22. Contrasting Wi-Fi / WiMAX / Cellular
Wi-Fi
CSMA/CA
WiMAX Efficient for unpredictable traffic in an
unlicensed band
Inefficient for predictable traffic (voice)
“Sharing model” designed for unlicensed
• Fast dynamic scheduling band
No control of resource allocation policy
• Contention access for bandwidth
requests only
• Resource allocation exclusively by BS –
retains tight policy control by network
• Efficient for both bursty, unpredictable 2G/3.xG Cellular
traffic and voice
• Packet overlays but based on slot
based, circuit switched resource
allocation
• Efficient for voice traffic
• Inefficient for bursty traffic (email,
http)
WiMAX is the Optimal Solution for Mobile Internet