The document discusses proposals for an "Outer Beltway" road in Northern Virginia and alternatives to address traffic issues in the region. It summarizes that the Outer Beltway has been proposed and rejected multiple times due to high costs and not effectively addressing transportation needs. Concerns about the current proposal include environmental impacts, induced development, and not aligning with where most people live and work in the region. The document advocates focusing transportation funding on improving existing east-west corridors and expanding public transit options instead of the Outer Beltway.
Local Update for PEC Supporters in Charlottesville & Albemarle County
Outer Beltway Presentation 02-11-13
1. The Outer Beltway
What’s Being Proposed,
What’s the Impact?
Chris Miller, President of
The Piedmont Environmental Council
Stewart Schwartz, Executive Director of
The Coalition for Smarter Growth
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
2. December 2012 VDOT Map
Rt. 50 Rt. 28
Rt. 15
Rt. 66
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
3. The section in red is what’s currently being discussed:
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
4. Brings up a lot of questions:
• Where exactly are we talking about?
• What kind of road would it be?
• Would it make my commute easier? Would it help with
daily trips like getting to school, grocery shopping, etc.?
• How is safety being addressed?
• How would this impact my property?
• How would it change the place that I’ve chosen to live?
• How much would it cost? How would it impact other
projects?
What, if anything, can I do about it?
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
5. A little background on the ‘Outer Beltway’
The road has been repeatedly proposed and then
rejected, because of cost and ineffectiveness in
addressing real transportation needs:
• 234 Bypass Extended—1988
• Washington Bypass--1989 (a full outer beltway study)
• Western Transportation Corridor--1997
• Tri-County Parkway—2005
• Bi-County Parkway—2011
• North-South Corridor of Statewide Significance—2011
• Northstar Blvd and Belmont Ridge Rd—2012
• 234 Bypass—2013 (name has returned)
All compose elements of an Outer Beltway
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
6. Over time, there
have been many
potential routes…
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
7. A VDOT Plan
from 1990
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
8. A VDOT Plan
from 1997
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
9. In 2011, the State
designated a:
‗Corridor of
Statewide
Significance‘
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
13. VDOT points to Airport Demands & Freight
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
14. The Airport benefit may be over-stated
Only 0.1% of the Northern Virginia freight weight
comes through Dulles now.
While that is a real number and expected to grow –
should it be a priority over other regional
economic drivers?
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
15. As VDOT points out
―Almost 57% of all new jobs
and 32 % of new households
will be located in activity
clusters throughout the
Washington region.‖
But note that most
of the ‗activity
clusters‘ are east.
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
19. Where People Work (Va Employment Commission 2013)
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
20. The proposal would come with major impacts
Credit Carey Pohanka
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
21. It would cut through a National Park
Staging area of the
confederate troops.
150th anniversary
reenactment took
place on this farm.
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
22. Major Impact on the Battlefield
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
23. Environmental Impact
An Environmental Protection Agency analysis estimates that a
new highway, when compared to alternatives, will cause:
– 2.5x the impacts to threatened and
endangered plants
– 10x the impact on
wetlands
– 10x the impact on the
floodplain area
– And potentially threaten the
Lake Manassas public water
supply
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
26. Experience tells us:
New highways also lead to:
• Speculative development
• Land is easily rezoned to accommodate such
development
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
28. In Prince
William, the road
would put
intense
development
pressure on the
Rural
Crescent, openin
g up 80,000
acres.
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
29. In Loudoun, the 22,813
acre Transition
Area, already under
assault in the
past, would feel the
pressure to develop at
suburban densities once
again.
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
30. But Everyone Agrees Our Transportation System Needs Work
Virginia ranks among the nation’s most congested regions
What Are Other Options to Reduce Traffic?
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
31. What Are the Other Options to Reduce Traffic?
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
33. By Enhancing Existing East-West Corridors
Potential Solutions:
• Additional lanes on Rt. 50, Rt. 7 and I-66 (Suburban Area)
• Intersection improvements -- e.g. at I-66 and I-28
• Completing Suburban Area Interchanges on Rt. 50 & 7
• Bus Rapid Transit/Metro
• Better local road connections
• Better land use
• Extend traffic calming to Lenah & Willowsford
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
34. Fund Multimodal Options
Silver Line—Metro to Loudoun
Funding needed from State?
VRE to Gainesville
Funding needed from State?
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
35. Metro
Metro, MARC & VRE:
114 Stations
= Being Planned
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
37. Localized Congestion Solutions: Gilberts Corner
Completed: Roundabouts at Gilbert‘s Corner
Traffic Calming in Aldie
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
38. Fund Original Plans
VDOT has a 6 Year Plan
It includes 900+ statewide projects such as:
– additional lanes on I-66
– additional lanes on the Rt. 7 bypass in Leesburg
– additional lanes on Rt. 28
– intersection improvements at Rt. 215 and Rt. 29
– many badly needed bridge rehabilitations
– Route 606 expansion to four lanes
(the list did not include the Outer Beltway proposal)
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
39. Fund Original Plans
Loudoun has a Plan
Missing links and
bottlenecks in County Plan
add up to $1.46 Billion
according to County’s
Eastern Loudoun
Transportation Study.
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
40. Fund Original Plans
Prince William has a Plan
• Improvements to I-66
• Improvements to Rt. 28
• New Rt 1 & 123
Interchange
• Transit Improvements
– Expanded PRTC Routes
– New Park and Ride Lots
– Extending VRE to
Gainesville
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
41. What’s the best use of limited funds?
One Billion for….
OR
Completion of North- Localized
South Corridor Improvements Along
Heavily Used Routes
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
47. Still in the Public Process—Input Critical to Outcomes
• Dulles Access Road
– Next meeting due in
March
– Decision by June
regarding location
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
49. What Can You Do?
Contact:
• Congressman Frank Wolf, Senator Mark Warner, Senator Tim
Kaine, Board of Supervisors
Action:
– Speak out at public input opportunities
– Oppose this one billion dollar project
– Ask for focus on your current commuter problems
– Local congestion solutions
– Oppose more State funding for VDOT with reform and better priorities
– Talk to your neighbors and spread the word
– Continue to participate in local planning
– Sign up for Land Use & Transportation alerts so we can keep you
informed as new information becomes available: www.pecva.org
Spread the word about this waste of transportation funding!
PIEDMONT ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL
Notas del editor
Corridor Designation was created in 2009. First time it has been used to designate an area for a future highway.VTrans Identifies Corridor of Statewide Significance as: An integrated, multimodal network of transportation facilities that connect major centers of activity within and through the Commonwealth and promote the movement of people and goods essential to the economic prosperity of the state.First designation created completely outside of VTrans and included only very limited public process.
1st Need: How much need is there for people and freight capacity in this area?2nd Need: Will it relieve traffic congestion or increase it?3rd Need: Transit is a viable mode in this outer area due to low demand. Same probably true of HOV. And do we need to build a 65 mph highway to get a trail?
VDOT says freight will triple, but if it’s starting at .1%... Is that worth a billion dollars.