1. BEST PRACTICES
CASE STUDY: ZURICH’S TRANSPORT SYSTEM
CITY AND METROPOLITAN PLANNING
Group Members-
Sangge Nangkar
Savitri Kumari
Yassna Gautam
Assignment-1
School of Planning and Architecture , New Delhi
Semester-II
Masters of Urban Planning
Session-2016-17
2. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
OVERVIEW
INTRODUCTION
TRANSPORT POLICY
PUBLIC TRANSPORT
LESSON LEARNT
CHALLENGES
WAY FORWARD
REFERENCES
3. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 3
INTRODUCTION TO ZURICH TRANSPORT SYSTEM
4. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 4
Public transport in Zurich is provided by VBZ, a multi-modal operator
of trams ,trolleybuses and buses. Trams form the backbone of the
system.
Since the mid-1970’s,the city of Zurich has committed to a strongly
pro-public transport policy giving it high priority in streets and at
junctions.
The basic concept is that the city provides an excellent operating
environment and VBZ should operate on time service within that
frame.
ITS is central to Operations Management and high-quality, on-time
services , VBZ first implemented ITS in the early-1970’s.
The ITS is integral to the VBZ operation and to the organization
,business processes, operating procedures, data and management.
VBZ has evolved from using ITS to just know where their vehicles are
to precision operation with on –time running and transfer assurance.
Passenger information is extremely well-developed, prior to the trip,at
stops and in the vehicles . It provides a seamless and ubiquitous
guidance.
OVERVIEW
5. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 5
Switzerland
Inhabitants 8.3 Mio.
Area 41‘000sq.km
1700 sq.km-Zurich
Density 200 Inh./km2 Switzerland
837 Inh./ km2 Zurich
Cars per 1000
inhabitants 497 Switzerland
INTRODUCTION
Population
• City: 378,000 (City Area 91.9 km2)
• Agglomeration: 1.25 million
• Metropolitan area: 1.68 million
• Greater Zurich Area: 3.2 million
Transport
• Motorisation: 376 Cars / 1000 Inhabitants
• Network public transport: 288 km
• Network streets: 740 km
• Network bike routes: 340 km
• Parking: public ground 51,000 . private
220,000
Economy
• Economic engine: generates 20% of
Switzerland’s GDP
A systematic approach for increasing public
transport efficiency:
– Public transport priority
– S-Bahn regional rail system (commuter rail)
– Coordinated ticketing and schedules
– Sustainable mobility program
6. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 6
PUBLIC TRANSPORT
Modal-Shift in the Canton of Zurich
1994 - 2010
Number of Cars per 1000 Inhabitants
City of Zürich
Public transport grows –private car traffic
stabilized Zurich City Limits
Modal Split(inner city)
21. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 21
One ticket for all public transport means in the entire metropolitan area
Strong suburban railway system
Attractive tram & bus service within town
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION –BACKBONE OF URBAN MOBILITY SYSTEM
Attractive network
Competitive journey time
High frequency
Dense network
easy access
100% integrated regional ticket system
Infrastructure investment fund and financing of
operations
Zone-based fare system
Unlimited within zone & time period
Free choice of transport mode
Uniform price level
22. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 22
Based on three principles:
Limitation of the number of private vehicles entering downtown .
Canalisation of the car traffic on the principal axes, speed and access limitation on secondary
roads.
Improvement and encouragement of the public transport and pedestrian mobility
108 Departures per Hour in an empty
Station
TRANSPORTATION POLICY
23. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 23
Story of Zurich is not just about the current state of transit in the city but also a 40-
year history of constant upgrades to transit and a lessening of the impact of cars on
the city over that time and the concomitant flowering of the city as one of the most
livable in the world.
24. Dynamic traffic management
A "speed up program" was started: reserved tracks were created for tram and
bus, the traffic lights were programmed to give way to public transport
vehicles (through a sensor system), and a central control room was created
for the management of the public traffic in real time.
To manage the private traffic all traffic lights of the town are connected to an
electronic traffic management system.
Improvement of the suburban public transport
To create a network of 320km (200 miles) with 13 radial lines departing at
Zurich Main station every 15, 30 or 60 minutes.
The service is carried out with 120 two-floor train units, 400 seats each.
Restricting the private traffic
Marketing
4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 24
Promoting sustainable mobility behaviour
• Building and cultivating public awareness
• Innovative products and advertising
• Event management
• Mobility consulting for companies and schools
25. 100% integrated regional ticket systems
100% open system: no reservations, no
supplements, no access gates, no time
restrictions
Consolidated ticketing for 313 trams, 80
trolleybuses and 261 urban buses.
ITS Applications:
automated vehicle location;
operations management
including incident management;
traffic signal priority;
electronic fare collection (smart cards);
real-time passenger information
pre-trip, at stations and in vehicles;
automated passenger counting;
timetabling; and
vehicle and driver scheduling.
INTELLIGENT TRANSPORT SYSTEM
4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 25
Easy Memorizeable Timetable
main national public transport hubs
00/15/30/45
+/- integrated ticket system nationwide by law
26. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 26
Parking management
• Historic compromise (public parking
places frozen and shifted from street to
underground public parking garages)
• Private parking: trip-counting models
• Routing system for public parking garages
• Variable parking fees (time, congestion)
Low-speed zones in residential
areas
Until 2014:
• Expand area of 30 km/h for
noise protection
27. 4/24/2017
BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 27
LESSONS LEARNED
Maintaining the efforts
Implementing a Mobility Strategy
• It is not a one time action, but a
continuous task
• Rather a lot of little and modest
steps than few large steps
• Keep up political and public
awareness
• Early and persistent education
among age groups
• Teaching ways for sustainable
mobility behaviour
The project level
Sub-strategies are not prioritized
• Trade-offs between sub-strategies
have to be solved on a project level
• Rules of conduct are necessary for
efficient implementation
• Development of a Transport process
28. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 28
–Public spaces
Functionality vs. appearance in public spaces
• Public spaces in cities are generally very limited
• Mobility Strategy aims to rearrange public spaces in a rather functional manner
• Urban planning strives for a high quality of p. s. (perception, aesthetics…)
• Broad analysis of public spaces
Strategy «Public Spaces», vision and aims
• Vision: «Functionality, Sensuality, Aesthetics, Quality of stay»
Clear hierarchy
Coherent design
High quality of time spent in public spaces
29. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 29
WAY FORWARD
New Cross City Link
Main goals
more capacity on 2 access routes
more capacity at main station
speed up trough running trains to reach next hub
Western Access Bridge
New 4-track Underground Station
30. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System 30
WAY FORWARD
ENVIGASED ZURICH CITY IN 2025
35. 4/24/2017 BEST PRACTICES -Case Study-Zurich Transport System
35
Railway Network and Trains saturated
CHALLENGES and OPPORTUNITIES
CHALLENGES
completely saturated
network
traffic grows faster than
the network
complexity of
regulations
OPPORTUNITIES
high political and public
acceptance
further extension
projects planned
financing still
comfortable