9. Critical incident
• Observable behavior
• Sufficiently complete
Professor Kam-hon Lee 9
10. H Richard Niebuhr Framework
T YP E 5 Christ the transformer
of business culture
TY P E 3 Christ above
business culture
TY P E 4 Christ and business culture
in paradox
T YPE 2 Christ of
business culture T YP E1 Christ against
business culture
Professor Kam-hon Lee 10
11. Negotiation Styles Framework
Yielding Integrating
Other Compromising
Avoiding Dominating
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 11
12. Integrated Framework
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 12
13. Variables
• Key variable
• Response to an ethical challenge
• Other variables
• Antecedents
• Consequences
Professor Kam-hon Lee 13
16. Results
• Response to an ethical challenge
• Focus on antecedents
• China business
• Christian corporate culture
Professor Kam-hon Lee 16
17. China business
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
YPE 1
TChrist against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 17
18. Avoiding
Christ against
TYPE 1
business culture
• Unable to handle
corruption practices
• Closed down China operation
Professor Kam-hon Lee 18
19. China business
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
ChristP E 4
T Y and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 19
20. Compromising
TYPE 4 Christ and business
culture in paradox
• Paid penalty in spite of innocence
• Amount smaller than what violators
paid
Professor Kam-hon Lee 20
21. Christian corporate culture
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5Dominating
TChrist 5 transformer
YPE the
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 21
22. Dominating
Christ the transformer
TYPE 5
of business culture
• No intermediary roles for MNCs
• Only two new clients per year
Professor Kam-hon Lee 22
23. Christian corporate culture
TY PE 2 Yielding
TChrist 2
Y P E of
T Y P E 2 culture
business
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 23
24. Not Yielding
TYPE 2
Not Christ of
business culture
• No more in-company fellowship
meetings
• Operating like an ordinary plant
Professor Kam-hon Lee 24
25. Normative reflection
• Beyond positive science
• Prescriptive directive
Professor Kam-hon Lee 25
26. Normative reflection
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
YPE 1
TChrist against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 26
27. Avoiding
Christ against
TYPE 1
business culture
• Christian corporate culture
• Not going public in spite of success
Professor Kam-hon Lee 27
28. Normative reflection
TY PE 2 Yielding
TChrist 2
Y P E of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 28
29. Yielding
TYPE 2
Christ of
business culture
• China business
• Nurturing guanxi
Professor Kam-hon Lee 29
30. Normative reflection
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
T Christ3
YPE above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 30
31. Integrating
TYPE 3
Christ above
business culture
• China business
• Investing in safety equipments
Professor Kam-hon Lee 31
32. Normative reflection
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
ChristP E 4
T Y and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5 Dominating
Christ the transformer
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 32
33. Compromising
TYPE 4 Christ and business
culture in paradox
• Christian corporate culture
• Trapping a disloyal senior executive
Professor Kam-hon Lee 33
34. Normative reflection
TY PE 2 Yielding
Christ of
business culture
T YP E 3 Integrating
Christ above
business culture
Other TY P E 4 Compromising
Christ and business
culture in paradox
TY P E 1 Avoiding
Christ against T YP E 5Dominating
TChrist 5 transformer
YPE the
of business culture
business culture
Self
Professor Kam-hon Lee 34
35. Dominating
Christ the transformer
TYPE 5
of business culture
• China business
• Prayer and miracle
Professor Kam-hon Lee 35
37. Righteousness & Profitableness
H Richard Niebuhr Negotiation
Types Styles
5 types 5 styles
Equal righteousness Different profitableness
Professor Kam-hon Lee 37