1. Autonomy as a Mechanism to
Address Exclusion and to Enhance
Participation of Minorities
Atty. Erwin M. Caliba
"Governance, Democracy, and Media: Building Better Communities"
23rd National Press Forum
July 5, 2019 Hotel Jen, Manila

2. Filipino minorities, used
to live in their
homelands.
 Self-governed
 Self-subsistent
 Possessing unique
identity, language and
culture.

3. SPANISH AMERICAN POST-
COLONIZATION
Minorities Excluded from Power and Deprived
of Meaningful Political Participation

4. Regional Autonomy to Address
Exclusion
Autonomy “device to allow ethnic or other groups
that claim a distinct identity to exercise direct
control over affairs of special concern to them
while allowing the larger entity to exercise those
powers that cover common interests”

5. HOW?
•Recognition of minorities’ identities.
•Recognition of minorities’ territory where they
constitute the majority of the population
•Making minorities governors themselves.

6. Regional Autonomy
•Ensures Citizen Participation
•Brings More Responsive Governance
•Upholds the Rule of Law

7. INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, ANCESTRAL DOMAINS AND RIGHT
TO SELF-DETERMINATION
How about peoples with
distinct identities and culture
outside the Cordilleras and in
the Bangsamoro?
NCIP Map

8. 1987 Constitution
“The State recognizes and
promotes the rights of
indigenous cultural
communities within the
framework
of national unity and
development”
(Declaration of State Policies and Principles, Article II, Sec. 22)

9. • “The State, subject to the provisions of this
Constitution and national development
policies and programs, shall protect the
rights of indigenous cultural
communities to their ancestral
lands to ensure their economic, social,
and cultural well being.
• The Congress may provide for the
applicability of customary laws
governing property rights or relations in
determining the ownership and extent of
ancestral domain.
(National Economy and Patrimony, Article XII, Section 5)

10. “ The State shall recognize,
respect and protect the rights of
indigenous cultural communities
to preserve and develop their
cultures, traditions, and
institutions. It shall consider
these rights in the formulation of
national plans and policies.”
(Education, Science and Technology, Arts, Culture and Sports,
Article XIV, Section 17)

11. INDIGENOUS PEOPLES RIGHTS ACT (RA 8371)
Four Bundles of Rights
Rights to ancestral domains and lands
Rights to self-governance and empowerment
Rights to social justice and human rights
 Rights to cultural integrity

12. The Ancestral Domains are indigenous peoples’
“private but community property which belongs
to all generations and therefore cannot be sold,
disposed or destroyed.”

13. • Right to freely pursue their economic, social and cultural well-being
and have the right to determine the priorities of development.
• Free and Prior Informed Consent (FPIC)
• Right to use justice systems, conflict resolution institutions, peace-
building processes and customary laws and practices
• Right to Participate fully, if they so choose, at all levels of decision-
making
RIGHT TO SELF-GOVERNANCE AND SELF-DETERMINATION

14. The UN General Assembly adopted on
September 13, 2007 the UN
Declaration of the Rights of the
Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP)
declaring, among others, the
collective rights of the indigenous
peoples to self-determination.
Confirmed the rights granted by IPRA.
UN Declaration of
the Rights of the
Indigenous Peoples
(UNDRIP)

15. •Challenges to the Right to Self-Determination
Cruz vs. Secretary of DENR (2000)
-certain provisions allegedly an unlawful deprivation of State’s
ownership over lands of the public domain as well as minerals and natural
resources therein in violation of the medieval doctrine of Jura Regalia.
Unduran v. Aberasturi (2015)
- Limited the Jurisdiction of the Quasi-Judicial Functions of the NCIP
Many Complaints from Communities

16. Concerns on the Draft Federal Constitution
- Indigenous peoples’ Rights and Welfare now placed
under the exclusive powers of the regions
-Formulation of Section 9, Article XV (National
Economy and Patrimony)

17. Section 5 of Article XII (1987
Constitution)
Section 9, Article XV Draft Federal
Constitution
The State, subject to the provisions of
this Constitution and national
development policies and programs,
shall protect the rights of indigenous
cultural communities to their ancestral
lands to ensure their economic, social,
and cultural well-being.
The Congress may provide for the
applicability of customary laws
governing property rights or relations in
determining the ownership and extent
of ancestral domain.”
The Federal Republic shall, subject to the
provisions of the Constitution and
national development policies and
programs, respect the primacy of
customary laws of indigenous peoples
to their ancestral domains and lands,
and all resources found therein to
ensure their economic, social, and
cultural well-being.
Ancestral domains which are communal
properties cannot be alienated.

18. CONCLUSION
Autonomy will strengthen the state, pave the way for inclusion and
enhance the participation of minorities.
The right of the Indigenous Peoples to Self-Determination and communal
ownership of their ancestral domains should be well-entrenched in the
Constitution

19. Photos from Google