16. Prioritization Write Tech Note to Governments on why one unified example is or is not possible 4 Draft Unified Example and then specializations. 3 Determine & clearly articulate objectives (see Modeling Guidance) 2 Form Team for SAR Example Upgrade. 1
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26. UPDM/DoDAF 2.0 Its Place and Role in Defense Acquisition Its Place and Role in Defense Acquisition Clarence Moreland Atego Inc. All Rights Reserved
27. JCIDS Analysis Process 03/17/10 The FAA synthesizes existing guidance to specify the military problems to be studied. The FSA takes this assessment as input, and generates recommendations for solutions to the needs. FNA then examines that problem, assesses how well the DOD can address the problem given its current program, and recommends needs the DOD should address. Clarence Moreland Atego Inc. All Rights Reserved Architectures are utilized Throughout
28.
29.
30.
31. Methodology Structure OV-1, OV-5, OV-6c OV-2, OV-4 OV-6 Class & State Diagrams System Performance OV-2, OV-3, SV-1, SV-2, SV-4, SV-6, SV-7, SV-10c Clarence Moreland Atego Inc. All Rights Reserved DoDAF Task Lists Conditions Doctrine Standards Modeling Heuristics Work Organization CONOPS Development Operational Scenarios Definition Architecture Framework Definition CONOPS Development Operational Scenarios Definition Architecture Framework Definition CONOPS Development Operational Scenarios Definition Architecture Framework Definition Functional Area Analysis CONOPS Development Operational Scenarios Definition Architecture Framework Definition Joint Integrating Concept Gap Analysis Gap Analysis Gap Analysis Gap Analysis Find Track Fix Target Access Engage “ As Is” Find Track Fix Find Track Fix Find Find Track Fix Target Access Engage Find Track Fix Target Access Engage “ As Is” Find Track Fix Find Track Fix Find Find Track Fix Target Access Engage Target Access Engage Target Target Access Engage “ As Is ” Constructive Iteration Constructive Iteration Constructive Iteration Functional Needs Analysis Integrated Experiments Performance Definition Measurement Notation
Of course, these simplified inputs and outputs decompose into much more complicated sets of products, and the analyses themselves require much more examination. The point is, however, that a JCIDS CBA is not really different than any other analysis. It must specify the issues, estimate our current and projected abilities, and recommend actions. Note that your CBA may not include an FSA. The current trend in JCIDS for jointly-initiated assessments is to do an FAA and an FNA, and then produce a “Joint Capabilities Document” (JCD), which is sent to the JROC. If the JROC opts to act on the needs identified in the assessment, they will assign a sponsor (typically a Service), to do one or more FSAs. This also means that you may do a CBA which consists of nothing but an FSA. In these cases, you will have to rely on someone else’s FAA and FNA, to include repairing any defects and reacting to subsequent changes in guidance.
There are five types of sememes: two denotational and three connotational, with connotational occurring only in phrase units (they do not reflect the denotation): Denotational 1: Primary denotation, for example "head" (body); Denotational 2: Secondary denotation by resemblance with other denotation: "head" (ship); Connotational 1: High position, as the role or function of "head" in the operation of the human body; Connotational 2: Emotive, e.g., meaning in "honey"; Connotational 3: Evaluative, e.g., meaning in "sneak" – move silently and secretly for a bad purpose Denotation is the specific, literal image, idea, concept, or object that a sign refers to. Connotation is the figurative cultural assumptions that the image implies or suggests. It involves emotional overtones, subjective interpretation, socio-cultural values, and ideological assumptions. Examples: Stop Sign Denotation—Stop (even without words, we recognize the meaning from the shape and color) Connotation—Risk (accident or ticket) Health club ad Denotation—fit person in foreground --> you could look like this Connotation—fit person in background --> you could pick up a date like this in our club
Work organization occupies the highest level because it provides the structure within which the modeling language and its heuristics can be effectively applied, measured, and refined. While a given process may be able to accommodate many variations in heuristics and language, the these elements are the foundation of any methodology, as the directly impact the process and its artifacts.