This presentation was given at a workshop to select indicators for Fish Conservation Zone (FCZ) assessments on November 7 and 8, 2016, in Vientiane, Lao PDR. Many organizations have worked with communities and government officials throughout Lao PDR to establish co-managed FCZs to promote sustainable fisheries, protect fish species, and/or enhance food security However, few resources exist to determine how well these FCZs are performing to meet their objectives. The only way to determine if FCZs are successful is through assessment. FISHBIO's new project seeks to develop an assessment tool in the form of a best-practices guidebook. This guidebook is intended to be a resource that civil society organizations and government counterparts can use to assess and improve the management and performance of FCZs. Another goal of the project is to provide networking opportunities for the many organizations that have been involved in FCZ establishment.
Developing a Guidebook to Assess Fish Conservation Zones in Lao PDR
1. Project Overview: Developing a Guidebook to
Assess Fish Conservation Zones in Lao PDR
Presented by:
Erin Loury| Fisheries Biologist
Funded by:
Critical Ecosystem Partnership Fund
2. What are FCZs?
• Fish Conservation Zones (FCZs) =
areas closed to some or all fishing
• Goals to protect fish populations,
livelihoods, food security
• Lao Fisheries Law (2009): Legal
framework for FCZ co-management
• Responsibility shared between
communities and local government
authorities
• Now more than 1,000 FCZs in Lao
PDR
3. Many Groups Have Helped Establish
FCZs in Lao PDR
*This list is not intended to show all groups
4. Handbook for FCZ Establishment
• 2009 Guidebook by DLF
and WWF
• Step-by-Step Guidelines
for establishing new co-
managed FCZs
• Community consultations,
regulations development
and approval, sign
installation, enforcement
• Next step: FCZ
assessment
5. Tools are Needed for FCZ Assessment
• How do we know if FCZs are
successful? Only way to know
is with assessment
• Fisheries management does
not end with FCZ establishment
• Need to regularly check-in to
assess and adjust management
activities
• Tools are needed to guide the
FCZ assessment process
6. FCZ Assessment is Like Health Check-Ups
1) Take a child to visit
the doctor. The doctor
takes measurements.
2) The doctor uses standard
tools to assess whether the
child is healthy.
3) The doctor makes
recommendations to
improve health.
4) Repeat the health check-up process as the child gets older.
7. New Project Goal: Develop a Guidebook for
Monitoring FCZs in Lao PDR
To improve the use of FCZs for aquatic conservation
and livelihood sustainability:
• Develop a guidebook of best practices for assessing FCZs
in Lao PDR
• Provide networking opportunities for Civil Society
Organizations and fishery co-management groups
working with FCZs
8. Project Donor: Critical Ecosystem Partnership Fund
• Joint initiative of l'Agence Française de Développement,
Conservation International, the European Union, the
Global Environment Facility, the Government of Japan,
the MacArthur Foundation and the World Bank
• Goal to work with Civil Society to protect “biodiversity
hotspots” (biologically rich yet threatened areas)
9. CEPF work in the IndoBurma Hotspot
• Investing in projects since
2008
• Regional Implementation
Team = IUCN Asia Regional
Office in Bangkok
• Funded 2 previous FISHBIO
Laos FCZ projects
• Funded other projects in
Laos related to elephants,
gibbons, silver-leafed
monkey, plants, illegal
wildlife trade, Mekong
River livelihoods
10. Three Project Phases from 2016-2018
• 2016: Develop a framework for
assessing FCZ effectiveness
and create a draft guidebook
for FCZ assessment in Lao PDR
• 2017: Test the framework
outlined in the guidebook by
measuring indicators at 3 pilot
FCZ sites in the field
• 2018: Refine, finalize, and
disseminate the guidebook
11. Project Output: FCZ Assessment Guidebook
• The guidebook will be multi-page document. This tool is
intended to help a community or organization answer the
question, “Is this FCZ successful?”
• Will include list of recommended indicators of FCZ
performance in three categories:
• Ecological
• Socioeconomic
• Governance
• Will include guidance on methods that can be used to
measure each of these indicators in the field
• Written in English and translated into Lao, available online
12. Intended Benefits
•Help FCZ managers use time and effort most
effectively by determining which approaches are
successful or unsuccessful
•Help CSOs collect information to demonstrate to
donors the value of continued support for FCZs
•Allow stakeholders to provide input on the
guidebook to ensure it is as useful and relevant as
possible
•Improve communication and sharing lessons
learned among organizations involved in FCZ
management and assessment
13. Multinational Agreements Have Targets for
Protected Areas and Fisheries Conservation
• United Nations Sustainable Development
Goals (SDGs)
• Convention on Biological Diversity: Aichi
Biodiversity Targets
• Goal 15: Protect, restore and promote sustainable use of
terrestrial ecosystems (includes inland freshwater ecosystems)
• Aichi Target 6: Sustainable use of fish stocks
• Aichi Target 11: Inland waters “… are conserved through
effectively and equitably managed, ecologically representative
and well connected systems of protected areas...”
• Lao National Level CBD target: “At least 250 Fish Conservation
and breeding sites (that include local/indigenous species) are
established and are recognized /supported by stakeholders”
Now that you have some background about Fish Conservation Zones and FISHBIO, Our goal in this next presentation is to introduce everyone to FISHBIO’s new project called developing a Guidebook to assess Fish Conservation Zones in Lao PDR. Describe our motivation for the project, the activities, timeline, and our intended benefits.
To reiterate that FCZs are very important in Laos, and there are many of them.
Many players involved. These are just a few, we’re not trying to forget anybody. One of our goals is trying to identify who all the players are. This is the user group we hope will benefit from the outputs of our project. Because many groups hae invested a lot of time, resources, and effort in esstablishing FCZs, Goal of our project is to create a tool that will benefit all these actors.
A helpful tool exists for establishing FCZs. FISHBIO uses this protocol. Once the FCZs are established, the next step is assessing themm, which this handbook recommends. Our goal is to create a similar tool for that next step of assessment.
Why do we need tools for asessment. Not enough to establish them and hope that they work, for them to really be successful we need to check in regularly to see if we need to adjust management activities.
Assessment is important to do regularly. Measure different indicators of human health like heart rate and bloood pressure. Just like a doctor needs tools, we need tools to perform a standard FCZ assessment, and that is what our project is hoping to provide. When you create an FCZ you may do an initial check in at the end of the project, but it’s important to continue to go back and check the health of the FCZ and confirm that it’s achieving it’s goals.
Because there are so many groups working on FCZs, we want to try to bring people together and learn from each other.
Funding comes from CEPF. Joint initiative of many governments and donors. Because the donor’s mission is to work with Civil Society, that is the goal of our project.
This is our ideal timeline, although it might be shifted somewhat.
At the end of the project, we hope to produce a document in the form of a guidebook that people can use as a tool to help conduct an FCZ assessment. Developing these indicators is the focus of our upcoming technical workshop this afternoon and tomorrow, so we’ll be talking about them at length. We’ve come up with these symbols to represent 3 categories of indicators.
Our goal is for the tool to be widely accessible
Assessment is important because it takes a lot of time an effort to establish and manage FCZs, and we need to know If that effort is being used effectively. FCZ assessment is complex, and this tool is not intended to be comprehensive, but it’s a starting point for people to build off of. Donors also want to see evidence that these interventions are working. We want to create an initial foundation that can continue to evolve and grow over time.
Another benefit to this project is that FCZ assessment can help fulfill targets for protected areas set by multinational agreemnts such as the …In a broad context, the this type of assessment matters because it’s directly related to goals set by many targets set by multinational agreements.
So our project is hoping to work towards improving sustainable fisheries management and the protection of freshwater areas.