practice Price vs Value
 
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the DealAnalyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
 
Practice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning Considerations
Practice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning ConsiderationsPractice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning Considerations
Practice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning Considerations
 
Hot Valuation Issues for Physician Agreements
Hot Valuation Issues for Physician AgreementsHot Valuation Issues for Physician Agreements
Hot Valuation Issues for Physician Agreements
 
Finance for the Non-Finance Manager
Finance for the Non-Finance ManagerFinance for the Non-Finance Manager
Finance for the Non-Finance Manager
 
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationHot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
 
healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmchealthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
healthcaretransactionsAdvertorial16_lbmc
 
Valuing Dr. Exit
Valuing Dr. ExitValuing Dr. Exit
Valuing Dr. Exit
 
Fair Value Analysis of Healthcare Entities
Fair Value Analysis of Healthcare EntitiesFair Value Analysis of Healthcare Entities
Fair Value Analysis of Healthcare Entities
 
Reitmans Case Analysis
Reitmans Case AnalysisReitmans Case Analysis
Reitmans Case Analysis
 
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healtIn Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
In Module One, our first step is to direct our focus on what healt
 
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
Fundamentals of Healthcare ValuationFundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
 
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
Fundamentals of Healthcare ValuationFundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
 
Practical Advice on Physician Compensation
Practical Advice on Physician Compensation Practical Advice on Physician Compensation
Practical Advice on Physician Compensation
 
PYA Considers the “Taxing” Developments Facing Healthcare Organizations
PYA Considers the “Taxing” Developments Facing Healthcare OrganizationsPYA Considers the “Taxing” Developments Facing Healthcare Organizations
PYA Considers the “Taxing” Developments Facing Healthcare Organizations
 
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
 
FAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS
FAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESSFAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS
FAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS
 
Auditing A Practical Approach Canadian 2nd Edition Moroney Solutions Manual
Auditing A Practical Approach Canadian 2nd Edition Moroney Solutions ManualAuditing A Practical Approach Canadian 2nd Edition Moroney Solutions Manual
Auditing A Practical Approach Canadian 2nd Edition Moroney Solutions Manual
 

Physician Practice Acquisitions by Hospitals

  • 1. Physician Practice Acquisitions by Hospitals Presented by W. James Lloyd, CPA/ABV, ASA Tennessee Society of CPAs 2010 Healthcare Conference November 30, 2010
  • 2.
  • 4. Common Types of Physician Alignment Strategies Page
  • 5. Physician Practice Acquisitions - “Buy and Employ” Transactions Page
  • 6. Transaction Drivers Lifestyle preference and practice patterns Increasing specialization/aging Decreasing supply… Increasing pressure… Healthcare reform Operating costs Page
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. Navigating the Regulatory Environment Page IRS Stark Anti- Kickback
  • 10. Compliance Issues Regarding Hospital-Physician Financial Relationships Fair Market Value ________________________________________________________________________ Cents ________________________________________________________________________ Scope : Range of Dollars Only Key Question : “How Much”? Commercial Reasonableness ________________________________________________________________________ Sense ________________________________________________________________________ Scope : Overall Arrangement Key Question : “Why”? Two Components Page
  • 11.
  • 12. Factors in Determining CR Business Purpose Provider Analysis Facility Analysis Resource Analysis Independence & Oversight Commercial Reasonableness Determination Page
  • 13.
  • 14. FMV of the Practice – Key Concepts Page
  • 15. Methods Typically Used to Value Physician Practices Page
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18. Assessing Intangible Value The existence of intangible value primarily comes down to cash flow Physician groups that generate positive cash flow (above the physician’s “normalized” compensation based on professional productivity) will normally have some level of intangible value Practices that do not produce such positive cash flow, generally will not have intangible value Page
  • 19.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. Buyer’s Side Due Diligence Page
  • 25.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29. Accounting for the Transaction Hospitals acquiring physician practices must account for the transaction under the “acquisition” method. Accordingly, the transaction price (including debt assumed) must be allocated among the identifiable assets acquired from the transaction. Goodwill is recorded as the difference between the transaction price and the identifiable assets. Page
  • 30. ASC 805, Business Combinations (SFAS 141R) Page
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.

Notas del editor

  1. So what does this mean in the context of a physician practice? In summary, it means that fair market value is the amount determined from the perspective of a pool of potential investors in an arm’s-length transaction based solely on the underlying financial merits of the practice. Accordingly, the assumptions used to value the practice must be void of any potential synergies or other benefits that a particular buyer (i.e., hospital) might be able to achieve post acquisition, such as higher volume or reimbursement rates. Consideration of such synergies would generally change the standard of value from fair market value to investment value . This is often a challenging issue for physicians to grasp and accept because such synergies often do exist.