2. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally2
Extrusion Qualification
Goals:
Validate Interface Internal Extrusion
Use Interface Balloon Data
Significantly Reduce Balloon Component Cost
-Lower service level and reduce backorder risk
-Significantly Increase Interface balloon yield
-Significantly Reduce Scrap BSC in IQA
-Use Interface Data to decrease IQA cost
3. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally3
Extrusion Qualification
Strategy:
- Identical Inspection & Measurement Methods
- Validate methods at BSC and Interface
- Transition to “Supplied Data” via Interface
- Eliminate BSC 100% proof loading
4. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally4
Extrusion Qualification
Requirements:
-Continue current strategy to validate internal extrusion
- Manage measurement anomalies
- Document SCARs and NCMRs
- PpK evaluation memos
- Supplier Quality, Sustaining R&D and DA
- Document & Lock Requirements
-Purchase Interface inspection station ($35K)
- Duplicate Interface measurement method
-Equipment Lead-Time – Four to Five Weeks
-Develop and Validate BSC and Interface Inspection procedures
-Execute Design and Process changes:
- Align balloon burst requirement with finished device
- IQA lot acceptance per AQL 95/99.9 confidence.
5. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally5
Extrusion Qualification
Estimate for Method Validation:
-$13K EE IV/O of Inspection Station
-$20K for MG Sustaining Engineering
-$15K for Travel (SJ and Maple Grove)
6. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally6
Extrusion Qualification
Quarter Scrap FARF IQA Labor External
Extrusion
Q1 $15,700 $2,000 $25,000
Q2 $31,000 $3,500 $46,400
Q3 $33,000 $4,000 $45,000
Q4 $17,000 $2,000 $35,000
Total $96,700 $11,500 $151,400
Interface Requirements for legacy balloons:
Pay for extrusion
Pay for scrap
Cost Incurred & Forecast
7. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally7
Detail & Back-UP Slides
Detail & Back-UP Slides
8. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally8
Balloons for Measurement
Balloon Part Numbers and Inspection Priority
BSC P/N Size Priority SO PO# Qty
Request
Ship date
Received
date
Interface
WO#
BSC
Batch #
FA
Status Comment
12565 2.5x103 1 17468 6234623 31 27-Oct 28-Oct N/A 5001026435 Done Completed. See CR 1017380
11800 2.5x20 1 17468 6234623 31 27-Oct 28-Oct N/A 5001025939 Done Completed. See CR 1017380
12468 5.0x103 2 17472 6234624 31 8-Oct 1-Oct N/A 5001014922 In CR Pending CR 1019813
11597 5.0x20 2 17472 6234624 31 8-Oct 28-Sep N/A 5001013157 In CR Pending CR 1019813
11598 6.0x20 3 17473 6234603 31 15-Oct 1-Oct N/A 5001014921 Passed Pending FAIR approval
12469 6.0x103 3 17473 6234603 31 21-Oct 12-Oct N/A 5001020041 Failed
Balloon Length failed
Statistical & practical test
11802 3.5x20 5 17476 6234614 31 22-Oct 7-Oct N/A 5001017602 Passed Pending FAIR approval
13158 3.5x103 5 17476 6234614 31 22-Oct N/A 5001040707 Passed Pending FAIR approval
11599 7.0x20 4 17474 6234610 31 22-Oct 8-Oct N/A 5001018219 Passed
Pending FAIR approval by
John L.
12044 7.0x83 4 17474 6234610 31 22-Oct 15-Oct N/A 5001021097 Failed
Rejected due to Banana
Shape Pending NCMR E-
6879
12575 2.0x103 6 17454 6234616 31 26-Oct 21-Oct N/A 5001023633 Failed
Balloon Length failed
Statistical & practical test
11799 2.0x20 6 17454 6234616 31 26-Oct 21-Oct N/A 5001023634 Failed
Balloon length failed Ppk. 0.95
from measurement < 1.33
11804 2.0x23 6 17454 6234616 31 26-Oct 4-Nov N/A 5001029716 Failed
Balloon length failed Ppk. 0.53
from measurement < 1.33
(Linda)
11809 2.0x40 6 17454 6234616 31 26-Oct 21-Oct N/A 5001023635 Failed
Balloon length failed Ppk. 0.48
from measurement < 1.33
(Linda)
12567 4.0x103 7 17477 6234803 31 1-Nov 2-Nov N/A 5001028393 Pending
P value too low. Need more
study
11596 4.0x20 7 17477 6234803 31 1-Nov 29-Oct N/A 5001027025 Pending
P value too low. Need more
study
11600 8.0x20 8 17471 6234612 31 25-Oct 28-Oct N/A 5001026431 Passed FAIR OK. Pending approval
11615 8.0x43 8 17471 6234612 31 25-Oct N/A Not Received
12566 3.0x103 9 17475 6234779 31 29-Oct 29-Oct N/A 5001027024 Pending In Work
11801 3.0x20 9 17475 6234779 31 29-Oct 28-Oct N/A 5001025936 Pending
Missing Page 3 double wall
thickness measurement. IQA
redo
9. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally9
Methods & Measurement
Details:
Methods / Measurement Processes
Review Procedures
Evaluate Interface & BSC Processes
Methods Required:
Balloon Body Dimensions
Duplicate Interface Inspection Station
Equipment Capital Cost – Interface Quote
BSC to adopt Interface method for Stem IDs’
Burst
Validate Interface Balloon Component Burst Process
Interface burst data (AQL, 95/99.9 confidence)
Validate BSC and Interface DWT Measurement Processes
10. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally10
Methods & Measurement
11. Boston Scientific Confidential -- For Internal Use Only. Do Not Copy, Display or Distribute Externally11
Methods & Measurement
ID Task Name Duration Start Finish Resource
Names
1 Methods 112 days Mon 4/12/10 Tue 9/14/10
2 review MGwork instructions, validations, observe process in MG 5 days Mon 4/12/10 Fri 4/16/10 John H
3 review SJ QP 1006 procedures 10 days Mon 4/12/10 Fri 4/23/10 John H
4 review / observe SJ incomingprocesses / equipment 5 days Mon 4/26/10 Fri 4/30/10 John H
5 Draft new IP 35 days Mon 4/12/10 Fri5/28/10
10 Interface Visit 1 day Tue 4/27/10 Tue 4/27/10
15 Draft TMV (gage R&Rs) protocols 10 days Fri 5/28/10 Fri6/11/10
20 Equipment 80 days Mon 4/12/10 Fri7/30/10 RonLee
26 Update IP drafts 10 days Mon 7/5/10 Fri 7/16/10 John H
27 Update TMV (gage R&Rs) protocols 10 days Mon7/5/10 Fri7/16/10
32 IP Due Diligence (verifygage R&Rs, trainoperators) 10 days Mon 7/19/10 Fri7/30/10
36 Update IP and TMVs 5 days Mon8/2/10 Fri 8/6/10
40 Release IP to Numeric 5 days Mon 8/9/10 Fri 8/13/10 John H
41 Execute TMVs 10 days Mon 8/16/10 Fri8/27/10 JohnH
45 Write TMRs and CR 7 days Mon 8/30/10 Tue 9/7/10
49 Release IP to Alpha 5 days Wed 9/8/10 Tue 9/14/10 John H
50 Update prints (?) touse new IP 5 days Wed 9/8/10 Tue 9/14/10 R&D
JohnH
John H
M T W T F S S M T W T F S S
Apr 11, '10 Apr 18, '10 Apr
Notas del editor
Definitions Cp= Process Capability. A simple and straightforward indicator of process capability. Cpk= Process Capability Index. Adjustment of Cp for the effect of non-centered distribution. Pp= Process Performance. A simple and straightforward indicator of process performance. Ppk= Process Performance Index. Adjustment of Pp for the effect of non-centered distribution
NCMRNon-Conforming Material Report
SCAR (Supplier Corrective Action Request)
Scrap FARF (First Article Report Form)
IP (Inspection Procedure – Protocols)
NSMR (New Supplier Material Report)
A gage R&R study helps you investigate: Whether your measurement system variability is small compared with the process variability.
How much variability in the measurement system is caused by differences between operators.
Whether your measurement system is capable of discriminating between different parts