Recomendados
Recomendados
Más contenido relacionado
Último
Último (20)
Destacado
Destacado (20)
Seeing Things from a Different Angle: Discovering Diverse Perspectives about Claims
- 1. SEEING THINGS FROM A DIFFERENT ANGLE: DISCOVERING DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES ABOUT CLAIMS SIHAO CHEN, DANIEL KHASHABI, WENPENG YIN, CHRIS CALLISON-BURCH, DAN ROTH D2 ANDO NAACL 2019 1
- 3. • Warrant, Data Warrant, Perspective( ), Premise, Reason … Reason Warrant Premise (Eemeren + 1987 ?) (Habernal + 2018) Term • Backing Evidence ARGUMENT MINING 3 Warrant Premise (Freeman 2011)
- 5. 5
- 6. EVIDENCE • (Aharoni+ 2014) Reason 1,392, Evidence: 1,291 • Web (debate ) (Wachsmuth+ 2017) 6 Claim Evidence
- 7. CONTRIBUTION • • Perspective • Claim • Perspective • Perspective • Perspective Stance • Perspective Evidence 7 Perspective Reason Claim Reason
- 8. • idebate.com debatewise.org procon.org • 1k claim 8k Perspective 8k Evidence 8
- 9. • Mturk Support Oppose 4 + invalid perspective • 10(Claim + perspective) 3 Worker ρ≥0.5 • 10 Claims Perspective Worker 94% • Perspective 8,135 → 4,652 9
- 10. • Mturk Perspective • Mturk • Perspective • Perspective 4,652 + 4,567 10
- 11. WEB • Bing Claim+Perspective 10 • Mturk • Perspective 4,652 + 4,567 +2,427 11
- 12. • Claim Perspective • Perspective • 350 Claim Perspective 12
- 13. EVIDENCE • Evidence 8 Perspective Mturk Evidence Perspective • 4 20 Evidences • 87.7% 13
- 14. • Mturk Claim World, Politics, Society 14
- 15. Train / dev / test = 60 / 15 / 25 • IR Perspective Evidence • BERT • 15
- 16. T1: Perspective T2: Perspective Stance T3: Perspective T4: Perspective Evidence 16 IR TOP60 IR TOP15