SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 5
A
     Reflection
         By
Shirley D. Guillermo
Introduction
        Generative Grammar is defined as a description in the form of a set
    of rules for producing the grammatical sentence of a language. The
    idea of a generative grammar was first definitely articulated by Noah
    Chomsk y in Syntactic Structures (1957). The generative grammar’s task
    is ideally not just to define the interrelation of elements in a particular
    language but also to characterize universal grammar- that is the set of
    rules and principles intrinsic to all natural language – which are
    thought to be an innate of the human intellect.
                                                   www.merriam-webster.com
        Below are additional information that I got from the readings I did
    with generative and transformation grammar.
The Modals of the Generative Grammar
      The ff. are the modals of the generative grammar:
 1) Finite state grammar are the rule system that strung word together,
  one by one and acknowledge no layer phrase structure.

 2) Phrase structure grammar are build up phrase out of words and put
    the phrases together into sentences.

 3) Transformational grammar seeks to identify rules (transformation)
    that govern between parts of a sentence on the assumptions that
    beneath such aspects as word order a fundamental structure exists.
                                                  … Shinti Sigh
Questions about Generative Grammar
 1) What are the difference between traditional grammar and generative grammar?
          Traditional grammar is based on the descriptive grammar used to teach Latin for
    centuries.
          Generative grammar was conceived as a way of describing language structures so
    that computers might one day communicate using human language.
   2) What is the difference bet. traditional grammar and language?
          Traditional grammar is a framework used to described the structural patterns
    and rules in language called syntax function.
           A language is a composite form of vocal articulation and written form
   using the sets of rules of that vocalization or written structure of communication in any
    native language.
   3) What is the difference bet. traditional grammar and communicative
        grammar?
          All grammar is traditional and communicative. Grammar is grammar. It
   is the way a language works. It changes overtime, as the language evolves.
           There is a school of thought however that differentiate bet. traditional and
    modern grammar. While traditional grammar is static and does not change, modern
    grammar is the amorphous, fluid shifting of the rules of grammar over time.
                                                                      …. Wilkipedia.com
Reflection
      Linguists are people who study language the way botanists study plants or
    the way chemists study molecules. Much of the basic structure of the English
    sentence would be quite familiar even to the amateur linguistic. But like
    botanists studying a new specimen, teachers (like me) will often find
    something new or different in an unusual sentence. Because we want to update
    ourselves with the latest trends in teaching the English language, we will try to
    study various different examples of it, then draw our own conclusion about
    “how it works.”

       The knowledge that I got from the narrative report of Madam Grace about
    generative grammar and the readings I had because I was absent when she
    reported it to the class , gave me a chance to learn and know more about some
    of the more “unusual things” (for me) about the English sentence.

       Although some critics said that generative grammar are too complicated,
    “analytic rather than generative” and designed for reasoning across grammar
    composition, I find the new information as a positive modern approach and
    useful to my job as a language teacher.


Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Presentation generative-transformational grammar
Presentation generative-transformational grammar Presentation generative-transformational grammar
Presentation generative-transformational grammar Nailun Naja
 
Generative grammar
Generative grammarGenerative grammar
Generative grammarLheo Fronda
 
Deep structure and surface structure
Deep structure and surface structureDeep structure and surface structure
Deep structure and surface structureAsif Ali Raza
 
Transformational-Generative Grammar
Transformational-Generative GrammarTransformational-Generative Grammar
Transformational-Generative GrammarRuth Ann Llego
 
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptx
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptxConstituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptx
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptxDr. Shadia Banjar
 
Generative Theory on Language
Generative Theory on LanguageGenerative Theory on Language
Generative Theory on LanguageRyan Gan
 
Constituency, Trees and Rules
Constituency, Trees and Rules Constituency, Trees and Rules
Constituency, Trees and Rules Eman Al Husaiyan
 
Transformational generative grammar
Transformational  generative grammarTransformational  generative grammar
Transformational generative grammarBaishakhi Amin
 
General linguistics
General linguisticsGeneral linguistics
General linguisticszhian asaad
 
The Different Theories of Semantics
The Different Theories of Semantics The Different Theories of Semantics
The Different Theories of Semantics Nusrat Nishat
 
semantics and pragmatics (1)
semantics and pragmatics (1)semantics and pragmatics (1)
semantics and pragmatics (1)ramazan demirtas
 
Discourse and the sentence
Discourse and the sentenceDiscourse and the sentence
Discourse and the sentenceStudent
 
Introduction to syntax
Introduction to syntaxIntroduction to syntax
Introduction to syntaxFarjana Ela
 
Noam chomsky and generative grammar
Noam chomsky and generative grammarNoam chomsky and generative grammar
Noam chomsky and generative grammarAsia Fareed
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Presentation generative-transformational grammar
Presentation generative-transformational grammar Presentation generative-transformational grammar
Presentation generative-transformational grammar
 
Generative grammar
Generative grammarGenerative grammar
Generative grammar
 
Universal grammar
Universal grammarUniversal grammar
Universal grammar
 
Deep structure and surface structure
Deep structure and surface structureDeep structure and surface structure
Deep structure and surface structure
 
Transformational-Generative Grammar
Transformational-Generative GrammarTransformational-Generative Grammar
Transformational-Generative Grammar
 
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptx
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptxConstituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptx
Constituency tests, presented by dr. shadia yousef banjar.pptx
 
Binding theory
Binding theoryBinding theory
Binding theory
 
Generative Theory on Language
Generative Theory on LanguageGenerative Theory on Language
Generative Theory on Language
 
Generative grammar
Generative grammarGenerative grammar
Generative grammar
 
Stylistic analysis
Stylistic analysisStylistic analysis
Stylistic analysis
 
Generativism
GenerativismGenerativism
Generativism
 
Constituency, Trees and Rules
Constituency, Trees and Rules Constituency, Trees and Rules
Constituency, Trees and Rules
 
Transformational generative grammar
Transformational  generative grammarTransformational  generative grammar
Transformational generative grammar
 
Systemic Functional Linguistics
Systemic Functional LinguisticsSystemic Functional Linguistics
Systemic Functional Linguistics
 
General linguistics
General linguisticsGeneral linguistics
General linguistics
 
The Different Theories of Semantics
The Different Theories of Semantics The Different Theories of Semantics
The Different Theories of Semantics
 
semantics and pragmatics (1)
semantics and pragmatics (1)semantics and pragmatics (1)
semantics and pragmatics (1)
 
Discourse and the sentence
Discourse and the sentenceDiscourse and the sentence
Discourse and the sentence
 
Introduction to syntax
Introduction to syntaxIntroduction to syntax
Introduction to syntax
 
Noam chomsky and generative grammar
Noam chomsky and generative grammarNoam chomsky and generative grammar
Noam chomsky and generative grammar
 

Destacado

Transformational Grammar by: Noam Chomsky
Transformational Grammar by: Noam ChomskyTransformational Grammar by: Noam Chomsky
Transformational Grammar by: Noam ChomskyShiela May Claro
 
Transformational generative grammar
Transformational generative grammarTransformational generative grammar
Transformational generative grammarKat OngCan
 
Descriptive vs
Descriptive vsDescriptive vs
Descriptive vssaba_kese
 
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguity
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguitygrammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguity
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguityDedew Deviarini
 
Transformations in Transformational Generative Grammar
Transformations in Transformational Generative GrammarTransformations in Transformational Generative Grammar
Transformations in Transformational Generative GrammarBayu Jaka Magistra
 
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive GrammarGrammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive GrammarSerena Luna
 
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.Nabeela Taimur Ali
 
Summary - Transformational-Generative Theory
Summary - Transformational-Generative TheorySummary - Transformational-Generative Theory
Summary - Transformational-Generative TheoryMarielis VI
 
The universal grammar approach
The universal grammar approachThe universal grammar approach
The universal grammar approachBuket Demirbüken
 
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition Device
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition DeviceUniversal Grammar and Language Acquisition Device
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition DeviceGeraldine Lara
 
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR Eduardo Beccerrit
 
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar)
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar) Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar)
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar) may ann alberto
 
Language And Prescriptive Grammar
Language And Prescriptive GrammarLanguage And Prescriptive Grammar
Language And Prescriptive GrammarRick McKinnon
 
Prescriptivism vs Descriptivism
Prescriptivism vs DescriptivismPrescriptivism vs Descriptivism
Prescriptivism vs DescriptivismTennycut
 

Destacado (20)

Transformational Grammar by: Noam Chomsky
Transformational Grammar by: Noam ChomskyTransformational Grammar by: Noam Chomsky
Transformational Grammar by: Noam Chomsky
 
Transformational generative grammar
Transformational generative grammarTransformational generative grammar
Transformational generative grammar
 
Traditional grammar
Traditional grammarTraditional grammar
Traditional grammar
 
Descriptive vs
Descriptive vsDescriptive vs
Descriptive vs
 
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguity
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguitygrammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguity
grammaticality, deep & surface structure, and ambiguity
 
Transformations in Transformational Generative Grammar
Transformations in Transformational Generative GrammarTransformations in Transformational Generative Grammar
Transformations in Transformational Generative Grammar
 
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive GrammarGrammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar
Grammar II-2014 prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar
 
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.
Avram noam chomsky's services to syntax.
 
Summary - Transformational-Generative Theory
Summary - Transformational-Generative TheorySummary - Transformational-Generative Theory
Summary - Transformational-Generative Theory
 
The universal grammar approach
The universal grammar approachThe universal grammar approach
The universal grammar approach
 
Grammar
GrammarGrammar
Grammar
 
Structuralism
StructuralismStructuralism
Structuralism
 
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition Device
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition DeviceUniversal Grammar and Language Acquisition Device
Universal Grammar and Language Acquisition Device
 
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR
GRAMATICA GENERATIVA - GENERATIVE GRAMMAR
 
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar)
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar) Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar)
Mental Grammar-Descriptive Grammar (Competence Grammar, Linguistic Grammar)
 
Mental grammar
Mental grammarMental grammar
Mental grammar
 
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam ChomskyLanguage Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
 
Language And Prescriptive Grammar
Language And Prescriptive GrammarLanguage And Prescriptive Grammar
Language And Prescriptive Grammar
 
Prescriptivism vs Descriptivism
Prescriptivism vs DescriptivismPrescriptivism vs Descriptivism
Prescriptivism vs Descriptivism
 
Traditional grammar
Traditional grammarTraditional grammar
Traditional grammar
 

Similar a Generative grammar

Linguistics
LinguisticsLinguistics
LinguisticsAna K
 
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.comLinguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.comHono Joe
 
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.comLinguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.comHono Joe
 
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptx
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptxChinese Mandarin Style.pptx
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptxChikoyXhi
 
Grammar-LET Review
Grammar-LET ReviewGrammar-LET Review
Grammar-LET Reviewh4976
 
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptx
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptxSyntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptx
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptxJamelMirafuentes
 
Language and its components
Language and its componentsLanguage and its components
Language and its componentsMIMOUN SEHIBI
 
Colaborative work Transformational grammar
Colaborative work Transformational grammarColaborative work Transformational grammar
Colaborative work Transformational grammarDaysi Pachacama
 
Corpus linguistics and multi-word units
Corpus linguistics and multi-word unitsCorpus linguistics and multi-word units
Corpus linguistics and multi-word unitsPascual Pérez-Paredes
 
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdf
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdfmelt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdf
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdfAliAwan652291
 
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptx
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptxStructure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptx
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptxMARITESAGUILAR5
 
Natural Language Processing
Natural Language ProcessingNatural Language Processing
Natural Language ProcessingMariana Soffer
 

Similar a Generative grammar (20)

Linguistics
LinguisticsLinguistics
Linguistics
 
English Grammar
English GrammarEnglish Grammar
English Grammar
 
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.comLinguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
 
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.comLinguistics Theories MPB 2014  Progressive-edu.com
Linguistics Theories MPB 2014 Progressive-edu.com
 
Testing
TestingTesting
Testing
 
MELT 104 Functional Grammar
MELT 104   Functional GrammarMELT 104   Functional Grammar
MELT 104 Functional Grammar
 
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptx
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptxChinese Mandarin Style.pptx
Chinese Mandarin Style.pptx
 
Syntax and grammar
Syntax and grammarSyntax and grammar
Syntax and grammar
 
Ngu phap
Ngu phapNgu phap
Ngu phap
 
Grammar-LET Review
Grammar-LET ReviewGrammar-LET Review
Grammar-LET Review
 
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptx
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptxSyntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptx
Syntactic Features in Mother Tongue.pptx
 
Language and its components
Language and its componentsLanguage and its components
Language and its components
 
Colaborative work Transformational grammar
Colaborative work Transformational grammarColaborative work Transformational grammar
Colaborative work Transformational grammar
 
Corpus linguistics and multi-word units
Corpus linguistics and multi-word unitsCorpus linguistics and multi-word units
Corpus linguistics and multi-word units
 
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdf
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdfmelt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdf
melt104-functionalgrammar-121027003950-phpapp02.pdf
 
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptx
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptxStructure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptx
Structure-of-the-English-Grammar 1.pptx
 
The study of language
The study of languageThe study of language
The study of language
 
English Grammar
English Grammar English Grammar
English Grammar
 
Functional grammar
Functional grammarFunctional grammar
Functional grammar
 
Natural Language Processing
Natural Language ProcessingNatural Language Processing
Natural Language Processing
 

Generative grammar

  • 1. A Reflection By Shirley D. Guillermo
  • 2. Introduction  Generative Grammar is defined as a description in the form of a set of rules for producing the grammatical sentence of a language. The idea of a generative grammar was first definitely articulated by Noah Chomsk y in Syntactic Structures (1957). The generative grammar’s task is ideally not just to define the interrelation of elements in a particular language but also to characterize universal grammar- that is the set of rules and principles intrinsic to all natural language – which are thought to be an innate of the human intellect.  www.merriam-webster.com Below are additional information that I got from the readings I did with generative and transformation grammar.
  • 3. The Modals of the Generative Grammar  The ff. are the modals of the generative grammar:  1) Finite state grammar are the rule system that strung word together, one by one and acknowledge no layer phrase structure.  2) Phrase structure grammar are build up phrase out of words and put the phrases together into sentences.  3) Transformational grammar seeks to identify rules (transformation) that govern between parts of a sentence on the assumptions that beneath such aspects as word order a fundamental structure exists. … Shinti Sigh
  • 4. Questions about Generative Grammar  1) What are the difference between traditional grammar and generative grammar?  Traditional grammar is based on the descriptive grammar used to teach Latin for centuries.  Generative grammar was conceived as a way of describing language structures so that computers might one day communicate using human language.  2) What is the difference bet. traditional grammar and language?  Traditional grammar is a framework used to described the structural patterns and rules in language called syntax function.  A language is a composite form of vocal articulation and written form  using the sets of rules of that vocalization or written structure of communication in any native language.  3) What is the difference bet. traditional grammar and communicative  grammar?  All grammar is traditional and communicative. Grammar is grammar. It  is the way a language works. It changes overtime, as the language evolves.  There is a school of thought however that differentiate bet. traditional and modern grammar. While traditional grammar is static and does not change, modern grammar is the amorphous, fluid shifting of the rules of grammar over time.  …. Wilkipedia.com
  • 5. Reflection  Linguists are people who study language the way botanists study plants or the way chemists study molecules. Much of the basic structure of the English sentence would be quite familiar even to the amateur linguistic. But like botanists studying a new specimen, teachers (like me) will often find something new or different in an unusual sentence. Because we want to update ourselves with the latest trends in teaching the English language, we will try to study various different examples of it, then draw our own conclusion about “how it works.”  The knowledge that I got from the narrative report of Madam Grace about generative grammar and the readings I had because I was absent when she reported it to the class , gave me a chance to learn and know more about some of the more “unusual things” (for me) about the English sentence.   Although some critics said that generative grammar are too complicated, “analytic rather than generative” and designed for reasoning across grammar composition, I find the new information as a positive modern approach and useful to my job as a language teacher. 