SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 28
Descargar para leer sin conexión
60,000
Reasons for
a CIL in Dudley




 This report is copyright to Dudley Centre for Inclusive
       Living and Linda Laurie Associates 2012
1. Introduction
Over the last 30 years, Disabled People all over the world – from Dudley
to Durban – have begun to demand that we have choice and control in
our daily lives. This research breaks new ground because Disabled
People in Dudley have for the first time asked other local Disabled People
about their experiences of living here. The findings of our survey and the
recommendations in this report spell out in more detail than ever before
why it is urgent for us to get a fully-funded CIL (Centre for Inclusive Living)
here in Dudley - Britain‟s second largest town.

In the 1970s, Disabled People in the USA began to set up Centres for
Independent Living (CILs). They provided services like the provision of
advice and support for Disabled People wishing to employ their own staff
to work in the ways and at the times Disabled People wanted them. This
helped give Disabled People full control over how they lived their lives.

Similar CILs have been set up in the UK and now the Government thinks
that every town should have a CIL. The report “Improving the Life
Chances of Disabled People”, of which this was a key recommendation,
has been widely acknowledged as underpinning current government
strategy regarding the development of Independent Living for Disabled
People1. In its “Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory
Disabilities”2, Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (MBC) also
recognises the importance of the „Life Chances‟ report.

CILs all over the country are different from each other because they are
set up by local Disabled People to meet local needs, but they are always
controlled by and accountable to Disabled People themselves.

1
 Improving the Life Chances of Disabled People (2006) Office for
Disability Issues (link)
2
  Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory Disabilities (2010-2013)
(2011) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (link)


                                      1
Dudley CIL is a grassroots organisation. The initiative to form a CIL in
Dudley has come from the community and reflects a need amongst
Disabled People living in Dudley to break down the isolation we face by
coming together to remove the barriers to our equal participation in the
borough. If, as we intend, Dudley CIL is to build its strength and grow as
an accountable, user-led service provider and campaigner, we will need
genuine, long-term commitment and support from the statutory, not-for-
profit and private sectors. If the genuine voices of Disabled People are not
to be drowned out or lost during the radical changes currently underway
within public service provision, pro-active measures need to be taken by
all key stakeholders to preserve, protect and promote Dudley CIL as the
authentic local voice of the disabled community.

The 2001 census3 found that there were at least 304,474 people living in
Dudley. Indications are that this figure had increased to approximately
306,600 by 20094. As with other areas in Britain, Dudley‟s population is
ageing. According to the 2001 census, 19.1% of the population in Dudley
is living with a long-term health condition. This is higher than the national
average of 18.2%. This is why we believe that there are at least 60,000
Disabled People living here. This means that there are 60,000 reasons
why Dudley needs a CIL.

In Dudley:

     67% of the population provide between 1 and 19 hours unpaid help
      and support per week to family and friends
     27% provide 50 or more hours unpaid help and support per week to
      family and friends
     34,651 households (28%) include a Disabled Person5
3
 2001 Census: Standard Area Statistics (England and Wales) (2001)
Office for National Statistics (Link)
4
 Dudley Borough Economic Assessment March 2011 (2011) Dudley
Metropolitan Borough Council (Link)
5
  Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory Disabilities (2010-2013)
(2011) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (Link)

                                      2
However, according to a response to a Freedom of Information request
made by Dudley CIL in 2010, Dudley MBC only provides services to:

    6,610 people with a physical impairment
    811 people with learning difficulties
    611 people with mental health difficulties

In December 2009, we organised a conference on Independent Living
because we believe that it is important for Dudley to have its own CIL. At
this conference, a steering group was formed. We now have mentoring
support from a sister CIL in Leicestershire. They are helping us to build up
support for a CIL here in Dudley. We already have a constitution, a bank
account, a website and a growing network of members. We have a small
amount of funding and are actively seeking further funding from a range of
sources, to carry out important work in the areas identified by this research.
We receive administrative support from West Midlands Regional Disability
Network and we are a group member of Dudley Local Involvement Network
(LINk) and of Dudley Council for Voluntary Services.

Dudley CIL promotes the active participation of Disabled people in all
aspects of society. We plan to achieve this by:

    Securing the necessary facilities and support to ensure maximum
     choice for Disabled People
    Promoting the full inclusion of Disabled People in all aspects of society
    Campaigning locally for all Disabled People's human and civil rights
    Representing the views and aspirations of Disabled People in Dudley
    Implementing an action plan to achieve full civil rights for Disabled
     People
    Building a strong, active and informed membership
    Consulting, involving and engaging Dudley CIL members in all aspects
     of the organisation to create a sense of belonging and ownership
    Empowering Disabled People
    Encouraging young Disabled People's involvement in the organisation

                                     3
Dudley CIL‟s work is underpinned by the principles of the Social Model of
Disability. This model has been developed by Disabled People and it
views Disabled People as being restricted by the way society is set up,
rather than by our bodies and minds. The Social Model says that we are
disabled by a society that continually puts barriers in our way. It is
important to remember that Disabled People are equal to non-disabled
people. We are not „special cases‟ and we do not have „special needs‟.
We all have different needs, therefore some things must change before
we have equality. This should be our right. Every opportunity should be
provided to make sure that we are included, not just by changing physical
access, but also by challenging attitudes, myths and stereotypes about
Disabled People.

When we talk about Disabled People, we include:

   people with physical impairments (whether or not you can see that
    someone has an impairment)
   people with sensory impairments (deaf and hearing impaired people
    as well as blind and partially sighted people)
   people with chronic illness or health issues including HIV and AIDS
   learning Disabled People including those with labels such as
    dyslexia, speech and language impairments
   people with emotional and behavioural differences
   people with impairments such as epilepsy, diabetes, Sickle Cell
    Anaemia
   children labelled as 'delicate'
   people who identify as 'disfigured'
   short people
   people who are in or who have survived the mental health system

We aim to become a borough-wide, democratic organisation run and
controlled by Disabled People. We want to be recognised as a body to be
properly consulted at all times on issues affecting Disabled People.


                                    4
2. The Research
Early on, we realised that it is important to work out what Disabled People
in Dudley want from a CIL. We therefore asked the Big Lottery for money
so that we could do some research to find this out. Another CIL – the
Southampton Centre for Independent Living – has come up with 12 keys
to Independent Living. These 12 keys (or basic rights) sum up the most
important things needed by Disabled People if we are to live equal lives.
They are:

     Full Access to our environment
     A fully accessible Transport system
     Technical aids and Equipment
     Accessible/Adapted Housing
     Personal Assistance
     Inclusive Education and Training
     An adequate Income
     Equal opportunities for Employment
     Appropriate and accessible Information
     Advocacy (towards Self-Advocacy)
     Peer counselling
     Appropriate and Accessible Health Care Provision

We drew up a questionnaire which asked Disabled People in Dudley what
were the most important things they needed to live independently in
Dudley. During the summer and autumn of 2011, we took these
questionnaires to various meetings and groups throughout Dudley to try to
get the views of a representative cross-section of the Disabled
Community living in the Borough.

We were pleased that we managed to get 72 people to fill in
questionnaires between July and November 2012. After the results were
collated, a further 11 were returned. These have been used to contribute
to the qualitative data, but arrived too late to be included in the
quantitative data, in this report.

                                     5
We also asked for the views of a separate self-organised group of people with
learning difficulties. We asked the same questions as the questionnaire, but to
make sure that things were accessible, we asked for views in one big focus
group and wrote down what people said on to flipchart paper (pictured).




The views we got back from this focus group and from all the
questionnaires returned before the deadline, have been summarised in
the next 12 sections of this report.

Despite having a very small amount of funding to carry out this research,
we believe that we have made an excellent start in producing a picture
explaining the barriers to independent living that Disabled People in
Dudley experience. It is crucial that these barriers are identified, so that
we can begin our work to minimise or remove them. For the first time,
Dudley CIL is able to provide up-to-date detailed evidence about the
needs, aspirations and priorities of Disabled People in the borough.

Completed questionnaires have been
received from a range of people living
throughout all of the Dudley townships
with almost an equal number from both
men and women.

Figure 1: Proportional Diagram showing the
numbers of male and female respondents.

                                      6
Respondent ages range from under 18 to over 79, with roughly half being
below the age of 55.

    14

    12

    10

     8

     6

     4

     2

     0
         under 19-30 31-42 43-54 55-66 67-78              79+
          18
Figure 2: Bar chart showing the age distribution of respondents

52 respondents (72.2%) identify as White British. 12 (16.7%) responses
come from Asian Disabled People, but only 1 (1.4%) from the Black
Community.


                                                         White British (52)

                                                         Asian (12)

                                                         No Answer (3)

                                                         British Asian (2)

                                                         European (1)

                                                         Irish (1)

                                                         Afro-Caribbean (1)



Figure 3: Pie chart showing the ethnic origin of respondents


                                    7
We failed to reach some of those Disabled People in Dudley whose views
are seldom heard and realise that it was ambitious to hope that the
resources we had to conduct this research would be enough to get a
complete picture of the views of the whole disabled community. We think
that more research needs to take place to find out in detail what things all
Disabled People in the Borough of Dudley feel are needed to improve
access to independent living in the area. This further research we believe
needs to focus in particular upon getting the views of Younger Disabled
People and the views of Disabled People in Dudley‟s Black and Minority
Ethnic Communities. Whilst some views from these under-represented
voices are reflected in this report, we recognise that more work is
necessary.

We are surprised by some of the responses to our questions and
summarise the most significant of these below. We also include some of
the most striking and informative comments which sum up the general
views of those who choose to give more detailed information about their
lives. A majority of those who respond to the questionnaire choose to tick
boxes and not to provide detailed feedback or reasons for their views. A
significant minority of respondents do however share important
experiences and, where appropriate these have been included in this
report.




                                     8
2.1.     Where I Live



Of the 60 respondents who express an opinion, 73.3% say that they are
generally happy with the environment in the area in which they live, however
26.7% express varying degrees of dissatisfaction with their local area.




                                               Happy (44)

                                               Unhappy (16)

                                               No Opinion Given (12)




Figure 4: Pie chart showing participants' happiness with their environment

       “It is hilly. There are
       no crossings and no              “Don't go out”
         local amenities”


          “I don't go out very often as I need support/carer”


             “No. Shopping - shelves too high. Path edges
               not level at some places for wheelchair”

           “Too many roads with cars parked on footpaths
            and lots of illegal parking which makes it hard
                          to cross roads safely”


                                    9
2.2.     Using Public Transport



People were asked to report whether or not they can use different
types of public transport - buses, trains, coaches, taxis and trams.
Most respondents indicate that they can use buses (65.3%), whilst
less than a third (29.2%) say that they can access trams. This may be
due to the limited geographical area covered by tram routes in Dudley.
In general, there are some striking differences in the accessibility of
public transport identified by respondents, depending upon the
township in which individuals live.

A number of people state that bus passes, including those for carers,
make travelling on public transport easier. A minority of respondents
express strong dissatisfaction with the inaccessibility of buses.

   “I feel very strongly about not being able to use buses. Adverts
   lie when they say we can all use any form of transport
   because buses are completely inaccessible to me. The adverts
   are misleading because I simply can’t use the bus”



People involved in the focus group also say that they have experienced
bullying and “rude drivers” whilst using public transport. Other barriers
identified by people in this focus group include steps, doorways that are
too narrow, heavy doors, signage that only uses words and the need for
more lifts that give spoken information indicating floors, etc.




                                   10
Trams                                            Trams

   Taxis                                            Taxis

Coaches                                        Coaches

  Trains                                           Trains

  Buses                                            Buses
           0%    20%   40%   60%   80% 100%                 0%   20%   40%   60%   80% 100%

                 Kingswinford                          Coseley/ Sedgeley/ Gornal

  Trams                                            Trams

   Taxis                                            Taxis

Coaches                                        Coaches

  Trains                                           Trains

  Buses                                            Buses
           0%    20%   40%   60%   80% 100%                 0%   20%   40%   60%   80% 100%

                Dudley/ Netherton                                   Halesowen

  Trams

   Taxis                                                     Key:
Coaches                                                      People who found the
                                                             transport accessible
  Trains
                                                             People who found the
  Buses                                                      transport inaccessible
           0%   20%    40%   60%   80% 100%                  No answer given
                   Stourbridge

  Figure 5: Bar charts showing the accessibility of transport in the
            townships in Dudley




                                              11
2.3. Equipment for
     Independent Living




72.2% of people said they did not have the equipment they needed to
live independently in the community.



        “I need a walk-in shower. I also need light dimmers”


               “I cannot afford specialist equipment to
              support my communication as this would
                     cost in the region of £1200”



Some people who attended the focus group reported that equipment is
difficult to both find and obtain, and that this was made even more
difficult due to a lack of funding.




                                   Figure 6: Diagram showing the
                                   proportion of people without the
                                   equipment they need to live
                                   independently




                                 12
2.4.     My Community



People were asked whether they were happy with where they are
currently living. The overwhelming majority of respondents say that they
are happy with their living environment. This is surprising given the
consistent findings of research carried out into Housing and Disabled
People, which indicates an extremely high level of dissatisfaction
expressed by Disabled People regarding accessibility and their housing.
According to the 2007/08 Survey of English Housing6, one in five
Disabled People requiring adaptations to their home believe that their
housing is not suitable.

The responses received to this question may be explained by the fact
that the question asked does not specifically mention housing or
accommodation.

     “Problems with horrendous traffic-not safe for wheelchairs. Some
      anti-social behaviour. Accommodation-adapted semi but would
        like a purpose built wheelchair accessible accommodation”


           “Mostly. I have an alcoholic neighbour whose visitors
             from time to time can make living unbearable”

Other responses indicate a lack of dropped kerbs and obstacles placed
on pavements outside shops. The difficulty in obtaining repairs is
highlighted by the focus group.

People were also asked whether they experience bullying, abuse or
teasing in the area where they live. 26.4% report that they are victims of
this type of behaviour from other people.
6
 Survey of Housing in England 2007-08 (2009) Department for
Communities and Local Government (link)

                                    13
This includes a significant proportion (35.7%) of all Asian respondents,
which demonstrates the combined impact of discrimination on the
grounds of both race and impairment experienced by Disabled People
from Black and Minority Ethnic communities.


                                                 No (51)

                                                 Don't know (2)

                                                 Yes - Asian (5)

                                                 Yes - White British (14)



Figure 7: Pie chart showing the ethnic origin of respondents

Members of the focus group also said that bullying was an issue for
them within their communities.

                  “Bullied by able-bodied shoppers.
                    Swore at by other road users”

              “One of jobs not good, pick on me at work”

                 “People saying snide comments. Also
                people being ignorant and not wanting
                     to learn about my disability”

                 “I cannot go to the park on my own
                     because people swear at me”

14 respondents (almost 20%) tick a box on the questionnaire to indicate
that they want to receive advice and support to help them deal with this
bullying. This is a significant number of respondents and demonstrates
the need for a CIL in Dudley which can provide such support to victims
of disability hate crime.


                                   14
2.5. Personal Assistance for
         Independent Living


Most respondents say that they do not need anybody to provide
personal assistance, however a significant minority state that they don't
get the support they need.

Those questionnaire respondents who indicate that they do have
enough personal support (80.6%) include those people who have paid
and unpaid assistance. 26.9% of Dudley residents provide 50 or more
hours of unpaid support per week7 and, based on national8 and local9
evidence, it is estimated that approximately 60% of these are women.

13.9% of questionnaire respondents say that they do not have the
human support they need to live independently and go out when they
want to.

        “I would like help with anything I can’t do, or struggle
          to do unaided. For example, I would like help with
          shopping, decorating, ironing and preparing food”

                 “Without a PA/ carer, I am unable to
                  go out and my budget is being cut”

                   “I need more support to live a fully
                     inclusive life like other people”

7
 2001 Census: Standard Area Statistics (England and Wales) (2001)
Office for National Statistics (Link)
8
 Survey of Carers in Households 2009/10 (2010) NHS Health and
Social Care Information Centre (Link)
9
 Dudley Citizens Panel Quarterly Survey (2004) Dudley Metropolitan
Borough Council (Link)


                                   15
“Funding is not targeted correctly at people
              who need support. Criteria are too rigid and
                 don’t reflect or meet individual need”

                 “PAs are very much required by me in
               particular and in general. I need access to
               PAs to support me with leisure activities”

       “My son is 5 years old and is registered disabled. We would
       have appreciated help with appropriate childcare to enable
          us to more easily earn a living. We never found any”

Nine respondents state that they need help with shopping. This support
is usually not available for people who are not recognised as having
“personal care” needs and people who are often on low incomes are
often advised by local authorities to shop on-line. This ignores the issue
of extra delivery costs and the fact that many people, particularly those
that are also elderly, do not have access to a computer.

The focus group members speak about their difficulties whilst receiving
personal assistance, which include:

      a lack of control and respect for their choice
      the people providing their assistance taking over
      a lack of training for Disabled People who employ personal assistants
      a lack of funding
      the length of time it takes to arrange funding for personal assistance
      a lack of information about who can apply for personal assistant jobs

When people manage to overcome all of these barriers, the experience
of employing personal assistants is often a positive one:

        “I am retired. I do a lot of voluntary work. I have got two
          staff. I am lucky I have two very good people working
        for me. I employ them myself through Direct Payments”

                                    16
2.6.     Education and Training
36 people (50%) are involved in some kind of study. 26
people study at a learning centre and 19 study at home.



                                            Figure 8: Venn diagram
                                            showing the distribution of
                                            learning by questionnaire
                                            respondents




The majority of people who are learning at an institution are positive
about the support they receive from their tutors or trainers. The
enjoyment and rewards that people are obviously experiencing from
undertaking education are very apparent from the responses received at
the focus group session.

           “Love going to college”                  “Like studying”

     “Meeting new people”
                                                   “Made new friends”

      “Staff helpful”

The barriers identified by Disabled People undertaking study include a
lack of computer equipment, inaccessible materials, bullying, a lack of
support or encouragement, inadequate transport, insufficient resources
and a shortage of courses.

 “Inaccessible information is a               “Lack of support to use
    big barrier to self-study”               my learning materials and
                                                  to write for me”

                                  17
2.7.     Enough Money



12% of those who answer the question about whether they have enough
money to meet their essential needs say that they do not.




Figure 9: Pie chart showing percentage of respondents who do not have
enough money

Concerns that people have regarding their income include meeting rising
heating costs and the increasing costs associated with car usage – often
the only means of getting out and about for people unable to access
public transport.


     I can't always afford to go out due to fuel costs for my car.


               A personal budget to enable me to go out
              to places in my Motability vehicle whenever
                    and wherever I want/ need to go.




                                  18
2.8.    Support to do a Job



Unemployment amongst Disabled People is still 51% (compared to
22.5% amongst the general population10). Respondents to this survey
are knowledgeable about the benefits of employment. The members of
the focus group say that the positive things about working include:

“Working together”                                “Learning”

       “Mixture of people”                        “Getting paid”

       “Freedom”                     “Self-respect”

The barriers to employment identified by respondents in this research
include a loss of benefits when taking up employment; “rubbish jobs and
no pay”; not being treated with respect; “using and not paying learning
disabled people for their hard work and commitment.”

Of the 41 respondents who express an
opinion, 11 (21.6%) do not have the
support required to do a job they enjoy.

Figure 10: Diagram representing the
number of respondents with (green) and
without (red) support



         “I would need support and equipment to enable me to
        do a job. I have a job I enjoy, but find it difficult as I am a
             volunteer and have no funding to support me”

10
  Labour Force Survey – 2nd Quarter 2011 (2011) Office for National
Statistics (Link)

                                     19
2.9.      Information I can Understand


Overwhelmingly, people appear to be satisfied with
information that they receive or they have someone who
helps them access it, but other comments included:

    “Some suppliers of information have not got it in a format I
   can read it or will not supply it like this. They say ‘get someone
        else to read it to you’. I am not sure who they mean”




  “It never explains what I want to be explained. If I want information
  about getting from A to B, I will be given information about mobility
training instead. This is putting the blame on me and saying I can’t do
     it because of my impairment rather than because of the lack of
 information or [because of] barriers in the environment. If you ask for
large print, you either get A4 blown up to A3 or 16 point with no other
 sizes. There is no customised large print, for example with proper line
  spacing or 24 point available. This is a lack of knowledge on the part
of the provider. If it isn’t a lack of knowledge, it must be unwillingness
 to do it. I am supposed to be grateful for whatever they can give me”


         “Information could be improved by putting information
             into suitable formats, such as large print, audio,
                  British Sign Language, Easy Read, etc.”


  “Explanation [should be] simple with no jargon. Be given/ directed
   to support groups/agencies. More information re medications”




                                   20
2.10. Help to Speak Up for
        Myself



Almost a third of respondents say they need to talk to
someone to get help with a problem they are facing.



              “Professionals who carry out assessments
            have a complete lack of understanding as to
            why we need what we need and there is no
           brokerage or advocacy service in the borough
             to provide Disabled People with support in
                        these assessments.”



The focus group members identify that there are “Not enough well-
trained advocates” and one of the problems they experience with
advocacy is “People speaking for you without your permission”.




                                   21
2.11. Getting Support and Advice
        from other Disabled People



Over a fifth of the people who answer the question about peer support
from other Disabled People state that they do not get enough support.
Such a high level of demand for what in many other areas constitutes a
core CIL service is one important example evidenced by this research of
the need for a well-funded self-organised Centre for Inclusive Living in
Dudley.

              “Put me in touch with an organisation that
                  can provide peer support, please”


           “I would like someone to talk to me about this.
          In my view, this is definitely needed around here”


           “I do not have fellow disabled people of my age
            range to talk to about young people's issues”


        “I have no access to peer support. The main difficulty
         is that there is nobody to ask for such support. You
                   would need a CIL to fill the gap”


       “No peer support because Disabled People in Dudley are
        unconnected and need support to support each other”




                                  22
2.12. Keeping Well



Of those who respond to questions about healthcare:

       16% say that they are unhappy with the way nurses speak to them
        when they attend hospital appointments

       The same percentage of respondents are unhappy with the way
        doctors speak to them

       9% are unhappy with the treatment they receive from nurses

       This figure rises to 13% when respondents are asked whether they
        are happy with the treatment they receive from doctors

 70


 60


 50


 40

                                                               Happy
 30
                                                               Unhappy

 20


 10


  0
       Communication Treatment by Communication Treatment by
        with nurses     nurses     with doctors    doctors


Figure 11: Bar chart showing respondents‟ experiences with healthcare
professionals




                                     23
Rudeness, abruptness and a lack of understanding of disability are
highlighted by a number of participants as issues they face when dealing
with medical staff.

          “Because I am hard of hearing, they should have a
         report put on my records to let them know and then
              they could look and speak directly to me”


      “I have had mixed experiences. An improvement would
     be for nurses to know how to communicate with me in a
        civil manner which treats me as an adult. Very, very
              often, they use jargon, which is a barrier to
      communication. The opposite can happen, where they
      give me no information whatsoever. Then, I have to try
                and work out what I haven’t been told”


                   “I do not like the way the nurse
                    talks to me. It is very abrupt”


              “I believe if patients can be treated with
           value mental health services would drastically
            improve and so would the rate of recovery”


              “Health workers talk to my mum, not me”




                                  24
Participants are also asked about their experiences of being dealt with
by doctors. Insufficient time with doctors during appointments is
highlighted by participants as an obstacle to their successful
communication with medical professionals.



          “I can’t generally follow what they are saying to me.
              They can be highly patronising. This is again a
                 situation of being talked to like a child”



The focus group discussed some of the things that help them when they
need to access healthcare. Their comments include the fact that they
prefer to receive treatment from doctors of the same gender

This group also say that barriers to healthcare that they had experienced
include:

                      “Doctor talks to the support
                        worker not the patient”


                          “Info not easy-read”


              “Doctor’s receptionists not understanding”


                       “Screening not explained”




                                   25
3. Conclusion
The action research in this report has been conducted by an embryonic,
user-led Centre for Inclusive Living. It lays the basis for more in-depth
research to be conducted by Disabled People and provides important
insights into the institutionalised barriers faced by Disabled People
across Dudley. The issues highlighted in this report will help Dudley CIL
and its partners to better focus their activities, developing services which
will address the genuine needs and priorities voiced by Disabled People.
The gaps in knowledge evident from the findings of this research also
highlight the urgent necessity for further action research to be conducted
amongst young Disabled People and Disabled People living in Dudley‟s
least heard communities.

A priority for Dudley CIL arising from this research will be to take action
which challenges prejudice and discrimination, both at an individual and
at an institutional level. The urgent need for investment to develop
effective local peer support, self and peer advocacy is clearly confirmed
by the findings of this research. The isolation, intimidation, victimisation,
bullying and harassment of disabled individuals are endemic throughout
much of the borough. A clear theme to emerge from this research is the
lack of support experienced by many disabled individuals who are
demanding peer support in order to challenge this discrimination. 11
people (15.3%) of respondents in this research tick a box to indicate that
they want to speak to someone about being sad. 21 (29.2%) people want
to know more about Dudley CIL and 24 (33.3%) want to know more
about future events.

At an institutional level, the apparent lack of understanding and empathy
concerning disability issues evident from, for example, responses
concerning the attitudes of health professionals, highlights the need for
Disability Equality Training across the public sector in Dudley. According
to a response from Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council to a Freedom
of Information request, Dudley MBC‟s budget for social care was
£86.403m in 2009/10. For the year 2011/12, despite the ageing
population it will have shrunk by £7m to £79,018m.




                                    26
At a time of substantial cuts in public services, it is vital that the human
rights of Disabled People are protected. This can only be achieved if
those responsible for front line services to the disabled community are
conscious of the likely impact of such changes upon the lives of Disabled
People.

It is hoped that this action research makes an important contribution
towards furthering the understanding of how discrimination against
Disabled People works in Dudley. We hope that this important ground-
breaking report, compiled by and for the Disabled Community in Dudley,
helps to evidence the growing and urgent need for long-term investment
to sustain the authentic voices of our community through ensuring that
our CIL receives the support it needs to thrive and flourish.




          This report is copyright to Dudley Centre for Inclusive
                Living and Linda Laurie Associates 2012



                                    27

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divide
The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divideThe Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divide
The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divideCentre for Ageing Better
 
Final DTLAONE Mission Presentation
Final DTLAONE Mission PresentationFinal DTLAONE Mission Presentation
Final DTLAONE Mission PresentationDavid Herrmann
 
2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review
2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review
2015_ADD_International_Annual_ReviewVirginia Tarozzi
 
DRC Guide to Funders
DRC Guide to FundersDRC Guide to Funders
DRC Guide to FundersRich Watts
 
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne Turnbull
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne TurnbullThe role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne Turnbull
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne TurnbullRich Watts
 
Disability Equality NW business plan summary
Disability Equality NW business plan summaryDisability Equality NW business plan summary
Disability Equality NW business plan summaryRich Watts
 
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus group
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus groupecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus group
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus groupecdp
 
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementia
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementiaDr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementia
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementiashibley
 
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programme
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership ProgrammeEngaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programme
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programmestevenpruner01
 
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB Jess Farr
 
ecdp email bulletin 34
ecdp email bulletin 34  ecdp email bulletin 34
ecdp email bulletin 34 ecdp
 
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationTurkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationKendall Brune
 
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationTurkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationKendall Brune
 
Rayleigh generic december 2011
Rayleigh generic   december 2011Rayleigh generic   december 2011
Rayleigh generic december 2011Big Lottery Fund
 
Cbr Sangli Seminar
Cbr Sangli SeminarCbr Sangli Seminar
Cbr Sangli SeminarT Chirackal
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divide
The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divideThe Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divide
The Road to Recovery: Bridging the digital divide
 
Final DTLAONE Mission Presentation
Final DTLAONE Mission PresentationFinal DTLAONE Mission Presentation
Final DTLAONE Mission Presentation
 
2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review
2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review
2015_ADD_International_Annual_Review
 
DRC Guide to Funders
DRC Guide to FundersDRC Guide to Funders
DRC Guide to Funders
 
SWK-597-43W Chapter 3
SWK-597-43W Chapter 3SWK-597-43W Chapter 3
SWK-597-43W Chapter 3
 
National Volunteering Forum, 14 July 2015 - Rob Pomfret, Cabinet Office
National Volunteering Forum, 14 July 2015 - Rob Pomfret, Cabinet Office National Volunteering Forum, 14 July 2015 - Rob Pomfret, Cabinet Office
National Volunteering Forum, 14 July 2015 - Rob Pomfret, Cabinet Office
 
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne Turnbull
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne TurnbullThe role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne Turnbull
The role of DPULOs - presentation from CCIL CEO Lynne Turnbull
 
Disability Equality NW business plan summary
Disability Equality NW business plan summaryDisability Equality NW business plan summary
Disability Equality NW business plan summary
 
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus group
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus groupecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus group
ecdp Fulfilling Potentail staff focus group
 
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementia
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementiaDr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementia
Dr Shibley Rahman presentation on citizenship and dementia
 
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programme
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership ProgrammeEngaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programme
Engaging With Social Care Slides For Eo E Leadership Programme
 
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB
Ncvo 7th October Disability LIB
 
ecdp email bulletin 34
ecdp email bulletin 34  ecdp email bulletin 34
ecdp email bulletin 34
 
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationTurkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
 
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanizationTurkey kb global ageing and urbanization
Turkey kb global ageing and urbanization
 
Awpf manifesto
Awpf manifestoAwpf manifesto
Awpf manifesto
 
Community-Integrated Employment for People with Developmental Disabilities
Community-Integrated Employment for People with Developmental DisabilitiesCommunity-Integrated Employment for People with Developmental Disabilities
Community-Integrated Employment for People with Developmental Disabilities
 
Rayleigh generic december 2011
Rayleigh generic   december 2011Rayleigh generic   december 2011
Rayleigh generic december 2011
 
Cbr Sangli Seminar
Cbr Sangli SeminarCbr Sangli Seminar
Cbr Sangli Seminar
 
VADSA
VADSAVADSA
VADSA
 

Destacado

CILK/CILK++ and Reducers
CILK/CILK++ and ReducersCILK/CILK++ and Reducers
CILK/CILK++ and ReducersYunming Zhang
 
Merton CIL general leaflet
Merton CIL general leafletMerton CIL general leaflet
Merton CIL general leafletRich Watts
 
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)Rich Watts
 
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOs
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOsBuilding our Futures: HR and DPULOs
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOsRich Watts
 
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011Rich Watts
 
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULO
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULOULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULO
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULORich Watts
 
Skills for Care PA toolkit survey
Skills for Care PA toolkit surveySkills for Care PA toolkit survey
Skills for Care PA toolkit surveyRich Watts
 
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-survey
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-surveySkills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-survey
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-surveyRich Watts
 
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable report
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable reportADASS SW commissioning roundtable report
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable reportRich Watts
 
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final report
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final reportImpact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final report
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final reportRich Watts
 
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentation
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentationJCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentation
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentationRich Watts
 
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012Community Support Fund application form, July 2012
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012Rich Watts
 
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 December
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 DecemberSpeech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 December
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 DecemberRich Watts
 
Social work practice pilots
Social work practice pilotsSocial work practice pilots
Social work practice pilotsRich Watts
 
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp response
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp responseDH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp response
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp responseRich Watts
 
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkit
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkitAre You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkit
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkitRich Watts
 
Cilk Plus Parallel Reduction
Cilk Plus Parallel ReductionCilk Plus Parallel Reduction
Cilk Plus Parallel ReductionAlbert DeFusco
 
Fortran introduction
Fortran introductionFortran introduction
Fortran introductionsanthosh833
 

Destacado (20)

Mit cilk
Mit cilkMit cilk
Mit cilk
 
CILK/CILK++ and Reducers
CILK/CILK++ and ReducersCILK/CILK++ and Reducers
CILK/CILK++ and Reducers
 
Merton CIL general leaflet
Merton CIL general leafletMerton CIL general leaflet
Merton CIL general leaflet
 
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)
Peer support and DPULOs: three case studies (DRUK)
 
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOs
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOsBuilding our Futures: HR and DPULOs
Building our Futures: HR and DPULOs
 
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011
JCHR Independent Living Inquiry visit to ecdp, 8 Sept 2011
 
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULO
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULOULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULO
ULOs: 2010 and beyond conference -- Cambridgeshire ULO
 
Skills for Care PA toolkit survey
Skills for Care PA toolkit surveySkills for Care PA toolkit survey
Skills for Care PA toolkit survey
 
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-survey
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-surveySkills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-survey
Skills for Care: Recruiting disabled people e-survey
 
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable report
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable reportADASS SW commissioning roundtable report
ADASS SW commissioning roundtable report
 
Essex Unite
Essex UniteEssex Unite
Essex Unite
 
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final report
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final reportImpact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final report
Impact of Personal Budgets in Adult Social - final report
 
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentation
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentationJCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentation
JCHR Independent Living report - seminar presentation
 
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012Community Support Fund application form, July 2012
Community Support Fund application form, July 2012
 
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 December
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 DecemberSpeech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 December
Speech about DPULOs to Personalisation Expert Panel conference, 6 December
 
Social work practice pilots
Social work practice pilotsSocial work practice pilots
Social work practice pilots
 
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp response
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp responseDH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp response
DH's Caring for our Future consultation : ecdp response
 
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkit
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkitAre You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkit
Are You Ready for Business? DPULO toolkit
 
Cilk Plus Parallel Reduction
Cilk Plus Parallel ReductionCilk Plus Parallel Reduction
Cilk Plus Parallel Reduction
 
Fortran introduction
Fortran introductionFortran introduction
Fortran introduction
 

Similar a Dudley CIL community research report

Social Work Curriculum for Citizenship
Social Work Curriculum for CitizenshipSocial Work Curriculum for Citizenship
Social Work Curriculum for CitizenshipCitizen Network
 
good-big-society-brief What the Government should do for people with with l...
good-big-society-brief   What the Government should do for people with with l...good-big-society-brief   What the Government should do for people with with l...
good-big-society-brief What the Government should do for people with with l...Pete and Wendy Crane
 
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesCorporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesOmid Omidvar
 
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier final
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier finalSelf directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier final
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier finalRich Watts
 
Evidence in social care: what do we know?
Evidence in social care: what do we know?Evidence in social care: what do we know?
Evidence in social care: what do we know?Jo Moriarty
 
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position Paper
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position PaperDisability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position Paper
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position PaperHitomi Honda
 
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...diversity services
 
Creative Support in Aged Care
Creative Support in Aged CareCreative Support in Aged Care
Creative Support in Aged CareCitizen Network
 
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this eveningDementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this eveningshibley
 
A Fair Society in Northern Ireland
A Fair Society in Northern IrelandA Fair Society in Northern Ireland
A Fair Society in Northern IrelandCitizen Network
 
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPD
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPDInclusive local decision making & the UNCRPD
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPDneilmcrowther
 
2017 SW 216 DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx
2017 SW 216   DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx2017 SW 216   DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx
2017 SW 216 DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptxcharmainenyangoni
 
community-led-support scie roundtable report jg
community-led-support scie roundtable report jgcommunity-led-support scie roundtable report jg
community-led-support scie roundtable report jgJane Green MA Ed
 
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older people
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older peopleAn Eden Project Field Guide to working with older people
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older peopleEdenProjectWebTeam
 
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk eventFlourishing
 
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about us
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about usLeedsCommunityFoundation all about us
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about usMartin Allison
 

Similar a Dudley CIL community research report (20)

Social Work Curriculum for Citizenship
Social Work Curriculum for CitizenshipSocial Work Curriculum for Citizenship
Social Work Curriculum for Citizenship
 
good-big-society-brief What the Government should do for people with with l...
good-big-society-brief   What the Government should do for people with with l...good-big-society-brief   What the Government should do for people with with l...
good-big-society-brief What the Government should do for people with with l...
 
Webinar: Independent Living Centers (ILCs) for People with Disabilities
Webinar: Independent Living Centers (ILCs) for People with DisabilitiesWebinar: Independent Living Centers (ILCs) for People with Disabilities
Webinar: Independent Living Centers (ILCs) for People with Disabilities
 
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesCorporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
 
ED Summit 2014 NACDD Policy Presentation
ED Summit 2014 NACDD Policy PresentationED Summit 2014 NACDD Policy Presentation
ED Summit 2014 NACDD Policy Presentation
 
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier final
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier finalSelf directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier final
Self directed support and mh - ot b and nd-ti project flier final
 
Evidence in social care: what do we know?
Evidence in social care: what do we know?Evidence in social care: what do we know?
Evidence in social care: what do we know?
 
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position Paper
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position PaperDisability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position Paper
Disability Definitions and Models - WVI DWG Position Paper
 
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...
Exploring How NDIS and Disability Service Providers in Perth Are Revolutioniz...
 
Creative Support in Aged Care
Creative Support in Aged CareCreative Support in Aged Care
Creative Support in Aged Care
 
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this eveningDementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
Dementia friendly communities - my talk this evening
 
A Fair Society in Northern Ireland
A Fair Society in Northern IrelandA Fair Society in Northern Ireland
A Fair Society in Northern Ireland
 
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPD
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPDInclusive local decision making & the UNCRPD
Inclusive local decision making & the UNCRPD
 
2017 SW 216 DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx
2017 SW 216   DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx2017 SW 216   DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx
2017 SW 216 DISABILITY STUDIES for circulation.pptx
 
community-led-support scie roundtable report jg
community-led-support scie roundtable report jgcommunity-led-support scie roundtable report jg
community-led-support scie roundtable report jg
 
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older people
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older peopleAn Eden Project Field Guide to working with older people
An Eden Project Field Guide to working with older people
 
Training slideshow
Training slideshowTraining slideshow
Training slideshow
 
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event
5 bcil presentation for Barnet LINk event
 
Older_Better_Strategy
Older_Better_StrategyOlder_Better_Strategy
Older_Better_Strategy
 
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about us
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about usLeedsCommunityFoundation all about us
LeedsCommunityFoundation all about us
 

Más de Rich Watts

Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 Change
Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 ChangeOverview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 Change
Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 ChangeRich Watts
 
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...Rich Watts
 
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyer
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyerSelf-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyer
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyerRich Watts
 
Merton CIL peer support leaflet
Merton CIL peer support leafletMerton CIL peer support leaflet
Merton CIL peer support leafletRich Watts
 
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012Rich Watts
 
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissioners
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissionersDPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissioners
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissionersRich Watts
 
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and families
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and familiesBrandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and families
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and familiesRich Watts
 
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisationsripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led OrganisationsRich Watts
 
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisationsripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led OrganisationsRich Watts
 
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012Rich Watts
 
Strengthening DPULOs programme overview
Strengthening DPULOs programme overviewStrengthening DPULOs programme overview
Strengthening DPULOs programme overviewRich Watts
 
Options for user engagement
Options for user engagementOptions for user engagement
Options for user engagementRich Watts
 
User engagement research final report - summary, july 2012
User engagement research final report  - summary, july 2012User engagement research final report  - summary, july 2012
User engagement research final report - summary, july 2012Rich Watts
 
User engagement research final report - final, july 2012
User engagement research final report  - final, july 2012User engagement research final report  - final, july 2012
User engagement research final report - final, july 2012Rich Watts
 
Community Support Fund - Organisation information pack
Community Support Fund - Organisation information packCommunity Support Fund - Organisation information pack
Community Support Fund - Organisation information packRich Watts
 
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012Rich Watts
 
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holders
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holdersSelf-defined training needs of Direct Payment holders
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holdersRich Watts
 
DPULO Ambassador application form
DPULO Ambassador application formDPULO Ambassador application form
DPULO Ambassador application formRich Watts
 
DPULO Ambassador information pack
DPULO Ambassador information packDPULO Ambassador information pack
DPULO Ambassador information packRich Watts
 
Best practice in Direct Payments support
Best practice in Direct Payments supportBest practice in Direct Payments support
Best practice in Direct Payments supportRich Watts
 

Más de Rich Watts (20)

Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 Change
Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 ChangeOverview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 Change
Overview of the mental health system - for Older Leaders 4 Change
 
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...
Self-Directed Support in Scotland for people with mental health problems, 1 A...
 
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyer
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyerSelf-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyer
Self-Directed Support information session - 25 November 2013 event flyer
 
Merton CIL peer support leaflet
Merton CIL peer support leafletMerton CIL peer support leaflet
Merton CIL peer support leaflet
 
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012
Report on Wiltshire CIL's conference on ILF - 24 July 2012
 
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissioners
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissionersDPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissioners
DPULOs Making A Difference: working with commissioners
 
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and families
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and familiesBrandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and families
Brandon Trust: a personalised approach with children and families
 
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisationsripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation notes: User-Led Organisations
 
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisationsripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisations
ripfa NCASC 2012 presentation: User-Led Organisations
 
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012
People First Ltd: Marketing report and Learning, August 2012
 
Strengthening DPULOs programme overview
Strengthening DPULOs programme overviewStrengthening DPULOs programme overview
Strengthening DPULOs programme overview
 
Options for user engagement
Options for user engagementOptions for user engagement
Options for user engagement
 
User engagement research final report - summary, july 2012
User engagement research final report  - summary, july 2012User engagement research final report  - summary, july 2012
User engagement research final report - summary, july 2012
 
User engagement research final report - final, july 2012
User engagement research final report  - final, july 2012User engagement research final report  - final, july 2012
User engagement research final report - final, july 2012
 
Community Support Fund - Organisation information pack
Community Support Fund - Organisation information packCommunity Support Fund - Organisation information pack
Community Support Fund - Organisation information pack
 
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012
CommunitySupport Fund guidance notes, July 2012
 
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holders
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holdersSelf-defined training needs of Direct Payment holders
Self-defined training needs of Direct Payment holders
 
DPULO Ambassador application form
DPULO Ambassador application formDPULO Ambassador application form
DPULO Ambassador application form
 
DPULO Ambassador information pack
DPULO Ambassador information packDPULO Ambassador information pack
DPULO Ambassador information pack
 
Best practice in Direct Payments support
Best practice in Direct Payments supportBest practice in Direct Payments support
Best practice in Direct Payments support
 

Último

57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdfGerald Furnkranz
 
Brief biography of Julius Robert Oppenheimer
Brief biography of Julius Robert OppenheimerBrief biography of Julius Robert Oppenheimer
Brief biography of Julius Robert OppenheimerOmarCabrera39
 
Referendum Party 2024 Election Manifesto
Referendum Party 2024 Election ManifestoReferendum Party 2024 Election Manifesto
Referendum Party 2024 Election ManifestoSABC News
 
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and information
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and informationOpportunities, challenges, and power of media and information
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and informationReyMonsales
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsnaxymaxyy
 
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdf
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdfTop 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdf
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdfauroraaudrey4826
 
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victory
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep VictoryAP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victory
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victoryanjanibaddipudi1
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.NaveedKhaskheli1
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkbhavenpr
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012ankitnayak356677
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest2
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeAbdulGhani778830
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkbhavenpr
 

Último (13)

57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
 
Brief biography of Julius Robert Oppenheimer
Brief biography of Julius Robert OppenheimerBrief biography of Julius Robert Oppenheimer
Brief biography of Julius Robert Oppenheimer
 
Referendum Party 2024 Election Manifesto
Referendum Party 2024 Election ManifestoReferendum Party 2024 Election Manifesto
Referendum Party 2024 Election Manifesto
 
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and information
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and informationOpportunities, challenges, and power of media and information
Opportunities, challenges, and power of media and information
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
 
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdf
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdfTop 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdf
Top 10 Wealthiest People In The World.pdf
 
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victory
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep VictoryAP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victory
AP Election Survey 2024: TDP-Janasena-BJP Alliance Set To Sweep Victory
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
 

Dudley CIL community research report

  • 1. 60,000 Reasons for a CIL in Dudley This report is copyright to Dudley Centre for Inclusive Living and Linda Laurie Associates 2012
  • 2. 1. Introduction Over the last 30 years, Disabled People all over the world – from Dudley to Durban – have begun to demand that we have choice and control in our daily lives. This research breaks new ground because Disabled People in Dudley have for the first time asked other local Disabled People about their experiences of living here. The findings of our survey and the recommendations in this report spell out in more detail than ever before why it is urgent for us to get a fully-funded CIL (Centre for Inclusive Living) here in Dudley - Britain‟s second largest town. In the 1970s, Disabled People in the USA began to set up Centres for Independent Living (CILs). They provided services like the provision of advice and support for Disabled People wishing to employ their own staff to work in the ways and at the times Disabled People wanted them. This helped give Disabled People full control over how they lived their lives. Similar CILs have been set up in the UK and now the Government thinks that every town should have a CIL. The report “Improving the Life Chances of Disabled People”, of which this was a key recommendation, has been widely acknowledged as underpinning current government strategy regarding the development of Independent Living for Disabled People1. In its “Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory Disabilities”2, Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (MBC) also recognises the importance of the „Life Chances‟ report. CILs all over the country are different from each other because they are set up by local Disabled People to meet local needs, but they are always controlled by and accountable to Disabled People themselves. 1 Improving the Life Chances of Disabled People (2006) Office for Disability Issues (link) 2 Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory Disabilities (2010-2013) (2011) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (link) 1
  • 3. Dudley CIL is a grassroots organisation. The initiative to form a CIL in Dudley has come from the community and reflects a need amongst Disabled People living in Dudley to break down the isolation we face by coming together to remove the barriers to our equal participation in the borough. If, as we intend, Dudley CIL is to build its strength and grow as an accountable, user-led service provider and campaigner, we will need genuine, long-term commitment and support from the statutory, not-for- profit and private sectors. If the genuine voices of Disabled People are not to be drowned out or lost during the radical changes currently underway within public service provision, pro-active measures need to be taken by all key stakeholders to preserve, protect and promote Dudley CIL as the authentic local voice of the disabled community. The 2001 census3 found that there were at least 304,474 people living in Dudley. Indications are that this figure had increased to approximately 306,600 by 20094. As with other areas in Britain, Dudley‟s population is ageing. According to the 2001 census, 19.1% of the population in Dudley is living with a long-term health condition. This is higher than the national average of 18.2%. This is why we believe that there are at least 60,000 Disabled People living here. This means that there are 60,000 reasons why Dudley needs a CIL. In Dudley:  67% of the population provide between 1 and 19 hours unpaid help and support per week to family and friends  27% provide 50 or more hours unpaid help and support per week to family and friends  34,651 households (28%) include a Disabled Person5 3 2001 Census: Standard Area Statistics (England and Wales) (2001) Office for National Statistics (Link) 4 Dudley Borough Economic Assessment March 2011 (2011) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (Link) 5 Strategy for People with Physical and Sensory Disabilities (2010-2013) (2011) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (Link) 2
  • 4. However, according to a response to a Freedom of Information request made by Dudley CIL in 2010, Dudley MBC only provides services to:  6,610 people with a physical impairment  811 people with learning difficulties  611 people with mental health difficulties In December 2009, we organised a conference on Independent Living because we believe that it is important for Dudley to have its own CIL. At this conference, a steering group was formed. We now have mentoring support from a sister CIL in Leicestershire. They are helping us to build up support for a CIL here in Dudley. We already have a constitution, a bank account, a website and a growing network of members. We have a small amount of funding and are actively seeking further funding from a range of sources, to carry out important work in the areas identified by this research. We receive administrative support from West Midlands Regional Disability Network and we are a group member of Dudley Local Involvement Network (LINk) and of Dudley Council for Voluntary Services. Dudley CIL promotes the active participation of Disabled people in all aspects of society. We plan to achieve this by:  Securing the necessary facilities and support to ensure maximum choice for Disabled People  Promoting the full inclusion of Disabled People in all aspects of society  Campaigning locally for all Disabled People's human and civil rights  Representing the views and aspirations of Disabled People in Dudley  Implementing an action plan to achieve full civil rights for Disabled People  Building a strong, active and informed membership  Consulting, involving and engaging Dudley CIL members in all aspects of the organisation to create a sense of belonging and ownership  Empowering Disabled People  Encouraging young Disabled People's involvement in the organisation 3
  • 5. Dudley CIL‟s work is underpinned by the principles of the Social Model of Disability. This model has been developed by Disabled People and it views Disabled People as being restricted by the way society is set up, rather than by our bodies and minds. The Social Model says that we are disabled by a society that continually puts barriers in our way. It is important to remember that Disabled People are equal to non-disabled people. We are not „special cases‟ and we do not have „special needs‟. We all have different needs, therefore some things must change before we have equality. This should be our right. Every opportunity should be provided to make sure that we are included, not just by changing physical access, but also by challenging attitudes, myths and stereotypes about Disabled People. When we talk about Disabled People, we include:  people with physical impairments (whether or not you can see that someone has an impairment)  people with sensory impairments (deaf and hearing impaired people as well as blind and partially sighted people)  people with chronic illness or health issues including HIV and AIDS  learning Disabled People including those with labels such as dyslexia, speech and language impairments  people with emotional and behavioural differences  people with impairments such as epilepsy, diabetes, Sickle Cell Anaemia  children labelled as 'delicate'  people who identify as 'disfigured'  short people  people who are in or who have survived the mental health system We aim to become a borough-wide, democratic organisation run and controlled by Disabled People. We want to be recognised as a body to be properly consulted at all times on issues affecting Disabled People. 4
  • 6. 2. The Research Early on, we realised that it is important to work out what Disabled People in Dudley want from a CIL. We therefore asked the Big Lottery for money so that we could do some research to find this out. Another CIL – the Southampton Centre for Independent Living – has come up with 12 keys to Independent Living. These 12 keys (or basic rights) sum up the most important things needed by Disabled People if we are to live equal lives. They are:  Full Access to our environment  A fully accessible Transport system  Technical aids and Equipment  Accessible/Adapted Housing  Personal Assistance  Inclusive Education and Training  An adequate Income  Equal opportunities for Employment  Appropriate and accessible Information  Advocacy (towards Self-Advocacy)  Peer counselling  Appropriate and Accessible Health Care Provision We drew up a questionnaire which asked Disabled People in Dudley what were the most important things they needed to live independently in Dudley. During the summer and autumn of 2011, we took these questionnaires to various meetings and groups throughout Dudley to try to get the views of a representative cross-section of the Disabled Community living in the Borough. We were pleased that we managed to get 72 people to fill in questionnaires between July and November 2012. After the results were collated, a further 11 were returned. These have been used to contribute to the qualitative data, but arrived too late to be included in the quantitative data, in this report. 5
  • 7. We also asked for the views of a separate self-organised group of people with learning difficulties. We asked the same questions as the questionnaire, but to make sure that things were accessible, we asked for views in one big focus group and wrote down what people said on to flipchart paper (pictured). The views we got back from this focus group and from all the questionnaires returned before the deadline, have been summarised in the next 12 sections of this report. Despite having a very small amount of funding to carry out this research, we believe that we have made an excellent start in producing a picture explaining the barriers to independent living that Disabled People in Dudley experience. It is crucial that these barriers are identified, so that we can begin our work to minimise or remove them. For the first time, Dudley CIL is able to provide up-to-date detailed evidence about the needs, aspirations and priorities of Disabled People in the borough. Completed questionnaires have been received from a range of people living throughout all of the Dudley townships with almost an equal number from both men and women. Figure 1: Proportional Diagram showing the numbers of male and female respondents. 6
  • 8. Respondent ages range from under 18 to over 79, with roughly half being below the age of 55. 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 under 19-30 31-42 43-54 55-66 67-78 79+ 18 Figure 2: Bar chart showing the age distribution of respondents 52 respondents (72.2%) identify as White British. 12 (16.7%) responses come from Asian Disabled People, but only 1 (1.4%) from the Black Community. White British (52) Asian (12) No Answer (3) British Asian (2) European (1) Irish (1) Afro-Caribbean (1) Figure 3: Pie chart showing the ethnic origin of respondents 7
  • 9. We failed to reach some of those Disabled People in Dudley whose views are seldom heard and realise that it was ambitious to hope that the resources we had to conduct this research would be enough to get a complete picture of the views of the whole disabled community. We think that more research needs to take place to find out in detail what things all Disabled People in the Borough of Dudley feel are needed to improve access to independent living in the area. This further research we believe needs to focus in particular upon getting the views of Younger Disabled People and the views of Disabled People in Dudley‟s Black and Minority Ethnic Communities. Whilst some views from these under-represented voices are reflected in this report, we recognise that more work is necessary. We are surprised by some of the responses to our questions and summarise the most significant of these below. We also include some of the most striking and informative comments which sum up the general views of those who choose to give more detailed information about their lives. A majority of those who respond to the questionnaire choose to tick boxes and not to provide detailed feedback or reasons for their views. A significant minority of respondents do however share important experiences and, where appropriate these have been included in this report. 8
  • 10. 2.1. Where I Live Of the 60 respondents who express an opinion, 73.3% say that they are generally happy with the environment in the area in which they live, however 26.7% express varying degrees of dissatisfaction with their local area. Happy (44) Unhappy (16) No Opinion Given (12) Figure 4: Pie chart showing participants' happiness with their environment “It is hilly. There are no crossings and no “Don't go out” local amenities” “I don't go out very often as I need support/carer” “No. Shopping - shelves too high. Path edges not level at some places for wheelchair” “Too many roads with cars parked on footpaths and lots of illegal parking which makes it hard to cross roads safely” 9
  • 11. 2.2. Using Public Transport People were asked to report whether or not they can use different types of public transport - buses, trains, coaches, taxis and trams. Most respondents indicate that they can use buses (65.3%), whilst less than a third (29.2%) say that they can access trams. This may be due to the limited geographical area covered by tram routes in Dudley. In general, there are some striking differences in the accessibility of public transport identified by respondents, depending upon the township in which individuals live. A number of people state that bus passes, including those for carers, make travelling on public transport easier. A minority of respondents express strong dissatisfaction with the inaccessibility of buses. “I feel very strongly about not being able to use buses. Adverts lie when they say we can all use any form of transport because buses are completely inaccessible to me. The adverts are misleading because I simply can’t use the bus” People involved in the focus group also say that they have experienced bullying and “rude drivers” whilst using public transport. Other barriers identified by people in this focus group include steps, doorways that are too narrow, heavy doors, signage that only uses words and the need for more lifts that give spoken information indicating floors, etc. 10
  • 12. Trams Trams Taxis Taxis Coaches Coaches Trains Trains Buses Buses 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Kingswinford Coseley/ Sedgeley/ Gornal Trams Trams Taxis Taxis Coaches Coaches Trains Trains Buses Buses 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Dudley/ Netherton Halesowen Trams Taxis Key: Coaches People who found the transport accessible Trains People who found the Buses transport inaccessible 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% No answer given Stourbridge Figure 5: Bar charts showing the accessibility of transport in the townships in Dudley 11
  • 13. 2.3. Equipment for Independent Living 72.2% of people said they did not have the equipment they needed to live independently in the community. “I need a walk-in shower. I also need light dimmers” “I cannot afford specialist equipment to support my communication as this would cost in the region of £1200” Some people who attended the focus group reported that equipment is difficult to both find and obtain, and that this was made even more difficult due to a lack of funding. Figure 6: Diagram showing the proportion of people without the equipment they need to live independently 12
  • 14. 2.4. My Community People were asked whether they were happy with where they are currently living. The overwhelming majority of respondents say that they are happy with their living environment. This is surprising given the consistent findings of research carried out into Housing and Disabled People, which indicates an extremely high level of dissatisfaction expressed by Disabled People regarding accessibility and their housing. According to the 2007/08 Survey of English Housing6, one in five Disabled People requiring adaptations to their home believe that their housing is not suitable. The responses received to this question may be explained by the fact that the question asked does not specifically mention housing or accommodation. “Problems with horrendous traffic-not safe for wheelchairs. Some anti-social behaviour. Accommodation-adapted semi but would like a purpose built wheelchair accessible accommodation” “Mostly. I have an alcoholic neighbour whose visitors from time to time can make living unbearable” Other responses indicate a lack of dropped kerbs and obstacles placed on pavements outside shops. The difficulty in obtaining repairs is highlighted by the focus group. People were also asked whether they experience bullying, abuse or teasing in the area where they live. 26.4% report that they are victims of this type of behaviour from other people. 6 Survey of Housing in England 2007-08 (2009) Department for Communities and Local Government (link) 13
  • 15. This includes a significant proportion (35.7%) of all Asian respondents, which demonstrates the combined impact of discrimination on the grounds of both race and impairment experienced by Disabled People from Black and Minority Ethnic communities. No (51) Don't know (2) Yes - Asian (5) Yes - White British (14) Figure 7: Pie chart showing the ethnic origin of respondents Members of the focus group also said that bullying was an issue for them within their communities. “Bullied by able-bodied shoppers. Swore at by other road users” “One of jobs not good, pick on me at work” “People saying snide comments. Also people being ignorant and not wanting to learn about my disability” “I cannot go to the park on my own because people swear at me” 14 respondents (almost 20%) tick a box on the questionnaire to indicate that they want to receive advice and support to help them deal with this bullying. This is a significant number of respondents and demonstrates the need for a CIL in Dudley which can provide such support to victims of disability hate crime. 14
  • 16. 2.5. Personal Assistance for Independent Living Most respondents say that they do not need anybody to provide personal assistance, however a significant minority state that they don't get the support they need. Those questionnaire respondents who indicate that they do have enough personal support (80.6%) include those people who have paid and unpaid assistance. 26.9% of Dudley residents provide 50 or more hours of unpaid support per week7 and, based on national8 and local9 evidence, it is estimated that approximately 60% of these are women. 13.9% of questionnaire respondents say that they do not have the human support they need to live independently and go out when they want to. “I would like help with anything I can’t do, or struggle to do unaided. For example, I would like help with shopping, decorating, ironing and preparing food” “Without a PA/ carer, I am unable to go out and my budget is being cut” “I need more support to live a fully inclusive life like other people” 7 2001 Census: Standard Area Statistics (England and Wales) (2001) Office for National Statistics (Link) 8 Survey of Carers in Households 2009/10 (2010) NHS Health and Social Care Information Centre (Link) 9 Dudley Citizens Panel Quarterly Survey (2004) Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council (Link) 15
  • 17. “Funding is not targeted correctly at people who need support. Criteria are too rigid and don’t reflect or meet individual need” “PAs are very much required by me in particular and in general. I need access to PAs to support me with leisure activities” “My son is 5 years old and is registered disabled. We would have appreciated help with appropriate childcare to enable us to more easily earn a living. We never found any” Nine respondents state that they need help with shopping. This support is usually not available for people who are not recognised as having “personal care” needs and people who are often on low incomes are often advised by local authorities to shop on-line. This ignores the issue of extra delivery costs and the fact that many people, particularly those that are also elderly, do not have access to a computer. The focus group members speak about their difficulties whilst receiving personal assistance, which include:  a lack of control and respect for their choice  the people providing their assistance taking over  a lack of training for Disabled People who employ personal assistants  a lack of funding  the length of time it takes to arrange funding for personal assistance  a lack of information about who can apply for personal assistant jobs When people manage to overcome all of these barriers, the experience of employing personal assistants is often a positive one: “I am retired. I do a lot of voluntary work. I have got two staff. I am lucky I have two very good people working for me. I employ them myself through Direct Payments” 16
  • 18. 2.6. Education and Training 36 people (50%) are involved in some kind of study. 26 people study at a learning centre and 19 study at home. Figure 8: Venn diagram showing the distribution of learning by questionnaire respondents The majority of people who are learning at an institution are positive about the support they receive from their tutors or trainers. The enjoyment and rewards that people are obviously experiencing from undertaking education are very apparent from the responses received at the focus group session. “Love going to college” “Like studying” “Meeting new people” “Made new friends” “Staff helpful” The barriers identified by Disabled People undertaking study include a lack of computer equipment, inaccessible materials, bullying, a lack of support or encouragement, inadequate transport, insufficient resources and a shortage of courses. “Inaccessible information is a “Lack of support to use big barrier to self-study” my learning materials and to write for me” 17
  • 19. 2.7. Enough Money 12% of those who answer the question about whether they have enough money to meet their essential needs say that they do not. Figure 9: Pie chart showing percentage of respondents who do not have enough money Concerns that people have regarding their income include meeting rising heating costs and the increasing costs associated with car usage – often the only means of getting out and about for people unable to access public transport. I can't always afford to go out due to fuel costs for my car. A personal budget to enable me to go out to places in my Motability vehicle whenever and wherever I want/ need to go. 18
  • 20. 2.8. Support to do a Job Unemployment amongst Disabled People is still 51% (compared to 22.5% amongst the general population10). Respondents to this survey are knowledgeable about the benefits of employment. The members of the focus group say that the positive things about working include: “Working together” “Learning” “Mixture of people” “Getting paid” “Freedom” “Self-respect” The barriers to employment identified by respondents in this research include a loss of benefits when taking up employment; “rubbish jobs and no pay”; not being treated with respect; “using and not paying learning disabled people for their hard work and commitment.” Of the 41 respondents who express an opinion, 11 (21.6%) do not have the support required to do a job they enjoy. Figure 10: Diagram representing the number of respondents with (green) and without (red) support “I would need support and equipment to enable me to do a job. I have a job I enjoy, but find it difficult as I am a volunteer and have no funding to support me” 10 Labour Force Survey – 2nd Quarter 2011 (2011) Office for National Statistics (Link) 19
  • 21. 2.9. Information I can Understand Overwhelmingly, people appear to be satisfied with information that they receive or they have someone who helps them access it, but other comments included: “Some suppliers of information have not got it in a format I can read it or will not supply it like this. They say ‘get someone else to read it to you’. I am not sure who they mean” “It never explains what I want to be explained. If I want information about getting from A to B, I will be given information about mobility training instead. This is putting the blame on me and saying I can’t do it because of my impairment rather than because of the lack of information or [because of] barriers in the environment. If you ask for large print, you either get A4 blown up to A3 or 16 point with no other sizes. There is no customised large print, for example with proper line spacing or 24 point available. This is a lack of knowledge on the part of the provider. If it isn’t a lack of knowledge, it must be unwillingness to do it. I am supposed to be grateful for whatever they can give me” “Information could be improved by putting information into suitable formats, such as large print, audio, British Sign Language, Easy Read, etc.” “Explanation [should be] simple with no jargon. Be given/ directed to support groups/agencies. More information re medications” 20
  • 22. 2.10. Help to Speak Up for Myself Almost a third of respondents say they need to talk to someone to get help with a problem they are facing. “Professionals who carry out assessments have a complete lack of understanding as to why we need what we need and there is no brokerage or advocacy service in the borough to provide Disabled People with support in these assessments.” The focus group members identify that there are “Not enough well- trained advocates” and one of the problems they experience with advocacy is “People speaking for you without your permission”. 21
  • 23. 2.11. Getting Support and Advice from other Disabled People Over a fifth of the people who answer the question about peer support from other Disabled People state that they do not get enough support. Such a high level of demand for what in many other areas constitutes a core CIL service is one important example evidenced by this research of the need for a well-funded self-organised Centre for Inclusive Living in Dudley. “Put me in touch with an organisation that can provide peer support, please” “I would like someone to talk to me about this. In my view, this is definitely needed around here” “I do not have fellow disabled people of my age range to talk to about young people's issues” “I have no access to peer support. The main difficulty is that there is nobody to ask for such support. You would need a CIL to fill the gap” “No peer support because Disabled People in Dudley are unconnected and need support to support each other” 22
  • 24. 2.12. Keeping Well Of those who respond to questions about healthcare:  16% say that they are unhappy with the way nurses speak to them when they attend hospital appointments  The same percentage of respondents are unhappy with the way doctors speak to them  9% are unhappy with the treatment they receive from nurses  This figure rises to 13% when respondents are asked whether they are happy with the treatment they receive from doctors 70 60 50 40 Happy 30 Unhappy 20 10 0 Communication Treatment by Communication Treatment by with nurses nurses with doctors doctors Figure 11: Bar chart showing respondents‟ experiences with healthcare professionals 23
  • 25. Rudeness, abruptness and a lack of understanding of disability are highlighted by a number of participants as issues they face when dealing with medical staff. “Because I am hard of hearing, they should have a report put on my records to let them know and then they could look and speak directly to me” “I have had mixed experiences. An improvement would be for nurses to know how to communicate with me in a civil manner which treats me as an adult. Very, very often, they use jargon, which is a barrier to communication. The opposite can happen, where they give me no information whatsoever. Then, I have to try and work out what I haven’t been told” “I do not like the way the nurse talks to me. It is very abrupt” “I believe if patients can be treated with value mental health services would drastically improve and so would the rate of recovery” “Health workers talk to my mum, not me” 24
  • 26. Participants are also asked about their experiences of being dealt with by doctors. Insufficient time with doctors during appointments is highlighted by participants as an obstacle to their successful communication with medical professionals. “I can’t generally follow what they are saying to me. They can be highly patronising. This is again a situation of being talked to like a child” The focus group discussed some of the things that help them when they need to access healthcare. Their comments include the fact that they prefer to receive treatment from doctors of the same gender This group also say that barriers to healthcare that they had experienced include: “Doctor talks to the support worker not the patient” “Info not easy-read” “Doctor’s receptionists not understanding” “Screening not explained” 25
  • 27. 3. Conclusion The action research in this report has been conducted by an embryonic, user-led Centre for Inclusive Living. It lays the basis for more in-depth research to be conducted by Disabled People and provides important insights into the institutionalised barriers faced by Disabled People across Dudley. The issues highlighted in this report will help Dudley CIL and its partners to better focus their activities, developing services which will address the genuine needs and priorities voiced by Disabled People. The gaps in knowledge evident from the findings of this research also highlight the urgent necessity for further action research to be conducted amongst young Disabled People and Disabled People living in Dudley‟s least heard communities. A priority for Dudley CIL arising from this research will be to take action which challenges prejudice and discrimination, both at an individual and at an institutional level. The urgent need for investment to develop effective local peer support, self and peer advocacy is clearly confirmed by the findings of this research. The isolation, intimidation, victimisation, bullying and harassment of disabled individuals are endemic throughout much of the borough. A clear theme to emerge from this research is the lack of support experienced by many disabled individuals who are demanding peer support in order to challenge this discrimination. 11 people (15.3%) of respondents in this research tick a box to indicate that they want to speak to someone about being sad. 21 (29.2%) people want to know more about Dudley CIL and 24 (33.3%) want to know more about future events. At an institutional level, the apparent lack of understanding and empathy concerning disability issues evident from, for example, responses concerning the attitudes of health professionals, highlights the need for Disability Equality Training across the public sector in Dudley. According to a response from Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council to a Freedom of Information request, Dudley MBC‟s budget for social care was £86.403m in 2009/10. For the year 2011/12, despite the ageing population it will have shrunk by £7m to £79,018m. 26
  • 28. At a time of substantial cuts in public services, it is vital that the human rights of Disabled People are protected. This can only be achieved if those responsible for front line services to the disabled community are conscious of the likely impact of such changes upon the lives of Disabled People. It is hoped that this action research makes an important contribution towards furthering the understanding of how discrimination against Disabled People works in Dudley. We hope that this important ground- breaking report, compiled by and for the Disabled Community in Dudley, helps to evidence the growing and urgent need for long-term investment to sustain the authentic voices of our community through ensuring that our CIL receives the support it needs to thrive and flourish. This report is copyright to Dudley Centre for Inclusive Living and Linda Laurie Associates 2012 27