15. •When your healthcare provider talks in clear terms
•When you are able to listen actively, absorb the key points,
and understand and retain the information
•When both parties are able to understand each other
without confusion
35. Education: Children and Families Act –
Importance of Section 19 Principles:
Section 19 CFA provides that:
“In exercising a function under this Part in the case of a
child or young person, a local authority… must have
regard to…
the need to support the child and his or her parent, or the
young person, in order to facilitate the development of the
child or young person and to help him or her achieve the
best possible educational and other outcomes.”
Applies to everything done under Children and Families Act
39. EHC Plans – Health Sections
• Section C – Health care needs relating to the young person’s
SEN
• Section G – Health Care provision reasonably required – the
Clinical Commissioning Group CCG has veto
• If the plan specifies health care provision, the responsible
commissioning body must arrange the specified health care
provision for the child or young person.
40. Health: Multi-Disciplinary Assessment of Needs
• Behaviour
• Cognition (understanding)
• Communication
• Psychological/emotional needs
• Mobility
• Nutrition (food and drink)
• Continence
• Skin (including wounds and ulcers)
• Breathing
• Symptom control through drug
therapies and medication
• Altered states of consciousness
• Other significant needs
“These needs are then given a weighting
marked "priority", "severe", "high",
"moderate", "low" or "no needs".
“If you have at least one priority need, or
severe needs in at least two areas, you
should be eligible for NHS continuing
healthcare.
“You may also be eligible if you have a
severe need in one area plus a number of
other needs, or a number of high or
moderate needs, depending on their
nature, intensity, complexity or
unpredictability.”
www.nhs.uk Eligibility for NHS Continuing
Healthcare
43. EHC Plans – Care Sections
• Section D – Social care needs relating to the child’s SEN
• Section H – Social care for under 18’s as reasonably required under
section 2 of the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act 1970 and
under the Care Act 2014 for those over 18
• Any other social care provision reasonably required by the learning
difficulties and disabilities which result in the child or young person
having special educational needs
• LA can take account of resources when deciding whether ‘necessary’
(not just desirable) to provide service
• BUT once accepted to be necessary to provide service, must provide
sufficient service to meet need
44.
45. Quality of Life Matters
Happy Talk
“Happy talkin’, talkin Happy talk,
Talk about things you’d like to do
You’ve got to have a dream,
If you don’t have a dream,
How you gonna have a dream
come true?”
South Pacific Musical Happy Talk" as written by
Richard Rodgers Oscar Hammerstein II
46.
47.
48. “Knowledge is Power” – Sir Francis Bacon
Education
• Children and Families Act 2014
• New SEN regulations and the introduction of
Education Health and Care Plans
Health
• Personal health budgets available from April 2014
• Continuing Healthcare eligibility criteria Guidance for
children and young adults updated January 2016
• Health needs included in EHC plans from September
2014
Social Care
• Chronically Sick and Disabled Children’s Act 1970
• Care Act 2014
52. Lennox Gastaut Syndrome
• Age of onset – 1-7 years of age
• Seizure types – tonic (mostly nocturnal), atonic, myoclonic, atypical absence, generalized
tonic clonic, focal
• Associated EEG pa6erns – generalized 1-2hz slow spike and wave, generalized slowing,
paroxysmal fast acNvity (recruiNng rhythm) during sleep (see figures)
• Common e9ologies – variety of eNologies, proceeded by infanNle spasms in 9-40% of
cases
• Treatment – felbamate, clobazam, rufinamide, topiramate, zonisamide, ketogenic diet,
valproate, leveNracetam, VNS, corpus callosotomy, focal corNcal resecNon (if there is a
focus)
• Prognosis – moderate to severe intellectual impairment, usually correlates with eNology
and seizure control
American Epilepsy Society 2015
EEG: Slow Spike and Wave EEG: Paroxysmal Fast AcNvity
62. The history of epilepsy geneNcs
1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010
CHRNA4
GABRG2
SCN1B
SCN1A
Copy number
variant
revoluNon
Ion channel disorders
> 100 candidate gene studies
with negative results
Courtesy of Ingo Helbig
Next generaNon sequenc
bubble
82. Current and Emerging
Pharmacological Therapies for LGS
(Including Cannabidiol)
J Helen Cross
UCL-Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health,
London & Young Epilepsy, Lingfield.
4th June 2017
83. Treatment in Lennox Gastaut
Syndrome
• Principles of treatment of epilepsy
• Treatments used in Lennox Gastaut Syndrome
• What is the evidence?
• Is there variability of use?
• Newer agents on the horizon
84. Principles of Treatment
• Choose baseline medication
• One change at a time
• Start low, go slow
• Formulate a plan
• Discuss possible side affects at outset
• Reassess
• Limited role of levels (NB phenytoin, concern re
toxicity/compliance)
86. Problems
• Trials
• Aim to demonstrate safety and efficacy – rarely
comparative studies (SANAD)
• are predominantly in adult patients
• are predominantly in patients with focal seizures
• EMEA has relaxed data required for epilepsy
where little age difference eg focal seizures
• Rarely obtain syndrome specific efficacy
• Availability
87. ‘Randomised Controlled Trials’
• Randomisation limits the potential for selection
bias
• Blinding minimises information and investigator
bias
• Precision determined by sufficient sample size,
accurate assessment of outcome endpoints
88. • Short term efficacy
relative to comparator
• Common adverse
events
• Pharmacokinetic data
• Optimal dosage
• Benefit relative to other
comparators/existing
drugs
• Long term
retention/benefit
• Related comorbidity
• Seizure aggravation
• Synergistic action with
other drugs
What do the trials tell
us?
What the trials don’t tell
us?
89. Objectives in treatment
• What are our current treatment strategies in LGS?
• What medications have we available?
• What can we expect from AED treatment?
• Are there alternatives to AEDs – what are the likely
outcomes?
• How do we monitor effect?
• What expectations should we discuss with
families?
90. First line therapy – expert
opinion
Wheless et al, J Child Neurol 2005;20s1:s1-56
91. Sodium valproate:
clinical experience in LGS
• No controlled clinical trials
• review of 336 patients (38 with LGS) given 400–3000 mg/day
• ≥50% improvement in myoclonic astatic seizures seen for
11/11 patients on monotherapy and 10/27 on polytherapy1
• Reviews and opinion
• overall 25–30% of patients attain ≥50% improvement2
• reduction in number of atypical absences and myoclonic seizures3,4
• poor efficacy versus tonic seizures, drop attacks and
tonic-clonic seizures2,4
• efficacy greater in cryptogenic versus symptomatic LGS5
1. Covanis A. et al. Sodium valproate: monotherapy and polytherapy. Epilepsia 1982;23:693–720
2. Pisani et al. [Lennox-Gestaut syndrome: therapeutic aspects]. Riv Neurol 1989;59:217–9
3. Schmidt D, Bourgeois B. A risk-benefit assessment of therapies for Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. Drug Saf 2000;22:467–77
4. Markand ON. Lennox-Gastaut syndrome (childhood epileptic encephalopathy). J Clin Neurophysiol 2003;20:426–41
5. Glauser TA, Morita DA. e medicine 2006. URL: http://www.emedicine.com/neuro/topic186.htm
94. Conclusions: Cochrane review
• Optimum treatment for Lennox-Gastaut syndrome
remains uncertain
• No study has shown any drug to be highly efficacious in
treatment of LGS
• Lamotrigine, topiramate, felbamate and rufinamide may
be helpful as add on therapy
• Evidence base for one therapy over another limited; each
patient needs to be considered individually, taking into
account potential benefit of each therapy vs risk of
adverse effects
Hancock E, Cross H. Treatment of Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013;CD003277.
97. Continued seizures – what next?
• Have you the correct diagnosis?
• Is it epilepsy?
• Have you a syndrome diagnosis?
• Have you used an appropriate drug?
• What is the likelihood of response?
• What drug next?
• Should alternative treatments be considered?
99. Drug Combinations
• Assume 10 commonly used drugs
How many combinations of 1, 2 or 3 drugs are
possible?
Is the probability of any particular combination of
drugs working independent of previous
medications?
101. What is a ‘New’ Treatment?
A new medication
A new way of
management
New data on
old treatment
102. What is the likelihood ‘new’ medication will
work?
Kwan & Brodie NEJM 2000;342: 314-319
• 525 patients age 9-23 years
• 333 (63%) SF during or after treatment
• 470 previously untreated
• 222 (47%) SF with initial drug
• 67 (14%) SF during second or third
• If first drug not effective - 11% SF
Camfield & Camfield Epilepsia 2007;48:1128-1132
• 692 children followed over 20 years; 80 symptomatic
• 17 LGS highest risk of intractability (94%; p<0.001 compared to
all others)
103. Seizure freedom with additional
drugs?
285 drug additions in 155 patients; 16% resulted in seizure freedom (28% SF)
Luciano & Shorvon. Ann Neurol 2007
Median 20 months assessment
104. How do we measure treatment effect?
• Single centre studies likely to have relatively small
proportion of LGS
• AED effect likely to have to be determined on
individual basis
• ? Studies require review of alternative outcome
measures to seizure frequency
105. How do we measure treatment effect?
• Seizure frequency
• Seizure type? Over what time frame?
• Frequency of emergency medication
• Admissions to hospital
• Attendance in school
• Cognitive and behavioural effects
• Can they be quantified within a trial situation
• Lack of relevant standardised tests
• ‘Quality of life’ specific goals different in each child
• What is clinically relevant?
107. Zonisamide*
tolerability & safety
Safety Ohtahara & Yamatogi 2004
• 1512 patients – 928 children
• 244/928 reported adverse events
• 18.9% monotherapy; 30.4% polytherapy
• Most common adverse events
• Mental/psychiatric 19.4% (includes mental
function, motivation or volition)
• Gastrointestinal symptoms 8.7%
• Neurological symptoms 5.8%
* Licensed for add on therapy in refractory partial seizures >18 years
108. Cannabis
• Cannabis: for the most part, Cannabis sativa.
• One of the most widely used recreational and medicinal
drugs worldwide.
• ~150 million people smoking cannabis daily (WHO)
• Likely the first non-food plant cultivated by humans (~8000
BC)
• Best known for its psychoactive constituent, Δ9-
tetrahydrocannabinol (‘THC’).
109. The endocannabinoid system
• First described in the late
1980s/early 1990s
• Endogenous ligands, receptors,
synthetic and degradation
enzymes
• Cannabinoid receptors:
• cell surface receptors
• present on a wide variety of cell
types.
• two CBR types:
• CB1:
• CB2:
• Endocannabinoids:
• anandamide
• 2-arachidonoyl glycerol
• Numerous synthetic ligands for
CB1Rs and CB2Rs have also
been developed
Anandamide 2-arachidonoyl glycerol (2-AG)
Courtesy of Dr Ben Whalley
110. Summary of historical preclinical
evidence
• Large preclinical evidence base asserting mixed effects on
seizures in animal models
29
Compound
Species
Number of discrete
conditions/models/designs
Dose Anticonvulsant
No
effect
Proconvulsant
THC 6 31
0.25-200
mg/kg
61% 29% 10%*
CBD 2 21
1-400
mg/kg
81% 19% 0%
Other plant
cannabinoids
2 7 N/A 100% 0% 0%
CB1 receptor
agonists
2 55 N/A 73% 18%
2%
(7% mixed effect)
*Includes non-seizure studies where convulsions were reported (see next slide)
Whalley (2014) Cannabis and Seizures American Herbal Pharmacopeia
111. No reliable conclusions can be drawn at present regarding the efficacy of cannabinoids as
a treatment for epilepsy. The dose of 200 to 300 mg daily of cannabidiol was safely
administered to small numbers of patients generally for short periods of time, and so the
safety of long term cannabidiol treatment cannot be reliably assessed.
Four randomized trial reports, 48 patients, each of which used cannabidiol as the treatment
agent.
One report was an abstract and another was a letter to the editor. Anti-epileptic drugs
were continued in all studies. Details of randomisation were not included in any study report.
There was no investigation of whether the control and treatment participant groups were
the same or different. All the reports were low quality.
The four reports only answered the secondary outcome about adverse effects. None of the
patients in the treatment groups suffered adverse effects.
Cannabinoids for epilepsy
D Gloss & B Vickery
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2014, Issue 3.
Art.No.: CD009270.
112. The British Journal of Psychiatry (2011) 198, 442–447.
• 104 chronic cannabis,
• 49 early-onset users
• 55 late-onset users
• 44 controls
• No differences in IQ, vocabulary or block
design
• The early-onset group had
• more perseverative errors
• completed fewer categories on the WCST and
on the Stroop test, poorer performance on
the FAB
115. Cannabinoids: GW Pharma
• Pure cannabidiol and cannabidivarin; almost
insignificant THC
• CBD is one of two major cannabinoids in Sativex
• Human exposure to pure CBD in clinical trials has
been limited
116. FDA IND; open label protocol
Epidiolex (CBD)
Inclusion criteria
• Intractable early onset epilepsy
• < 3 AEDs (not including VNS or KD)
• Non progressive disorder
• No significant laboratory abnormalities
Protocol
• 4 week baseline seizure diary
• CBD 5mg/kg/day
• Titrated at 2-5mg/kg increments until tolerance or max 25mg/kg/day
• Labs for FBC, Liver, kidney function & AED levels 4, 8 and 12 weeks
Devinsky, Sullivan, Friedman, Thiele, Marsh, Laux, Hedlund,
Tilton, Bruno, Bluvstein, Cilio
117. Cannabidiol in childhood epilepsy
• 214 patients across 11
sites
• safety & tolerability 167
• Adverse events 79%
• 137 efficacy analysis
Dravet N=32
49% responders, 3% SF
LGS N=30
37% responders, 3% SF
Lancet Neurology e-pub ahead of print 15th December 2015
118. Conclusion: cannabidiol might reduce seizure frequency and might have an adequate
safety profile in children and young adults with highly treatment-resistant epilepsy.
Lancet Neurology 2016;15:270-8
Safety analysis (N=162)
Somnolence 41 (25%)
Decreased appetite 31 (19%)
Diarrhoea 31 (19%)
Fatigue 21 (13%)
Convuslsion 18 (11%)
Increased appetite 14 (9%)
Status epilepticus 13 (8%)
Lethargy 12 (7%)
Weight increased 12 (7%)
Weight decreased 10 (6%)
119. AED interaction; clobazam
13/25 children CBD 2—
25mg/kg/day
Mass General Hospital,
Boston
Norclobazam increased in
12/13
Side effects 10/13
• Drowsiness 6
• Ataxia 2
• Irritability 2
• Restless sleep 1
• Urinary retention 1
• Tremor 1
• Loss of appetite 1
Geffrey et al, Epilepsia, 56(8):1246–1251, 2015
120. >50% reduction
• Clobazam 36/70 (51%)
• No clobazam 18/67 (27%)
Multiple logistic regression
clobazam use only
independent predictor of
reduction >50% in motor
seizures
Lancet Neurology 2016;15:270-8
122. Cannabidiol dose and label accuracy in edible
medical cannabis products
JAMA June 23/30, 2015 Volume 313, Number 24
August to October 2014; individuals sent to dispensaries in San Francisco, Los Angeles,
and Seattle, USA.
Entire package contents were assessed
123. • Anecdotal, open label and now RCT evidence of benefit -
short term tolerability evident
• Need for further trial data
Efficacy
Safety
• Long term safety/tolerability & sustained efficacy requires
evaluation – pure CBD vs ?THC
• Possible wider benefits in comorbidities (eg anxiety
disorders, cognition) requires further consideration
Where are we now with
cannabinoids?
124. UCL - Institute of Child Health
New and Emerging Therapies in Epilepsy
Paediatric Epilepsy Update
9th September 2016
Sophia Varadkar, MRCPI, PhD
Consultant Paediatric Neurologist & Honorary Senior Lecturer
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust
and UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health, London, UK
125. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Disclosures
• I have received educational travel support and
honoraria for speaking engagements from
LivaNova and UCB with remuneration paid to my
department
126. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Outline
1. Introduction
2. Drug
i. Novel targets
ii. Re-purposing
iii. Re-visiting
iv. Concept of precision
therapies
3. Non-drug
i. Ketogenic diet
ii. (Metabolic epilepsies)
iii. Stimulation therapies
iv. (Epilepsy surgery)
v. Immune therapies
128. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Expectations of treatment and treatment
response in epilepsy
• Common
• Not just one condition
• Treatment aim is seizure freedom
• Achieved with the first drug in 70%
• Achieved with the second drug in a
further 10-20%
129. UCL - Institute of Child Health
ILAE Consensus Definition
Failure of:
• adequate trials of
• two tolerated
• appropriately chosen
• and used AED
schedules
(monotherapy or
combination)
• to achieve seizure
freedom
130. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Quantifying the response to AEDs:
Effect of past treatment history
Schiller, Y. et al. Neurology 2008;70:54-65
How many drugs should you try?
131. UCL - Institute of Child Health
AED development
1910 1920 19301940 1950 19601970 19801990 2000 2010
phenobarbitone phenytoin
lamotrigine
sodium valproate
carbamazepine
tiagabine
zonisamide
perampanel
clobazam
stiripentol
lacosamide
topiramate
gabapentin
vigabatrin
levetiracetam
ketogenic diet
Slide courtesy of Prof Helen Cross
132. UCL - Institute of Child Health
2. New in treatment - Drug
i. Novel targets
a. Neuronal synapse
b. Other sites
ii. Re-purposing drugs used in other
diseases
iii. Re-visiting drugs used for other
epilepsies or abandoned in the past
133. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Site of action of
AEDs at the
neuronal synapse
Bialer & White; Nature Reviews Drug Discovery
2010: 68-82
• Consider a new drug
which acts on a
different site
• Consider synergism
134. UCL - Institute of Child Health
New sites of action
• Perampanel – post-synaptic AMPA receptors
• Cannabadiol – CB1 and CB2 receptor ligand
• (Retigabine – potassium channel)
135. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Perampanel – novel site at the neuronal
synapse
136. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Perampanel - highly selective, non-competitive, post-
synaptic AMPA receptor antagonist
Redrawn and adapted from [2] and [3].1Hanada et al. Epilepsia 2011;52:1331–1340;
2Rogawski MA, Löscher W. Nat Rev Neurosci 2004;5:553–564; 3Rogawski MA. Epilepsy Currents 2011;11:56–63. 13
Post-synaptic neuron
Pre-synaptic
neuron
Inhibitory interneuron
Post-synaptic excitability
AMPA receptor
Glutamate
NMDA receptor
137. UCL - Institute of Child Health
% of patients achieving ≥50% reduction from baseline in seizure
frequency/28 days
*P<0.05 vs placebo
**P<0.005 vs placeboN=45
N=21
N=13
N=44
N=20
ITT population: studies 304,305 &306, pooled. Double-blind phase
1Data on file, Eisai Inc; 2Rosenfeld et al. 2012 CNS; 3ISE Table 14.2. 2.2
Responder rate
14
Responderrate(%)
Overall
Population1
N=1478
Adolescents
(306)2
N=60
Adolescents
(304 & 305)2
N=83
Adolescents
(Pooled)3
N=143
N=441
N=180
N=172
N=431
N=254
N=14
N=21
N13
N=12
N=31
N=32
N=20
Adolescents
*
*
*
*
*
Krauss GL et al. Neurology 2012;78(18):1408--1415; French JA et al. Neurology 2012;79:589–596: French JA et al.
Epilepsia. Epub 20 Aug 2012; 4Krauss GL et al. Epilepsia. Epub 20 Aug 2012.
138. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Perampanel – personal view
• It works
• Even seizure freedom
• Even 2mg can be helpful
• Prevention of evolution to
bilateral convulsive
• Long half-life
• Introduce very slowly
Bad
• Aggression can prevent
ongoing use
• Dizziness to be expected
• Can see overshoot
• Interaction with other
drugs – exacerbates
lamotrigine side-effects
Good
139. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Cannabinoids – a (not so) new drug
140. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Historical use of cannabis in epilepsy
• Been around for millenia!
141. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Cannabinoids
Receptors
• Endogenous cannabinoid
receptors identified in
1988
– CB1
– CB2
• Cannabinoids are ligands
at these receptors
3 groups
• Endocannabinoids -
endogenous
• Phytocannabinoids –
plant derived Cannabis
sativa
• Synthetic Cannabinoids
142. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Two major cannabinoids
THC
• analgesic, anti-
spasmodic, anti-tremor,
anti-inflammatory,
appetite stimulant and
anti-emetic properties
CBD
• Anti-inflammatory, anti-
convulsant, anti-psychotic,
anti-oxidant,
neuroprotective and
immunomodulatory effects.
• Lacks the psychotomimetic
and psychotropic effects of
THC
• May alleviate some of the
potentially unwanted side-
effects of THC.
143. UCL - Institute of Child Health
What our patients are reading about
‘Charlotte Figi who suffered from Dravet’s syndrome - through treatments
using Cannabidiol, her seizure frequency went from hundreds per week, to
only a few per month.’
144. UCL - Institute of Child Health
CBD for epilepsy so far
Efficacy
• 50% responders, 3%
seizure free
– Devinsky, Lancet
Neurology 2015
– Friedman, NEJM 2015
Emerging experience
• Side-effects
– Somnolence
– Decreased appetite
– Diarrhoea
– Tremor
• Interaction with clobazam
– Geffrey, Epilepsia 2015
• Abnormal liver function
• Up to 25-50 mg/kg/day
• Tolerance
145. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Tuberose Sclerosis – novel targets away from
the neuronal synapse
146. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Tuberose Sclerosis – novel targets away from
the neuronal synapse
• mTOR inhibitors – rapamycin/
everolimus
• Used for SEGA
• Used for renal angiomyolipomata
• Ketogenic diet and vigabatrin
have effects via the mTOR
pathway
• Use for epilepsy?
– Krueger et al Ann Neurol 2013
– Cardamone et al J Peds 2014
(Sirolimus)
– Exist 3 trial
147. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Repurposing & precision therapies
148. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Neonatal epileptic
encephalopathies
1
month
4
months0 1 year
6
months
Epilepsy limited to females with
mental retardation
PCDH19
Early onset epileptic
encephalopathy
STXBP1, CDKL5, ARX,
PLCB1, SLC25A22,
SPTN1, SLC19A3
Early myoclonic
encephalopathy
Infantile epileptic encephalopathies
KCNQ2
encephalopathy
Epilepsy in infancy with migrating
focal seizures
SCN1A, KCNT1, PLCB1
Dravet syndrome
SCN1A
West syndrome
CDKL5 in girls
ARX in boys
Copy Number Variants 8%
Genetic basis of the Early Infantile Epileptic Encephalopathies
Slide courtesy of Prof Helen Cross
149. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Repurposing & precision therapies
Loss of function
mutations
Gain of function
mutations
• KCNT1
• SCN2A
• KCNQ2
• SCN1A
150. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Repurposing & precision therapies
Loss of function
mutations
Gain of function
mutations
• KCNT1
• SCN2A
• KCNQ2
• SCN1A
151. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Weckhuysen et al Neurology 2013;1697-703
152. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Retigabine/Ezogabine
• First-in-class K+
channel opener
• FDA Drug Safety
Communication 2013
– retinal abnormalities
and skin discoloration
• FDA 2015
– Manage risks
• 2016 – production
being discontinued
Gunthorpe Epilepsia 2012
153. UCL - Institute of Child Health
KCNT1- precision therapy?
Epilepsy of infancy with
migrating focal seizures
• Gain of function mutation
• Therefore use a Na
channel blocker from
cardiology
– Quinidine; reverses gain of
function in vitro (Milligan et
al)
– Mexilitine
Quinidine
• Favourable response in
one patient
– Bearden, Ann Neurol 2014
• Our experience- 2 cases
treated: 1 no response; 1
no response and severe
pulmonary vasculopathy
• in vitro response to
Quinidine does not
always predict clinical
response
154. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Repurposing & precision therapies & re-
visiting
Loss of function
mutations
Gain of function
mutations
• SCN2A and SCN8A
• Use Na channel blockers
– High dose phenytoin and
carbazepine
• SCN1A
– Avoid Na channel blockers
– CBD
– Revisting ‘old’ drugs
155. UCL - Institute of Child Health
SCN1A - re-visiting fenfluramine
• High doses used for obesity, heart valve thickening, taken
off market
• Effective for self-induced/photosensitive seizures
– Boel, Neuropediatrics 1996
• Effective in Dravet syndrome
– Ceulemans, Epilepsia 2012
• Mechanism uncertain: stimulates serotonin; 5HT2A
agonist?
• Randomised placebo control trial beginning in Europe and
US
157. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Ketogenic diet
• A high fat diet,
designed to mimic the
metabolic effects of
starvation, used in the
treatment of epilepsy
• Modified Atkin’s Diet
for teenagers and
adults
158. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Ketogenic diet – decanoic acid
• Seizure control by
decanoic acid through
direct AMPA receptor
inhibition
– Chang, Brain 2015
• ↑DA:OA could make
diet better
• Seizure control by
ketogenic diet-
associated medium
chain fatty acids
• Chang,
Neuropharmacology
2013
• Now tolerability trials -
‘Betashot’ with low glycaemic
diet
• To improve outcome of
epilepsy surgery
160. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Treatment of symptoms
• Seizures
– Anti-epileptic drugs
• limited effect, aim to prevent bilateral convulsive
• Topiramate
• Perampanel for EPC – Gode J Epileptology 2016
– Botox for EPC Lozsadi Neurology 2004
– Steroids
– (VNS, TMS)
161. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Immune basis to RE
• Antibody-mediated CNS degeneration
• T-cell cytoxicity
• Microglial-induced degeneration
– mTOR activation co-localising with microglial activation,
Liu Acta Neuropath Comm 2014
• Inflammatory gene expression
• Up-regulation of HMGB1 and toll-like receptor in
surgical specimens
– Luan Epilepsy Research 2016
162. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Treatment directed against the primary
process
In 1990s and 2000s
• Plasmaphoresis
• Immunoglobulin
• Steroids
• Immunosuppressive
therapy
Tacrolimus Bien et al 2004
Azathioprine Varadkar et al
2011
Monoclonal antibodies
• Rituximab
– Laxer Epilepsia 2008
• Natalizumab
– Bittner Neurology 2013
• Adalimumab
– Lagarde Epilepsia 2016
– Cognitive stabilisation?
163. UCL - Institute of Child Health
VNS Therapy: next generation device –
what’s new?
164. UCL - Institute of Child Health
What we already knew
Benefits of magnet mode
stimulation
• May abort or decrease
severity of seizures1-3
• May improve postictal
recovery2
• Offers more control for
patients and their
families1,2
What about missed
treatment opportunities?
• By day/night
• What if magnet mode
didn’t rely on a person?
1. Boon P, et al. J Clin Neurophys. 2001;18:402-407.
2. Fromes GW, et al. Epilepsia. 2000;41(suppl 7):117.
3. Schachter SC and Saper CB. Epilepsia.
1998;39:677-686.
165. UCL - Institute of Child Health
New Generation VNS Therapy
AspireSR What’s new?
– (Standard VNS
Therapy stimulation
with on-demand
magnet stimulation)
– DNA™ Technology
• Seizure detection
algorithm based on
ictal tachycardia
• Automatic stimulation
upon seizure
detection
Detect, No)fy, Act, cardiac-based
detec)on system
166. UCL - Institute of Child Health
43
Seizure Detec?on
Threshold
Background
Heart Rate
Foreground
Heart Rate
How Does Seizure Detection Based Upon
Ictal Tachycardia Work?
Detec?on algorithm – Live Example
Data on file, Cyberonics Inc . Houston Tx
Foreground heart rate = short term average (~10 seconds)
reacts quickly to heart rate
changes
Background heart rate = long term average (~5 minutes)
reacts slowly to heart rate
changes
167. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Aspire SR: E36 study
• European multi-centre study
• Prospective, unblinded
• Recorded vEEG and ECG,
ictal and non-ictal in the EMU
• Looking at performance,
safety and efficacy
168. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Decision at GOSH to implant Aspire SR
• Do our children get ictal tachycardia?
– At first, we implanted those with confirmed ictal
tachycardia on VT
• Standard VNS therapy plus
– Bigger battery
– Auto-stimulation
– So, greater dosing
• Early impression is of earlier response
169. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Potentially treatable metabolic epilepsies?
NCL2 (Late infantile Battens) Intra-ventricular enzyme-
replacement therapy
NCL6 (variant of late infantile
Battens)
Intra-thecal viral vector gene
therapy
Pyridoxine dependent epilepsy Lysine restriction diets
Molybdenum cofactor and
sulphite oxidase deficiencies
Purified cyclic pyranopterin
monophosphate IV
170. UCL - Institute of Child Health
Summary
• Though there has been a slowing of drug-
discovery, treatment options for drug-resistant
epilepsy continue to expand
• Novel sites and modes of action are promising
avenues to explore
• C10 medium chain fatty acid may be key in the
ketogenic diet
• VNS Aspire SR device has a cardiac based
seizure detection algorithm which may enhance
stimulation therapy
171. UCL - Institute of Child Health
New and Emerging Therapies in Epilepsy
Paediatric Epilepsy Update
9th September 2016
Sophia Varadkar, MRCPI, PhD
Consultant Paediatric Neurologist & Honorary Senior Lecturer
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust
and UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health, London, UK
172. Ketogenic Diets
in the treatment of LGS
patients
Dr Chris(n Eltze
Consultant Paediatric Neurologist
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children
173. KD – treatments in LGS
• What are ketogenic Diets ?
• How does it work ?
• What’s the evidence for effec(veness?
• When should KD be considered ?
• What about side effects ?
• How can KD treatments be accessed ?
• Other dietary therapies and new research
174.
175.
176. History
• Fasting suppresses seizure activity:
• Conklin (J Am Osteopathic Assoc 1922;26:11-14)
Early reports of improving seizure control
‘patient deprived of food……up to 25 days’
178. MCT Ketogenic Diet
Modified Ketogenic Diet (MOD)Classical Ketogenic Diet 4:1
E. Neal, 2012
Dietary Treatment of Epilepsy, Wiley-Blackell
179. Classical Ketogenic Diet (CKD):
(Long Chain Triglycerides)
• Using standard food for
composi(on of meals plans:
2:1, 3:1 or 4:1 -
fat: (carbohydrate + protein) ra(o
• Up to 90% of total calories from
fat
• Meal/snack recipes, all in correct
ra(o
185. How does in work ?
• Exact mechanisms unknown - many hypotheses
• Effects mediated by polyunsaturated fa_y acids
• Ketosis induces shibs in brain amino acid handling favouring GABA produc(on
• Suppression of seizures mediated by adenosine ac(ng on adenosine A1 receptors
• Reduc(on of toxic waste products in the brain cells
• Improve energy produc(on pathways in the cell
• Reduce cell death in some animal models
• Supresses inflamma(on
• Changes ‘biochemical state’ of body
• Cells use ketones ( derived from fa_y acids ) as main source of energy
• Complex adap(ve processes take place
→ Enhance suppression of seizure ac(vity
Excita(on
Inhibi(on
Epilep(c seizure
Excita(on Inhibi(on
186. Neuroprotective effects of KD
Maalouf et al 2009 , Brain Research Reviews
• Improvement of mitochondrial
func(on
• Decrease of reac(ve oxygen species –
reduc(on of oxida(ve stress
• Increased ATP produc(on
• Inhibi(on of apoptosis
• An(-inflammatory effects
Potential role of KD
following brain trauma and
in neurodegenerative
conditions
189. Efficacy in childhood epilepsy
D Keene Ped Neurol 2006;35:1-5
A systematic review
• 26 studies;14 met criteria for inclusion, mostly
retrospec=ve, no control group
• Outcome measures degree of seizure control,
dura=on pa=ent remained on diet, occurrence of
adverse events
• Total collec=ve popula=on 972 pa=ents
• At 6m
• 15.6% (CI 10.4-20.8) seizure free
• 33.0% (CI 24-41.8) >50% reduc=on
190. Newer studies:
comparing KD vs control group (not on
KD)Study N Age
(y)
Type of
KD
Dura=on
(months)
> 50% sz
reduc=on
> 90 sz reduc=on Seizure free
Neal et al 2008 1451 2-16 CKD
MCT
3 KD: 28/73 (38%)
C: 4/72 (6%)
KD: 5/72 (7%)
C: 0
KD: 0
C:0
Sharma et a 2013 1022 2-14 MOD 3 KD: 26/50 (52%)
C: 6/52 (11.5%)
KD:15/50 (30%)
C: 4/52 (7.7%)
KD: 5 (10%)
C: 0
Lambrechts et al
2017
483 1-18 MCT, CKD 4 KD: 13/26 (50%)
C: 4/22 (18.5%)
KD: 3/26 (11.5%)
C: 1/22(4.5%)
KD: 3 (11.5%)
C: 2 (9%)
1 14 (~ 10%) with LGS, 2 47 (46%) with LGS, 31 pa(ent with LGS
191. Which KD type works better ?
• Classical KD versus MCT
• Neal et al , Epilepsia 50(5):1109-1117, 2009 (45 on Classical, 49 on
MCT; age 2-16y)
• both KD types have comparable efficacy (no significant difference between
mean percentage of baseline seizures at 3,6 and 12 months)
• Classical KD versus MOD
• Kim et al, Epilepsia, 57(1):51-58, 2016,(51 on Classical, 53 on MOD; age 1-18y)
• Mean percentage of baseline seizures:
• Aber 3 months: Classical KD 38.6%, MOD 47.9%
• Aber 6 month: Classical KD 33.8%, MOD 44.6%
• Difference not sta(s(cally significant in overall group
197. Ketogenic Diet - Side Effects
• Gastrointes=nal symptoms:
• nausea, vomi(ng (worsening of Gastro-oesophageal Reflux), cons(pa(on
• Low blood Sugar (occasionally in ini(a(on phase)
• Excess ketosis – acidosis (ini(a(on phase)
• Renal stones (3-6%)
• Risk factors: young age, hypercalciuria, (tx with carbonic anhydrase
inhibitors: Topiramate, Zonisamide)
• Preven(on – potassium citrate (alkalinisa(on of urine)
reduc(on from 6.7 to 0.9 % (McNally et al, Pediatrics, 2009)
• Increased Bruising (Berry-Kravis et al, Ann Neurol 2000)
• Weight loss, Inadequate growth
• Pancrea((s
• Hyperlipidaemia
• Decreased bone density – fractures (Long-term treatment)
198. When to consider KD treatment
• Seizures despite of AED treatment
(usually - failure of ≥ 2 AEDs)
• Poor tolerance to AEDs
• (Rare) Metabolic disorders affec(ng
• transport of glucose from blood into brain
• Glut 1 transporter deficiency syndrome
• Metabolism of glucose
• Pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency
199. How can KD treatments be accessed ?
• Discuss referral to Ketogenic Diet Service with your Paediatrician,
(Paediatric) Neurologist
• KD-Team:
• Doctor (Paediatric Neurologist)
• Die((an
• Epilepsy Nurse Specialist
⇒ Detailed assessment
• Exclude contraindica(ons (i.e. rare metabolic condi(ons)
• Recommend to address feeding difficul(es, ea(ng disorders and swallowing problems
before (feeding support may be required)
⇒ Provide more informa(on and discuss which KD type most suitable
⇒ Agree with you treatment goals
200. When would be the KD be
contraindicated ?• Metabolic condi(ons
• Beta-Fa_y oxida(on defects
• Organic acidurias
• Pyruvate carboxylase deficiency (lac(c acidosis)
• Rela(ve contraindica(ons
• Feeding difficul(es (food refusal)
• Swallowing problems (alterna(ve feeding route: NG tube
or PEG)
• Severe gastro-oesophageal reflux (frequent vomi(ng)
201. Starting on KD
• Outpa(ent setng
(for all pa(ents > 1 year and well)
• Teaching session (Die((an, Nurse Specialist)
• Follow up – regular telephone consulta(ons with die((an in ini(al phase
• Aber 3 months review by KD team (outpa(ent appointment)
• Review progress and treatment goals with pa(ent and family
⇒ Decision to con(nue or stop
202. Ketogenic Diet – Duration of
Treatment
• Aber 3 months assess efficacy
• Consensus statement Kossoff et al Epilepsia, 50(2):304–317, 2009
• First effects aber 2 weeks
• Dura=on of treatment
• Ini(ally up to 2 years (than taper diet)
• in sz free pa(ents sz control oben maintained
20% relapsed aber discon(nua(on
(Mar(nez et al 2007, Epilepsia)
• In Glut 1 deficiency syndrome:
• Con(nue into adulthood ? Transi(on to MOD
203. Low GI diet
• ‘Glycaemic Index’
• Fewer fluctua=ons in glucose lead to effec=ve sz control
• Carbohydrate restric=on – 40-60 gm/day
• Muzykewicz et al 2009; Epilepsia
Boston, Massachuse_s
• Retrospec(ve
• N=76 (89% had tried >=3 AEDs)
• > 50% sz reduc(on
• 54% aber 6 month
• 66% aber 12 months
204. C 10 (decanoic acid)
Potential explanation why MCT works
Mitochondria – produce energy in cells
• Increases number and func(on of
mitochondria in cells
• Hughes SD et al, J Neurochem, 2014
• Can suppress epilep(form ac(vity by
blocking AMPA receptors (receptor for
excitatory neurotransmi_er Glutamate)
• Chang et al, Brain 2016
On-going first study to evaluate feasibility of new MCT food product (higher
percentage of C10 )
Chief Inves(gator: Prof M Walker
206. On-going and future Research
• Efficacy of KD in adolescents and adults
• Efficacy and Safety of KD in very young children (<2 years)
• Inves(ga(ng disease modifying effects of KD
• Biomarker – that allow to predict response to KD
• Course of epilepsy once KD is discon(nued
(?disease modifying effect of KD)
• Outcome data should also include development/cogni(on and
behaviour